A TRANSYLVANIAN INTERLUDE on 11 June 1848 Dumitru Brătianu Had

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A TRANSYLVANIAN INTERLUDE on 11 June 1848 Dumitru Brătianu Had A TRANSYLVANIAN INTERLUDE On 11 June 1848 Dumitru Brătianu had received his accreditation as diplomatic agent in troubled Austria-Hungary, as the first diplomatic representative of modern Romania.221 Until then, Romanian interests abroad had been represented by officials of the Ottoman suzerain power. He travelled via Vienna, where the situation was confused after the collapse of the interim government led by Karl Ludwig von Fic- quelmont, and reached Pest in late June. Since March, under popular pressure, the Habsburg monarchy appeared to have imploded. Vienna as the official centre of power in the Empire was now challenged by Central European “staging-points in the multilateral contestation” during the events of 1848–49:222 Milan, Buda-Pest,223 Prague, Lemberg, Cracow, Timişoara, Braşov, Blaj and Cluj – to mention just a few of the cities engulfed by the protests – were all bursting with revolu- tionary ferment, political and territorial demands and potential multi- ethnic strife. Only one element in the confusing political landscape of 1848–49 remained stable: the now beleaguered Habsburg dynasty and the principle of dynastic loyalty as the pivotal centre of an otherwise explosive multi-national conundrum. After March and especially after the enactment of the April Laws by the Hungarian Diet, the new Hungarian regime had been operat- ing on the basis of a virtual, if brittle, parliamentary sovereignty and autonomy from Austria. A reformist Hungarian government led by Lajos Batthyány comprised the liberal István Széchenyi, the ‘roman- tic hero’ Lajos Kossuth and the ‘man of the future’, Ferenc Deák.224 Embedded within, and extending beyond, the complex network of constitutional, political, economic and military difficulties facing the empire was the thorny nationalities question. The ethnic dilemmas of the multi-national Austrian state would prove an obstacle to dialogue and a main cause of the defeat of the revolutions in Austria, Hun- gary, Transylvania and the Romanian Principalities. To summarise a 221 Anul 1848, 1: 515. Cf. also Iordache, Dumitru Brătianu, 90. 222 The Revolutions, ed. Evans and von Strandmann, 183. 223 Buda and Pest were still two separate, though contiguous, cities. They finally united in 1873 to form the present-day Hungarian capital, Budapest. 224 The Revolutions, ed. Evans and von Strandmann, 187. a transylvanian interlude 91 convoluted situation in simple terms, Croats, Serbs, Slovaks, Ruthenes and Romanians turned against a would-be centralist, unified Hun- garian state and “against a government which they perceived to be Magyar- and noble-dominated, its political benefits outweighed by a cultural-linguistic agenda of ‘Magyarization’ [. .].”225 On the occasion of a first in a series of national meetings in the Transylvanian town Blaj, on April 30, five to six thousand Romanian peasants urged by some of their intellectual leaders, initially declared themselves ready to fight for their rights by constitutional, non-violent means.226 At the time, the union of Transylvania to Hungary, ultimately sought by the Hungarians, was still considered of minor importance, as the Roma- nians were trying primarily to obtain their recognition as a ‘nation’ within the Austrian Empire and the civil and political rights such a recognition would have entailed. However, as Hungarian pressures for Transylvania’s merger with Hungary mounted, at their national con- gress at Blaj on May 15–17, thirty thousand Romanians “proclaimed the independence of the Romanian nation and its full equality with the other nations of Transylvania and declared their intention of maintaining its rights by creating a new political system based upon liberal principles.”227 Both conservatives and liberals in the Magyar- dominated Transylvanian government united and persisted in their refusal to recognize the Romanians as a separate nation, and perceived the links between the Transylvanian and Wallachian intellectuals as an encouragement to separatism and to a ‘Greater Romania project’. Consequently the Transylvanian Diet, in which the Romanians were not represented, pronounced the union of Transylvania to Hungary on 30 May and Emperor Ferdinand, in refuge in Innsbruck, recognised the union on June 10. It was against the backdrop of a solid Austrian- Hungarian front on the issue of the Transylvanian Romanians that Dumitru Brătianu arrived in Pest to negotiate with the Hungarian lead- ers. His suggestions for a Romanian-Magyar defensive alliance against the Austrians and the Russians – who were then poised for military intervention against the insurrection – were initially waived aside by Lajos Batthyány, the leader of the separatist Hungarian government. A compromise subsequently proposed by the Hungarian side would 225 Idem, 192. 226 Keith Hitchins, A Nation Discovered: Romanian intellectuals in Transylvania and the idea of nation, 1700–1848 (Bucharest, 1999), 184 sqq. 227 Ibid., 192..
Recommended publications
  • Hungary's Policy Towards Its Kin Minorities
    Hungary’s policy towards its kin minorities: The effects of Hungary’s recent legislative measures on the human rights situation of persons belonging to its kin minorities Óscar Alberto Lema Bouza Supervisor: Prof. Zsolt Körtvélyesi Second Semester University: Eötvös Loránd Tudományegyetem, Budapest, Hungary Academic Year 2012/2013 Óscar A. Lema Bouza Abstract Abstract: This thesis focuses on the recent legislative measures introduced by Hungary aimed at kin minorities in the neighbouring countries. Considering as relevant the ones with the largest Hungarian minorities (i.e. Croatia, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia and Ukraine), the thesis starts by presenting the background to the controversy, looking at the history, demographics and politics of the relevant states. After introducing the human rights standards contained in international and national legal instruments for the protection of minorities, the thesis looks at the reasons behind the enactment of the laws. To do so the politically dominant concept of Hungarian nation is examined. Finally, the author looks at the legal and political restrictions these measures face from the perspective of international law and the reactions of the affected countries, respectively. The research shows the strong dependency between the measures and the political conception of the nation, and points out the lack of amelioration of the human rights situation of ethnic Hungarians in the said countries. The reason given for this is the little effects produced on them by the measures adopted by Hungary and the potentially prejudicial nature of the reaction by the home states. The author advocates for a deeper cooperation between Hungary and the home states. Keywords: citizenship, ethnic preference, Fundamental Law, home state, human rights, Hungary, kin state, minorities, nation, Nationality Law, preferential treatment,Status Law.
    [Show full text]
  • Paths in Austrian and Finnish History
    Smallcons Project A Framework for Socio-Economic Development in Europe? The Consensual Political Cultures of the Small West European States in Comparative and Historical Perspective (No. HPSE-CT-2002-00134) Work Package 10 Paths in Austrian and Finnish History Helmut Konrad, Martin Pletersek, Andrea Strutz (eds.) Department of History/Contemporary History, University of Graz September 2004 Contributors: Helmut Konrad, Martin Pletersek, Johanna Rainio-Niemi, Henrik Stenius, Andrea Strutz 2 Contents Helmut Konrad, Martin Pletersek, Andrea Strutz Paths in Austrian and Finnish history – a tentative comparison Helmut Konrad Periods in the History of Austrian Consensualism Henrik Stenius Periodising Finnish Consensus Martin Pletersek, Andrea Strutz A Monarchy and Two Republics – the Austrian Path (including comparative context of neighbouring new EU-members) Johanna Rainio-Niemi Paths in the Austrian and Finnish history: FINLAND (including comparative context of neighbouring new EU-members) 3 Paths in Austrian and Finnish history – a tentative comparison Helmut Konrad, Martin Pletersek, Andrea Strutz The smallcons-project "A Framework for Socio-economic Development in Europe? The Consensual Political Cultures of the Small West European States in Comparative and Historical Perspective" reserves a particular place for Austria and Finland because "[…] these cases suggest that the communication capacity conditional for consensualism can emerge within only a few decades." (Annex to the contract: 3). As opposed to the other project countries, the project proposal assumes that the two are the discontinuity cases whose historical paths didn't seem to point towards consensualism. In the words of Peter Katzenstein, "[…] the Austrian train was at every branch switched in a direction opposite from the other small European states." (1985: 188).
    [Show full text]
  • HUNGARIAN STUDIES 16. No. 2. ([2002)
    Volume 16 Number 2 Hungarian Chair Symposium, April 14, 2002, Bloomington: "Lajos Kossuth in Changing Context: History, Freedom and Memory in Modern Hungary, 1948-2001" Pál Kelemen: „Vom Holocaust [...] läßt sich nur mit Hilfe der ästhetischen Imagination eine reale Vorstellung gewinnen" - Fremderfahrung und Gedächtnis bei Imre Kertész c g m < o HUNGARIAN STUDIES a Journal of the International Association for Hungarian Studies (Nemzetközi Magyarságtudományi Társaság) Hungarian Studies appears twice a year. It publishes original essays - written in English, French and German - dealing with aspects of the Hungarian past and present. Multidisciplinary in its approach, it is an international forum of literary, philological, historical and related studies. Each issue contains about 160 pages and will occasionally include illustrations. All manuscripts, books and other publications for review should be sent to the editorial address. Only original papers will be published and a copy of the Publishing Agreement will be sent to the authors of papers accepted for publication. Manuscripts will be processed only after receiving the signed copy of the agreement. Hungarian Studiesis published by AKADÉMIAI KIADÓ H-1117 Budapest, Prielle Kornélia u. 19/D Homepage: www.akkrt.hu/journals/hstud Order should be addressed to AKADÉMIAI KIADÓ, H-1519 Budapest, P.O. Box 245, Fax: (36-1) 464-8221, E-mail: [email protected] Subscription price for Volume 16 (2002) in 2 issues USD 142.00, including normal postage, airmail delivery USD 20.00. Editorial address H-1067
    [Show full text]
  • HUNGARIAN STUDIES 15. No. 1. (2001)
    1848-1849 IN HUNGARY GÁBOR GÁNGÓ Vienna University, Vienna, Austria There can be no doubt that the Hungarian Revolution of 1848 and the subse­ quent war of independence belong to the events that significantly contributed to the development of modern Hungarian historical consciousness. Decisive alter­ natives emerged during this critical period: national sovereignty versus develop­ ment under foreign power, or the cultivation of friendly compromises reached through negotiations versus violent confrontations. The patterns of thinking asso­ ciated with these choices also imposed their influence on the interpretations of other recent historic turning points such as the events of 1956. For a better understanding of what happened to Hungary during the years 1848-1849 we need to divide the events into three distinct but interconnected spheres. First, we need to consider the discussions between the spokesmen of the last Hungarian feudal assembly, the Diet of 1847-1848, and the leaders connected to the court of Emperor Ferdinand I (as King of Hungary: Ferdinand V) (1835^48) in Vienna. These discussions were followed by the negotiations on the formation and recognition of an independent and responsible Hungarian govern­ ment in 1848. Second, we have to delineate the revolutionary mass movement organised by leftist and radical intellectuals in Pest on March 15,1848. Third, we need to examine the civil war, which began in autumn 1848, between the National Guard army of the Hungarian government, the Austrian troops, and the insurgents of the non-Magyar nationalities. Due to the expansion of the Turkish Empire and to the rise of the House Habsburg, the kingdom of Hungary, one of the leading states in East-Central Eu­ rope during the late Middle Ages, had lost its independence during the sixteenth century.
    [Show full text]
  • 1867 As the Year of Constitutional Changes Around the World
    ELJ_2017-2__press 2018.12.12. 16:34 Page 39 Balázs Rigó* 1867 as the Year of Constitutional Changes Around the World I Introduction and Methodology The composite jubilee of the year 1867 provides the topic for this paper. We will see how 1867 influenced both international relationships and constitutional changes through the world. The apparent and evident parallelism between Canada and Hungary because of the jubilee of 1867 gave the hint to examine other events of constitutional history. The significant changes in the form of government or constitution of a country have a great impact on the neighbour - ing countries and politics. This phenomenon was the root of our examination; namely to analyse the corresponding events and the constitutional changes closely relating to the Canadian and Hungarian changes with an eye to other determining and / or neighbouring countries in the international relationship. Our objective is therefore to describe the process of the changes of 1867, or more precisely, the second half of the 1860’s, mostly in a descriptive way, since Hungarian and / or other foreign readers may not be so well-read on the history of the other side of the world, as they are on their own history. After that, our other incentive is to make a comparison of the detailed processes of the constitutional development of the examined countries, with an eye to the formation of the alliances of the First World War, as the end of the old world order started in 1867. The combination of these incentives, namely the description of the events and the internal developments, and placing of these developments into the external, foreign relationships basically determines which countries are to be analysed.
    [Show full text]
  • Mađarska Revolucija
    UDC: 323.1=511.141 94439 Review Scientific Article REVOLUTIONS OF 1848 AND 1956 – PARADIGM Goran VASIN OF BUILDING THE NATIONAL Faculty of Philosophy University of Novi Sad * IDENTITY OF HUNGARIANS Department of History Th e national identity of the Hungarians was built in several stages and several directions during the process of historical longevity. Firstly, it had been profi led through the anti-Ottoman and anti-Habsburg struggle; later on it was formed as unifi cation of the territories under the Crown of St. Stephan, to receive later on anti-Russian and anti-Soviet features. Th e Revolutions of 1848/1849 and 1956 are particularly characteristic in this respect. Th e national defeats that followed the aforementioned Revolutions were consolidated by the anti-Habsburg and anti-Turkish tones / 1848 /, and especially anti-Soviet / 1956 /. Th us, the cult of freedom, national sacrifi ce and tragedy, which was dominant earlier too, has now been upgraded into one of the most important components of the contemporary national identity of Hungarians, particularly highlighted by the refl ection of the events of the fall of the Berlin Wall and of Accession to the EU and NATO. Key words: Revolution 1848, Revolution 1956, Hungary, national identity, Habsburg, Austro-Hungary, Trianon, Soviets, Imre Nagy There are many factors that determined the identity frame and the form of the creation of the Hungarian national political concept in the modern age. Deeply entrenched fi rstly in the anti-Ottoman, and then anti-Austrian tradition, at the beginning of the 19th century the creators of * This article is written as a part of the Republic Project Territories of Vojvodina in the Context of European History (177002) [email protected] 9 Goran Vasin Revolutions of 1848 and 1956 – paradigm of building… the concept of the Hungarian political and stately nation had before them an open space with a look into the past.
    [Show full text]
  • $ the Structure and Command System of the Hungarian Army in The
    $$506 +,6725< Volume 1, Issue 2 (2002) 329–347 The structure and command system of the Hungarian army in the War of Independence of 1848–1849 TAMÁS CSIKÁNY Miklós Zrínyi National Defence University, Budapest, Hungary The War of Independence in 1848-1849 is one of the most glorious chapters in Hungarian history. The Hungarian Army, set up within a few months, managed to hold victory over one of the best armies of Europe of that time. The paper deals with the organizing, as well as the command and control system of the Hungarian Army. Special attention is paid to the organizing of the Home Defence (Honvéd) batallions, the most efficient units of the Hungarian Defence forces. Introduction The period of the revolution and war of independence of 1848–1849 is an outstanding and determining epoch in the history of Hungary. During this one and a half year time there were more changes in the country than there had been in the previous decades. The so called 1848 April Laws triggered irreversible social changes. The Hungarian administration and legislation were given an entirely different image by the activity of the government independent from the Vienna Court and responsible only to the Hungarian legislature. The country made tremendous efforts in order to reduce its distance from Western Europe. For the beginning of that activity favourable conditions were created by the Springtime of Nations of 1848, nearly paralyzing the European Great Powers, especially the Austrian Empire, which held Hungary in dependency. In March the revolutions in Vienna, Pest, and Milan generated such a shock which took the Vienna Court several months to overcome.
    [Show full text]
  • Történelem Angol Nyelven
    Név: ........................................................... osztály:...... TÖRTÉNELEM ANGOL NYELVEN KÖZÉPSZINTŰ ÍRÁSBELI VIZSGA 2010. október 20. 8:00 2010. október 20. ● Az írásbeli vizsga időtartama: 180 perc Pótlapok száma Tisztázati Piszkozati NEMZETI ERŐFORRÁS MINISZTÉRIUM ÉRETTSÉGI VIZSGA Történelem angol nyelven középszint — írásbeli vizsga 0913 Történelem angol nyelven — középszint Név: ........................................................... osztály:...... Important information Give clear answers and make all your work unambiguous – even if you need to make corrections in your text. Try to be concise and keep to the point. Do not use more space than is provided. Only write as many answers as required by the task. (If you write more, they will be evaluated in the order in which they appear.) Please write in blue ink. When working on the exam tasks consider the following. • Read the instructions carefully. • Do exactly what the instructions tell you. • Study the sources provided (pictures, diagrams, texts, maps). • Use the resources that you are allowed to use for each task: the maps of the Secondary School Historical Atlas [Középiskolai történelmi atlasz] and the bilingual dictionaries. Personal names, geographical data and concepts from these resources will be considered as part of your answer only if they are correctly spelled. • Consider your answers carefully before writing them down so that you do not have to correct them later. We advise you to follow these steps when dealing with the shorter or longer essay-type questions: 1. Identify the place and time of the given event or problem. 2. Use the given sources and the map [Történelmi atlasz] to understand the task. 3. Collect the general concepts (for example: development, change, production) and the time-specific concepts (for example: serf, guild, personality cult) that can be used to describe the given event or problem.
    [Show full text]
  • Catholic Priests from the Diocese of Csanád in the Hungarian Revolution and the War of Independence (1848 – 1849)
    Trivent Publishing © The Authors, 2015 Available online at http://trivent-publishing.eu/ Philosophy, Communication, Media sciences Series Volume Saint Gerard of Cenad: Tradition and Innovation Catholic Priests from the Diocese of Csanád in the Hungarian Revolution and the War of Independence (1848 – 1849) Péter Zakar Department of Modern History, University of Szeged Gál Ferenc College, Faculty of Social Sciences, Szeged, Hungary [email protected] Abstract The Church, mainly the local clergy, played an important, galvanising role in Hungary in 1848. In the spring of 1848 the possibility of a democratic transformation in the Catholic Church seemed to be a crucial point. The liberal priests started a strong movement in the heart of the Diocese of Csanád. Alajos Magyari, a teacher in the seminary of Temesvár wanted to abolish celibacy and to create a new democratic Catholic Church government. The supporters of Church modernisation adopted the philosophy and culture of Enlightenment, Liberalism, and Romanticism, creating an immanent theology on these bases. Ten priests from the Diocese of Csanád joined the Honvéd Army and took up weapons, while another ten priests served as army chaplains. The Revolution and War of Independence resulted in the formation of a unique revolutionary theology. Keywords: Church history; Diocese of Csanád; the Hungarian Revolution of 1848-1849; liberal clergymen in Hungary; priests in the National Guard; priests in the Honvéd Army; revolutionary theology; the liberal clerical interpretation of the Revolution. This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC-BY- NC-ND 4.0) license, which permits others to copy or share the article, provided original work is properly cited and that this is not done for commercial purposes.
    [Show full text]
  • The Holy Crown of Hungary, Visible and Invisible LA´ SZLO´ PE´ TER
    SEER, Vol. 81,No.3, July 2003 The Holy Crown of Hungary, Visible and Invisible LA´ SZLO´ PE´ TER The reader at this point will certainly ask: how it is possible that a national relic of such great significance has never been properly examined in order to attain satisfactory conclusions [about its origin]. The answer is as contradictory as unexpected: precisely because such importance was attached to the crown; because it has been treated as the greatest national treasure. Ka´lma´n Benda and Erik Fu¨gedi on the Holy Crown1 The history of political ideas reveals continuities and unexpected revivals. Too frequently it proves premature to pronounce a political idea dead. A well-known example which demonstrates that major political ideas hardly ever disappear without trace has been the re- emergence of the natural law theory which had spent years in the doldrums while utilitarianism dominated political philosophy in Britain and America.2 Ideas whose impact is more limited and confined to a single national society could, likewise, unexpectedly revive after their apparent demise. When over forty years ago the present writer, working towards his DPhil in Oxford, took up the doctrine of the Holy Crown of Hungary, he thought that the subject was of purely historical interest, or at least one without any direct relevance to Hungarian politics, present and future. The reason why this assumption looked obvious at the time was not even primarily because Hungary, as a part of the Soviet bloc, was ruled by Communists who rejected and sneered at any political La´szlo´ Pe´ter is Emeritus Professor of Hungarian History at the School of Slavonic and East European Studies, University College London.
    [Show full text]
  • 1848: European Revolutions
    Rapport, M. (2012) 1848: European revolutions. In: Isakhan, B. and Stockwell, S. (eds.) The Edinburgh Companion to the History of Democracy. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh, UK, pp. 282-292. ISBN 9780748640751 Copyright © 2012 Edinburgh University Press A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge The content must not be changed in any way or reproduced in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holder(s) When referring to this work, full bibliographic details must be given http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/78871/ Deposited on: 13 May 2013 Enlighten – Research publications by members of the University of Glasgow http://eprints.gla.ac.uk 1 1848: The European Revolutions Between February and April 1848, the conservative order which had dominated Europe since the fall of Napoleon in 1815 was felled by the hammer-blows of revolution across the continent. The revolutions swept liberal, or reformist, governments to power, tasked with forging a new political order based on the principles of civil rights and parliamentary government. By the end of 1849, all the revolutions had collapsed, making them a short and violent European experiment in liberal (and, in some countries, democratic) politics. For the history of democracy, the fascination of 1848 lies in the the variety of democratic forms which boiled to the surface of European political life in such a short space of time and in such a diversity of places. The revolutions witnessed, if only incipiently, the application of the rich and conflicting variety of democratic ideas and practices which have since been identified and closely-defined as part of the modern democratic experience.
    [Show full text]
  • Hungarian Revolution in 1956 Authors: Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities
    JOURNAL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES AND HUMANITIES HUNGARIAN REVOLUTION IN 1956 AUTHORS: JOURNAL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES AND HUMANITIES _____________________ISSN 1820-0869 Milivoj BEŠLIN, Institute for Philosophy and _____________________Broj 1/2017 Social Theory, University of Belgrade Scientifi c Editorial Offi ce: Ivo GOLDSTEIN, Eric GORDY, Haris DAJČ, Faculty of Philosophy, University Egidio IVETIĆ, Dušan JANJIĆ, of Belgrade Predrag MATVEJEVIĆ, Anđelka MIHAJLOV, Aleksandar MIRKOVIĆ, Darko TANASKOVIĆ, Christine Mladenka IVANKOVIĆ, Institute for Recent SINAPI, Aleksandra STUPAR, Josip history, Belgrade VRANDEČIĆ, Marc PILKINGTON, Ognjen RADONJIĆ, Pritam SINGH, Tvrtko JAKOVINA, Faculty of Humanities and Faruk ULGEN Social Sciences, University of Zagreb Edited by Siniša ZARIĆ Alexander MESAROVICH, Faculty of Vojislav BABIĆ Philosophy, University of Belgrade Publisher Momir SAMARDŽIĆ, University of Novi Sad, Faculty of Philosophy Beograd, Francuska 14 E-mail: [email protected] www.limesplus.rs; www.hedu.biz Nikola SAMARDŽIĆ, Faculty of Philosophy, www.komunikacija.org University of Belgrade For Publisher Zorica STABLOVIĆ BULAJIĆ Goran VASIN, Faculty of Philosophy, University of Novi Sad Editor-in-chief Nikola SAMARDŽIĆ Executive Editorial Offi ce: Haris DAJČ, Zorica STABLOVIĆ BULAJIĆ, Ivana STOJANOVIĆ Maja VASILJEVIĆ secretary, Mirjana KNEŽEVIĆ, Nevena KOČAK Design Kristina Radovanović CIP - Каталогизација у публикацији Народна библиотека Србије, Београд Technical Editor 32 Predrag Knežević LIMES plus : journal of Social Sciences and Humanities / editor-in-chief Nikola Samardžić. - [Štampano izd.]. - 2004, br. Sale and Subscription 1- . - Beograd : HERAedu, 2004- (Beograd : Instant sys- [email protected]; +381 11 72 46 023 tem). - 24 cm Tri puta godišnje. - Drugo izdanje na drugom mediju: Limes plus Printed by (Online) = ISSN 2406-2871 Instant system, Beograd ISSN 1820-0869 = Limes plus COBISS.SR-ID 114047756 CONTENT NO.
    [Show full text]