Application of Semantic Technology to Define Names for Fungi Nathan Wilson

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Who am I?

• Naturalist • Mycologist • Software Professional • Director of Biodiversity Informatics for EOL • Director of the MBL Center for Library and Informatics

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Observer

http://mushroomobserver.org/ Tuesday, July 17, 12 Linnaeus, We Have a Problem!

• Cryptic Species • Paraphyletic & Polyphyletic Groups • Convergent Evolution • Changing Circumscriptions

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Cryptic Species

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Who spiked the ?

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Candidates

• Pine Spike • vinicolor • • Chroogomphus ochraceus

Tuesday, July 17, 12

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Para/Polyphyly

Tuesday, July 17, 12 What’s white or red and spicy!?

© Nathan Wilson

© Dimitar Bojantchev © Oluna & Adolf Ceska Tuesday, July 17, 12 Convergent Evolution

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Who likes truffles?

© Noah Siegel

© Mary Smiley

© Daniel B. Wheeler

© Nathan Wilson © Oluna & Adolf Ceska Tuesday, July 17, 12 Gasteromycetes anyone?

© Nathan Wilson © Noah Siegel

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Changing Circumscriptions

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Definition of a Scientific Name Reference Latin name Type Circumscription

Cap: 2-10cm wide; usually overlapping or in a row or a rosette; kidney shaped, also described as fan shaped, sometimes fused laterally; can be flat to wavy; multicolored concentric zoning on the upper surface; zones alternate between

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Definition of a Scientific Name Reference Latin name Type

Circumscription(s) Cap: 2-10cm wide; usually overlapping or in a row or a rosette; kidney shaped, also Cap: 2-10cm wide; described as fan shaped, overlapping or in a row or a sometimes fused laterally; rosette; kidney shaped, also Cap: 2-10cm wide; can be flat to wavy; described as fan shaped; can overlapping, also rosette; can multicolored concentric be flat to wavy; multicolored be flat to wavy; multicolored Cap: 2-10cm wide; zoning on the upper surface; concentric concentric; zones alternate overlapping, wavy; zones alternate between

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Why Bad Things Happen to Good Taxonomists

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Observations & Scientific Names

Circumscription(s)

People Observations Scientific Names

Barcodes Type

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Can Technology Save (or at least help) Our Heros?

Tuesday, July 17, 12 The Semantic Web

• A particular system for representing and extracting ‘meaning’ from the World Wide Web • Sparse data is easy • Data merging is trivial

Tuesday, July 17, 12 A ‘Triple’

• (, , ) • “Laetiporus sulphureus” “is a” “Laetiporus” • :Laetiporus_sulphureus rdfs:subClassOf :Laetiporus .

Tuesday, July 17, 12 An OWL Description

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Semantic Vernacular Description Identifier: SV1234 SVD Name: PineSpike

EquivalentTo: and (hasOverallShape some StipitateAgaric) and (hasHymenophoreShape some Gilled) and ((hasPileusDiscColor some Brown) ...

Chroogomphus rutilus Chroogomphus ochraceus Chroogomphus vinicolor

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Definition of a Scientific Name Reference Latin name Specimen

Circumscription(s) SV9876543 SV8756431 SV7564627 SV6643978

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Observations, Scientific Names & SVDs

Circumscription(s)

People Observations SVDs Scientific Names

Barcodes Type

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Features of an SVD

• Explicit, fixed collection of observable features • If it ‘looks’ like a PineSpike, it is a PineSpike • Amenable to peer review/codification • Inherently unique • Stable

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Complementary to Scientific Names

• Real world / Computable • Phylogenetic / Observable • Scientific literature / Field identification • Connections easy to make

Tuesday, July 17, 12 How Do We Get Started?

Tuesday, July 17, 12 May I Have a Few Volunteers from the Audience?

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Need a Fungal Ontology • References for features and values • Online definitions • Open collaborative process • Start with macroscopic features • Move into microscopic, chemical & molecular features

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Peer Review Process

• Review should be online & reasonably fast • Need review before use • Alternative names & semantic definitions • Support from some number of people • Measurable collaborative process • Is there a role for anonymous review?

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Acknowledgements

• Deborah McGuinness • Kathryn Dunn • Han Wang • Tom Volk

Tuesday, July 17, 12 Questions?

Tuesday, July 17, 12