79788SEC 2009 453 EN DOCUMENTDETRAVAIL F.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EN EN EN COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES Brussels, 8.4.2009 SEC(2009) 453 COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT accompanying the COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THE COUNCIL Building a sustainable future for aquaculture A new impetus for the Strategy for the Sustainable Development of European Aquaculture Impact Assessment {COM(2009) 162 final} {SEC(2009) 454} EN EN TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Procedural issues and consultation of Interested Parties ..............................................4 1.1. Introduction...................................................................................................................4 1.2. The consultation process...............................................................................................4 1.3. General overview on feedback and contributions received from the consultation exercise ......................................................................................................................................5 1.4. Interservice Steering Group..........................................................................................7 1.5. Impact assessment – board opinion ..............................................................................7 2. What issue/problem is the policy/proposal expected to tackle? ...................................8 2.1. What is aquaculture?.....................................................................................................8 2.2. Aquaculture as an answer to increasing demand for aquatic food ...............................9 2.3. Economic, social, and environmental dimensions of aquaculture..............................11 2.4. What is the problem and why is action required?.......................................................12 2.5. Main factors influencing the development of the aquaculture industry and underlying drivers of the problem.................................................................................................16 2.6. Who is affected? .........................................................................................................25 2.7. Does the EU have the right to act? .............................................................................26 3. What is the overall policy objective in terms of expected impacts?...........................28 3.1. General objective........................................................................................................28 3.2. Strategic and policy-orientated objectives..................................................................28 4. What main policy options are available to achieve the objective? .............................30 5. Analysis of impacts.....................................................................................................31 5.1. General considerations................................................................................................31 5.2. Possible action to contribute achieving the objectives and their incremental effect under Option 2 ......................................................................................................................36 5.3. Likely economic, social and environmental impacts..................................................42 5.4. Overall estimates of possible environmental and socio-economic impacts depending on aquaculture growth scenarios......................................................................................48 6. Comparing options......................................................................................................52 6.1. Comparing options......................................................................................................52 6.2. Preferred option..........................................................................................................58 7. Monitoring and evaluation..........................................................................................58 EN 2 EN ANNEX I ..................................................................................................................................60 ANNEX II.................................................................................................................................87 ANNEX III..............................................................................................................................106 ANNEX IV .............................................................................................................................122 EN 3 EN 1. PROCEDURAL ISSUES AND CONSULTATION OF INTERESTED PARTIES 1.1. Introduction This Impact Assessment accompanies the Commission’s communication for a “strategy for the sustainable development of European aquaculture”. It assesses and compares different possible options for the framework under which public authorities in the EU could take to provide the best conditions for sustainable growth of aquaculture in Europe, ensuring both adequate supplies of healthy seafood and compliance with high European standards (especially environmental and health protection). This document is without prejudice to the final content of the Strategy to be adopted by the Commission. It has to be highlighted that, given that the Commission Communication is a political initiative and envisages action for public authorities across a wide range of different policy areas, this document is mainly based on qualitative analyses. It cannot analyse the impacts of each individual action; nor can it foresee the evolution of the European aquaculture industry in the future, as this largely depends on the decisions and action economic operators. Any specific legislative proposals that may be presented subsequently to this Strategy for sustainable development of European aquaculture and that would normally require an impact assessment will be accompanied by separate specific impact assessments. This initiative is referred to under item 2008/MARE/012 in the Commission 2008 Work Programme. This impact assessment is based on the results of a broad stakeholder consultation exercise and internal and external data and reports. 1.2. The consultation process This initiative started in spring 2007 in the form of a broad consultation exercise conducted by the Commission (DG MARE, formerly DG FISH) on the opportunities for the development of Community aquaculture, with reference in particular to an earlier Communication of 2002 on an European aquaculture strategy (COM(2002)511 final). The Commission’s minimum standards for consultation have been met. The consultation phase lasted practically until the end of 2007 and was organised through three different types of consultation: • An internet-wide consultation exercise was initiated on 10 May 2007 (through “Your Voice in Europe” and the DG FISH – now DG MARE – website). In order to provide guidance and facilitate the contribution from any interested party, DG MARE prepared a consultation document, together with other Commission DGs (ENV, SANCO, RDT), highlighting the mains issues where opinions were sought. This consultation document was accompanied by background facts and figures on European aquaculture.1 This internet consultation exercise lasted until 16 July, but written contributions continued to be received later. • In parallel with the consultation published on the internet, specific consultation meetings were organised with representatives and members of each of the main stakeholders and civil society 1 The consultation documents can be found at the following address: http://ec.europa.eu/fisheries/cfp/governance/consultations/consultation_100507_en.htm. EN 4 EN groups, namely finfish producers, shellfish producers, the fish feed industry, NGOs, and social partners. A similar invitation for a specific consultation meeting was offered to the representatives of the aquatic food processing and marketing sector, but this invitation was declined. • As a third step, the Commission organised a large stakeholder conference in Brussels on 15-16 November 2007 in order to discuss the main challenges to the sustainable development of aquaculture in Europe and in particular the role of public authorities in this context.2 An overarching follow-up and information exchange on this initiative was conducted in the framework of the Advisory Committee for Fisheries and Aquaculture (ACFA) and its Working Group 2, which is specifically dedicated to aquaculture. ACFA is the formal consultative body for the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP). Both the ACFA plenary session and its Working group 2 meet several times a year.3 The initiative and consultation process were accompanied by a number of events on aquaculture organised by the European Parliament (Special hearings by the Intergroup on Sustainable Development in October 20074 and by the Committee on Fisheries in March 2008). The Council of Fisheries Ministers also held an informal lunchtime debate on aquaculture at their June 2008 meeting (under the Slovenian Presidency). Very recently, the European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) also contributed to the organisation of an International Aquaculture Conference (Brussels, September 2008).5 1.3. General overview on feedback and contributions received from the consultation exercise Participants at each of the specific stakeholder meetings welcomed this initiative and all expressed their satisfaction at being consulted. Generally, these meetings were held in “listening mode” and provided participants with the chance to air their concerns and problems.