ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY PUBLISHED QUARTERLY

Volume V, No. 4 DECEMBER, 1923 Serial No. 20

EDITOR FRANCIS R. PACKARD, M.D., Philadelphia, Pa.

ASSOCIATE EDITORS HORACE MANCHESTER BROWN, M.D. . . . Milwaukee HARVEY CUSHING, M.D...... Boston CHARLES L. DANA, M.D...... New York * GEORGE DOCK, M.D...... Pasadena FIELDING H. GARRISON, M.D...... Washington HENRY BARTON JACOBS, M.D...... Baltimore HOWARD A. KELLY, M.D...... Baltimore THOMAS McCRAE^ M.D...... Philadelphia LEWIS STEPHEN PILCHER, M.D...... Brooklyn SIR D’ARCY POWER, K.B.E., F.R.C.S. (ENG.) F.S.A. London DAVID RIESMAN, M.D...... Philadelphia JOHN RUHRAH, M.D...... Baltimore CHARLES SINGER, M.D...... Oxford EDWARD C. STREETER, M.D...... Boston CASEY A. WOOD, M.D...... Chicago

WINTER NUMBER

NEW YORK PAUL B. HOEBER, INC., PUBLISHERS 67-69 EAST 59th STREET ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY

Volume V, No. 4 DECEMBER, 1923 Serial No. 20 /

Original articles are published only with the understanding that they are contributed exclusively to the ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY. Manuscripts offered for publication, books for review, and all correspondence relating to the editorial management should be addressed to the Editor, Dr. Francis R. Packard, 302 South 19th Street, Philadelphia, Pa. Communications regarding subscriptions, reprints, and all matters regarding the business management of the ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY should be addressed to the publishers, Paul B. Hoeber, Inc., 67-69 East 59th Street, New York City. The ANNALS OF MEDICAL HISTORY is published quarterly, the four issues comprising one volume. No advertising is carried. The subscription price is $8.00 a yeAr. Single numbers, as far as available, $2.50 per copy. A few sets of Vols. I, II, III and IV are available in parts as published at $8.00 per volume; $10.50 per volume, bound in cloth. British Representatives: Bailliere, Tindall & Cox, 8 Henrietta St., Covent Garden, London, W. C. 2. Subscription in Great Britain, £2, 2s a volume. Entered as second-class matter, June 2, 1917, at the Post Office, New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 3, 1879. Copyright, 1923, by Paul B. Hoeber, Inc. INDEX TO VOLUME V A mbroise Pare, Die Behandlung der Schusswunder Book Reviews: ** (i545)» by H. E. Sigerist, review of, by Fielding Packard, Francis R.: “Paleopathology, An H. Garrison, 188. Introduction to the Study of Ancient Evi­ Anatomical Fugitive Sheets, Early, LeRoy Crum- dences of Disease,” by Roy L. Moodie, 409. mer, 189. “S. P. E. Tract No. ix, The Language of Habitat of the Soul, The, Horace M. Brown, 1. Anatomy,” by Wm. Cuthbert Morton, Anatomist, The Centenary of a Great, editorial, 177. l8^ Anderson, Alexander, Life of, Correspondence, “The Antiquity of Disease,” by Roy L. Jacob Rosenbloom, 178. Moodie, 410. Antiquity of Disease, The, by Roy L. Moodie, review “The Gold-Headed Cane,” by Wm. Mac- of, by Francis R. Packard, 410. michael, 411. Arab Medicine & Surgery, by M. W. Hilton-Simp­ “Translation of Selected Passages from De son, review of, by Francis R. Packard, 90. L’AuscuItation Mediate,” Laennec, 410. Arte Phisicali, De, et de Cirurgie of Master John Riesman, David: “Studien zur Geschichte der Arderne, Surgeon of Newark, by Sir D’Arcy Medizin Karl Sudhoff,” by Henry E. Power, review of, by Francis R. Packard, 93. Sigerist, 411. “ Veroffentlichungen der Schweizerischen Ge­ Dailey, Garland Howard: The Life and Work of sellschaft fur Geschichte Medizin und der William Hewson, F.R.S., 209. Naturwissenschaften,” by Conrad Brun­ Blood, Rabelais on, Correspondence, D. Fraser ner, 288. Harris, 87. Bright, Richard, of Guy’s Hospital, DeLancey Book Reviews: Rochester, 301. Burr, C. W.: “Our Medicine Men,” by Paul H. Brown, Horace M.: The Anatomical Habitat of the DeKruif, 94. Soul, 1. Dana, Charles L.: “Geschichte der Medizin im Burr, C. W.: review of “Our Medicine Men,” by Uberblick mit Abbildungen,” von Prof. Th. Paul H. DeKruif, 94. Meyer Steineg und Prof. Karl Sudhoff, 285. Garrison, Fielding H.: “Ambroise Pare, Die Y^ampaign of the Somme in 1415, The Medical Behandlung der Schusswunder (1545),” Service of the Expedition of Henry v in the, by H. E. Sigerist, 188. editorial, 175. “Estados Unidos £ Medicina,” by Oscar Centenary of a Great Anatomist, The, editorial, 177. Clark, 188. the Death of Edward Jenner, The, editorial, 80. “Kurzes Handbuch der Geschichte der Medi­ Charlton, M.: Outlines of the History of Medicine zin,” by Karl Sudhoff, 187. in Lower Canada under the French Regime, “Rudolf Virchow und die Deutschen Natur- 1608-1750, 150, 263. forschersammlungen,” by Karl Sudhoff, 186. Chinese Household Manual of Obstetrics, A, J. “Skizzen,” by Karl Sudhoff, 186. Preston Maxwell, 95. Krumbhaar, E. P.: “Geschichte der Alten Chronologia Medica: A Handlist of Persons, Periods Kolner Universitat,” by Adam Wrede, 289. and Events in the History of Medicine, by Sir Packard, Francis R.: “A History of Magic and D’Arcy Power and J. S. Thompson, review of, Experimental Science,” by Lynn Thorn­ by Francis R. Packard, 286. dike, 286. Clark, Oscar: Estados Unidos £ Medicina, review of, “Arab Medicine and Surgery. A Study of the by Fielding H. Garrison, 188. Healing Art in Algeria,” by M. W. Hilton- Congress of the History of Medicine, Fourth Inter­ Simpson, 90. national, editorial, 177. “Chronologia Medica. A Handlist of Persons, Correspondence: Periods and Events in the History of Execution of Guiteau, Charles L. Dana, 401. Medicine,” by Sir D’Arcy Power and Life of Alexander Anderson, Jacob Rosen­ J. S. Thompson, 286. bloom, 178. “De Arte Phisicali et de Cirurgie of Master Note on the Poisoners of xvi and xvn, Cen­ John Arderne, Surgeon of Newark,” by turies, A, Charles Greene Cumston, 402. Sir D’Arcy Power, 93. Proceedings of the Dutch Society for the “Doctor and Patience,” by Harold M. History of Medicine, Physics and Mathe­ Hays, 94. matics, The, M. A. Van Andel, 82. “Early British Botanists and Their Gardens Rabelais on Blood, D. Fraser Harris, 87. Based on Unpublished Writings of Good- The Post-Mortem Examination of Lord Byron’s yer, Tradescant, and Others,” by H. T. Body, Krumbhaar, E. B., 283. Gunther, 184. Courtney, J. W., Moli^re and the Faculty, 309. “Ephraim McDowell, Father of Ovariotomy Crummer, LeRoy: Early Anatomical Fugitive Sheets, and Founder of Abdominal Surgery, with 189. an Appendix on Jane Todd Crawford,” by Cumston, Charles Greene: A Note on an Overlooked August Schachner, 89. Painting of Saint Roch, 149. “Greek Biology and Greek Medicine,” by The Poisoners of Sixteenth and Seventeenth Cen­ Charles Singer, 181. turies, Correspondence, 402. “Greek Biology and Medicine,” by Henry Cutbush, Edward, M.D., Capt. F. L. Pleadwell, Osborn Taylor, 182. 337- Tiana, Charles L.: Execution of Guiteau, Corre- Garrison, Fielding H.: “Rudolf Virchow und die spondence, 401. Deutschen Naturforschersammlungen,” by Karl review of “Geschichte der Medizin im Uber Sudhoff, 186. blick mit Abbildungen,” von Prof. Th. Meye “Skizzen,” by Karl Sudhoff, 186. Steineg und Prof. Karl Sudhoff, 285. Geschichte der Altern Kolner Universitat, by Adam DeKruif, Paul H.: Our Medicine Men, review of, by Wrede, review of, by David Riesman, 289. C. W. Burr, 94. der Medizin im Uberblick mit Abbildungen von Descriptive List of the Incunabula in the Library of Prof. Th. Meyer Steineg und Prof. Karl Sudhoff, the College of Physicians of Philadelphia, A, review of, by Charles L. Dana, 285. Charles Perry Fisher, 45. Gold-Headed Cane, The, by Wm. Macmichael, Doctor and Patience, by Harold M. Hays, review of, review of, by Francis R. Packard, 411. by Francis R. Packard, 94. Greek Biology and Greek Medicine, by Charles Donley, John: Riolan and Harvey, 26. Singer, review of, by Francis R. Packard, 181. Dutch Society for the History of Medicine, Physics, and Medicine, by Henry Osborn Taylor, review of, and Mathematics, The Proceedings of the, Cor­ by Francis R. Packard, 182. respondence, M. A. Van Andel, 82. Gunther, H. T.: Early British Botanists and Their Gardens Based on Unpublished Writings of Good­ yer, Tradescant, and Others, review of, by Parlier Methods Employed in the Treatment of Francis R. Packard, 184. Syphilis, The, Francis R. Packard, 225. Guy’s Hospital, Richard Bright of, DeLancey Early Anatomical Fugitive Sheets, LeRoy Crummer, Rochester, 301. 189. Gwyn, Norman B.: Osler, Student of the Toronto British Botanists and Their Gardens Based on School of Medicine, 305. Unpublished Writings of Goodyer, Tradescant, and Others, by H. T. Gunther, review of, by LJabitat of the Soul, The Anatomical, Horace M. Francis R. Packard, 184. * * Brown, 1. Editorials: Harris, D. Fraser: Rabelais on Blood, Correspond­ Fourth International Congress of the History ence, 87. of Medicine, 177. Harvey, Riolan and, John Donley, 26. George Morewood Lefferts, Francis R. Packard, Hays, Harold M.: Doctor and Patience, review of, 398. by Francis R. Packard, 94. The Centenary of a Great Anatomist, 177. Heermann, Lewis, Surgeon in the United States The Centenary of the Death of Edward Jenner, Navy (1779-1833), F. L. Pleadwell and W. M. 80. Kerr, 113. The Medical Service of the Expedition of Hewson, William, F.R.S., An Account of His Life Henry v in the Campaign of the Somme in and Work, Garland Howard Bailey, 209. 1415, 175. Hill, Oliver Perry, The Transylvania School and, The Octocentenary of St. Bartholomew’s Hos­ Dan C. Elkin, 387. pital, Thomas McCrae, 279. Hilton-Simpson, M. W.: Arab Medicine and Sur­ Elkin, Dan C.: The Transylvania School and Oliver gery, review of, by Francis R. Packard, 90. Perry Hill, 387. History of Magic and Experimental Science, A, by Eponymic History of the Ganglion Semilunare Lynn Thorndike, review of, by Francis R. (Gasseri), A Note on the, Henry Viets, 23. Packard, 286. Estados Unidos E Medicina, by Oscar Clark, review Medicine in Lower Canada, Outlines of the, of, by Fielding H. Garrison, 188. Under the French Regime, 1608-1750, M. Execution of Guiteau, Correspondence, Charles L. Charlton, 150, 263. Dana, 401. Medicine, Fourth International Congress of the, Expedition of Henry v in the Campaign of the editorial, 177. Somme in 1415, The Medical Service of the, Horner, William Edmonds (1793-1853), William editorial, 175. Shainline Middleton, 33. Household Manual of Obstetrics, A Chinese, J. Preston Maxwell, 95. Paculty, Moli^re and the, J. W. Courtney, 309. Hydrophobia: Four Centuries Ago, William Ren­ * Fisher, Charles Perry: A Descriptive List of the wick Riddell, 242. Incunabula in the Library of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia, 45. Incunabula in the Library of the College of Phy- Fugitive Sheets, Early Anatomical, LeRoy Crummer, 1 sicians of Philadelphia, A Descriptive List of the, 189. Charles Perry Fisher, 45. f^anglion Semilunare (Gasseri), A Note on the Tenner, Edward, The Centenary of the Death of, Eponymic History of the, Henry Viets, 23. editorial, 80. Garrison, Fielding H.: review of “Ambroise Pare, Die Behandlung der Schusswunder (1545),” IZerr, W. M. and F. L. Pleadwell: Lewis Heermann, by H. E. Sigerist, 188. Surgeon in the United States Navy (1779- “Estados Unidos E Medicina,” by Oscar Clark, 1833), 113. 188. Kobro, I.: Three Medical Pioneers in Norway, 393 “Kurzes Handbuch der Geschichte der Medizin,” Krumbhaar, E. B.: review of “Geschichte der Alten by Karl Sudhoff, 187.j Kolner Universitat,” by Adam Wrede, 289. Krumbhaar, E. B.: The Post-Mortem Examination Morway, Three Medical Pioneers in, I. Kobro, of Lord Byron’s Body, Correspondence, 283. 393- Kurzes Handbuch der Geschichte der Medizin, by Note on an Overlooked Painting of Saint Roch, A, Karl Sudhoff, review of, by Fielding H. Garrison, Charles Greene Cumston, 149. 187. the Eponymic History of the Ganglion Semilunare (Gasseri), A, Henry Viets, 23. the Poisoners of xvi and xvii Centuries, Charles I aennec, Translation of Selected Passages from Greene Cumston, Correspondence, 402. De L’AuscuItation Mediate, review of, by Francis R. Packard, 410. YYbstetrics, A Chinese Household Manual of, J. Language of Anatomy, the, S. P. E. Tract No. ix, Preston Maxwell, 95. by Wm. Cuthbert Morton, review of, by Francis Octocentenary of St. Bartholomew’s Hospital, The, R. Packard, 185. Thomas McCrae, editorial, 279. Lefferts, George Morewood, editorial, Francis R. Osler, Student of the Toronto School of Medicine, Packard, 398. Norman B. Gwyn, 305. Leidy, Joseph, Scientist, William Shainline Middle­ Our Medicine Men, by Paul H. DeKruif, review of, ton, 100. by C. W. Burr, 94. Library of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia, Outlines of the History of Medicine in Lower A Descriptive List of the Incunabula in the, Canada, Under the French Regime, 1608-1759, Charles Perry Fisher, 45. M. Charlton, 150, 263. List of the Incunabula in the Library of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia, A Descriptive, Dackard, Francis R.: Earlier Methods Employed Charles Perry Fisher, 45. A in the Treatment of Syphilis, The, 225. Lloyd, James Hendrie: Dr. John Memis and his George Morewood Lefferts, editorial, 398. Title, 146. review of “A History of Magic and Experimental Lord Byron’s Body, The Post-Mortem Examination Science,” by Lynn Thorndike, 286. of, Correspondence, E. B. Krumbhaar, 283. “Arab Medicine and Surgery,” by M. W. Hilton-Simpson, 90. “Chronologia Medica: A Handlist of Persons, AAacmichael, Wm.: The Gold-Headed Cane, review Periods and Events in the History of Medi­ of, by Francis R. Packard, 411. cine,” by Sir D’Arcy Power and J. S. Thomp­ Maimonides, A Twelfth Century Physician, Walter son, 286. Mendelson, 250. “De Arte Phisicali et de Cirurgie of Master Malaria, A Review of an Early Paper on, Joseph John Arderne, Surgeon of Newark,” by Sir Evans Sands, 77. D’Arcy Power, 93. Manual of Obstetrics, A Chinese Household, J. “ Doctor and Patience,” by Harold M. Hays, 94. Preston Maxwell, 95. “Early British Botanists and Their Gardens Maxwell, J. Preston: A Chinese Household Manual Based on Unpublished Writings of Goodyer, of Obstetrics, 95. Tradescant, and Others,” by H. T. Gunther, McCrae, Thomas: The Octocentenary of St. Bar­ 184. tholomew’s Hospital, editorial, 279. “Ephraim McDowell, Father of Ovariotomy McDowell, Ephraim, Father of Ovariotomy and and Founder of Abdominal Surgery, with an Founder of Abdominal Surgery, with an Appendix Appendix on Jane Todd Crawford,” by on Jane Todd Crawford, by August Schachner, August Schachner, 89. review of, by Francis R. Packard, 89. “Greek Biology and Greek Medicine,” by Medical Pioneers in Norway, Three, I. Kobro, 393. Charles Singer, 181. Medicine in Lower Canada Under the French “Greek Biology and Medicine,” by Henry Regime, 1608-1750, Outlines of the History of, Osborn Taylor, 182. M. Charlton, 150, 263. “Paleopathology, an Introduction to the Study in the Philippines, Primitive, Anastacia Villegas, of Ancient Evidences of Disease,” by Roy L. 229. Moodie, 409. Memis, Dr. John, and his Title, James Hendrie “S. P. E. Tract No. ix, The Language of Lloyd, 146. Anatomy,” by Wm. Cuthbert Morton, 185. Mendelson, Walter: Maimonides, A Twelfth Century “The Antiquity of Disease,” by Roy L. Physician, 250. Moodie, 410. Methods Employed in the Treatment of Syphilis, “The Gold-Headed Cane,” by Wm. Mac- The Earlier, Francis R. Packard, 225. michael, 411. Middleton, William Shainline: Joseph Leidy, Scien­ “Translation of Selected Passages from De tist, 100. L’AuscuItation Mediate,” Laennec, 410. William Edmonds Horner (1793-1853), 33. Painting of Saint Roch, A Note on an Overlooked, Moli^re and the Faculty, J. W. Courtney, 309. Charles Greene Cumston, 149. Moodie, Roy L.: Paleopathology, An Introduction Paleopathology, an Introduction to the Study of to the Study of Ancient Evidences of Disease, Ancient Evidences of Disease, by Roy L. Moodie, review of, by Francis R. Packard, 409. review of, by Francis R. Packard, 409. The Antiquity of Disease, review of, by Francis R. Papal Chair, A Physician in the, David Ricsman, 291. Packard, 410. Paper on Malaria, A Review of an Early, Joseph Morton, Wm. Cuthbert: S. P. E. Tract No. ix, The Evans Sands, 77. Language of Anatomy, review of, by Francis R. Philippines, Primitive Medicine in the, Anastacia Packard, 185. Villegas, 229. Physician in the Papal Chair, A, David Riesman, Sigerist, H. E.: Studien zur Geschichte der Medizin, 291 s Karl Sudhoff, review of, by David Riesman, 411. Pioneers in Norway, Three Medical, I. Kobro, 393. Singer, Charles: Greek Biology and Greek Medicine, Pleadwell, Capt. F. L.: Edward Cutbush, M.D., review of, by Francis R. Packard, 181. 337- Skizzen, by Karl Sudhoff, review of, by Fielding H. and W. M. Kerr: Lewis Heermann, Surgeon in the Garrison, 186. United States Navy (1779-1833), 113. S. P. E. Tract No. ix, The Language of Anatomy, by Poisoners of XVI and XVII Centuries, a Note on the Wm. Cuthbert Morton, review of, by Francis R. Charles Greene Cumston, Correspondence, 402. Packard 18^ Post-Mortem Examination of Lord Byron’s Body, Steineg, Prof. Th. Meyer, and Prof. Karl Sudhoff, The, E. B. Krumbhaar, Correspondence, 283. Geschichte der Medizin im Uberblick mit Abbil- Power, Sir D’Arcy: De Arte Phisicali et de Cirurgie dungen, review of, by Charles L. Dana, 285. of Master John Arderne, review of, by Francis Student of the Toronto School of Medicine, Osler, R. Packard, 93. Norman B. Gwyn, 305. and J. S. Thompson: Chronologia Medica: A Studien zur Geschichte der Medizin Karl Sudhoff: Handlist of Persons, Periods and Events in the by Henry E. Sigerist, review of, by David Ries­ History of Medicine, review of, by Francis R. man, 411. Packard, 286. Sudhoff, Karl, and Prof. Th. Meyer Steineg: Ge­ Primitive Medicine in the Philippines, Anastacia schichte der Medizin im Uberblick mit Abbil- Villegas, 229. dungen, review of, by Charles L. Dana, 285. Proceedings of the Dutch Society for the History of Kurzes Handbuch der Geschichte der Medizin, Medicine, Physics and Mathematics, The, Cor­ review of, by Fielding H. Garrison, 187. respondence, M. A. Van Andel, 82. Rudolf Virchow und die Deutschen Naturfor- schersammlungen, review of, by Fielding H. Dabelais on Blood, Correspondence, D. Fraser Garrison, 186. 1 Harris, 87. Skizzen, review of, by Fielding H. Garrison, 186. Review of an Early Paper on Malaria, A, Joseph Syphilis, the Earlier Methods Employed in the Evans Sands, 77. Treatment of, Francis R. Packard, 225. Riddell, William Renwick: Hydrophobia: Four Centuries Ago, 242. 'T’aylor, Henry Osborn: Greek Biology and Medi- Riesman, David: A Physician in the Papal Chair, * cine, review of, by Francis R. Packard, 182. 291. Thorndike, Lynn: A History of Magic and Experi­ review of “Studien zur Geschichte der Medizin mental Science, review of, by Francis R. Packard, Karl Sudhoff,” by Henry E. Sigerist, 411. 286. “ Veroffentlichungen der Schweizerischen Gesell­ Thompson, J. S., and Sir D’Arcy Power: Chrono­ schaft fur Geschichte Medizin und der logia Medica: A Handlist of Persons, Periods and Naturwissenschaften,” by Conrad Brunner, Events in the History of Medicine, review of, by 288. Francis R. Packard, 286. Riolan and Harvey, John Donley, 26. Three Medical Pioneers in Norway, I. Kobro, 393. Rochester, DeLancey: Richard Bright of Guy’s Toronto School of Medicine, Osler, Student of the, Hospital, 301. Norman B. Gwyn, 305. Roch, Saint, A Note on an Overlooked Painting of, Transaltion of Selected Passages from De L’Auscul­ Charles Greene Cumston, 149. tation Mediate, Laennec, review of, by Francis R. Rosenbloom, Jacob: Life of Alexander Anderson, Packard, 410. Correspondence, 178. Transylvania School and Oliver Perry Hill, The, Rudolf Virchow und die Deutschen Naturforscher- Dan C. Elkin, 387. sammlungen, by Karl Sudhoff, review of, by Treatment of Syphilis, the Earlier Methods Em­ Fielding H. Garrison, 186. ployed in the, Francis R. Packard, 225. Twelfth Century Physician, Maimonides, A, Walter Qands, Joseph Evans: A Review of an Early Paper Mendelson, 250. on Malaria, 77. Schachner, August: Ephraim McDowell, Father of \7an Andel, M. A.: The Proceedings of the Dutch Ovariotomy and Founder of Abdominal Surgery, * Society for the History of Medicine, Physics, with an Appendix on Jane Todd Crawford, review and Mathematics, Correspondence, 82. of, by Francis R. Packard, 89. Veroffentlichungen der Schweizerischen Gesellschaft School and Oliver Perry Hill, The Transylvania, Dan fur Geschichte Medizin und der Naturwissen­ C. Elkin, 387. schaften, by Conrad Brunner, review of, by of Medicine, Osler, Student of the Toronto, David Riesman, 288. Norman B. Gwyn, 305. Viets, Henry: A Note on the Eponymic History of Service of the Expedition of Henry v in the Cam­ the Ganglion Semilunare (Gasseri), 23. paign of the Somme in 1415, The Medical, edi­ Villegas, Anastacia: Primitive Medicine in the torial, 175. Philippines, 229. Sigerist, H. E.: Ambroise Pare, Die Behandlung der Schusswunder (1545), review of, by Fielding H. VVrede, Adam: Geschichte der Al ten Kolner Garrison, 188. ’ ’ UniversitSt, review of, by David Riesman, 289.