DOCSLIB.ORG

INDO-PACIFIC Controversy Over Co-Authored Book by Former Heads of ISI and RAW

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
INDO-PACIFIC Controversy Over Co-Authored Book by Former Heads of ISI and RAW INDO-PACIFIC Controversy over Co-authored Book by Former Heads of ISI and RAW OE Watch Commentary: Discussions of Source: Baqir Sajjad Syed. “Army to investigate former ISI chief over claims in book,” the various conflicts and issues between India Dawn, 29 May 2018. https://www.dawn.com/news/1410634 and Pakistan from a regional perspective took The Pakistan Army on Monday set up a ‘court of inquiry’ to investigate former director a new turn in late May with the publication of a book co-authored by retired General Asad general of Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) retired Lt Gen Asad Durrani’s collaboration Durrani, the former head of Pakistan’s Inter- with A.S. Dulat, former chief of Indian spy agency RAW (Research and Analysis Wing), in Services Intelligence (ISI), and A.S. Dulat, the what is being seen as a lightning-rod book project that has stirred heated controversy… former head of India’s Research and Analysis “A formal court of inquiry headed by a serving lieutenant general has been ordered to Wing (RAW). The accompanying excerpted probe the matter in detail. Competent authority has been approached to place the name sources from Pakistan and India discuss the book of Lieutenant General Asad Durrani (retd) on Exit Control List (ECL),” ISPR Director and some of the impact that it has had in both General Maj Gen Asif Ghafoor tweeted…The book The Spy Chronicles: RAW, ISI, and the countries. Illusion of Peace was last week launched in India… The article from Dawn, a widely-read The two former spies have in the book touched upon some of thorny issues that have kept newspaper in Pakistan, reports on the Pakistani Pakistan-India ties strained for decades and at times pushed them to the brink of war. Army’s investigation into Durrani following These issues include terrorism, particularly the Mumbai attacks, Kashmir, spy wars and publication of the book and that he has been the influence of defence bureaucracies and spy agencies in the two countries. placed on an “Exit Control List,” preventing The military is taking it as a potential case of violation of ‘Military Code of Conduct’, him from traveling outside the country while which it says is applicable to all serving and retired military personnel. Section 55 of the investigation takes place. The article notes the Military Law, which relates to “conduct unbecoming of an officer” is considered to that Durrani may have violated “Section 55 of have a very wide scope…In the worst-case scenario, former military officers fear, court the Military Law, which relates to “conduct martial proceedings could be initiated against him…many believe that he did not spill unbecoming of an officer”,” and that this “is any classified secrets. Defence analysts, however, say he could be at fault for not getting considered to have a very wide scope.” The prior permission for the book and then not getting his part vetted and cleared by the army, article also mentions what many other sources in which is the usual procedure. Pakistan reported, that at the very least, Durrani “could be at fault for not getting prior permission Source: “Spy Chronicles: What Got Gen Durrani Into Trouble With the ISI,” The Quint, for the book,” not that he revealed any classified 5 June 2018. https://www.thequint.com/lifestyle/books/spy-chronicles-what-got-asad- information. durrani-into-trouble-with-isi The article from India’s The Quint, an English- …The book in question is an extensive dialogue between former RAW chief AS Dulat and language news website, mentions how the book Durrani, former chief of Pakistan’s premier intelligence agency Inter Services Intelligence was “mediated by journalist Aditya Sinha” and (ISI), mediated by journalist Aditya Sinha. Durrani headed ISI from August 1990 till examines one of the sections of the book that March 1992… likely contributed to Durrani’s legal issues. In the book’s discussion on the case of Kulbhushan The two discuss issues that have long haunted the two nations, but never found a place Jadhav, a Research and Analysis Wing agent on the political agenda. Here are few excerpts from the book that have got Durrani into who was arrested in Pakistan (allegedly in trouble. Balochistan) and charged with espionage, the Discussing the arrest of retired navy officer Kulbhushan Jadhav from the Pakistani article notes that Durrani “holds the Pakistani province of Balochistan on charges of espionage in March 2016, former RAW chief Dulat establishment responsible for the “faulty” says, “If this were a RAW operation, and he was a RAW spy, then it’s a pretty sloppy handling of Balochistan” and he was quoted operation.” saying “From the very beginning, Pakistan’s On the other hand, Gen Durrani said Pakistan’s arrest of Yadav for “being a spy” was handling of Balochistan has been faulty.” Both an attempt by the country to “counter the Indian threat after Pathankot.”…Durrani goes authors spoke fairly candidly about a number of to say that since India was looking for links between Pathankot attack and Pakistani issues throughout the book, but there has been establishment, this was Pakistan’s counter argument, “We know you’ve been doing this (in no mention of Dulat facing any consequences Balochistan).”… from the Indian government. It remains to be seen what, if any, disciplinary action is taken Asad Durrani also holds the Pakistani establishment responsible for the “ faulty” against Durrani, but the book marks a significant handling of Balochistan. “From the very beginning, Pakistan’s handling of Balochistan moment in Indian-Pakistani relations. End OE has been faulty. No one understood that it was complex better than the founder himself.”… Watch Commentary (Stein) “The military is taking it as a potential case of violation of ‘Military Code of Conduct’, which it says is applicable to all serving and retired military personnel. Section 55 of the Military Law, which relates to ‘conduct unbecoming of an officer’ is considered to have a very wide scope.” OE Watch | July 2018 31.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 10 Pakistan's Nuclear Program
    10 PAKISTAN’S NUCLEAR PROGRAM Laying the groundwork for impunity C. Christine Fair Contemporary analysts of Pakistan’s nuclear program speciously assert that Pakistan began acquiring a nuclear weapons capability after the 1971 war with India in which Pakistan was vivisected. In this conventional account, India’s 1974 nuclear tests gave Pakistan further impetus for its program.1 In fact, Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, Pakistan’s first popularly elected prime minister, ini- tiated the program in the late 1960s despite considerable opposition from Pakistan’s first military dictator General Ayub Khan (henceforth Ayub). Bhutto presciently began arguing for a nuclear weapons program as early as 1964 when China detonated its nuclear devices at Lop Nor and secured its position as a permanent nuclear weapons state under the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty (NPT). Considering China’s test and its defeat of India in the 1962 Sino–Indian war, Bhutto reasoned that India, too, would want to develop a nuclear weapon. He also knew that Pakistan’s civilian nuclear program was far behind India’s, which predated independence in 1947. Notwithstanding these arguments, Ayub opposed acquiring a nuclear weapon both because he believed it would be an expensive misadventure and because he worried that doing so would strain Pakistan’s western alliances, formalized through the Central Treaty Organization (CENTO) and the South-East Asia Treaty Organization (SEATO). Ayub also thought Pakistan would be able to buy a nuclear weapon “off the shelf” from one of its allies if India acquired one first.2 With the army opposition obstructing him, Bhutto was unable to make any significant nuclear headway until 1972, when Pakistan’s army lay in disgrace after losing East Pakistan in its 1971 war with India.
    [Show full text]
  • Comparative Constitutional Law SPRING 2012
    Comparative Constitutional Law SPRING 2012 PROFESSOR STEPHEN J. SCHNABLY Office: G472 http://osaka.law.miami.edu/~schnably/courses.html Tel.: 305-284-4817 E-mail: [email protected] SUPPLEMENTARY READINGS: TABLE OF CONTENTS Reference re Secession of Quebec, [1998] 2 S.C.R. 217 .................................................................1 Supreme Court Act, R.S.C., 1985, c. S-26. An Act respecting the Supreme Court of Canada................................................................................................................................11 INS v. Chadha, 462 U.S. 919 (1983) .............................................................................................12 Kenya Timeline..............................................................................................................................20 Laurence Juma, Ethnic Politics and the Constitutional Review Process in Kenya, 9 Tulsa J. Comp. & Int’l L. 471 (2002) ..........................................................................................23 Mary L. Dudziak, Working Toward Democracy: Thurgood Marshall and the Constitution of Kenya, 56 Duke L.J. 721 (2006)....................................................................................26 Laurence Juma, Ethnic Politics and the Constitutional Review Process in Kenya, 9 Tulsa J. Comp. & Int’l L. 471 (2002) .......................................................................................34 Migai Akech, Abuse of Power and Corruption in Kenya: Will the New Constitution Enhance Government
    [Show full text]
  • US Foreign Policy in Pakistan
    Claremont Colleges Scholarship @ Claremont CMC Senior Theses CMC Student Scholarship 2015 U.S. Foreign Policy in Pakistan: Bringing Pakistan Into Line with American Counterterrorism Interests Henry E. Appel Claremont McKenna College Recommended Citation Appel, Henry E., "U.S. Foreign Policy in Pakistan: Bringing Pakistan Into Line with American Counterterrorism Interests" (2015). CMC Senior Theses. Paper 1117. http://scholarship.claremont.edu/cmc_theses/1117 This Open Access Senior Thesis is brought to you by Scholarship@Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion in this collection by an authorized administrator. For more information, please contact [email protected]. CLAREMONT MCKENNA COLLEGE U.S. FOREIGN POLICY IN PAKISTAN: BRINGING PAKISTAN INTO LINE WITH AMERICAN COUNTERTERRORISM INTERESTS SUBMITTED TO PROFESSOR JENNIFER TAW AND DEAN NICHOLAS WARNER BY HENRY E. APPEL FOR SENIOR THESIS FALL 2014/SPRING 2015 APRIL 27, 2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements..........................................................................................................5 Abstract............................................................................................................................6 1 – Introduction...............................................................................................................7 Organization..........................................................................................................8 2 – Realism, The Filter Effect and the U.S. Foreign Policy in Pakistan...................12
    [Show full text]
  • 2009 Helping-Pakistan-Defeat-The
    © 2009 Institute for Social Policy and Understanding All Rights Reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means without permission in writing from the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding. The Institute for Social Policy and Understanding normally does not take institutional positions on public policy issues. The views presented here do not necessarily reflect the views of the Institute, its staff, or trustees. ABOUT THE AUTHOR H A IDER A LI H USSEIN M ULLICK , ISPU F ELLOW Haider Ali Hussein Mullick is a fellow at the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding (ISPU), a senior fellow at the Joint Special Operations University (JSOU), and conducts research on American foreign policy toward South Asia and the Middle East. During his career, he has focused on American-Pakistani relations and broader issues of security; socio- economics; and the geopolitics of Pakistan, Afghanistan, and South Asia. He is the author of a forthcoming book-length monograph: Pakistan’s Security Paradox: Countering and Fomenting Insurgencies. In addition, Haider has conducted research at the Brookings Institution’s Foreign Policy Studies (U.S.-Pakistan Relations), the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars (Pakistan’s Political Economy and Reviving Failed States), and the Hudson Institute’s Center on Islam, Democracy, and the Future of the Muslim World (Madrassa Education and Links to Islamist Militancy). Haider’s editorials have appeared in Newsweek, The Washington Post, Foreign Policy Magazine, The Nation (Pakistan), The Daily Times, The News International, The Times of India, Indian Express, Gulf News, and Pakistan Link.
    [Show full text]
  • Pakistan Response Towards Terrorism: a Case Study of Musharraf Regime
    PAKISTAN RESPONSE TOWARDS TERRORISM: A CASE STUDY OF MUSHARRAF REGIME By: SHABANA FAYYAZ A thesis Submitted to the University of Birmingham For the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Department of Political Science and International Studies The University of Birmingham May 2010 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. ABSTRACT The ranging course of terrorism banishing peace and security prospects of today’s Pakistan is seen as a domestic effluent of its own flawed policies, bad governance, and lack of social justice and rule of law in society and widening gulf of trust between the rulers and the ruled. The study focused on policies and performance of the Musharraf government since assuming the mantle of front ranking ally of the United States in its so called ‘war on terror’. The causes of reversal of pre nine-eleven position on Afghanistan and support of its Taliban’s rulers are examined in the light of the geo-strategic compulsions of that crucial time and the structural weakness of military rule that needed external props for legitimacy. The flaws of the response to the terrorist challenges are traced to its total dependence on the hard option to the total neglect of the human factor from which the thesis develops its argument for a holistic approach to security in which the people occupy a central position.
    [Show full text]
  • Choosing Sides and Guiding Policy United States’ and Pakistan’S Wars in Afghanistan
    UNIVERSITY OF FLORDA Choosing Sides and Guiding Policy United States’ and Pakistan’s Wars in Afghanistan Azhar Merchant 4/24/2019 Table of Contents I. Introduction… 2 II. Political Settlement of the Mujahedeen War… 7 III. The Emergence of the Taliban and the Lack of U.S. Policy… 27 IV. The George W. Bush Administration… 50 V. Conclusion… 68 1 I. Introduction Forty years of war in Afghanistan has encouraged the most extensive periods of diplomatic and military cooperation between the United States and Pakistan. The communist overthrow of a relatively peaceful Afghan government and the subsequent Soviet invasion in 1979 prompted the United States and Pakistan to cooperate in funding and training Afghan mujahedeen in their struggle against the USSR. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Afghanistan entered a period of civil war throughout the 1990s that nurtured Islamic extremism, foreign intervention, and the rise of the Taliban and Al-Qaeda, ultimately culminating in the devastating attacks against Americans on September 11th. Seventeen years later, the United States continues its war in Afghanistan while its relationship with Pakistan has deteriorated to an all-time low. The mutual fear of Soviet expansionism was the unifying cause for Americans and Pakistanis to work together in the 1980s, yet as the wars in Afghanistan evolved, so did the countries’ respective aims and objectives.1 After the Soviets were successfully pushed out of the region by the mujahedeen, the United States felt it no longer had any reason to stay. The initial policy aim of destabilizing the USSR through prolonged covert conflict in Afghanistan was achieved.
    [Show full text]
  • Pakistans Inter-Services Intelligence
    Inhaltsverzeichnis Seite EINFÜHRUNG 1 Pakistans Inter-Services Intelligence 1 DAS ERSTE JAHRZEHNT 8 1.1 Die Gründungsgeschichte 8 1.2 Gründungsvater Generalmajor Walter J. Cawthorne 9 1.3 Die ISI-Führung der ersten Jahre 11 1.4 Strukturelle Konzepte: 1948-1958 11 2 DIE ZEIT DER ERSTEN GENERÄLE: 1958-1971 14 2.1 Der ISI unter Feldmarschall Ayub Khan (1958-1969) 14 2.2 General Yahya Khan (1969-1971) 20 2.3 Veränderungen in der ISI-Leitungs- und Aufgabenstruktur 23 2.4 ISI und CIA - verstärkte Kooperationen 24 2.5 Operationen in Indien: Die 60er und 70er Jahre 3 REGIERUNGSCHEF ZULFIKAR ALI BHUTTO: 1971-1977 28 3.1 Cherat – Kampfschule der Armee 28 3.2 Brennpunkt Balochistan: Die 70er Jahre 29 3.3 Die Geburt des Special Operation Bureau 3.4 Eine fatale Ernennung: Armeechef Zia-ul-Haq 32 3.5 Innenpolitische Verstrickungen 34 3.6 Der Sturz eines Regierungschefs 37 4 ZWISCHENBILANZ VON 30 JAHREN: 1948-1977 40 5 DER ISI UNTER ZIA-UL-HAQ: 1977-1988 5.1 Die ausgehenden 70er Jahre 44 5.2 Weihnachten 1979: Die Afghanistan-Option 46 5.3 Das Afghanistan-Bureau im ISI 49 5.4 Logistik und Korruption 53 5.5 Ingenieur Gulbuddin Hekmatyar 57 5.6 Das Jahr 1987: Abschied von Akhtar Rehman und Yousaf 58 6 TURBULENZEN ENDE DER ACHTZIGER JAHRE 62 6.1 Von Akhtar Rehman zu Hamid Gul 62 6.2 Die Katastrophe im Ojhri-Camp 63 6.3 Ein Flugzeugabsturz mit Folgen: Der Tod von Zia-ul-Haq 65 6.4 Desaster in Afghanistan: Jalalabad 69 7 INNENPOLITISCH SZENARIEN: 1988-1991 73 7.1 Armeechef General Mirza Aslam Beg 73 7.2 Wahlen und Regierungsbildung 76 7.3 Im ISI: Von Hamid
    [Show full text]
  • Pak a TH the R DEG AR Kistan-Japa HESIS SUB REQUIREM GREE in P
    ALLAMA I.I.QAZI CAMPUS JAMSHORO Ph.D Thesis Pakistan-Japan Political and Economic Relations in Post Cold War Era: Challenges & Responses KHALIL-UR-RAHMAN SHAIKH A THESIS SUBMITTED TOWARDS THE PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY DEGREE IN POLITICAL SCIENCE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF SINDH AREA STUDY CENTER FOR FAR EAST AND SOUTH EAST ASIA UNIVERSITY OF SINDH, JAMSHORO PAKISTAN SEPTEMBER 2011 AREA STUDY CENTER FOR FAR EAST AND SOUTH EAST ASIA, UNIVERSITY OF SINDH, JAMSHORO, PAKISTAN CERTIFICATE This is to certify that Mr.Khalil-ur-Rahman Shaikh S/O Muhamamd Bux Shaikh has carried out his research work on the topic entitled as “Pakistan-Japan Political and Economic Relations in Post Cold War Era: Challenges & Responses” under my supervision. His research work is original, distinct and his thesis is worthy of presentation to the University of Sindh for award of Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science. Professor Dr.Lutufullah Mangi Supervisor Department of International Relations University of Sindh ACKNOWLEDGEMENT In the beginning I would like to say thanks to my supervisor Dr. Lutfullah Mangi for his advice, guidance and cooperation. In spite of busy schedule, he dedicated time to read draft several times and improved it. I would also like to pay my deepest sense of gratitude to Japan Foundation for granting me short fellowship which enabled me to visit Japan and conduct interviews of diplomats, professors and other persons directly or indirectly related to Pakistan-Japan relations. During my stay in Japan I also visited various universities and libraries to collect the valuable material.
    [Show full text]
  • Why the U.S. Mistrusts Pakistan's Powerful Spy Agency
    SPECIAL REPORT REUTERS/MOHSIN RAZA WHY THE U.S. MISTRUSTS PAKISTan’S POWERFUL SPY AGENCY The killing of Osama bin Laden exposes just how dysfunctional the relationship between U.S and Pakistani spies has become. BY CHRIS ALLBRITTON AND Abbottabad in northern Pakistan. There, Pakistan's powerful and mysterious Inter- MARK HOSENBALL the agents determined that the courier Services Intelligence agency, known as the ISLAMABAD/WASHINGTON, MAY 5 would make contact with one of the world's ISI, raided a house but failed to find al-Libbi, most wanted men, Abu Faraj al-Libbi, who a senior Pakistani intelligence official told N 2003 OR 2004, PAKistani intelligence had succeeded Sept. 11 mastermind Khalid Reuters this week. agents trailed a suspected militant courier Sheik Muhammad as al Qaeda operations Former Pakistan President Pervez Ito a house in the picturesque hill town of chief a few months earlier. Agents from Musharraf later wrote in his memoirs that MAY 2011 ISI MAY 2011 HIDING PLACE: Aerial views, released by the United State Department of Defense May 2, 2011, shows before (L) and after (R) views of the compound that Osama bin Laden was killed in on Monday in Abbottabad, Pakistan. REUTERS/DEPArtmeNT OF DEFENSE/HANDOUT an interrogation of the courier revealed that who U.S. officials say has been living with al-Libbi used three houses in Abbottabad, his family and entourage in a well-guarded which sits some 50 km (30 miles) northeast compound for years? of Islamabad. The intelligence official said The answer to that question goes to the that one of those houses may have been in heart of the troubled relationship between the same compound where on May 1 U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Report No
    SPECIAL REPORT NO. 462 | JANUARY 2020 UNITED STATES INSTITUTE OF PEACE www.usip.org The India-Pakistan Rivalry in Afghanistan By Zachary Constantino Contents “A Deadly Triangle” ......................3 India in Afghanistan .....................4 Pakistan’s Concerns .................... 9 The Role of Kashmir in Three-Country Tensions ............ 12 How Pakistan Could Punish India in Afghanistan ................... 14 Conclusions and Policy Implications ...................... 17 Afghan President Ashraf Ghani arrives in Islamabad on June 27, 2019, for a meeting with Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan. (Photo by Press Information Department via AP) Summary • India and Pakistan pursue mutually owing to its patronage of a resil- Afghanistan would sharply increase exclusive objectives in Afghanistan ient Taliban insurgency, though should the United States decide to and leverage sharply different tools the Pakistan-Taliban relationship is abruptly withdraw from Afghanistan to achieve their respective goals. replete with tension. India believes without a broad-based intra-Afghan Pakistan utilizes militant groups, supporting the existing Afghan sys- peace deal in place. including the Afghan Taliban, as tem best serves its interests, a poli- • Confidence-building measures con- strategic proxies, while India plac- cy informed by the lack of plausible structed around transparency and es considerable weight on its soft alternatives. New Delhi is unlikely economic cooperation are not likely power influence among Afghans. to acquire, let alone deploy,
    [Show full text]
  • Cover Page – Title
    KASHMIR: THE VIEW FROM ISLAMABAD 4 December 2003 ICG Asia Report N°68 Islamabad/Brussels TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..................................................................................................... i I. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 1 II. HISTORY OF THE KASHMIR CONFLICT – A PAKISTANI PERSPECTIVE 3 III. PERCEPTIONS OF NATIONAL SECURITY ........................................................... 4 A. HISTORY OF WAR .................................................................................................................4 B. SIMLA AGREEMENT ..............................................................................................................5 C. KASHMIRI MILITANCY, PAKISTANI INTERVENTION AND NEAR WAR CRISES.........................5 D. COSTS OF CONFLICT .............................................................................................................8 IV. DOMESTIC OPPORTUNITIES AND CONSTRAINTS......................................... 10 A. CIVIL AND MILITARY BUREAUCRACIES ..............................................................................10 B. REGIONAL DIFFERENCES.....................................................................................................15 C. POLITICAL PARTIES.............................................................................................................16 1. Regional Parties .......................................................................................................17
    [Show full text]
  • Crisesinsouthasia: Trendsandpotentialconsequences
    ­­­ Crises­in­South­Asia:­ Trends­and­Potential­Consequences Michael­Krepon Nate­Cohn Editors September­2011 Copyright © 2011 The Henry L. Stimson Center ISBN: 978-0-9845211-9-7 Cover and book design by Shawn Woodley All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means without prior written consent from the Stimson Center. Stimson Center 1111 19th Street, NW, 12th Floor Washington, DC 20036 Telephone: 202.223.5956 Fax: 202.238.9604 www.stimson.org Table­of­Contents Preface.................................................................................................................................iii List.of.Abbreviations.......................................................................................................... v Crises.in.South.Asia:.Trends.and.Potential.Consequences........................................... 1 Michael Krepon Appendices Appendix.I:..The.Structure.of.South.Asian.Crises.from.Brasstacks.to.Mumbai......29 Samuel Black Appendix.II:..Spoilers, Mass-Casualty.Attacks,.and.the.Disruption.of.Hopeful. India-Pakistan.Diplomacy......................................................................................55 Nathan Cohn Appendix.III:..Mass-Casualty.Attacks.in.India............................................................63 Nathan Cohn and William Shimer Appendix.IV:..Mass-Casualty.Attacks.in.Pakistan.......................................................71 Nathan Cohn Appendix.V:..Chinese.Involvement.in.South.Asian.Crises.........................................93
    [Show full text]