Heterotopia, Utopia, and the Extermination Camps of Operation Reinhard

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Heterotopia, Utopia, and the Extermination Camps of Operation Reinhard ABSTRACT Title of Dissertation: DARK MIRROR: HETEROTOPIA, UTOPIA, AND THE EXTERMINATION CAMPS OF OPERATION REINHARD Sarah Wanenchak, Doctor of Philosophy, 2019 Dissertation directed by: Professor Roberto P. Korzeniewicz, Chair, Department of Sociology, University of Maryland In Michel Foucault's body of work, the notion of heterotopia stands out as both particularly intriguing and particularly underdeveloped. Introduced in the introduction of The Order of Things (first published 1966) and further described in the lecture “Of Other Spaces” (1967), heterotopia has been used by scholars in a variety of fields, from social theory to architecture. Of special interest is the way Foucault describes the relationship between heterotopia and utopia, one defined by its liminal nature and the other by its unreality. This work seeks to shed new light on that relationship, by focusing on heterotopias as threshold spaces between the real social world and the perfected but unreal world to come. I approach the concept of utopia with an eye toward its eliminationist implications, and use three extermination camps established as part of the Nazi regime’s Operation Reinhard as cases through which to explore significant features of a heterotopia, how those features manifest in these cases, and what connects these spaces to the world that can be glimpsed in the mirror they create. Although I primarily use historical cases as a way to expand existing theory, I aim to build upon that expansion by pointing the way toward the development of new theoretical tools for historical-comparative analysis of spaces of both extermination and detention. Finally, I suggest that work might be done focusing on embodied identities as themselves forms of heterotopia, which introduces possibilities for additional analysis of the roles of bodies and identity in cases of certain kinds of mass violence and death. DARK MIRROR: HETEROTOPIA, UTOPIA, AND THE EXTERMINATION CAMPS OF OPERATION REINHARD by Sarah Wanenchak Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Maryland, College Park, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2019 Advisory Committee: Professor Roberto P. Korzeniewicz, Chair Professor Meyer Kestnbaum Professor Lee Konstantinou Professor Jeffrey Lucas Professor Reeve D. Vanneman © Copyright by Sarah Wanenchak 2019 Preface A war story is a black space. On the one side is before and on the other side is after, and what is inside belongs only to the dead. — Catherynne M. Valente, Deathless This all began, believe it or not, with mice. I was in junior high school. I don't recall now what year it was; what I do recall is that I was a strange and inward-looking kid, ill-suited to a social life for which I had been ill-prepared. Many if not most people recall feelings of awkward isolation as children, but some of us experience it in greater degrees of intensity than others, and my experience was intense. This wasn't the fault of any person in particular; it's what you should probably expect when you cross the emotional upheaval of adolescence with burgeoning mental illness. Not long before, I had been diagnosed with both Attention Deficit Disorder and Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (a delightful symptom of which was compulsively gouging wounds in my skin) What happened on this day—which I swear I'm going to return to, the day with the mice— wasn't a direct result of those things, but to the extent that mental illness shapes the disposition of children as a whole, I have to think it played a part. Okay. Let’s get back to the mice. A lot of my classmates spent free time outside. I tended to spend mine in the computer lab—or, even better, in the library. I was attending a private Quaker school by then, and I guess the collection must not have been as closely curated as a public school’s might have been (I found some fairly scandalous stuff now and then in terms ii of sexual content) because frequently I stumbled on things that a lot of people would likely deem too adult for a kid at the tender age of ten or eleven, not in terms of sexual content so much as in terms of violence. In terms of depictions of just how cruel human beings can be to one another. So that afternoon, I found Art Spiegelman’s masterwork Maus. You see it, right? Kid finds comic book (I had no idea what a graphic novel was and if I had known I would have had no idea why the distinction matters), kid has this kid-idea of what comic books are, kid sees anthropomorphic mice on the cover (kid has always loved anthropomorphic animals), kid picks up the book and cracks it open. Kid’s life is never the same. * * * I knew what the Holocaust was. We do teach it in schools. But my memory of that teaching is that it was somewhat abstract, distant, and vague. Lots of people died, yes, and they died because of who they were and nothing more, and they were killed by monstrous human beings as part of an insane project that those monsters believed would make the world a better place. I don't recall much about that last part; the emphasis was on the evil, not on what motivated the evil or what served as its relatively mundane seeds. I don't blame elementary school teachers for not taking a deep dive into the political, cultural, and economic forces that propelled Nazi Germany and its people past the lethal point of no return. Children can understand a lot—they can often understand a great deal more than we give them credit for—but there are still places one should probably be reluctant to go. iii Millions of people died. Right, got it. Except what kind of number is “a million”, let alone multiple millions? There's a point beyond which numbers lose their meaning and we cease being able to conceive of relative size. It's all simply huge. “Million” is a stand in for “we cannot express or understand how many”. When examining mass atrocity, you can go top-down through the lens of those unfathomable numbers, or you can approach bottom-up from the perspective of individual people and what they experienced. People usually adopt both, though both present their own unique difficulties. My teachers must surely have done so. But what I recall, prior to that day with the mice, was the top-down. It was the numbers, which were essentially meaningless to me. Everyone reads The Diary of Anne Frank, but what I remember are the mice. I suppose we all have to find our own routes to the truth. Some of those routes will necessarily be strange ones. * * * What I found in the library that day was actually the second volume in Spiegelman’s two volume work, And Here My Troubles Began. The book details the day to day existence of Spiegelman’s father after he arrives at the gates of Auschwitz, from those gates themselves to liberation and the war’s end. The story basically concludes there; unusually, it's the first volume—My Father Bleeds History—that covers more of the war’s aftermath, and delves into Spiegelman’s strained relationship with his father and the past suicide of his mother. While Spiegelman’s father concludes his tale with a kind of happily-ever-after, it's clear from both volumes that no end to this kind of trauma is happy, and in fact such trauma doesn't iv even end. It carries across generations. It's knitted into the DNA of those who inherit their parents’ and grandparents’ memories. I think it was some time before I read the first volume, which also describes the German invasion of Poland and the run-up to the Final Solution’s implementation. So it was that I came to the foundations of the Final Solution after the fact. That first day, I was plunged into the individual level details of life and death in the camps—the horror of the trains, the beatings, the abuse, the terror, the rampant sickness, the shootings and the gas chambers. It wasn't about numbers anymore; instead, it was about the story of one man and his desperate struggle for survival in the face of overwhelming odds. Which, although accurate, sounds too much like a movie poster; it was about suffering, presented in the most immediate and explicit possible way. I remember being both entranced and shaken to the core. I was stunned by the gut-punch of the story, not least because of how it made sense of itself, or rather how it didn't. There was no point to this suffering, no redemption for the people involved. Again, survival was not a happy ending. What happened was fundamentally absurd and yet on a deep level I was haunted by the idea that it was indeed explicable. That it was comprehensible. It was a puzzle to which there was an answer. (I should note that this was the same year and the same library in which I first encountered Keiji Nakazawa’s Barefoot Gen, his semi-autobiographical manga that tells the story of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and the immediate aftermath. Extreme suffering became something of an obsession of mine.) From that point on, atrocity and mass death haunted me. In another year in junior high school, I read and wrote about ethnic cleansing in Bosnia-Herzegovina. In v high school I wrote a lengthy and impassioned term paper about the American press’s failure in adequately covering the genocide in Rwanda, and the associated failure of the American government in responding to it, and I discovered the torture and murder committed by the Khmer Rouge in their concentration camps.
Recommended publications
  • From the Ashes of Sobibor: a Story of Survival Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    FROM THE ASHES OF SOBIBOR: A STORY OF SURVIVAL PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Thomas Toivi Blatt | 242 pages | 25 Jun 1997 | Northwestern University Press | 9780810113022 | English | Evanston, United States From the Ashes of Sobibor: A Story of Survival PDF Book October 16, Here again, Blatt's luck continues. From Solon His Follie. All but My Life. I had to drag myself through the rest of the reading in this class, but this book I read with gusto! It's not only a story of another extermination camp, but also presents the life after the author's escape from this place of terror. I had learned about Auschwitz and Dachau but I knew little about Sobibor until this class and this book and it has changed me in ways I can't even describe. His family has perished, and he's learning while on This book was given to me by my daughter, who had taken a course on the Holocaust in college, which she liked a great deal. Add to Wishlist. Learn more about citation styles Citation styles Encyclopedia. From the Ashes of Sobibor is the story of a courageous boy who vowed that he would live to witness for those who died, for those whose lives had been reduced to the ashes of Sobibor. Blatt was captured, jailed, and then hospitalized, nearly dying of typhus before finally returning home. Teddie rated it really liked it Feb 04, Publication Date. Truthfully, I want everyone to read this book. Books by Thomas Toivi Blatt. Survival and Recovery. Enlarge cover. From the Deep Woods to Civilization.
    [Show full text]
  • Basic Christian 2009 - C Christian Information, Links, Resources and Free Downloads
    Sunday, June 14, 2009 16:07 GMT Basic Christian 2009 - C Christian Information, Links, Resources and Free Downloads Copyright &copy 2004-2008 David Anson Brown http://www.basicchristian.org/ Basic Christian 2009 - Current Active Online PDF - News-Info Feed - Updated Automatically (PDF) Generates a current PDF file of the 2009 Extended Basic Christian info-news feed. http://rss2pdf.com?url=http://www.BasicChristian.org/BasicChristian_Extended.rss Basic Christian 2009 - Extended Version - News-Info Feed (RSS) The a current Extended Basic Christian info-news feed. http://www.BasicChristian.org/BasicChristian_Extended.rss RSS 2 PDF - Create a PDF file complete with links of this current Basic Christian News/Info Feed after the PDF file is created it can then be saved to your computer {There is a red PDF Create Button at the top right corner of the website www.basicChristian.us} Free Online RSS to PDF Generator. http://rss2pdf.com?url=http://www.BasicChristian.org/BasicChristian.rss Updated: 06-12-2009 Basic Christian 2009 (1291 Pages) - The BasicChristian.org Website Articles (PDF) Basic Christian Full Content PDF Version. The BasicChristian.org most complete resource. http://www.basicchristian.info/downloads/BasicChristian.pdf !!! Updated: 2009 Version !!! FREE Download - Basic Christian Complete - eBook Version (.CHM) Possibly the best Basic Christian resource! Download it and give it a try!Includes the Red Letter Edition Holy Bible KJV 1611 Version. To download Right-Click then Select Save Target _As... http://www.basicchristian.info/downloads/BasicChristian.CHM Sunday, June 14, 2009 16:07 GMT / Created by RSS2PDF.com Page 1 of 125 Christian Faith Downloads - A Christian resource center with links to many FREE Mp3 downloads (Mp3's) Christian Faith Downloads - 1st Corinthians 2:5 That your faith should not stand in the wisdom of men, but in the power of God.
    [Show full text]
  • Příloha Č. 12: Sobibórský Proces 1965
    Sobibórský proces před Zemským soudem v Hagenu 1965 Obžalovaný funkce v Sobibóru trestný čin rozsudek Karl Frenzel (*20. 6. 1911 napomáhání ke společné vraždě vedoucí tábora I (židovské pracovní Zehdenick – †2. 9. 1996 nejméně 150 000 osob, vražda 6 doživotí komando) Garbsen) židovských vězňů Franz Wolf (*9. 4. 1907 in dozor nad svlékáním obětí, dozor napomáhání ke společné vraždě 8 let odnětí svobody Český Krumlov – †???) nad tříděním obětí po obětech nejméně 39.000 osob Erich Fuchs (*9. 4. 1902 obstarávání materiálu pro stavu napomáhání ke společné vraždě Berlín – †25. 7. 1980 4 roky odnětí svobody vyhlazovací části tábora nejméně 79.000 osob Koblenz) Alfred Ittner (*13. 1. 1907 táborový písař, konfiskace cenností napomáhání ke společné vraždě Kulmbach – †3. 11. 1976 4 roky odnětí svobody obětí nejméně 68 000 osob Kulmbach) Erwin Lambert (*7. 12. stavitel organizace T4 (stavba napomáhání ke společné vraždě 1909 Schildow – †15. 10. 3 roky odnětí svobody plynových komor v Sobibóru) nejméně 57 000 osob 1976 Stuttgart) Werner Dubois (*26. 2. 1913 Wuppertal – †22. 10. napomáhání ke společné vraždě přechodně vedení lesního komanda 3 roky odnětí svobody 1971 Münster ) nejméně 15.000 osob Erich Lachmann (*6. 11. velitel strážního komanda napomáhání ke společné vraždě osvobozující rozsudek kvůli 1909 in Liegnitz – †23. 1. z Trawnik, do podzimu 1942 nejméně 150.000 osob údajnému nedostatku důkazů 1972 Wegscheid) Hans–Heinz Schütt (*6. 4. napomáhání ke společné vraždě osvobozující rozsudek kvůli úřední činnost a platové záležitosti 1908 Dummersdorf – †???) nejméně 86.000 osob údajnému nedostatku důkazů velitel komanda pro stavbu statku Heinrich Unverhau (*26. 5. na místě vyhlazovacího tábora napomáhání ke společné vraždě osvobozující rozsudek kvůli 1911 Vienenburg – †???) v Sobibóru a v Bełżecu za účelem nejméně 72.000 osob údajnému nedostatku důkazů zakrytí stop po masovém vraždění Robert Emil Franz Xaver napomáhání ke společné vraždě 30 osvobozující rozsudek kvůli Jührs (*17.
    [Show full text]
  • Die Akte Sobibor
    Jürgen Graf, Thomas Kues, Carlo Mattogno DIE AKTE SOBIBOR Dem Andenken an Jürgen Rieger gewidmet INHALT Teil 1. Die gnadenlose Hatz auf den greisen John Demjanjuk ...................................................................... 1 Teil 2. Das offizielle Sobibor-Bild und die zeitgenössischen Dokumente ......................................................... 5 Teil 3. Der Schlüsselzeuge .................................................................................................................... 11 Teil 4. Die Entstehung des Mythos ......................................................................................................... 18 Teil 5. Das Lager Sobibor in der Darstellung der offiziellen Geschichtsschreibung ......................................... 23 Teil 6. Julius Schelvis’ Standardwerk über Sobibor. Eine kritische Analyse ................................................... 27 Teil 7. Zeugen-Panorama ...................................................................................................................... 32 Teil 8. Toivi Blatt, sein Tagebuch und sein Gespräch mit Karl August Frenzel ............................................... 37 Teil 9. Die „Gaskammern“ von Sobibor im Lichte der „Augenzeugenberichte“ und „historischen Forschungen“ . 42 Teil 10. Die beiden Sobibor-Prozesse von 1950 ....................................................................................... 46 Teil 11. Der Sobibor-Prozeß in Hagen (1965/1966) .................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Patterns of Cooperation, Collaboration and Betrayal: Jews, Germans and Poles in Occupied Poland During World War II1
    July 2008 Patterns of Cooperation, Collaboration and Betrayal: Jews, Germans and Poles in Occupied Poland during World War II1 Mark Paul Collaboration with the Germans in occupied Poland is a topic that has not been adequately explored by historians.2 Holocaust literature has dwelled almost exclusively on the conduct of Poles toward Jews and has often arrived at sweeping and unjustified conclusions. At the same time, with a few notable exceptions such as Isaiah Trunk3 and Raul Hilberg,4 whose findings confirmed what Hannah Arendt had written about 1 This is a much expanded work in progress which builds on a brief overview that appeared in the collective work The Story of Two Shtetls, Brańsk and Ejszyszki: An Overview of Polish-Jewish Relations in Northeastern Poland during World War II (Toronto and Chicago: The Polish Educational Foundation in North America, 1998), Part Two, 231–40. The examples cited are far from exhaustive and represent only a selection of documentary sources in the author’s possession. 2 Tadeusz Piotrowski has done some pioneering work in this area in his Poland’s Holocaust: Ethnic Strife, Collaboration with Occupying Forces, and Genocide in the Second Republic, 1918–1947 (Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland, 1998). Chapters 3 and 4 of this important study deal with Jewish and Polish collaboration respectively. Piotrowski’s methodology, which looks at the behaviour of the various nationalities inhabiting interwar Poland, rather than focusing on just one of them of the isolation, provides context that is sorely lacking in other works. For an earlier treatment see Richard C. Lukas, The Forgotten Holocaust: The Poles under German Occupation, 1939–1944 (Lexington: The University Press of Kentucky, 1986), chapter 4.
    [Show full text]
  • The Survivor's Hunt for Nazi Fugitives in Brazil: The
    THE SURVIVOR’S HUNT FOR NAZI FUGITIVES IN BRAZIL: THE CASES OF FRANZ STANGL AND GUSTAV WAGNER IN THE CONTEXT OF INTERNATIONAL JUSTICE by Kyle Leland McLain A thesis submitted to the faculty of The University of North Carolina at Charlotte in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History Charlotte 2016 Approved by: ______________________________ Dr. Heather Perry ______________________________ Dr. Jürgen Buchenau ______________________________ Dr. John Cox ii ©2016 Kyle Leland McLain ALL RIGHTS RESERVED iii ABSTRACT KYLE LELAND MCLAIN. The survivor’s hunt for Nazi fugitives in Brazil: the cases of Franz Stangl and Gustav Wagner in the context of international justice (Under the direction of DR. HEATHER PERRY) On April 23, 1978, Brazilian authorities arrested Gustav Wagner, a former Nazi internationally wanted for his crimes committed during the Holocaust. Despite a confirming witness and petitions from West Germany, Israel, Poland and Austria, the Brazilian Supreme Court blocked Wagner’s extradition and released him in 1979. Earlier in 1967, Brazil extradited Wagner’s former commanding officer, Franz Stangl, who stood trial in West Germany, was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. These two particular cases present a paradox in the international hunt to bring Nazi war criminals to justice. They both had almost identical experiences during the war and their escape, yet opposite outcomes once arrested. Trials against war criminals, particularly in West Germany, yielded some successes, but many resulted in acquittals or light sentences. Some Jewish survivors sought extrajudicial means to see that Holocaust perpetrators received their due justice. Some resorted to violence, such as vigilante justice carried out by “Jewish vengeance squads.” In other cases, private survivor and Jewish organizations collaborated to acquire information, lobby diplomatic representatives and draw public attention to the fact that many Nazi war criminals were still at large.
    [Show full text]
  • Smith's Report
    SMITH’S REPORT On the Holocaust Controversy No. 157 www.Codoh.com January 2009 See Back Issues at: www.smithsreport.com Challenging the Holocaust Taboo Since 1990 The Growing Self-Accusation Movement In Germany By Kevin Käther Translated by J. M. Damon [Translator’s note.] Truth Is Coming to the In the tradition of Henry Tho- Reich Capitol Day 2 of the of the Self- reau and Mahatma Gandhi, the Accusation Trial of Kevin new activists demand that they be Kevin Käther Käther tried and punished for their crimes. My self-accusation trial con- r. Kevin Käther is a rep- tinued on 18 November 2008, and M resentative of the grow- let me begin by saying that it was ing "Self-Accusation" movement, the best trial day so far! Court re- or citizens’ demanding that they be sumed shortly after 1 pm, at which charged and tried for crimes of time I continued submitting my opinion. evidentiary motions, namely the The following trial report re- body of facts establishing the sci- flects the growing courage, enthu- entific validity of Germar Rudolf’s siasm and freshness of vision analyses of the so-called “gas among patriotic young Germans as chambers” at Auschwitz. they answer the call for a new kind Today I submitted the Rudolf of civil disobedience. They are Kevin Käther Expert Report on the ‘Gas Cham- publicly “confessing” the “crime” bers’ of Auschwitz, making clear to of expressing opinions critical of Growing numbers of judges the Court that Rudolf’s critics have their government’s inquisitorial and public officials are also ex- been unable to disprove it.
    [Show full text]
  • Everyday Objects from the Holocaust-PT 2
    On display at the Washington State Holocaust Education Resource Center. State Holocaust Education Resource Center. Washington On display at the Harve Photo by of Siegfried Fedrid. On loan from the family Bergmann. Blanket Siegfried (Fred) Fedrid was born deaf to Jewish parents who were also deaf. In 1944, Fred was deported to Auschwitz where he obtained this woolen blanket. He managed to keep this blanket while in Dachau and Dachau’s sub-camps. Later, in America, Fred explained that this single blanket could keep him and five other men warm. www.HolocaustCenterSeattle.org A seven year-old Siegfried “Fred” Fedrid pictured with his mother, an aunt, and other cousins in Vienna, circa 1927. Fred was the only survivor. iegfried “Fred” Fedrid was born in April 1920 When Fred returned to Vienna to look for his friends in Vienna, Austria. Fred was born deaf to and relatives, he found no one. Further, he was told Jewish parents who were also deaf. In 1936 Fred that the Nazis had sold all of the possessions he and his Sgraduated from the School for the Deaf in Vienna. At parents had left behind. He had lost everything. 16 years old, he began an apprenticeship in a custom tailor shop. He trained there until 1938, when the Fred was hired at a Nazis forced the owner of the shop, a Jewish man, to “He wanted people to custom tailor shop, close his business. know that deaf people lived in a rented room, are capable, intelligent, and supported himself. In October of 1941, the Gestapo arrested Fred and his and able to support family.
    [Show full text]
  • An Organizational Analysis of the Nazi Concentration Camps
    Chaos, Coercion, and Organized Resistance; An Organizational Analysis of the Nazi Concentration Camps DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Thomas Vernon Maher Graduate Program in Sociology The Ohio State University 2013 Dissertation Committee: Dr. J. Craig Jenkins, Co-Advisor Dr. Vincent Roscigno, Co-Advisor Dr. Andrew W. Martin Copyright by Thomas V. Maher 2013 Abstract Research on organizations and bureaucracy has focused extensively on issues of efficiency and economic production, but has had surprisingly little to say about power and chaos (see Perrow 1985; Clegg, Courpasson, and Phillips 2006), particularly in regard to decoupling, bureaucracy, or organized resistance. This dissertation adds to our understanding of power and resistance in coercive organizations by conducting an analysis of the Nazi concentration camp system and nineteen concentration camps within it. The concentration camps were highly repressive organizations, but, the fact that they behaved in familiar bureaucratic ways (Bauman 1989; Hilberg 2001) raises several questions; what were the bureaucratic rules and regulations of the camps, and why did they descend into chaos? How did power and coercion vary across camps? Finally, how did varying organizational, cultural and demographic factors link together to enable or deter resistance in the camps? In order address these questions, I draw on data collected from several sources including the Nuremberg trials, published and unpublished prisoner diaries, memoirs, and testimonies, as well as secondary material on the structure of the camp system, individual camp histories, and the resistance organizations within them. My primary sources of data are 249 Holocaust testimonies collected from three archives and content coded based on eight broad categories [arrival, labor, structure, guards, rules, abuse, culture, and resistance].
    [Show full text]
  • Reichskommissariat Ostland from Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    Create account Log in Article Talk Read Edit View history Reichskommissariat Ostland From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia "Ostland" redirects here. For the province of the Empire in Warhammer 40,000, see Ostland (Warhammer). Navigation Reichskommissariat Ostland (RKO) was the civilian occupation regime established by Main page Germany in the Baltic states (Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania), the north-eastern part of Reichskommissariat Ostland Contents Poland and the west part of the Belarusian SSR during World War II. It was also known Reichskommissariat of Germany Featured content [1] initially as Reichskommissariat Baltenland ("Baltic Land"). The political organization Current events ← → for this territory—after an initial period of military administration before its establishment— 1941–1945 Random article was that of a German civilian administration, nominally under the authority of the Reich Donate to Wikipedia Ministry for the Occupied Eastern Territories (German: Reichsministerium für die besetzten Ostgebiete) led by Nazi ideologist Alfred Rosenberg, but was in reality Interaction controlled by the Nazi official Hinrich Lohse, its appointed Reichskommissar. Help The main political objective, which the ministry laid out in the framework of National Flag Emblem About Wikipedia Socialist policies for the east established by Adolf Hitler, were the complete annihilation Community portal of the Jewish population and the settlement of ethnic Germans along with the expulsion or Recent changes Germanization of parts of the native population
    [Show full text]
  • Carrier / Chiriac with Niran / Sinai Explaining the Holocaust And
    Carrier / Chiriac with Niran / Sinai 2021 Explaining the Holocaust and Genocide in Contemporary Curricula, Textbooks and in Pupils’ Writings in Europe Country Studies Peter Carrier / Christine Chiriac with Ben Niran and Stavit Sinai Explaining the Holocaust and Genocide in Contemporary Curricula, Textbooks and in Pupils’ Writings in Europe Country Studies urn:nbn:de:0220- 2021-0037 This publication was published under the creative commons licence: Attribution 3.0 Germany (CC BY 3.0) https://creativecommons.org/licenses/ by/3.0/. Cite as: Peter Carrier and Christine Chiriac with Ben Niran and Stavit Sinai. Explaining the Holocaust and Genocide in Contemporary Curricula, Textbooks and in Pupils’ Writings in Europe: Country Studies. (2021). urn:nbn:de:0220- 2021-0037. Explaining the Holocaust and Genocide in Contemporary Curricula, Textbooks and in Pupils’ Writings in Europe COUNTRY STUDIES The National Dimensions of Explanations of the Holocaust and Genocides in European Educational Media Peter Carrier / Christine Chiriac with Ben Niran and Stavit Sinai Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 3 ALBANIA .................................................................................................................................. 4 AUSTRIA ................................................................................................................................. 10 BELARUS ...............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction: History and Its Discontents
    Notes Introduction: History and Its Discontents 1. Compare Bain Attwood’s comments in ‘In the Age of Testimony: The Stolen Generations Narrative, “Distance”, and Public History’, Public Culture, 20, 1 (2008), 94–95. My thanks go to Becky Jinks for reading – and greatly improving – an earlier version of this Introduction. 2. See, for example, Lothar Kroll, Utopie als Ideologie: Geschichtsdenken und politisches HandelnimDrittenReich(Paderborn: Schöningh, 1999). 3. On the distinction between historicism in the sense of the speculative philos- ophy of history and historicism in the sense of setting events meaningfully in their historical context in the tradition of Ranke, see Frank Ankersmit, Meaning, Truth and Reference in Historical Representation (Leuven: Leuven University Press, 2012). 4. See my discussions of these issues in Chapter 12 and in ‘History, Memory, Testi- mony’, in Jane Kilby and Antony Rowland (eds.), The Future of Testimony (London: Routledge, 2013). 5. Tony Judt with Timothy Snyder, Thinking the Twentieth Century (London: William Heinemann, 2012). That does not mean I agree wholeheartedly with their partic- ular contextualisations; for example, Judt and Snyder suggest that the emergence of Holocaust consciousness in the West has buried an awareness of the sophistica- tion of Central and Eastern European history and thought, which is now regarded as interesting only insofar as it illuminates the background to and possibility of the Holocaust. Other, positive traditions have been forgotten (237). I would suggest that things are a little more complicated than that, both with respect to Holocaust consciousness – which has hardly been a uniform process in ‘the West’ – and to Western knowledge of the history of Eastern Europe.
    [Show full text]