Afro-Colombian Women's Organisations in Post-Accord Colombia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 | A LTERNAUTAS 7 (1) – J ULY 2020 Alternautas (Re)Searching Development: The Abya Yala Chapter Alternautas – Vol.7 – Issue 1 – July 2020 Preface Introduction to the Special Issue on Indigenous and Afrodescendant Movements and Organizations in Latin America: Negotiating, Resisting, Performing and Re-purposing Dominant Categories – Diego Silva & Nancy Postero Afro-Colombian Women’s Organisations in Post- Accord Colombia: Gendering and Racialising Violent Pluralism across the Conflict Continuum in Bogotá, Colombia – Julia Zulver Spatiality, Temporality and Ontology: Constraints for the Restitution of Indigenous Peoples’ Territorial Rights in Colombia – Yira Lazala Were there Nonhumans in Bagua? The Gobierno Territorial Autónomo de la Nación Wampis and the Emergence of Vertical Territoriality in the Northern Peruvian Amazon – Thomas Niederberger Baianas de Acarajé against FIFA: Coloniality Nowadays – Larissa Da Silva Araujo Occupying and Expanding (un)Expected Categories: Ways of Being and Becoming Indigenous within the United Nations System– Urpi Saco Chung Seeds of Resistance: The Pijao Group, a Youth Process of Decolonization and the Unity of the Pijao People– Viviana Lozano Ducuara, Edwin Alexander Henao Conde ISSN - 2057-4924 -- Alternautas is a peer reviewed academic blog EDITORIAL BOARD that publishes content related to Latin American Ana Estefanía Carballo (University of Melbourne, Australia) Critical Development Michela Coletta (University of Warwick, United Kingdom) thinking. Gibrán Cruz-Martínez (Institute of Public Goods and Policies, CSIC, It intends to serve as a Spain) platform for testing, Emilie Dupuits (Universidad Central del Ecuador) circulating, and debating María Eugenia Giraudo (University of Warwick, United Kingdom) new ideas and reflections Rebecca Hollender (The New School, United States) on these topics, expanding Valesca Lima (Maynooth University, Ireland) beyond the geographical, Angus McNelly (Queen Mary, University of London, United cultural and linguistic Kingdom) boundaries of Latin Paulina Méndez Rheinische (Friedriech-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn, America - Abya Yala. We Germany) hope to contribute to connecting ideas, and to Nicholas Pope (SOAS, University of London, United Kingdom) provide a space for María del Pilar Ramírez Gröbli (University of Bern, Switzerland) intellectual exchange and Philip Roberts (University of York, United Kingdom) discussion for a nascent Läetitia Saint-Loubert (Université de la Reunión, France) academic community of Diego Silva (The Graduate Institute of International and Development scholars, devoted to Studies, Switzerland) counter-balancing Johannes M. Waldmüller (Universidad de las Américas, Ecuador) mainstream understandings of development. COLLABORATORS - COMMISSIONING EDITORS & COPY EDITORS -- Alexander D’Aloia (Australian National University, Australia) www.alternautas.net Adrian E. Beling (Humboldt Universität, Germany – Universidad f: /Alternautas Alberto Hurtado, Chile) t: @alternautas Juan Jaime Loera González (Escuela de Antropología e Historia del [email protected] Norte de México, México) London, UK. Julien Vanhulst (Universidad Católica del Maule, Chile) ISSN - 2057-4924 -- María Mancilla García (University of Stockholm, Sweden) Sue A. S. Iamamoto (Universidade Federal da Bahia, Brazil) Anne Freeland, Columbia University (United States) 3 | A LTERNAUTAS 7 (1) – J ULY 2020 Contents Preface ...................................................................................... 5 Introduction to the Special Issue on Indigenous and Afrodescendant Movements and Organizations in Latin America: Negotiating, Resisting, Performing and Re-purposing Dominant Categories ............................................................... 9 Afro-Colombian Women’s Organisations in Post-Accord Colombia: Gendering and Racialising Violent Pluralism across the Conflict Continuum in Bogotá, Colombia ....................... 31 Spatiality, Temporality and Ontology: Constraints for the Restitution of Indigenous Peoples’ Territorial Rights in Colombia ............................................................................... 47 Were there Nonhumans in Bagua? The Gobierno Territorial Autónomo de la Nación Wampis and the Emergence of Vertical Territoriality in the Northern Peruvian Amazon ..................... 62 Baianas de Acarajé against FIFA: Coloniality Nowadays ......... 79 Ocupando y Ampliando Categorías (in)Esperadas: Formas de Ser y de Convertirse en Indígena dentro del Sistema de las Naciones Unidas ..................................................................... 92 Occupying and Expanding (un)Expected Categories: Ways of Being and Becoming indigenous within the United Nations System .................................................................................. 113 Contents | 4 Semillas de Resistencia: El Grupo Pijao, un Proceso Juvenil por la Descolonización y Unidad del Pueblo Pijao ...................... 134 Seeds of Resistance: The Pijao Group, a Youth Process of Decolonisation and the Unity of the Pijao People ................. 148 5 | A LTERNAUTAS 7 (1) – J ULY 2020 Preface Welcome to the seventh volume of Alternautas! We are proud to present to readers with this Special Issue of Alternautas, ‘Indigenous and Afro-descendant Movements and Organisations in Latin America. Resisting, Performing and Re-purposing Dominant Categories’. In this issue we continue to publish critical research and alternative intellectual perspectives about Latin American development processes. We are pleased to have several new authors joining us this time from various parts of the world. The foci of this special issue are the political strategies, forms of resistance, and anti- political practices that indigenous and Afro-descendant communities across Latin America have developed to deal with diverse challenges presented to them by the state and the market. However, it is impossible to preface this issue without reflecting on the contemporary global crises that are currently affecting all of our lives in so many ways. The effects of Covid-19, since the first South American case was declared in São Paulo, Brazil on 26 February 2020, have been devastating. As we write this in August 2020, the epicentre of the Covid-19 pandemic is sweeping through the Amazon region of Brazil, Colombia and Peru. But the number of cases is also rampant in Colombia, Peru, Guatemala, and Bolivia, and there are now cases in every Latin American country. Some of the worst-affected areas are the marginalised rural and urban peripheral ones, where there tends to be high concentrations of indigenous and Afro-descendant populations. We clearly still have a lot to learn about this disease, and we do know that pandemics affect different populations in different ways, but what is becoming clear is the ethnic and racial inequalities that were already embedded in Latin American societies – such as higher levels of Preface | 6 malnutrition, difficulties in accessing health services, and precarious infrastructure – are going to be accentuated.1 Amadeo Martínez, the General Coordinator for the Abya Yala Indigenous Forum (FILAY), has already identified the very real threat that the pandemic poses for food security.2 This has led to calls by the United Nations and the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) for greater support and responses in the Amazon region. When we put all of this together, there is clearly a risk of new forms of violence and conflict beginning to emerge once resources, clean water, and food are in short supply. Responses to the Covid-19 crisis by Latin American governments have been patchy, to say the least. In just a couple of examples, the Articulation of Indigenous Peoples of Brazil (APIB) has accused the Bolsonaro government of a "fascist strategy", aimed at “cleaning up the area” to make way for a developmental project in the Amazon.3 Similarly, a public letter addressed to President Vizcarra in Peru by civil society organisations and indigenous groups have demanded urgent state resources and humanitarian action after five months of inaction.4 Intersecting with this very immediate crisis are more protracted issues of racial and ethnic hierarchy. However, these are shifting into sharper focus in dominant academic and policy-making discourse due to the momentum generated by the global Black Lives Matters movement. Although the movement is building in a number of developed societies, the sense of immediate moral outrage in Latin America appears far less widespread. News about the death of fourteen-year-old João Pedro Matos Pinto being killed by seventy police bullets on May 18, 2020 was clearly heart breaking. But the everyday, quotidian nature of ethnic and racial violence in Latin America has significantly different repercussions. 1 Hooper, Monica Webb, Anna María Nápoles, and Eliseo J. Pérez-Stable. "COVID-19 and racial/ethnic disparities." Jama (2020). 2 https://i.noticiasfides.com/filac-alerta-del-peligro-de-desaparicion-de-pueblos-indigenas-por- el-covid-19-404707/ 3 http://apib.info/2020/07/08/contra-as-decisoes-anti-indigenas-do-governo-bolsonaro/ 4 https://content.eia-global.org/assets/2020/08/20200813_Amazon_in_Emergency.pdf 7 | A LTERNAUTAS 7 (1) – J ULY 2020 As we go to press, the pandemic is crashing global and local markets, and the immediate health effects for Latin American minority communities are becoming more visible every day. However, the continued neglect of Afro-descendant and indigenous communities treatment in relation to Covid-19 is another demonstration