H160 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 The SPEAKER pro tempore. Pursu- that who literally saved lives, GABBY’s woman marries an astronaut, but a ant to clause 1(c) of rule XIX, further staff members, who were so heroic at love of science and a love of their coun- proceedings on this resolution will be this time, and just the shock that all of try brought them together. She was a postponed. them I know are still going through. champion for NASA and space explo- f But I know that they are really heart- ration before she married Captain ened by the fact that most people in Mark Kelly, but she has become one of RECESS America are just reaching out to them, the greatest advocates for the mission The SPEAKER pro tempore. Pursu- and people are saying, what can I do, of NASA. ant to clause 12(a) of rule I, the Chair how can I help, where can I be of serv- In 2007, our economy began to con- declares the House in recess subject to ice to this situation? tract and people lost jobs, and Rep- the call of the Chair. And that’s what we do in America is resentative GIFFORDS stood up to fight Accordingly (at 12 o’clock and 42 we come together. We pull together. for them, for help for the Tucson area minutes p.m.), the House stood in re- We say, okay, we need to be Americans and for our great country. It has not cess subject to the call of the Chair. and Americans first. And I think that’s been easy, but GABBY does not give up. what we’re seeing out of this. And I As one of the more youthful Members f just hope that we, throughout this of Congress, Congresswoman GIFFORDS b 1355 country, can continue to maintain that has served at a time when the first feeling of goodwill toward one another, President of our generation was elect- AFTER RECESS of wanting to help one another, of ed. The recess having expired, the House wanting to reach out to one another The SPEAKER pro tempore. The was called to order by the Speaker pro and wanting to work together no mat- time of the gentlewoman has expired. tempore (Mrs. BONO MACK) at 1 o’clock ter where we are in the country, be- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the and 55 minutes p.m. cause that’s what makes us great. gentlewoman an additional 15 seconds. f So our prayers and our support are Ms. CASTOR of Florida. It is a time with GABBY and with the others, and of hope and promise, but in the middle EXPRESSING SENSE OF HOUSE they will continue to be. The reports of a time of great economic challenge REGARDING ARIZONA SHOOTING appear to continue to be good, which is for Arizona, for Florida, and for all of The SPEAKER pro tempore. Pursu- so gratifying and so heartening to all America. But GABBY GIFFORDS has an ant to clause 1(c) of rule XIX, pro- of us. And we all look forward to the optimistic eye to the future. She be- ceedings will now resume on the reso- day when she’s back here standing on lieves that working together we can lution (H. Res. 32) expressing the sense this floor with the rest of us. solve many of the challenges before us. of the House of Representatives with Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam And in her honor we must recommit to respect to the tragic shooting in Tuc- Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- doing so. son, Arizona, on January 8, 2011. tlewoman from Florida (Ms. CASTOR). From the stories of the victims and The Clerk read the title of the resolu- Ms. CASTOR of Florida. I thank Mr. the heroes in Tucson, it is obvious that tion. PASTOR for yielding. it is a community composed of remark- The SPEAKER pro tempore. When Madam Speaker, on behalf of my able individuals. And it may explain proceedings were postponed earlier community in Florida, the Tampa Bay why the Tucson area has sent such a today, 4 hours and 6 minutes of debate area, I rise to honor my friend and col- remarkable public servant to represent remained on the resolution. league, GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, her staff them. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- The gentleman from California (Mr. and the other victims of the Arizona fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- DANIEL E. LUNGREN) has 2 hours re- shooting tragedy. The arc of time of utes to the gentleman from Louisiana, maining, and the gentleman from Ari- Congresswoman GIFFORDS’ service to her community and in the U.S. House Dr. FLEMING. zona (Mr. PASTOR) has 2 hours and 6 Mr. FLEMING. I thank my friend minutes remaining. so far has proven to be a time of change and challenge. from California. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Madam Speaker, I rise today in sup- fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield such b 1400 port of House Resolution 32. Last week, time as she may consume to the gen- Through it all, Representative GIF- in an act of cowardly violence, our tlewoman from North Carolina (Mrs. FORDS has been a model public servant. friend and colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS, MYRICK). When we were sworn in 4 years ago, was gunned down at a public event in- Mrs. MYRICK. I thank the gentleman Congresswoman GIFFORDS and I arrived tended to give her constituents a forum for yielding the time. as part of a class, Republican and Dem- to express their opinions. While our I think like everyone else who is ocrat, that had very high ideals. She Nation honors, mourns, and remembers here, I’m here today in support of this was a leader from the very beginning. those hurt and killed in this senseless resolution, not only because it recog- We adopted ethics reform. We bolstered tragedy, it is imperative that we nizes what happened in that tragic sit- veterans. We sought modern solutions strengthen our resolve as public serv- uation that just shocked and saddened for energy challenges. We helped more ants to not let these acts deter us from all of us on Saturday, but I think most students attend college. And she, par- the important work we do and from people in America were really just in a ticularly, promoted scientific innova- who we are. state of shock and not actually know- tion. America was founded on the idea ing what to do at that time when we She sought a seat on the Armed Serv- that the people have direct access to saw what was happening, not just to ices Committee at a time when our their elected representatives, and as our friend, GABBY GIFFORDS, who is a country was struggling with the war in long as I serve, I plan to continue that friend with everyone here, but also to Iraq. She sought that seat because she tradition. As Speaker BOEHNER so elo- all of the other families that were wanted to ensure that the military per- quently put it, no act, no matter how touched by this. sonnel and the bases in her district had heinous, must be allowed to stop us It goes so deep in the Tucson commu- a champion—and did they ever. from our duty. nity when you look at the six people Congresswoman GIFFORDS rose quick- Our thoughts and prayers are with who gave their lives and the people ly to become a leader on solar energy Congresswoman GIFFORDS, her family, who are still in the hospital fighting and on immigration reform. GABBY and all those who suffered from last for their lives and all the heroes of that works to strike a balance with prag- week’s events. day. We keep hearing story after story matic policies that actually work. And Finally, God bless GABBY GIFFORDS. after story of the heroes that emerged, whether it was President Bush or God bless the victims of this tragedy. just ordinary, everyday Americans who President Obama, Congresswoman GIF- God bless this institution. And God do what we do in situations like that. FORDS spoke up boldly for additional bless the United States of America. We don’t think about ourselves, but we resources on the U.S. border. Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam come forward to help the other person. I know it sounds like a modern fairy Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- And there were so many people like tale, that a beautiful, smart congress- tleman from Minnesota (Mr. ELLISON).

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:12 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00018 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.041 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H161 Mr. ELLISON. I thank the gentleman America at a time when we saw one of and issues she cares so deeply about for yielding me this time. the bad things. but always in a way that is respectful On behalf of the people of the Fifth You know, as I was walking over of opposing views. She is a fierce com- Congressional District of Minnesota, here, I was thinking about Wednesday, petitor, but is always considerate of let me offer my heartfelt condolences I guess a week ago today, coming down others. to those brave Americans who lost on the elevator with Mark and GABBY The SPEAKER pro tempore. The their lives in the tragedy at Tucson, and her parents. We had a wonderful time of the gentleman has expired. and let me offer wishes of a very speedy visit. I have had an opportunity to Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the recovery for those people who are serve on the Science Committee with gentleman an additional 30 seconds. Mr. VAN HOLLEN. That is why she wounded, including our own friend and GABBY. I went to lunch with her. She was such a good role model for Chris- colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS. And also, has a little interest in space, in case let me offer congratulations to those you didn’t know it. And how some- tina Taylor Green—the 9-year-old girl born on that terrible day of September heroic people who jumped up to help times we take for granted our friends 11, 2001, and who was gunned down on their fellow Americans at a time of and acquaintances and life itself, and another awful day for our Nation. tragedy and need. how in just a moment life can change. Christina Taylor Green, Gabe Zim- It would be very human for anyone to So today we offer this resolution to merman, and four others are, trag- be a little bit shy about coming to a recognize some good things about our ically, no longer with us. As we mourn public event after hearing about a trag- country, to wish our good friend GABBY their loss, we also pray for the full re- edy like this. But I think that in the a complete recovery and to come back covery of those who were injured. spirit of GABBY GIFFORDS, we should re- here, and we offer our thoughts and GABBY GIFFORDS’ light continues to affirm and rededicate ourselves to pub- prayers for our country. God bless shine, and she will continue to inspire lic access, public engagement. America. young and old throughout Arizona and I don’t think it would be honoring Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam our Nation. God bless GABBY GIFFORDS her great work that she and we expect Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- and all the victims of this horrible for her to carry on if we didn’t get tleman from Maryland (Mr. VAN tragedy. right back out there and engage in a HOLLEN). Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- spirited conversation about the shape Mr. VAN HOLLEN. Madam Speaker, fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- and destiny of our democracy. And so I many of us have just come from a con- utes to the gentlewoman from Missouri think it is important to make a very gressional prayer service for the vic- (Mrs. EMERSON). bold statement that we will reaffirm tims of the terrible tragedy in Arizona Mrs. EMERSON. Madam Speaker, our dedication to having a robust, open where we sang ‘‘Heal Us Now.’’ you know, we all get to know a person access, and free democracy by not let- We all know in this body that GABBY through the words of others. For our ting forces of fear and hatred, despera- GIFFORDS is one of our brightest lights: colleague GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and for tion and madness deter us from this smart, fair, courageous, and consid- everyone affected by the violence in very important and noble enterprise. erate of people of all points of view. Tucson, the outpouring of prayer and God bless America, and we wait for She is a very effective legislator and a emotion really tells the story of how and we look forward to a speedy recov- caring and thoughtful friend. And the we are all touched by these sad events. ery from our colleague, GABRIELLE GIF- people of Arizona could not have a bet- I think all of us draw strength from FORDS. ter representative in this United States one another in hearing the personal Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Congress. stories of relationships that they have fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- On Saturday, she was doing the job had with GABBY, and it really does help utes to the gentleman from Texas (Mr. she loves so dearly and takes so seri- us. I thought it would be important for NEUGEBAUER). ously: meeting with her constituents us to also hear just a couple of stories, Mr. NEUGEBAUER. Madam Speaker, and listening to their concerns when just a couple of sentiments, from some I wish I didn’t have to rise today in this senseless act of violence occurred. of GABBY’s friends and supporters back support of this resolution because it We come together to grieve for those home because they know GABBY, per- haps, in a little different way than we was a sad day for America last Satur- who were killed, including GABBY’s tal- day. ented and energetic outreach director, do. Carol Frazier writes, ‘‘Many prayers But let me say this: On behalf of the Gabe Zimmerman; to pray for the and much love to you and all the vic- people of the 19th Congressional Dis- quick recovery of those injured; and to trict, whom I represent, we send our tims of this stupid tragedy. GABBY, you honor those who, in a moment of chaos are what we need in Congress. I was so heartfelt condolences to the families and violence, took heroic actions that and the friends and the loved ones of impressed with meeting you—that you saved the lives of many, including looked me in the eye and truly listened those who were killed in this senseless GABBY. attack. to what I was saying.’’ We also offer our prayers for GABBY b 1410 A high school friend, Erika Noebel, writes, ‘‘Your entire UHS family is and the others who are making recov- GABBY GIFFORDS is a person who is ery from this act as well. You know, as always thinking of others—her con- pulling for you. We just love you so I read through this resolution, and as stituents, her staff, her colleagues. I much and are so proud to be your con- many of you like I have been watching spoke with her frequently during the stituents.’’ Scott Smith writes, ‘‘I hadn’t even TV, Saturday was a bad day. It was a very tough campaign she went heard of you until this tragic event, horrible day for America. Dana and I through, and she was always just ask- GABBY, but you are in my thoughts, were in the grocery store shopping ing how were her colleagues doing. and I very much hope you pull through when I got the notice that my friend ABBY Today, in that same way, G would this, especially because you were doing GABBY, our colleague GABBY, had been want us to be thinking and praying for your job talking to your constituents shot, along with others. It was terrible. the others—for her fallen and injured when this happened.’’ As we have gotten an opportunity to constituents and for her heroic staff. I think, like all of us here in the watch over the last few days, what we Gabe Zimmerman died doing what he House of Representatives, Cathy learned is that out of this horrific act, loved, serving the people of Arizona. Paredes expresses her sentiments best: we saw some of the things that make His many good works are a testament ‘‘Love you, Gabby. Stay strong. We are America great. We saw people tackle to the selfless works of public service here for you.’’ the attacker. We saw people offer as- performed by congressional staff every God bless GABBY GIFFORDS. sistance to GABBY and others. We saw a day for the people of our districts and Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam man shield his wife from the attacker. our Nation. Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- We saw the first responders do remark- GABBY GIFFORDS has always con- tleman from Texas (Mr. GONZALEZ). able work in getting people to the hos- ducted herself in a manner that brings Mr. GONZALEZ. Madam Speaker, I pital in what would be record time. We honor on this people’s House. She pas- am from San Antonio, and in my home- saw so many of the good things about sionately advocates for the positions town, about a year and a half ago, a

VerDate Mar 15 2010 02:41 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00019 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.045 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H162 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 convenience store owner was murdered Mr. DONNELLY of Indiana. On be- Mr. OLSON. I thank my colleague by a robber. half of all of the people of northern In- from California. The brother of the slain owner ob- diana, we want to express our prayers GABBY, I know you feel things and served that both his brother and the and thoughts for the victims and the you hear things. When asked, you murderer got up that same morning families of those killed and injured in squeeze a hand, you hold two fingers and made conscious choices: His broth- Arizona. up, and you hold a ‘‘thumbs up.’’ I er chose to go to work and support his To the staff of Congresswoman know you feel the love and prayers of a family—a right and a good thing. The GABBY GIFFORDS, we want to thank you Congress, a Nation, and a world that murderer made a choice to rob and for your service to our country and for only wants you to have a full and kill—an evil and a destructive thing. your sacrifice to our country. speedy recovery. My friend, right back On January 8, 2011, in Tucson, many To my friend GABBY GIFFORDS, who I at you. I will see you when you get people got up that morning and made a came into Congress with in 2006, we back in this Chamber. choice to do the right and good thing. love you and Mark. We miss you and Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam Only one person got up that morning Mark terribly. We are praying for your Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- and decided to do an evil and destruc- recovery. We know you are getting tlelady from Massachusetts (Ms. TSON- tive thing. stronger every day, and we can’t wait GAS). We cannot and will not allow the cru- to see you back here in the House Ms. TSONGAS. Madam Speaker, I elty of one person to overshadow the again in the very, very near future. rise today to express my deep sym- goodness that each of his victims rep- May God bless you, and may God pathy for the victims of the tragedy in resents. We in this Chamber are not bless our beloved country. Tucson, Arizona, this past Saturday. helpless. We offer our prayers for those Like all of us, I mourn for the grievous b 1420 who died and for a speedy recovery for harm that came to those who attended those who have survived. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Congresswoman GIFFORDS’ Congress on And, to GABBY, I know we all join in fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- Your Corner; for our colleague, GABBY, saying: Hurry back. This House needs utes to the gentleman from Texas (Mr. a courageous and conscientious law- you. We love you. OLSON). maker whose recovery and good health But we can do more. We can set an Mr. OLSON. I thank my colleague we all yearn for today; for a 9-year-old example that creates a fertile environ- from California. child bursting with innocent enthu- ment for constructive discourse that Madam Speaker, I rise today in sup- siasm and great promise; for a re- extends beyond the confines of this port of the resolution before the House spected jurist engaged in a simple act Capitol. and to pay tribute to my colleague and Despite the heartache and the trag- of friendship; for a kind and accom- dear friend, GABBY GIFFORDS. I have plished staffer; for a loving husband edy of last Saturday, we find solace been privileged to call her a friend as and inspiration that, in our Nation, the who instinctively shielded his wife the chairwoman of the Space and Aero- from the rain of bullets, and for a hus- United States of America, the goodness nautics Subcommittee while I was the of the many will always triumph over band, also lovingly protective, who was ranking member. unable to stave them off; and, finally, a the evil of the few. We found that we share a deep pas- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- widowed retiree still giving to her com- sion for space and NASA, and we have fornia. Madam Speaker, it is my pleas- munity, all so abruptly and violently worked closely on these issues to- ure to yield 2 minutes to the gen- losing their lives; and for those who are gether. In sitting in a hearing that tleman from Florida (Mr. MACK). thankfully recovering, all engaged in GABBY was running with your eyes Mr. MACK. Madam Speaker, I rise the abiding promise of democracy, closed, you would be hard pressed to today with sadness in my heart and a coming to talk with their Congress- know who was the Republican and who bit of anger about what happened in woman, gathering in the parking lot of was the Democrat. And as a freshman Tucson. a local supermarket on a Saturday I cannot help but think that, on that Member in Congress, it was heartening morning. morning, a colleague of ours was doing to know that while the controversial This horrific incident has raised what she enjoyed, doing what is ex- issues of the day may divide us, there many serious questions about appro- pected of a Member of Congress—meet- is also room for collaboration and priately identifying and caring for ing with her constituents, talking unity on both sides of the aisle. That those who suffer from mental illness, about the important issues of the day. was because of GABBY. about the accessibility of violent weap- She went to work that morning, to the I have no better bipartisan friend in ons, about the tone and language of our grocery store, to listen to her constitu- the Congress than GABBY GIFFORDS. politics today, and about the solemn ents. For someone to show up and pull Madam Speaker, she is warm and kind, obligations of elected office in a demo- the trigger is something that I don’t but the GABBY I know is also tough. cratic society—of those serving, of think any of us will ever forget. She will pull through this with her their staff, and of constituents eager to I pray for GABBY. My thoughts and husband, Mark, by her side. I wouldn’t participate and be heard. prayers go to all of the family members bet against her. But today we honor with our words who have been affected by this tragedy. Other Members of our House family those who tragically lost their lives We hope and we cannot wait for that need our support too. I would like to and those harmed by this senseless act day when GABBY comes back to this say a prayer for Gabe Zimmerman and of violence. We pray for GABBY and all floor—when she walks through that his family, GABBY’s staffer who lost his those still recovering; and we remem- door, when she joins us again, when she life, as well as Ron Barber and Pam ber their families and loved ones now casts a vote. Most importantly, Simon, her other staffers who were vic- struggling with the immensity of their though, I cannot wait to see that smile tims in this horrible, horrible tragedy. losses. In the days ahead, however, we on her face. No matter who you are, We must also remember the others must honor and remember them with whenever you met GABBY, she always who lost their lives or were seriously our actions. greeted you with a smile, with kind- injured. They are in our hearts and Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- ness in her heart, with determination prayers as the Nation begins the heal- fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- and strength. ing process. utes to the gentleman from Pennsyl- GABBY, we are praying for you. We Madam Speaker, I am going to close vania (Mr. MEEHAN). pull for you. Our hearts and prayers are my remarks by talking to my friend as Mr. MEEHAN. I want to thank my with you. You are missed, and we look if she was here because in many ways friend for yielding. forward to seeing you back on the floor she is. Madam Speaker, I rise and join my of the House. The SPEAKER pro tempore. The colleagues—and in fact fellow citizens Thank you and God bless you. time of the gentleman has expired. from across this Nation—in thought Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- and prayer following the tragic assault Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield the on GABBY GIFFORDS and 19 others in tleman from Indiana. gentleman an additional 30 seconds. Tucson. I pray that in these critical

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:12 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00020 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.047 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H163 hours GABBY GIFFORDS will heal and our own roofs to turn their rooms, ga- ‘‘GABRIELLE is a strongly principled begin the path to a fuller recovery. rages or backyards into private areas person who, at Cornell, continually Just yesterday, I was privileged to where we’re even afraid to tread. For worked toward improvement, finding a join a large number of my freshmen protectors and preservers of the law, way to reach a positive agreement. I colleagues as we went on a visit to the it’s not okay to tell me that nothing is found myself continually impressed Walter Reed Army Hospital where we wrong with receiving an email that with her ability to see workable solu- were humbled and inspired by the re- says, ‘‘I’m concerned and looking for a tions to issues, even when we did not markable strength of severely injured good old-fashioned lynching.’’ For agree on the issue. GABBY is fun, pas- military heroes who are fighting to re- those who debate and protest, it’s not sionate, intelligent, highly competent, cover from their wounds. I pray that okay to spit, to say racial slurs, to say and focused. She is a person who turns GABBY GIFFORDS will be provided with reload, or to arm, in reference to de- words into action, something that a similar resolve. bate, and it’s also not okay to say a should be valued now more than ever.’’ I pray for those who lost their lives group other than yourself is a Nean- GABBY, Cornell prays for you, and the and the families of their loved ones derthal and they want people to die citizens of upstate New York are reach- who now struggle with grief. And I quickly. ing out to all of those families affected by this senseless act of violence and think particularly, having been a b 1430 former prosecutor, of Judge John Roll, praying that they may find peace, com- whose loss is being deeply felt by our The SPEAKER pro tempore. The fort, and healing. colleagues in their public service from time of the gentlewoman has expired. Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the the judiciary. While this tragedy was Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- gentlelady an additional minute. not related to his duties per se, it is a tlelady from California (Mrs. DAVIS). Ms. RICHARDSON. For our courts, reminder that our judges too often face Mrs. DAVIS of California. I come even in 1919 and 1931 in the cases of threats that impinge on the independ- here today shaken by an act of horrific Schenk v. United States and Near v. ence that they must be accorded for proportions and yet heartened by boun- Minnesota, our forefathers had the wis- our system of government and freedom tiful acts of the human spirit. We are dom to know that the most stringent and, just as importantly, justice, to comforted that in these times, the pain protection of free speech would not prosper. and the shock can be lightened, if only protect a man in falsely shouting Lastly, I want to express deep condo- temporarily, by knowing that the good ‘‘fire’’ in a theater and causing panic. lences to the family of Christina Tay- overwhelms the bad. I think that is So who would tell me that it would how GABBY would want us to reflect lor Green, whose grandfather, Dallas be appropriate that on August 17, 2009, Green, is a member of the Philadelphia today. that it would be appropriate for a man We grieve for the losses and the pain community. This tragic incident to carry an AR–15 rifle and a pistol felt in the community of Tucson for or- brought it home in a very personal way only feet from our President. dinary people who we learned are quite to the people of my region. Let us And now, for those of us who are here extraordinary. allow this horrible tragedy to inspire today, we turn to the resolution on the We know the tireless efforts of our all Americans to become better instru- floor. own staff who come to work every day ments of peace. On page 4, sections 7 and 8, the reso- with one goal in mind—to help people. Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam lution says that we would have the That’s why we mourn the loss of Gabe Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- right of people to peaceably assemble Zimmerman. tlelady from California (Ms. RICHARD- and that all would participate without But most of all, I come here today to SON). being silenced for fear of intimidation. send, in the most public way I can, my Ms. RICHARDSON. Madam Speaker, I’m sad to say that, yes, even in this love and Mi Shebeirach—a Hebrew I concur in expressing the sense of the own Chamber on these grounds, I don’t prayer for the sick which celebrates House of Representatives with respect think we’ve always fulfilled those the spirit of healing to those recov- to the tragic shooting in Tucson, Ari- words of ‘‘peaceable assembly free of ering from their wounds, and particu- zona, on January 8, 2011. intimidation.’’ larly to my dear friend and colleague, Like all Americans, on Saturday We, too, must not react. But it’s time Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. morning I was not only saddened, but I to act, not just in legislation, but to do People beyond GABBY’s district are was sick to my stomach while I what Congresswoman GIFFORDS asked learning about the political acumen of watched the horrible attack against us to do—to reduce the divisive tone in this talented and engaging leader. As my colleague, my office mate for 2 this country. Maybe if we start as lead- public servants, we do our jobs by lis- years, Congresswoman GIFFORDS— ers, others will follow. tening to the American people—by known as ‘‘GABBY’’ to me—and her I express condolences. I pray for looking constituents in the eye, assur- staff, her constituents, and all Ameri- those on their recovery, and I also ing them that we want to help, letting cans. commit to work on this issue and to them know that we understand with a We know now that on January 8 Con- work with my colleagues. nod, a handshake, and most often a gresswoman GIFFORDS reached out and Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- hug, as GABBY frequently was known to sought ‘‘new ways to reduce the highly fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- do. To have that important connection partisan divisive tone that all too often utes to the gentleman from New York so shaken by the attempted assassina- dominates our public discourse.’’ (Mr. GIBSON). tion of our colleague and friend is dev- Today, I am going to do exactly that, Mr. GIBSON. I thank the gentleman astating. not in words of criticism, but thoughts for yielding. But GABBY, of all people, was an ex- of observation and a desire to help. Madam Speaker, I rise today on be- ample of what it means to be connected For lawmakers, whether Federal, half of the people in upstate New York to your district. I know she wouldn’t State or local, this tragic incident to express our deepest condolences and stand for this kind of violence, but she must make us reevaluate our spending sympathies to all of those affected by also wouldn’t stand for allowing it to priorities and accept the fact that our this horrific tragedy. We pray for those stop us from our service. continued failure to adequately fund who lost their lives and for the recov- Whenever she talked about her con- mental illness is a mistake. For agen- ery of those wounded in the attack. stituents, she prefaced it with, ‘‘I real- cies, whether they be educational, I first met GABRIELLE GIFFORDS ly understand where they are coming military or private vendors and busi- many years ago at Cornell University from, and we need to solve this prob- nesses, we must be diligent in con- where we were graduate students to- lem.’’ necting the dots and making use of gether in the mid-1990s. I did not know Her constituents are fortunate to good technology to have real-time in- her well, but we shared mutual friends have such a representative with such formation. who always spoke of her in the kindest energy and skill who cares about them For parents, whether your child, who of terms. Last night I heard from one so deeply. will always be your child regardless of of GABBY’s good friends, Colin Forth, The SPEAKER pro tempore. The their age, should not be allowed under and he shared the following: time of the gentlewoman has expired.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:12 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00021 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.049 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H164 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the ing forward to her marriage and to fu- trict, out to the Congresswoman’s fam- gentlelady an additional 30 seconds. ture trips. And just last week, we dis- ily, to the Congresswoman herself, and Mrs. DAVIS of California. She cares cussed going to Afghanistan again. to all the families that were affected about their concerns, fears, and hopes So I look forward to GABBY’s speedy by such a tragic day in our Nation’s and knows how to work with people recovery, for her return here to the history. from all political persuasions. House, and for that trip that we will We shall never forget what happened My heart goes out to everyone af- take to Afghanistan to go greet our last Saturday. But as I walked into fected by this massacre, and the shock men and women in harm’s way. work today, and I saw the Sun break- from it reverberates throughout my May God bless GABBY. May God con- ing as it was coming up and shining on community and our country. tinue to bless the United States of the dome of the Capitol, it was a glo- So I am listening to my constituents America. rious sight. Because what it reminded that hope that this tragedy will engage Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam me is that even in our darkest days us anew in serious and civil discourse Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- this Nation always will rise again. And on how we can leave a better world for tleman from Oregon (Mr. as we stand here rightfully and pay our our children and our grandchildren. BLUMENAUER). respects to our dear colleague and the That is what GABBY strived to do daily. Mr. BLUMENAUER. I appreciate the families that suffered so much, and are It is what she would want us to be opportunity to come together to ex- suffering as we speak, let us not forget doing right now. press our sorrow and support for our that this Nation will rise, and we will Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- friend and colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS, persevere. fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 3 min- and the 19 other victims of this sense- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam utes to the gentleman from Pennsyl- less rampage. Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- vania (Mr. SHUSTER). I cherish the time I spent with GABBY tlelady from New York (Mrs. MCCAR- Mr. SHUSTER. I rise today with a in Tucson to promote the livability of THY). heavy heart to join my colleagues in her community. There I’ve seen first- Mrs. MCCARTHY of New York. The support of this resolution and to honor hand the respect Congresswoman GIF- great State of New York certainly the innocent Americans whose lives FORDS commanded from the entire sends their wishes and their prayers to were so senselessly and tragically al- civic leadership. I witnessed the emo- the great State of Arizona. New York tered by the events in Tucson last tional connection between GABBY and State went through a horror the same week. her political supporters. They knew as Arizona is going through now. It’s so GABRIELLE GIFFORDS was embodying that she was somebody special, and you parallel it’s scary. Six killed, 20 in- the very essence of what it means to be could see that she treated each and jured, my husband dying, murdered, an elected Representative in our great every one of them the same way. my son shot. But this is really a mes- Republic by meeting and listening to 1440 sage of hope because my son did sur- her constituents last Saturday. Gabe b vive. Many of the victims survived. Zimmerman, Ron Barber, and Pamela Then there is the bond between But I think the wonderful thing that Simon were there, too, doing their jobs GABBY and her terrific team. It makes needs to be out there are the prayers like thousands of other dedicated con- it so jarring, the loss of Gabe Zimmer- that came through from all parts of gressional staffers who support us and man, the wounding of Rod Barber and this country. the work we do here every day in Pam Simon of her office. Her out- Washington and especially back in our standing staff is representative of the GABBY’s staff, you are suffering ter- districts. amazing men and women, over 10,000 in ribly. Those that have died, your fami- The Americans who lost their lives all, here on Capitol Hill and back lies are suffering terribly. And those on Saturday and the innocent victims home, who make the government proc- that have been wounded have to go who were wounded were performing ess possible. They are like family, not through the pain to heal. What I will their civic duty to take an active role just for GABBY. We must do all we can say to all of you, time will heal you. in their government, and among them to protect the safety of staff and the You will never forget, but time will were 9-year-old Christina Taylor Green employees who serve our country every make you smile again. and Pittsburgh native Judge John Roll. day. GABBY would be so proud of this In our disbelief of the events last Finally, this is about our relation- Chamber today. One of the things that week, let us not forget the heroism of ship with GABBY and our responsibility GABBY is known for is how bipartisan those who subdued the attacker pre- to heal and repair. The path forward is she is. And she has brought this Cham- venting further loss of life. They put illustrated by GABBY herself, the best ber together. It’s just a shame that a their own lives on the line to protect example I know of someone who uses tragedy has to bring us all together. their neighbors. They represent the her intelligence, charm, passion, and You know, GABBY’s going to be fine, best of America and shine in our dark- commitment to bring people together. and she will be back here. And she’ll be est hour. Then they can sort out the difficult over there hugging people, talking to We will not allow this tragedy to issues that way, and move forward with people. But that’s what we as a Nation weaken our resolve or to undermine the same good humor, skill, and results have to learn. We can disagree, but we the sacred responsibility that we as as GABBY. As she recovers, I hope we need to work together. That is what elected officials have to serve the peo- can honor her service and sacrifice by GABBY wants, and that’s what she’ll ple we represent. To allow this act of doing all that we can to restore that push when she gets back here. violence to keep us from our duties spark, that civility, and that commit- So with that, the prayers of this Na- would be a disservice to the people we ment to civilized discourse. tion go to all. God bless our country, honor today, especially GABBY. Madam Speaker, that’s a tall order. God bless the victims. GABBY was a friend of mine. We first Can we beat the odds? Our dear friend Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- became friends when I looked at her GABBY will show us how, as she is beat- fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 3 min- bio and realized that her family and ing the odds right now. I am confident utes to the gentlelady from Ohio (Mrs. she were operators and owners of a tire her recovery will be a triumph of her SCHMIDT). business just as my family was. So not spirit, will, and intellect, and be a fur- Mrs. SCHMIDT. Madam Speaker, I only could GABBY and I talk policy, but ther inspiration to us all. rise today to recognize and honor our we could talk tire; and there are few Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- colleague GABBY GIFFORDS and to women that can talk tire like GABBY. fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- mourn the loss of those that died in Also, I served on the Armed Services utes to the gentleman from New York Tucson on Saturday, and to also pray Committee and got to know her very (Mr. REED). for those who have been affected by well. We traveled on two trips—one to Mr. REED. Madam Speaker, I rise this great tragedy, and to applaud the Afghanistan and one to Iraq. It was the today without a script, but to send my courage of those who risked their own week before her wedding to Mark that thoughts and prayers, and those of all lives so that others might live, and to we traveled, and she talked about look- of the thousands of people from my dis- thank the first responders and the

VerDate Mar 15 2010 02:41 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00022 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.050 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H165 health care professionals whose quick FORDS, her family, her staff, and the families and friends. However, as is so action and work saved their lives. other victims of the senseless tragedy. often the case when an act of random You know, Madam Speaker, nobody Since she was first elected in 2006, cruelty bewilders and depresses us, ex- ever thought Saturday would happen, GABBY GIFFORDS has been one of the ceptional displays of generosity, cour- especially GABBY. She was just out brightest lights in this Congress. I have age and heroism can serve as a potent there doing her job. And when you gotten to know her personally in the counterweight. These acts are a re- think of the 20 families, and the com- Blue Dog Coalition, and she is my minder of the extraordinary selfless- munity and the Nation, and how we friend. I have been especially impressed ness that people are capable of. have been affected by this act of vio- by her intelligence, her warm person- Let’s remember and salute those acts lence, you think of the little girl that ality, and her singular ability to bridge today. Mark and GABBY, we are think- went there to meet her Congresswoman differences and bring people together. ing of you. We are behind you all the who never came home. You think These qualities, and the fact that she time. We love you. about the person that took her, that was attacked while serving her con- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam wonderful neighbor who now will al- stituents, make the situation all the Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- ways think about what if I hadn’t done more heartbreaking. tlelady from Ohio (Ms. KAPTUR). this, what if I hadn’t said would you In the book of Isaiah, it is written, Ms. KAPTUR. Madam Speaker, I rise like to come? ‘‘Come let us reason together.’’ Let us in support of the resolution and join Madam Speaker, there are so many then take this opportunity to pause my dear colleagues and on behalf of the people affected by this tragedy. And no and reflect on the lives of the victims, people of northern Ohio, who join citi- one can ever understand the mind of a the heroism of the first responders, and zens across our Nation in pouring out person that would do this random act the bedrock principle of American de- compassion and healing to the families of violence. But we as a Nation can mocracy—reaffirmed in the resolution and citizens of Arizona who have been come together. We can recognize the before us today—the right to assemble so harmed and wounded at liberty’s courage of those that helped stop him. peacefully and to petition the govern- doorstep, the U.S. House of Representa- We can recognize the courage of those ment for the redress of grievances. tives. Let our prayers and comfort flow to that are fighting for their lives, espe- b 1450 cially our GABBY. We can pray espe- the victims, to the healers, to those cially that this Nation will never again We must not let violence or the who must carry forward with full mem- see that kind of tragedy. threat of violence deter us from rep- ory and understanding of what has And most importantly, Madam resenting our constituents and doing transpired and why. Let us strive to do Speaker, we as a Nation—and I know the Nation’s business. God bless GABBY and to be so much better as a people. people have said to me, well, what can GIFFORDS, the other injured, the fami- Our collective feeling of brotherly and we do? We as a Nation can pray. Get lies of those who were killed, the peo- sisterly love and the unity that flows down on our knees every morning and ple of Arizona and the United States of from it holds the power to heal. every night. Pray for GABBY. Pray for America. We all feel that desire. Our constitu- her family. Pray for those folks that Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- ents feel that desire. Congresswoman are suffering in the hospital. Pray for fornia. Madam Speaker, it is my privi- GABBY GIFFORDS, our beloved col- those moms and those dads and those lege to yield 2 minutes to the gen- league, is fighting to show us the way brothers and those sisters and those tleman from New Jersey (Mr. FRELING- forward. We pray for her and her fam- aunts and those uncles and those HUYSEN). ily. We pray for all victims and their grandparents that will never touch the Mr. FRELINGHUYSEN. Madam families. We pray for all those who are family members again. Pray for Speaker, Saturday was indeed a grim taking this difficult journey with GABBY’s staff. Mourn the loss of her day for our Nation. It was the day our them. staffer. Mourn the loss of all six who beloved colleague, GABRIELLE GIF- What a remarkable young woman perished. But most importantly, to FORDS, was attacked while doing her GABBY is. She represents the highest pray that the folks that have been af- job listening to her constituents. It aspirations of America. She is kind, fected can have the courage to go on. was GABBY herself who aptly said just talented, highly motivated, effer- You know, we had a prayer service. last year that the term ‘‘representa- vescent and so in love with her hus- And Cantor Leon Sher wrote a beau- tive’’ is more of a job ‘‘description’’ band, Mark. We know GABBY is a fight- tiful song. And at the end of the song than a job ‘‘title.’’ er and so very enjoyable to be with. he says: As we all work to represent our con- We embrace her, her family, her staff We pray for healing of the people, stituents and our States and Nation, with the same affection as would she. We pray for healing of the land. the Speaker is correct when he said And if GABBY were able at this mo- And peace for every race and nation, that ‘‘an attack on one who serves is ment, we know she would be embracing Every child, every woman, every an attack on all who serve.’’ Last the victims of the fallen and their man. weekend, GABBY’s efforts to serve her loved ones. I don’t think any words can sum up constituents brought her staff, herself This is a moment for America to what we need to do here now today. So and her constituents into a line of fire take stock of itself. No one should have let us pray for GABBY that she comes from a deranged man who shot 21 de- to endure what these citizens have had back and she fights for what she be- fenseless, innocent citizens. to endure. Frankly, no one should have lieves in. Six people died and many were had to endure the mean-spirited and I welcome her spirited debate and her wounded. Phyllis Schneck was a 79- inciteful political campaigns GABBY smile and her Pollyanna point of view. year-old native of New Jersey who did. But let us hope that all of those that lived during the summer on Old Lake In the sweep of history, this attack have been touched by this tragedy can End Road in the Green Pond section of was an attack on liberty. It desecrates heal and heal in a short run. Thank Rockaway Township in my congres- our worth as a people. We must all you. God bless this country, and God sional district. She was one of those. search our souls. How could such a hei- bless all in it. Mrs. Schneck and her late husband, nous act transpire? Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam Ernie, lived for years in Towaco, and The SPEAKER pro tempore. The Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- they were active members of the Oak time of the gentlewoman has expired. tleman from Georgia (Mr. BISHOP). Ridge Presbyterian Church. She was a Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the Mr. BISHOP of Georgia. I thank the member of the Montville Women’s gentlelady an additional 30 seconds. gentleman from Arizona for yielding. Club. She was a mother, grandmother Ms. KAPTUR. If the evidence shows Madam Speaker, my wife, Vivian, and great grandmother. Hers, as were that unaddressed mental illness, cou- and I were shocked and saddened to the others, were lives well lived. pled with guns and disturbing Internet learn of the awful events in Tucson, Madam Speaker, our minds reel from postings were contributing factors, as Arizona, last Saturday. First and fore- Saturday’s violence. Our hearts ache when two Capitol Police officers were most, our prayers are with GABBY GIF- for those slain and injured and their gunned down just a decade ago outside

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:12 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00023 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.053 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H166 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 this Chamber, then Congress must fi- friend and colleague, Congresswoman reer in public service and attending nally, finally engage that which to GABBY GIFFORDS. college, she hoped and said, at Penn date it has been unwilling to fully em- In addition to the dedicated members State; 30-year-old Gabe Zimmerman, brace and understand. When human of her staff who were also wounded and Gabrielle’s staffer, newly engaged, tragedy falls at your knees, do you all of the other innocent victims of this master of social work, who dedicated look away, or do you stoop to pick up unconscionable act of violence, I want his life to public service; 79-year-old the pieces and ask why? Why? to express my sincere sympathies to Phyllis Schneck, New Jersey native, May God bless America. May the the families of U.S. District Court church volunteer, loved cooking and campaigns of 2012 be conducted in a Judge John Roll, Gabe Zimmerman, a spending time with her family; 76-year- manner that brings credit to our Na- valued member of our congressional old Dorwan Stoddard, devout Chris- tion’s highest aspirations, mindful of family, Dorwan Stoddard, Dorothy tian, survivor of 17 heart stents, who the suffering that has occurred. And Morris, Phyllis Schneck and most espe- died saving the life of his wife, a grade may God give America and her leaders cially Christina Taylor Green, a re- school friend; and 76-year-old Dorothy and her people great wisdom in the markable 9-year-old child who had just Morris. We pay tribute to them all, and days ahead. won her first election to the student we thank them for their service to this Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- council and wanted to speak to her country. fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- Congresswoman about a career in pub- And we will not let this attack deter utes to the gentlewoman from Illinois lic service. us from carrying on the business of the (Mrs. BIGGERT). Madam Speaker, as Speaker BOEHNER American people and engaging in civil Mrs. BIGGERT. Madam Speaker, I so aptly noted just moments after this discourse in our representative democ- rise today with a heavy heart to ex- tragedy occurred, an attack on one racy. press my condolences to the families who serves is an attack on all who Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam and loved ones of Congresswoman serve. I would venture to say that all of Speaker, I yield 1 minute to the distin- GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, her staffer, Gabe us who have the high honor of serving guished gentleman from Washington Zimmerman, and all the victims of last in this body, the people’s House, have (Mr. LARSEN). Saturday’s shooting. searched our souls to try to understand Mr. LARSEN of Washington. Madam Like all my colleagues here today, I the nature of this attack on the very Speaker, what does the Lord require? have struggled to make sense out of core of our democracy. Do justice, love mercy, and walk hum- this horrible tragedy since first hear- Like most of us, Congresswoman GIF- bly with God. These words from the ing the news that our good friend and FORDS knows that there is simply no prophet Micah are as true today as colleague had been viciously attacked. substitute for spending time with your they were when first spoken. They pro- As I watched the news and learned constituents. The plain truth is that vide guidance to how we in Congress about the innocent lives that had been you cannot effectively represent your can lead by example for everyone in cut short, it became painfully clear to community in Congress unless you this country as we try to come to me that nothing will ever be able to ex- make time to interact with the people terms with the tragedy in Arizona. plain such an atrocity. who hired you for this job. We can work with each other with Politics is the art of genteel dis- And as for me, I will continue to do justice, with mercy and humility in agreement. Actions like those we wit- that because I truly believe that even our hearts. When Micah said these nessed last Saturday have no place, no in the face of this kind of mindless vio- words, they were guidance. Today they excuse, no explanation, nor rationaliza- lence, constituents have a right to are a plea. And I know that we can tion in our democratic system. question their Members of Congress di- heed these words. What I do know is that GABBY is rectly. And we, who have been en- Madam Speaker, I ask that we keep fighting hard for her life, fighting with trusted with the honor of public serv- all the victims and the families of this the same tenacity that fueled her pas- ice, must never allow fear or threats to tragedy in our prayers, and I especially sion for public service, and I take com- undermine that fundamental principle. ask that we keep GABBY in our hearts. fort in the knowledge that my friend is Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- 1500 winning that battle. b fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- Like GABBY, we must never stop Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- utes to the gentleman from Colorado fighting for our great democracy and fornia. Madam Speaker, so we may be (Mr. COFFMAN). the time-honored traditions that keep able to equalize the remaining time, I Mr. COFFMAN of Colorado. Madam it strong. Neither we nor our constitu- reserve the balance of my time. Speaker, I rise today in support of ents, all 300-plus million of them, will Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield 2 House Resolution 32. be intimidated by the violent actions minutes to the gentleman from Penn- I had the opportunity to work with of the few. sylvania (Mr. ALTMIRE). Representative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS As Americans, we will come together Mr. ALTMIRE. On behalf of the over the last 2 years on the House and mourn for those who lost their Fourth Congressional District of west- Armed Services Committee, and I have lives that day, and we will honor the ern Pennsylvania, I rise to pay tribute always admired the gentlelady from survivors and heroes of this tragedy and offer our deepest sympathy and Arizona for her dedication to her con- that stood strong together in the face condolences to the 20 victims of the stituents and to our Nation. of madness. tragedy in Tucson. And as a member of This resolution before us today con- Madam Speaker, I join all my col- the class of 2006, I grew to know GABBY demns in the strongest possible terms leagues here today to express my sup- quite well, and we look forward to the the horrific attack which occurred last port for this resolution, and I know I day, hopefully very soon, when she will Saturday in Tucson, Arizona. This res- speak for all of my constituents in the join us back here in this Chamber. And olution offers the heartfelt condolences 13th District of Illinois when I say that I know her well enough to know that to the families, friends, and loved ones we share in the loss of our friends from her first priority on a day like today of those who were killed in that at- Arizona, and our thoughts and prayers would be to honor the 19 constituents tack. It expresses a hope for the rapid are with their families at this difficult who were taken and affected by this and complete recovery of those wound- time. tragedy, especially the six who lost ed in the shootings. It applauds the Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam their lives. bravery and quick thinking exhibited Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- So it is in that spirit that I honor, by those who prevented the gunman tleman from Missouri (Mr. CLAY). and we all honor in this Chamber, 63- from potentially taking more lives. It Mr. CLAY. I thank the gentleman year-old U.S. district judge John Roll, recognizes the service of the first re- from Arizona for yielding. a Pittsburgh native, an active Catholic sponders to race to the scene, and the Madam Speaker, I rise in support of parishioner; 9-year-old Christina health care professionals who tended to this bipartisan resolution and to offer Green, a Pennsylvania native, third the victims. my thoughts and prayers for the swift grader who had already told her par- This resolution stands firm in the be- healing and complete recovery of my ents she was looking forward to a ca- lief in a democracy in which all can

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:12 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00024 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.055 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H167 participate and in which intimidation Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- the tragic acts which have been re- and threats of violence cannot silence fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- counted by so many on the floor. the voices of any American. utes to the gentleman from Virginia We all step back in shock and horror This resolution honors the service (Mr. GOODLATTE). and sadness at what took place in Tuc- and leadership of Representative Mr. GOODLATTE. Madam Speaker, I son. It is an attack on the individuals GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, a distinguished am shocked and saddened by the sense- that clearly affects all of their lives. It Member of this House, as she coura- less act of violence that occurred Sat- is also an attack on what this country geously fights to recover. urday against Congresswoman is about. It is important that as we Madam Speaker, when adjourning GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, her staff and hope and pray for the recovery of the today, let us do so out of respect for members of the Tucson community. victims, and we hope and pray for un- the victims of this attack. Just 2 days before this horrific attack, derstanding for the families of the vic- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam GABBY joined me and many other Mem- tims, and we mourn the loss of those Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the dis- bers of Congress in reading aloud the who perished that day, it is important tinguished gentlewoman from Ohio U.S. Constitution on the House floor. It that we also recognize that they were (Ms. SUTTON). was my honor to yield to GABBY to great Americans who were there to ex- Ms. SUTTON. Madam Speaker, we read the First Amendment. And on ercise their right of assembly, and the know GABRIELLE GIFFORDS as a col- Saturday, she and those participating great American tradition which rep- league and a friend, a member of our in her Congress on the Corner event resents what this government is all congressional class of 2006, the major- were exercising their First Amendment about, which is we can sit down and ity makers. She is an outstanding pub- freedoms of free speech and to peace- have discussions. We can disagree with lic servant whose sole and constant ably assemble. each other. It is okay to disagree with commitment is to help make her dis- It is unconscionable that anyone each other. That is the strength of this trict and our Nation as great as it can would take violent action to deprive country. That is the idea behind Amer- be. someone of their life and liberty. Our ica, that we have the opportunity to The shooting that has left GABBY thoughts and prayers are with GABBY, look for the best ideas from wherever fighting to recover and that has her family, her staff and others who they come. claimed the lives of her outreach direc- were affected by Saturday’s tragic When it comes to public service, it tor, Gabe Zimmerman, and five other events in Tucson. While this tragedy would be good for all of us to recognize innocent victims was horrific and stun- serves as an unfortunate reminder of the ideals of our colleague, GABBY GIF- ning. Our thoughts and prayers go out evil actions, it must also remind us of FORDS. She was a good friend, a good colleague, someone who had the right to GABBY, her husband, Mark, and their the good in people as we hear the sto- ideas and motivations when she first family and to all of the victims and ries of the heroes of that day, people got to Congress, and continues to rep- their families. who gave their lives, people who saved resent those motivations. She is some- In recent days the Nation has learned other lives. one who is smart, articulate, looking much about GABBY and her commit- We as Members of Congress cannot to solve problems, and someone who ment to kindness and service. We’ve allow this senseless act of violence that knew how to be compassionate for her learned also of other extraordinary occurred against Congresswoman GIF- Americans present on that day. We constituents. FORDS to deter us from our jobs or I think everybody in this well prob- learned of Christina Taylor Green, a deter the American people from exer- ably knows a story where GABBY talked child full of grace born on 9/11, taken cising their precious freedoms. away far too soon but who will be re- to them about her constituents in Tuc- membered always not only by her b 1510 son and an issue that mattered to her. beautiful family, but by a grieving Na- I read again the words that Ms. GIF- That is what impresses me about Rep- tion that glimpsed her spirit, leaving FORDS read on the floor on Thursday. resentative GIFFORDS. It is a model her goodness impressed forever on our Amendment I: ‘‘Congress shall make that I think we can all remember and collective memory. no law respecting an establishment of continue to follow as we do our best for America has learned of Gabe Zim- religion, or prohibiting the free exer- our constituents. Madam Speaker, I close by saying I merman, a faithful public servant who cise thereof; or abridging the freedom wish all the best to the families, the used his life to make a difference in his of speech, or of the press; or the right victims, and our thoughts and prayers country and for his community; and of of the people peaceably to assemble, are with them. Judge Roll, husband and father, com- and to petition the Government for a Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- mitted to justice and the rule of law; of redress of grievances.’’ fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- Dorothy Morris, beloved wife of George Madam Speaker, I don’t know if Ms. utes to the gentleman from South GIFFORDS spoke on the floor after that. Morris, who also was critically wound- Carolina (Mr. DUNCAN). ed as he tried to shield her from the Those may have been the last words Mr. DUNCAN of South Carolina. bullet; and of Phyllis Schneck, loving she uttered on the floor of the House. I Madam Speaker, let me preface my re- mother of three and beloved grand- join my colleagues in praying that we marks by saying I barely know GABBY. mother of seven; and of Dorwan Stod- will see her again on this floor exer- As a freshman Member of the House, I dard, who acted with great love in giv- cising her precious freedoms. was sworn in last week with a lot of ing his life to save his wife. God bless her and all of the victims colleagues I hope to get to know over We remember these extraordinary of this tragedy. the coming days. But I rise today in people and the others who were in- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam concert with my friends and colleagues jured, and we remember the heroes who Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- on both sides of the aisle to express the came to the aid of fellow citizens, these tleman from Utah (Mr. MATHESON). sadness and grief that all in our coun- ordinary yet great Americans reflect- Mr. MATHESON. Madam Speaker, on try feel over the loss of life in Tucson ing the best of our Nation and its citi- Saturday morning in Tucson, it started this past weekend. zenry. And we join together today to out in a very good way. It started out The citizens of South Carolina mourn condemn this violent rampage. with a number of people who wanted to with our Nation, and we lift up in pray- But let us also join together to ex- engage in one of the great American er the family and friends of the victims press our appreciation for those who of- traditions, a tradition of our govern- in Arizona. Much of the coverage and fered themselves up in service, like ment which is that we have a discus- attention has been centered around our GABBY, Gabe and Judge Roll, and all sion of ideas. That is what America is wounded colleague, GABBY. My family who were there participating in our about, a competition of ideas. And so and I join in praying for her healing, representative Republic. Let us reach we had Congresswoman GIFFORDS and and for the others who have been out one to another in common purpose. we had her staff and we had members wounded. It has been said, God has not called us of the community gather. That is a I also want to celebrate the lives of to see through each other, but to see positive start to that day. Of course the six who were lost: 9-year-old Chris- each other through. Let it be so. that positive start was destroyed by tina Taylor Green, an inspiration to us

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:12 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00025 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.058 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H168 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 all; Judge John Roll; congressional think that we should ever remove any- best you can. I will continue to dis- staffer Gabriel Zimmerman; Pastor thing from the table as it relates to our agree with you when and as needed. I Dorwan Stoddard; Dorothy Morris; and liberties and our freedoms.’’ am just one man, but all of us citizens Phyllis Schneck. ‘‘Don’t retreat, reload!’’ can only do what we can do. While we mourn their loss, we also The SPEAKER pro tempore. The ‘‘I, for one, will never threaten, en- remember what they meant to their time of the gentleman has expired. courage or resort to any violence what- families, their friends, and to their Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the soever while debating, disputing, and communities. I join with all of my fel- gentleman an additional 30 seconds. arguing politics. For whatever tiny low Americans in honoring their lives Mr. DINGELL. I thank the gen- weight I count for in the great sea of and in praying that God’s comfort may tleman. Americans, I want you to feel safe from rest upon their families. May God bless I would observe, we saw the district any harm. them and may He continue to bless of GABRIELLE GIFFORDS had crosshairs ‘‘Make your decisions, and vote your America. put on it. As a lifetime rifleman and votes in Congress—please try and not Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam shooter, I know what crosshairs signify be such an idiot Republican about it— Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the dean when you put them on somebody, and I and know that you are safe in the of the Congress, the distinguished gen- know what happened. Third District for all of your life if I tleman from Michigan (Mr. DINGELL). One other quotation: ‘‘If ballots don’t shall have any say in the matter. (Mr. DINGELL asked and was given work, bullets will.’’ ‘‘Thanks for all the work that you permission to revise and extend his re- So here we have a denigration of the do. Most sincerely . . . ’’ marks.) great debate and the system of govern- That’s a message that I know GABBY would want us to embrace and one that Mr. DINGELL. I thank my dear ment of ours where threats are made. would not only give her resolve but friend for yielding me this time. Members of this body have a duty to would, hopefully, attract her sense of Madam Speaker, I rise, as do all of speak out, as do members of the media my colleagues, with sincere condo- humor as well. who have been saying these kinds of I reserve the balance of my time. lences to the families who lost loved things and leading us into a time when Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam ones in the horrific events of last Sat- we create a threat not just to the lives Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- urday. The victims amongst them were and well-being of our Members but also tlewoman from Ohio (Ms. FUDGE). a young student, a number of congres- to the lives and well-being of this coun- Ms. FUDGE. I thank the gentleman sional staff members, one of our dear try and its debates. for yielding. friends and colleagues who has served Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Madam Speaker, it is with a heavy with distinction and remarkable abil- fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield myself heart I stand today to support this res- ity and grace, and an outstanding Fed- such time as I may consume. olution and to encourage Congress- eral judge. Madam Speaker, last week GABBY woman GABBY GIFFORDS, her family During my career in Congress, I have GIFFORDS did speak the words of the and all victims of the Arizona shoot- witnessed horrific events: the assas- First Amendment here on the floor. ing. I am in prayer for their well-being, sinations of President Kennedy and They talk about the right of citizens of their healing and their peace. Martin Luther King and Robert Ken- the United States to come and plead GABBY and I served together on the nedy. I have seen firsthand anger their case to their Members of Con- Science and Technology Committee, brought on by landmark life-changing gress and to seek the redress of their and we lived in the same DC apartment legislation such as the civil rights bill. grievances. I think our Founding Fa- building. I learned of her passion for Like other Members, I have found the thers anticipated that we would be in- people and for her commitment to current state of affairs is also some- volved in robust and vigorous debate, service. In her honor, I call for a return what new to me. but they also hoped that we would uti- to compassion and an abandonment of One of my colleagues, as we were lize some sense of civility as we did so. hate-laden rhetoric. going to the memorial service, ob- I would like to read an e-mail that I Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., said, served to me that he had as a judge received in my office from a con- ‘‘Returning violence for violence mul- sent large numbers of people off to jail, stituent that I think would bring a tiplies violence, adding deeper dark- but he had never been as concerned smile to the lips of GABBY GIFFORDS, ness to a night already devoid of stars. about his own personal safety and that and it responds in some way to what Darkness cannot drive out hate; only of his family as he is today. Our Found- the gentleman from Michigan has just love can do that.’’ ing Fathers wanted our system of gov- said. If I could speak directly to the Amer- ernment to be a vigorous one, full of These are those words: ican people, I would ask them to com- enthusiastic and vibrant debate. But I ‘‘Dear Representative LUNGREN: I bat this great darkness with love, not don’t believe that they wanted to see write to share with you my feelings with fear. I would ask them to combat the kind of debate and discussion that upon hearing the news of the terrible this great darkness with a tide of hope we are seeing both in this place and in shooting in Tucson, Arizona. I find I and faith and perseverance and to un- other places of public assembly. am overwhelmed by emotions. In the derstand our unity. I want to read a few of the state- past, and I suspect in the future, I have Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- ments that I have seen that I find to be disagreed with you on many of the po- fornia. I reserve the balance of my pretty awful. Here is one: litical things that you have said and time. ‘‘People are really looking toward done. I have voted against you. I have Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam those Second Amendment remedies and even felt and expressed frustration and Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- saying, my goodness, what can we do to anger about you. I wish now to state tleman from Missouri (Mr. CARNAHAN). turn this country around? I’ll tell you, that if unlikely circumstances arose Mr. CARNAHAN. Madam Speaker, I the first thing we need to do is to take and I were in a position to protect you rise today to recognize and lift up in (blank) out.’’ That blank is for the from physical attack, I would do what- our prayers my friend and colleague name of the person. ever I possibly could to preserve your from Arizona, Congresswoman GABBY The next one: ‘‘I want people in safety and your person at whatever GIFFORDS; the dedicated public serv- (blank) armed and dangerous on this risk to myself. ants on her staff and the citizens en- issue of the energy tax because we need gaged in the most fundamental prac- to fight back.’’ b 1520 tice of our American democracy— ‘‘I want to kill (blank) with a shov- ‘‘Our democracy and freedom cannot meeting with their Representatives at el.’’ survive if elected officials feel threat- a Congress on Your Corner public ‘‘Every night I get down on my knees ened and find themselves having to event. In the aftermath of this horrific and pray (blank) will burst into consider their physical safety as they attack, we have learned a lot about the flames.’’ make the decisions and fill the respon- lives and actions of the victims and he- ‘‘Our Nation was founded on violence. sibilities of office. Please continue to roes of last Saturday. They reflect the The option is on the table. I don’t do your job as a Member of Congress as very best of America.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 02:41 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00026 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.061 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H169 GABBY not only spoke out regarding or who were injured will hold a special Madam Speaker, I rise today in mem- the importance of government by the place in our hearts, thoughts, and pray- ory of the victims and in support of my people, but she lived it every day. Last ers. colleague from Arizona, her staff, the week, I sat here on this floor of the We cannot let this random act of hei- loved ones of the victims, and those House, in line with GABBY and our col- nous violence deter us from our duty to who bravely and skillfully responded to leagues, as we read the U.S. Constitu- serve our constituents, and I know we the attack. tion. The section that she read from will move forward together as a strong- My freshmen colleagues and I have this very podium was the First Amend- er united House. only been here for a few short days, but ment, which protects the right of the Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam in Representative GIFFORDS we see the people to peaceably assemble and to Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- temperament and dedication needed to petition the government for a redress tlewoman from Pennsylvania (Ms. be good representatives of the people. of grievances. SCHWARTZ). She embodies these qualities and is an Ms. SCHWARTZ. Madam Speaker, I remember thinking to myself what example for everyone here in the peo- last Saturday in Tucson and across the an ideal section for GABBY to read be- ple’s House. cause of her great example as an en- country, so many Americans, including myself, were horrified and deeply sad- Let us not forget the personal side of gaged public servant and as truly being this tragedy. Those lost include two a Representative who stays close to the dened by the mass shooting at a con- gressional outreach event hosted by dedicated public servants, a devoted people. great-grandmother and a loving wife, a U.S. Representative GABRIELLE GIF- This resolution before us today is heroic husband whose last action was necessary and appropriate but, by FORDS. The senselessness, the violence and the magnitude of death and injury protecting his wife, and a 9-year-old in- itself, will not be long remembered. terested in public service. They will all What will be remembered is our re- were stunning and alarming. It is a personal tragedy. It is a na- be missed. solve, our unified national resolve, to tional tragedy. It is heartbreaking and In the wake of this tragedy, we find stand against extreme and divisive wrenching because we all share in the solace and we find power in prayer. My rhetoric and against building barriers pride of our representative democracy. prayers are for the families of the vic- between citizens and their Representa- Members reaching out to their con- tims, for the speedy recovery of Con- tives that would weaken our democ- stituents and constituents having the gresswoman GIFFORDS and all others racy and diminish our way of life. An opportunity formally and informally to who were wounded. I pray for law en- attack on one citizen, while engaging talk to their Representatives of Con- forcement investigating this cowardly in our representative democracy, is an gress is at the core of our responsibil- attack. I pray for the medical workers, attack on all citizens and the very ities and is a value we all hold as that their work heals those who have foundation of our democracy. Americans. So even as we mourn, as been injured. I pray for this House, its Let us resolve, in honor of all the vic- Americans, we cannot allow this to di- leaders, fellow Members and their tims in Tucson, that every Representa- minish or deter our civic interactions. staffs. And I pray for our country, ask- tive and every citizen continue to meet I ask for my colleagues to join to- ing God for His blessings during this on corners across America to work gether in honoring those who were time of grief. through our differences, to find com- killed. My thoughts and my deepest This attack hits each of us in a per- mon ground and to make progress sympathies are with them and with sonal way, but we must resolve to working together. their loved ones. move forward, representing the men To GABBY and every person impacted And, to GABBY, GABBY is our col- and women who sent us here to do our by this tragedy, we resolve today to al- league and she is our friend. I share in Nation’s work. ways be in your corner. acknowledging and honoring her com- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam mitment to public service and her prin- fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- cipled leadership on behalf of her con- utes to the gentleman from Ohio (Mr. tleman from New Jersey (Mr. PAYNE). stituents. She has a deep passion for LATTA). (Mr. PAYNE asked and was given who we are as Americans and for work- Mr. LATTA. I thank the gentleman permission to revise and extend his re- ing to find that common ground to for yielding. marks.) meet our Nation’s challenges. Her Madam Speaker, I rise on this sad Mr. PAYNE. Madam Speaker, I rise inner strength, determination, and her day to join my colleagues in recog- to express my sincere condolences to good spirit are all serving her well as nizing the lives of those affected by the the families of the victims of this she struggles to recover from her horrible tragedy in Tucson, Arizona, senseless tragedy and to the family of wounds. Reports from her doctors have this past weekend. our colleague, Congresswoman GABBY As we reflect on this tragic event, been remarkably positive. GIFFORDS. I hope and pray for her So my heartfelt thoughts and prayers the one thing that must be remem- quick recovery. And to the people of are with GABBY and with all those in- bered is that our colleague from Ari- the Eighth Congressional District of jured, and I wish them swift and full zona, Congresswoman GIFFORDS, was Arizona, we know what you’re going recoveries. I extend those thoughts and simply doing her job, a job that she through: the life of a 9-year-old who prayers to her husband, Mark; to all loves to do. Meeting with her constitu- wanted to be a student council rep- the families and friends of the victims; ents and providing them with assist- resentative and was elected to that, to GABBY’s staff; and to all those af- ance is the basic duty of any Member Christina Taylor Green; Federal Judge fected by this senseless shooting. John Roll, father and grandfather; of Congress. The best and only way for I love this country deeply and the Phyllis Schneck, a former Jerseyite Members of Congress to carry out their values we all share. It is my hope that who still loved the New York Giants oaths is to be with, listen to, and see our Nation will come together to honor who, as you may know, play in New what our constituents are experi- those who perished and to affirm our Jersey; Gabriel Zimmerman, com- encing. The nameplates on the front of commitment to move forward in a way mander of outreach, who did such a our offices read ‘‘Representative.’’ Con- that allows us to voice our differences great job for her; and two 76-year-olds, gresswoman GIFFORDS was doing just and to debate the solutions to our chal- Dorothy Morris and Dorwan Stoddard, as we do day in and day out—rep- lenges while respecting our shared love who shielded his wife so that she would resenting our citizens at home and here and dedication to our great Nation. in Washington. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- live. The loss of life and injury suffered by fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- I thank the leadership for bringing the victims will always be remembered utes to the gentleman from Arkansas forth this resolution, first acknowl- by this body. Whether it was Federal edging the victims of the tragic shoot- (Mr. GRIFFIN). Judge John Roll; Gabe Zimmerman, ing in Tucson, Arizona, and also con- Congresswoman GIFFORDS’ staff mem- b 1530 demning the act of violence which was ber; or 9-year-old Christina Taylor Mr. GRIFFIN of Arkansas. I thank a product of hatred that threatens the Green, all of those who lost their lives the gentleman for yielding me time. democracy of this Nation in which all

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:12 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00027 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.072 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H170 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 can participate and in which intimida- and two others were wounded. We pray them just today, but they’ll need them tion and threats of violence cannot si- for their recovery and for Gabe’s fam- in the weeks, the months, and the lence the voices of any American. Con- ily and friends in this time of tragedy. years to come. A pain that will never gresswoman GIFFORDS, her staff mem- The efforts of her intern, Daniel Her- leave their hearts. bers, and constituents were exercising nandez, may very well have saved Second, thankfulness. We sure thank this very privilege on Saturday, Janu- GABBY’s life, and we will always be God for GABBY’s remarkable recovery ary 8, as well as the right afforded to grateful for his quick actions. and pray that her recovery continues all of us under the First Amendment of We also pray for the other victims of in a speedy way and in a way that the Constitution. this unspeakable act of violence: for causes her to recover to the point It is ironic that gun violence has, Christina Taylor Green, Dorothy Mor- where she can return to this House and throughout our history, brought down ris, Phyllis Schneck, Dorwan Stoddard, work with us again. leaders—Abraham Lincoln, 150 years and Judge John Roll. We pray for swift And I think of patience and wisdom— ago, who said all people should be free; and fair justice for them as well. and I’m addressing the Speaker but our President, John F. Kennedy in 1963, As we stand here today, Democrats asking the Members of this body to during that time; his brother, Bobby and Republicans, we are steadfast in think about patience and wisdom in a Kennedy, 5 years later; Mohandas Gan- our determination to keep representing moment because first of all, let’s re- dhi, who brought India into independ- our constituents. We will not let the spect the investigation that’s being ence; Tom Mboya, a Kenyan who tragic events in Tucson change the way conducted by the law enforcement offi- talked about a united Africa; Yitzhak we represent the people. We will in- cers across this country, the Federal, Rabin, who, if he had lived, I think stead look to Saturday’s heroes as a re- local, and State agencies. Let’s respect there would be peace in the Middle minder of the real strength that is their continued efforts in weeding East; and then, of course, Dr. Martin America. through the information that they’re Luther King. As Americans, we know that adver- gathering. Let’s be patient when we The SPEAKER pro tempore. The sity, however tragic, makes us stronger think about legislation and laws that time of the gentleman has expired. and brings us closer together. That is we might be passing that could inhibit Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the what GABBY would want. We look for- that investigation or maybe even in- gentleman an additional 30 seconds. ward to the day we welcome her back hibit some of the freedoms that we Mr. PAYNE. So as we think about to this Chamber. God bless America today enjoy, patience in allowing them the tragedy of so many outstanding and all her citizens hurting in the wake to gather the needed information Americans who have lost their lives, I of this tragedy. where we can base good decisions on implore each and every one of us to Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam building good laws that protect the continue in the spirit of unity, support, Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- citizens of this great Nation. and love that often overflows during tleman from Maryland (Mr. SARBANES). And lastly hope. Hope, which is a tragic events. May we continue in such Mr. SARBANES. I thank the gen- thing we all hold near and dear to our spirits to prevent further acts, for we tleman for yielding. hearts, hope that this country con- all know that only love drives out ha- In the last few days, I have run into tinues to maintain its freedom, hope in tred and only good drives out evil. scores of people of my district, the the American people, hope that we can Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Third District of Maryland, who have all stand together after this tragedy. If fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- expressed their shock and their sadness there is a silver lining in this tragedy, utes to the gentleman from Texas (Mr. at the events that occurred in Tucson it is the hope and the strength and the BRADY). last weekend. On their behalf and for trust that the people of this country Mr. BRADY of Texas. Madam Speak- myself, I want to express our deep con- can build together to keep this country er, we gather here today to honor the dolences to the families of all those free. victims and the heroes of the tragic who were victimized by this tragedy. Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam shooting that took place in Arizona A word about GABBY GIFFORDS, our Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- this past weekend. colleague. She and I came in together tleman from New York (Mr. ENGEL). GABBY GIFFORDS is one of the best in the same class. We began in January Mr. ENGEL. I want to first say I’m so this institution has to offer. I have had of 2007. She is everything that a Rep- proud of all of my colleagues on both the honor of working with her on resentative in this body should be. She sides of the aisle who have spoken NASA issues in support of human is thoughtful. She is hardworking. She today. GABBY has brought us all to- spaceflight. is compassionate and, to a fault, she is gether as never before. GABBY embodies the type of public attentive to the concerns of her con- I’m a good friend of GABBY GIFFORDS. servant many of us strive to be: smart, stituents. That is why she was there at She’s a good friend of mine. I first met kind, and dedicated, fulfilling her duty that supermarket last Saturday. her before she ran for Congress when a representing her constituents. That’s We pray for her speedy recovery. We mutual friend said to me, You ought to why she was holding a public meeting pray for the recovery of all those who meet this lady. She wants to run for on the first weekend of the new ses- survived this terrible event. We mourn Congress and wants some advice. sion. the loss of those who perished, and we Would you give it to her? I called I pray for her strong recovery and for send our thoughts and prayers to their GABBY. She called me back. We spoke. her family and staff, and I look forward families. And she decided to run, and we’ve been to working with her once more in this Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- good friends ever since. body. fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- My colleagues have all said it today: I think in the darkest moments in utes to the gentleman from Wash- GABBY is as kind and as sweet and as our history we also see the brightest ington, the former distinguished sheriff nice a person as you could ever meet. stars. Those stars are the men who of King County, Mr. REICHERT. She’s considerate, she’s thoughtful, wrestled the gunman to the floor, the Mr. REICHERT. I thank the gen- she’s caring, smart, hardworking. It’s woman who kicked the magazine away, tleman. hard to believe that anyone would the loved ones who protected their Madam Speaker, there are a few want to harm her. She was doing what spouses and children, the intern who words that have touched me over the she always did—going out in service of had enough first aid training to put last few days that I would like to her constituents, helping her constitu- pressure on GABBY’s head wound, the share. First, thankfulness, thoughtful- ents, going out to a shopping center. first responders who responded to that ness, prayerfulness, patience, wisdom, You know, I have another connection scene, and the medical teams that got and hope. with GABBY. My son Jonathan attended most of the victims into the operating the University of Arizona, just grad- rooms in under 38 minutes. b 1540 uated this year. And she and I spoke GABBY’s staff so clearly reflects her First we should remember those who many times about Tucson. I have been character and leadership. Gabe Zim- have lost loved ones, keep them in your to Tucson many, many times in these merman lost his life fulfilling his duty, thoughts and prayers. They’ll not need past 5 years. I’ve even shopped in the

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:36 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00028 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.075 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H171 Safeway, tragically, where the gunman gentlelady who so proudly advocates Responsibility for this weekend’s shot all of the people, including GABBY. on their behalf here in the United shooting in Tucson rests solely on the You know, GABBY said something to States House of Representatives shoulders of the madman who pulled me this past August as we recessed. I Among the fallen were Phyllis the trigger. However, it is our responsi- served as the chair of the Western Schneck, a great-grandmother; Doro- bility, as citizens in the world’s strong- Hemisphere Subcommittee of the thy Morris, a devoted wife; Gabe Zim- est democracy, to seriously consider House Foreign Affairs Committee and merman, a public servant; John Roll, the impact that the accessibility of GABBY served on my subcommittee, an honorable judge; Christina Taylor high-capacity weapons and the in- and we talked about having a field Green, a 9-year-old girl who just want- creased vitriol of public dialogue have hearing in Tucson. And when I said to ed to learn more about government; on impressionable or unstable individ- her, Let’s try to do it in September or and Dorwan Stoddard, a man who gave uals and our society as a whole. October of this year, she said to me, his life protecting and saving his wife. For all of the pain and agony caused No. You know, the speech, the lan- They are all in our thoughts and pray- by this tragedy, it could also be a turn- guage has gotten very hostile and peo- ers. ing point for the country. Already lead- ple’s attitudes toward Washington have Our Founding Fathers made no mis- ers from across the political spectrum been very hostile, and I don’t really take when they included the right to are discussing the vital need to turn want to do anything that would show peaceably assemble among the first te- down the rhetorical volume and dial that I’m the Washington person. That’s nets of democracy. The inexplicable vi- back extremism for the sake of our Na- how bad the atmosphere is. olence of last Saturday is a stark, trag- tion. I couldn’t help but thinking about ic reminder that we must never waver b 1550 that when I heard about the shooting in our steadfast support of the First We all are praying for GABBY’s recov- on Saturday. Amendment and the precious freedoms ery and for the families of those who The SPEAKER pro tempore. The it affords us every day. were killed and wounded Saturday. Let time of the gentleman has expired. As our colleague, GABBY, and all of each of us resolve to do all we can to Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the those directly affected by this tragedy protect our democracy from those who gentleman an additional 30 seconds. continue to heal from Saturday’s in- would deny and subvert it. Mr. ENGEL. You know, in this coun- comprehensible events, let us remem- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- try we do our political discourse with ber the victims and their loved ones in fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- balance, not bullets. And although the our thoughts and in our prayers and in utes to the gentleman from New York assassin tried to murder a U.S. Con- our actions. As those of us here have (Mr. GRIMM). gresswoman, he really was trying to known, and as people all throughout Mr. GRIMM. I thank the gentleman stick a stake or murder American de- the Nation are witnessing, GABBY GIF- from California for yielding. mocracy. All of us on both sides of the FORDS is a fighter. Let’s keep in our Madam Speaker, I thank you for the aisle are not going to let him. We are prayers the hope that she once again opportunity to come to the House floor going to continue to do what we’ve joins us back here on the floor of this, to honor the victims of the tragic done before—going out in the street, the people’s House. shooting in Arizona. The six individ- meeting people, taking care, and help- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam uals killed and the 14 wounded, includ- ing our constituents. We are going to Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gen- ing Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIF- continue to attend town hall meetings tleman from Kentucky (Mr. YARMUTH). FORDS, were victims of a heinous and and do the kinds of things that GABBY Mr. YARMUTH. Madam Speaker, despicable act of violence. On behalf of would want us to do. Congresswoman GABBY GIFFORDS is one the constituents of the 13th District of I look forward to GABBY returning of the kindest, most thoughtful and New York, I want to extend my deepest here. I look forward to working with hardest working elected officials any- sympathies to the victims, their fami- her again. GABBY GIFFORDS is the best where. It is a shame that it took a des- lies and friends, and to the staff of Con- America has to offer, and we honor her picable act to shine this bright spot- gresswoman GIFFORDS. We will con- and all of the other victims of the light on GABBY. She is what virtually tinue to keep them in our thoughts and shooting today. every American would say they want prayers. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- in a Member of Congress—smart, open, As we come together as a Congress fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- friendly, intellectually honest, and and a country to mourn and reflect, I urge my colleagues not to lose sight of utes to the gentleman from Louisiana very brave. She cares passionately what we have been called here to do (Mr. SCALISE). about all of her constituents and, as and what we are here to accomplish. Mr. SCALISE. Madam Speaker, it is she was demonstrating on Saturday, Congresswoman GIFFORDS was doing with a heavy heart today that I join what they think. the exact thing I hope we will all con- my colleagues in paying respects to the Speaker BOEHNER was absolutely cor- tinue to do—going out into her commu- victims of the senseless tragedy that rect when he said an attack on one nity and taking the time to meet with, Member of Congress is an attack on all, took place last weekend in Arizona. I to talk to, and most of all, to listen to but Saturday’s attack was more than extend my prayers to the families of her constituents. This is what keeps us those who lost their lives, to the an assault on a Congresswoman. It was connected to the heartbeat of our dis- wounded, and the recovering, and to an attack on American democracy. trict. This is what allows us to effec- our dear colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS. GABBY was doing what her job title im- tively serve our constituents and our GABBY is an energetic Member of plied—listening to her constituents at country. This is what democracy is all Congress who works and enjoys and an event set up like hundreds before, about. This is what we have been elect- treats all of those she meets with de- conducting the business essential to ef- ed to do. cency and kindness. I was here with fective representation. Dozens of citi- Additionally, I implore my col- her just last week while we read the zens were actively participating in our leagues to resist the innate temptation United States Constitution on the floor democracy, asking questions and ex- to enact reactionary legislation or call of this House. GABBY so eloquently pressing themselves. The attack on for extreme measures that could ad- read from that bedrock of our democ- GIFFORDS was an attack on them as versely impact the institution of the racy the First Amendment. In a direct well. House of Representatives. Giving due reflection of her passion for interacting Earth-shaking tragedies sometimes respect to the Capitol Police and the with those she represents, GABBY read create the opportunity for our society FBI, we should allow them to do their of the established right of the people to to have a reasoned discussion on criti- jobs, to thoroughly investigate, and af- peaceably assemble. cally important issues that we often ford them the time to offer us rec- All of those gathered in Tucson on cannot have under normal cir- ommendations for our safety and that Saturday were engaging in what should cumstances. In the wake of catas- of our staff and constituents. have been a peaceful activity that is trophe, our hope is that such a discus- I hope that moving forward we will absolutely fundamental to our form of sion can strengthen our democracy and not let this incident create distance be- government—spending time with the help our Nation emerge stronger. tween ourselves and those we have

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:36 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00029 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.078 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H172 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 been sent here to represent. We cannot Christina attended Representative GIF- Phyllis Schneck, Dorothy Morris, and let this senseless, this completely FORDS’ Congress on Your Corner event Dorwan Stoddard. senseless act of violence keep us from because she cared about her commu- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam serving our districts as effectively as nity, and a neighbor thought she would Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the dis- possible. enjoy it. tinguished gentleman from New York The SPEAKER pro tempore. The But while this tragedy has extin- (Mr. ISRAEL). time of the gentleman has expired. guished lives of promise, it has also re- Mr. ISRAEL. I thank the gentleman Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- vealed some incredible heroes. Today from Arizona for yielding. fornia. I yield the gentleman an addi- we stand shoulder to shoulder and pray Madam Speaker, the violence in Tuc- tional 30 seconds. for the speedy recovery of our friend son and the shooting of my very good Mr. GRIMM. As we move forward, let and the other wounded victims. friend GABBY GIFFORDS is not a time us remember that, while we should re- The SPEAKER pro tempore. The for partisanship and it is not a time for main aware of the danger around us, time of the gentleman has expired. politics. It is a time for reflection, and we cannot live in fear or isolate our- Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. I yield the I have three brief reflections to share selves in a bubble. Today, I mourn with gentleman an additional 30 seconds. with my colleagues. my colleagues and the Nation, and I Mr. PETERS. And I just say to all, I knew GABBY pretty well. We will continue to pray for those lost and God bless the victims and their fami- weren’t best friends, but we were good to pray for Congresswoman GIFFORDS lies; God bless all those who are griev- friends. I was with her and her hus- and the others injured in the attack ing, and God bless America. band, Mark, on the day that Mark pro- and that they will have a full and Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- posed to her. We were in New York, and speedy recovery. fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- GABBY and I had several events to do. Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam utes to the distinguished gentleman And Mark kept asking if GABBY could Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the dis- from Texas, Dr. BURGESS. leave early, and I kept saying no. And tinguished gentleman from Michigan Mr. BURGESS. I thank the gen- finally, Mark said, There is no choice. (Mr. PETERS). tleman from California for yielding. She’s leaving early. Mr. PETERS. Madam Speaker, it is Madam Speaker, I stand today in I later learned that the reason that with a heavy heart that I take to the support of the resolution; I stand today she had to leave these events early was floor of the House today to pay tribute in support of the victims of the dev- because Mark took her to the Mer- to the fallen, but also to honor the he- astating events of last Saturday, and I chant Marine Academy in Kings Point roes, to express grief in the wake of stand today in honor of one of our own, and proposed to her. Most of my con- tragedy, but also to express my heart- Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. stituents now know GABBY GIFFORDS. felt gratitude to those who showed in- Congresswoman GIFFORDS was the Few know that this important day in credible bravery in the face of evil. youngest woman elected to the Arizona her life occurred on Long Island. Madam Speaker, I come to the floor State Senate and now, at the Federal Second reflection, I believe that of the House today to honor my col- level, continues to serve the constitu- GABBY would have been uncomfortable league and friend GABBY GIFFORDS, be- ents of her hometown with enthusiasm with the attention that she is getting cause I want every American to know and distinction. It was in this spirit of today and over the past several days. I that she exemplifies what every Amer- statesmanship that she participated in believe she would want Americans ican wants to see in their Member of her Congress on Your Corner event at more focused on the 9-year-old girl who Congress. The GABBY I know is smart the grocery store in Tucson, Arizona. was killed, on the Federal judge who and hard working. The GABBY that This event characterizes the Congress- was killed, on the congressional staffer southern Arizona knows is personable woman’s approach to her constituents. who lost his life, on the others who and accessible. The GABBY we all know She recognizes the importance of re- were killed and wounded. is dedicated and humble. maining open to the people—retail rep- And my final reflection is this: I be- GABBY takes her job representing Ar- resentation—absolutely necessary in lieve that we should reject the notion izona seriously. She works hard to ef- order to fully grasp the extent of the that GABBY’s colleagues in Congress fect change on the issues that matter needs and views of those she served. need to hide from our constituents, most to her southern Arizona constitu- Congresswoman GIFFORDS epitomizes that we should reduce our exposure. ents. We both served on the Committee the term ‘‘public servant,’’ under- This is not the time for us to hide from on Science and Technology in the last standing that she works for the people our constituents. This is the time for Congress, and I was privileged to be first, last, and always. us to reassert our connection with our able to collaborate with GABBY on her Congresswoman GIFFORDS was doing constituents. And this isn’t the time signature issue—solar energy develop- the work of the American people when for us to hide our opinions. ment. She worked tirelessly to create her life was threatened. And after she This is a time for us to reassert our not only clean energy for America, but recovers, I have no doubt that she will opinions, but to do it without vilifying also new jobs for Americans. return with that same energy and de- one another. There is a way to have We are both residents of border termination. opinions without necessarily demean- States, albeit different borders, and I I look forward to working with her ing one another. We have the right to was proud to cosponsor her legislation again. I had the opportunity to partner our opinions, but not to be called any to help give businesses the tools nec- with her on the Congressional Motor- more or less of an American with a dif- essary to enforce immigration stand- cycle Caucus in support of motorcycle ferent opinion. ards. I admired her strong commitment safety awareness, and I saw that en- Opinions and the expression of those to our national defense and her tireless ergy and enthusiasm firsthand. opinions are the essence of democracy. dedication to the men and women who One of our primary freedoms that our They are American. And it is fitting serve our country in uniform. But even forefathers upheld was the right to life. that GABBY GIFFORDS on this floor, at more than her legislative prowess, it is After years of fighting on behalf of oth- that podium last week, read the First her smile and friendly nature that ers, Congresswoman GIFFORDS must Amendment in the Constitution, which makes her a beloved figure here in the now fight for her own life. And let us talks about our right to have opinions. Halls of Congress as well as in her also remember the doctors and the home district. And we all pray for her nurses, the first responders who played b 1600 speedy recovery. such a pivotal role in preventing an We should continue to express those We also mourn the loss of those who even greater loss of life last Saturday. opinions but do it in a way that would were senselessly murdered while par- I will keep Congresswoman GIFFORDS make our children proud of us, do it in ticipating in the most fundamental and those who were injured and their a way that is respectful and tolerant. democratic tradition—talking with the families in my prayers. I also offer my That is exactly what GABBY GIFFORDS people who represent us; victims like 9- deepest condolences to the families of did while she was here, and it is ex- year-old Christina Taylor, who was Christina Taylor Green, U.S. District actly what she will do when she re- just elected to her student council. Judge John M. Roll, Gabe Zimmerman, turns.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:36 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00030 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.081 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H173 Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- plified that better than her. We know day’s shooting in Tucson and pray with fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- that. all of us for them and their families. utes to the gentleman from California The SPEAKER pro tempore (Mrs. This senseless tragedy has struck at (Mr. ROHRABACHER). EMERSON). The time of the gentleman the very foundation of the United Mr. ROHRABACHER. Madam Speak- has expired. States of America, attacking a rep- er, I rise in support of the resolution. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- resentative to Congress, a congres- The tragedy we discuss today is of fornia. I yield the gentleman 1 addi- sional staffer, innocent bystanders in enormous consequence to the families tional minute. front of a grocery store. But there were of those who were killed and wounded Mr. ROHRABACHER. Congress- heroes who showed up that day: the in- and, of course, our hearts go out to woman GIFFORDS and I were on sepa- tern, Daniel Hernandez, who came to them, especially to the member of our rate sides of a major issue, an issue of GABRIELLE GIFFORDS’ aid; the witnesses own family, congressional family, to great concern to me. I have been on the who immediately tried to help those the Giffords, but all those who were Science Committee for 22 years, and who were injured; the civilians who killed or wounded in this senseless vio- she was for a totally different approach bravely stopped the shooter from injur- lence that took place in Arizona. This, to the American space program than I ing and inflicting more harm on others; of course, is not just of great con- have been on. We had some very seri- the emergency room personnel; the sequence to them but of great con- ous debate on that issue. emergency personnel overall whose de- sequence to all of us. I will tell you not only was she kind cisive action saved other lives. These There are things that we must learn, and articulate, but she was brilliant— are the true examples of the spirit of and there are events like this that hap- which of course I didn’t necessarily what America is all about. pen that will help us shape what we want her to show that brilliance in her It’s important to remember that this will do in the future. One thing we arguments against my arguments. But was an outrageous act by a deranged must not let this do is to reduce the ac- I remember right here on this floor, individual. Despite all the talk about tual contact between the American after a major debate that we had, I tone and rhetoric, it’s important to re- people and their elected representa- walked over to her when the gavel member that we all on this House floor tives. went down and people were leaving, can disagree without being disagree- We will not let the acts of a de- and I said, you know, you did a great able. mented individual reduce the right of job for your position today. I really re- The fact is that as public officials, the American people to have direct spect you more than some of the people Madam Speaker, being accessible to contact with their Member of the on my side of the issue, because you the public is an important part of our House of Representatives, and we will were articulate, you took your respon- jobs, and we cannot let this tragedy not let this senseless act of violence di- sibility seriously, you have presented stop us from doing our important minish or in some way stampede us your arguments. I just want you to work. We are Members of the people’s into in some way diminishing the free- know how much I admire that in you. House, and the minute we start sepa- dom and reducing the freedom of the Keep it up and I know you will be rating ourselves from the people is the American people themselves. Speaker someday—and I shouldn’t say minute that we weaken our Republic. The events in Tucson remind us how Finally, let me just say there is a that to my colleagues over here. I don’t fragile our lives are. We pray again for positive lesson to be learned from this say that often to my colleagues on the tragic event, and that is we must make the victims and their families, and we other side of the aisle. remember what really matters and sure that we treat each other better But that’s the type of spirit that she here in Congress, and those of us who that civility should rule the day. had, and I would hope that we send Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- are active in the political arena need that message to GABBY and to the rest er, I yield 2 minutes to the gentle- to understand we need to be kinder to of the American people today. woman from Maine (Ms. PINGREE). each other. Even as we disagree with Mr. PASTOR of Arizona. Madam Ms. PINGREE of Maine. I thank my each other fervently on policy, there is Speaker, I yield myself such time as I colleague from Iowa for yielding the no reason for us to have insinuations may consume. time. about negative values of the person on On behalf of Congresswoman GABBY Madam Speaker, it’s hard, after a the other side of the argument. GIFFORDS, the families of the victims, long day like this when all of us are We need to make sure that we exem- the people recovering in Tucson and feeling so sad and discouraged about plify for the American people that peo- my fellow Arizonans, I want to express the challenges that have been faced by ple can disagree on fundamental issues, a sense of gratitude to all the Members GABBY and her family and others, to even have basic differences in value here who have spoken and will speak, actually think of anything that hasn’t systems and what their goal is for our for your prayers, for your condolences been said. But I want to reiterate what government, but still respect the other and your affection you have given all so many of my colleagues have said, so person’s opinion and treat the other of us. many of us who consider ourselves person with kindness and dignity. We thank you very much from the friends of GABBY, who are so proud of That’s one lesson that we need to learn bottom of our hearts. We hope that the work that she has done, who know and to make sure the American people some of the expressions you have given what a hard fighter GABBY is and hope see us as an example of that. of showing respect, more respect to that she continues to pull through Ronald Reagan used to say, be really each other, more love for each other every day. tough when it comes to policy but, and disagreeing, debating, but not I sit near GABBY on the Armed Serv- DANA, be really nice to people. Well, being disagreeable, will help us do the ices Committee, and I have never seen that’s how Ronald Reagan ended the business of this House. GABBY walk into a hearing room with- Cold War. He was really tough on com- Madam Speaker, I yield the balance out a pile of letters that she plans to munism, but he was very kind to those of my time to the distinguished gen- sign, a few things that she is going to people who worked in the Soviet tleman from Iowa (Mr. BRALEY), and I read, prepared to ask good questions Union, which later led to that disinte- ask unanimous consent that he be al- and keep her eye on the conversation gration. lowed to control that time. and the debate the whole time we are Today we need to be kinder to each The SPEAKER pro tempore. Without in there. That is just GABBY; she is al- other. We need to be respectful of the objection, the gentleman from Iowa ways working, she is always thinking. fact that people on the other side of (Mr. BRALEY) will control the time. issues are as intelligent as we are and There was no objection. b 1610 as moral as we are, but that doesn’t Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- You turn to her and ask her a ques- mean we shouldn’t use tough language fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- tion. She always has a smile or a little about those issues. Let’s be kinder to utes to the gentleman from Ohio (Mr. joke or is ready to make a plan for each other and let’s send that as a TIBERI). some kind of an outing or a field trip present, a get-well message to GABBY, Mr. TIBERI. Madam Speaker, I rise or something that we could all do to- because there is no one else that exem- today to honor the victims of Satur- gether. She is a wonderful colleague, as

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:36 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00031 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.086 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H174 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 we can see today, well respected by My friend, all of our friend, Arizona rying out the most central of our re- both sides of the aisle, well regarded by Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, sponsibilities as elected representa- all colleagues, whether they agree or has believed in that dream for her en- tives, as was already mentioned, and disagree, and highly well regarded back tire life. Today, she represents a bea- that is making ourselves available to in her home community where she had con of hope, perhaps ‘‘our’’ last best our constituents. That this horrific at- another hard-fought election but came hope, to restore some measure of civil- tack occurred in the middle of a gath- through. ity to the important public debates of ering that is the basis of our represent- Our thoughts and prayers are with our day. ative democracy is a reminder to us all her. I know GABBY is on the Armed This is not a time to be finger point- that we must all remain constantly Services Committee because she’s a ing. Rather, this is a time, in memory committed to upholding the principles fighter. She’s a fighter for the people of all those who died or who were in- upon which our great Nation was she represents, and I do believe she’s jured during this dark day in our his- founded. fighting in her hospital room today, tory, to start talking again like friends As we come together to offer our fighting for her life alongside her hus- and neighbors. prayers to all those involved, I hope band. Right now, we should be praying for that we will carry forward the senti- Our thoughts and prayers are with GABBY and all of the other victims of ment that so many have expressed in the others who died alongside where this horrible ordeal. We should be the last few days, including on the GABBY was lying, who came to that searching our soul as a Nation, asking floor of this House of Representatives, event and were injured, innocent vic- one important question, a question that our country’s commitment to pas- tims—a young woman and a staff mem- Abraham Lincoln confronted every sin- sionate debate is the heart of our de- ber who was dedicated. gle day of his Presidency: How have we mocracy, but that debate must also be Many of us realize when we take this allowed hateful rhetoric to paralyze rooted in civil discourse and mutual re- job on that we take a risk, but we often our national debates? spect. We can, and we should, debate forget the risk of those who serve with Yes, we all have different points of with vigor the pressing challenges fac- us, those young people who come out view, but we should discuss them, and ing our Nation, but we must do so in a and stand beside us, the risk that they we should debate them without resort- way that moves our country forward are also taking just to be with us ev- ing to name-calling or questioning and that is constructive. In part, that erywhere we go. each other’s motives. GABBY has al- will require us to recommit ourselves— I also want to mention someone else ways stood for civility. She is the most recommit ourselves—to civil discourse who I was asked to mention who wasn’t delightful and the kindest Member of and honest debate as well as to remain- appearing in the resolution that we Congress, and I think we’ve all said ing accessible to our constituents and talked about earlier today, but Dr. Ste- that. Her never-ending smile and her listening to all viewpoints. ven Rayle, a former emergency room unfailing willingness to work in our We are a Nation, I believe, that re- physician was just a few feet away Nation’s best interests have earned her jects violence. And on a day when we saw really the very worst of humanity, from GABBY when the shooting began. the respect of people everywhere. In the terrifying moments after the I, like all of my colleagues, cannot we also saw the very best: individuals shooting, Rayle was able to use his wait for the day when GABBY walks who were willing to lay down their back onto this floor and she joins us. trained first responder skills to triage lives to save others. Let those folks She is a strong woman with a very un- what I can only imagine was a terri- serve as our inspiration, and let us con- breakable spirit and a passion for life, tinue to keep all those affected in our fying scene. And we owe him a great her family, her friends, and our great thoughts and prayers and continue to deal of gratitude. Nation. The SPEAKER pro tempore. The move forward in America in a con- Let us all pray to give GABBY the time of the gentlewoman has expired. structive, positive, and mutually re- strength to carry her through the dif- Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield the gen- spectful manner. ficult days ahead. I believe with all of Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- tlewoman 30 additional seconds. my heart that GABBY was put on Earth fornia. Madam Speaker, I am privi- Ms. PINGREE of Maine. I just again by God to make a difference. And she leged to yield 2 minutes to the gen- want to thank Dr. Rayle for his her- has. I know, because she’s made a dif- tleman from California (Mr. MCCLIN- oism and for his being there with ference in my life. TOCK). GABBY in the first possible moments. So the next time that a debate heats Mr. MCCLINTOCK. I thank the gen- We owe him our gratitude, and every- up and threatens to get ugly, let’s re- tleman for yielding. one else who worked so hard to make member our responsibilities as leaders. Madam Speaker, I haven’t gotten to sure that people were safe as quickly as Let’s remember what Abraham Lincoln know GABRIELLE GIFFORDS very well possible at that scene. said. Let’s take a deep breath and yet, and I thank God that by His grace And I echo the remarks of my earlier ‘‘agree to disagree agreeably.’’ Let’s do I haven’t lost the chance to do so. I ANA OHRABACHER colleague, D R . I hope that for GABBY. didn’t know the Americans who came this all reminds us to think about how Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- to speak with her that day. But what I we speak, to think about how we speak er, I yield 2 minutes to the gentleman do know is that they gathered last Sat- with each other, how we conduct our from Iowa (Mr. LOEBSACK). urday to do something uniquely Amer- business, and how we move forward. Mr. LOEBSACK. I thank my col- ican. This is a solemn week. We will have league and friend from Iowa for recog- GABRIELLE GIFFORDS was reaching many solemn weeks ahead of us, and nizing me. out and listening to her employers, the we have a lot of work to do. Madam Speaker, I join my col- American people, and they had come to Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- leagues, my constituents, and all offer her their guidance, advice, and fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 3 min- Americans in mourning for those who counsel. In this respect, the attack on utes to the gentlewoman from Cali- lost their lives in this weekend’s hei- GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and her constitu- fornia, a distinguished presiding officer nous event and in praying for those, in- ents struck at the very heart of our of this body, Mrs. BONO MACK. cluding our dear friend and colleague, process of representative democracy, Mrs. BONO MACK. I thank the gen- Congresswoman GIFFORDS, who are that very point where the American tleman for yielding. fighting to recover. people communicate their views to Madam Speaker, I rise today to offer I have had the honor to serve with their elected representatives. That is a prayer for our Nation. President GABBY, like many in this body, on the the linchpin in the entire process of Abraham Lincoln, during the height of Armed Services Committee since we self-government. the Civil War and during a very low were both elected in 2006, and I’ve al- This was not only an attack on those point in American civility, once told a ways been struck by her intelligence who serve; it was an attack on every hushed crowd: ‘‘My dream is of a place and by her commitment to her con- citizen who steps forward to offer hon- and a time where America will once stituents. est advice and counsel and, yes, even again be seen as the last best hope of When she and her constituents were criticism to those they have selected to Earth.’’ attacked on Saturday, she was car- serve them and to serve the Nation.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 02:41 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00032 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.089 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H175 It is the nature and strength of many Members have said, and to speak situation. As we do, we must maintain participatory democracy to have sin- with one voice against the violence and our support for those seeking recovery cere and passionate differences of opin- the hate that claimed the lives of both and pray for the well-being of all those ion. But in moments like this, we see Republicans and Democrats, Americans involved. the very best of the American people all both young and old. Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- come forward. We put aside our dif- Our thoughts and our prayers today er, I am pleased to yield 2 minutes to ferences and disagreements, and we and since Saturday have been with the distinguished gentleman from Cali- stand together as one Nation, the GABBY, her family, as well as all of the fornia (Mr. BECERRA). American Nation; one race, the Amer- victims and their families affected by Mr. BECERRA. Madam Speaker, I ican race; one people, the American this terrible tragedy. It is now up to us thank the gentleman for yielding. people. Men and women of goodwill to move forward in the same spirit that To our friend and colleague, GABBY cease to be Republicans or Democrats. they have shown as they persevere GIFFORDS, to the victims and heroes in We suspend our political agendas; we through this terrible time. Tucson, and to all of their loved ones, silence the partisan recriminations, With that, it rests on us to be better. our thoughts and prayers are with you. and we stand together as Americans. As Mark’s brother said from space: It is You have won our hearts with your By doing so, we pay supreme honor to a peaceful planet. It looks peaceful. courage and example in these difficult our fellow citizens who were felled in Sadly, it is not; but we can do better. times. GABBY, knowing your ethic of the exercise of their rights and respon- We must do better. hard work, your tenacity and deter- sibilities as a free people. We salute the Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- mination, and knowing you as a fighter heroes who, without a moment’s hesi- fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- for what you believe in, I simply say to tation, rose to resist and stop this cra- utes to the gentleman from Pennsyl- you: keep at it, don’t stop. Fight, fight, ven and depraved attack, and we assure vania (Mr. THOMPSON). fight. And we look forward to seeing the world, as Lincoln said, that ‘‘gov- Mr. THOMPSON of Pennsylvania. you here and welcoming you here in ernment of the people, by the people, Madam Speaker, today our thoughts your House, the people’s House. for the people, shall not perish from and prayers are with all of those who Times like these make it unmistak- the Earth.’’ were taken from us last week in this ably clear how important second Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- horrific tragedy in Tucson, Arizona. chances are. Not everyone in Tucson er, I am pleased to yield 2 minutes to Our Nation stands with Congress- will have that second chance. How the distinguished gentleman from woman GIFFORDS in her recovery, her lucky we are that we can pick up the Texas, another colleague from the family, her staff, and all of those who baton for them and finish the job of Armed Services Committee, Mr. REYES. have been impacted by this tragic seeking justice and making our democ- event, including the family of Gabe racy a more perfect Union. b 1620 Zimmerman, GIFFORDS’ director of America, this is our second chance. Mr. REYES. I thank my colleague for community outreach, and Federal This is our opportunity to shine. Let us yielding. Judge John Roll, who both died during make our work, whether here as duly Madam Speaker, today I rise on be- the shooting. sworn Representatives of the people or half of the people of the 16th Congres- We also stand with Christina Taylor as the media or as responsible citizens sional District of Texas to express our Green who lost her life that day. Chris- of America, let us make our work community’s profound sadness in the tina had hoped to go to Penn State one count. wake of Saturday’s senseless act of vio- day and pursue a career of helping oth- It is our turn to show courage and to lence that claimed the lives of six ers. Penn State is one of the top public be an example as we move forward, Americans and has left our esteemed universities in the country, and it is lo- doing our part to build a better Amer- colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS, fighting cated in my congressional district. I ica. We owe that to GABBY and the for her life and has affected 13 others. share those same aspirations and have good people of Arizona. Let’s honor Ironically enough, last week on no doubt that Christina would have them by hitting that second chance out Thursday we had a meeting of the Bor- achieved her dreams and been success- of the park. der Caucus. GABBY came to that meet- ful in the career path of her choosing. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- ing, and we discussed the agenda for I offer my deepest condolences to her fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- the 112th Congress. I can tell you that family. utes to the gentleman from Michigan she is a tireless champion on border While this tragedy reminds us of how (Mr. HUIZENGA). issues. She is an incredible Member, fragile life is, it also shows us what we Mr. HUIZENGA of Michigan. I thank dedicated to representing the people of can truly be thankful for. my friend from California for yielding her district, and I have had the pleas- I want to commend and thank all of me this time. ure of working with her on border the Federal, State, and local officials Madam Speaker, I rise in support of issues, on military issues, and on intel- for all of their efforts over the last this resolution today. ligence issues on many occasions. week. These everyday heroes are often I, like all of my colleagues, was Over the last few days, my office has unsung despite the dangerous situa- shocked and very sobered by these received an outpouring of support for tions they are placed in. Americans ev- events. I was especially touched as a GABBY, for her family, and for her staff, erywhere are also thankful for those new Member seeing the location and as well as everyone else who was af- who showed courage to stand up in the the situation and the circumstances. fected by this tragedy. face of danger: This is something we all have done as Madam Speaker, when I was in my Daniel Hernandez, Representative Members. As a former district director congressional district this past Sun- GIFFORDS’ intern, the hero who assisted for a former Member of this body, my day, I was approached by a gentleman Congresswoman GIFFORDS by per- heart especially goes out to the family who I recognized who said something forming triage immediately after the of Gabe Zimmerman, of Ron Barber to me that I thought was very touch- shooting. and Pamela Simons, to all the staff ing. He said: Congressman, I often dis- Bill Badger, a retired Army National who have ever served Members in this agree with you on many issues, but I Guard colonel who tackled the gunman House, both here in Washington and want you to know that I’m praying for despite being grazed by a bullet in the out of that district. We want to say your friend from Arizona and for you. I back of his head. thank you for your service. We want to hope she keeps up the fight and pulls People like Daniel and Bill serve as say that our hearts and thoughts and through. real-life examples of what it takes to prayers are with those families that I expressed my appreciation on behalf be a hero. As we mourn our losses, we have been touched. And rest assured, of all of us and shook his hand. are grateful for such courageous acts. your safety is on top of our mind for us Madam Speaker, in the aftermath of Our prayers are with Congresswoman all. this tragedy, one of the best ways that GIFFORDS, her staff, all those we lost or As a father, I mourn the loss of a 9- I know of to honor the victims is to were injured, and their families. All of year-old daughter. I too have a 9-year- come together as Americans, as so us are searching to make sense of this old daughter, and I think all of us as

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:36 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00033 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.091 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H176 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 parents cannot help but look at this and time will tell what moved him to man, lost his life in this senseless at- and be heartbroken. commit this unspeakable act. Yet, for tack while two other members of her As an American, this is an assault on those of us here in this room, we all Arizona-based staff were injured. our humanity. This is not the first have to do more to drain our politics of In the midst of one of the darkest time this has happened in our Nation’s the venom where such hatred breeds. hours of our country in recent mem- history. It is a sad day nonetheless. We At this moment, above all, I pray for ory, let us also thank those whose are again asking God to heal our land. GABBY’s recovery and for the others I courage and bravery, whether in help- We will rise to this challenge as a peo- do not know, and I mourn those who ing take down the gunman or in assist- ple. I will continue to do my job as a were lost. ing in providing care for the injured, duly elected Member of this body. I Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- deserve recognition. We thank them for know my staff will do its job. I know fornia. Madam Speaker, it is my pleas- their valor. all of my colleagues’ staff will do their ure to yield 2 minutes to a member of Madam Speaker, during times of job as well; and we as a body, most im- our committee, the gentleman from tragedy, we depend on steady leader- portantly, will continue to do the peo- Georgia, Dr. GINGREY. ship to guide us through our grief. I ple’s work as we move forward through Mr. GINGREY of Georgia. I thank my commend the leadership of both parties this tragedy. colleague from California for yielding for remembering that there is much We again will rise to this challenge, time. more that unites us than divides us. and we pray that healing and grace and I rise in strong support of this resolu- Again, I pray for the recovery of our peace be brought to all of the victims. tion. colleague, Ms. GIFFORDS, and for all of Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- First and foremost, I would like to the victims of the Tucson shooting. er, I yield 2 minutes to the distin- extend my prayers and wishes, as well Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- guished gentlewoman from Con- as those of my constituents in north- er, I yield 2 minutes to the distin- necticut (Ms. DELAURO). west Georgia, to my colleague Rep- guished gentleman from Maine (Mr. MICHAUD). Ms. DELAURO. Madam Speaker, this resentative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, her Mr. MICHAUD. I thank the gen- weekend we honor a truly historic family and staff, and to all the other American who, through unyielding tleman for yielding. victims of the shooting. What took Madam Speaker, I rise today in struggle, bent the trajectory of our Na- place was an unspeakable tragedy, and tion closer to justice. ‘‘Violence . . . strong support of this resolution. it has absolutely no place in our soci- All of us on Capitol Hill were dealt solves no social problems,’’ that man, ety. Dr. Martin Luther King—himself a vic- with the shocking news that Congress- Madam Speaker, on Saturday morn- woman GABBY GIFFORDS and her staff tim of violence—wrote. ‘‘It only cre- ing, Ms. GIFFORDS was hosting an event ates new and more complicated ones.’’ were shot and that her director of out- fundamental to our duties as Members reach, Gabe Zimmerman, was killed. The shootings in Arizona remind us of of Congress—meeting with and listen- the truth of these words. They show This tragedy makes me think of my ing to our constituents so that we can own staff and the great work that they that the world is still a dangerous best represent them in Washington. It do each and every day for me, rep- place for those who stand up for civic is painfully sad and sobering that, in resenting the people I was elected to duty. the process of doing her job, GABBY was I do not have to tell this body that represent. brutally attacked. I join our entire country in con- GABBY GIFFORDS has been an exem- I had the pleasure of serving with tinuing to pray for the recovery of our plary Member of this House. As a small GABRIELLE on both the House Armed friend and colleague, Congresswoman businesswoman in her earlier career, Services Committee and the Science GABBY GIFFORDS. She is a hardworking she has worked hard to see that the and Technology Committee during the and highly respected Member of this economic concerns of Arizona’s fami- 110th Congress. I have always known Chamber, and she is a true advocate for lies are heard in Washington. As one of her to be a thoughtful legislator and a her home State. the growing number of women Mem- dedicated public servant and have al- In 2008 I had the privilege of joining bers here, she has been a powerful voice ways appreciated her cheerful disposi- her in Tucson for a discussion on the on immigration reform, energy inde- tion. Throughout her tenure in Con- need to improve mental health care for pendence, reducing drug trafficking gress, Representative GIFFORDS has dis- our servicemembers returning from the and cartel violence along the border, tinguished herself as one of the Mem- wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. I know and the continued importance of ex- bers of this body who works well with she cares passionately about this issue ploring the stars. our colleagues on both sides of the as she does about so many other issues b 1630 aisle. important to her constituents. May God bless Congresswoman As a third-generation Tucsonian, she My prayers continue to be with her GABBY GIFFORDS, her family, her has brought an Arizonan’s love of the and her family, and I look forward to the day when she walks back onto this friends, and all those in Arizona who sun to her advocacy of renewable en- have been affected by this tragedy. ergy and the benefits of solar power for House floor. Madam Speaker, we must also not Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- all Americans. fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- More importantly, however, GABBY is forget the other individuals who were victims of Saturday’s attack. One of utes to the gentleman from Virginia an exemplary person. She is fun to be (Mr. RIGELL). the casualties was 9-year-old Christina with. She is a dear friend of mine, a Mr. RIGELL. I thank my colleague Taylor Green, who was born on Sep- friend to my family—my stepdaughter, from California. Anna Greenberg, is her pollster—and I tember 11, 2001, and was recently elect- Madam Speaker, I rise in strong sup- know that, wherever you stand in this ed to serve on her school’s student port of this resolution today. Chamber, she was a friend to you. She council. Driven by her interest in poli- We gather here to remember the in- never had anything but a smile for tics, she had gone to GABBY’s event last nocent people whose lives were cut anyone, left or right. Saturday to learn more about our Fed- tragically short by the horror that un- For this, simply for serving her con- eral Government. The tragedy of her folded in Arizona on Saturday. We also stituents to the best of her ability, she death reminds us all of the fragile na- gather to honor and pray for our col- was shot in the line of duty. ture of life and what it means to be a league, Representative GIFFORDS, and At this very moment, she fights for public servant. the others wounded in that attack. life in Arizona—a life that has already Additionally, we all know the critical It was a real privilege for me to par- been cruelly denied six others in this role that our staff members play in ticipate in the reading of the Constitu- tragedy, including a longtime officer of helping us carry out our duties and tion with GABBY, and I anxiously look the court, a staffer just like the young better serve our constituents. Like us, forward to her return to the House men and women we rely on every day, members of our staffs are dedicated floor. and a little 9-year-old girl. public servants. That is why it is truly Joined by so many in Virginia’s Sec- The troubled individual who per- heartbreaking that a member of Ms. ond District, I offer my heartfelt con- petrated this evil is now in custody, GIFFORDS’ district staff, Gabe Zimmer- dolences to all of those affected by this

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:36 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00034 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.094 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H177 tragedy. I commend the citizens, the b 1640 Chamber. Until then, we can strive to- first responders, and the health care I am going to do my own ‘‘Congress wards the lofty standard she has set. professionals who bravely worked to on the Corner’’ in honor of GABBY this We can find inspiration in her steadfast protect and save lives. coming Friday because nobody, no lone commitment to those she serves, and We are blessed to live in a country gunman, nobody can stop the demo- we can draw strength from her unwav- where freedom and the opportunity to cratic process and stop us from doing ering belief in democracy. peacefully assemble and petition our our job of interacting with our con- Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- elected officials, even at a grocery stituents. er, I yield 2 minutes to the distin- store, is a cherished right. We uphold On behalf of myself and my family guished gentleman from Rhode Island that right today, and we stand united and the people that I represent from and Providence Plantations (Mr. in condemning this senseless act of vio- southern Nevada, I send our collective CICILLINE). lence. condolences to those people that have Mr. CICILLINE. I thank the gen- My wife, Teri, joins me and all of this lost loved ones in Tucson. And our tleman for yielding. body in praying for those who lost thoughts and prayers to the survivors. Madam Speaker, I rise in support of their lives, for those who were wounded We wish them all Godspeed. God bless this resolution and in honor of the vic- and their families. them, and God bless this great Nation. tims and those left suffering as a result May God bless America and bring Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- of last weekend’s devastating tragedy peace to America. fornia. Madam Speaker, before I yield 2 in Arizona. Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- minutes to the gentleman from Iowa In what can only be described as a er, I am pleased to yield 2 minutes to (Mr. LATHAM), I ask unanimous consent brutal act of domestic terrorism, Con- the distinguished gentlewoman from that the gentleman from California gresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, Nevada (Ms. BERKLEY). (Mr. CALVERT) be allowed to control members of her staff, and other mem- Ms. BERKLEY. I thank the gen- the balance of my time. bers of the Tucson community are now tleman. The SPEAKER pro tempore. Without fighting for their lives. And six inno- Madam Speaker, I don’t think there objection, the gentleman from Cali- cent others, including a 9-year-old lit- are enough words to express my feel- fornia (Mr. CALVERT) will control the tle girl and the Congresswoman’s direc- ings at this time, and I am sure the time. tor of community outreach, Gabe Zim- words that I have will never be ade- There was no objection. merman, gave the ultimate sacrifice in quate to truly share my grief with my Mr. LATHAM. I thank the gentleman the exercise of our democracy. colleagues and with our country. from California for yielding. This tragedy gives us great pause as As with all of the Members of Con- I rise today to join my colleagues in we begin the work of the 112th Con- gress, my thoughts and prayers are offering my prayers and condolences to gress and serves as a painful reminder with those who lost loved ones in the the victims of Saturday’s senseless vio- that our democracy is built upon the aftermath of this senseless act of vio- lence in Tucson. To the families and ability of our citizens to participate lence. My heart is hurting for those loved ones of those who lost their lives fully in their democracy, and we must who were injured—some catastroph- or were injured, know that every Mem- protect that. These have been tragic ically, some still fighting for their ber of Congress and their staff stand hours for our country, for those who lives. with you today. lost loved ones, and for those who were I love GABBY GIFFORDS. I don’t think This legislative body was designed to injured and their families. On behalf of there is a better example of a true pub- be a forum for the will of the American the people of the First District of lic servant than this remarkable people, and Congresswoman GIFFORDS Rhode Island and my colleague, Con- woman the country has gotten to know has always met her constituents in ac- gressman JIM LANGEVIN of the Second over the last few days. She is kind and cordance with that spirit. She and her District, we send our sincerest condo- caring and dedicated, and the very fact staff members who accompanied her on lences from our entire State to all that she was doing her Congress on that Saturday possessed a deep under- those who have lost a loved one as a re- Your Corner just 4 days from the time standing that a Representative of the sult of this hideous attack. We also ex- she was sworn in for another term people’s House must listen and remain tend our thoughts and prayers to Con- gives you some idea of how dedicated as accessible as possible to the people. gresswoman GIFFORDS, her staff and she was to her job. The citizens who lost their lives Sat- her constituents, all of whom were vic- While I watched in horror, like most urday morning were exercising their tims of this tragedy. And we pray that of the country, and was riveted to my patriotic duty to participate in the those injured have a speedy and full re- television set this weekend, I also democratic process: a widely respected covery. couldn’t help but marvel at those who Federal judge; a dedicated church serv- May God grant our Nation and all the rose above personal fear, who had the ant; a great grandmother who deeply victims peace and comfort. And may presence of mind and who, in spite of believed in her country; a former sec- we renew our commitment to the their own personal safety, tackled the retary and homemaker; and a 9-year- ideals that have made America great, perpetrator of this heinous crime; at old girl, herself a leader, getting an including the free exchange of ideas the young intern who possibly saved early glimpse of how our democracy and a democracy that continues to lis- GABBY’s life by his medical attention works. And it is with an especially ten carefully to the people we serve. to her; and at those who attended the heavy heart that we mourn the loss of Mr. CALVERT. Madam Speaker, I wounded and comforted the bystanders. Gabe Zimmerman, a dedicated member yield myself such time as I may con- These are the true heroes in our coun- of Congresswoman GIFFORDS’ staff and sume. try—the medical personnel, the hos- a member of this congressional com- Last Saturday, Congresswoman pital administrators and staff. munity who was also a tireless servant GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and many others The entire citizenry of Tucson has to the people of Arizona’s Eighth Dis- were victims of a brutal and brazen at- given us hope for our Nation as they trict. That those voices and lives were tack as they participated in a Congress have risen to this occasion and have cut short is a national tragedy of the on Your Corner event. Six people were demonstrated to the rest of us how highest order. killed and many more were injured. good we are in times of trial. This is a heartbreaking moment in Like many of my colleagues, I have The SPEAKER pro tempore. The the history of the House of Representa- had the pleasure to work with Rep- time of the gentlewoman has expired. tives and our Nation, but we cannot resentative GIFFORDS and can attest Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield the gen- allow this tragedy to put us on the de- that she is a thoughtful, kind, and won- tlewoman an additional 30 seconds. fensive. We cannot retreat from our re- derful person. My prayers are with her Ms. BERKLEY. I’ve gone through sponsibilities to be accessible and re- and her family as she begins the road many stages of grief in the last few sponsive to the will of the American to recovery. days. First, I was heartsick at the people. My thoughts are also with the fami- news. Then I was angry. And now I’m I look forward to the day when Con- lies of those who were killed. No words resolved. gresswoman GIFFORDS rejoins us in this can ease the pain of their families, and

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:36 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00035 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.096 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H178 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 our country shares in the grief of six the true nature of America. We are But even in tragedy we see the great lives cut short. The goodness that here today to say it most emphatically strength of this Nation. We see the he- Dorothy Morris, Judge John Roll, does not. roic actions of individuals, private and Phyllis Schneck, Dorwan Stoddard, The true nature of America is not an professional, who helped subdue the Gabe Zimmerman, and 9-year-old evil, haunted person killing innocent attacker and who helped the wounded Christina Taylor Green brought to this people. The true nature of this country survive. And we see a nationwide out- world will never be forgotten. is the diligence of GABRIELLE GIFFORDS pouring of concern and prayer for It is during moments of tragedy that as she stood there listening to her con- GABBY GIFFORDS and all of those that Americans forget our differences and stituents so patiently. The true nature were injured. And of course that rises unite around common goodness. We of America is the optimism of a 9-year- far above political differences. love our country and our countrymen. old girl eager to become involved in May God bless the families and bless We will never let any one act or one in- the political process. The true nature us in our work here this year in the dividual deter us from living in free- of America is the ultimate act of self- 112th Congress. dom and without fear. As Members of lessness as a long-term husband inter- Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- Congress, we refuse to be cowed by poses his body between that and the er, I yield 2 minutes to another fine senseless violence. Our duty is to our bullets and saves the life of his beloved gentleman from New Jersey (Mr. constituents, and we will fulfill that wife whom he met in grammar school. PALLONE). Mr. PALLONE. Madam Speaker, ear- duty without reservation or hesitation. b 1650 The lesson from last Saturday can be lier this afternoon many of us attended found in the courageous acts of strang- The true nature of America is the a congressional prayer service for the ers and neighbors who banded together skill and heroism of the young intern, victims of the shooting in Arizona, and amid violence to help others and con- 5 days in the service of Congresswoman I just wanted to reflect on three things front a madman. Let us honor Rep- GIFFORDS, who rushed to her side and that occurred there that really were resentative GIFFORDS’ intern, David very likely saved her life with his skill. meaningful for me. Hernandez, who did not hesitate to The true nature of America is the ju- One was after the prayer service, the come to her aid, and three incredible diciousness and careful reasoning of staff of GABBY GIFFORDS were gathered, Arizonans who, without regard for the Federal judge who gave his life by and we had an opportunity to meet their own lives, tackled and subdued happenstance on that day at that mo- them and shake their hands and talk to the attacker. ment. The true nature of America is them a little bit. And I was just taken Whatever the deranged purpose of the the three brave Arizonans who ran to- aback, first of all, by how young they shooter, it has only served to strength- ward a man with a loaded gun who was were and how optimistic they were, of en our resolve and the greatness of our firing away, threw their bodies at him course optimistic about her because country and to marvel at the bravery and saved the lives of countless others they really feel and they’re praying, and kindness of our fellow Americans, around them. and we all do, that she has a full recov- who without thought of their own safe- Saturday was a horrendous day, but ery. ty acted in the face of evil. It is their let us be resolved that it will not be But I can’t help but reflect on the stories of bravery that will be remem- marked in history by the manifesta- fact that not only the Congresswoman bered and held up as an example of an tion of evil that it represents, but by but her staff were so dedicated. I would exceptional nature of our great Amer- the manifestation of optimism and dili- often talk to GABBY on the floor often- ican character. gence and selflessness and goodness times in the back of this room; and as As we move forward from this hor- that truly reflect the spirit of the many have said, she was wonderful. rible event, let us keep the feelings of American people. She was so enthusiastic about her job, brotherhood and compassion that May God bless our colleague and all about her constituents. She is also a should not only exist in the wake of a those who suffered through this long beautiful person. And I was just so tragedy, but in our everyday lives. nightmare. happy to hear that after the operation God bless our dear friend, GABBY GIF- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- that they were optimistic about her re- FORDS, all those who were injured, the fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- covery, and it seems like every day she families of the fallen, and God bless utes to the gentleman from Alabama gets better. So I’m really looking for- America. (Mr. ADERHOLT). ward to her coming back here. Madam Speaker, I yield the balance Mr. ADERHOLT. First of all, I would And I want to pay tribute to her of my time to the gentleman from Cali- like to join in with my colleagues in staff. I mean, obviously three of them fornia (Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN), and I condemning this act of violence and to were injured. One was killed. That per- ask unanimous consent that he be al- express my deepest condolences to all son was killed, and all of them were lowed to control that time. of the families who were killed in the facing the reality, unfortunately, that The SPEAKER pro tempore. Without attack on January 8, 2011, in Tucson, we do face now that when we do out- objection, the gentleman from Cali- Arizona. reach, that there is a certain amount fornia may resume. I join millions of others in praying of danger. But I also think that it’s There was no objection. for the recovery of all of those that really important for us to say that we Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- were injured. Especially we pray for are going to fight against that. We are er, I am delighted to yield 2 minutes to our colleague, the Honorable Rep- going to continue to be out there meet- the gentleman from New Jersey (Mr. resentative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. It has ing with our constituents, and we want ANDREWS). been my privilege and honor to work people to come and meet with us. (Mr. ANDREWS asked and was given with her, especially on the well-being The second thing was the House permission to revise and extend his re- of this Nation’s space program, and I Chaplain. At the prayer service today marks.) pray for her full recovery and God’s he said that the Arizona victims were Mr. ANDREWS. Madam Speaker, we strength for her husband and her entire essentially martyrs to the cause of are gathered here this afternoon to family. America because they were out there show respect and affection for our be- In a Nation where there is freedom, participating in democracy. And I real- loved colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS, to some individuals will choose to do evil, ly think that that’s true, that the need mourn the dead, and to provide support and certainly no law can cure the to participate and the democratic proc- for those wounded in body and in spir- human heart. I do pray for the individ- ess is what this is all about. And to the it. uals who are suffering from anger, like extent that we reinforce that in the We also have a special responsibility those of the accused, that they will aftermath of this tragedy is really im- here this afternoon to tell the truth find the counseling and healing that portant. about the nature of America. Our chil- they need. And the last thing I would say is dren and people all over the world saw Actions like this, which include the some of the Members today, and par- acts of heinous violence on Saturday, tragic death of a 9-year-old child, are ticularly ED PASTOR when he spoke at and many think that that represents not normal. the prayer service, he said that we

VerDate Mar 15 2010 01:36 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00036 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.099 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H179 have to be inspired to better the lives Mr. JOHNSON of Georgia. Madam and prayers of Florida’s Second Con- of others. Speaker, I rise in support of this reso- gressional District I deliver. Our hearts The SPEAKER pro tempore. The lution that recognizes the tragedy in are broken over the events of Satur- time of the gentleman has expired. Tucson on Saturday. I’m deeply day. We want to deliver today our Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield the gen- shocked and saddened, and I’m praying thoughts especially to those families tleman an additional 30 seconds. for GABBY, her family, staff, and the who lost their loved ones, the six fami- Mr. PALLONE. And I noticed that other victims of this senseless act of lies who are today memorializing them the little girl, Christina Green, the one violence. and planning those details. who unfortunately passed away, actu- In times like these, words often fail I also want to make sure that I ex- ally told her parents that she wanted to describe our anguish and pain. As a press my appreciation for the short to have a career that involved helping fellow Member of the class of 2006, I’ve time that I had a privilege of speaking those less fortunate than her. And I gotten to know Congresswoman GIF- with Representative GIFFORDS. Last think if there is anything that we can FORDS well and have developed enor- Thursday, shortly after we were sworn do in the aftermath of this tragedy, as mous respect for her intellect and her in, I walked just outside the floor. She ED PASTOR said at the prayer service, love for this country. met me outside, and she extended her hand to me. And she said, ‘‘Hello, I am let us be inspired to better the lives of b 1700 others. Let’s try to make something Gabby Giffords. You must be new.’’ positive of this tragedy. She and I have served together on the And I said, ‘‘Well, I am new. I am Steve That little girl was so much in my House Armed Services Committee. And Southerland.’’ She goes, ‘‘Where are heart when I heard about her and her she was very gracious on the morning you from, Steve?’’ And I said, ‘‘Flor- wanting to have a career in public serv- of President Obama’s swearing in. She ida.’’ She said, ‘‘Let me introduce you ice and her being there at this outreach offered to share her blanket with me as to some people that will help you.’’ center because of that desire. we both braved the cold during the in- And she walked down the hall and out Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- auguration. We kept each other warm, to the steps, and she introduced me to fornia. Madam Speaker, I am very and we had warm dialogue and happy numerous, numerous floor staff. I did pleased to yield 2 minutes to the gen- moments. not have any other encounter with her GABBY and her staff were performing tleman from Florida (Mr. STEARNS). except for that 5-minute brief time. Mr. STEARNS. I thank my distin- a fundamental duty of a Member of And on Saturday, when I learned of guished colleague; and on behalf of my- Congress: That is listening to the con- the events that had occurred in Tuc- self and my constituents from the cerns of her constituents. Our democ- son, it was with horror that I got Sixth Constitution District in north- racy depends on this type of open and home, and I turned on the television, central Florida, we offer our thoughts informal meeting of elected officials and I realized that it was that wonder- and prayers to our colleague and the people that they serve. We can- ful, sweet person who with kindness not let this cowardly act of violence GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and her family. and gentleness introduced me to the I also join the American people in ex- prevent us from engaging with our con- staff. And so it is with a burdened tending our condolences to the other stituents. I encourage my colleagues to heart today that I want those in this victims of this terrible event. This is a take appropriate caution but to con- Chamber and the people of America to heartbreaking loss. tinue holding constituent meetings and know that the citizens of Florida’s Dis- But I’m encouraged by the positive do the job we were elected to do with- trict Two are heartbroken as well. We news from her doctors. And I commend out fear. To do otherwise would allow are praying for each and every one af- those medical professionals in Tucson the gunman a small taste of victory fected. for their dedication and outstanding and would diminish our democracy and And I want to make sure that we go work. Obviously, we look forward to dishonor the victims of this senseless from here to continue, in honor of those who have given their lives and GABBY coming back to the House floor. act. ABBY those who have been affected, to create We miss her warm demeanor and her I look forward to G ’s speedy re- a more perfect Union, that we work courageous qualities. covery and to working with her on the In paying our respects to her and the Armed Services Committee again soon. hard to secure the blessings of liberty. And I would like to say a few words For that is how we will be known by others harmed and killed in this sense- about Federal Judge John Roll, who the world. Not by our security, not by less act of violence, we must make it lost his life on Saturday. Judge Roll our policy, but by the civility, by the clear that we will not be deterred from was with Congresswoman GIFFORDS the love we show and care for one another. meeting with the American people. The day of the shootings to press for fund- That will make us a shining city on a act of this deranged individual should ing to relieve overcrowding in his dis- hill. And that’s what I am committed not alter the routine duties of our of- trict. to doing. fice. I’ve had 560 town meetings in my The SPEAKER pro tempore. The Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- district. I understand what it must be time of the gentleman has expired. er, I am pleased to yield 2 minutes to to remain accessible to my constitu- Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield the gen- the distinguished gentleman from the ents. An attack on any single Member tleman an additional 30 seconds. Commonwealth of Massachusetts (Mr. is an assault on this institution, and Mr. JOHNSON of Georgia. Judge Roll MCGOVERN). we must carry on in our commitment had been a lifetime servant of his com- Mr. MCGOVERN. Madam Speaker, I to an open and representative govern- munity and his State, 63 years old. And appreciate the opportunity to speak ment. as Justice John Roberts said, Judge here today. As has been said over and So I extend my best wishes to my Roll’s death is a somber reminder of over, GABRIELLE GIFFORDS is a smart, colleague for a satisfactory and swift the importance of the rule of law and gifted, and compassionate Member of recovery. I also share my deepest sym- the sacrifices of those who work to se- Congress. It is a privilege to be her col- pathies with the families of the victims cure it. league and friend. Arizona is privileged who were injured and killed in this in- Finally, I would like to recognize the to be represented by a person of her comprehensible act. other victims. I won’t name them, and caliber. Let me close with two Bible quotes, I do not know them personally, but I My wife, Lisa, and I pray for her re- from Psalm 46:1, ‘‘God is our refuge and want to express my sympathy and con- covery. And our thoughts are with her, strength, an ever-present help in trou- dolences to their families. her family, her friends, and her com- ble’’; and 1 Peter 3:14, ‘‘But even if you Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- munity as they come together in the should suffer for what is right, you are fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- aftermath of this terrible act of vio- blessed. Do not fear what they fear. Do utes to the gentleman from Florida lence. I look forward to seeing GABBY not be frightened.’’ (Mr. SOUTHERLAND). back here where she belongs, on this Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- Mr. SOUTHERLAND. I thank the floor, advocating on behalf of her con- er, I yield 2 minutes to the distin- gentleman from California for yielding. stituents. guished gentleman from Georgia (Mr. Madam Speaker, I rise today in sup- I served in this House for many years JOHNSON). port of this resolution. The thoughts as a congressional aide. And since I’ve

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00037 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.101 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H180 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 been elected to Congress, I’ve come to fighting for the freedom of the Iraqis the words of Robert Kennedy that were appreciate even more the generous and there. And we just grew a common said on that tragic day so many years selfless service of our staffs. So I am bond in the service and the recognition ago, and I quote: ‘‘Let us dedicate our- especially touched and grieved by the of those who were serving in an even selves to what the Greeks wrote so murder of Gabe Zimmerman, who more difficult circumstance. many years ago: ‘to tame the savage- served as GABBY’s director of commu- We found the opportunities to work ness of man and make gentle the life of nity outreach. across the aisle on several issues just this world.’ ’’ For those whose lives were lost— after we returned. And those are the Get well soon, GABBY. We need your Christina Taylor Green, Dorothy Mor- strong memories that compel me today leadership, your strength, your cour- ris, Judge John Roll, Phyllis Schneck, to stand up and say that I have grown age. You are in our thoughts; you are and Dorwan Stoddard, who was related to respect and admire the efforts of in our prayers. to one of my own staff, my sympathy, this courageous young woman as she Mr. DANIEL L. LUNGREN of Cali- condolences, and prayers are with their served here in Congress. fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- families and loved ones. As we saw the unforeseeable and utes to the gentleman from Pennsyl- I believe so very strongly that we tragic circumstances of this past week- vania (Mr. PLATTS). here in this House, and all of us as end, we realized that there are cir- Mr. PLATTS. I thank the distin- Americans, must come together and cumstances that face us all. And I guished gentleman from California for transform this tragedy into something would recognize right now that yielding to me. Madam Speaker, I rise in humble and positive and hopeful. We live in a coun- GABRIELLE GIFFORDS decided to do her solemn support for House Resolution try that is too polarized. And we live in job no matter the risk. She served with a country where a culture of violence is 32. courage, determination, with openness I also rise to express my heartfelt all too common. If this horrible act of and a forthrightness to her constitu- gratitude to our distinguished Speaker, violence results in all of us becoming ents that should be a model to all of us. the gentleman from Ohio (Mr. more civil to one another, in taking a I know that she is an inspiration for BOEHNER), and all Members of the more careful look at the words and im- me today as she struggles to regain her House leadership, Republican and agery we use when talking to and health and to regain her position here Democratic alike. The thoughtful and about one another as we deal with dif- serving the American people. compassionate manner in which they ficult and controversial policy debates, I have been able to support many of have united the Members of this great if it results in concrete ways to begin GABRIELLE GIFFORDS’ initiatives in the institution in prayerful support for our to reverse this culture of violence, then past. It’s my privilege today to lend beloved colleague and friend, Congress- our Nation will triumph over this pain my support to this resolution. I pray woman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, and all of and loss. for her speedy recovery and for the re- the victims of the January 8 attack in Today is a time to grieve, to mourn, covery of those injured on that fateful Tucson, Arizona, is sincerely appre- to express sympathy. But unfortu- day. I pray for the comfort of those ciated. nately, in the aftermath of this trag- who lost loved ones. May God bless Madam Speaker, as with all Ameri- edy, too many of the old fights resur- GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. cans, I was deeply saddened and horri- faced. The left blamed the right, the Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- fied upon learning of the senseless and right blamed the left, everybody er, I yield 2 minutes to the gentle- violent attack on Congresswoman GIF- blamed the media, op-eds were written, woman from New York (Mrs. FORDS, members of GABBY’s staff, and and bills were introduced. But Madam MALONEY). citizens of Arizona’s Eighth District. Speaker, none of that will bring back b 1710 This act of violence was an unthink- those who were lost. None of that will able attack on a dedicated public serv- put a 9-year-old girl back at the break- Mrs. MALONEY. I thank the gen- ant and her constituents. fast table where she belongs. tleman for yielding. It was also an attack on one of the Like many of my colleagues, on Mon- Madam Speaker, like so many of my most important cornerstones of our day I participated in a national mo- colleagues, I knew GABBY GIFFORDS to form of representational democracy— ment of silence. The best thing about be a warm and caring friend, a rising the duty of elected officials to reach that moment was that for just a star in the House with a moral compass out to the citizens they serve. It is im- minute or two the noise stopped. We as sure as it is true. That is why she re- perative that we not allow the tragic paused and we reflected. And I hope cently spoke out against the rising tide events of January 8 to prevent elected that we can do more of that in the of hate speech in our country and the officials from fulfilling this duty to re- months and years ahead. lack of civility in our political process. main in close contact with their con- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- While it may be too early to come to stituents and well grounded in their fornia. Madam Speaker, it is my pleas- any conclusions about the con- concerns. ure now to yield 2 minutes to the gen- sequences of the recent and tragic On behalf of my wife, Leslie, and our tleman who has returned from New events, it is never too late to reflect on family and all residents of Pennsylva- Mexico (Mr. PEARCE). lessons we have learned from earlier nia’s 19th Congressional District, I Mr. PEARCE. Madam Speaker, it’s such tragedies and take them to heart. offer our deepest sympathies to the my distinct honor to rise today and Guns kill. And those who glamorize families, the friends, and the coworkers call Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIF- gunplay do no service to humanity. of those who were taken from us in this FORDS not only a colleague, but a Words matter. And those who use in- attack. Please know that you and all friend. I had the pleasure of working flammatory rhetoric to achieve cheap the victims of this terrible tragedy are with this fine lady from Arizona on political gain wound our country and and will continue to be in our thoughts several initiatives, beginning very weaken the ties that bind us. and prayers. May God watch over you early in her first term. The districts Democracy triumphs. The funda- as he continues to watch over our that we serve are very similar, south- mental wisdom that has distinguished grieving Nation. ern New Mexico, southern Arizona. We our Nation and led her to greatness re- Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- share the southern border. We have sides in our unwavering commitment er, I yield 2 minutes to the gentle- issues of public land, public access, re- to settle our disputes with ballots, not woman from Wisconsin (Ms. BALDWIN). sources. So many of our perspectives bullets. Ms. BALDWIN. I thank the gen- originate from the same sort of dis- My thoughts and prayers go out to tleman for yielding. trict. Congresswoman GIFFORDS—I hope for Madam Speaker, I rise to express my I got to know GABBY just in her first her swift and complete recovery—and thoughts and offer my prayers and month here. In February, we went to- to her family and to all the friends and those of my constituents for my friend gether to Iraq to visit soldiers. To- family members of the victims of that and colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS, who gether we would sit down and visit tragic event. lies critically wounded; and for her with young men and young women who As we approach the observance of staffer, Gabe Zimmerman; for the pre- were defending our country, who were Martin Luther King Day, let us recall cious patriot, Christina Taylor Green;

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00038 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.104 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H181 for Dorothy Morris, Judge John Roll, colleague. She was shot in the line of Less than a year ago, another dis- Phyllis Schneck and Dorwan Stoddard, duty, the duty of listening to, so that turbed individual expressed his anger who lost their lives in this senseless she could more effectively represent by crashing his airplane into a building tragedy; and to their families. those constituents. It was a duty that in Austin, Texas, that housed IRS em- Our thoughts and prayers, too, go out she and many of us do love and do ployees, causing great death and de- to the other innocent victims of this treasure that interaction with our con- struction. Incredibly, a Facebook page tragedy, including congressional staff- stituents. was erected quickly in his honor. What ers Ron Barber and Pamela Simon and Today, more so than ever, as Mem- I said then I would reemphasize today: their families, and our heartfelt grati- bers of Congress are called to that We must turn down the volume on hate tude to all those brave souls who re- duty, we realize that it goes with us to discourage more such horrors. sponded valiantly and quickly, pre- wherever we go. Every trip to the gro- Debate, vigorous debate, is at the venting even more death and injury. cery store, to church, to a soccer game, very heart of our democracy. Some- And to the people of Arizona, who love can turn into a town hall meeting. times it is heated and strongly worded. their State and our democracy, to you That accessibility to those who count Such strong discourse helps us to set we express our solidarity. on us to make the right decision is America’s course. But violence is not GABBY, as we all know, is one of the something that we cannot give up. discourse. It debases our democracy. nicest, most decent, dedicated, con- Even though this past weekend’s Violence can kill a human being, but it cerned, and compassionate Representa- events have devastated us, we must not cannot kill the truth. In a free and tives in this body. The fact that she compound the tragedy by being de- open market of ideas, truth will ulti- and her staff were gunned down while terred from those duties. mately prevail. doing their jobs, doing exactly what is The shooting occurred on Saturday, In the words of Dr. Martin Luther required in a democracy, makes this and on Sunday I kept a previously King, Jr., whose life and work we cele- tragedy even more unfathomable. scheduled district appointment at Fort brate this very month, ‘‘I believe that And so I am concerned about the im- Campbell. That Army post is home to unarmed truth and unconditional love pact of this tragedy on our democracy. the 101st Airborne when they are not will have the final word in reality. We cannot have a well-functioning de- deployed, as they currently are in Af- That is why right, temporarily de- mocracy without ample interaction ghanistan. These public servants know feated, is stronger than evil trium- and discourse between members of the what the senseless loss of an honored phant.’’ We pray for those lost and the public and their elected officials. many who still suffer from this great Directly or indirectly, this tragedy friend, colleague, even a hero feels like. They also know better than anyone tragedy. invites us to examine the way we con- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- else that service is often most valuable duct business on all levels. There is no fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- when it is performed in the face of fear, question that political discourse has utes to the gentleman from Pennsyl- uncertainty, or hostility. become toxic at times, and I hope that vania (Mr. FITZPATRICK). out of this tragedy comes a renewed So many of my constituents have Mr. FITZPATRICK. Madam Speaker, commitment to civility. asked what will this mean for how we, I rise today to humbly add my voice to I applaud Speaker BOEHNER and as Members, carry out our jobs. I think the remarks made so eloquently by my Leader PELOSI for setting the right we will all be more careful when we un- colleagues. tone. We have a moment now to look dertake our duties. We know we are re- I had the honor of personally meeting prospectively at how we debate issues sponsible not only for our own safety; Representative GIFFORDS for the first of great import. we are responsible for the safety of our time just last week, here in the Cham- The SPEAKER pro tempore. The staff, our constituents who bring issues ber; and although my service in the time of the gentlewoman has expired. to us. And in this, I hope our service House has thus far only overlapped Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield the gen- does credit to the men and women in ever so briefly with hers, GABBY’s atti- tlewoman an additional 30 seconds. uniform. tude of service and spirit of commit- Ms. BALDWIN. I hope we seize this The SPEAKER pro tempore. The ment to those that she represents was moment to come together as a Con- time of the gentlewoman has expired. immediately apparent. gress and ask, How can we bring re- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Representative GIFFORDS was prac- newed civility to consequential debate fornia. I yield the gentlewoman an ad- ticing one of the most basic and impor- and create a new environment in which ditional 30 seconds. tant duties that a Member of Congress people can differ without demonizing b 1720 will have, making herself available to others? constituents, when a gunman viciously People reach different conclusions Mrs. BLACKBURN. I hope our service and inexplicably attacked her and 19 about the important topics of our time, does credit to the men and women in others. but each of us, like GABBY, seeks office uniform who have served us so very It is difficult to find explanation for because we want to make life better for well. God bless GABBY GIFFORDS, bless such a tragic event. And while an ex- the people we represent. We want a bet- her staff, her constituents, the other planation will always elude us, we can ter America. innocent victims, bless this House and find comfort in the prayer of a friend GABBY, keep fighting the good fight. our great Nation. and constituent from my home district We need you and America needs you. Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- in Pennsylvania, Rabbi Ira Budow. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- er, I yield 2 minutes to the gentleman Just this past Monday evening before fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield 2 min- from Texas (Mr. DOGGETT). a town hall meeting in Bucks County, utes to the gentlewoman from Ten- Mr. DOGGETT. Our energetic and Rabbi Budow prayed. He said, ‘‘I pray nessee (Mrs. BLACKBURN). talented colleague GABBY GIFFORDS that the disaster in Arizona serves as a Mrs. BLACKBURN. Madam Speaker, was doing what she does so well, the wake-up call for our country and re- I, like our colleagues, am rising in sor- core responsibility of every Member: sults in a more caring and loving at- row today to address the events that listening to her constituents in an open mosphere for us all. At the end of the occurred in Arizona this past weekend. public forum. Young and old, Ameri- day, we are all Americans and rise and Our thoughts and prayers are with all cans of all political philosophies gath- fall together.’’ of those victims, with their families, ered to meet with her. I’m proud to support the resolution. and with our colleague, GABBY GIF- This is the very type of neighborhood Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- FORDS. She was doing what we all do— office hours that so many of us hold. I er, I am happy to yield 2 minutes to hearing the concerns of her constitu- have held many of them throughout the distinguished gentlewoman from ents. And I think we all know and rec- central Texas. And this is the very Hawaii (Ms. HIRONO). ognize that we in this Chamber are type of accessibility and openness that Ms. HIRONO. Madam Speaker, I rise more visible and more accountable is fundamental to our democracy and to join my colleagues today in support than ever before. critical to a society that recognizes of this resolution and associate myself On Saturday, a madman, a monster, that change is achieved through bal- with the eloquent and heartfelt expres- attempted to assassinate our beloved lots, not bullets. sions of condolences and comfort from

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00039 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.107 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H182 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 my colleagues from both sides of the Ms. HAYWORTH. Madam Speaker, I space endeavors, veterans health care, aisle. And hearing the wonderful sto- rise to honor the victims of Saturday’s and comprehensive immigration re- ries about GABBY told on this floor help senseless and atrocious attack. Con- form. But GABBY is also known around capture the warmth and humanity that gresswoman GIFFORDS and her staff are Capitol Hill as a smart, generous, and is GABBY GIFFORDS. constantly in the thoughts and prayers unfailing dedicated public servant and The shock, horror, and tears that fol- of her colleagues in the House. And as friend. She is the one who would be lowed the unfolding of the terrible a mother, I am most profoundly sad- helping to plan a baby shower for one news from Arizona, it’s like just yes- dened by the loss of the youngest vic- of her colleagues, to reach across the terday. Here was GABBY, out on the tim, Christina Taylor Green. Christina aisle to lend a supportive hand to a col- first day after we finished votes to was only 9 years old. league in need of advice or a laugh, to meet with her constituents at a Con- She belonged to history at the begin- take time to offer a hand to a staffer gress on your Corner, an event that ning of her life, and she belongs to his- after a long day at work. many of us do in our own districts. She tory at the end of her life. She was I also think of GABBY as a unique and was joined by her dedicated staff and a born on September 11, 2001; and Chris- all-too-rare representative in this Con- large number of constituents who tina was acutely aware of the impact gress. She prefers considerate and de- wanted to talk with her, including a that day had on our Nation. But she al- tailed debate over harsh and angry third grader so excited to meet with ways found the positive and hopeful in rhetoric. She chooses her words her Congressperson, who had just been that dreadful event. She would often thoughtfully, and has spoken out elected to an office in her elementary tell people she was born on a holiday, against violent language and the con- school. and she said it was a holiday because it sequences such careless acts create. I send my condolences on behalf of gave hope to say that and people came So I would argue if we really want to all of the people of Hawaii to the fami- together on that day. She wore red, pay tribute to GABBY here today, may lies of those who lost loved ones in this white, and blue; and she was vocal her service not be an exception to the senseless act of violence. And I’m going about her patriotism and her pride to rule. We in this Chamber have the op- to say their names again because they be an American. portunity to live every day by the must not be forgotten: John Roll, 63, And in addition to being extremely words we are speaking today. chief judge for the U.S. District of Ari- patriotic, Christina was an inquisitive Madam Speaker, the sorrow and grief zona; Gabriel Matthew Zimmerman, 30, and mature young lady who had re- of Saturday’s tragedy will echo for Representative GIFFORDS’ director of cently taken an interest in the most many years to come. As we pray and community outreach; Christina Taylor fundamental of American rights, civic take stock of this tragedy, I am also Green, 9 years old, a beautiful and engagement. She had just been elected concerned by the ease with which a bright girl who should have had a to her own student government, and clearly troubled young man could ob- chance for a full life; Dorothy Morris, she was attending Saturday’s event to tain a firearm. And I believe that this 76, whose husband was critically in- meet her Congresswoman and learn incident also illuminates a serious gap jured trying to protect her during the more about government. in our mental health system, one shootings; Phyllis Schneck, 79, mother As we grieve for her loss, it is impor- where far too many ill people slip of three, grandmother of seven; Dorwan tant to pay tribute to the model young through the cracks. The price for these Stoddard, 76, who shielded his wife, citizen Christina was and for us to failings is all too often paid, as in this Mavy, who was also wounded. Our prayers are with those who are honor her memory. As adults, we can case, by friends and neighbors. We owe struggling to recover from their inju- all learn from Christina’s positive out- it to the victims of this horrific trag- ries, including our dear friend and my look on life, love of country, and par- edy to improve our mental health sys- tem. classmate, GABBY, GABBY’s husband, ticipation in government. Mark Kelly, and all of the family mem- Even during these very dark and The SPEAKER pro tempore. The bers of the victims. We are all one fam- painful times, we should take solace in time of the gentlewoman has expired. Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield the gen- ily. As we say in Hawaii, ohana, united knowing that with children like Chris- tlewoman an additional 30 seconds. in our collective grief and prayers. tina growing up in our society, our Na- The SPEAKER pro tempore. The tion has a bright future. Mrs. CAPPS. We owe it to the vic- tims of this horrific tragedy to improve time of the gentlewoman has expired. b 1730 Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield the gen- our mental health system; and, in addi- tlewoman 30 additional seconds. Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- tion, to address gun violence. We can Ms. HIRONO. I thank the gentleman. er, I am delighted to yield 2 minutes to do better. Let us resolve to do so. Like The day before this terrible tragedy, the gentlewoman from California (Mrs. everyone here and countless at home, I GABBY had reached out to a friend of CAPPS). am praying for GABBY’s swift recovery, hers, Kentucky Secretary of State Mrs. CAPPS. I thank my colleague for her constituents who lost their Trey Grayson, a Republican, to talk to from Iowa. lives, and for our country. him about ways that we all could tone Madam Speaker, I rise to express my Let us adopt this resolution today in down the political rhetoric and par- strong support for H. Res. 32, a resolu- honor of our beloved friend GABBY and tisanship. tion to honor GABBY GIFFORDS as she the victims of this senseless tragedy. At this point we don’t know what recovers from her injuries, to pay trib- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- drove the gunman to commit this hor- ute to those who lost their lives, and to fornia. Madam Speaker, at this time I rible act of violence. Regardless of thank those who helped the injured and do not believe I have any other speak- whether his actions have a causal con- prevented further loss of life. ers. I reserve my time to close. nection with an increasingly negative This is a devastating and emotional Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- tone of our political discourse, I think week for all of us here in Congress, for er, I yield 2 minutes to the gentleman this tragedy should give us all pause to our staff, and for America as a whole. from California (Mr. SHERMAN). reflect. Just as we have all come to- The senseless and atrocious loss of life Mr. SHERMAN. We come together gether today to honor the victims of in Tucson has infringed upon our sense today as a Nation to mourn those who this tragedy, I believe we can honor of safety and decency. It has also left died in Arizona and to pray for the full GABBY by going forward with a height- us grieving for a colleague, for her recovery of those still lying in hospital ened commitment to respect each staff, and for the six Americans who beds in Tucson. other, listen to each other’s points of lost their lives last Saturday, as re- GABBY GIFFORDS has captured the view and come up with policies that cited by my colleague from Hawaii just love and admiration of this entire will strengthen our Nation. We must go now. country as America has come to know forward together. Mahalo nui loa. Representative GIFFORDS—GABBY to her through news reports, just as we Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- so many of us—is truly a treasured have come to know her over the last 4 fornia. Madam Speaker, it is my privi- Member of this body. She is a gifted years as the most delightful and engag- lege to yield 2 minutes to the gentle- legislator, frequently leading her col- ing Member of this House, and as a woman from New York, Dr. HAYWORTH. leagues on issues like solar energy, woman who brought intelligence and

VerDate Mar 15 2010 02:02 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00040 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.110 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H183 determination to the service of this First, we must vow that we will never Arizona, the senseless loss of life, and country. let the work of a madman stop us from the cowardly attack on GABBY GIF- The last time I had a chance to spend doing our work on behalf of the Amer- FORDS has for many Americans raised time with GABBY was just 6 days ago. ican people. Secondly, we will make it the question of whether we as a Nation We were here on the House floor. As it clear to all that while we have dis- have lost our way. Many wonder, if an happens, we sat next to each other as agreements, we are all still Americans, act so benign as GABBY’s effort to lis- we waited our turn to be assigned a and we respect each other. Words mat- ten to her neighbors in the Eighth Con- portion of the Constitution to be read. ter. When we show Americans that we gressional District of Arizona can be We had a chance to listen to each pas- can disagree substantively and respect- the target of such violence, whether sage, to speak briefly about some of fully, we bring our entire country clos- there is hope and a future for our de- the salient provisions. And as they got er together and show the world why mocracy. down the line to where we were sitting, America is the greatest force for good. One voice from our recent past sug- it became apparent that GABBY would There is a song Sarah McLachlan gests there is still hope for that fragile be called upon to read the First sings, ‘‘Angel’’—we place them in the ideal. On April 4, 1968, Senator Robert Amendment to the Constitution, and arms of angels. And may God bless this Kennedy spoke in Indianapolis, Indi- that I would be called upon to read the family and these people who endured ana, shortly after the slaying of Martin considerably less august Third Amend- this horrific event. Luther King at a time when political ment. Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- violence wracked our Nation. This is For just a selfish instant, I wondered er, I yield 2 minutes to the gentleman what he said: why luck couldn’t have been just a lit- from Virginia (Mr. MORAN). ‘‘We have to make an effort in the tle different. If we had been sitting just Mr. MORAN of Virginia. Madam United States. We have to make an ef- one seat over, then I could have stood Speaker, GABBY GIFFORDS is a wonder- fort to understand, to get beyond these here and talked about freedom of reli- ful human being and a treasured col- difficult times.’’ gion and freedom of speech. But provi- league and friend. But this resolution, He then said, ‘‘My favorite poem was dence had determined otherwise, had as important and appropriate as it is, Aeschylus, and he once wrote, ‘Even in determined that GABBY GIFFORDS stops short of any collective commit- our sleep, pain which cannot forget should stand on this floor and have the ment to prevent this type of tragedy falls drop by drop upon the heart, honor of reading the First Amendment, from happening again. It happened be- until, in our own despair, against our an amendment that is best known for cause of a combustible mix of: one, a will, comes wisdom through the awful its earlier clauses but which ends with highly charged, antigovernment polit- grace of God.’ ’’ the words that enshrine the right of ical environment; two, easy access to He concluded that what we need in the people peaceably to assemble and weapons whose only purpose is to kill the United States is not division. What to petition the government for a re- large numbers of human beings; and, we need is not hatred. What we need is dress of grievances. three, mental illness. not violence and lawlessness. It is love Not too long ago, another mentally The day after she read those words at and wisdom and compassion toward this podium, she flew home to Arizona ill person used the same kind of weap- one another. so she could stand in front of a on to kill 32 innocent people on the GABBY GIFFORDS’ work at that Tuc- Virginia Tech campus. In response we Safeway, intending to meet people son shopping mall on January 8 and all passed legislation eventually that en- peaceably assembled, and listen to peo- those present and all those victimized ple petition for a redress of their griev- abled States to provide the names of by a coward’s bullets were affirming ances. people that they judged were too men- Senator Kennedy’s vision that peaceful The SPEAKER pro tempore. The tally imbalanced to be buying guns and time of the gentleman has expired. provide those names to the National dialogue and understanding is the true Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield the gen- Instant Criminal Background Check calling of the American people, not di- tleman an additional 30 seconds. system. We authorized $250 million to vision and violence. As one who entered Congress with Mr. SHERMAN. I was relieved yester- enable them to do that. But since then, GABBY in the class of 2006—a tight-knit day when doctors said that they were we have appropriated each year less group that has met every Wednesday confident that the assassin had not than 10 percent of that amount. As a over the last 4 years—it has been an taken GABBY’s life. And I am confident result, of the 2.6 million people that honor to watch her on the Armed Serv- that that assassin did not take from the States know should be disqualified ices Committee, advocating for the Air our people the right to peaceably as- from buying firearms, less than 20 per- Force and for military families. Even semble and to tell their elected rep- cent are actually on that list and so during the lame duck session, she was resentatives their ideas and, yes, their disqualified. In fact, less than 4 percent a leader in enacting the GI Bill Patch, grievances. of Arizonans who the State knows which will make sure that the Guard I look forward to 2 years from now should be disqualified from purchasing and reservists will not be left out from and 2 years after that and 2 years after firearms are actually on that list and the GI Bill’s educational benefits. She that, to sitting here on this floor with unable to purchase those firearms. GABBY and waiting until she is called is an extraordinary person this country upon to read the First Amendment. b 1740 needs if we are going to overcome the Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- So perhaps we could consider fol- many challenges that we face today. fornia. Madam Speaker, contrary to lowing up on this resolution with some Madam Speaker, I strongly support my previous statement, I do have an- concrete steps to prevent this from passage of this resolution, which is an other speaker. At this time I would happening again. I know it is impor- affirmation that we will not surrender like to yield 2 minutes to the gen- tant to protect one’s individual free- our way of life to the forces of lawless- tleman from Tennessee, Dr. ROE. doms, but a little 9-year-old girl should ness and hate. Mr. ROE of Tennessee. Madam also have the freedom to visit with her On behalf of the people of eastern Speaker, I rise in support of this reso- Congresswoman, secure in the knowl- Connecticut, I want to express our awe lution, and I join my colleagues in de- edge that her Congress has the courage and reverence to the examples of nouncing the horrific attack that oc- to take reasonable steps to protect her human courage and excellence which curred against one of our own this past and our country from such senseless vi- GABBY GIFFORDS and the other victims weekend, and took the lives of six inno- olence. in Tucson displayed to the world last cent people, including a staff member, Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Saturday. Gabe Zimmerman, and a beautiful 9- fornia. I reserve the balance of my Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- year-old child. We continue to pray for time. fornia. I continue to reserve the bal- Congresswoman GIFFORDS and all those Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- ance of my time. injured, and the families of the de- er, I yield 2 minutes to the gentleman Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- ceased. from Connecticut (Mr. COURTNEY). er, I am proud to yield 2 minutes to the As Members of Congress we have two Mr. COURTNEY. Madam Speaker, gentlewoman from the District of Co- responsibilities after such an attack. the horror of Saturday’s bloodshed in lumbia (Ms. NORTON).

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00041 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.113 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H184 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 Ms. NORTON. I thank the gentleman When I heard of this tragedy, I imme- had been a place kicker at Iowa State for yielding. diately asked the question that each of University, where I graduated from col- Madam Speaker, a gunman has un- us here must have wondered dozens of lege and where I was an unknown walk- derestimated the will and undaunted times: How could anyone hate or seek on under Earl Bruce. And we talked bravery of GABBY GIFFORDS. to harm this wonderful public servant, about that. And I have in my office Tragically, we have lost Gabe Zim- this beautiful person, who has never this little print of Beardshear Hall at merman, her director of community spoken a cross word or shown a down- Iowa State University that my friend outreach; her constituents; Judge John cast expression throughout her time in GABBY gave to me that she got from Roll; Christina Taylor Green; Phyllis this great House? her brother Alex because she knew this Schneck; Dorwan Stoddard; and Doro- Though these answers are painfully was important to me. This little pic- thy Morris, all of whom were engaged slow in coming, I pray her return to ture is an emblem of what an amazing in the very civic activities we most en- the warm embrace of her family will be human being GABBY GIFFORDS is be- courage, along with 13 others who were swift. cause she was always thinking more of injured along with Congresswoman More selfishly, because she is my her friends than she was of herself. GIFFORDS. friend and because I see in her the pure I got on a red eye after first meeting Together, these Americans have heart of a servant, I pray she will re- GABBY GIFFORDS and flew back to my brought this House together as never turn to this Chamber as soon as pos- district and met an unknown Senator before for a much needed time of re- sible to continue her work for the peo- from Illinois who had just gotten elect- flection. I am heartbroken for all who ple of Arizona, whom she so treasures. ed named Barack Obama for the very were in the line of fire and for their GABBY knows at her core that she is an first time. That’s what is great about families. ordinary lady called to an extraor- this country is these random meetings I focus now on GABBY because I can- dinary mission. that we have with amazing people from not get her out of my consciousness. I all over the country who we meet on GABBY, you are a champion among am trying to understand her prescient champions, a friend among friends, and the House floor, many of whom came in fearlessness of her own safety in the a fighter among fighters for the com- in one of the largest classes in recent days before the attempt on her life mon good. We are all pulling for you. memory. You heard them come to the given what has happened to civil dis- Get well soon. We can’t wait to have floor today and talk about someone course in our country. you back. they barely knew or may have met Can GABBY’s selflessness and her con- Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- briefly or didn’t know at all, because cerns for our country give us the for- that is what binds us together is the fornia. I continue to reserve the bal- titude to follow her example in assum- spirit, the history of this Chamber and ance of my time. ing that it is not the safety of Members what it has meant as the people’s Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. I yield myself that is at risk? Do we dare follow House. such time as I may consume. GABBY in her search for ways to be at That is why it is incumbent on all of once resolute and respectful? Madam Speaker, this body is numb. us to take away as a lesson from this Remarkable courage and determina- We forget that we are a family, a dys- tragedy a renewed sense of respect for functional family at times, but that we tion have made GABRIELLE GIFFORDS each other and for the common purpose the living manifestation of what Mem- are a family. We all get to know each that brought us all here together in the bers of this institution and the citizens other, and we all have a common pas- first place. of our great country want to be. May sion for the values of this country, val- I talked about how we are a family. GABBY GIFFORDS’ words prove as con- ues that brought us here in the first Every Thanksgiving our family has a tagious as her courage. place. That is a remarkable story that tradition of watching a movie called Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- we have heard unfolding about our ‘‘Home for the Holidays’’ about a very fornia. I continue to reserve the bal- good friend GABBY GIFFORDS since this dysfunctional family. The star of that ance of my time. horrible tragedy first took place. movie is Holly Hunter. In one of the Mr. BRALEY of Iowa. Madam Speak- All of us in this body share a unique closing moments of this movie—which er, I am pleased to yield 2 minutes to sense of responsibility for what hap- like all good movies makes you laugh, the distinguished gentleman from pened to our dear friend, to her coura- makes you cry and makes you think— Maryland (Mr. CUMMINGS). geous staff and to the incredible people Holly Hunter’s father is down in the Mr. CUMMINGS. I thank the gen- who showed up to participate in democ- basement watching old home movies tleman for yielding. racy at that Safeway in Tucson on Sat- and he’s talking to her about one mo- Madam Speaker, like every speaker urday. I know that a lot of us had this ment in his life that took 5 seconds and today, I rise with a very heavy heart. shared experience of horror on Satur- made all the difference in the world in Our friend GABRIELLE GIFFORDS lies in day as we watched these horrible im- his relationship with his daughter. And a hospital bed, fighting desperately for ages appear in front of our eyes. he said, You were fearless, huh? Fear- her life. I want to briefly talk about my good less. At the same time, dozens are in friend GABBY. That is my friend, GABBY GIFFORDS. mourning for those killed in the sense- It is ironic that on this day when our She is fearless in what makes this job less slaughter, including Judge John President is in Tucson, honoring the worth having. That is why we have a Roll and our own Gabe Zimmerman— memory of those who lost their lives responsibility—to her and all the peo- Congresswoman GIFFORDS’ director of and those struggling to put their lives ple who lost their lives and who showed public outreach. back together, that my connection up at that town hall meeting because We join them in a grieving process with GABBY and President Obama go they care about this country—to make that is painful beyond words. back to the exact same day. It was Sep- a difference going forward in how we To those families, particularly that tember 29 of 2006. GABBY and I were talk to each other and how we care of Gabe’s, who reached out in GABBY’s both candidates for Congress. We met about each other. voice each and every day, we weep for at an event, and there were things As we look forward to next Monday, your loss and know of the constant about her that leaped off the page im- we should remember what Martin Lu- ache left in your hearts by the sudden mediately. ther King, Jr. taught us, that ‘‘the loss of those you loved, and we are moral arc of the universe is long, but it b 1750 blessed to join you in the celebration of bends toward justice.’’ We have a col- their lives. It was her passion for why she was lective duty, all of us, to make sure As we mourn those who were lost, we running, it was her fearlessness, and it that we bend that arc sooner and triumph, with equal emotion, in mir- was that smile that you’ve heard peo- quicker so that the American people acles. By the mercy of God and the ple talking about that could light up a realize that we are all in this together swift hands of our medical heroes, room. and that this is the people’s House for GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and many of those We got to talking about each other a reason. wounded by this madman have been and what we had in common; and I I want to thank my Republican col- saved. learned that her brother, Alex Giffords, leagues for their extreme sensitivity

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00042 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.116 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H185 and their devotion to this important cause I am involved in mankind. And, prayer and reflection for the victims of this resolution, and I thank my colleague therefore, never send to know for tragedy and for our Nation. from California for helping us put this whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.’’ Mr. ROTHMAN of New Jersey. Madam resolution together today. Mr. RUSH. Madam Speaker, it is with a Speaker, I rise today to join my colleagues in Madam Speaker, I yield back the bal- heavy heart that I rise this morning to pay trib- recognizing my friend, Congresswoman ance of my time. ute to my esteemed colleague from the great GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, members of her staff, Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- state of Arizona, U.S. Rep. GABRIELLE GIF- and other victims of the senseless attack fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield myself FORDS, who with God’s grace is still alive and which took place on January 8, 2011 in Tuc- such time as I may consume, and I rise appears to be heading toward a promising re- son, Arizona. in enthusiastic support of H. Res. 32. covery. I am grateful to God for His divine GABBY is kind, brilliant, beautiful, charming, Madam Speaker, I am privileged and intervention in the lives of those 13 other vic- intellectually curious, honest, and a powerful humbled to be able to close out this de- tims who, along with Rep. GIFFORDS, were presence. She is truly one of the most amaz- bate. I am not, as some who have come shot last Saturday at a shopping mall in Rep. ing people I’ve met in my life. She is devoted to the floor, a close personal friend of GIFFORDS’ Tucson, Arizona district. Right now, to public service for all the right reasons—to GABBY GIFFORDS; but I have, as have news accounts indicate that those 13 people make America stronger, safer, better–edu- others, been under her spell here. I will survive their injuries. cated and to protect America from its en- have had the chance to talk with her But, Madam Speaker, six people, including emies. She is thoroughly dedicated to her dis- on several occasions in an informal set- a nine–year–old girl, did not survive last Satur- trict and selflessly serves her constituents. Her ting, and I might mention that on each day’s gunfire by a young man who, by every constituents, even those who do not always of those occasions she reminded me account, is clearly mentally unbalanced. It is share her political views, respect her for being that she used to be Republican. I don’t my opinion that under no set of circumstances ready to help them and fight for what is right. know if that was her way of thinking should the gunman have been able to pur- I know my colleagues on both sides of the that maybe we could have a rapport— chase a handgun with a 30-round magazine. aisle recognize her as a person of great integ- you didn’t really need that with her be- That young man was able to wreak all this rity who fights tirelessly for her principles. cause of her openness and her smile, havoc in a matter of a few minutes before sev- Madam Speaker, my thoughts at this time but it was interesting. She always did eral courageous Americans rose to the occa- are with my friend GABBY. We are all hoping it with a smile, and she always did it sion as they quickly wrestled the assailant to and praying for her complete recovery, as well with an invitation to engage with her the ground. as for the families of those who were killed that is the mark of her. Today, however, is a day to honor the tragic and those who were wounded and are strug- We pray, all of us together, that she loss of life that took place last Saturday and gling to recover. Violence and threats have no and those others grievously wounded to also pray for the continued strength and full place in our democracy. will have a speedy and full recovery. recovery of Rep. GIFFORDS and the others Mr. GERLACH. Madam Speaker, I stand We pray for those who have lost their who survived. united today with my colleagues and our na- lives. We pray for this institution, that Rep. GIFFORDS is a brilliant woman who rep- tion as we remember those killed and wound- we will take the correct lessons out of resents the best of what a Member of this ed during the shootings on Saturday in Tuc- this tragedy. And when I use the word body should be. She keeps an abiding focus son, Arizona. ‘‘tragedy,’’ it is a tragedy on the side of on serving her constituents and, last Saturday, To the families, loved ones and friends of those who were attacked and the insti- she was in the midst of an open air forum, those who suddenly and senselessly lost their tution that was attacked. It is, how- ‘‘Congress on Your Corner,’’ where she and lives, I join my colleagues in extending our ever, the product of a criminal act, and her staff had assembled a portable congres- most sincere condolences and hope that they we should understand that. sional office to, literally, take the best of their find comfort during these extremely difficult Madam Speaker, it is always within legislative and constituent service ability di- days. our power to either take the proper les- rectly to the people who elected her to serve. To those still recovering in the hospital, in- sons from a particular incident or to Mr. Speaker, last Saturday, Rep. GIFFORDS cluding our respected colleague and dedicated discard them, to think deeply about and her staff were operating in the best tradi- public servant GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, we offer them or think of them superficially. I tions of this Congress and in the best tradi- our prayers for healing of the physical and believe that the fact that we have dedi- tions of our democracy. That is why it still emotional wounds inflicted during this cated this entire day to trying to find seems incredible to me that Americans as di- unprovoked and despicable attack. the right lessons out of that and to verse as nine–year–old Christina Taylor Green We also stand united today in expressing give proper respect to those who suf- to 79–year–old Phyllis Schneck, a mother of our deepest gratitude to all who demonstrated fered in this tragedy is evidence of the three and grandmother of seven, should come true courage and extraordinary heroism in that fact that we will attempt to take the to this public forum only to lose their lives to grocery store parking lot to prevent more lives proper lessons out of this. a deranged assailant with a gun. from being lost and provide care for their One is, of course, that this is the peo- This simply should not happen in our coun- neighbors in need. ple’s House. If you read the Constitu- try but, sadly, far too often it does. Lives were lost and forever changed in an tion, article I, it is clear that the Madam Speaker my prayers and support re- instant on Saturday. The anguish and sorrow House of Representatives is meant to main with Rep. GIFFORDS and her husband, will linger much longer. be the closest to the people of any of Captain Mark Kelly, a NASA astronaut, their That is why it is important to solemnly honor the Federal institutions. We all, in a family and the team of medical professionals the memories of the victims of this dark day real sense, no matter where we come and first responders who have done an amaz- and, as the resolution we are voting on today from, are institutionalists in that we ing job in helping Rep. GIFFORDS and the states, reaffirm our belief in a democracy in love this institution—we fought in other survivors to continue to improve. I also which all can participate and in which intimida- many ways to get here—but we honor extend my condolences to the six Americans tion and threats of violence cannot silence the one another by showing respect to one who lost their lives that day including Gabriel voices of any American. another and we honor our constituents Zimmerman, Rep. GIFFORDS’ community out- Mr. CARDOZA. Madam Speaker, I rise as well. reach director, who lost his life in the midst of today to say a few words honoring my friend Speaker BOEHNER has said, ‘‘An at- serving his community. and colleague, Rep. GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. tack on one is an attack on all.’’ That At another day and at another time I will I first came to know GABBY when she joined is true. Perhaps several hundred years amplify my voice and advocacy in a manner the Blue Dog Coalition, a group of moderate, ago the writer and the poet, John that I hope will make a dent in the wanton pro- fiscally conservative Democrats of whom I Donne, said it best. He said, ‘‘No man is liferation and availability of guns in our society have served as co-chairman. an island, entire of itself. Every man is to those who clearly should not have them. I came to know—and admire—GABBY more a piece of the continent, a part of the But, for now, I wish God’s peace and healing when I travelled to her district in southern Ari- main. If a clod be washed away by the power upon GABBY GIFFORDS and the other zona to host a town hall on agriculture with sea, Europe is the less, as well as if a survivors of this tragic event. her. promontory were, as well as if a manor I also pray for our President and for our Na- As all who have met her know, GABBY is a of thy friend’s or of thine own were; tion as we assemble in a spirit of community bright, energetic young woman who is deeply any man’s death diminishes me, be- tonight, in Tucson, in a national service of committed to public service. That inner

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00043 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.118 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H186 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 strength will no doubt carry her through this conducting a ‘‘Congress on Your Corner’’ all medical personnel who have worked tire- tragedy and to a full recovery. event, which gives her constituents an oppor- lessly throughout these difficult times. Your ef- As painful as it may be too admit, this trag- tunity to meet directly with her and raise forts undoubtedly saved lives and your dedica- edy was not unexpected. GABBY’s office had issues or ask questions of concern. All of us tion cannot be praised enough. been the target of violence before. conduct events like this in some form as often Again, my thoughts and prayers go out to And, as all of us who have held public as we can because it is such a fundamental the victims and their families. events over the past few years know, the aspect of our job. As Speaker BOEHNER said Mr. OWENS. Madam Speaker, I rise today anger and vitriol has been escalating. last week, ‘‘this is the people’s House.’’ Mov- to pay tribute to Congresswoman GABRIELLE Sadly, it was only a matter of time before ing forward, even in this time of grief and sad- GIFFORDS, her staff, their families and every- hateful speech turned to hateful action. ness, I believe it is important to keep it that one affected by the tragic events of January 8, Passionate public debate is essential to our way. Rather than inappropriately increasing 2011 in Tucson, Arizona. democracy. It is what our founders fought and the barriers between us and those who we It has been my honor to work with Con- died for, and it is what made the United States represent, we must stay committed to engag- gresswoman GIFFORDS here in Washington, unique among nations at our birth. ing in precisely the kind of activities that Con- and to call her a friend. Congresswoman GIF- But we must maintain respect and civility in FORDS gresswoman GIFFORDS and her staff under- has earned her reputation as a prag- our discussions. Elected officials have a re- took last Saturday. We must continue to travel matic, rational and clear-minded lawmaker, sponsibility to set an example and behave like around our communities and be in contact and we are all better for having served with statesmen. with those we represent. We must be more her. My wife and I have had the opportunity to The media have a responsibility to encour- accessible, not less. spend time with her and her husband, who are age debate, without feeding the flames of Madam Speaker, as we struggle to make truly patriotic and dedicated Americans not de- anger. sense of these horrific events, one thing re- serving of this fate. And the public has a responsibility to stand mains perfectly clear to all of us in public life: The details of this horrifying event are still up and be strong voices in our democracy, this type of incident cannot be condoned—and coming to light, but in these uncertain times it without degrading the debate into petty name- is my hope that we can come together to bring our accessibility to our constituents cannot be calling. relief to the victims and justice to those re- curtailed—if our nation is to endure as a As one of my colleagues said recently about sponsible, not point partisan fingers or score democratic republic. a verbal attack made against him, ‘‘It’s not Before I close, I again wanted to join my political points. We owe it to those lost or what you meant to say that matters, or even colleagues in remembering all the victims and wounded in this senseless crime to grieve for how I understand it. What matters is how your rededicating ourselves to the enduring Amer- the fallen, pray for those in recovery and re- words are interpreted by the least sane person flect on how we might better serve our office ican values which Congresswoman GIFFORDS in my district.’’ and her staff embody: openness, accessibility, and the work of this great nation. I look forward to the day—hopefully soon— Madam Speaker, I know I speak for all my and a sincere commitment to serve those who when we will see GABBY back on this floor, colleagues in wishing her a speedy recovery. we represent. fighting for her constituents in southern Ari- I look forward to working with her again soon Mr. MCKEON. Madam Speaker, I rise today in the halls of Congress. zona. to join the entire House Armed Services family Until then, instead of pointing fingers and Mr. MILLER of Florida. Madam Speaker, in my shock and sadness at the shooting of playing the blame game, let’s take this tragedy Saturday was a tragic day for America. Like Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and as an opportunity to return civility to our de- most Americans, my wife Vicki and I felt a pro- members of her staff. The tragic events that found loss because of the senseless attacks mocracy. occurred this past Saturday give us all reason Mr. TIERNEY. Madam Speaker, I join my at a Congress on your Corner event held by to come together and reflect on the frailty of colleagues in supporting this resolution. On Representative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. human life—my thoughts and prayers go out behalf of the hundreds of thousands of resi- GABBY serves with me on the House Armed to GABBY, to her family, and to all the victims dents and families I represent in Massachu- Services Committee, and all of us who have of this heinous crime. Violent acts of this na- setts, I respectfully offer my deepest sym- worked with her hold her in the highest re- ture have no place in our democratic society, pathies and condolences to the families, gards as a hard-working public servant. The and it is my hope that justice will be swift for violent attack on a Member of Congress, her friends and loved ones of those who were those who perpetrated this attack. killed last Saturday in Tucson, Arizona. I want staff, and innocent constituents was not only I spoke with GABBY just before the holidays attack against humanity; it was also an attack to express my support for those who were in- and am reminded of her tireless efforts to jured. Let’s hope their recovery is swift. on our freedom and democracy. work across party lines in representing Arizo- Throughout the history of our Nation, Ameri- Our focus right now must remain on hon- na’s 8th Congressional District, as well as her oring the lives that were lost and the lives that cans have stood together in times of tragedy. unwavering support for our men and women in Today we gather to honor that tradition and will never be the same as a result of this un- uniform. Today we rise to honor the service of speakable attack. However, as we turn to display our unwavering support for GABBY and Representative GIFFORDS and offer our the other victims and families affected by this each other, seek solace and mourn, we can- thoughts and prayers for her, her family, and attack. Let one man’s senseless act not over- not lose sight of the fact that extraordinary all victims of this attack. shadow her service, or the lives of those who heroism and selfless courage could be found Mr. MARINO. Madam Speaker, I rise today were tragically lost. amid the horror of that day. The worst of trag- to express my heartfelt sorrow for the tragic Vicki and I continue to pray for her full re- edies brought out the best of humanity, as it and senseless attack on Representative covery, for her family and staff and all of those so often does. There were men and women of GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, her staff and constitu- whose lives were gravely impacted and for- all ages, who, in some cases, were injured ents. I especially want to offer my condo- ever changed. themselves, shielding children from harm, lences to the families of Christina Taylor Mr. FARR. Madam Speaker, oh sister how tending to the injured, and apprehending the Green, Judge John Roll, Dorothy Morris, Phyl- I have cried, prayed, and listened to stories gunman. All of them put their own lives at risk lis Schneck, Dorwan Stoddard, and Gabriel about you. I am so sorry for your pain of to help save others. Zimmerman. Their memories will live on in the losses, and your pain through your recovery. I’d also like to convey the heartache and hearts of all Americans. But I am, at the same time, so proud of you concern of my constituents—and all Ameri- I would also like to send my best wishes to and delighted you are alive. cans—for my colleague, Congresswoman those who were wounded during the attack, For all the wrong reasons, today the world GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. As so many have noted, particularly our colleague Representative GIF- rightfully knows what a remarkable person you GABBY is a smart and honorable member of FORDS. We hope for your speedy and com- are. They know how fortunate our country has Congress, but even more so, she is a great plete recovery. been to have you in public service. You still person—a warm, caring, thoughtful, and a Also important to remember are the heroic haven’t stopped serving, because your injured hard-working public servant who strives and actions of the individuals who put their lives on life has given hope to millions that you will re- succeeds in making a real difference for the the line to bring down the gunman before he cover—and that those with like kinds of inju- people and community she represents. Our had the opportunity to reload his weapon. ries may also have a chance. You are a na- hearts go out to GABBY’s husband, Mark Kelly, Without your quick thinking and brave inter- tional role model for public service-brave, kind, her parents and family, and her dedicated staff vention this tragedy could have been much friendly, accessible and effective. in Washington and Arizona. worse. While praying for your life I recalled every It is well-known now that this shooting oc- Finally, it is important to recognize the conversation we had and each photo I have curred while Congresswoman GIFFORDS was emergency responders, nurses, doctors, and taken of you and Mark.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00044 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\K12JA7.067 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H187 I remember when you were first elected in 9-year-old Christina Taylor Green, there to her, she’s worked honestly and tirelessly to your great class of freshman. I was so proud meet her representative because she wanted bridge that divide. There are few greater goals to meet the woman that took Jim Kolbe’s to become involved in government; Dorothy in public life than bringing people together and place. You had been a Fulbright Scholar in Morris, there with her husband of over 50 creating unity. Whatever your politics, Rep- Mexico. We talked about your student life years, George, who was critically injured trying resentative GIFFORDS is a listener and a seek- there and my similar age experience of being to shield his wife from the shooting; federal er of solutions. In politics and in life, that is a in Peace Corps in South America—how we district Judge John Roll, who had just come rare thing. had parallel experiences serving in the Ari- from Mass, which he attended daily; Phyllis She spread that ethic to her staff, as Tuc- zona and California legislatures. Schneck, age 79, who was spending the win- son knows very well. Gabe Zimmerman, her Starting with that first conversation, we both ter in Arizona; and Dorwan Stoddard, a 76- director of community outreach, had an incred- knew we were like brother and sister in a year-old retired construction worker, who ible and contagious desire to help people and large body of Congress. Over the years I grew shielded his wife Mavy, who sustained injuries make their lives better. When we speak of amazed at how hard you worked, and it made in the shooting. And also slain was Gabe Zim- public service, we sometimes forget the many me wonder if you ever had time for yourself. merman, the 30-year-old community outreach unelected but no less dedicated men and Obviously meeting and marrying Mark, an ad- director for Congresswoman GIFFORDS, a con- women whose work enriches the city, district, mired astronaut, gave you an added value to gressional staffer like the thousands of dedi- state or country they serve. Tucson, and I life. This might be why you always came to cated public servants we have the privilege of hope the country, will never forget public serv- work so happy. I pray that you never lose your working with in this House. Just there doing a ants like Gabe. He will be missed by more happiness, as it always lightens up the room job he loved serving the people. people than he could ever know. for others. But I do worry about how tough I haven’t had the privilege of getting to know Judge Roll was a strong, honest and effec- your district has made your campaign de- GABBY as well as some have, but she and I tive advocate for the American justice system, mands, and thus on your personal life. shared an interest in keeping the space pro- and his loss will be deeply felt. Christina Your recovery keeps me smiling, after the gram strong. I pray for her full recovery and Green, at only 9 years old, had already made tears of tragedy, to watch you—once again— look forward to working with her again when an impression on everyone around her and show me—while sitting in the Chamber—the she returns to this House. From what I know will be long remembered. Dorwan Stoddard, a marred of politicians on your Blackberry. of her through other colleagues, GABBY GIF- committed and long-time church volunteer, re- GABBY you are the only member that has the FORDS epitomizes what every member of this portedly died saving his wife’s life by shielding full schedule of NASA launches and landings body aspires to be: a dedicated, courageous her from gunfire. Dorothy Morris and her hus- at your finger tips. This is just another exam- public servant with a heart of service and an band, George, were together on that tragic ple of how clever you are in application of optimism about America that is infectious. day as they had been for the past 55 years of technology to political life style. Madam Speaker, we honor the memory of their happy marriage, and her daughters and So today our colleagues stand in the Cham- those whose lives were taken last Saturday family will hold her memory very close. Phyllis ber to salute you, to mourn the loss of other and express our heartfelt condolences to their Schneck was an outgoing mother and grand- wonderful people, and to begin the dialogue families and friends, and we pray for those mother known for her generosity and devotion on what we have learned from your tragic en- who were wounded that they will recover to her family, and our thoughts go out to her counters. quickly, including our colleague, GABBY GIF- and her loved ones today. I hope that we can learn and honor the vic- FORDS. Alongside the victims of this tragedy, I tims, with smarter gun control and better fund- Mr. SMITH of Texas. Madam Speaker, would like to take a moment to recognize the ing for mental health treatment. And I hope we today we honor Congresswoman GIFFORDS. many heroes of that day—people who offered can develop a better understanding that hate The House stands together in support of her medical assistance, alerted law enforcement, talk and negative campaigning leaves the and in condemnation of a senseless attack prevented further violence or assisted in too wrong impression for young people growing that severely injured her and claimed six lives. many other ways to count. This resolution up in our society. A democracy based on neg- I have served with Representative GIFFORDS names Patricia Maisch, Army Col. Bill Badger, ative talk can not survive. on the Science Committee, and am grateful Roger Sulzgeber, Joseph Zimudio, and Daniel I pray that you fully recover. I lost my 17- for this opportunity to speak about her char- Hernandez, Jr. To that list we can add brave year-old sister from a horse accident, while acter and professionalism. people like Steven Rayle, an MD who was at she was visiting me in Colombia during my Representative GIFFORDS is a warm, friendly the event and offered emergency medical at- time with the Peace Corps. It was just months individual who is genuinely interested in oth- tention to the wounded, and many others after my mother had died of cancer. My sister ers, and who always maintains an upbeat atti- whose names may emerge over time. Nancy died because of the lack of medical tude. It is in the spirit of unity that we all go for- care available in the rural hospital. So I am She works hard to improve the lives of her ward together. As difficult as this time has extremely relieved that the availability of good constituents, and is engaged and energized been for Tucson and the Nation, this can be medical science and a rapid response saved about issues of concern to them. She also a moment when the best is truly in each of us. your life. goes out of her way to be accessible, which This can be a time when the truest values of We all look forward to seeing you back on is exactly what she was doing when this trag- humanity join us all—values that let us mourn the floor of the House of Representatives. You edy occurred. appropriately, reflect together, take time for have always been the spirit of public service, The reprehensible attack that took place has ourselves, and bring us closer. At this mo- and will continue to be forever more. God united us as Members of Congress and re- ment, there is no greater goal than to heal our bless you GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. minded us that while the act of a lone gunman wounds and grow stronger. Mr. WOLF. Madam Speaker, I join with my cannot always be prevented, we must make Out of great tragedy and sorrow, there will colleagues today to honor the 6 who died and sure that justice prevails and that our demo- be a new America. Pain brings people to- the 14 who were wounded, including our own cratic ideals remain secure. gether and reminds us of the time we all share colleague GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, in the horror We hope and pray for Representative GIF- on this Earth. It also reminds us of the value which unfolded last Saturday morning in Tuc- FORDS’ full recovery. of being good to one another, and how easily son, Arizona. Mr. GRIJALVA. Madam Speaker, I rise we forget ourselves in a heated moment. Pain, I was at home Saturday checking my today to honor the memories of Gabe Zimmer- as horrible as it is, is inevitable. Our lives can- iPhone when I saw the shocking news of the man, Judge John Roll, Christina-Taylor Green, not be free of it. What matters now—what al- shootings and that Congresswoman GIFFORDS Dorothy Morris, Dorwan Stoddard, and Phyllis ways matters—is how we respond to it. and her staff were among the victims. What I Schneck. I rise also to voice my sincere hope Our most important response will not be po- read was hard to comprehend. She and her for the recovery of our friend and colleague, litical—it will be simply human. It will be to staff were doing their jobs, back in her district Representative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, and the build bridges and remember those who have on a weekend, meeting with constituents in others who were injured in Saturday’s terrible died. Public life should be about bringing peo- the finest example of representative govern- shooting. The loss to the Congressional com- ple together; so should private life. We are ment. And in a split second, the lives of those munity and to Tucson has already been great. stronger and more human when we are to- there were forever changed, and in a larger We can only hope the loss will not become gether. That’s true of a family, a community, context, all of our lives have changed. even greater. and a country. In a very real sense, a coun- My heart and prayers go out to those who Representative GIFFORDS serves a politically try—our country—is a family. Families may lost their lives and to their families. There was divided community. As long as I have known fight, disagree and say things they regret, but

VerDate Mar 15 2010 03:43 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00045 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.027 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H188 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 in the end, they come together. They rejoin It has been an honor to serve alongside of her public figures have increasingly utilized polit- their hands and make peace. This is a time to on the Armed Services Committee, and I have ical rhetoric that includes violent imagery to make peace in America. witnessed first-hand her dedication. make a point. We can do better. We must do There are few occasions to offer a call for GABRIELLE’s passion for her job is evident to better. national unity, and in our lifetimes there will be all those who know her, and it is no surprise As someone who knew the late Dr. Martin few others. I sincerely hope the next is not an- to me that GABRIELLE was doing what she Luther King, I have drawn inspiration during other tragedy. With that hope, today I add my loves most on that horrible Saturday. I look this crisis from one of his statements. Dr. King voice to the many who call for a stronger na- forward to her full and speedy recovery, and believed that ‘‘nonviolence means avoiding not tional family. There is nothing more important. I anxiously await her return to Congress. only external physical violence but also inter- Mr. RUNYAN. Madam Speaker, along with While I am hopeful about GABRIELLE’s re- nal violence of spirit. You not only refuse to the rest of the American people, I was covery, I am heartbroken over the deaths of shoot a man, but you refuse to hate him.’’ As shocked and saddened by news of the Janu- the six innocent people caught at the wrong we approach the Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., ary 8, 2011 attack on Congresswoman place, at the wrong time. Christina Taylor holiday, I hope we can reflect on these words GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, her Congressional staff, Green, who was only 9 years old, was re- and his teachings and make our world a more Judge John Roll, and her constituents at a cently elected to her school’s student council just and peaceful place. public event in Tucson, Arizona. and hoped to speak with a government official Mr. LUJA´ N. Madam Speaker, it is with a Congresswoman GIFFORDS is a dedicated that tragic day. Pennsylvania native and Fed- heavy heart that I rise today to mourn the vic- public servant who was engaging in the most eral judge, John Roll, was hoping to meet with tims of Saturday’s tragic shooting that took the important role we have as Members of Con- his Congresswoman to discuss overcrowding lives of six people, injured numerous others, gress: interacting with and listening to our con- of prisons. Gabriel Zimmerman was struck and left our friend and colleague, GABRIELLE stituents. January 8, 2011 was indeed a sad while carrying out his duties as the Congress- GIFFORDS, fighting for her life. In an instant, day for our Nation and this sick and senseless woman’s Director of Community Outreach. the Tucson community, and indeed the entire act of violence in Arizona has no place in our Dorothy Morris, Dorwan Stoddard, and Phyllis country, was shocked by the senseless vio- society. Schneck were going about their regular Satur- lence and saddened by the loss. My thoughts and prayers are with Congress- day activities and hoped they would get a For four years, GABBY GIFFORDS has been a woman GIFFORDS and the other victims of this chance to speak with their member of Con- well-respected member of this body, serving unfathomable attack. May their families and gress. her constituents with determination and dis- friends find comfort and strength in knowing Madam Speaker, I hope that all those tinction. To those who know her, it comes as the American people are with them in spirit touched by these tragic events find peace and no surprise that she is fighting with such te- during this difficult time. comfort. Saturday, January 8, 2011 should be nacity to recover from this severe injury. I wish Mr. AL GREEN of Texas. Madam Speaker, a reminder to all Americans that there is no her all the best on a full and speedy recovery today I extend sympathies and well wishes to place for violence in a free political process. I and look forward to the day when we will wel- my colleague, Congresswoman GABRIELLE continue to pray for those that were lost and come her back to this chamber. GIFFORDS of the 8th Congressional District of for the recovery of those who were wounded, I know I join with my constituents in New the State of Arizona. I wish a speedy recovery and I hope we as a country can move forward Mexico in honoring those who lost their lives for this remarkable woman who has dedicated and learn from this tragedy. in this heinous attack, those who wanted noth- her life and career in service to her constitu- Mr. CONYERS. Madam Speaker, today I ing more than to be part of our democratic ents. rise in support of House Resolution 32, ex- process and speak with their elected rep- I would also like to extend my deepest con- pressing the sense of the House of Rep- resentative or dedicate themselves to public dolences to the families of the victims who resentatives with respect to the tragic shooting service. Their memory will not be forgotten. were fatally wounded: nine-year-old Christina in Tucson, Arizona, on January 8, 2011. Last My thoughts and prayers are with all of those Taylor Green, Congressional Staffer Gabe Saturday’s senseless and vile act of violence involved in this tragedy as well as their fami- Zimmerman, Federal Judge John Roll, and Ar- wounded Congresswoman GIFFORDS at an lies and friends during this difficult time. izona citizens Dorwin Stoddard, Phyllis event with her constituents. Six Americans Mr. LEWIS of Georgia. Madam Speaker, Schneck, as well as Dorothy Morris. To the were tragically killed and 14 others, including today I rise with a heavy heart at this moment people of Tucson, Arizona affected by this relatives of the slain, are recovering. of great sadness in our nation’s history. The random, senseless act of violence, my First, above all else, I want to express how violence we witnessed last weekend in Ari- thoughts and prayers remain with you. deeply saddened I am by this weekend’s zona still seems so unreal, so shocking, so As they work through the ineffable tragedy events. Congresswoman GIFFORDS is a dedi- unbelievable. Only a few days ago, Rep- which befell this community on Saturday, Jan- cated public servant, a cherished colleague, resentative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS stood in the uary 8, 2011, I must commend the tireless ef- and a friend. I join with all Americans in wish- well of the House reading the First Amend- forts of Pima County’s first responders, as well ing GABBY and the other wounded a speedy ment, and today she is fighting to regain her as the efforts of bystanders in their role to re- recovery. I also mourn the loss of those who ability to speak. store and maintain order during this tragedy. passed. Gabriel Zimmerman was Congress- I keep hoping that in the midst of this great With their efforts, lives were saved. woman GIFFORDS’ community outreach direc- tragedy, we will say enough is enough. I keep America is mourning both for the victims of tor. Dorwin Stoddard, a retiree, was waiting in hoping we will finally find it necessary to teach this tragedy and for the assault against our line with his wife to speak to the Congress- the way to love, the way of peace and non-vi- constitutional right to peaceably assemble. woman and protected his wife from the gun- olence, not only to our children, but that we That our citizens can fall under attack while man’s bullets. The youngest victim was 9- will embrace it among ourselves as adults and upholding our Democratic values is deplor- year-old Christina Green who had just been as national leaders. We pray a special prayer able. We must never allow an act of violence elected to her elementary school’s student today for all of the people of Arizona, but es- to thwart this right. council. Dorothy Murray was a retired home- pecially GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and her husband I ask my colleagues to join me in support of maker and her husband was among the in- Mark Kelly. the Resolution before this chamber today jured. Phyllis Schneck, also a retiree and a Representative GIFFORDS is one of the most which condemns this indiscriminate act of vio- New Jersey native, spent winters in Arizona. hopeful, optimistic people you would ever want lence and honors Representative GIFFORDS as Chief Judge John Roll was a respected jurist to meet. She is wonderful. She is smart, and she fights to recover. who served on the federal bench since 1991 she is beautiful. I hope that one day soon she Mr. BRADY of Pennsylvania. Madam and became Chief Judge in 2006. will rejoin us in this chamber. My thoughts and Speaker, I rise today to offer my condolences Last Saturday, Representative GABRIELLE prayers are with the victims and the families of regarding the terrible events that took place on GIFFORDS was doing the people’s business, all those who were hurt, those who are still Saturday, January 8, 2011, in Tucson, Ari- meeting constituents in front of a local grocery struggling to be made whole, and with the zona. The attempted assassination of Rep- store and explaining how government, can im- families of all those who were slain. May God resentative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and the killing prove their lives. She was doing her job: con- bless them all in these difficult hours. of six people, including a 9-year-old child, a necting her constituents to their government. Mr. INSLEE. Madam Speaker, it is with a federal judge, and a congressional aide, is an The tragic event should cause us all to stop heavy heart that I rise to support House Reso- unspeakable tragedy. and consider what more we can to do to lution 32, expressing the sense of the House Congresswoman GIFFORDS is not only an change the tone of our national politics. In re- of Representatives with respect to the tragic esteemed colleague of mine, she is my friend. cent years, it seems that politicians and other shooting in Tucson, Arizona, on January 8,

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00046 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.029 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H189 2011. Our thoughts and prayers are with the can all agree that too often these days our po- Mr. RANGEL. Madam Speaker, I rise to ask victims and their loved ones, including my litical rhetoric has gotten overheated and vitri- all Americans to join me in my prayers for friend and colleague GABBY GIFFORDS, the Gif- olic. Lower our voices and raise our commit- Representative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS’ speedy fords staff, and all who are mourning this trag- ment to peaceful resolve. and full recovery. I extend my thoughts to her edy in Arizona and across the Nation. I want to make this very clear, this is not husband, Captain Mark Kelly, their family, and The events of this weekend are difficult to about being on the left or the right—the shoot- those of all the staff and constituents who comprehend. GABBY is a champion for her ing in Tucson was an attack on all Americans were innocent victims of this traumatic event. constituents and it was because of her devo- from a perpetrator who tried to strike at the At a time like this we should also remember tion to them that she was outside a local gro- very heart of our great democracy. that all of our staffs could be in harm’s way, cery store the Saturday morning when she Being from Paterson, NJ and it being the just by working with us. Staff is a vital part of nearly lost her life. As the tragedy unfolded, day after Alexander Hamilton’s birthday, I am our lives, and without them we would not be she was surrounded by a group of dutiful staff reminded of one of the greatest political de- able to function. While everyone is concerned and constituents, including an intern who may bates in the history of our Nation between Al- about Members’ safety, I think we should also have saved her life, and many who so unbe- exander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson. be concerned for our staff. lievably lost their own lives or were injured. The nature of the debate between Hamilton Such act of violence on GABBY, her staff I have gotten to know GABBY through our and Jefferson was as monumental in their day and constituents is a threat to the virtue of shared efforts to advance renewable energy as it is in ours—their arguments went to the open government and has no place in our de- policies, including our working together on the very core of our Nation in its infancy and the mocracy. Concern for safety should not stand Sustainable Energy and Environment Coali- issues they debated remain contested to this between public officials and the people. My tion. She’s bright and engaging, and is always day—yet despite the gravity of their discussion constituents in Upper Manhattan have a spe- bringing in fresh ideas to achieve solutions to not once did they cross the line from fierce cial understanding of this tragedy because of our Nation’s energy problems. My heart is with disagreement to considering violent solutions. the amount of gun violence we have in the her and her husband at this moment as she I hope we will use this occasion to pause district. fights for her recovery. If there is anyone who and recognize that in our great Nation we GABBY is one of the most charming and bril- can pull through, I believe it will be GABBY. each have a responsibility to stand shoulder- liant stars I have seen in Congress. She is a It is in times like these that I believe our Na- to-shoulder with our fellow citizens in times true dedicated public servant who works tire- tion can rise above our past and shine brighter both good and bad. lessly for the people of her district and our than we have before. While it will take time to Names of the Victims: Chief Judge John great country. I have great love and affection learn exactly why this has happened, I hope Roll, 63; Christina Taylor Green, 9; Dorothy for GABBY and I look forward to seeing my that as we heal, our Nation will find a way to Morris, 76; Phyllis Scheck, 79; Dorwan Stod- dear colleague and friend back in Washington be more compassionate, understanding and dard, 76; and Gabriel ‘‘Gabe’’ Zimmerman, 30, very soon. peaceful. (GIFFORDS’s staff as a Community Outreach Mr. QUIGLEY. Madam Speaker, I rise today Mr. PASCRELL. Mr. Speaker, I rise with all Director). in support of H. Res. 32 and to offer my of my colleagues here to honor the victims of Mr. SERRANO. Madam Speaker, it is with thoughts and prayers for my friend and col- the tragedy in Tuscon and to speak of our heartfelt sadness that today I remember those league GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, as well as the 18 great colleague GABBY GIFFORDS. who lost their lives in this bravery in trying to other victims of Saturday’s unthinkable tragedy We are all encouraged by the signs of re- stop the gunman. I remember those who were in Tucson. covery that GABBY is showing every day she wounded and even now are fighting to recover I hope and pray for the wellbeing of all has been in the hospital. Our prayers are with from their wounds. I remember all of the family those battling for their lives and offer my deep- her, her husband Commander Mark Kelly and members who are struggling with great losses. est condolences to those who did not sur- her entire family. Finally, I remember with hope for her speedy vive—Christina Taylor Green, Dorothy Morris, As Co-Chair of the Traumatic Brain Injury recovery, Representative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. Judge John M. Roll, Phyllis Schneck, Dorwin Taskforce I know GABBY faces a long road. This is a sad time for our Nation, a time Stoddard, and Gabe Zimmerman. My heart We now she is receiving the best care in the when we reflect on how all too often violence goes out to the families and loved ones of all world—but even more importantly we all know strikes and randomly takes some of our best involved. that she’s a fighter and that’s exactly what and brightest. All of the lives that were lost Congress on Your Corner is democracy in she’s doing now. were special to those who loved them—to action. Ms. GIFFORDS, her staff, and everyone On Monday in honor of the victims in Tuc- their spouses and their children and their attending Saturday’s event were doing what son I called for a Week of Solidarity in the 8th grandchildren. Judge John Roll was a public this country is built on: participating in a con- District of New Jersey. official serving our country with distinction and versation between an elected official and the I love that word ‘‘solidarity’’ and all it rep- dedication. Christina Taylor Green was a people she represents. As sadness gives way resents. I wanted all our faith leaders to hold young child with an interest in learning more to reflection, I hope we will remain committed services and events this week—in order for about how government works. I hope that in to that ideal. our collective community to reflect on this na- the future our children will be able to meet Just 2 years ago, I was a new member of tional tragedy and pray for the victims and with their representatives without endangering this body. GABBY GIFFORDS greeted me with their families and for all of America. their lives. warmth, kindness, and friendship. With all my As tragically occurred in Tucson, too many As a Member of Congress who has worked heart, I hope to one day return the favor. of our communities have been afflicted by gun with Representative GIFFORDS, I am especially Mrs. CHRISTENSEN. Madam Speaker, I violence—as a nation now is the time to heal touched by this senseless tragedy. Represent- rise to join my colleagues in support of this with our words and find unity where there may ative GIFFORDS is a very friendly, hard working resolution and to offer heartfelt sympathies oil be strife. colleague. She is someone who is easy to get behalf of myself, my family, staff and the peo- I find it especially appropriate that the end along with and always willing to chat and lend ple of the U.S. Virgin Islands to the people of of this week will culminate with the observ- a helping hand. She was doing what is ex- the Eighth District of Arizona, our colleague ance of Martin Luther King Day—a man who pected of all of us who represent our constitu- GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, her staff, their families gave our entire Nation the chance to find soli- ents—we meet with our constituents and we and all others who were hurt or killed in the darity with each other—it is a bond that serves listen to their concerns and we try to help tragic and senseless attack in Tucson, Ari- us well in the wake of this tragedy. them. That is what we were elected to do— zona. The victims in Tucson truly embody the and so it is especially hard to see that one of Everywhere that I went at home, my con- greatest spirit of our Nation, you had individ- our own was injured while doing—what we all stituents responded with outrage, but also uals from every different background, both do—our job. prayerfully to this horrendous event. Our young and old, coming together as citizens to Please let me conclude by saying that my churches devoted Sunday services in memory take part in one of the most essential rites of thoughts and prayers are with all of those who of those who died, offered prayers for speedy our representative democracy—it is indeed died or were injured and with the families who and full recovery tor those injured, for the af- government of the people, by the people, for loved them. My prayers are with Representa- fected families, for the residents of the district the people. tive GIFFORDS as she recovers and my hope and for our nation as well as in grateful tribute I hope we will all look towards GABBY’s ex- is that soon she will be back with us here in to all who responded and continue to respond. ample and use it to guide us towards a better the House of Representatives where she be- We joined our fellow Americans in the mo- public discourse with each other—I think we longs. ment of silence on Monday.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00047 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.030 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H190 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 I, like all of my colleagues, and all public fig- 50 years, George, at a retirement community Now is a time for reflection. My prayers and ures understand and accept the risks of being just north of Tucson. When the shots rang out, condolences are with the fallen victims’ fami- in public office and we and those charged with George, a former Marine and retired airline lies and with those, including GABBY, who are the responsibility of protecting us act to miti- pilot, threw himself on his wife in an attempt making their way along the long road to recov- gate these risks. However we are here to rep- to shield her from the bullets. George survived ery from the injuries they suffered. May our resent the residents of our districts and are after suffering two gunshot wounds; Dorothy nation honor the loss of innocent lives with committed to doing what is needed to do so did not. greater peace and understanding. to the best of our ability. That means that we Judge John Roll, age 63, was the chief Mr. RAHALL. Madam Speaker, West Vir- must meet, listen and interact with our con- judge of Arizona’s Federal district court. Ap- ginians’ hearts are heavy for our fellow citi- stituents as much as possible. This incident pointed to the Federal bench in 1991 by Presi- zens lost last weekend in Tucson, Arizona. To will not prevent us from doing so, dent George H.W. Bush, Judge Roll was a those recovering, our dear colleague, GABBY But just as we continue to carry out our du- widely respected jurist by his colleagues. GIFFORDS, our thoughts and fervent prayers ties, it is the responsibility of everyone, but Known for this deep Catholic faith, it is re- are offered. particularly those who have a public platform, ported that Judge Roll was simply stopping by Our country’s resolve is strengthened each to be responsible in what they communicate to the event to say hello to his friend, GABBY, time it is tested. Citizen participation is the the public and how. after morning mass. Judge Roll is survived by democratic bedrock of our more perfect Union. There are many who warned that the in- his wife, Maureen, their three sons, and five Representative GIFFORDS understands the creasingly inflammatory rhetoric of the past grandchildren. value of constant constituent conversation, year, especially as the campaigns got under- Phyllis Schneck, age 79, a widow and re- and her example shines as a beacon for pub- way, could lead to some kind of violent action. tired homemaker, was a native of Rutherford, lic office holders throughout our Republic to That being said I do not intend to point fin- New Jersey, where she would return during follow. gers or cast blame, but ask only that each and the hot Tucson summers. Phyllis is known by May GABBY’s dedication to others serve her every one of us here and across this country her three children, seven grandchildren, and recovery, as the blessings we celebrate in the honestly and fully examine our hearts, our great-granddaughter as a talented cook, and Book of Ruth, ‘‘a restorer of thy life, and a consciences and our past words and actions she spent much of her retirement volunteering nourisher of thine old age.’’ and ensure that going forward all that we do at her church. According to her daughter, Mrs. BACHMANN. Madam Speaker, today I and say reflect respect and unity instead of Phyllis was a registered Republican who was join with my colleagues in condemning the discord, divisiveness and violence. not involved in politics, but Representative savage attack in Tucson last Saturday that As someone who has abhorred violence GIFFORDS was ‘‘the first person she really took shattered the lives of so many innocent vic- and worked for peace all of my life, I have had a liking to.’’ tims, and their families and friends, and broke the great privilege and honor of joining my dis- Dorwin Stoddard, age 76, was a Tucson na- the heart of a nation. Since the news of this tinguished colleague JOHN LEWIS and the Faith tive and leader in his church. Dorwin attended awful tragedy, I have prayed through tears for and Politics Institute almost every year that the event with his wife Mavy, a high school comfort, and for peace in the midst of the they have held it on the civil rights pilgrimage classmate who he reunited with and married storm, for the families of the six people whose to pay tribute to all who work for justice and after both their former spouses passed away. lives were senselessly ended by a gunman equality but also to renew my dedication to After seeing Mavy shot and wounded, Dorwin who had no concern for human life. I have non-violence and my commitment to furthering threw himself on her and shielded her from also been praying for healing for those who the beloved community envisioned by the Rev. the spray of bullets. As Dorwin’s stepdaughter were injured; among them a respected col- Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. noted, ‘‘What a way to go, as the hero, he league and friend, GABBY GIFFORDS. It is a spiritual, renewing and life enriching— lived that kind of a life.’’ GABBY and I came to Congress together in for some, life changing experience—and I Gabe Zimmerman, age 30, was the Director 2006. Over the years we have often voted dif- would urge as many as can to attend this of Community Outreach for Representative ferently. From time to time, we found our- year. GIFFORDS. Oftentimes the face of Representa- selves at opposite ends of the table during Our colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS, as many tive GIFFORDS’s office to her constituents, as media interviews, offering contrasting view- have already said and everyone now knows is one of his colleagues said, ‘‘Gabe helped peo- points. But the moment we stepped away from a special person. Many of us supported her ple for a living.’’ Gabe was engaged to be the set, we greeted each other as we often did during what was an extremely difficult and un- married with a wedding date set for 2012. on the House floor, as friends, with a hug, a necessarily bitter campaign. She may not The youngest victim, Madam Speaker, was warm smile, and a few precious moments of have always voted as I would have wanted Christina Taylor Green, age 9, a third grade conversation. I cherished those times with her to, but she is without a doubt fearless and student at Mesa Verde Elementary School. GABBY, and I look forward to renewing them faithful in the representation of her district and Christina had recently been elected to the stu- as she recovers and returns to the good, faith- all of us respect her highly and love her dear- dent council and was inspired into politics by ful, and hard-working service that she has ly. We thank God that she is progressing well President Obama’s 2008 campaign. A neigh- given to the people of Arizona’s 8th District. and we pray for her full and speedy recovery. bor brought Christina to the event to meet her I am rejoicing to hear the doctor’s prognosis This body is incomplete without her presence. Congresswoman. Born on the fateful day of of recovery for GABBY, but my heart is broken As we approach the hard fought for Martin September 11, 2001, Christina was taken from for the families of the six victims who lost Luther King holiday, let us all rededicate our- her parents and this nation on January 8, loved ones in that unconscionable act last Sat- selves to the principles he espoused, commit 2011. urday. They were American citizens who were ourselves to continuing his legacy and to Madam Speaker, today, with the passage of brutally gunned down even as they were tak- being drum majors for justice and peace! House Resolution 32, the People’s House ing advantage of the time-honored American Mr. HONDA. Madam Speaker, I rise today mourns with family and with the nation for tradition of meeting face-to-face with an elect- in support of House Resolution 32, honoring these innocent lives cut short. During these ed representative for a free and open dis- our colleague, Representative GABRIELLE GIF- trying times for our nation, I am reminded of course about issues of concern. One of the FORDS, and those killed and injured in a what Senator Robert F. Kennedy once said in small ways we can honor their memory is to senseless shooting during a Congress on his remarks to the Cleveland City Club just carry on with that discourse, opening our Your Corner event in Tucson, Arizona. Our months before he was assassinated. doors to the American people, listening to their colleague GABBY was doing her job to serve ‘‘A sniper is only a coward, not a hero; and concerns, and exercising the free exchange of the constituents of the 8th Congressional Dis- an uncontrolled, uncontrollable mob is only the ideas that has marked our nation throughout trict of Arizona, those who were killed and voice of madness, not the voice of the people. its history. wounded were there to participate in the ‘‘Whenever any American’s life is taken by Ms. MCCOLLUM. Madam Speaker, last Sat- democratic process we hold dear. As the na- another American unnecessarily—whether it is urday in Tucson, Arizona our colleague, Rep. tion mourns with the victims’ families, we learn done in the name of the law or in the defiance GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, was shot by a disturbed about these innocent Americans whose lives of law, by one man or a gang, in cold blood gunman while she was meeting her constitu- were cut short by this unspeakable crime or in passion, in an attack of violence or in re- ents. This shooting resulted in the death of six against our democracy and our humanity. sponse to violence—whenever we tear at the Americans who were participating in the most Dorothy Morris, age 76, known to her fabric of life which another man has painfully common of events in this democracy, a meet- friends as ‘‘Dot,’’ was a retired homemaker and clumsily woven for himself and his chil- ing with their congresswoman. Fourteen addi- and secretary who lived with her husband of dren, the whole nation is degraded.’’ tional Americans were wounded in the attack,

VerDate Mar 15 2010 03:43 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00048 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.053 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H191 including the critical wound suffered by Con- people of your congressional district. We hope and all others who died or were harmed by gresswoman GIFFORDS. that if any good will come of this horrific event, this uncaring perpetrator.’’ Fred Gates, St. On January 10, 2011, dozens of concerned it will be that people will once again realize Paul, Minnesota. and compassionate Minnesotans visited my that our fellow citizens, regardless of political ‘‘Please know that you are loved and sup- St. Paul District Office to express their support views, are human and deserve to be treated ported in vastly greater measure than the dis- for Congresswoman GIFFORDS, the victims, with respect and civility. Our words can have tortion and hatred that made this unspeakable and the people of Tucson. They also ex- consequence so far beyond our intent.’’ Steve tragedy possible.’’ Lori Stee, St. Paul, Min- pressed their heartfelt condolences to those Schaus & Angela Braun, St. Paul, Minnesota. nesota. who were killed. ‘‘My heart is terribly heavy with this horrific ‘‘My thoughts are with Rep. Giffords’ family With the consent of the concerned citizens event. For any public servant to be struck as they support Gabrielle’s recovery and with who I have the honor to represent, I submit down while serving the people is an appalling the others affected by this violent act. We are the eloquent words of Minnesotans who send affront to every citizen. For innocent and ran- incredibly lucky to live in a country where polit- their prayers and support for Representative dom people to be struck down in this way is ical violence is extremely rare. The rhetoric GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and all of those whose an affront to all humanity. Let us all pray for that creates a context for violence must cease. lives have been hurt by this senseless act of the families of the victims, and work for peace Hate is not a response for disagreement.’’ violence. I join them not only in praying for among all people.’’ Ross Willits, St. Paul, Min- Anne Claflin, St. Paul, Minnesota. healing and peace, but I will continue to dedi- nesota. ‘‘I extend my deepest condolences to Con- cate myself to working to make a more peace- ‘‘Gabby, you are in my thoughts and prayers gresswoman Giffords and all the victims of this ful and less hostile America. as you recover. I am deeply saddened that senseless tragedy. There are consequences The following comments were made by Min- someone like yourself who has willingly given to the violent rhetoric that plagues the political nesotans who visited my St. Paul district office of themselves has become a victim of such a landscape today—it’s the innocent and the on Monday, January 10, 2011. These mes- senseless act. We pray that the rhetoric that brave that suffer.’’ Dr. Mary de Leon-Denton, sages of support and sympathy were tran- inflames will be replaced by words of coopera- Inver Grove Heights, Minnesota. scribed directly from their individual hand- tion and collaboration in our houses of Con- ‘‘My prayers are with you and especially I written notes. gress. Blessings to you and your family.’’ pray that somehow, someway, some good will ‘‘My prayers and thoughts are with the Con- Jeanne Sedgwick, St. Paul, Minnesota. come of this horrible tragedy.’’ Michael gresswoman and her staff. This act of horrific ‘‘There are no words at my command to ex- Michauk, St. Paul, Minnesota. violence was a response to the everyday work press my sorrow at what happened and my ‘‘Congresswoman Giffords, I give you my that public officials do on a daily basis to warm best wishes to all you so affected by deepest and heartfelt support to the service serve their constituents. Congresswoman Gif- truly cruel and senseless violence.’’ Elmer and honor you give to our country. The need- fords and her staff’s work exemplifies this. I Pierre, St. Paul, Minnesota. less violence and anger that has been shown hope that the Congresswoman can continue to ‘‘Rep. Giffords: Please accept my deepest in our country over politics has to stop. It is do this important work.’’ Henry Parker, St. condolences. I also wish you immense sad that something like this had to happen in Paul, Minnesota. strength and courage.’’ Heather Meyers, order for the dialogue to begin to change how ‘‘ ‘It is here my daughters, that love is to be Eagan, Minnesota. we promote change with deepest prayers and found, not hidden away in the corners but in ‘‘As someone who has been involved in pol- sympathy to all harmed.’’ Aaron Crawford, St. the midst of occasions of sin. And believe me, itics for years and met many members of Con- Paul, Minnesota. although we may more often fail and commit gress, I was horrified as I watched the events ‘‘In this time of great sorrow and shock, my small lapses, our gain will be incomparably the of this past weekend unfold. I was deeply sad- great hope is that all this will serve to wake up greater.’—Saint Teresa of Avila’’ Loren dened by this attack and I want to show my those in our nation who don’t believe that gun Cramer, St. Paul, Minnesota. support for the victims and their families. I violence is a huge problem that needs to be ‘‘I’m so sorry to hear of this violent attack in hope and pray for a speedy recovery and I be- addressed—yet again. Our thoughts and pray- Tucson. I hope for and pray for Giffords and lieve that Congresswoman Giffords’ service ers are with all of you—and with our country!’’ others.’’ Mary Doran, St. Paul, Minnesota. ‘‘Keep up your work. We need you now and devotion to her country is truly heroic. Julie B. Goldstein, St. Paul, Minnesota. ‘‘To Congresswoman Giffords, her family more than ever.’’ Jason Garrett, St. Paul, Min- You are in the hearts and minds of all Ameri- and those injured and killed: This morning I re- nesota. cans. God bless.’’ John Moore, St. Paul, Min- ‘‘God bless America. Thoughts and prayers nesota. ceived a note from two constituents—St to the victims and their families.’’ Nicole Ly, ‘‘I offer prayers for Representative Giffords, Paulites in the summer and Arizona snowbirds Oakdale, Minnesota. her family, and all others affected by this in the winter. Gene and Ginny shared their af- ‘‘Our thoughts and prayers are with you, senseless, terrible tragedy. The wounded and fection for ‘our dear Gabby’. The road ahead your staff, and your family during this difficult killed, especially Christina Green and her fam- is difficult for all of us. I wish you strength in time. You have the nation behind you with an ily. May you be comforted and strengthened your recovery and wisdom for all Americans outpouring of love and well wishes.’’ Shelly by the prayers of our nation.’’ Florence as we reconcile the meaning of this tragedy Schafer, Woodbury, Minnesota. Steichen, St. Paul, Minnesota. with our own actions as citizens. To be truly ‘‘Although Congresswoman Giffords may ‘‘We need better gun control measures and free from violence and persecution, we must have been the target, all citizens who engage an increase in civil discourse—sending pray- persist in our efforts to maintain an open soci- their elected officials have become unsettled ers to the families who lost loved ones in this ety where we can disagree peacefully and by this act. Civil war < Be civil.’’ Mary Jane senseless act of violence and also to the fam- move forward together. My best to you and LaVigne, Birchwood Village, Minnesota. ily of Congresswoman Giffords for her speedy your families.’’ Minnesota State Rep. Erin Mur- ‘‘I am so sad to hear about the shooting. I and full recovery.’’ Lyn Burton, St. Paul, Min- phy, St. Paul, Minnesota. pray for your recovery. I want you to be strong nesota. ‘‘To Congresswoman Giffords, victims, and and continue to be the fighter that you are so ‘‘Congresswoman Giffords: Thank you for their family and friends: My heart goes to all you can continue to walk and serve the people your service. Thank you for your support of of you, and I continue to pray for all of you. of America. Thank you for your service. Your health care reform. Prayers for you and your Public service is noble work, and it is difficult. district is giving up a lot for America and my family for strength in adversity.’’ Mary J. Pohl, Thank you for all you do, and know the good- thoughts are with you.’’ Kao Ly Ilean Her, St. St. Paul, Minnesota. will of the people of our state and country is Paul, Minnesota. ‘‘The rhetoric of violence, scapegoating and with you at this very difficult time. Together, ‘‘My heart goes out to the Giffords family. I demonization must end! My sympathy to Rep. we will heal and find grace in our democracy.’’ was born and raised in Tucson, and now Giffords, her family, her staff and all victims of Minnesota State Rep. Kate Knuth, New Brigh- serve in the Minnesota House. To think our violence in Tucson.’’ Richard Lee Dechert, ton, Minnesota. public servants are under attack is so sad. We Maplewood, Minnesota. ‘‘My heart bleeds for all of you. Courage.’’ pray for you Gabby. We pray for the victims.’’ ‘‘My prayers, thoughts, and heartfelt sym- Ted King, Minneapolis, Minnesota. Nora Slawik, Maplewood, Minnesota. pathy go out to Congresswoman Gabrielle ‘‘May you experience a speedy recovery. ‘‘Our thoughts and our prayers are with all Giffords’s family, friends, and supporters. My Thoughts and prayers for you and your fam- the victims of the Arizona shooting!’’ Susan daily prayers will include the wishes for the ily.’’ Peter Austin, Minneapolis, Minnesota. Zumberge, St. Paul, Minnesota. long term recovery of Congresswoman Gif- ‘‘May you heal and feel better in time. You ‘‘Our thoughts and prayers go out to you, fords. I express my heartfelt thoughts and are in our prayers. May God be with you. You the other victims, their loved ones, and the prayers for the Federal Judge, the young girl are in our thoughts as you recover from this

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00049 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.056 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H192 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 tragic event.’’ Paehin Young, Minneapolis, people of Arizona. It could have been any of plete recovery. I also wish to extend my sym- Minnesota. us. I also wish Rep. Giffords a speedy recov- pathy to you who lost family members. All of ‘‘Thank you for all your service to the coun- ery and hope to see her return to the House you are in my thoughts and prayers.’’ Cheryl try. My thoughts and prayers are with you and and serve her constituents.’’ Devin Driscoll, St. Kenney, St. Paul, Minnesota. your staff. We need more people like you.’’ Paul, Minnesota. ‘‘My prayers are with Congresswoman Sam Dougherty, St. Paul, Minnesota. ‘‘Please accept my deep sympathies for Gabrielle Giffords and all who have been in- ‘‘Our prayers go out to those affected by your current situation. We as, U.S. citizens, jured or killed in this vicious act of violence this attack’’ Kevin Weingart, Coon Rapids, are a very special society. Those that attempt against persons serving US citizens as part of Minnesota. to steal our lives, and the lives of our friends, this great democracy—also with all who love ‘‘My thoughts are with you and your commu- will find that we are strong in the face of ad- them. To be engaged in dialogue on the nity in this time where senseless violence has versity. The actions against the U.S. citizens issues—to engage civilly in our civic process changed how everyone feels. Public servants in Tucson, including Rep. Giffords, are a trag- needs to be returned to our democracy from and those who engage in our government and edy that I hope is never repeated. Trusting in citizens to the media to the halls of Congress. the political process should not fear for their God’s healing and your full recovery.’’ Jim Committed to civil civic engagement and to safety. I hope that everyone affected by this McKie, West St. Paul, Minnesota. prayers for our prayers for our nation as we tragedy can come together in solidarity. Thank ‘‘Thank you for all of your work and service. move forward from this tragedy, I remain,’’ you for your service and bravery.’’ Meagan My thoughts and prayers are with you and ‘‘Ginger’’ K. Virginia Hidsfrom, St. Paul, Min- Bachmayer, Minneapolis, Minnesota. your family and we hope you have a speedy nesota. ‘‘May the sun rise in your hearts and souls. recovery.’’ Warren Claflin, South St. Paul, Min- ‘‘My family and I were stunned to hear of Our deepest condolences, warm wishes and nesota. this senseless violence. You are in our never-ending prayers are with you.’’ Jill ‘‘This weekend’s events were a sad re- thoughts and prayers. Our heartfelt condo- Curran, Larry Wichlans and Family, St. Paul, minder of the consequences that can arise lences go to the families of those killed, and Minnesota. when political rhetoric becomes hateful or vio- we pray for ongoing strength for those wound- ‘‘I feel so saddened by the events in Tuc- lent. Angry, upset and unbalanced people re- ed and their families.’’ Kathleen Proctor, Lau- son, AZ. My sincerest sympathies go out to all spond in unpredictable ways. Thank you, Rep. derdale, Minnesota. the victims. God bless, Gundy.’’ Gundy Giffords, for your service to your district and ‘‘To all in Tucson, AZ affected by this Gunderson, Oakdale, Minnesota. your country. Thank you to the staff that helps senseless tragedy: You have support from us ‘‘A truly tragic moment in our nation’s his- you in this work. No American should ever in Minnesota by way of encouragement during tory. My prayers and support are with the vic- fear violence as a consequence of participa- your time of pain and grief. We will advocate tims and our nation’s leadership as we strug- tion in our democracy.’’ Paul Rohlfing, lives in for a return to civil discourse in the US rather gle with the complex issues that led to this Minneapolis, works in St. Paul. than vitriolic campaign language that goes on. violent event.’’ Cheryl Westman, St. Paul, Min- ‘‘Our thoughts and prayers are with you and May your pain and anguish turn into positive nesota. your family from the St. Paul Federation of communication among people in every com- ‘‘Thank you for doing this, our prayers are Teachers in St. Paul, Minnesota.’’ Julie Haw- munity of our country.’’ Joanne Tromiczak- with the Giffords family. This is not what our kins, Inver Grove, Minnesota. Neid, St. Paul, Minnesota. ‘‘I feel anguish at this terrible violence country is about. It is time to come together.’’ ‘‘My heartfelt wishes and prayers to Con- (senseless) and the resulting loss of life and Jody Prip, New Prague, Minnesota. gresswoman Giffords, her staff, and constitu- hurt. Gun violence is too prevalent in our soci- ‘‘Blessings of hope and prayers for each ents she proudly represents. My heart, mind, ety and too many unstable people have too one of the innocents killed and injured in this and soul grieve for those who have died and easy access to guns. I do lay some blame on tragedy. This feels the same as the tragedies have been injured by this senseless act of vio- radio shows with hosts that stoke the flames of Bobby Kennedy, MLK and 9/11. God help lence. May we, as citizens of the United of people’s anger and sit back and say they us all—if we calm down—we will get through States, and as members of our global world, have no responsibility. Please continue to get continue to foster peaceful solutions to vio- this.’’ Robert F. Riesert, St. Paul, Minnesota. stronger and the keep the faith.’’ Julia Fish, St. ‘‘Following the violence, it has been a pain- lence that surrounds us.’’ Mary Tacheny, St. Paul, Minnesota. ful and angry weekend—much of it emailing Paul, Minnesota. ‘‘In these challenging times, know that the ‘‘My prayers go out to you, you who were my own vitriolic reaction to personal friends. thoughts, prayers, and best wishes of all injured or killed, your families, your friends, Expressing fear for our country and the safety Americans are with you and your family. We your loved ones. My prayers go out to you, of our representatives was a helpful and im- mourn the loss of life, and share your vision you who witnessed the violence, you whose mediate necessity. The shock remains al- of a healthier and stronger country. One of my lives won’t be the same. I pray for the person though many of us, as was Gabby herself, close friends works in Congresswoman who did this. Only God understands. I pray for feared the new language and images pre- McCollum’s office in St. Paul. I know how hard our country to find peace. God bless you all. sented often now in a repetitive fashion filling our public servants work, and you must be so May somehow, some good come of this.’’ the airwave and filling especially vulnerable proud of the bravery of your young staff intern, Laura K. Kochevar, St. Paul, Minnesota. minds with pictures of weapons as political Daniel. I am sorry beyond words that this hap- ‘‘I thank all public servants and especially tools. We shared emails then too, as we heard pened. Peace to you, and all who were im- their staff for their dedication to the people and watched the rhetoric become louder and pacted by this tragedy.’’ Adam Robinson, St. they serve. As a former staffer, my heart goes scarier. Helpless to counteract these emo- Paul, Minnesota. out to all the families directly affected by this tional appeals, we signed petitions con- ‘‘Our thoughts and prayers are with the fam- tragedy. Also I send the thoughts and prayers demning them. We still wait helplessly for the ilies involved in this terrible tragedy. Hopefully to every Member of Congress and their staff apology that will not come. We pray for cool this will become a time of healing, and a time to get through this and pray that our country down and safety.’’ Janyce Kovash, St. Paul, when the vitriol between opposite sides will learn from this and stop the incendiary Minnesota. ceases. We pray that Congresswoman rhetoric. Thank you.’’ Kathleen Murphy, St. ‘‘ ‘Violence is a cycle,’ said Dr. King. When Gabrielle Giffords and all the wounded re- Paul, Minnesota.. met with senseless actions against public cover. Our condolences go to those who lost ‘‘We are all saddened by this tragedy. As servants and the public at large, we must their lives in Tucson. We pray for the safety of Speaker Boehner said, ‘An attack on one who strive to do justice to the sacrifice and heroism all public officials, and the continuing health of serves is an attack on all who serve.’ We all of so many—by reaching out to those who our nation.’’ Tom and Susan Pugh, South St. stand with you and your staff in solidarity as serve and thanking them by tamping down the Paul, Minnesota. we grieve this incident and work to make rhetoric and respecting those of all political ‘‘Our thoughts are with you as you recover sense of this senseless event. We thank you persuasions. And also by answering the call to from this brutal and senseless attack. I am for your sacrifices in service to the people of justice and caring for our friends and neigh- confident you will continue to serve the people Arizona’s 8th District. May you all have a bors. We will never have a satisfactory answer of Arizona and the United States. To the fami- speedy recovery and also never forget those to the question ‘why?’ but we can use the mo- lies who are struggling with this unimaginable who were lost, and use the memories we have ment to consider for fully ‘how?’—How do we loss, the thoughts and prayers of the nation as a guide and inspiration for the future. God- ensure that this never happens again? My are with you.’’ Samantha Gemberling, St. speed, Gabe Zimmerman, Christina Green, thoughts and prayers are with the families of Paul, Minnesota. Judge John Roll, Dorothy Morris, Dorwan those who lost their lives, especially Gabe ‘‘I wish Congresswoman Giffords, and all Stoddard, and Phyllis Schneck.’’ Melissa Zimmerman, who gave his life in service to the others who were wounded, a steady and com- Jamrock, St. Paul, Minnesota.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 05:02 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00050 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.058 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H193 ‘‘Change-makers walk a difficult and scary Just last week my wife Joyce and I had the and it’s time for all of us to take a step back path. But one that gives us hope and energy. opportunity to visit with GABBY in Statuary Hall and reflect on the effects of the vitriol. Thank you for walking, for walking yours with before the ceremonial swearing-in. The philosopher, Voltaire, once wrote, ‘‘I de- courage and pluck. My heart aches for the vio- As in so many of my other interactions with test what you write, but I would give my life to lence, pain, and fear that has been done to all her, GABBY was gracious, energetic, and will- make it possible for you to continue to write.’’ of you and us. I send you my heartfelt wishes ing to offer a lending hand as I got settled. He was articulating a crucial component—per- for healing, safety, and peace.’’ Sheri Smith, We took a few photos and talked about haps THE crucial component—on which our St. Paul, Minnesota. ways we would work together in good spirits. nation was founded: That no matter how much ‘‘Love will conquer all. Remember you have Of course, GABBY and I also went back-and- I may disagree with your opinion, it is essen- the support of the people. Be well.’’ Chuck forth about our favorite rivalry, ASU versus U tial that you have the right to express it. Repile, St. Paul, Minnesota. of A. But too often, lately, it seems that we can- ‘‘My deepest sympathies for Congress- GABBY takes enormous pride in her job rep- not merely disagree with one another’s opin- woman Giffords, her staff, and their families resenting the communities and people of the ions or policies. Instead disagreements be- during this difficult time. I wish the Congress- 8th district. come personal. Verbal attacks devolve into woman and all those injured a speedy recov- My wife Joyce and I send our thoughts and harsh questions about motives and character. ery.’’ Cameron Erickson, Eagan, Minnesota. prayers to Mark during this difficult time. We Debates about policies or proposals sink to ‘‘To all parties involved: This is a tragedy in are deeply appreciative of Mark’s generosity in fear-mongering and rhetorical claims that the every sense. Not only for Rep. Giffords, Chief sharing GABBY with us in Washington and Ari- fate of our Republic lies in the balance. Justice Roll, and the other civilians involved. zona. Those of us in this chamber, and others in Now, more than ever, it has become apparent It is also important to not forget that these elected office, understand the rhetorical nature we are a broken, divided nation in need of re- individuals lost their lives or were injured while of such comments, but can we be absolutely pair and healing. We must disconnect from they were exercising their right to participate certain that such verbal attacks are not being hateful political rhetoric and campaigns and and have a say in our nation’s republic. misconstrued in a culture of increasing anger come together in this time of tragedy. God Indeed, they became victims while exer- and a greater acceptance of confrontation? cising a fundamental right that has served as bless the Giffords.’’ Louise Dickson, North Absolutely, we must preserve each person’s the backbone of our nation since its found- Oaks, Minnesota. fundamental First Amendment rights, but can ing—a right our nation’s founders sacrificed so ‘‘To all AZ residents: This is truly a tragic we not agree that we ought to disagree in a dearly for. Just as the victims of this past Sat- time, not only for the families of those directly more agreeable fashion? As elected Rep- urday’s tragedy did as well. affected by this horrible incident, but all resi- resentatives, our words certainly do have con- We are stunned by the tragedy, but we re- dents of the 8th district and the state. They sequences for the policies and actions we are main resolute in our commitment assemble have lost their representation and voice in DC trying to shape, but it extends well beyond peacefully and engage civilly in the type of and in government—the foundation of our these four walls . . . to the thousands of peo- discourse that is fundamental to our republic. country. That a mentally ill young man did not ple who provide us with staff support here in Although words may not be sufficient to get the help needed, was allowed to legally the Capitol and in our home districts . . . for capture the sorrow and grief we are experi- purchase a weapon, and used it against inno- the men and women who are the face of our encing, Joyce and I send our thoughts and cent citizens—is wrong. That our political dis- government, performing essential federal work prayers to GABBY, Mark, Roxanna and John course has gotten so angry that it fed this every day in communities across our nation Green, the parents of Christina Taylor Green young man’s delusions is wrong. We must al- and especially for the public, which has placed and the loved ones of Judge Roll, Dorwin ways remember there are other Loughners out its trust in us. there. May all those wounded hail those who Stoddard, Dorothy Morris, Gabe Zimmerman, There are sure to be multiple legislative pro- died and may we all learn from this.’’ Laura Phyllis Schneck, and the Tucson community. posals in response to this week’s tragedy, but Neritt, St. Paul, Minnesota. Our hearts and prayers are with you. perhaps the best response is more simple and ‘‘Thank you and thanks to all our U.S. rep- Mr. CONNOLLY of Virginia. Madam Speak- more personal. Speaker BOEHNER said an at- resentatives for your dedicated service. Our er, I rise to join my colleagues and the rest of tack on one of us is an attack on all of us, and freedom sits with all of us as you represent we the Congressional community in extending my it will take a collective response from all of us all the people. I pray for your good health and prayers and support to the victims of the hor- to temper our rhetoric and return to a level of protection.’’ Carol Gariann, Shoreview, Min- rible shooting this past Saturday in Tucson, discourse that honors the victims of this nesota. Arizona, and to their families and friends. Our ‘‘My condolences to the shooting victims, friend and colleague, GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, week’s senseless tragedy. their friends, and families. My thoughts and continues to fight for her life. She and 13 oth- Mrs. LOWEY. Madam Speaker, I rise in prayers are with all of you, and all who feel ers were wounded in this unspeakable trag- condemnation of the senseless attack that the pain of this tragedy.’’ Mark Jenkins, Maple- edy, in which six people were killed, including took place on Saturday, January 8th in Tuc- wood, Minnesota. three retirees, a nine-year old child, a federal son, Arizona targeting Congresswoman ‘‘My condolences go out to the families of judge and a member of Representative GIF- GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and other innocent men, the victims of this horrible tragedy. My heart FORD’s staff. women, and children. goes out to you all.’’ Kenneth Sinn, St. Paul, During the past two years it has been my The families and friends of those victims Minnesota. pleasure to serve with GABBY GIFFORDS on the who died in the attack—Gabriel Zimmerman, ‘‘Rep. Giffords—you are right. We will be House Foreign Affairs Committee. She is an U.S. District Judge John Roll, Phyllis Schenck, mellowing the rhetoric. Let’s listen to the Pima intelligent and dedicated public servant. During Dorwin Stoddard, Dorothy Morris, and nine- County Sheriff.’’ Rick Cardenas, St. Paul, Min- my term in this body, I benefited from watch- year-old Christina Taylor Green—are in all of nesota. ing and working with GABBY. I know that the our thoughts and prayers. It is heartbreaking ‘‘Like Congresswoman McCollum, I am House of Representatives, and indeed, the en- that so many lost their lives as a result of the shocked at this event and want you all to tire country have benefited from her work and actions of one highly disturbed individual. know I am thinking of you. Some good may that this chamber will feel her absence until We also hope and pray for the health of come from this evil, however, as people are she fully recovers and is able to return to the GABBY GIFFORDS and fourteen other innocent now discussing the role inflammatory speech House floor. individuals who were injured in this premedi- may play in today’s America.’’ Bernice Vetich, This past Saturday was yet another tragic tated and indiscriminate act of violence. I pray St. Paul, Minnesota. reminder of the prevalence of violence in our that they will gain the strength to recover Mr. SCHWEIKERT. Madam Speaker, I rise society. Our primary concern at this moment physically and emotionally from this horrific in support of the resolution. must be with the victims and their families and event. It is with a heavy heart that I come to the friends. We must help them work through their GABBY GIFFORDS is a warm, kind, and spir- floor today to offer these thoughts on the trag- grief. We must help the injured through their ited woman and a dedicated and hardworking ic events of this past Saturday in Tucson that recovery process. representative. It is all the more tragic that this took the lives of Judge John M. Roll, Christina There is no silver lining when six people are violent act occurred as she was fulfilling her Taylor Green, Dorwin Stoddard, Dorothy Mor- murdered. However, if we do not learn from most basic duty as a representative—solving ris, Gabe Zimmerman, and Phyllis Schneck this tragedy, then we will be doomed to repeat government problems for her constituents and and gravely injured Congresswoman GABBY it. Mr. Speaker, I would submit that our polit- listening to their concerns and opinions about GIFFORDS and many others. ical rhetoric has become grossly overheated, federal issues.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00051 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.059 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H194 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 I commend the heroes of January 8th. With- I hope that our support—together with the the safety of others, and without their actions, out the heroic actions of bystanders who sub- prayers and well wishes offered by the people it is likely many more lives may have been dued the shooter and those who administered of Arizona and indeed all of America—will help lost. first aid to the victims, as well as the first re- her and her family now and in the weeks and Acts and threats of violence such as these sponders and medical personnel who saved months ahead. have no place in our society and the voices of victims’ lives, the toll of fatalities and injuries Even as she copes with her own severe in- the American people will not be silenced or di- surely would have been far worse. juries, I am sure that GABBY is thinking of all minished because of these acts. If anything positive could come of this horri- the others who were killed and injured during As we pause to reflect on the tragic events fying event, I hope that self-reflection will re- the attack on her. Gabe Zimmerman, her di- of Saturday, we should make special efforts to sult in a return to civility in our political dis- rector of community outreach, was killed. Two remember those whose lives were senselessly course. Elected officials, media personalities, more members of her Congressional staff, taken: Gabe Zimmerman, Christina Taylor and political activists should make a real effort Ron Barber and Pam Simon, were injured in Green, Judge John M. Roll, Dorwin Stoddard, to turn down the temperature in heated rhet- the shooting. Congressional staff members Dorothy Morris, Phyllis Schneck. We should oric, carefully considering the actions it could help us, to help our constituents, but they remember their families in our prayers—and incite, even if unintended, and the public at often are not recognized or appreciated. Let ask that they be comforted in their grief. large must reject the incendiary language that us all remember that our staffers—and gov- Like so many others, words cannot ade- has become too common. ernment workers generally—are committed to quately express my shock and sorrow over Those who died in Tucson on Saturday will public service. They work hard, make many this tragedy. My thoughts and prayers are with not be forgotten, and justice will be served for sacrifices, and they provide valuable, essential all the affected families. the attacker who caused such heartbreak for service. Ms. FOXX. Madam Speaker, last Saturday so many. We all pray for the families of the We are thinking also of residents of the Tuc- our country suffered a terrible blow. In a victims, the recovery of the survivors, and a son community who attended this event to senseless and despicable act of violence, a more civil and peaceful tomorrow. meet and speak with their elected representa- crazed gunman attempted to kill one of this Mr. DEUTCH. Madam Speaker, just days tive, never sensing that they would be in body’s finest members and our good friend, ago, our nation was shaken by the brutal act harm’s way. Congresswoman GABBY GIFFORDS, while slay- of violence committed against Congress- Christina Taylor Green, Dorothy Morris, ing six others and wounding many more, woman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and the constitu- John Roll, Phyllis Schneck, and Dorwan Stod- GABBY was gunned down while doing the ents waiting in line to speak with her. dard were all killed in this senseless, brutal at- very thing she was elected to do—listening to The shots fired in Tuscon claimed the lives tack. her constituents and soliciting their feedback. of several Americans, from a federal judge I join my colleagues in expressing condo- She was participating in a proud tradition of with decades of service to our country, to a lences to their families, friends and loved representative democracy, where democrat- young child participating in our great democ- ones. ically elected representatives interact with the racy for the very first time. In a matter of seconds, the gunman reck- constituents they represent in Washington. Tragedies like this one tear at the fabric of lessly and viciously sprayed bullets in all direc- When the gunman pulled the trigger he was our democracy, which is woven together by tions. In addition to killing six people and attacking not just a good and decent Member the everyday conversations that take place be- wounding Congresswoman GIFFORDS, he in- of Congress and her constituents, he was also tween ordinary people and those they elect to jured thirteen other people. We pray for their attacking the freedom-loving people of Amer- represent them in government. full and speedy recovery. ica who every two years send public servants What started out as a routine morning in In a democracy, it is not only common but like GABBY to Washington to handle their inter- American political life—an elected representa- moreover essential that citizens and their rep- ests in the Capitol. tive listening to the thoughts and concerns of resentatives freely communicate and ex- We must not tolerate this violence and the her community—ended in senseless blood- change ideas, even opposing opinions. Unfor- assault it represents on our democratic way of shed. tunately, violent events like the shooting in life. Make no mistake; there is no room for vio- As we pay tribute to those who fell victim to Tucson have a chilling effect on our ability to lence in our vigorous national debate. this violence, and as we pray for the swift re- engage in our civic duties without fear. We I pray for God’s peace for all the victims of covery of Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIF- must not give in to fear. At the same time, we this tragic attack and swift healing for all FORDS, we must also reaffirm ourselves to the absolutely must all do whatever is necessary those, especially GABBY, who are still fighting work being done that morning before those to restore safety and security. We must re- to recover. The House of Representatives is shots rang out. dedicate ourselves to ending violence and pro- not whole without the smiling face of GABBY Congresswoman GIFFORDS enjoys such re- moting peace, and we must take necessary, and I eagerly await the day when she returns spect in this body not only because of her in- commonsense steps to reduce the potential to work on behalf of her constituents. They tellect and warmth but also because of her for killings like this. could ask for no finer person to represent commitment to directly engaging with people. Ms. LINDA T. SA´ NCHEZ of California. them in Congress. She believed—and every day put into action— Madam Speaker, I rise today to strongly sup- Ms. LORETTA SANCHEZ of California. I that with sincere, hard work we can forge port the resolution honoring the victims of the rise today on behalf of my district in Orange common ground, in our communities and as a Arizona tragedy. County to offer my prayers and condolences nation. I condemn the senseless act of violence to all those wounded and killed in the recent In a few days, when this body reconvenes that ended six lives too soon and injured many and tragic shootings in Tucson, Arizona. I and we resume the business of moving our others, including one of our colleagues, Rep- want to honor my colleague and dear friend, nation forward, let us honor Congresswoman resentative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS of Arizona. Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, who GIFFORDS by keeping that sense of common Representative GIFFORDS is an indefatigable remains in critical condition and those who lost purpose in the forefront of our minds as we advocate for her constituents and a strong be- their lives, Gabriel Zimmerman, Christina work to overcome the many challenges faced liever in the value of public service. She has Green, John Roll, Dorothy Morris, Phyllis by our nation. worked day and night to improve her commu- Schneck and Dorwin Stoddard. Ms. WATERS. Madam Speaker, the shoot- nity and help those around her in need. Even GABBY was doing what all Members of Con- ing of Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, when she’s had a strong disagreement with a gress must do, interact with their constituents and the killing and wounding of members of colleague—on either side of the aisle—she and provide a venue for them to petition their her staff and community attending her ‘‘Con- was always willing to work with those col- government. It is a sad day in America when gress on your Corner’’ event, was a national leagues again. For her, disagreements do not the basis of our democracy, the interaction be- tragedy. foreclose cooperation. She truly embodies tween elected officials and those they rep- It is most appropriate that we speak out to what it means to be a public servant. resent, is put into jeopardy by those who wish share our sadness, sorrow and grief as well I want to commend the quick and heroic ac- to do us harm. as our hopes for healing and recovery. tions of the brave citizens who responded that Those lost on that day were robbed of life I am encouraged that GABBY continues to day. In a frightful situation, when the natural too early, like nine-year-old Christina Green, defy the odds and is showing signs of response is to run in fear, Patricia Maisch, whose life was bookended by tragedy. She progress. She is truly a survivor, with a strong Roger Sulzeber, Joseph Zimudie, and Daniel was born on September 11, 2001, but strove will to live. I know that she faces a long and Hernandez, Jr. took actions to help the injured at such a young age to be engaged in her difficult path to recover from her injuries, and and stop the attack. They risked their lives for community. Or the life of GABBY’s close aide,

VerDate Mar 15 2010 03:43 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00052 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.039 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H195 Gabriel Zimmerman, who at 30 years old had we heard of his horrible actions: ‘‘How could Sadly, Saturday’s assassin took advantage made public service and helping those in the you be so hateful? How could you do this?’’ of an event which embodies the very essence Eighth District of Arizona his purpose in life for As the paramedics and emergency respond- of public service and the right to assemble the last 4 years. Judge John Roll dedicated ers attended to the scene, the true sorrow of without fear. Like GABBY, I hold these kinds of his life to public service and understood the the event became clear. Twenty patriotic ‘‘Congress On Your Corner’’ events in my dis- risks associated with controversial issues. And Americans were shot, many severely. Six of trict to hear directly from my constituents, to remember those that left so many loved them lost their lives for no reason other than whether they agree with me or not. Listening ones and memories behind, Dorwin Stoddard, that they participated in the democratic proc- to our constituents is a fundamental duty of Dorothy Morris, and Phyllis Schneck. ess. each Member of Congress and provides an I await the day that we welcome our col- This tragedy has touched our Nation to its extraordinary opportunity to talk one-on-one in league back into the House chamber and will very core. The fact that this horrific event an inclusive and equitable environment. That continue to pray for those still in the care of would occur during such an open democratic our constituents would have to worry about vi- doctors and those who have passed on. event has chipped away at our innocence as olence as part of that process is unthinkable. Mr. SMITH of Nebraska. Madam Speaker, I a country. The fact that some would rather We must continue to remain accessible to our rise in support of the resolution before us hon- turn to bullets instead of words to address dif- constituents while taking appropriate meas- oring the victims and heroes of the tragic fering opinions makes us feel as though our ures going forward to protect their safety. shooting in Tucson, Arizona, this past week- democratic process is under siege. As we pray for GABBY’s recovery and for the end. However, it is my hope that the lives of families and friends of all of those impacted by Today’s action is a reflection on the victims those six brave souls will not be lost in vain, Saturday’s tragedy, let us honor their legacy of a deeply tragic, singular incident which and that we can become even stronger as a by striving to reinforce the spirit of Democracy changed so many lives forever and to re- Nation. Our Nation was founded on the in which the victims sought to engage in on nounce the barbaric actions taken by a single premise that the American people have the Saturday in Tucson. Together as a nation, we individual. We also honor those bystanders right to elect their own leaders, to have their can have a vigorous debate without compro- and first responders who reaffirmed our faith voices heard, and have a say in their own mising the civility and respect for one an- in humanity by risking their lives to save oth- government. We fought, and many died, to other’s human dignity that is core to our great ers. protect that right. And no one is allowed to Nation’s principles. Today marks a time of healing as we cele- take that away from us. Mr. HALL. Madam Speaker, I rise today to The American democratic process should brate the lives of those who were lost. GABBY speak in support of my friend and colleague, is a colleague and a friend who is known for not be one of anger and hateful words, but of GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, who four days ago was her civility and willingness to reach out. Her discourse and discussion. After all our country the target of a malicious, senseless attack in office was just a couple of doors down from has been through to protect our freedoms, we Tucson, Arizona. In the aftermath of this trag- mine on the fifth floor of Cannon our freshman must maintain respect for one another and un- edy, 6 have lost their lives, 12 were wounded, derstand that the ability to share differing opin- year and I was her colleague on the House and GABBY is still in the hospital fighting for ions is at the core of what makes our Nation Science and Technology Committee through her life. She is a dear friend, and one of the so great. most sincere, conscientious, and thoughtful the 111th Congress. She is a consummate So it is in the spirit of respect and democ- professional who is dedicated to her constitu- members I have had the pleasure of working racy that I support this resolution. My prayers with. ents and her country. go out to the families of the victims, all of the GABBY has so many friends in Congress Our prayers are with her and the other vic- survivors, and to my friend GABBY GIFFORDS, and is an outstanding Congresswoman for her tims as they recover from this horrifying event. for a speedy and full recovery. To those who district and for the Committee on Science, As we move forward, we should take strength lost loved ones, words simply cannot express Space, and Technology. She has served the in the outpouring of support from all corners of my feelings of sadness at such a devastating last 2 years as the chairwoman of our Space our country. loss. and Aeronautics Subcommittee and has done Ms. CHU. Madam Speaker, this weekend, a Mr. HEINRICH. Madam Speaker, I rise a magnificent job overseeing our Nation’s horrible tragedy befell the city of Tucson, the today to pay tribute to the many victims of space program. The passion that she brings State of Arizona and the Nation. One of our Saturday’s tragic shooting in Tucson, Arizona, with her is always evident and she has been own, Representative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, and to voice my hope for a full recovery for willing to ask the tough questions and work was doing her duty as a Member of Congress. each of the survivors, particularly my col- across the aisle in support of what she be- She was out in the neighborhood, talking face league and friend, Representative GABRIELLE lieves. to face with her constituents about their con- GIFFORDS. On behalf of me, my family, my GABBY loves her district and her constitu- cerns and their problems. ‘‘Congress on Your staff, and the constituents of New Mexico’s ents, and she is always finding a way to work Corner’’ was an event she had done before First Congressional District, I express our her home state of Arizona into the discussion. with success and she wanted to start the New heartbreak at the attempted assassination, the I have been to her district with her to support Year with an open door to her constituents. devastation of so many innocent lives, and the solar energy and to the Cape with her to sup- When she arrived at the local Safeway, senseless attack on our nation’s Democratic port the Shuttle flights. Perhaps it hurts even dressed in a red blazer, black slacks and process. more that this shooting took place at an event black pumps, she greeted those in attend- Our thoughts and prayers go out to all the that was organized so she could listen to her ance, hugged each of her staff and gave a victims of this senseless tragedy, and espe- constituents and discuss how she represents short speech. Then, constituents began asking cially to the friends and families of Judge John their interests. She was doing her job, being questions, getting their photo taken, and ask- M. Roll, Gabe Zimmerman, Christina Taylor accessible, and listening to the people she ing for help. It was then, only minutes after the Green, Dorothy Morris, Phyllis Schneck and represents. event began, that a young man, armed with a Dorwan Stoddard. We are grateful for the he- GABBY is a beautiful young lady with a semiautomatic handgun with 33 deadly roes who courageously intervened, the first re- beautiful family, and a stepmother of two rounds, directly faced GABBY and shot her sponders and health care professionals and young children. It’s hard to understand how point blank in the head. But he didn’t pause; those who continue to assist the survivors in someone could do something like that. In a he kept shooting. With such rapid fire, those their recovery. moment’s time, one person destroyed the lives waiting in line to speak to GABBY had no Though she remains in critical condition, I of so many innocent victims. Events like this chance to escape his wrath. know GABBY, and can attest to her nature as remind us of how fragile life can be and how What happened in Tucson was not just a fearless fighter. We’ve worked closely to- in the blink of an eye, everything can change. about unspeakable tragedy. It was about he- gether on the House Armed Services Com- I’ve been around a long time and have seen roic actions. When the gunman turned to flee, mittee as clean energy advocates and as New too many terrible senseless events; these are a brave but wounded bystander grabbed the Democrats. As the only member of Congress times when you feel helpless, and all you can shooter, as others came to his aid. One coura- with a spouse on active-duty, she is a tireless do is pray and come together to display soli- geous older woman, Patricia Maisch, tried to advocate for military families and is unques- darity and support for those who have been wrestle a second magazine full of another 33 tionably one of the most talented Democratic affected. I will continue to pray every day for deadly bullets from him to protect others from leaders of my generation. With all of that in GABBY, her husband Astronaut Mark Kelly, her his indiscriminate gunfire. She began shouting mind, I am optimistic and hopeful that she will family, her staff, Judge John Roll, little 9-year at him, even as she remained in danger. She overcome this tragedy. Her recovery is impor- old Christina Green, and the families of all the raised the questions many of us asked when tant to our nations’ future. victims in this tragedy.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00053 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.035 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H196 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 Mr. POLIS. Madam Speaker, last weekend, people of Arizona she so strongly represents, with civility and a sense of enforcing the Con- the world watched as what began as a sunny and to our country as a whole. stitution to keep America strong and provide Saturday morning in southern Arizona ended In 2009, I had the opportunity to visited for the general welfare. in tragedy and horror for our Nation. Violence GABBY in her district. It was apparent how I pledge my part in making that happen. of this kind has no place in America, and our many folks she has touched with her work in To those families who are living this un- grieving Nation will spare no expense to find the Arizona State Senate and the House of speakable tragedy, we extend our condo- out how this tragedy happened and ensure Representatives. Her passion for public serv- lences and prayers to your family. And we that it can never be repeated. ice is truly an example we should all embrace. pray for a speedy recovery for our dear Col- Last Saturday was a dark day in our Na- I would also like to recognize and honor the league, Congresswoman GABBY GIFFORDS, tion’s history and a day which I will never for- victims who lost their lives during this horrible and the other great Americans who are victims get. My thoughts and prayers are with Con- tragedy: Christina Green, Dorothy Morris, of this tragedy. gresswoman GIFFORDS, her family and her Judge John Roll, Phyllis Schneck, Dorwan Mr. TONKO. Madam Speaker, I rise today staff. My staff is my family, and I cannot com- Stoddard and Gabriel Zimmerman, the Con- on behalf of Congresswoman GIFFORDS, her prehend why anyone could or would hurt a gresswoman’s aide. staff, the injured, those who lost their lives and group of honest, hard-working people united in I pray for a speedy recovery to everyone in- all of their families and loved ones—all of their desire to serve the people of southern jured during this tragic event and hope for whom remain in our thoughts and prayers fol- Arizona. GABBY’s quick return to Congress to do what lowing this past Saturday’s horrible and tragic I also join the Nation in honoring the lives of she loves most, represent the people of Arizo- event. Having the opportunity to serve with the six brave Americans who lost their lives in na’s 8th GABBY on the Science and Technology Com- this senseless act of violence and in offering Mr. KIND. Madam Speaker, I am extremely mittee in Congress has truly been a blessing my support and best wishes for a speedy re- saddened by the senseless act of violence as she embraces the human spirit in all her covery to all those affected by this tragedy. that occurred in Arizona. My thoughts and work. GABBY is not a weathervane politician—she GABBY GIFFORDS is a good heart, a great prayers go out to my close personal friend, takes courageous votes that are supported by mind, and one of the nicest Members of Con- Rep. GIFFORDS, her family and all the victims gress with whom I have had the honor of serv- of this terrible tragedy. her keen intellect and engaging personality. Her quick wittedness and joy in providing serv- ing. When I last saw her, at the airport just Rep. GIFFORDS is a hard-working, compas- hours before the attack, she was going home sionate Member of Congress. This past week- ice through her work as a Representative stands as testimony to us all. to do exactly what we all do—what we were end’s event is particularly tragic because she She is one of our Nation’s brightest young elected and what the people of this country was doing what all Members should be out leaders—intelligent, dedicated, effective and doing, showing her dedication to her constitu- expect us to do—working with constituents, fair. listening to their concerns and being respon- ents and out listening to folks back home. I wish her and all the other injured victims sive to their needs. During her time in Congress, I have worked in this senseless tragedy a quick and speedy Saturday’s attack came as a shock to me with her on various initiatives through the ef- recovery. not just as a member of Congress, but be- forts of the New Democrat Coalition. I have al- Mr. WALZ. Madam Speaker, today I rise cause the violence reached beyond the realm ways been particularly impressed with her after some of the saddest days I have ever of politics, and took the lives of innocent, ordi- commitment to fiscal responsibility, deficit re- lived through. A friend and a colleague, an ex- nary Americans who took time out of their duction, and advancing innovation and tech- emplary member of this body was gunned busy lives to participate in our democracy. nology. She is a long-term thinker who has down while doing her job. Innocent lives were As Members of Congress, when we sign up worked to promote initiatives that are impor- lost and a Nation grieves for their family and to serve our country we understand there is tant to both her district and the country. friends. an inherent risk. But we never imagine our I would like to send my deepest sympathies GABRIELLE is one of the finest public serv- mere presence could so endanger innocent to the families of Gabe Zimmerman, a com- ants I have ever had the privilege of knowing. constituents wishing to voice their opinions. An mitted member of her team in addition to When GABRIELLE and I first arrived here in the attack at an event of this kind is an attack Judge John M. Roll, Christina Taylor Green, beginning of 2007, it was with a deep pride in against that which makes our Nation great and Dorothy Morris, Phyllis Schneck, and Dorwan our home districts and the commitment that must not be tolerated. Stoddard. These individuals were engaging in we would do whatever it took to work hard for GABBY is famous for her smile that could the political process in the best way possible, the people we were so honored to represent. light up a room and her fearless tenacity to by speaking directly to their representative. GABRIELLE’s passion for her job and her con- reach across the aisle to find solutions for the The exchange of ideas is critical to our de- stituents is an inspiration to me and to this problems facing this Nation. In a tight race in mocracy and it’s important that Members of Congress. My greatest hope is that she will re- a politically diverse district, GABBY was re- Congress continue to provide forums in which covery as quickly as possible and come back elected three times because of her ability to to meet with and listen to constituents. I have to join her colleagues who miss her. My wife find consensus in a sea of chaos and her will- and will continue to make town halls and lis- Gwen and I are praying for her recovery and ingness to fight, not for the left or for the right, tening sessions a priority in western Wis- our thoughts are with her wonderful husband but for what’s best for the people of Arizona. consin. At this time, we should also take this Mark and her wonderful family. If we, as a nation, can learn from our mistakes moment to remember that we can fight hard Gwen, my staff and I all grieve for the loss and take something away from this tragedy, for the principles in which we believe with civil- of her Director of Outreach, Gabe Zimmerman let it be that we follow her footsteps and use ity and consideration without compromising and we are praying for the speedy recovery of our office and our government to unite rather our values or the values of others. Ron and Pam, two staffers who are still recov- than divide our healing Nation. I also want to thank all the first responders, ering from gunshot wounds. Mr. THOMPSON of California. Madam law enforcement and medical personnel In a Politico story this week, Doug Hart, Speaker, I rise today in honor of a dear friend whose quick actions helped prevent further president for the Arizona Alliance for Retired and colleague Congresswoman GABRIELLE loss of life. These individuals provide an in- Americans said of Gabe, ‘‘He just had a heart GIFFORDS, as well as all of those who lost their valuable service to all of our communities and for people.’’ Politico also reported Gabe told lives or were injured during the tragic events I thank them for their dedicated work. the Tucson Citizen in 2007, ‘‘We serve who of January 8, 2011, in Tucson, Arizona. I wish GABBY and all others involved a walks into our office and we don’t even ask Today the House gathers at an incredibly speedy recovery. what party they belong to.’’ In Gabe’s memory, sad moment for our country. The events of Mr. BUTTERFIELD. Madam Speaker, I have let us continue to serve our constituents to the January 8, 2011, are reprehensible and truly come to the well today, not to make a long best of our ability, regardless of their political heartbreaking. I speak today of my close speech, for my colleagues have spoken so beliefs. And today, let us remember Gabe and friend and an esteemed colleague in the Blue well, but to extend the heartfelt tribute to the all those members of our own staff who come Dog Coalition, GABBY. Her leadership and affected families on behalf of the people of the to work every day dedicated to helping the compassion for the people she represents is a first district of North Carolina. Americans we serve. testament to the meaningful work she has ac- Madam Speaker, we must seize this sense- I also want to express my deepest condo- complished during her tenure as a United less and tragic event as an opportunity for us lences to Judge John Roll’s family. In the sto- States Representative. The legacy she has to reconcile our differences and reduce the ries that have emerged in recent days, we can created is one of moderate and pragmatic political tone in this country. The American see he was a dedicated public servant and a leadership—qualities that are essential to the people are demanding that we represent them distinguished member of our judicial system.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:51 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00054 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.021 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H197 My thoughts and prayers are also with all Services Committee and are both members of ture, we not only do a disservice to those who the families of GABRIELLE’s constituents who the Blue Dog Coalition. I know firsthand her were harmed and killed on Saturday, but we were victims in this horrific attack. They were commitment to making our Nation better for all betray our commitment to the participatory doing what we hope our constituents will do Americans. She is a tireless advocate for principles on which our democracy, which every day. Come to our events and lend us every man and woman in uniform and their must serve as a political and social example their wisdom and ideas. These civic minded families. Today, we are all praying not only for to other nations, was founded. We should re- Americans make our jobs possible and we her recovery, but for her return to Congress. examine how we treat and care for those suf- grieve over losing them. When Congresswoman GIFFORDS, her staff, fering mentally in our country. We must thor- As I think about the event that GABRIELLE and her constituents gathered to participate in oughly discuss how individuals become eligi- hosted on Saturday and the kind of Arizonians one of the most basic American rights in our ble to purchase automatic weapons. And we who attended her event, I am reminded of the great Nation—the right to civil discourse—no must learn to communicate about our dif- very best in the American people. A young girl one expected the day to end tragically. The ferences in ways that are more thoughtful and born in the depths of tragedy who wanted to shooting on January 8, 2011, is a national civil and that better promote aspiration to make the world better for her classmates and tragedy and an attack on the right of every those qualities in all who hear or read our her generation. A husband who’s final act was American to participate in free and open dia- words. protecting his wife. A passionate advocate for logue with the men and women they elect to I continue to hope and pray for a full recov- justice who wanted to share his thoughts with represent them in Congress ery for Congresswoman GIFFORDS and the his Representative. They were all people who I would like to recognize Congresswoman other injured victims and for a healing within wanted to make a difference in the direction of GIFFORDS’s staff members who were wounded for all those hurt internally by Saturday’s the country they loved and their attendance at in the shooting, including Gabe Zimmerman, events. Our Nation must continue to grow and Saturday’s event was no less than the dream who lost his life, and the five other Americans become stronger in the face of this tragedy. and vision of our founding fathers. who were killed: Christine-Taylor Green, Doro- Ms. WASSERMAN SCHULTZ. Madam I don’t know whether the heated political thy Morris, U.S. District Court Judge John Speaker, I solemnly rise in support of this res- rhetoric caused the terrible events on Satur- Roll, Phyllis Schneck, and Dorwin Stoddard. olution. day. We may never know the answer to that We are all praying for their families and loved We come together today in tribute to Con- question. But surely we can all agree that our ones. gresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS and all of politics have been too divisive, our debates Madam Speaker, today, our hearts are with the innocent victims of a deranged gunman’s too heated and our words too harsh. our friend, Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIF- actions in Tucson, Arizona. In the honor of the victims of Saturday’s at- FORDS. This past weekend, our Nation witnessed a tack, we must rededicate ourselves to civility. Mr. OLVER. Madam Speaker, on Saturday, horrifying and tragic act of violence that took To passionate, but never angry, public debate. Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, along the lives of six, and left many others wounded, To respectful disagreements. To rededicate with members of her congressional staff and including our friend and colleague, GABBY. ourselves to accessibility to the people we constituents, were senselessly shot while at- GABBY is one of my closest friends and my represent and to the notion that debate with- tending a ‘‘Congress on Your Corner’’ event in thoughts and prayers are with her husband out violence is the cornerstone of our rep- Tucson. Those killed by the gunman—U.S. Mark, GABBY’s parents, and their family as resentative democracy. District Judge John Roll, Gabe Zimmerman, they struggle to get through this unimaginable Mr. STARK. Madam Speaker, I join my col- Christina Green, Dorothy Morris, Phyllis tragedy. I pray for her full recovery and the recovery leagues in honoring Representative GIFFORDS, Scheck and Dorwin Stoddard—were citizens of the other victims of this horrific act of mourning the victims of this senseless shoot- participating in the democratic process, meet- senseless violence. I also pray for the Tucson ing, and lauding the heroism of those who en- ing and speaking with their Member of Con- gress. community and for our Nation. dangered themselves to help those who were While she and the others wounded in this Like everyone else, I was shocked by the injured. attack struggle to recover, we pause to honor Saturday’s horrific shooting in Tucson of news. This kind of deadly violence shakes a those we have lost. community and a nation to its core. The rapid, Representative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, mem- They were Americans from every walk of life-saving action of Tucson’s emergency re- bers of her staff, a federal judge, and innocent life, and from every season in the journey of sponders and medical professionals and the bystanders should never have happened. life. They died exercising freedoms that make acts of courage displayed by those at the Representative GIFFORDS was performing the this country so special—the freedom to peti- event do, however, serve to remind us that the most fundamental duty of a Member of Con- tion their government and speak freely to their kindness of the human spirit can fight back in gress—she was making herself available to elected representatives. her constituents. It is something we all do— even the darkest of moments. My thoughts They include: and something I strongly believe we must con- and prayers are with all those in Tucson, in Christina Taylor Green, a 9-year-old girl just tinue to do. particular the families of those who were in- elected to her student council who wanted to My thoughts are with the victims, their family jured or killed, and especially with my friend see her Congresswoman in action; members and their friends at this time. and outstanding colleague in the House, A Federal judge—John McCarthy Roll—who I hope that we can learn from this tragedy. GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. stopped by to thank his colleague for working Violence has no place in our democracy. In the four years I have served with Con- with him on immigration matters; While the details of the shooting are still com- gresswoman GIFFORDS, she has been a stal- Gabe Zimmerman, a 30-year-old congres- ing to light, we can all agree that political rhet- wart supporter of her district, her State and sional caseworker who brought compassion to oric and imagery that condones or encourages America’s interests at home and abroad. It is his community outreach work; and violence—whether from activists, party organi- impossible not to admire her commitment to Three additional victims who were vibrant zations, or politicians—is unacceptable. We the job of Representative and the passion with and active retirees like so many in my home can have differences of opinion on policy and which she pursues her interests and policy district in South Florida—Phyllis Schneck, 79, still treat each other with humanity. agenda. I am proud to serve on the Sustain- Dorwan Stoddard, 76, and Dorothy Morris, 76. Mr. BOSWELL. Madam Speaker, I rise able Energy and Environment Coalition, where Now, anyone who knows GABBY, knows that today to recognize Congresswoman GABBY is an influential advocate for renewable she is one of the most kind, thoughtful, and GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, who is a courageous energy. She is a positive, moderate, thoughtful optimistic people you will meet. She has the leader and fierce ally for her State of Arizona voice in our Caucus, and it is my greatest sunniest disposition and sees the good in ev- and for all Americans. Congresswoman GIF- hope that she will recover from this terrible eryone—even people who most wouldn’t. So it FORDS, her staff, and her constituents were tragedy and return as soon as possible to her is particularly unbelievable that she would be subjected to a tragic act of violence on Janu- job. We certainly need her and miss her. the target of a deranged individual with anti- ary 8, 2011, when a gunman opened fire at a I don’t believe that I have ever seen her government views. When I heard the news, I public event for the Congresswoman in Tuc- without a smile on her face, which is quite a thought, ‘‘Not GABBY?’’ son, Arizona. The entire State of Iowa is pray- feat for someone working on Capitol Hill. She She is also deeply committed to the prin- ing for her recovery, and for the family mem- is a wonderful, upbeat and remarkable person. ciples of public discourse and vibrant democ- bers and loved ones of every American af- It is imperative that we begin to learn every- racy that brought her face to face with her fected by the Arizona shooting. thing we can from what happened in Tucson. constituents on Saturday. She simply rep- Madam Speaker, Congresswoman GIF- If we do not take what measures we can to resents the very best of what a public servant FORDS and I served on the House Armed prevent such violence from occurring in the fu- should be.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:09 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00055 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.033 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H198 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 So I would be misleading you if I said I un- Today—we recognize and honor the service one of the hardest-working members of this derstand why this happened, I do not. Per- of Representative GIFFORDS, a dedicated pub- House, and has proven herself to be an ener- haps it is impossible to make sense of a mind lic servant and truly exceptional Member of getic representative of her district’s interests so full of hate, so deranged and so broken. Congress. and a thoughtful stateswoman. She is loved And I cannot tell you with any certainty that We also recognize the bravery of those he- and admired by her colleagues and her con- the acrimony and political vitriol that are so roes and first responders, who saved lives and stituents in the Eighth District of Arizona, who prevalent in our society today contributed to prevented the deranged gunman from doing are fortunate and grateful that she survived spurring this madman. But I fear that his deep- further damage. this terrible attack. seated distrust of our government contributed The ability to resolve problems and conflicts But there are six others who will not be re- to his actions. in a non-violent manner is a bedrock value of turning to their families and friends as a result We must move forward—but how? How do our system of government. of this tragedy, and I know GABBY would want we honor the victims of this tragedy? How do Saturday’s cowardly attack is an assault on the focus to be on them. One of the six, we protect our society from such hatred? the very principles that we as Americans hold GABBY’s Outreach Director Gabriel Zimmer- I have looked in my own heart, and what I dear. man, was a Federal employee killed while know is that we need each other right now. I urge my colleagues to cast a vote to con- helping GABBY better represent her constitu- Though our hearts are heavy, we must be demn hatred, and honor those innocent indi- ents. steadfast in our determination to uphold the viduals who were impacted by this heinous act Madam Speaker, I grieve for our nation American spirit and the principles of our de- of violence. when a 9-year-old girl seeking to meet her mocracy for which GABBY has so vigorously The thoughts and prayers of Barbara and I Congresswoman becomes a target for murder. fought. go out to the families of those who lost their I fervently hope that all Americans, especially I believe we should use this moment to re- lives in this terrible tragedy, and we continue those of us honored with the public trust, view mind each other, remind all Americans and re- to pray for a full recovery for Representative this tragedy as a moment to take personal re- mind the world that the strength of our convic- GIFFORDS and all other victims. sponsibility for building a safer, more civil and tions, the strength of our democracy, comes Madam Speaker, I rise to add some addi- better future. from our unity of purpose. tional remarks to my earlier statement in sup- We are praying for you, GABBY, and for the Yes, as public servants and passionate ad- port of H. Res. 32. families of all those affected by this senseless vocates we have, and we will, disagree on In this time of grieving for all of us, it is im- tragedy. policies of the day, sometimes vigorously. portant we take this moment to recognize and Mr. SIRES. Madam Speaker, I rise today in That is as it should be. honor the six individuals who lost their lives in honor of Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIF- But I have no doubt that every person in this heinous crime. FORDS, her staff, and all the victims of the Tuc- this chamber loves our country, staunchly de- Christina Taylor Green was a 9-year-old son tragedy. fends our Constitution, and brings to this body child, recently elected to the student council at On January 8, Representative GIFFORDS a desire to see a more perfect union. Let us Mesa Verde Elementary School. was hosting an event to simply engage with show the world the truth of these words. Dorothy Morris, 76, was married to her hus- her constituents. At that event, a man fired I can say it no better than the words that band George for over 50 years. George was shots at the Congresswoman, her staff, and conclude our Declaration of Independence. In also at the shooting and courageously tried to the assembled crowd. this sacred document, our founding fathers shield his wife from the attack. Due to this senseless act, six people are call for us to ‘‘mutually pledge to each other John Roll, 63, had an outstanding legal ca- dead and fourteen others are injured, including our lives, our Fortunes, our sacred Honor.’’ reer, culminating in his service as Chief Judge the Congresswoman, who remains in critical Indeed—if we are not joined in the united for the District of Arizona. He and his wife condition. effort to strengthen our democracy—then we Maureen had three children and five grand- I have had the pleasure to serve on the risk allowing those that hate all that we stand children. House Committee on Foreign Affairs with Con- for, rip us asunder. Phyllis Schneck, 79, a New Jersey native, gresswoman GIFFORDS, and it has been noth- As Speaker BOEHNER so eloquently said, was spending the winter in Arizona. She was ing less than an honor to work with her. Her ‘‘An attack on one who serves is an attack on a church volunteer and a proud mother of passion and commitment to her constituents all who serve.’’ So we must pledge to come three, and grandmother of seven. and her country is unyielding, and she has al- together, to work together, and to be together. Dorwan Stoddard, 76, was also a church ways approached her work in Congress with Let us rededicate ourselves to doing so with volunteer and also shielded his wife, Mary, the attention and respect that it deserves. I a new tone of civility in our public discourse. during the attack. was shocked and saddened to hear of this at- Let us show the world that there is so much Gabriel Zimmerman, 30, was engaged to be tack. more that unites us than divides us. married and was known throughout the com- On Saturday morning, six people attended And when we do disagree, we know that we munity as a man of great character for his an event held by their local representative, solve those differences not with violence, but work in Representative GIFFORDS’ office. and for this, they lost their lives. In a demo- with words and with our vote. Let us stand together to honor the lives of cratic country that symbolizes hope and free- We are united in the pursuit so eloquently these individuals, and offer our heartfelt con- dom for so many, it is difficult to witness and put by President Abraham Lincoln, ‘‘that gov- dolences to the families, friends, and loved impossible to understand this hateful act. ernment of the people, by the people, and for ones they leave behind. My thoughts and prayers, along with those the people, shall not perish from the earth.’’ I urge my colleagues to reaffirm our commit- of all Americans, go out to the Giffords’ family, I finish by noting that GABBY has always ex- ment to a democracy in which all peoples can the families of the Congresswoman’s staff, emplified the Jewish ideal of tikkun olam—re- participate without intimidation or fear of vio- and all those impacted by this tragedy. pairing and healing the world. May we all lence, and support today’s resolution. I would also like to thank that day’s heroes come together in this beautiful message of Again, the thoughts and prayers of Barbara for their quick reactions that undoubtedly healing—for our wounded world, our beloved and I go out to the victims and families im- saved many lives. The actions of these indi- friend, and all the victims of this tragedy. pacted by this tragedy, and we continue to viduals and the outpouring of support from May the strength with which GABBY has pray for a swift recovery for Representative around the country give us all strength during healed the world, and the spirit of tikkun olam GIFFORDS and all others wounded in this ter- this difficult time. in turn heal her, the other wounded, and the rible tragedy. Mr. GEORGE MILLER of California. Madam families of those who lost loved ones. Mr. BISHOP of New York. Madam Speaker, Speaker, I rise to join my colleagues to honor Madam Speaker, it is with a somber heart I rise today to join my colleagues in supporting those who died and were wounded in Tucson, that I rise to voice my strong support for H. the Resolution before us today, and to ex- Arizona this past Saturday. The senseless Res. 32. press my deepest condolences for the families rampage took the lives of six remarkable peo- This resolution condemns the horrific attack of those killed in the tragic shooting in Tucson, ple and forever altered the lives of their fami- that took place in Tucson this past weekend, Arizona, on January 8. I also offer my prayers lies, 13 other people who were wounded, and honors the memory of all those who lost their for a speedy and full recovery to my friend each of their families. This tragedy has lives in the attack, and expresses hope for a and colleague, GABBY GIFFORDS, as well as to touched the soul of our Nation and we will not complete recovery for all those wounded in all those wounded in the attack. forget it. the attack, including our friend and colleague, This past Saturday was a dark day for this Like my colleagues and Americans through- Representative GABRIELLE GIFFORDS. chamber and our nation. GABBY GIFFORDS is out our country, I am deeply saddened and

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:09 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00056 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.048 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE January 12, 2011 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H199 disturbed by the events that took place as our prevent Americans from participating in the natured rhetoric—and discuss our opinions re- colleague, Congresswoman GABRIELLE GIF- democratic process. spectfully. The negative and personal attacks FORDS, conducted her outdoor constituent It is my hope to once again work alongside against one other must stop. town meeting in Tucson. To the families of my colleague, Congresswoman GIFFORDS, as I hope that GABBY makes a speedy recovery those who died I offer my heartfelt condo- we seek to find solutions to problems that we and can soon return to this floor where she lences. And for my colleague, GABBY, as we face as a nation. will continue to be an example of courtesy and call her, and her family, and to the other vic- May God bless the victims of this tragedy, civility to us all. I yield the balance of my time. tims and their families, I offer my prayers as their families and all Americans. Ms. CLARKE of New York. Madam Speak- they receive urgent medical treatment and Mrs. CAPITO. Madam Speaker, I rise today er, I rise on behalf of the people of New begin their recovery. in support of House Resolution 32 to honor York’s 11th congressional district to offer my I share in the comments that so many of my the victims of the senseless act of violence thoughts and prayers to Congresswoman colleagues have already made about GABBY. that took place in Tucson on Saturday. GABRIELLE GIFFORDS, her staff, constituents, She has worked hard and contributed much. Six members of the Arizona community lost and all those affected by this tragic shooting. She is a highly respected colleague and a their lives and one of our own, GABBY GIF- I am truly shocked, horrified and deeply sad- courageous representative for Arizona and our FORDS, has been gravely injured. It’s hard to dened by this senseless act of violence. I take country. The attack on Congresswoman GIF- find the words to describe the deep sorrow we time to reflect on those who lost their lives, in- FORDS and her staff and constituents is deplor- all feel for the families and friends of the cluding a Federal judge, a 9-year-old girl, and able and represents an attack on all Ameri- shooter’s victims. one of Congresswoman GIFFORDS’ staff. I pray cans. His actions have shown us human behavior for a swift recovery for the wounded and offer I also join my colleagues in saluting the her- at its darkest, but the heroes of the day rep- my heartfelt thanks to those who rushed in to oism of four men and women who subdued resent our society at its best. The innocent by- offer aid. the shooter and attended to GABBY imme- standers quickly rallied to curtail the gunman I consider GABBY, as she is affectionately diately after she was shot. These men and and perform triage on the victims. The Amer- called, to be a wonderful colleague whom I women truly made a difference on that Satur- ican people are humbled by the bravery of have the pleasure of serving alongside on im- day. They deserve our praise and admiration. those who put themselves in harm’s way and portant issues such as immigration reform. Madam Speaker, the responsibility for this grateful for the talented first responders and She has demonstrated exemplary leadership tragedy lies with the shooter, someone who medical professionals who have compas- and is a very well respected Member of the had earlier been identified as needing mental sionately cared for the wounded. House of Representatives. health care and who should never have been As we’ve all come to know, GABBY is a fight- While we do not know the motive, we do able to obtain a gun. Thankfully, he is in cus- er. With the help of the thoughts and prayers know that the time has come for us to tone tody and his fate is now in the hands of our of millions of Americans who are wishing for down our rhetoric and partisanship. We are re- sponsible for our words and must respect law enforcement and judicial system. her speedy recovery, GABBY has beat the But while he will be tried for his act, this at- odds and has thus far made a remarkable turn those who hold different points of view. Our tack has raised in all of us a deep and gnaw- for the better. We should all be inspired by constituents and the world at large should see ing question that must be unanswered. How us as examples of civility, peaceful debate and GABBY’s strength. can we improve ourselves after this tragedy? Madam Speaker, we cannot forget that this democracy. Regardless of one’s political affili- Everyone who meets Congresswoman GIF- ation, we must learn to respectfully agree to tragedy occurred as GABBY was performing FORDS knows she is not an angry woman. She her most fundamental duty as an elected rep- disagree. There are several issues before has sought to balance the diverse interests of resentative: listening to the people. This attack Congress that would benefit all Americans and her district while doing what she believes to is quite literally an assault on the very demo- many people overseas but often times have be in the best interest of our country. Yet she been marginalized by partisanship. Our con- cratic values which we seek everyday to up- was attacked, vilified and denounced by ex- stituents expect us to work for them and not hold in this Chamber. As we struggle with how treme political factions who sought to demon- allow politics to get in the way of governing. ize her for what she believed as a member of to handle the aftermath of this tragedy, let us Finally, this shooting has many of us think- Congress. reflect on the values that make our country ing about the security and safety of our con- We cannot undo the events of Saturday, great. stituents when we are back home holding January 8, but we can and should commit our- Mr. RUPPERSBERGER. Madam Speaker, town hall meetings, meeting with constituents selves to a more responsible level of political my heart goes out to all of the victims of the and doing the people’s work. Many people die discourse in America. I hope we can all learn terrible tragedy—those that were killed or in- or are wounded daily from gun violence and from the events in Tucson, that in the name of jured, their families and the entire Tucson many suffer from mental illnesses that are ei- GABBY and all of the victims of this deadly community. I extend my condolences to all of ther not properly diagnosed or treated. This shooting, we can commit ourselves to the members of the Arizona delegation. tragedy provides the opportunity to further dis- strengthen our Nation, not fight each other, to My thoughts and prayers are with GABBY. I cuss mental health and gun control legislation. be able to disagree with each other without know she is a fighter. I recall our trip together Madam Speaker, let us, as Members of hating or demonizing one another for it. to the Middle East. We met with the presi- Congress, reaffirm our commitment to work on Madam Speaker, thank you for this oppor- dents of Israel, Lebanon and Syria before we behalf of our constituents—those who sent us tunity to pay tribute to Congresswoman GIF- traveled to Iraq, where we walked down the here to represent their interest. Let us do our FORDS, her staff, her constituents, and every- streets of Baghdad together. I was so im- part to build a better Nation and world. one touched by the tragedy that unfolded on pressed by her courage and commitment to Mr. COSTELLO. Madam Speaker, I join our Saturday in Tucson. the troops on the frontline. colleagues today in offering my condolences Mr. DESJARLAIS. Madam Speaker, I rise It is unthinkable to me that GABBY was safer to the victims and families of last weekend’s today in support of House Resolution 32. in Baghdad than here in her own country. shooting in Tucson, Arizona. They are in our I am pleased that Members of the House of Every American has a right to express their thoughts and prayers during this extremely dif- Representatives came together today to speak opinion on whatever issue they choose, but ficult time. Our friend Congresswoman GIF- with a unified voice in both condemning this there is no place in our society for this kind of FORDS remains in the hospital, and we are heinous attack, and expressing our condo- hatred and violence. No one should have to hopeful that her recovery will continue to lences to the friends and families of all the in- think twice about their safety when they go to progress and that she will be back here on the nocent victims that were killed or wounded speak to their Congressman or attend a town House floor in the near future. due to this horrific act of violence. hall meeting. This has been an attack not only The passage of a few days has done little This resolution reaffirms the democratic on GABBY, her staff and her innocent constitu- to make this attack any more comprehensible. principles that Congresswoman GIFFORDS her- ents, but the democratic process itself. As much as anything, it is a chilling reminder self espoused when she read the First With every negative, we should put forth our of the fragile nature of our lives. It gives us all Amendment of the Constitution during the best effort to find a positive. It is my hope that pause that GABRIELLE was hurt doing the opening week of the 112th Congress—the this horrific tragedy will bring our country and same things that we do every day as part of right of the people peaceably to assemble, our Congress together. Our forefathers cre- representing our constituents, that staff mem- and to petition the government for a redress of ated a great system of government. Unfortu- bers were killed and injured as part of their grievances. nately, I don’t think the spiteful partisanship of service, and that in a public setting such as It is critical that we send a message that today is what they had in mind. We must be this we cannot absolutely guarantee anyone’s threats of violence and intimidation will not tolerant of other views—to tone down the ill- safety.

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:09 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00057 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 9920 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.015 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE H200 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE January 12, 2011 As I said immediately after the event, with- 64. A letter from the Secretary, Depart- titles were introduced and severally re- out drawing conclusions about what happened ment of Health and Human Services, trans- ferred, as follows: mitting the Department’s report entitled, here, I hope that as a country we agree to By Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- ‘‘Report to Congress on Head Start Moni- fornia (for himself, Mrs. ADAMS, Mr. tone down the volume and animosity that has toring for Fiscal Year 2008’’, pursuant to Sec- ADERHOLT, Mr. AKIN, Mr. ALEXANDER, become so much a part of our political dis- tion 641(e) of the Head Start Act; to the Mr. AMASH, Mr. AUSTRIA, Mrs. course. We can disagree without being en- Committee on Education and the Workforce. emies. 65. A letter from the Director, Regulatory BACHMANN, Mr. BACHUS, Mr. BARLETTA, Mr. BARTLETT, Mr. BAR- Madam Speaker, contrary to popular belief, Management Division, Environmental Pro- tection Agency, transmitting the Agency’s TON of Texas, Mr. BASS of New Hamp- most, if not all of us, ran for office because we shire, Mr. BENISHEK, Mr. BERG, Ms. want to help people—because we believe we final rule — Alaska: Adequacy of Alaska Mu- nicipal Solid Waste Landfill Permit Program BERKLEY, Mrs. BIGGERT, Mr. BILBRAY, have something to offer through public serv- [EPA-R10-RCRA-2010-0953; FRL-9247-6] re- Mr. BILIRAKIS, Mr. BISHOP of Utah, ice. That is certainly true for GABRIELLE. ceived January 4, 2011, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. Mrs. BLACK, Mrs. BLACKBURN, Mr. Through our grief, despite the potential risks, 801(a)(1)(A); to the Committee on Energy and BONNER, Mrs. BONO MACK, Mr. I think we still all agree that this work is worth Commerce. BOUSTANY, Mr. BRADY of Texas, Mr. BROOKS, Mr. BROUN of Georgia, Mr. doing, that we can and do make a difference, 66. A letter from the Director, Regulatory Management Division, Environmental Pro- BUCHANAN, Mr. BUCSHON, Ms. and that with GABRIELLE as our example, we tection Agency, transmitting the Agency’s BUERKLE, Mr. BURGESS, Mr. BURTON must push ahead as a country, as a society, final rule — Testing of Certain High Produc- of Indiana, Mr. CALVERT, Mr. CAMP- to help each other the best that we can. tion Volume Chemicals; Second Group of BELL, Mr. CANSECO, Mrs. CAPITO, Mr. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Chemicals [EPA-HQ-OPPT-2007-0531; FRL- CARDOZA, Mr. CARTER, Mr. CASSIDY, fornia. Madam Speaker, I yield back 8846-9] (RIN: 2070-AD16) received January 4, Mr. CHAFFETZ, Mr. COBLE, Mr. the balance of my time. 2011, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 801(a)(1)(A); to the COFFMAN of Colorado, Mr. COLE, Mr. The SPEAKER pro tempore. Pursu- Committee on Energy and Commerce. CONAWAY, Mr. CRAVAACK, Mr. CRAWFORD, Mr. CRENSHAW, Mr. CRITZ, ant to the order of the House of today, 67. A letter from the Director, Regulatory Mr. CULBERSON, Mr. DAVIS of Ken- the previous question is ordered on the Management Division, Environmental Pro- tection Agency, transmitting the Agency’s tucky, Mr. DENHAM, Mr. DENT, Mr. resolution and on the preamble. final rule — Approval and Promulgation of DESJARLAIS, Mr. DIAZ-BALART, Mr. The question is on the resolution. Air Quality Implementation Plans; Texas; DOLD, Mr. DREIER, Mr. DUFFY, Mr. The resolution was agreed to. Revisions to Rules and Regulations for Con- DUNCAN of South Carolina, Mr. DUN- A motion to reconsider was laid on trol of Air Pollution; Permitting of Grand- CAN of Tennessee, Mrs. ELLMERS, Mrs. the table. fathered and Electing Electric Generating EMERSON, Mr. FARENTHOLD, Mr. FITZPATRICK, Mr. FLAKE, Mr. f Facilities [EPA-R06-OAR-2005-TX-0031; FRL- 9248-9] received January 4, 2011, pursuant to FLEISCHMANN, Mr. FLEMING, Mr. FLO- APPOINTMENT OF MEMBERS TO 5 U.S.C. 801(a)(1)(A); to the Committee on RES, Mr. FORBES, Mr. FORTENBERRY, PERMANENT SELECT COM- Energy and Commerce. Ms. FOXX, Mr. FRANK of Massachu- MITTEE ON INTELLIGENCE 68. A letter from the Assistant Secretary, setts, Mr. FRANKS of Arizona, Mr. Legislative Affairs, Department of State, FRELINGHUYSEN, Mr. GALLEGLY, Mr. The SPEAKER pro tempore. Without transmitting the 2010 annual report on the GARDNER, Mr. GARRETT, Mr. GER- objection, pursuant to clause 11 of rule Benjamin A. Gilman International Scholar- LACH, Mr. GIBBS, Mr. GIBSON, Mr. X, clause 11 of rule I, and the order of ship Program, pursuant to Public Law 106- GINGREY of Georgia, Mr. GOHMERT, the House of January 5, 2011, and not- 309, section 304; to the Committee on Foreign Mr. GOODLATTE, Mr. GOSAR, Mr. withstanding the requirement of clause Affairs. GOWDY, Ms. GRANGER, Mr. GRAVES of Missouri, Mr. GRAVES of Georgia, Mr. 11(a)(1)(C) of rule X, the Chair an- 69. A letter from the Chairman, Merit Sys- tems Protection Board, transmitting a re- GRIFFIN of Arkansas, Mr. GRIFFITH of nounces the Speaker’s appointment of port entitled ‘‘Whistleblower Protections for Virginia, Mr. GRIMM, Mr. GUINTA, Mr. the following Members of the House to Federal Employees’’, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. GUTHRIE, Mr. HALL, Mr. HANNA, Mr. the Permanent Select Committee on 1204(a)(3); to the Committee on Oversight HARPER, Mrs. HARTZLER, Mr. Intelligence: and Government Reform. HASTINGS of Washington, Ms. Mr. THORNBERRY, Texas; 70. A letter from the Director, Office of HAYWORTH, Mr. HELLER, Mr. Mrs. MYRICK, North Carolina; Special Council, transmitting the Office’s HENSARLING, Mr. HERGER, Ms. HER- Performance and Accountability Report for RERA BEUTLER, Mr. HUELSKAMP, Mr. Mr. MILLER, Florida; FY 2010; to the Committee on Oversight and HUIZENGA of Michigan, Mr. Mr. CONAWAY, Texas; Government Reform. HULTGREN, Mr. HUNTER, Mr. HURT, Mr. KING, New York; 71. A letter from the Director, Peace Corps, Mr. ISSA, Ms. JENKINS, Mr. SAM JOHN- Mr. LOBIONDO, New Jersey; transmitting the Inspector General’s semi- SON of Texas, Mr. JOHNSON of Illinois, Mr. NUNES, California; annual report to Congress for the reporting Mr. JONES, Mr. KELLY, Mr. KING of Mr. WESTMORELAND, Georgia; period April 1, 2010 through September 30, New York, Mr. KINGSTON, Mr. Mrs. BACHMANN, Minnesota; 2010, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. app. (Insp. Gen. KINZINGER of Illinois, Mr. KISSELL, Act), section 5(b); to the Committee on Over- Mr. ROONEY, Florida; Mr. KLINE, Mr. LABRADOR, Mr. sight and Government Reform. LAMBORN, Mr. LANCE, Mr. LANDRY, Mr. HECK, Nevada. 72. A letter from the Deputy Assistant Ad- Mr. LANKFORD, Mr. LATHAM, Mr. There was no objection. ministrator for Operations, NMFS, National LATOURETTE, Mr. LATTA, Mr. LEE of f Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, New York, Mr. LEWIS of California, transmitting the Administration’s final rule ADJOURNMENT Mr. LOBIONDO, Mr. LONG, Mr. LUCAS, — Fisheries of the Exclusive Economic Zone Mr. LUETKEMEYER, Mrs. LUMMIS, Mr. Mr. DANIEL E. LUNGREN of Cali- Off Alaska; Steller Sea Lion Protection MACK, Mr. MANZULLO, Mr. MARCHANT, fornia. Madam Speaker, pursuant to Measures for the Bering Sea and Aleutian Is- Mr. MARINO, Mr. MATHESON, Mr. Senate Concurrent Resolution 1, I lands Groundfish Fisheries Off Alaska [Dock- MCCAUL, Mr. MCCLINTOCK, Mr. et No. 101006495-0498-01] (RIN: 0648-BA31) re- move that the House do now adjourn. MCHENRY, Mr. MCKEON, Mr. MCKIN- ceived January 6, 2011, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. LEY, Mrs. MCMORRIS RODGERS, Mr. The motion was agreed to; accord- 801(a)(1)(A); to the Committee on Natural ingly (at 6 p.m.), pursuant to Senate MEEHAN, Mr. MICA, Mrs. MILLER of Resources. Michigan, Mr. GARY G. MILLER of 73. A letter from the Director, Regulatory Concurrent Resolution 1 and pursuant California, Mr. MILLER of Florida, Management Division, Environmental Pro- to House Resolution 32, the House ad- Mr. MULVANEY, Mr. MURPHY of Penn- tection Agency, transmitting the Agency’s journed until Tuesday, January 18, sylvania, Mrs. MYRICK, Mr. final rule — Guidelines for Awarding Clean 2011, at 2 p.m., out of respect for the NEUGEBAUER, Mr. NUGENT, Mr. Water Act Section 319 Base Grants to Indian victims of the attack in Tucson, Ari- NUNES, Mr. NUNNELEE, Mr. OLSON, Tribes [EPA-HQ-OW-2011-XXXX; FRL-9247-8] Mr. PAUL, Mr. PAULSEN, Mr. PENCE, zona. received January 4, 2011, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. Mr. PETERSON, Mr. PETRI, Mr. PITTS, f 801(a)(1)(A); to the Committee on Transpor- Mr. PLATTS, Mr. POE of Texas, Mr. tation and Infrastructure. EXECUTIVE COMMUNICATIONS, POMPEO, Mr. POSEY, Mr. PRICE of ETC. f Georgia, Mr. QUAYLE, Mr. RAHALL, PUBLIC BILLS AND RESOLUTIONS Mr. REED, Mr. REHBERG, Mr. Under clause 2 of rule XIV, executive REICHERT, Mr. RENACCI, Mr. RIBBLE, communications were taken from the Under clause 2 of rule XII, public Mr. RIGELL, Mr. RIVERA, Mr. ROE of Speaker’s table and referred as follows: bills and resolutions of the following Tennessee, Mr. ROGERS of Kentucky,

VerDate Mar 15 2010 04:09 Jan 13, 2011 Jkt 099060 PO 00000 Frm 00058 Fmt 0636 Sfmt 0634 E:\CR\FM\A12JA7.019 H12JAPT1 smartinez on DSKB9S0YB1PROD with HOUSE