RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION RFA Board of Directors

Neil Koehler RFA Chairman Pacific Ethanol Inc. www.pacificethanol.com

Jeanne McCaherty Charles Wilson Geoff Cooper Rick Schwarck RFA Vice Chair RFA Treasurer RFA President RFA Secretary Guardian Energy LLC Trenton Agri Products LLC Renewable Fuels Association Absolute Energy LLC www.guardiannrg.com www.trentonagriproducts.com www.EthanolRFA.org www.absenergy.org

Neal Kemmet Mick Henderson Brian Kletscher Bob Pasma Ace Ethanol LLC Commonwealth Agri-Energy LLC Highwater Ethanol LLC Parallel Products www.aceethanol.com www.commonwealthagrienergy.com www.highwaterethanol.com www.parallelproducts.com Ray Baker Scott Mundt Pat Boyle Delayne Johnson Adkins Energy LLC Dakota Ethanol LLC Homeland Energy Solutions LLC Quad County Corn Processors Coop. www.adkinsenergy.com www.dakotaethanol.com www.homelandenergysolutions.com www.quad-county.com Eric McAfee John Didion Seth Harder Dana Lewis Aemetis Inc. Didion Ethanol LLC Husker Ag LLC Redfield Energy LLC www.aemetis.com www.didionmilling.com www.huskerag.com www.redfieldenergy.com Randall Doyal Carl Sitzmann Kevin Keiser Walter Wendland Al-Corn Clean Fuel LLC E Energy Adams LLC Ingredion Inc. Ringneck Energy LLC www.al-corn.com www.eenergyadams.com www.ingredion.com www.ringneckenergy.com Erik Huschitt Bill Pracht Chuck Woodside Brian Pasbrig Badger State Ethanol LLC East Kansas Agri-Energy LLC KAAPA Ethanol Holdings LLC Show Me Ethanol LLC www.badgerstateethanol.com www.ekaellc.com www.kaapaethanol.com www.smefuel.com Jim Leiting Jason Friedberg Eric Mosbey Pam Miller Big River Resources West Burlington LLC ELEMENT LLC * Lincolnland Agri-Energy LLC Siouxland Ethanol LLC www.bigriverresources.com www.elementbiofuels.com www.lincolnlandagrienergy.com www.siouxlandethanol.com Matthew Viergutz Neal Kemmet Steve Roe Mike Jerke Butamax Advanced Biofuels LLC Fox River Valley Ethanol LLC Little Sioux Corn Processors LLC Southwest Iowa Renewable Energy LLC www.butamax.com www.frvethanol.com www.littlesiouxcornprocessors.com www.sireethanol.com Ryan Drook Jim Boeding John Kosanovich Jim Pirolli CIE LLC Golden Grain Energy LLC Merrick & Co. The Andersons Inc. www.cie.us www.ggecorn.com www.merrick.com www.andersonsethanol.com Chad Friese Mark Ricketts Chris Wilson Dennis Balakian Chippewa Valley Ethanol Co. Grain Processing Corp. Mid-Missouri Energy LLC West Coast Waste * www.cvec.com www.grainprocessing.com www.midmissourienergy.com www.westcoastwaste.info Steve Markham Steve Christensen Thomas Corle Tim Winters CHS Inc. Granite Falls Energy LLC New Energy Blue LLC * Western New York Energy LLC www.chsinc.com www.granitefallsenergy.com www.newenergyblue.com www.wnyenergy.com Gary Anderson Derek Peine Heartland Corn Products Western Plains Energy LLC www.heartlandcorn.com www.wpellc.com

* Prospective Producer Member 2 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION

Without a doubt, 2019 proved to be a challenging year. An unprecedented number of small refinery waivers crippled RFS demand and led to more than 20 ethanol plants shutting down temporarily or permanently. Export demand has been undermined by growing protectionism across the globe. And while the Administration did finally allow the year-round blending of E15, expanding that market has been challenged by low RIN prices and strong opposition to higher ethanol blends from an incumbent oil industry that continues to protect its monopoly at the pump.

But at the dawn of a new decade, there are optimistic signs on the horizon. President Trump seems committed to limiting the damaging impact of small refinery exemptions. Increased global demand for low carbon octane is beginning to chip away at trade barriers. And drivers across the country are demanding higher octane lower cost E15. Thus, this Outlook indeed has put the Focus Forward. As has been the hallmark of the RFA and the in- dustry for decades, we will do the work necessary to open markets here and abroad, providing savings to consum- ers, value-added markets for farmers, and energy and environmental security for all of America.

The Renewable Fuels Association will continue to lead. We are working with our allies on Capitol Hill to move legislation providing greater certainty for the future, building upon the success of the RFS, seizing the low carbon high octane benefits of ethanol, and assuring further growth. We are working with industry allies and the U.S. government to expand export markets in China, Mexico, India, and anywhere consumers could benefit from in- creased biofuels. And we are continuing to build consumer understanding of ethanol’s superior performance with market development efforts focused on rebutting the mythology the oil industry has created about our fuel.

As you review the pages that follow, you will see an industry that is maturing and an association that is firing on all cylinders as we truly Focus Forward—not just reducing our weaknesses and threats; but maximizing our strengths and opportunities—as we forge our bright and clear path into 2020 and beyond.

Sincerely,

Geoff Cooper, President & CEO

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 1 Focusing Forward, From Challenge to Opportunity

was most assuredly the most The Administration did provide a boost to the ethanol market challenging year for the U.S. last year by finalizing a rule allowing the year-round use of 2019ethanol industry in decades. The E15, potentially increasing near-term ethanol demand by Environmental Protection Agency’s indiscriminate use of approximately 40 million gallons. Despite that action, the small refinery waivers under the Renewable Fuel Standard re- domestic ethanol blend fell below 10 percent at times during duced domestic demand while growing global protectionism the winter and spring as the market responded to demand limited ethanol markets abroad. As a result, ethanol prices destruction caused by small refinery exemptions, recovering plummeted, causing many ethanol production facilities to only in the fall after President Trump announced he would reduce output. Twenty plants closed their doors either per- direct EPA to fix the loophole causing so much damage to manently or temporarily, and U.S. ethanol production fell to America’s farmers. 15.8 billion gallons, 300 million gallons below 2018—despite Thankfully, as we focus forward into 2020 the picture bright- new production capacity coming on line. ens. With a growing E15 market, some movement to curtail rampant small refinery waivers and account for projected waived gallons in annual RVO regulations, and optimistic signs that trade barriers in China, Mexico, and other critical U.S. Fuel Ethanol international markets will soon be addressed, the outlook for Biorefineries by State ethanol production and marketing in 2020 is as bullish as it

has been in a decade.

WA ME MT ND VT MN NH ID MA OR WI MI NY RI SD CT WY PA NJ NE OH MD IA DE NV UT DC CO WV IL IN VA KY CA MO KS NC TN AZ NM OK AR SC GA MS AL LA TX FL

Installed Ethanol Biorefinery New Biorefinery Under Construction* *Excludes expansion projects

2 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION U.S. Ethanol Production Capacity by State Production Facilities (Million Gallons per Year)

Existing Operating Under Total Installed Ethanol Operating Ethanol Biorefineries Production Production Construc- Capacity Biorefineries Biorefineries Under Constr./ Capacity tion/ Expansion Iowa* 4,495 4,445 - 4,495 44 43 - Nebraska 2,274 2,176 - 2,274 26 23 - Illinois 1,887 1,718 - 1,887 14 13 - Minnesota 1,308 1,266 - 1,308 19 18 - Indiana 1,198 991 80 1,278 14 12 1 South Dakota 1,179 1,179 - 1,179 16 16 - Ohio 676 626 - 676 7 6 - Wisconsin 648 598 - 648 9 9 - Kansas 543 518 70 613 12 11 1 North Dakota 487 487 33 520 5 5 2 Texas 375 335 - 375 4 3 - Michigan 338 283 - 338 5 4 - Missouri 276 261 - 276 6 6 - Tennessee 230 230 - 230 2 2 - California 218 218 - 218 5 5 - New York 165 165 - 165 2 2 - Colorado 125 125 - 125 4 4 - Georgia 120 120 - 120 1 1 - Pennsylvania 110 110 - 110 1 1 - Idaho 60 60 - 60 1 1 - North Carolina 60 - - 60 1 - - Arizona 50 - - 50 1 - - Kentucky 48 48 - 48 2 2 - Oregon 42 42 - 42 2 2 - Florida 8 - - 8 1 - - Virginia 4 4 - 4 1 1 - TOTAL U.S. 16,924 16,005 183 17,107 205 190 4

Source: RFA *Data includes one operating plant with unknown or undisclosed production volumes.

“Today, we honor America’s cherished farming heritage. We salute your commitment to American energy independence, and we celebrate the bright future that we are forging together powered by clean, affordable American ethanol.”

—President Trump at RFA member plant Southwest Iowa Renewable Energy, June 2019

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 3 Focusing on the Rural Economy

ith trade policy decisions that hampered global crop marketing and bad weather wreaking havoc Wacross the Corn Belt, 2019 was a year that many in rural America are glad to have in the rear-view mirror. As in 2018, 2019 brought on another year of reduced cash receipts, as a trade dispute with China continued to be felt, bolstered only in part by a series of direct farm program payments. In its own 2020 outlook, CoBank reports that rural America will continue to lag behind the rest of the country; GDP growth in rural counties has averaged nearly 1 percent less than in urban counties since 2014.

This is why growing the ethanol industry remains of vital importance to rural America. In 2019, there were 68,684 U.S. jobs directly associated with the ethanol industry, and it supported an additional 280,327 indirect and induced jobs across all sectors of the economy. The industry created $23.3 billion in household income and contributed $43 billion to the national Gross Domestic Product. Moreover, the ethanol industry spent over $27 billion on raw materials, inputs, and other goods and services.

Just as U.S. ethanol production has contributed to America’s energy independence, so too have many of those working at ethanol plants and supporting operations: Almost one-quarter of the men and women employed by the industry are veterans of the U.S. military, and we salute them.

Ethanol’s Value-Added Proposition Based on average prices and product yields in 2019, a typical , the production of 15.8 billion gallons dry mill ethanol plant was adding roughly $1.20 of additional In 2019 of ethanol and 39.6 million metric tons of co-products value--or 31%--to every bushel of corn processed. and distillers oil had substantial economic impacts, including: CORN VALUE OF OUTPUTS PER BUSHEL • 68,684 direct jobs COST PER BUSHEL Ethanol...... $3.82 • 280,327 indirect and induced jobs Distillers Grains...... $1.11 $3.90 • $43 billion contribution to GDP Corn Distillers Oil...... $0.17 • $23.3 billion in household income TOTAL $5.10

4 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION

Gross Value of U.S. Ethanol Industry Output

Ethanol Co-products

7,025 20,948

Million Dollars

*

Source: RFA based on U.S. Dept. of Agriculture data * Estimated

Ethanol ndustry Petroleum National Workforce Fuels ndustry (All ndustries)

Ethanol GENDER Industry Female Workforce Male AND Demographics OER UNONZED

Sources: National Association of State Energy MLTARY Officials & Energy Futures Initiative ETERANS

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 5 Energizing Global Markets

he United States is the world leader in the production, Prohibitive tariffs imposed by China in connection with the consumption and export of ethanol. The nearly 16 billion trade conflict with the United States caused shipments to Tgallons of ethanol produced here in 2019 represents 54 fall to negligible levels for most of 2019. On the other hand, percent of global output. In comparison, Brazil accounted for longstanding antidumping duties by the European Union, only 30 percent of global production, despite significant growth which the U.S. industry had actively worked to overturn, were over the last two years. allowed to end.

U.S. ethanol exports declined modestly in 2019 to an estimated Exports to a large majority of the top-ten destinations for U.S. 1.5 billion gallons, second only to the record 1.7 billion gallons ethanol were higher in 2019. There were notable increases shipped in 2018 and representing approximately 10 percent of in shipments to India, the third-largest market, as well as to the ethanol produced in the United States. Colombia and South Korea.

For the fifth straight year, Brazil and Canada remained the U.S. ethanol imports more than doubled from the nearly 80 top two destinations for U.S. ethanol, taking nearly half of our million gallons received in 2018. Brazilian sugarcane-based exports. Shipments to Canada have been fairly stable in recent ethanol benefitted from the high prices of credits toward the years. However, exports to Brazil fell in 2019 as a result of California Low Carbon Fuel Standard and from widening price sizable inventories early in the year, higher ethanol production, spreads among categories of RFS credits (RINs) that resulted the continued implementation of a tariff rate quota, and the from small refinery exemptions doled out by the EPA. restriction of quota volumes during the September-February Multiple opportunities exist to regain momentum in export period. The decline in shipments to Brazil was the main factor growth. A resolution of the trade conflict with China could causing overall U.S. exports to recede in 2019. reopen a large-scale market. Canadian provinces are moving to higher blends. Average blend rates are increasing in India, and there is potential for barriers to the use of U.S. ethanol to be lowered. Considerable market development efforts have been conducted by the U.S. industry in Mexico. Finally, Brazil is likely to remain a top destination, and the U.S. industry remains engaged to ensure that it receives fair treatment as the RenovaBio program is implemented in 2020.

Global fuel ethanol production hit a new record of 29 billion gallons in 2019, with the United States again accounting for over half of the world’s production.

6 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION illion Gallons Source: RFA basedondata from U.S. Dept. of Commerce &U.S. Census Bureau *Estimated basedon Jan.-Nov. 2019data *Estimated basedon Jan.-Nov. 2019data Source: RFA basedon data from U.S. Dept. of Commerce &U.S. Census Bureau 1,000 1,200 1,00 1,600 1,00 00 600 00 200 200 00 600 00 0

Mexico 22% Canada 2%

ports

U.S. Ethanol ExportsandImports

Colombia Peru 3% 6%

mports

Top Destinations for U.S. EthanolExportsin2019

24% et ports Brazil

REST OF WORLD 14%

Netherlands

3%

* 2019 Global Fuel Ethanol Production by Country (Country, milliongallons,share of globalproduction)

Source: RFA analysis of publicandprivate data sources Oman 3% 1,00 nited tates 2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK

,620 0 rail 11% India Philippines Korea South South 5% 7% 600 2 estof World 290 1 Argentina 20 1 Thailand 00 2 anada 0 2 ndia 900 hina 1,0 uropean nion

7 Progressive Processors Unlock New Products

ophisticated ethanol production facilities have been In September, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration gained using engineering and design enhancements, new full authority to enforce the Food Safety Modernization Sprocess technologies, automation upgrades, and other Act Preventive Controls for Animal Food Rule. FDA over- advances to make remarkable gains in efficiency to extract sight lends formal assurance to domestic and international more out of each bushel of corn and generate multiple prod- customers that American-made ethanol co-products are safe uct streams. Industry is leaping forward to develop potential feed ingredients. new feed definitions to green-light the next generation of U.S. ethanol producers also captured 5.8 billion pounds ethanol co-products. of high-grade biogenic CO2 in 2019 for North American In 2019, U.S. ethanol producers generated 39.6 million food/beverage and industrial markets. Further, the industry metric tons (mmt) of distillers grains, gluten feed, and gluten is actively engaged in promoting the groundbreaking meal. These bio-products are valuable corn and soybean meal deployment of carbon capture and sequestration in a substitutes in rations used around the world to feed beef and pivotal step toward fighting climate change. dairy cows, pigs, chickens, turkeys, fish, and other animals. Ethanol plants extracted 3.8 billion pounds of corn distillers oil—a nearly $1 billion market underpinning the production of biodiesel and animal feed.

Top Destinations for U.S. Distillers Grains Exports in 2019 8%

Canada 6% Ireland 3%

Turkey South Korea 6% Japan 11% 5%

Mexico 19% Thailand 5% Vietnam Philippines 11% 2%

Indonesia 8%

REST OF WORLD 24%

Source: RFA based on data from U.S. Dept. of Commerce & U.S. Census Bureau *Estimated based on Jan.-Nov. 2019 data

8 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION Distillers Grains Consumption by Species A DIVERSIFIED TRADE PORTFOLIO Poultry Other U.S. biorefineries satisfied growing domestic animal food needs while also exporting at

Swine least one of every four tons of distillers grains Beef produced. Broadened educational and B2B

Dairy outreach helped to grow the U.S. bio-product customer base into the most diverse mix in our industry’s history. Source: Distillers grains marketing companies In 2019, 53 countries purchased a cumulative 10.9 mmt of U.S. distillers grains. Half of these exports landed in South- 4,000 Distillers Grains Production by Type, As-Is Basis east and East Asia, despite China’s decision in June to main- ,000 Modified tain anti-dumping and anti-subsidy tariffs on U.S. distillers Wet Distillers ,00 Wet Distillers Grains, 10% grains imports. Another quarter of sales were transborder

s ,000 Grains, 32% d

n 2,00 Condensed shipments, with Mexico extending its position as our top u

o Distillers

P 2,000

distillers grains customer for a third consecutive year.

n Solubles 1,00 Dried Distillers o Grains with (Syrup), 3%

ill i 1,000 Solubles, 46% The Renewable Fuels Association anticipates that mount- 00 Dried ing demand and geographic diversity lie ahead as countries 0 Distillers 200 2006 2007 200 2009 2010 2011 2012 Grains,201 201 9%201 2016 2017 201 around the globe em- Source: RFA based on U.S. Dept. of Agriculture data brace the use of these safe and economical U.S. Ethanol Industry Co-product Animal Feed Output ethanol bio-products.

593 istillers Grains orn Gluten eed orn Gluten eal 3,023 36,028 ,000

0,000

,000 s

0,000 n o T

c

2,000 tr i e U.S. Distillers Grains Exports

20,000 d n a s

1,000 u o

h 1,000 10,930 s T 10,000 n o 12,000 T

c

,000 i

r 10,000 t e 0 ,000

d

n 6,000 a 2000 2001 2002 200 200 200 2006 2007 200 2009 2010 2011 2012 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 2019 s Source: RFA based on data from U.S. Dept. of Agriculture. *Estimated u ,000 o

Note: All co-products converted to 10% moisture basis. h T 2,000

Corn Distillers Oil Production

3,774 200 2006 2007 200 2009 2010 2011 2012 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 2019

,000 Source: RFA based on data from U.S. Dept. of Commerce & U.S. Census Bureau ,00 *Estimated based on Jan.-Nov. 2019 data ,000 2,00 2,000 1,00

illion Pounds illion 1,000 00 0 200 2006 2007 200 2009 2010 2011 2012 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 2019

Source: RFA based on U.S. Dept. of Agriculture data *Estimated

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 9 A Clean Source for Octane

ctane continues to be in high demand, and ethanol Moreover, ethanol has the highest octane-blending value of is a clean, affordable source. To meet corporate any major source of octane while having among the lowest Oaverage fuel economy requirements and consumer market prices. Ethanol has a blending octane rating of 114, preferences, automakers are increasingly using turbocharged, which is higher than the ratings of the main petroleum-based higher-compression engines in which the use of high-octane components. In 2019, ethanol traded at the largest discount gasoline is recommended or required. As a result, premium to its blending value, as its market price remained subdued gasoline sales in the United States has been strong over the while the prices of other components rebounded. As a result, last five years. ethanol retained the title of being the most competitive source of octane in the world. This higher demand has driven up the price spread between premium and regular gasoline. In 2019, premium gasoline At the same time, supplies of petroleum-based compo- was 16 percent more expensive than regular gasoline in the nents have become constrained as a result of the increasing wholesale market and a lofty 29 percent more expensive at availability of lighter shale oils, the configuration of refineries, retail – reaching the highest levels in at least two decades. and restrictions on the sulfur content in fuel. Additionally, aromatic hydrocarbons such as benzene are toxic and worsen However, ethanol is helping to hold down the cost of both air pollution. regular and premium gasoline. According to a study by Dr. Philip K. Verleger, Jr., consumers saved an average of 22 cents per gallon from 2015 through 2018 as a result of the use of ethanol.

Premium Gasoline: Share of Sales and Price Difference vs. Regular Octane Blending Value vs. Market Price

1 0 00 1 1 2 20 12 20 200 11 10 1 10 9 10 100 entsGallon 7 0

6 Between Difference Price Premium and egular Gasoline and egular Premium Premium hare of Gasoline ales Gasoline of hare Premium 0 0 Alylate eformate Toluene T thanol T aphtha 2000 2001 2002 200 200 200 2006 2007 200 2009 2010 2011 2012 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 2019 lend alue aret Price Premium hare of Gasoline ales Retail Price Spread: Premium vs. Regular Wholesale Price Spread: Premium vs. Regular Source: Argus Media

Source: RFA based on U.S. Energy Information Administration data

10 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION Refiners have optimized operations to reduce hydrocarbon A key development in 2019 was the Trump administration’s octane production in order to take advantage of ethanol’s issuance of a rule allowing E15 (gasoline containing 15 per- properties. Today, most regular gasoline in the United States cent ethanol) to be sold year-round throughout the country. is produced using blendstock with an octane rating of 84, E15 sales volumes increased in response, as restrictions on which is then upgraded to a rating of 87 by adding 10 percent offering E15 in the summertime were lifted and as the num- ethanol. This allows refiners to increase their throughput of ber of retail stations carrying the fuel expanded. E15 sold at hydrocarbon blendstock at a lower cost. retail typically has an octane rating of 88, giving consumers an added boost at a lower cost. A recent analysis by Baker & O’Brien, Inc. for the U.S. Energy Information Administration researched prices at the distribu- The demand for octane looks set to continue to grow. It is tion terminal, where ethanol is blended, and “failed to find any being driven in the United States by the use of advanced significant change since 2010 to account for the increasing vehicle engines, tighter gasoline specifications, and the regular-to-premium retail gasoline price spread.” expansion of E15—and could be propelled further by the need for midlevel ethanol blends (e.g., E25-E30) to meet future fuel economy and emissions standards.

Blending Octane Ratings of Various A fuel’s is the Gasoline Octane Boosters octane rating measure of its ability to resist “knocking” Ethanol 120 114 in the engine, which is caused when the 117 11 air/fuel mixture detonates prematurely 110 110 107 10 during combustion. According to the U.S. 10 101 100 Department of Energy, “Using a lower 9 9 9 octane fuel than required can cause the 90 Octane Rating engine to run poorly and can damage the 0 84 engine and emissions control system over 7 time. It may also void your warranty.” 70 Gasoline nutane Alylate enene Toluene ylene T thanol ethanol lendstoc

Source: U.S. Department of Energy

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 11 The Low Carbon Solution

through 2018 ranked as the USDA. Further, CARB data show that ethanol is responsible earth’s five warmest years on for 22 million metric tons of GHG reduction from California’s 2014record, and 2019 is likely to top transportation sector since 2011—more than any other low them all. Moreover, unprecedented fires in Australia, re- carbon fuel. cord ice melt in the Arctic, and increasingly volatile weather Thankfully, the United States already has a framework in patterns have sparked a global dialogue about the growing place to drive future policy. The Renewable Fuel Standard imperative to reduce carbon. has been an important and effective policy reducing green- From RFA’s perspective, the ethanol industry should be help- house gas emissions from fuels for 15 years and has reduced

ing to lead the conversation because we have a great story to CO2-equivalent GHGs by an astounding 600 million metric tell. The U.S. Department of Energy, California Air Resources tons since its implementation. That is the equivalent of re- Board (CARB), Oregon Department of Environmental Quality, moving roughly half of the cars on the road in America for an U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and others already entire year or eliminating the annual emissions from 13 coal- recognize that grain-based ethanol reduces greenhouse gas fired power plants. With ethanol, we don’t have to wait and (GHG) emissions by 35 to 50 percent compared to gasoline. hope for major technological or economic breakthroughs; the Emerging technologies promise to boost that reduction to fuel is available now at a low cost to drive decarbonization of around 70 percent in just the next few years, according to our liquid fuels.

U.S. EPA Determination of California LCFS Credit Percentage by Fuel, Agricultural Land Use vs. 2007 Baseline Q1 2011 - Q2 2019

405

400

395 Ethanol 390 Renewable Diesel 385 Biodiesel 380 375 Electricity Million Acres Million 370 Biomethane 365 Other

360

355

350 Source: RFA using California Air Resources Board data 2007 2010 2011 2012 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 2019

Overall agricultural land use has dropped significantly since EPA established the 2007 baseline with the expansion of the Renewable Fuel Standard.

Source: RFA using U.S. Environmental Protection Agency data

12 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION Ca ii a y ia cp

Ca Ca Biofuels i ia ii ct a a Carbon t ii Cycle i

ii i ct t p ic The use of ethanol in gasoline in 2019 reduced CO2-equivalent greenhouse gas emissions from the transportation sector by 54.1 million metric tons. That’s equivalent to removing 11.5 million cars from the road for an entire year, or eliminating the annual emissions from 13 coal-fired power plants.

Source: RFA analysis using U.S. Dept. of Energy GREET model Carbon Intensity of Starch-based Ethanol

88.5 in California Gasoline

90

85

80 eM 2 75

70 63.7

65

60

Carbon Intensity gCO Carbon Intensity 55

50 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019

Source: RFA using California Air Resources Board data

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 13 The Law that Keeps on Giving

t has been 15 years since President George W. Bush The immediate success of the RFS led to the expansion of signed the Energy Policy Act of 2005 that established a the RFS in 2007, expanding the requirement to 36 billion gal- I7.5 billion-gallon Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS), creat- lons by 2022 and adding a certain carbon metric to measure ing a value-added market for farmers; assuring growth for future fuels. While the volumes envisioned by the 2007 bill biofuels like ethanol, biodiesel, and other advanced fuels; and will not be met, by every other measure the policy remains addressing critical environmental and energy security prior- an unmitigated success. It has lowered carbon emissions ities. The historic legislation was the first time low carbon from motor fuels far greater than anticipated. It has lowered fuels were required anywhere in the world. It sent a powerful consumer gasoline costs by infusing competition into an oth- signal to the market that motivated investors and technology erwise stagnant market. And it helped to dramatically reduce developers alike, and created today’s dynamic and growing U.S. dependence on imported petroleum. biofuels industry. As we Focus Forward, however, the RFS is likely to evolve. Legislation may be contemplated that would strengthen the carbon reducing function of the RFS, building on the success of this ground-breaking program to more closely reflect a low carbon fuel standard. Regulatory changes may also be afoot as the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency will set the volume requirements beginning in 2023. In either case, the RFA will continue to lead, protecting the RFS, and assuring that the environmental, energy, and consumer benefits of the expanded use of biofuels continues for decades to come.

14 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION 175 Source: RFA andU.S. Energy Information Administration *Estimated generations of our country anation thatis stronger, cleaner andmore secure.” climate change, expanding the production of renewable fuelsandgiving future “Today we make amajor step toward reducing our dependence confronting onoil, global —President George W. Bush, 2007 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988

1989 Historic U.S. Fuel Ethanol Production 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996

Source: RFA *As of December for each year specified 1997 1998 1999 1999 2019 2014 2009 2004 2000

Historical Biorefinery Countand Production Capacity 2001 2002 2003 2004

Installed Ethanol 2005 Biorefineries 2006 2007 205 213 191 50 79 2008 2009 2010 2011 Capacity (mgy)

Total Installed 2012 2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK Production

16,964 15,077 13,028 2013 1,799 4,398 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 15,800 Average Capacity

per Biorefinery 2019* (mgy) 36.0 82.8 70.8 68.2 55.7 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 16,000 18,000

Million Gallons

15 Still Waiving Away the Gallons

s it did last year, the impact of the U.S. Environ- In its final rule establishing the 2020 renewable volume mental Protection Agency’s granting of waivers to obligations, EPA stated it will reallocate gallons lost to ex- Asmall refineries from their renewable fuel blending emptions, based on a rolling three-year average of what the obligations has taken its toll on rural America. Under the Department of Energy has recommended, and extend this Trump administration, EPA issued 85 retroactive refinery to the 2019 compliance year. On average, DOE gallons have exemptions for the 2016-2018 compliance years, undercut- represented only about half of what EPA actually waived. ting the statutory renewable fuel volumes by a total of 4.04 As of January 2020, there were 21 waiver applications from billion gallons. small refineries pending before EPA. Given the furor that has For conventional renewable fuels like corn starch-based eth- arisen and the EPA response—which also includes a first-ever anol, Congress specifically established an annual requirement commitment to only grant partial waivers when warranted of 15 billion gallons beginning in 2015. However, due to the and recommended by DOE—we anticipate fewer full massive increase in SREs, EPA has enforced, on average, a exemptions to be granted in 2020, for current and future conventional renewable fuel requirement of just 13.78 billion 2019 applications, and less of a direct impact on domestic gallons annually for 2016-2018. ethanol demand.

Despite this, President Trump and EPA Administrator Andrew Wheeler repeatedly stated their commitment to at least 15 billion gallons. Farmers, renewable fuel producers and their allies throughout rural America spoke up for months on this issue and pulled no punches, with one farmer leader con- fronting President Trump directly on stage at a June event at RFA member plant Southwest Iowa Renewable Energy.

“Mr. President, you delivered on E15, but we have more work to do. The EPA’s oil refinery waivers threaten to undo your good works. I ask that you listen again because the pain that the ethanol and biodiesel industries have endured is holding back a farm economy that has further capacity to produce more clean air and clean liquid fuels for this country.”

— Iowa Farmer and National Corn Growers Association President Kevin Ross

16 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION RFS Conventional Renewable Fuel Blending Requirements: Statutory Levels vs. Actual Levels After EPA Waivers

tatty i it Final EPA RVO Actual Requirement After SREs E10 “Blend Wall”

150 1500 1500 1500 1500 1500 1500

Average Weekly Ethanol (D6) RIN Price 145 1440 1450 140 1405 17 11 140 19 10 10 164 161 15 15 14 120 10 ii a ii

100 125

80 120 201 2014 2015 2016 2017 201 60 EPA used a “general waiver” to set final RVOs below statutory levels in 2014-2016. Cents/RIN The courts struck down and vacated EPA’s 2014-2016 final RVOs and 40 remanded them back to EPA to address. Source: RFA using U.S. Environmental Protection Agency data 20 0 Small Refinery Exemptions Jan- Jul- Jan- Jul- Jan- Jul- Jan- Jul- Jan- Jul- Jan- Jul- Jan- Jul- Jan- Jul- at i Source: OPIS 40 5 The price of ethanol (D6) renewable identification numbers (RINs) 5 1 started 2019 at a relatively low level, due to swelling RIN inventories 0 that resulted from small refinery exemptions (SREs) granted roughly 25 a year earlier. However, prices plunged further following the August 19 20 announcement that 31 SREs had been granted for the 2018 compliance year and again after the release of the supplemental 15 proposal for the 2020 RFS renewable volume obligations, in which 10 7 7 5 6 6 the EPA assumed that future SREs would conform to Department of 5 Energy recommendations rather than historical practices. 1 1 0 201 2014 2015 2016 2017 201

Source: RFA using U.S. Environmental Protection Agency data

“As we travel through our districts in Iowa, SRE Applications Waived vs. DOE Recommendations we hear first-hand from farmers, renewable fuel producers, and rural communities about 120 the harm caused by the explosion of small 140 refinery exemption applications that EPA 790 1020 has approved in recent years. … Without 40 290 a binding commitment that EPA will account 440 290 for exemptions granted by EPA, this rule fails 2015 2016 2017 201 to keep the RFS whole.” c cta — Iowa Reps. Dave Loebsack, Cindy Axne and Abby Finkenauer Source: RFA using U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and U.S. Department of Energy data

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 17 Focusing Beyond E10

fter years of working to reverse a 2012 decision by E85 and other flex fuels encountered challenges in 2019, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to even as the number of E85 blender pumps increased and Alimit E15 to winter fuels, the agency in June finally market economics provided a significant incentive for con- promulgated a rule allowing the year-round use of the less sumers. E85 sales were estimated at 425 million gallons but expensive, higher octane ethanol fuel blend. As a result, E15 would have been higher if not for decreased production of sales grew significantly, to about 450 million gallons. That flex fuel vehicles and historically low RIN prices. growth was fueled by a better than 10% increase in retail The Trump administration has promised a package of incen- stations offering E15 and more auto manufacturers providing tives to encourage increased sales of E15 and flex fuels in warranty coverage for the higher ethanol blend. Today E15 2020. Those include streamlining labeling and removing other stations number near 2,000, and better than 95% of the vehi- barriers to E15 and financial assistance for infrastructure cles sold in the U.S. are legally approved for E15. As a result, projects facilitating higher ethanol blends. Assuming those in 2019 E15 sales surpassed E85 sales for the first time. measures are taken, the RFA remains highly optimistic the market will continue to move beyond E10 in 2020.

Expansion of U.S. Retail Stations 2019 National Average Retail Prices for E10 & E85 Offering E15 and E85

,000 .00 ,000 2.0 2.60 ,000 2.0 2,000 2.20 Price per Gallon Price

No. of Stations of No. 2.00 1,000 1.0 0 1.60 an eb ar Apr ay un ul Aug ep ct ov ec

2010 2011 2012 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 2019 E10 E85 Source: RFA *Estimated Source: RFA based on data from E85prices.com

Minnesota Average E15 Sales

Avg. Avg. alue alue 00 cents 1 cents

In the seven years since E15 700 was formally approved for use 600 by EPA, American drivers have 00 00 logged over 10 billion miles 00

on the fuel without a single 200 Gallons/Station/Day reported case of “engine 100 damage,” misfueling, or 0 ul19 ul1 ul17 ul16 an19 an1 an17 an16 un19 un1 un17 un16 Apr19 Apr1 Apr17 Apr16 eb19 eb1 eb17 eb16 ep19 ep1 ep17 ct19 ep16 ct1 ct17 ct16 Aug19 Aug1 Aug17 Aug16 ec1 ec17 ec16 ar19 ar1 ar17 ar16 ov1 ov17 ov16 ay19 ay1 ay17 inferior performance. ay16

Source: RFA based on Minnesota Dept. of Commerce data

18 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION “Year-round E15 sales is a win for consumers and our economy (more options and lower costs). It’s a win for the environment (cleaner fuel). It’s a win for our nation’s energy security (reduces dependence on foreign countries). And it’s a huge win for our nation’s agriculture industry (stronger commodity market).”

—U.S. Senator John Thune, South Dakota

The following model year 2020 vehicles are available as Flex Fuel Vehicles (FFVs):

CAN YOU Chevrolet Express (6.0L) Ford F-250/F-350 Super Duty (6.2L) Available for Fleet Purchase Only: Chevrolet Impala (3.6L)* Ford Transit (3.5L) Chevrolet Suburban (5.3L) Chevrolet Silverado (5.3L) Ford Transit Connect (2.0L) Chevrolet Tahoe (5.3L) Ford Explorer (3.3L) GMC Savana (6.0L) Ford Police Interceptor (3.3L) ? Ford F-150 (3.3L, 5.0L) GMC Sierra (5.3L) GMC Yukon (5.3L) GMC Yukon XL (5.3L)

E15 APPROVAL STATUS FOR CONVENTIONAL LIGHT-DUTY VEHICLES

MODEL YEAR : 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 U.S. Market Share BMW Group* BMW 1.8% Mini 0.2% Daimler Group (Mercedes-Benz) 2.0% FCA (Chrysler, Dodge, Fiat, Jeep, RAM) 13.1% Ford Motor Co. (Ford, Lincoln) 14.3% General Motors (Buick, Cadillac, Chevrolet, GMC) 17.0% Honda Motor Co. (Honda, Acura) 9.6% Hyundai Motor Co. (Hyundai, Kia) 7.7% Mazda 1.7% Mitsubishi Motors Corp. 0.8% Nissan Motor Co. Infiniti 0.7% Nissan† 7.6% Subaru‡ 4.2% Tata Motors (Jaguar, Land Rover) 0.7% Toyota Motor Corp. Lexus 1.7% Toyota 12.5% Volkswagen Group Audi 1.3% Porsche 0.4% Volkswagen 2.2% Volvo Car Group 0.6% All Others 0.2%

E15 Approved by Automaker in ALL Models * Approves the use of up to 25% ethanol blends † Approves the use of E15 for all models except Armada & Frontier E15 Approved by Automaker in SOME Models ‡ Approves the use of E15 for all models except BRZ, Forester & WRX E15 Approved by EPA only; NOT Approved by Automaker

Sources: Approval Status: Auto Manufacturer Owner’s Manuals; U.S. Market Share: GCBC (Jan.-Sept. 2019)

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 19 Fueling Value

thanol production and use has a long history of helping farmers and others by adding value to corn at the same Etime as it saves drivers at the gas pump. Henry Ford and Alexander Graham Bell were among the first to recognize that the plentiful sugars found in plants could be easily and inexpensively converted into clean-burning, renewable fuel. Bell himself referred to ethanol as a “clean, beautiful, and U.S. Ethanol Production efficient fuel” more than a century ago. by Technology Type Today’s industry uses state-of-the-art technologies to pro- duce ethanol and valuable bio-products from the starches t i and sugars found in grains, beverage and food waste, and 91 cellulosic biomass, and American farmers themselves are of- ten actively involved in many of these ethanol plants through ownership or leadership positions.

More than 90 percent of U.S. fuel ethanol is produced using the dry mill process, with the remaining amount coming from y i 909 wet mills. The main difference between the two processes is in the initial treatment of the grain.

In DRY MILLING, the entire grain kernel is first ground into “meal,” then slurried with water to form a “mash.” Enzymes Source: RFA based on U.S. Dept. of Agriculture data are added to the mash to convert starch to sugar. The mash is cooked, then cooled and transferred to fermenters. Yeast U.S. Ethanol Production is added and the conversion of sugar to alcohol begins. After by Feedstock Type fermentation, the resulting “beer” is separated from the re- maining “stillage.” The ethanol is then distilled and dehydrat- ed, then blended with about 2% denaturant (such as gasoline) C to render it undrinkable. It is then ready for shipment. The Cic ia at 4 stillage is sent through a centrifuge that separates the solids from the solubles. These co-products eventually become C 21 distillers grains, as well as corn distillers oil. C tac 940 Cic In WET MILLING, the grain is first separated into its basic ia 05

components through soaking. After steeping, the slurry is at a processed through grinders to separate the corn germ. The ctac 01 remaining fiber, gluten and starch components are further segregated. The gluten component (protein) is filtered and dried to produce animal feed. The remaining starch can Source: RFA then be fermented into ethanol, using a process like the dry mill process.

20 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION Dry Mill Ethanol Process

Grain Receiving and Storage Milling Cooking Liquefaction Fermentation

Dried Distillers Grains Dryer Bottling, Dry Ice and Distillers Other Uses Grains to Livestock and Poultry Syrup Tank Evaporator Liquids

Distillers Centrifuge Grains to Corn Distillers Oil Market Distillation Feed

Biodiesel

Wet Distillers Grains Solids Denaturant

Ethanol to Market Ethanol-Blended Ethanol Storage Molecular Sieve Gasoline to Consumer

On average, processed by a • 2.92 gallons of denatured fuel ethanol 1 bushel dry mill ethanol • 15.86 pounds of distillers grains animal feed (10% moisture) of corn biorefinery • 0.80 pounds of corn distillers oil (56 pounds) produces: • 16.5 pounds of biogenic carbon dioxide

Source: RFA

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 21 Innovating for the Future

nnovation continues to be the hallmark of U.S. ethanol The U.S. ethanol industry has come a long way since 1980 producers. Over the past year, ethanol production facilities and is looking forward to continuing to grow the industry. Ihelped to commercialize a variety of new technologies, Utilizing specialty enzymes, producers can be next-gener- from co-product diversification to engineered yeast. These ation facilities fermenting fiber into cellulosic ethanol. And advances further increase ethanol yields and reduce the en- yeast has been modified to produce less glycerol and pro- ergy intensity of the process, leading to reduced greenhouse duce their own glucoamylase during fermentation. Beyond gas emissions. production, new uses for ethanol are also on the horizon. New technology allows ethanol to be used as feedstock for One area of particular focus has been co-product diversifi- aviation fuel, and the industry is researching using ethanol as cation—including dry grind separation, dry fractionation and a diesel substitute and to generate electricity. fiber separation. These technologies result in higher valued and tailored feed products with enhanced feeding aspects for ruminants, swine and poultry. Aquaculture is also an area of growth for our co-products.

Driven in part by state low carbon fuel standards, plant efficiencies also continue to improve. New technologies that reduce carbon, like advanced motors, anaerobic digesters, co-generation of energy and carbon sequestration, are being adopted by facilities around the country. Enzyme manufac- turers also continue to innovate, offering products with bet- ter properties that help producers control costs and reduce or even eliminate use of other chemicals.

Total D3 RINs Generated

0,000

00,000

20,000

200,000

10,000

100,000

Thousand s Thousand 0,000

0 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 2019

eneable ompressed atural Gas Renewable Liquefied Natural Gas ellulosic eneable Gasoline lendstoc ellulosic thanol

Source: RFA based on U.S. Environmental Protection Agency data *Jan.-Nov.

22 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION Two of our nation’s newest ethanol plants are models of innovation. Since its opening in spring 2019, Ringneck Energy’s facility in Onida, South Dakota, quickly reached its nameplate capacity of 80 million gallons. Among its priorities are to improve access to the West Coast ethanol market with data collection to develop its carbon intensity score, increasing the value of its ethanol for blenders serving California and Oregon.

Not pictured: The Andersons and ICM, Inc. partnered together to create ELEMENT, LLC, a joint venture that in August 2019 completed a 70-million-gallon-per-year bio-refinery in Colwich, Kansas. The combination of ICM’s next-generation technologies and The Andersons’ merchandising, risk management and logistics expertise has Photos: Dakota Film Co. the potential to produce high-efficiency, low-carbon-intensity ethanol.

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 23 A Secure Energy Source

nergy security remains an enduring concern, a remind- On the other hand, homegrown ethanol is a secure source of er of which was provided by the September 2019 transportation fuel that has helped the nation limit its oil im- Eattacks on two key Saudi Arabian oil installations. ports and thus its susceptibility to developments in the world While the expansion of U.S. petroleum production in recent market. According to a recent study by energy economist Dr. years has been widely touted, we still import more than 200 Philip K. Verleger, Jr. that looked at oil market shocks starting million barrels of oil every month, highlighting the continuing with the 1973 Arab Oil Embargo, even “a modest amount of linkage between the world oil market and the U.S. market. renewable fuels can significantly moderate the price impact of market disruptions.” In 2019, the U.S. still sent an estimated $35 billion to OPEC countries for oil—$275 per American household— In 2019, U.S. dependence on imported crude oil and including $12 billion to Saudi Arabia alone. In fact, petroleum products fell to just 4 percent on a net basis (i.e., California, the largest gasoline-consuming state, has been imports minus exports), due to the increase in domestic importing increasing quantities of crude oil, more than production of both crude oil and biofuels. Yet, without the in- two-thirds of which come from OPEC. clusion of ethanol in the domestic fuel supply, the U.S. would have been dependent on imports for 10 percent of its needs.

The use of ethanol specifically reduced the need for crude oil imports by 514 million barrels. More broadly, the 15.8 billion gallons of ethanol produced for the domestic and export markets displaced 559 million barrels of crude oil.

“America remains far from energy independent. While net exports show a decreasing reliance on imports, the country continues to buy oil from other nations in part to meet the needs of its refiners. The US refining industry is generally configured to process heavier crude, for example, from Saudi Arabia, than that produced in its domestic shale fields.”

—Financial Times editorial, January 2020

24 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION Historic Oil Import Displacement by Ethanol

700 559

600 6 69 2 9 07 00 71 6 71

00 7 0 00 21 200

100

Transferring American isplaced il of arrels illion 2007 200 2009 2010 2011 2012 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 2019 Wealth to OPEC Source: RFA based on U.S. Dept. of Energy data *Estimated

U.S. Crude Oil Imports Even though U.S. oil production has 300,000 275,000 increased in recent years, our nation’s 250,000 economy still transfers tens of billions 225,000 200,000 of dollars every year to the OPEC cartel. 175,000 150,000 In 2019 alone, the U.S. sent some 125,000 100,000

$35 billion—or $275 per American Barrels Thousand 75,000 household—to OPEC nations to pay 50,000 for crude oil imports. 25,000 0 U.S. Spending an-2013 an-2014 an-2015 an-2016 an-2017 an-2018 an-2019 Sep-2013 Sep-2014 Sep-2015 Sep-2016 Sep-2017 Sep-2018 Sep-2019 on Crude May-2013 May-2014 May-2015 May-2016 May-2017 May-2018 May-2019

Oil Imports While U.S. crude oil production has increased, our nation still imports OPEC Nation (Billion $) over 200 million barrels per month on a gross basis.

Source: U.S. Dept. of Energy Saudi Arabia $12.3

Iraq $7.8 U.S. Petroleum Net Import Dependence with and without Ethanol

Nigeria $4.7 70% 61% Ecuador $4.4 60% 54% 58% Venezuela $1.9 50% 53% 47% 40% Libya $1.4 40% 30% 27%

Kuwait $1.1 20% 20% 10% Other OPEC $1.8 10% 4% 0% TOTAL $35.3 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019* Source: RFA based on U.S. Dept. of Energy data Actual Import Dependence Import Dependence ithout Ethanol

On a net basis (i.e., after accounting for U.S. exports), the United States relied on imports to meet 4% of its petroleum demand in 2019. Without the contribution of 15.8 billion gallons of ethanol, U.S. import dependence Source: RFA based on U.S. Dept. of Energy data *Estimated would have been equivalent to 10% of petroleum demand.

Source: RFA based on U.S. Dept. of Energy data *Estimated

2020 2ETHANOL019 ETHANOL INDUSTRY INDUSTRY OUTLOOK OUTLOOK 25 25 Advancing Sustainability and Efficiency

enewable fuels have been under attack for years with assertions from critics that never rang true, or that have Rbeen addressed over time as the ethanol industry has grown in sustainability and efficiency. Here’s a review of some key points that prove many of these accusations are wrong. 2. 1. Cropland Has Not Expanded Because Ethanol Does Not Raise Food Prices of Ethanol Production One of the longest running attacks on ethanol is also one of the most incorrect. As a food ingredient, corn Ethanol critics often assume that growing more corn is extremely inexpensive, even when it was above involves planting more cropland. In reality, there has $4 per bushel. And the total percentage of the “farm been little overall corn acreage increase with the advent share” of every dollar spent on food has remained at of ethanol because farmers are growing so much more less than 15 cents. In addition, as the ethanol indus- corn per acre. Even more, In the decade since the try has grown over the years, overall food inflation Renewable Fuel Standard was updated in 2007, total has decreased. U.S. cropland actually decreased by 7%.

U.S. Food Price Inflation U.S. Corn Acreage and Ethanol Production and Average Yield

Acres (Left) Yield (Right)

earverear Ethanol Inflation Inflation Rate Production Rate Trend (Left Axis) (Right Axis) 175 9.0 1,000 .0 16,000 7.0 1,000 6.0 12,000 .0 10,000 .0 BushelsAcre ,000 .0 Million Million Acres Planted 6,000

2.0 Gallons illion 1.0 ,000

Year-on-Year Food Inflation Food Year-on-Year 0.0 2,000 1.0 0 190 192 19 196 19 1990 1992 199 1996 199 2000 2002 200 2006 200 2010 2012 201 2016 201

Source: RFA and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; 2019 data estimated Source: RFA using U.S. Dept. of Agriculture data

26 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION 4. 3. Ethanol is Energy Positive Amazon Deforestation Isn’t Tied to U.S. Ethanol The average energy balance of corn ethanol is in the range

Related to No. 2, some try to blame the destruction of of producing 2.6 to 2.8 units of energy for every unit of the Amazon rainforest on biofuels production in the energy used, with the top quartile of dry mill biorefineries United States, under the guise of “indirect land use averaging 3.2 to 3.4 and some plants very likely achieving change.” Again, the data tell a different story. There is no 4.0. As far back as 2007, Professor Bruce Dale of Michigan statistical correlation between Amazon deforestation State University attacked the idea of “net energy,” pointing and U.S. ethanol production. As with food inflation, the out further that “Gasoline’s net energy is actually worse opposite appears to be true. than that of ethanol.” Attacks on ethanol need to be bal- anced with research into the ramifications of its removal from the fuel supply. Amazon Deforestation Rates vs. U.S. Ethanol Production

Deforestation in U.S. Ethanol Amazon (Sq. Miles) Production (Million Gal.) Dry Mill Corn Ethanol Average 1,000 Energy Balance Ratio Estimates, 2005-2016 16,000 . . 1,000 . . . . 12,000

10,000 . . . . ,000 . . . . . . 6,000 . ,000 Square Miles (Deforestation) (Deforestation) Miles Square 2,000 . Million Gallons (Ethanol Production) (Ethanol Gallons Million 0 . Kim & Dale Hill Farrell et al. EA Liska et al. USDA USDA RFA

200 200 2006 2007 200 2009 2010 2011 2012 201 201 201 2016 2017 201 (Shapouri (Gallagher (based on et al.) et al.) USDA Mueller & Kwik Source: RFA using Brazil National Institute for Space Research & U.S. Source: RFA Christianson & Assoc.) Energy Information Administration data

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 27 Advocacy and Industry Support

he RFA has been the voice of the U.S. ethanol industry to key decisionmakers. Through its various Committees, RFA for almost 40 years. Effective advocacy in Washington member companies direct the association’s technical, safety, Ttoday requires a strong technical foundation, effec- research, marketing and regulatory priorities. And with tive messaging across numerous platforms, and passionate regular interaction at RFA Board meetings and the National grassroots. With a combined 175 years of ethanol industry Ethanol Conference, RFA Members stay abreast of the policy, experience, the RFA staff brings unmatched industry knowl- marketing, and technology developments that affect their edge and unrivaled dedication to every forum where biofuels bottom line. are being discussed. Over the past year, the RFA testified If past is prologue, the coming months and years will bring before Congress, participated in regulatory hearings, argued dramatic change to ethanol policy and marketing. Count on in federal and district courts, and spoke at countless national the RFA and its membership to continue to lead the conver- and international events. sation, to develop the technical underpinnings, and to shape The RFA is far more than its staff, of course. As a produc- the message that will assure future growth. er-led organization where every company has a voice and a vote on policy, it is the membership that has driven our industry’s success. By hosting policy makers at their facili- ties and participating in Washington Fly-ins, RFA member companies effectively deliver the ethanol industry’s message

28 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION Photo: MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty Images RFA Committees

The RFA Technical Committee focuses on fuel specifications and standards development by ASTM International, National Conference of Weights and Measures, regulatory bodies, and other organizations. Committee members monitor technical issues impacting day-to-day plant operations, such as storage and handling, transportation, and fuel quality, as well as state and regional regulations and international blending practices.

Committee Chair: Cathy Woodliff, The Andersons, Inc.

The RFA Co-Products Committee focuses on issues relevant to co-products from ethanol production, including distillers grains, corn distillers oil, corn gluten, carbon dioxide and other products. Committee members address operational and reg- ulatory issues concerning production, storage and handling, transportation, international trade, animal nutrition, and animal feed safety.

Committee Chair: Matt Fitzthum, CHS, Inc.

The RFA Environmental, Health and Safety Committee examines and educates industry stakeholders on the im- plementation of environmental regulations for production, storage and handling, and transportation of ethanol. The committee tackles complex regulatory issues and provides guidance to members. This committee also leads the industry in advocating safe practices in ethanol production, storage and handling, transportation, and use. Committee members monitor and share information on hazardous materials, safety standards, and federal and state safety regulations. The Com- mittee also supports continuing education for every link of the ethanol supply chain.

Committee Chair: Steve Schleicher, Pinnacle Engineering, Inc.

The Renewable Fuels PAC builds a stronger voice for Amer- ican-made renewable fuels on Capitol Hill. Organized and operated by RFA members and staff, this Political Action Committee promotes consistent and forward-looking public policy essential to the growth and evolution of the industry by focusing on federal election activity.

Committee Chair: Randy Doyal, Al-Corn Clean Fuel LLCLLC

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 29 Creatively Reaching Unique Audiences

eaching audiences that often hear contrary ethanol mes- The RFA E85 Chopper remains a key element in several pro- saging is important to the Renewable Fuels Association, motions since its creation in 2018, and Builder Paul Teutul, Jr. Rand we do this in several powerful and creative ways, and was featured at the 2019 National Ethanol Conference. It especially when it comes to boating and motorcycle enthu- was also featured at numerous consumer and member events siasts who often are wary about ethanol blends. RFA’s goal is throughout the year and found its way back to the annual to change consumer perceptions before they reach the fuel Sturgis Motorcycle Rally. RFA has maintained a presence there dispenser and note that it is more than just the gallons that run for more than a decade. through those engines, they all own other vehicles and engines At the 2019 Sturgis event, RFA sponsored the 12th annual at home. Legends Ride with Twisted Sister’s Dee Snider as the ride For the past few years, for example, RFA and the National captain. RFA also hosted Free Fuel Happy Hours at the rally, Corn Growers Association have served as co-title sponsors providing a free tank of 93 octane E10 for nearly 1,000 mo- for the Crappie Masters Tournament Trail, a group of tourna- torcycles along with a ceremonial t-shirt. RFA enjoyed a clear ments spread across the country throughout the year, as a way presence throughout the 600+ acre campground with daily to reach professional and recreational boaters. In June 2019, promotions, banners, videos on the jumbotrons, and address- Crappie Masters President Mike Vallentine and Crappie Mas- ing the concert crowd each night. ters TV host Brian Sowers were featured in a national podcast and showcased the role ethanol plays in the tournament trail and how they educate participants on using E10 on the water and higher blends of ethanol on the road. At every tournament, each weekend, the winners have used E10 in their boats to bring home the trophy. RFA was featured at the first tourna- ment of the year, along with the National Championship, which was host to over 150 fishing teams.

In 2019, RFA partnered with Kenny Hauk to build a powerful E85 Jeep Wrangler with more than 1,100 horses under the hood and featured on television via Amazon Prime 2019 Crappie Masters National Champions Robert Carlile and Craig Nichols found ethanol a clear and powerful winner for their tournament boat for that tournament and throughout the year.

30 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION Strong Endorsements for RFA and Ethanol

“When we are filling up our boat before coming to the tour- naments, we never think twice about filling up with E10. We will continue to put ethanol in our boat.” Finally, RFA kicked off a bold new project with legendary Jeep designer Kenny Hauk of Hauk Designs to bring ethanol - 2019 Crappie Masters National Champion Robert Carlile back to global television, who built a custom Flex Fuel E85 “We are proud to use E10 in our boat and be a part of the Jeep Wrangler sporting more than 1,100 horsepower on group of winning teams who use ethanol. Our engine runs E85. This build was featured at the 2019 SEMA show in great when using ethanol-blended fuel. We see the benefits Las Vegas and on the second season of “Hauk Machines,” of running ethanol in our engine first-hand.” featured on Amazon Prime Video. The Jeep will be taken on - 2019 Crappie Masters National Champion Craig Nichols tour by Hauk Designs throughout 2020 to consumer events across the country.

From their fishing boats to motorcycles to off-road vehicles, “I usually run ethanol in my bike. It runs better on ethanol and American consumers spend a lot of time and money on their we get much better mileage. Yesterday, we filled up here in recreational vehicles. When they see the value of putting the morning and went 130 miles; she still had a quarter tank. ethanol into these prized possessions, they can be expect- The bikes run better on it.” ed to seek it out for their everyday vehicles as well—and to - Buddy Merk, Biker at Sturgis promote its value to others. RFA is making a clear difference when it comes to ethanol and these high-profile consumers. “Our goal was to build the most powerful JL Wrangler ever built that not only functions on road and off, but looks good while doing it. We have found E85 to be an outstanding fuel option that gives us the power and performance we have been looking for in an economical package and a fuel that can be bought at the local fuel station.”

- Legendary Jeep Designer Kenny Hauk

Clockwise, from top:

Onstage at Sturgis, RFA enjoyed an audience of thousands and the opportunity to share important messages daily.

RFA’s 2018 E85 Chopper remains a show-stopper wherever it’s parked.

At the 2019 Sturgis Motorcycle Rally in South Dakota, RFA’s Free Fuel Happy Hours led not just to happy bikers, but conversations about ethanol’s suitability for their treasured motorcycles.

2020 ETHANOL INDUSTRY OUTLOOK 31 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION

RFA MISSION RFA STAFF

Drive expanded demand for St. Louis, MO American-made renewable fuels Geoff Cooper President & CEO and bio-products worldwide. Ken Colombini Communications Director Kelly Davis Vice President of Regulatory Affairs Ann Lewis Senior Analyst RFA EXPERTISE Jackie Pohlman Manager of Member Relations Kelsey Quargnenti Digital Marketing Coordinator Regulation & Public Policy Scott Richman Chief Economist Research & Economic Analysis Other Midwest Staff Ethanol/Co-product Production & Use Cassie Mullen Director of Market Development Missy Ruff Director of Safety & Technical Programs EHS Management Robert White Vice President of Industry Relations Safety & Emergency Preparedness Air Quality & Health Effects Washington, DC Global Market Development Jessica Bennett Vice President, Government & External Affairs Marketing & Promotion Tony Dennis Office Manager Bob Dinneen Senior Strategic Advisor Public Relations Mary Giglio Director of Special Projects & Events Connor Hamburg Director of Government Affairs Edward S. Hubbard, Jr. General Counsel

Find Bios & Contact Info at EthanolRFA.org/staff

RFF MISSION RFF BOARD OF DIRECTORS

Meet the research and education Chairman needs of the U.S. fuel ethanol Dana Lewis, Redfield Energy LLC industry. Vice Chairman Chris Wilson, Mid-Missouri Energy Inc.

RFF FOCUS Treasurer Collaboration with academia, industry, and Mike Jerke, Southwest Iowa Renewable Energy LLC public policymakers on new uses, feedstocks, and technologies to promote a growing and sustainable renewable fuels industry.

32 RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION RFA Associate Members

Advanced Fuel Dynamics Fluid Quip Technologies Kentucky Corn Growers Association Novozymes advancedfueldynamics.com fluidquiptechnologies.com kycorn.org novozymes.com/en/advance-your- business/bioenergy AgMotion Inc. Fremont Industries LLC Lallemand Biofuels & Distilled Spirits agmotion.com fremontind.com lallemandbds.com Ohio Corn Marketing Program ohiocornandwheat.org Applied Material Solutions Inc. The Greenbrier Companies Inc. Lesaffre Advanced Fermentations—Leaf appliedmaterialsolutions.com gbrx.com/home/ lesaffreadvancedfermentations.com Phibro Ethanol Performance Group ethanolperformancegroup.com BASF Enzymes LLC GROWMARK Inc. Merjent Inc. basf.com growmark.com merjent.com Pinnacle Engineering Inc. pineng.com BetaTec Hop Products Inc. Hawkeye Gold LLC, a subsidiary Minnesota Bio-Fuels Association betatec.com of J.D. Heiskell & Co. mnbiofuels.org Protec Fuel Management LLC heiskell.com protecfuel.com Buckman USA Minnesota Corn Growers Association buckman.com ICM Inc. mncorn.org The ProExporter Network icminc.com prxgeo.com Christianson PLLP Minnesota Corn Research & Promotion christiansoncpa.com Illinois Corn Marketing Board Council Renewable Fuels Nebraska ilcorn.org mncorn.org renewablefuelsne.com CoBank cobank.com Indiana Corn Marketing Council Missouri Corn Growers Association Renew Kansas incorn.org/icmc mocorn.org renewkansas.com Compeer Financial compeer.com Innospec Fuel Specialties LLC Missouri Corn Merchandising Council RPMG LLC innospecinc.com mocorn.org rpmgllc.com CTE Global Inc. cte-global.com INTL FCStone Inc. MoistTech Corp. RSM US LLP intlfcstone.com moisttech.com rsmus.com D3MAX LLC d3maxllc.com Iowa Corn Growers Association Mole•Master Services Corp. SUEZ Water Technologies iowacorn.org molemaster.com suezwatertechnologies.com DuPont Nutrition & Biosciences xcelis.com Iowa Renewable Fuels Association Murex LLC Syngenta US iowarfa.org murexltd.com syngenta-us.com DSM dsm.com Kansas Corn Commission NALCO Water TrinityRail kscorn.com/kcc ecolab.com/nalco-water trinityrail.com Eco-Energy Inc. eco-energy.com Kansas Corn Growers Association National Corn Growers Association USD Group LLC kscorn.com/kcga ncga.com usdg.com ERI Solutions LLC erisolutions.com KATZEN International Inc. Nebraska Corn Board Whitefox Technologies Ltd. katzen.com nebraskacorn.gov whitefox.com Fagen Inc. fageninc.com K•Coe Isom Nebraska Corn Growers Association Wisconsin BioFuels Association kcoe.com nebraskacorn.org wibiofuels.org Farm Credit Services of America fcsamerica.com Kentucky Corn Promotion Council Nebraska Ethanol Board kycorn.org/ky-corn-promotion-council ethanol.nebraska.gov

RFA Supporting Members

Agricultural Retailers Association Iowa Central Fuel Testing Laboratory Mississippi State University Dept. Steele-Waseca Cooperative Electric aradc.org iowafuellab.com of Forestry swce.coop cfr.msstate.edu/forestry Bemidji (MN) State University Jamestown/Stutsman County Texas Renewable Energy Industries bemidjistate.edu Development Corp. Morton College Alliance growingjamestown.com/jsdc morton.edu treia.org Bismarck State College bismarckstate.edu Kentucky Energy & Environment National Corn-to-Ethanol Research United Association Cabinet—Office of Energy Policy Center ua.org Colorado Corn Growers Association energy.ky.gov ethanolresearch.com coloradocorn.com/ccga United Sorghum Checkoff Program Maryland Grain Producers National Sorghum Producers sorghumcheckoff.com Colorado Farm Bureau Utilization Board sorghumgrowers.com coloradofarmbureau.com Wisconsin Pipe Trades marylandgrain.org North Dakota Corn Council wipipetrades.org Corn Marketing Program of Michigan Michigan State University Dept. ndcorn.org/corncouncil micorn.org/cmpm of Agricultural, Food & Resource South Dakota Corn Growers Association Distillers Grains Technology Council Economics sdcorn.org distillersgrains.org canr.msu.edu/afre South Dakota Corn Utilization Council Great Falls (MT) Development Minnesota Dept. of Agriculture sdcorn.org Authority Inc. mda.state.mn.us gfdevelopment.org

2020 U.S. ETHANOL PRODUCTION CAPACITY BY PLANT

Under Production Operating Construction/ Company Location State Feedstock Capacity Production (mgy) Expansion (mgy) Capacity (mgy) Absolute Energy LLC St. Ansgar IA Corn 125 125 - Ace Ethanol LLC Stanley WI Corn/Cellulosic Biomass 54 54 - Adkins Energy LLC Lena IL Corn 60 60 -

Aemetis Inc. Keyes CA Corn/Sorghum 60 60 - Al-Corn Clean Fuel LLC Claremont MN Corn 125 125 - Alliance Bio-Products Inc. Vero Beach FL Cellulosic Biomass 8 - - Archer Daniels Midland Co. Clinton IA Corn 238 238 - Archer Daniels Midland Co. Decatur IL Corn 300 300 - Archer Daniels Midland Co. Marshall MN Corn 40 40 - Archer Daniels Midland Co. Peoria IL Corn 185 85 - Archer Daniels Midland Co. Plant 1 Cedar Rapids IA Corn 300 300 - Archer Daniels Midland Co. Plant 2 Cedar Rapids IA Corn 240 240 - Archer Daniels Midland Co. Plant 1 Columbus NE Corn 100 100 - Archer Daniels Midland Co. Plant 2 Columbus NE Corn 313 313 - Arkalon Energy LLC Liberal KS Corn 110 110 - Attis Biofuels, Inc. Fulton NY Corn 100 100 -

Badger State Ethanol LLC Monroe WI Corn 90 90 - Big River Resources Boyceville LLC Boyceville WI Corn 57 57 - Big River Resources Galva LLC Galva IL Corn 110 110 - Big River Resources West Burlington LLC West Burlington IA Corn 105 105 - Big River United Energy LLC Dyersville IA Corn 110 110 - Blue Flint Ethanol LLC Underwood ND Corn 70 70 - Bonanza BioEnergy LLC Garden City KS Corn/Sorghum 55 55 - Bridgeport Ethanol LLC Bridgeport NE Corn 50 50 - Bushmills Ethanol Inc. Atwater MN Corn 90 90 - Butamax Advanced Biofuels LLC Scandia KS Corn 10 10 - Calgren Renewable Fuels LLC Pixley CA Corn 55 55 - Carbon Green BioEnergy LLC Woodbury MI Corn 40 40 - Cardinal Ethanol LLC Union City IN Corn 100 100 - Cargill Inc. Blair NE Corn 210 210 - Cargill Inc. Eddyville IA Corn 35 35 - Cargill Inc. Ft. Dodge IA Corn 115 115 - Center Ethanol Company LLC Sauget IL Corn 54 - - Central Indiana Ethanol LLC (CIE) Marion IN Corn 55 55 - Chief Ethanol Fuels Inc. Hastings NE Corn 70 70 - Chief Ethanol Fuels Inc. Lexington NE Corn 50 50 - Chippewa Valley Ethanol Co. Benson MN Corn 50 50 - CHS Inc. Annawan IL Corn 125 125 - CHS Inc. Rochelle IL Corn 133 133 - Commonwealth Agri-Energy LLC Hopkinsville KY Corn 45 45 - Corn LP Goldfield IA Corn 60 60 - Corn Plus Winnebago MN Corn 42 - - Dakota Ethanol LLC Wentworth SD Corn 52 52 - Dakota Spirit AgEnergy LLC Spiritwood ND Corn 65 65 - DENCO II LLC Morris MN Corn 24 24 - Diamond Ethanol LLC (Conestoga Energy Partners LLC) Levelland TX Corn 40 - - Didion Ethanol LLC Cambria WI Corn 50 50 - E Energy Adams LLC Adams NE Corn 80 80 - East Kansas Agri-Energy LLC Garnett KS Corn 42 42 - ELEMENT LLC Colwich KS Corn/Sorghum/Cellulosic Biomass - - 70 Elite Octane LLC Atlantic IA Corn 120 120 - ESE Alcohol Inc. Leoti KS Waste Seed Corn 2 2 - Flint Hills Resources LLC Arthur IA Corn 120 120 - Under Production Operating Construction/ Company Location State Feedstock Capacity Production (mgy) Expansion (mgy) Capacity (mgy) Flint Hills Resources LLC Camilla GA Corn 120 120 - Flint Hills Resources LLC Fairbank IA Corn 120 120 - Flint Hills Resources LLC Fairmont NE Corn 120 120 - Flint Hills Resources LLC Iowa Falls IA Corn/Cellulosic Biomass 120 120 - Flint Hills Resources LLC Menlo IA Corn 120 120 -

Flint Hills Resources LLC Shell Rock IA Corn/Cellulosic Biomass 120 120 - Fox River Valley Ethanol LLC Oshkosh WI Corn 65 65 - Front Range Energy LLC Windsor CO Corn 40 40 - Gevo Inc. Luverne MN Corn 20 20 - Glacial Lakes Energy LLC Aberdeen SD Corn 53 53 - Glacial Lakes Energy LLC Huron SD Corn 32 32 - Glacial Lakes Energy LLC Mina SD Corn 100 100 - Glacial Lakes Energy LLC Watertown SD Corn 120 120 - Golden Grain Energy LLC Mason City IA Corn 145 145 - Golden Triangle Energy LLC Craig MO Corn 20 5 - Grain Processing Corp. Muscatine IA Corn 20 20 - Grain Processing Corp. Washington IN Corn 20 20 - Granite Falls Energy LLC Granite Falls MN Corn 65 65 - Green Plains Inc. Atkinson NE Corn 55 55 - Green Plains Inc. Central City NE Corn 116 116 - Green Plains Inc. Fairmont MN Corn 119 119 - Green Plains Inc. Fergus Falls MN Corn 55 55 - Green Plains Inc. Hereford TX Corn 105 105 - Green Plains Inc. Madison IL Corn 90 90 - Green Plains Inc. Mount Vernon IN Corn 90 90 - Green Plains Inc. Obion TN Corn 120 120 - Green Plains Inc. Ord NE Corn 65 65 - Green Plains Inc. Shenandoah IA Corn 82 82 - Green Plains Inc. Superior IA Corn 60 60 - Green Plains Inc. Wood River NE Corn 121 121 - Green Plains Inc. York NE Corn 50 50 - Guardian Energy LLC Janesville MN Corn 149 149 - Guardian Hankinson LLC Hankinson ND Corn 149 149 - Guardian Lima LLC Lima OH Corn 70 70 - Heartland Corn Products Winthrop MN Corn 120 120 - Heron Lake BioEnergy LLC Heron Lake MN Corn 65 65 - Highwater Ethanol LLC Lamberton MN Corn 65 65 - Homeland Energy Solutions LLC Lawler IA Corn 200 200 - Husker Ag LLC Plainview NE Corn 76 76 - ICM Biofuels LLC St. Joseph MO Corn 50 50 - Ingredion Inc. Cedar Rapids IA Corn 45 45 - Iroquois Bio-Energy Co. LLC Rensselaer IN Corn 50 50 - KAAPA Ethanol LLC Minden NE Corn 80 80 - KAAPA Ethanol Ravenna LLC Ravenna NE Corn 125 125 - Kansas Ethanol LLC Lyons KS Corn 80 80 - Lincolnland Agri-Energy LLC Palestine IL Corn 60 60 - Lincolnway Energy LLC Nevada IA Corn 50 50 - Little Sioux Corn Processors LLC Marcus IA Corn 160 160 - Louis Dreyfus Commodities LLC Grand Junction IA Corn/Cellulosic Biomass 125 125 - Louis Dreyfus Commodities LLC Norfolk NE Corn 45 45 - Marquis Energy LLC Hennepin IL Corn 400 400 - Marquis Energy-Wisconsin LLC Necedah WI Corn 100 50 - Marysville Ethanol LLC Marysville MI Corn 50 50 - Maumee Express Inc. Abingdon VA Waste Alcohol 4 4 - Under Production Operating Construction/ Company Location State Feedstock Capacity Production (mgy) Expansion (mgy) Capacity (mgy) Merrick & Company Inc. Aurora CO Waste Alcohol 3 3 - Mid-America BioEnergy LLC Madrid NE Corn 46 46 - Mid-Missouri Energy Inc. Malta Bend MO Corn 50 50 - Midwest Renewable Energy LLC Sutherland NE Corn 28 - - Nebraska Corn Processing LLC Cambridge NE Corn 44 44 - New Energy Spirit Biomass Refinery LLC Jamestown ND Wheat Straw - - 16 NuGen Energy LLC Marion SD Corn 130 130 - One Earth Energy LLC Gibson City IL Corn 120 120 - Pacific Ethanol Inc. Boardman OR Corn 40 40 - Pacific Ethanol Inc. Burley ID Corn 60 60 - Pacific Ethanol Inc. Madera CA Corn/Sorghum 40 40 - Pacific Ethanol Inc. Stockton CA Corn/Sorghum/Cellulosic Biomass 60 60 - Pacific Ethanol Inc. (ICP) Pekin IL Corn 90 75 - Pacific Ethanol Inc. Plant 1 Aurora NE Corn 45 - - Pacific Ethanol Inc. Plant 2 Aurora NE Corn 100 100 - Pacific Ethanol Inc. Plant 1 Pekin IL Corn 100 100 - Pacific Ethanol Inc. Plant 2 Pekin IL Corn 60 60 - Parallel Products Louisville KY Waste Sugars/Alcohol 3 3 - Parallel Products Ontario CA Waste Sugars/Alcohol 3 3 - Pennsylvania Grain Processing LLC Clearfield PA Corn 110 110 - Pinal Energy LLC Maricopa AZ Corn 50 - - Pine Lake Corn Processors LLC Steamboat Rock IA Corn 38 38 - Plymouth Energy LLC Merrill IA Corn 50 50 - POET Biorefining - Alexandria LLC Alexandria IN Corn 68 68 - POET Biorefining - Ashton LLC Ashton IA Corn 56 56 - POET Biorefining - Big Stone LLC Big Stone City SD Corn 79 79 - POET Biorefining - Bingham Lake LLC Bingham Lake MN Corn 35 35 - POET Biorefining - Caro LLC Caro MI Corn 53 53 - POET Biorefining - Chancellor LLC Chancellor SD Corn 110 110 - POET Biorefining - Cloverdale LLC Cloverdale IN Corn 92 - - POET Biorefining - Coon Rapids LLC Coon Rapids IA Corn 54 54 - POET Biorefining - Corning LLC Corning IA Corn 65 65 - POET Biorefining - Emmetsburg LLC Emmetsburg IA Corn 55 55 - POET Biorefining - Fostoria LLC Fostoria OH Corn 68 68 - POET Biorefining - Glenville LLC (Agra Resources LLC) Albert Lea MN Corn 42 42 - POET Biorefining - Gowrie LLC Gowrie IA Corn 69 69 - POET Biorefining - Groton LLC Groton SD Corn 53 53 - POET Biorefining - Hanlontown LLC Hanlontown IA Corn 56 56 - POET Biorefining - Hudson LLC Hudson SD Corn 56 56 - POET Biorefining - Jewell LLC Jewell IA Corn 69 69 - POET Biorefining - Laddonia LLC Laddonia MO Corn 50 50 - POET Biorefining - Lake Crystal LLC Lake Crystal MN Corn 56 56 - POET Biorefining - Leipsic LLC Leipsic OH Corn 68 68 - POET Biorefining - Macon LLC Macon MO Corn 46 46 - POET Biorefining - Marion LLC Marion OH Corn 150 150 - POET Biorefining - Mitchell LLC Mitchell SD Corn 68 68 - POET Biorefining - North Manchester LLC North Manchester IN Corn 68 68 - POET Biorefining - Portland LLC Portland IN Corn 68 68 - POET Biorefining - Preston LLC Preston MN Corn 46 46 - POET Biorefining - Shelbyville LLC Shelbyville IN Corn - - 80 POET Research Center Scotland SD Corn 11 11 - Prairie Horizon Agri-Energy LLC Phillipsburg KS Corn 45 45 - Pratt Energy LLC Pratt KS Corn 57 57 - Project LIBERTY Emmetsburg IA Cellulosic Biomass 20 - - Quad County Corn Processors Cooperative Galva IA Corn/Cellulosic Biomass 38 38 - Red River BioRefinery LLC Grand Forks ND Waste Sugars/Starch - - 17 Red River Energy LLC Rosholt SD Corn 35 35 - Under Production Operating Construction/ Company Location State Feedstock Capacity Production (mgy) Expansion (mgy) Capacity (mgy) Red Trail Energy LLC Richardton ND Corn 50 50 - Redfield Energy LLC Redfield SD Corn 60 60 - Reeve Agri-Energy Inc. Garden City KS Corn/Sorghum 12 12 - Ringneck Energy & Feed LLC Onida SD Corn 80 80 - Russell Ethanol Inc. Russell KS Corn/Sorghum/Waste Starch 55 55 - Show Me Ethanol LLC Carrollton MO Corn 60 60 - Siouxland Energy Cooperative Sioux Center IA Corn 90 90 - Siouxland Ethanol LLC Jackson NE Corn 80 80 - South Bend Ethanol LLC South Bend IN Corn 102 102 - Southwest Iowa Renewable Energy LLC Council Bluffs IA Corn 140 140 - Spectrum Business Ventures Inc. Mead NE Corn 25 - - Sterling Ethanol LLC Sterling CO Corn 42 42 - Summit Natural Energy LLC Cornelius OR Waste Sugars/Starch 2 2 - Synata Bio Inc. Hugoton KS Cellulosic Biomass 25 - - Tate & Lyle PLC Loudon TN Corn 110 110 - Tharaldson Ethanol LLC Casselton ND Corn 153 153 - The Andersons Albion Ethanol LLC Albion MI Corn 140 140 - The Andersons Clymers Ethanol LLC Clymers IN Corn 135 135 - The Andersons Denison Ethanol LLC Denison IA Corn 65 65 - The Andersons Marathon Ethanol LLC Greenville OH Corn 135 135 - Three Rivers Energy LLC Coshocton OH Corn 50 - - Trenton Agri Products LLC Trenton NE Corn 45 45 - Tyton NC Biofuels LLC Raeford NC Corn/Tobacco 60 - - United Ethanol LLC Milton WI Corn 62 62 - United Wisconsin Grain Producers LLC Friesland WI Corn 60 60 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Albert City IA Corn 135 135 -

Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Albion NE Corn 135 135 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Aurora SD Corn 140 140 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Bloomingburg OH Corn 135 135 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Bluffton IN Corn 115 - - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Charles City IA Corn 140 140 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Fort Dodge IA Corn 140 140 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Hartley IA Corn 140 140 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Jefferson WI Corn 110 110 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Lakota IA Corn 110 110 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Linden IN Corn 135 135 - Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Mount Vernon IN Corn 100 100 -

Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Riga MI Corn 55 - -

Valero Renewable Fuels Co. LLC Welcome MN Corn 140 140 - VERBIO North America Corp. Nevada IA Cellulosic Biomass 30 * - Western New York Energy LLC Medina NY Corn 65 65 - Western Plains Energy LLC Campus KS Corn/Sorghum 50 50 - White Energy Inc. Hereford TX Corn/Sorghum 130 130 - White Energy Inc. Plainview TX Corn 100 100 - Yuma Ethanol LLC Yuma CO Corn 40 40 -

U.S. TOTAL 16,964 16,045 183

* Actual operating production unknown; not included in total. CONNECT ONLINE www.EthanolRFA.org

Facebook “f” Logo CMYK / .eps Facebook “f” Logo CMYK / .eps

www.facebook.com/EthanolRFA

instagram.com/ethanolrfa

www.twitter.com/EthanolRFA

youtube.com/RenewableFuelsAssoc

RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION

ST. LOUIS WASHINGTON, DC

16024 Manchester Road 425 3rd Street, SW Suite 101 Suite 1150 Ellisville, MO 63011 Washington, DC 20024 TEL: 636-594-2284 TEL: 202-289-3835

Copyright © 2020 Renewable Fuels Association. All Rights Reserved.