SARVASTIVADA BUDDHIST SCHOLASTICISM

BY

CHARLES WILLEMEN • BART DESSEIN COLLETT COX

• s

BRILL 0 LEIDEN • NEW YORK • KOLN 1998 TABLE OF CONTENTS

Preface xi Introductory Remark xv

Chapter One: About the 1 1. Compilation of the Canon 1 2. Literature 10 3. Abhidharma 16 1. The. Name 'Sarvastivada' 16 2. Classification of Sarvastivada Abhidharma Texts 18 3. Sarvastivada Philosophical Basics 19

Chapter Two: History and Sarvastivada 36 1. The Mauryan Empire 36 1. General History 36 2. The Synods of Vaisall and Pataliputra 39 2.1 Reason for the Schism 41 2.2 Vaisall and the Ten Lax Practices 42 2.3 Pataliputra and the Five Theses of Mahadeva 44 2.4 The Opinion of the Sariputrapariprccha- 48 2.5 Geographical Grounds for the Schism 48 3. The Second Synod of Pataliputra 53 4. Sarvastivada Tripitaka 60 4.1 The Language of the Sarvastivada Canon 60 4.2 Sarvastivada Sutrapitaka 60 4.3 Sarvastivada Abhidharmapitaka 63 4.4 Sarvastivada Vinayapitaka 80 4.5 Vinayapitaka 85 4.6 Sarvastivada Ksudrakapitaka 89

2. and 93 1. General History 93 1.1 The Greek Kingdom of Bactria 93 1.2 The Western and Eastern Greek Kingdoms 94 VIII TABLE OF CONTENTS

1.3 Saka-Pahlava Reign 95 2. Doctrinal Development 102 3. Darstantika, Sautrantika and (Mula-)Sarvastivada .... 106

3. Kasmira 110 1. General History 110 2. The Synod of Kasmira 116 3. Vaibhasika Orthodoxy 121 4. Conclusion 123

4. China 126 1. The Road to China 126 2. Abhidharma Studies in China 131

Chapter Three: Kasmira: Vaibhasika Orthodoxy 138 1. Introduction 138 2. General Contextual Issues 139 2.1 Complexities in the Development of Abhi- dharma 139 2.2 Correlation between the Development of Abhidharma and the Emergence of 143 2.2.1 Sarvastivada Abhidharma Literature and the Emergence of the Sarvastivada . 145 2.2.2 Sarvastivada Abhidharma Literature and Branches in the Sarvastivada Sect 147 3. Sarvastivada Abhidharma Literature 160 3.1. The Set of Seven Early Sarvastivada Abhidharma Texts 160 3.2. Relations to other Abhidharma Collections 162 3.3. Dating and Periodization 166 Texts 177 1. Abhidharmasangitiparyayapadasdstra 177 2. Abhidharmadharmaskandhapadasdstra 181 3. Abhidharmaprajnaptipadasastra 189 4. Abhidharmavijnanakayapadasastra 197 5. Abhidharmadatukdyapadasastra 206 6. Abhidharmaprakaranapadasastra 212 7. Abhidharmajndnaprasthdnasdstra 221 8. The Vibhdsa Compendia ?. 229 TABLE OF CONTENTS DC

9. *Abhidharmanydydnusdrasdstra and *Abhidharmasama- yapradipikdsdstra 240 10. Abhidharmadipa and Vibhasdprabhdvrtti 249

Chapter Four: Bactria and Gandhara 255 1. Hrdaya Treatises 255 2. Abhidharmakosa 269 3. Abhidharmamrtarasa 278 4. Abhidharmdvatdra 282

Abbreviations S 286

Bibliography 287

General Index 313 Index of Technical Terms 332