Whales and Wolves the Evidence

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

WHALES AND WOLVES THE EVIDENCE (Marx, et. al., n.d.) Pakicetus (48-50 million years ago) Found in Pakistan (Marx, et. al., n.d.) Ambulocetus (47-48 million years ago) Found in ancient estuaries or bays (Marx, et. al., n.d.) Rodhocetus (39-47 million years ago) Found in Africa and North America (Marx, et. al., n.d.) Basilosaurus (35-37 million years ago) Found in ocean deposits (Marx, et. al., n.d.) Dorudon atrox (Found in 35-38 million year old ocean deposits) Retrieved from: http://www.rejectionofpascalswager.net/origin.html Whale Fin Retrieved from: http://www.rejectionofpascalswager.net/origin.html Retrieved from: http://www.boneclones.com/BC-044.htm Orca Whale Lower Jaw Bone (San Diego Natural History Museum, 2010) Dire Wolf Jaw Bone What does the evidence tell us? ! Whales are mammals, so they share many similarities with the wolf, and are more closely related than a whale and shark. ! The skeleton pictures show the fossil evidence that has been found. They show that whales descended from a land mammal. This land mammal likely shares a common ancestor with wolves. Here is a drawing of what the land animal to whale evolution probably looked like: (Marx, et. al., n.d.) ! Using the geologic information about where the skeletons were found, you can see how the descendants moved from land to estuaries (fresh and salt water mixed) to oceans. ! Using comparative anatomy, you can see the homologous structures of the whale fin and wolf leg. This suggests that they share a common ancestor. ! Using comparative anatomy, you can see the homologous structures of the whale jaw bone and the wolf jaw bone. This suggests that they share a common ancestor. .

Copy Link

Recommended publications

Wec01's SSSS Fossils Test 2019
wec01’s SSSS Fossils Test 2019 Team Name: _________________KEY________________ Team Number: ___KEY___ Team Members: ____________KEY____________, ____________KEY____________ This test consists of 18 stations with a total of 200 points. Each answer is worth one point except where specified otherwise. You are only given 2 ½ minutes with the specimens at each station, however you can work on any station’s questions at any time. Scoring Station 1: ___10___ / 10 Station 10: ___12___ / 12 Station 2: ___10___ / 10 Station 11: ____9___ / 9 Station 3: ___11___ / 11 Station 12: ___11___ / 11 Station 4: ___10___ / 10 Station 13: ___10___ / 10 Station 5: ___10___ / 10 Station 14: ___10___ / 10 Station 6: ____9___ / 9 Station 15: ___12___ / 12 Station 7: ____9___ / 9 Station 16: ____9___ / 9 Station 8: ___10___ / 10 Station 17: ___10___ / 10 Station 9: ____9___ / 9 Station 18: ___29___ / 29 Total: __200___ / 200 Team Number: _KEY_ Station 1: Dinosaurs (10 pt) 1. Identify the genus of specimen A Tyrannosaurus (1 pt) 2. Identify the genus of specimen B Stegosaurus (1 pt) 3. Identify the genus of specimen C Allosaurus (1 pt) 4. Which specimen(s) (A, B, or C) are A, C (1 pt) Saurischians? 5. Which two specimens (A, B, or C) lived at B, C (1 pt) the same time? 6. Identify the genus of specimen D Velociraptor (1 pt) 7. Identify the genus of specimen E Coelophysis (1 pt) 8. Which specimen (D or E) is commonly E (1 pt) found in Ghost Ranch, New Mexico? 9. Which specimen (A, B, C, D, or E) would D (1 pt) specimen F have been found on? 10.
[Show full text]
Functional Morphology of the Vertebral Column in Remingtonocetus (Mammalia, Cetacea) and the Evolution of Aquatic Locomotion in Early Archaeocetes
Functional Morphology of the Vertebral Column in Remingtonocetus (Mammalia, Cetacea) and the Evolution of Aquatic Locomotion in Early Archaeocetes by Ryan Matthew Bebej A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Ecology and Evolutionary Biology) in The University of Michigan 2011 Doctoral Committee: Professor Philip D. Gingerich, Co-Chair Professor Philip Myers, Co-Chair Professor Daniel C. Fisher Professor Paul W. Webb © Ryan Matthew Bebej 2011 To my wonderful wife Melissa, for her infinite love and support ii Acknowledgments First, I would like to thank each of my committee members. I will be forever grateful to my primary mentor, Philip D. Gingerich, for providing me the opportunity of a lifetime, studying the very organisms that sparked my interest in evolution and paleontology in the first place. His encouragement, patience, instruction, and advice have been instrumental in my development as a scholar, and his dedication to his craft has instilled in me the importance of doing careful and solid research. I am extremely grateful to Philip Myers, who graciously consented to be my co-advisor and co-chair early in my career and guided me through some of the most stressful aspects of life as a Ph.D. student (e.g., preliminary examinations). I also thank Paul W. Webb, for his novel thoughts about living in and moving through water, and Daniel C. Fisher, for his insights into functional morphology, 3D modeling, and mammalian paleobiology. My research was almost entirely predicated on cetacean fossils collected through a collaboration of the University of Michigan and the Geological Survey of Pakistan before my arrival in Ann Arbor.
[Show full text]
Transition of Eocene Whales from Land to Sea: Evidence from Bone Microstructure
RESEARCH ARTICLE Transition of Eocene Whales from Land to Sea: Evidence from Bone Microstructure Alexandra Houssaye1,2*, Paul Tafforeau3, Christian de Muizon4, Philip D. Gingerich5 1 UMR 7179 CNRS/Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Département Ecologie et Gestion de la Biodiversité, Paris, France, 2 Steinmann Institut für Geologie, Paläontologie und Mineralogie, Universität Bonn, Bonn, Germany, 3 European Synchrotron Radiation Facility, Grenoble, France, 4 Sorbonne Universités, CR2P—CNRS, MNHN, UPMC-Paris 6, Département Histoire de la Terre, Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris, France, 5 Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences and Museum of Paleontology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, United States of America a11111 * [email protected] Abstract Cetacea are secondarily aquatic amniotes that underwent their land-to-sea transition during OPEN ACCESS the Eocene. Primitive forms, called archaeocetes, include five families with distinct degrees Citation: Houssaye A, Tafforeau P, de Muizon C, of adaptation to an aquatic life, swimming mode and abilities that remain difficult to estimate. Gingerich PD (2015) Transition of Eocene Whales The lifestyle of early cetaceans is investigated by analysis of microanatomical features in from Land to Sea: Evidence from Bone postcranial elements of archaeocetes. We document the internal structure of long bones, Microstructure. PLoS ONE 10(2): e0118409. ribs and vertebrae in fifteen specimens belonging to the three more derived archaeocete doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0118409 families — Remingtonocetidae, Protocetidae, and Basilosauridae — using microtomogra- Academic Editor: Brian Lee Beatty, New York phy and virtual thin-sectioning. This enables us to discuss the osseous specializations ob- Institute of Technology College of Osteopathic Medicine, UNITED STATES served in these taxa and to comment on their possible swimming behavior.
[Show full text]
The Biology of Marine Mammals
Romero, A. 2009. The Biology of Marine Mammals. The Biology of Marine Mammals Aldemaro Romero, Ph.D. Arkansas State University Jonesboro, AR 2009 2 INTRODUCTION Dear students, 3 Chapter 1 Introduction to Marine Mammals 1.1. Overture Humans have always been fascinated with marine mammals. These creatures have been the basis of mythical tales since Antiquity. For centuries naturalists classified them as fish. Today they are symbols of the environmental movement as well as the source of heated controversies: whether we are dealing with the clubbing pub seals in the Arctic or whaling by industrialized nations, marine mammals continue to be a hot issue in science, politics, economics, and ethics. But if we want to better understand these issues, we need to learn more about marine mammal biology. The problem is that, despite increased research efforts, only in the last two decades we have made significant progress in learning about these creatures. And yet, that knowledge is largely limited to a handful of species because they are either relatively easy to observe in nature or because they can be studied in captivity. Still, because of television documentaries, ‘coffee-table’ books, displays in many aquaria around the world, and a growing whale and dolphin watching industry, people believe that they have a certain familiarity with many species of marine mammals (for more on the relationship between humans and marine mammals such as whales, see Ellis 1991, Forestell 2002). As late as 2002, a new species of beaked whale was being reported (Delbout et al. 2002), in 2003 a new species of baleen whale was described (Wada et al.
[Show full text]
A Brief History of Whale Evolution: As Supported by The
A Brief History of Whale Evolution As Supported By the Fossil Record BIOB 272 – Genetics and Evolution Presented by Mindy Flanders Presented for Rick Henry December 8, 2017 Cetaceans—whales, dolphins, and porpoises—are so different from other animals that, until recently, scientists were unable to identify their closest relatives. As any elementary student knows, a whale is not a fish. That means that despite the similarities in where they live and how they look, whales are not at all like salmon or even sharks. Carolus Linnaeus, known for classifying plants and animals, noted in the 1750s that “whales breathe air through lungs not gills; are warm blooded; and have many other anatomical differences that distinguish them from fish” (Prothero, 2015). Other characteristics cetaceans share with all other mammals are: they have hair (at some point in their life), they give birth to live young, and they nurse their young with milk. This implies that whales evolved from other mammals and, because ancestral mammals were land animals, that whales had land ancestors (Thewissen & Bajpai, 2001). But before they had land ancestors they had water ancestors. The ancestors of fish lived in water, too. Up until 375 million years ago (mya), everything other than plants and insects lived in water, but it was around that time that fish and land animals began to diverge. A series of fossils represent the fish-to-tetrapod transition that occurred during the Late Devonian Period 359-383 mya (Herron & Freeman, 2014). In search of a new food source, or to escape predators more than twice their size (Prothero, 2015), the first tetrapods pushed themselves out of the swamps and began to live on land (Switek, 2010).
[Show full text]
Experiencing Discoveries of Whale Evolution
Experiencing Discoveries of Whale Evolution Subject: Biology Grade Level: 10th Rational or Purpose: Students will be able to discover fossils of early whales in order to show how, where, and when they evolved from four-legged mammals. Students will explore this concept of evolution by experiencing how historical science works through predicting and testing. Materials: • Classroom timeline showing the Cenozoic era o Can be assembled with printed version OR o Creating your own with butcher paper Scale will be 1 inch = 1 million years, marked at every million years until 65 mya (millions of years ago) Afterwards, mark and label the range of each epoch Last 10,000 years (0.01 inch) Holocene Thin black line at top 2 mya – 10,000 years ago Pleistocene Orange 5 mya – 2 mya Pliocene Blue 24 mya – 5 mya Micoene Yellow 34 mya – 24 mya Olgiocene Green 55 mya – 34 mya Eocene Red 65 mya – 55 mya Paleocene brown • “Whales as Mammals” overhead • Copies of “The Origin of Whales and the Power of Independent Evidence” by Raymond Sutera • For each team: o Timeline of the Eocene epoch (55 to 34 mya) o “Whales in the Making” page with 6 whale-type mammals Strips #1 to 5 need to be placed in separate, numbered envelopes. This will create a sense of real “discovery” while students are gradually “unearthing” the whale fossils during the narrative description. Strip #6 will be held by the teacher. This will be handed out to each team after someone has drawn the predicted fossil traits expected between 46 and 55 mya.
[Show full text]
Early Evolution of Whales
Early Evolution of Whales A Century of Research in Egypt Philip D. Gingerich Introduction Living whales are fully aquatic and belong to two suborders of Cetacea: Mysticeti (baleen whales) and Odontoceti (toothed whales). Both of these modern suborders appeared when Earth changed from a ‘greenhouse’ earth to an ‘icehouse’ earth at in about the beginning of the Oligocene epoch (Zachos et al., 2001). Early whales, from the ‘greenhouse’ Eocene, all belong to a distinct paraphyletic suborder Archaeoceti. Archaeocetes differ from later modern whales in retaining many characteristics of land mammals, including complexly occluding cheek teeth, ear bones well integrated with the rest of the cranium, longer necks, less specialized forelimb flippers, and hind limbs with feet and toes. Archaeocetes are, in essence, the transitional forms documenting the origin of whales from an earlier land-mammal ancestry (Gingerich, 2005). The first archaeocete fossil to be studied scientifically was a very large vertebral centrum collected in 1832 near the Ouachita River in Caldwell Parish, Louisiana. This measured some 35 cm in length and was but one of a series of 28 vertebrae found together there. The animal represented was named Basilosaurus or ‘king lizard’ because of its size and presumed reptilian heritage (Harlan, 1834). At the time the British anatomist Richard Owen was busy studying the large reptiles he eventually called dinosaurs. To solve the mystery of Basilosaurus, Owen secured additional remains and showed that it was a mammal because its cheek teeth are double-rooted. Owen (1839) deemed the name Basilosaurus to be inappropriate and proposed Zeuglodon or ‘yoked teeth’ as a replacement name.
[Show full text]
Stomach Contents of Basilosaurus Cetoides
380 STOMACH CONTENTS OF BASILOSAURUS CETOIDES: IMPLICATIONS FOR THE EVOLUTION OF CETACEAN FEEDING BEHAVIOR, AND EVIDENCE FOR VERTEBRATE FAUNA OF EPICONTINENTAL EOCENE SEAS SWIFf*, Camm C., Department of Biology, Loyola Marymount College, Loyola Boulevard at West 80th Street, Los Angeles, California, 90045-2699, U.SA.; BARNES, Lawrence G., Section ofVertebrate Paleontology, Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, 900 Exposition Boulevard, Los Angeles, California, 90007, U.S.A. Direct evidence for the diet of fossil animals is rare but, occasionally the fossilized stomach contents· are found that can indicate the precise nature of the food of once-living animals. A fossil skeleton of a large basilosaurine basilosaurid archaeocete whale, Basi/osaunlS cetoides (Owen, 1839), has been found with a mass of bones and teeth that indicate the diet of the animal. The whale skeleton was found in the Late Eocene Yazoo Formation in Scott County, Mississippi, and it has the large, double rooted cheek teeth and large and elongate lumbar and caudal vertebral centra that typify the species. The stomach contents, excavated from within the rib cage of the skeleton, are an ovoid mass, light yellow in color, measuring approximately 15 by 25 em, with small fish bones exposed on the surface. Sectioning with a rock saw revealed that the internal structure of this mass is a fine-grained, calcareous matrix with hundreds of small bones. Part of this mass was dis-aggregated with hydrochloric acid, and the resulting residue includes body bones of teleost fishes and teeth of small sharks. The remains within the Basilosaunls cetoides skeleton belong to fishes and sharks ranging up to approximately 50 em in length, suggesting that the archaeocete was an active predator.
[Show full text]
Shorter Contributions to General Geology
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR FRANKLIN K. LANE, Secretary UNITED STATES GEOLOGICAL SURVEY GEORGE OTIS SMITH, Director Professional Paper 95 SHORTER CONTRIBUTIONS TO GENERAL GEOLOGY 1915 DAVID WHITE, CHIEF GEOLOGIST WASHINGTON GOVERNMENT PRJ;NTING OFFlCE 1916 THE AGE OF THE OCALA LIMESTONE. By CHARLES W jYTHE CooKE. INTRODUCTION. In 1881 Eugene A. Smith 1 announced the presenc~, underlying large areas in both west ern and peninsular Florida, of limestone which he correlated with the Vicksburg limestone of Mississippi and Alabama and designated by the term Vicksburg limestone. Among the local ities he mentioned specifically are Marianna, in Jackson County, and Ocala, in Marion County. In the following year Heilprin 2 described a species of Nummulites from fragments of rock found by Willcox in Hernando County, on the west coast of Florida, and two years later Willcox discovered the nummulitic limestone in place not far away. Heilprin believed the rock to be the equivalent, in part, of the "Nutnmulitic" of Europe and, on account of the association of the Nummulites with Orbitoides ephippium, considered it to be of Oligocene age. At the -meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in 1887 Johnson 3 said that the rocks mentioned by H ilprin "may be remnants of the Nummulitic limestone, which is really a stratum overlying the Vicksburg rocks" near Levyville and is apparently conformable with the "Vicksburg stage" but evidently not identical with it. The term Ocala appears to have been first formally used by Dall, who described the forma tion under the heading "Nummulitic beds, Ocala limestone (Oligocene of Heilprin)." He says: 4 Among the rocks which until recently were not discriminated from the Orbitoides limestone and which appear in central Florida directly and conformably to overlie the latter, though no one has described their contact, is a yellowish friable rock containing many Foraminifera, conspicuous among which are two species of Nummulites, N.
[Show full text]
The Evolution of Whales
The Evolution of Whales Geology 331 Whales Prothero, 2007 Evolution of Whales 1990s Evolution of Whales 2000s Prothero, 2007 Archaeocetes The two major groups of living whales: Mysticetes (baleen) and Odontocetes (toothed) Blue Whale, Humpback Whale, Sperm Whale, and Killer Whale Whale baleen Tertiary Outcrops Yielding Fossil Whales in Asia Closing of the Tethys Sea during the Cenozoic Indohyus: 48 MY old Pakicetus: 50 MY old Ambulocetus: 49 MY old Basilosaurus: 37 MY old Dorudon: 35 MY old Pakicetus: 50 MY old Size comparison with a modern coyote skull Ambulocetus: 49 MY old Ambulocetus in action Reconstruction of the fossil whale Ambulocetus from the Eocene of Pakistan (~ 49 million years ago). Ambulocetus was discovered in 1994. In this artists reconstruction, Ambulocetus is shown living like a crocodile, hunting land mammals near the shore. Rodhocetus: 46 MY old The ankle bones of Rodhocetus are more similar to artiodactyls (even-toed ungulates) than the traditional mesonychian ancestor. Ocean Hall, Smithsonian Institution Kutchicetus: 45 MY old 5 2 3 1 4 15 MY of evolution during the Eocene Evolutionary Order: 1, Pakicetus; 2, Ambulocetus; 3, Rodhocetus; 4, Kutchicetus; 5, Dorudon Basilosaurus: 37 MY old Ankle, foot, and toes of Basilosaurus excavated in Wadi Hitan, Egypt. The foot as shown is approximately 12 cm long. Photograph ©1991 Philip Gingerich. Phil Gingerich’s work on fossil whales http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I2C-3PjNGok Dr. B. Holly Smith working at the base of the tail at a Basilosaurus excavation in Wadi Hitan, Egypt. We are particularly interested in this part of the skeleton because this is where the reduced hind limbs, feet, and toes are found.
[Show full text]
Investigate How Whales Evolved from Living on Land to Life in the Sea
WHALES: Giants of the Deep Activities for Grades 9-12 Investigate How Whales Evolved from Living on Land to Life in the Sea Overview NYS Science Core Curriculum Before Your Visit: Students will discuss what makes a whale a LE 3.1a: The basic theory of mammal and read about the placement of whales in the Tree of Life. biological evolution states that the Earth’s present-day species During Your Visit: Students will observe features and gather developed from earlier, distinctly evidence to support the claim that the ancestors of present-day different species. whales lived on land. After Your Visit: Students will use the evidence collected from observing fossil specimens and reading labels at the Museum to write an explanation of how whales evolved from terrestrial to aquatic animals. Background for Educators Recent molecular and fossil discoveries show the close relationship of whales to even-toed ungulates, the artiodactyls (i.e. cow, sheep, hippopotamus). In fact, their closest relatives are hippos. The ancestors of whales lived on land about 50 million years ago. Known collectively as Archeocetes, or ancient whales, they might have moved into water in part because of environmental factors – a hot period on Earth. Once whales adapted to water, they diversified and came to inhabit the world’s oceans. Almost 80 spe- cies of Cetaceans are alive today. Scientists study both living and fossil species, and use both anatomy and genetic evidence to understand how these intelligent mammals evolved and where they fit in the Tree of Life. Additional information about the evolution of whales: http://evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibrary/article/evograms_03 Before Your Visit Activity 1: Discussion of What Makes a Whale a Mammal Plan how your students will explore the Whales exhibition Ask students to work in groups of two or three to list all basic using the worksheets.
[Show full text]
Colossal Fossil: Museum's New Whale Skeleton Represents Decades of Research 16 December 2010
Colossal fossil: Museum's new whale skeleton represents decades of research 16 December 2010 team led by Philip Gingerich, director of the U-M Museum of Paleontology and the Ermine Cowles Case Collegiate Professor of Paleontology. Since the 1980s, Gingerich and colleagues have located and mapped the remains of more than a thousand whales in an area of the Egyptian desert known as Wadi Hitan ("valley of the whales"), a UNESCO World Heritage site. Their work there was the subject of an article in the August 2010 issue of National Geographic. In addition, Gingerich and colleagues have made significant fossil whale discoveries in Pakistan. Exhibit preparators Dan Erickson and John Klausmeyer make final adjustments to a complete, 50-foot-long The finds have helped piece together the story of skeleton of the extinct whale Basilosaurus isis on display how whales evolved from typical land-dwelling at the University of Michigan Exhibit Museum of Natural mammals to creatures that spend their whole lives History. Credit: Mandira Banerjee in the sea---a story that will be showcased in the new exhibit, "Back to the Sea: The Evolution of Whales." There's a whale of a new display at the University "We created an exhibit on this topic in 1997 with of Michigan Exhibit Museum of Natural History, a Professor Gingerich, and since then he's made new leviathan that represents a scientific saga of discoveries that we're excited to be able to include equally grand proportions. in the new exhibit," Harris said. To help defray the costs of creating the Basilosaurus skeleton for A complete, 50-foot-long skeleton of the extinct display and completing the update of the "Back to whale Basilosaurus isis, which lived 37 million the Sea" exhibit, the Exhibit Museum has a Buy A years ago, now is suspended from the ceiling of Bone campaign underway, through which donors the museum's second floor gallery and will reign can sponsor individual bones in the skeleton.
[Show full text]