Power and Pragmatism in the Political Economy of Angkor

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Power and Pragmatism in the Political Economy of Angkor THESIS FOR THE AWARD OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN ARTS _________ DEPARTMENT OF ARCHAEOLOGY, UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY ____________ POWER AND PRAGMATISM IN THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF ANGKOR EILEEN LUSTIG _________ UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY 2009 Figure 1 Location map 1 Abstract The relationship between the Angkorian Empire and its capital is important for understanding how this state was sustained. The empire’s political economy is studied by analysing data from Pre-Angkorian and Angkorian period inscriptions in aggregated form, in contrast to previous studies which relied mainly on detailed reading of the texts. The study is necessarily broad to overcome the constraints of having relatively few inscriptions which relate to a selected range of topics, and are partial in viewpoint. The success of the pre-modern Khmer state depended on: its long-established communication and trade links; mutual support of rulers and regional elites; decentralised administration through regional centres; its ability to produce or acquire a surplus of resources; and a network of temples as an ideological vehicle for state integration. The claim that there was a centrally controlled command economy or significant redistribution of resources, as for archaic, moneyless societies is difficult to justify. The mode of control varied between the core area and peripheral areas. Even though Angkor did not have money, it used a unit of account. Despite being an inland agrarian polity, the Khmer actively pursued foreign trade. There are indications of a structure, perhaps hierarchical, of linked deities and religious foundations helping to disseminate the state’s ideology. The establishment of these foundations was encouraged by gifts and privileges granted to elite supporters of the rulers. Contrary to some views, Angkor was not excessively rigid or unusually hierarchical and autocratic when compared with contemporary analogous states. Its political economy is marked by three simultaneous cycles indicative of changing power relationships: cycles of royal inscriptions; of non-royal inscriptions; and fluctuating control over peripheral territories. Its processes and strategies were sufficiently flexible for it to endure as an empire for approximately six centuries, despite internal and external disturbances. 2 Acknowledgments This thesis had its beginnings in the decision to do something I had been advised against many years ago, on the grounds that women in the field of archaeology had few opportunities for employment. The relevance of this piece of logic had now passed. For encouragement to commence in the undergraduate program, I’d like to thank both Terry and my supervisor for this thesis, Roland Fletcher, who convinced me that enrolling was a better option than sitting in on classes. Over the years, Roland has assisted in many ways – in sharing his understanding of Southeast Asia and theory of archaeology, suggesting directions for my research and pointing out ‘glitches’ in my arguments. The Greater Angkor Project, which was Roland’s baby, became the umbrella under which I first visited Cambodia and subsequently returned for some of my research. I would like to thank Roland. I have received friendship and considerable assistance from within the University of Sydney and I would first like to thank my three generous research colleagues, Damian Evans, Mitch Hendrickson and Martin Polkinghorne, who were always willing to share ideas, make suggestions, and provide data or technical assistance. The perspectives from their disciplines were directly and indirectly relevant to my research. I would also like to thank Aedeen Cremin and Gaby Ewington for showing me their papers which were not yet published and Aedeen for seeking out data in Bangkok, Canberra and elsewhere. I would not have been able to make use of the Khmer texts without the assistance I received on many occasions from Michael Vickery, whose knowledge of the inscriptions and of the Khmer world I tapped for linguistic, historical and cultural issues — not always receiving an answer that simplified my task, indeed sometimes the opposite. I wish to thank Michael. I also wish to acknowledge two sources of enormous assistance, developed through the dedicated efforts of Doug Cooper of the SEAlang Project: the digitised Corpus of Khmer Inscriptions and Philip Jenner’s Dictionary of Old Khmer. I was able to consult both while they were still in the development stage. Thank you too to Philip Jenner for clarifying the meaning of some Khmer expressions. I am particularly grateful for Gerard Diffloth’s encouragement early in the study to question interpretations of an imperfectly understood language. This had a distinct bearing on my subsequent approach to the texts. University staff who provided advice or technical data for which I am grateful were: Pam Gutman, Dan Penny, Bob Hudson, Peter White and Ian Johnson. Special thanks go to Gavan Butler who spent time on background reading to be able to discuss economic issues for medieval Angkor. I would also like to thank the staff of Fisher Library, in particular Rena McGrogan and the very helpful Interlibrary Loan people; and the Archaeological Computing 3 Laboratory, Ian Johnson and Martin King for advice and the use of its facilities for the production of some of my database and graphics. Despite overcoming some of the obstacles encountered with non-English texts, I required the help of experts. Thank you to Narelle Fletcher and Aedeen Cremin (for the French), John Clark (for the Chinese) and Marina Goddess (for the Russian) for their intelligent translations of the unusual material. Christophe Pottier was most supportive in directing me to sources of data and in his willingness to share his knowledge and experience of Angkor and beyond. I would also like to thank Dominique Soutif for sharing his knowledge of ritual objects and showing me some of his unpublished translations; Gerdi Gerschheimer and Chris Eade, for discussing their ideas on the determination of equivalent values for Khmer units of measurement; and Chris for explaining his high-tech method of dating inscriptions from astronomical data. Several other researchers responded helpfully to my queries and these I would like to thank as well: John Miksic (economics); Bin Yang (Chinese trade routes); Dick Richards and Wong Wai Yee (ceramics), Gillian Green (textiles); Michael Aung-Thwin (Pagan economics); Rethy Chhem (Khmer medicine); Pierre Manguin (archaeology), Jacques Melitz (economics); Barend Jan Terwiel (Thai and Sukhothai trade); Thomas Maxwell (deities); Geoff Wade (Chinese trade) and Nicholas Hardwick (coinages). Kenneth Hall allowed me to have a copy of an English translation for O. W. Wolters of a 1963 paper by Leonard Sedov, and Bob Wicks sent me all the photocopied research material for his 1992 book Money, Markets and Trade in Early Southeast Asia. All these documents proved invaluable. I am especially indebted to Ngaire Richards, who designed my database and found the time to make the several alterations it required, to Peter Barker for his technical assistance in database operations, as well as to Damian Evans and Mitch Hendrickson for their help with GIS and Matthew Ciolek and OWTRAD for data on Silk Road trade routes. Terry Lustig has given much time to assist with statistical analysis and graphical and GIS representations. Thank you to Mitch Hendrickson, Martin Polkinghorne, Terry Lustig, Aedeen Cremin, Colleen Lustig and Kate Lustig who provided insightful comments on drafts of the thesis and to Judy Foster for assistance with data entry. I would also like to thank my other colleagues and friends, Wayne Johnson, Leonard Cox, Marnie Feneley, Edna Wong, Leon Shih, Alexandra Rosen and Donald Cooney who were around for much of my journey and were generous in many ways, and Terry, Kate, Colleen, Tyson, Aiden and Felix for their forbearance… Finally, I wish to acknowledge the financial assistance of the Sydney University Postgraduate Award, the Sydney University PhD Research Travel Grant Scheme, the Sydney University Postgraduate Research Support Scheme and the Carlyle Greenwell Fund during my candidature. 4 For Terry Table of Contents 1 The political economy of the Khmer Empire: an introduction 14 1.1 Introduction 14 1.2 Angkor: city and empire 16 1.2.1 Angkor the city 16 1.2.2 Angkor’s empire 19 1.3 Research agendas 21 1.3.1 Indianisation and colonisation 21 1.3.2 Indigenous innovation 24 1.3.3 Value of the epigraphic data for studying Angkor’s political economy 25 1.4 Power and early states 26 1.4.1 The exercise of power 26 1.4.2 Models of early states 28 1.5 Aim of research and thesis questions 29 1.5.1 Political processes 31 1.5.2 Economic processes 32 1.5.3 Ideological processes – the state and the religious foundations 32 1.6 Structure of thesis 33 1.7 Conclusion 36 2 Debates about political economies: empires and large states 37 2.1 Introduction 37 2.2 The study of empires 38 2.3 Models of empires and large states pertinent to Angkor 39 2.3.1 Asiatic Mode of Production 40 2.3.2 Core-periphery and world systems 41 2.3.3 Loosely integrated polities 43 2.3.4 Networks 46 2.3.5 Territorial-Hegemonic model 47 2.4 Models specific to Angkor 48 2.4.1 Processual model 49 2.4.2 The Temple Hierarchy model 52 2.5 Conclusion 54 3 The resources and economic basis of the Khmer empire 57 3.1 Introduction 57 3.2 Physical and biological resources 58 3.2.1 Land 58 3.2.2 Biological resources 59 6 3.2.3 Mineral resources 61 3.3 Infrastructure 61 3.3.1 Communication networks 62 3.3.2 Formation of the Angkor state:
Recommended publications
  • Virtual Sambor Prei Kuk: an Interactive Learning Tool
    Virtual Sambor Prei Kuk: An Interactive Learning Tool Daniel MICHON Religious Studies, Claremont McKenna College Claremont, CA 91711 and Yehuda KALAY Faculty of Architecture and Town Planning The Technion - Israel Institute of Technology Haifa 32000, Israel ABSTRACT along the trade routes from its Indic origins into Southeast Asia—one of the great cultural assimilations in human history. MUVEs (Multi-User Virtual Environments) are a new media for researching the genesis and evolution of sites of cultural Much of this important work has, so far, remained the exclusive significance. MUVEs are able to model both the tangible and province of researchers, hidden from the general public who intangible heritage of a site, allowing the user to obtain a more might find it justifiably interesting. Further, the advent of dynamic understanding of the culture. This paper illustrates a immersive, interactive, Web-enabled, Multi-User Virtual cultural heritage project which captures and communicates the Environments (MUVEs) has provided us with the opportunity interplay of context (geography), content (architecture and to tell the story of Sambor Prei Kuk in a way that can help artifacts) and temporal activity (rituals and everyday life) visitors experience this remarkable cultural heritage as it might leading to a unique digital archive of the tangible and intangible have been in the seventh-eighth century CE. MUVEs are a new heritage of the temple complex at Sambor Prei Kuk, Cambodia, media vehicle that has the ability to communicate cultural circa seventh-eighth century CE. The MUVE is used to provide heritage experience in a way that is a cross between a platform which enables the experience of weaved tangible and filmmaking, video games, and architectural design.
    [Show full text]
  • A New Date for the Phnom Da Images and Its Implications for Early Cambodia
    A New Date for the Phnom Da Images and Its Implications for Early Cambodia NANCY H. DOWLING SCHOLARS FAMILIAR WITH SOUTHEAST ASIAN ART HISTORY are well aware of a confusing chronology for early Cambodian sculpture. One reason for this situa­ tion is obvious. For nearly fifty years, Cambodian art history has been wed to the work of George Coedes. Praised as the dean of Southeast Asian history, he was a member of an elite group of French scholars who worked in Cambodia for decades before World War II. In 1944, he wrote Histoire ancienne des hats hindouses d'Extreme-Orient, in which he established a chronological framework for early Southeast Asian history based on an interplay of Chinese texts and indigenous inscriptions. Most Southeast Asian historians readily admit that "his book remains the basic source for early South East Asian history, and while much recent re­ search, based upon new inscriptional evidence or re-readings, modifies some of Coedes' specific conclusions, the structure remains his" (Brown 1996: 3). Such a singular dependency on Coedes had a stifling effect on Cambodian art history. When Jean Boisselier, carrying on the work of Philippe Stern and Gilberte de Coral-Remusat, made a comprehensive attempt to set in order Cambodian sculpture, the French art historian fitted the works of art into Coedes' ready­ made chronology. Unfortunately, this all happened as if it were preferable to adjust Cambodian sculpture to a preconceived notion of history rather than ques­ tioning the model. In this way, some basic mistakes have been made, and these seriously affect the chronology and interpretation of early Cambodian sculpture.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix Appendix
    APPENDIX APPENDIX DYNASTIC LISTS, WITH GOVERNORS AND GOVERNORS-GENERAL Burma and Arakan: A. Rulers of Pagan before 1044 B. The Pagan dynasty, 1044-1287 C. Myinsaing and Pinya, 1298-1364 D. Sagaing, 1315-64 E. Ava, 1364-1555 F. The Toungoo dynasty, 1486-1752 G. The Alaungpaya or Konbaung dynasty, 1752- 1885 H. Mon rulers of Hanthawaddy (Pegu) I. Arakan Cambodia: A. Funan B. Chenla C. The Angkor monarchy D. The post-Angkor period Champa: A. Linyi B. Champa Indonesia and Malaya: A. Java, Pre-Muslim period B. Java, Muslim period C. Malacca D. Acheh (Achin) E. Governors-General of the Netherlands East Indies Tai Dynasties: A. Sukhot'ai B. Ayut'ia C. Bangkok D. Muong Swa E. Lang Chang F. Vien Chang (Vientiane) G. Luang Prabang 954 APPENDIX 955 Vietnam: A. The Hong-Bang, 2879-258 B.c. B. The Thuc, 257-208 B.C. C. The Trieu, 207-I I I B.C. D. The Earlier Li, A.D. 544-602 E. The Ngo, 939-54 F. The Dinh, 968-79 G. The Earlier Le, 980-I009 H. The Later Li, I009-I225 I. The Tran, 1225-I400 J. The Ho, I400-I407 K. The restored Tran, I407-I8 L. The Later Le, I4I8-I8o4 M. The Mac, I527-I677 N. The Trinh, I539-I787 0. The Tay-Son, I778-I8o2 P. The Nguyen Q. Governors and governors-general of French Indo­ China APPENDIX DYNASTIC LISTS BURMA AND ARAKAN A. RULERS OF PAGAN BEFORE IOH (According to the Burmese chronicles) dat~ of accusion 1. Pyusawti 167 2. Timinyi, son of I 242 3· Yimminpaik, son of 2 299 4· Paikthili, son of 3 .
    [Show full text]
  • Women in Cambodia – Analysing the Role and Influence of Women in Rural Cambodian Society with a Special Focus on Forming Religious Identity
    WOMEN IN CAMBODIA – ANALYSING THE ROLE AND INFLUENCE OF WOMEN IN RURAL CAMBODIAN SOCIETY WITH A SPECIAL FOCUS ON FORMING RELIGIOUS IDENTITY by URSULA WEKEMANN submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF THEOLOGY in the subject MISSIOLOGY at the UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AFRICA SUPERVISOR: DR D C SOMMER CO-SUPERVISOR: PROF R W NEL FEBRUARY 2016 1 ABSTRACT This study analyses the role and influence of rural Khmer women on their families and society, focusing on their formation of religious identity. Based on literature research, the role and influence of Khmer women is examined from the perspectives of history, the belief systems that shape Cambodian culture and thinking, and Cambodian social structure. The findings show that although very few Cambodian women are in high leadership positions, they do have considerable influence, particularly within the household and extended family. Along the lines of their natural relationships they have many opportunities to influence the formation of religious identity, through sharing their lives and faith in words and deeds with the people around them. A model based on Bible storying is proposed as a suitable strategy to strengthen the natural influence of rural Khmer women on forming religious identity and use it intentionally for the spreading of the gospel in Cambodia. KEY WORDS Women, Cambodia, rural Khmer, gender, social structure, family, religious formation, folk-Buddhism, evangelization. 2 Student number: 4899-167-8 I declare that WOMEN IN CAMBODIA – ANALYSING THE ROLE AND INFLUENCE OF WOMEN IN RURAL CAMBODIAN SOCIETY WITH A SPECIAL FOCUS ON FORMING RELIGIOUS IDENTITY is my own work and that all the sources that I have used or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged by means of complete references.
    [Show full text]
  • A History of Cambodia Free Download
    A HISTORY OF CAMBODIA FREE DOWNLOAD David P. Chandler | 384 pages | 02 Aug 2007 | The Perseus Books Group | 9780813343631 | English | Boulder, CO, United States A History of Cambodia (Third Edition) Simultaneous attacks around the perimeter of Phnom Penh pinned down Republican forces, while other CPK units overran fire bases controlling the vital lower Mekong resupply route. Early Funan was composed of loose communities, each with its own ruler, linked by a common culture and a shared economy of rice farming people in the hinterland and traders in the coastal towns, who were economically interdependent, A History of Cambodia surplus rice production found its way to the ports. Recording of the Royal Chronology discontinues with King Jayavarman IX Parameshwara or Jayavarma-Paramesvara — there exists not a single contemporary record of even a king's name for over years. Discount Codes. Retrieved 29 June Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. During his nearly forty years in power he becomes the A History of Cambodia prolific monument A History of Cambodia, who establishes the city of Angkor Thom with its central temple the Bayon. Neher Book Category Asia portal. Nov 25, Sarah rated it really liked it. Archived from the original PDF on 14 July From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Books by David P. International Journal of Historical Archaeology. My solution was to skim for time periods where I was most curious and to sort through for activities in specific parts of the country. The last Sanskrit inscription is datedand records the succession of Indrajayavarman by Jayavarman IX Parameshwara — His book on "A history of Cambodia" provides a comprehensive and insightful analysis and narratives on Cambodian history from the pre and post Angkor period until modern Cambodia.
    [Show full text]
  • Reclamation and Regeneration of the Ancient Baray
    RECLAMATION AND REGENERATION OF THE ANCIENT BARAY A Proposal for Phimai Historical Park Olmtong Ektanitphong December 2014 Submitted towards the fulfillment of the requirements for the Doctor of Architecture Degree. School of Architecture University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa Doctorate Project Committee Kazi K. Ashraf, Chairperson William R. Chapman, Committee Member Pornthum Thumwimol, Committee Member ACKNOWLEDMENTS I would like to express the deepest appreciation to my committee chair, Professor Kazi K. Ashraf, who has the attitude and the substance of a genius: he continually and convincingly a spirit of adventure in regard to research and the design, and excitement in regard to teaching. Without his guidance and persistent help this dissertation would not have been possible. I would like to thank my committee members, Professor William R. Chapman and Dr. Pornthum Thumwimol, whose work demonstrated to me that concern for archaeological aspects of Khmer and Thai culture. They supported me immensely throughout the period of my dissertation. Their valuable advice and discussions guided me to the end-result of this study. I highly appreciated for their generally being a good uncle and brother as well as a supervisor. In addition, a thank you to the director, archaeologists, academic officers and administration staff at Phimai Historical Park and at the Fine Arts Department of Thailand, who gave me such valuable information and discussion. Specially, thank you to Mr. Teerachat veerayuttanond, my supervisor during internship with The Fine Arts Department of Thailand, who first introduced me to Phimai Town and took me on the site survey at Phimai Town. Last but not least, I would like to thank University of Hawaii for giving me the opportunity for my study research and design.
    [Show full text]
  • Analysis of the Khmer Walled Defensive System of Vimayapura (Phimai City, Thailand): Symbolism Or Military Effectiveness?
    manusya 23 (2020) 253-285 brill.com/mnya Analysis of the Khmer Walled Defensive System of Vimayapura (Phimai City, Thailand): Symbolism or Military Effectiveness? Víctor Lluís Pérez Garcia1 (บิกตอร์ ยูอิส เปเรซ การ์เซีย) Ph.D. in Archaeology, history teacher of the Generalitat de Catalunya, Institut Tarragona, Tarragona, Spain [email protected] Abstract This article analyses the walled defensive system of the Khmer city centre of Vimaya- pura (modern Phimai, Thailand) to evaluate the theoretical level of military effectivity of both the walls and the moats against potential attackers, considering their technical characteristics and the enemy’s weapons. We also study the layout of the urban en- ceinte, the constructive material, the gateways as well as weakness and strengths of the stronghold and the symbolic, monumental and ornamental functions in the overall role of the walls. Based on comparisons with similar cases, as well as in situ observa- tions of the archaeological remains and a bibliographical research, our study reveals that the stonewalls were not designed primarily to resist military attacks. Instead, the army, the moat, and possibly the embankments and/or palisades would have been the first lines of defence of the city. Keywords fortifications – city walls – military architecture – Thailand – South-East Asia 1 Member of the “Seminary of Ancient Topography” archaeological research group at Universi- tat Rovira i Virgili of Tarragona (Catalonia). www.victorperez.webs.com. © Víctor Lluís Pérez Garcia, 2020 | doi:10.1163/26659077-02302006
    [Show full text]
  • Figs. 7, 46 Pls. 15,16 Fig. 52 Fig. Figs. Fig. 24 Figs. 8, 12, Fig. 33
    INDEX Ak Yorn, Prasat XIX, XXIl,46, 55 Borobudur, Java XXI, 27, 45, 46, 49, Anavatapa, lake 94 50, 51 Fig. 44 Andet, Prasat 44 Boulbet,Jean. 46 Andon, Prasat see Neak Ta Brahma 7 Angkor XIX, XXIII, XXVIII, 4, 5, 14, 20, 23, 24,44,48,50,54,55,62, Cakravartin 111 63, 64, 68, 72, 76, 78, 79, 81, 90, Ceylon 16, 17 96, 97, 98, 109, 110 Chaiya, Thailand 45 Angkor Thom 59, 81, 90, 94, 98, 99, Cham XXV, XXVII, 28, 45, 90, 99 105, 106, 107, 111 Chau Say Tevoda 30, 81, 90, 97 Angkor Wat XXIV, XXV, XXVI, Chola, dynasty 28 XXVII, XXVIII, XXIX, 4, 8, 12, Chou Ta-kuan (Zhou Daguan) 29, 79, 24, 26, 30, 31, 74, 78, 80, 83-89, 87, 101, 112 91, 98, 99, 100, 109, 111, 112 Chrei, Prasat 82, 90 Fig. 25 Figs. 28, 78,79 Pls. 31-33 Coedes, George 6, 18, 19, 22, 83 Argensola, d' XXVIII Aymonier, Etienne XXVIII Dagens, Bruno XXIII, 18, 46, 93 Damrei Krap, Prasat 28, 45, 4 7 Figs. Bakong XXI, 4, 11, 45, 50, 51, 53, 54, 43, 45 Pl. 14 55, 59, 65. Figs. 7, 46 Pls. 15,16 Dhrannindravarman I, King 7 Bakasei Chamkrong 29, 34, 54, 60, 63, Dieng, Java XVII, XX 66, 106. Fig. 52 Do Couto, Diego XXXVIII Baluchistan XVIII. Bantay Chmar XXVI, XXVII, 5, 12, 96, Elephant Terrace 78 Fig. 21 99. Bantay Kdei 28, 96, 98, 100. Bantay Samre 24. Filliozat, Jean 21 Bantay Srei 11, 15, 66-67, 69, 72 Fig.
    [Show full text]
  • What and Where Was Chenla?", Recherches Nouvelles Sur Le Cambodge
    1 "What and Where was Chenla?", Recherches nouvelles sur le Cambodge. Publiées sous la direction de F. Bizot. École française d'Extrême-Orient, Paris, 1994, pp. 197-212.[ The research of which this paper is a part has been supported by a grant from the Social Science Research Council, New York.] All students of early Cambodian history must have been struck by the contradictory treatments of Chenla. In this paper my purpose is to review the evidence and offer a new conclusion about the identity and location of that polity. There has been a traditional consensus that Chenla was centered in Champassak in southern Laos, or even farther north, and it has even been said that "des inscriptions nous enseignent que, dans la seconde moitié du VIe siècle en tout cas, il occupait la vallée de la Se Moun et une partie...du Cambodge septen- trional" (Jacques, 1986: 61). The inscriptions to which reference is made are those of the Dangrek chieftains, Vīravarman, Bhavavarman, and Mahendravarman. But they in fact make no reference to Chenla at all, in this context they are being forced into a conception of Chenla based on other reasoning, and they themselves are not at all evidence for the existence of Chenla in their area.1 As Coedès put it in his synthesis of the Indian-influenced part of Southeast Asia, "the center of [Chenla] can be localized on the middle Mekong in the region of Bassac [because]...The History of the Sui, in information dating from before 598, thus before the total conquest of Funan [by Chenla]...says: 'near the capital [of Chenla] there is a mountain named Ling-kia-po-p'o, on the summit of which there is a temple...dedicated to a spirit named P'o-to-li" (Coedès, 1964:126, 1968: 65-6), which modern scholars have interpreted as the Ligaparvata in southernmost Laos where Wat Phu is located, with a sanctuary to Bhadreśvara.2 Otherwise Chinese information on Chenla just placed it southwest of Lin-i and north or northeast of Funan.
    [Show full text]
  • In His Publication of Two Inscriptions Coedès Said That They Were Not Very
    1 Coedès’ Histories of Cambodia "Colloque George Coedès aujourd‟hui". Bangkok, Centre d‟Anthropologie Sirindhorn, 9-10 September 1999. Published as “Coedès‟ Histories of Cambodia”, in Silpakorn University International Journal (Bangkok,), Volume 1, Number 1, January-June 2000, pp. 61-108. Michael Vickery On the back cover of the new printing of the 1968 English translation of Coedès‟ The Indianized States of Southeast Asia (Coedès 1968b), there are two extremely flattering testimonials by leading American historians of Southeast Asia. O.W. Wolters was convinced that “No course on earlier Southeast Asian history should be taught anywhere for foreseeable time without frequent reference to Coedès‟ book”; and David K. Wyatt chimed in with, “Not surprisingly, the students upon whom this reviewer has tested this volume as a textbook appreciated its authority and admired its rigor and [Coedès] standards”. That English translation had been made from the 1964 „second edition‟ of Coedès‟ Les états hindouisés d'Indochine et d'Indonésie [Coedès 1964a], little changed from the first edition issued in 1948. Moreover, that first edition of Les états hindouisés d'Indochine et d'Indonésie was nothing more than a new edition, in fact mostly a reprinting, of an earlier title, Histoire ancienne des états hindouisés d’extrême-orient (1944). These three volumes should not be called separate books, but three editions of the same work. The greatest change from 1944 to 1948 was the title, something I only discovered when preparing this paper, for Coedès 1944 is very difficult to find and I had never seen it before. 1 [*The purpose of this paper is to record disagreement with the assessments of Wolters and Wyatt.
    [Show full text]
  • Cambogia=Cambodia=Campucea= Kampuchea=Cambodge=Khmer
    CAMBOGIA CAMBOGIA=CAMBODIA=CAMPUCEA= KAMPUCHEA=CAMBODGE=KHMER Roat Kampuchea Regno di Cambogia Phnum Penh=Phnom Penh 400.000 ab. Kmq. 181.035 (178.035)(181.000)(181.040) Compreso Kmq. 3.000 di acque interne Dispute con Tailandia per: - Territorio di Preah Vihear (occupato Cambogia) - Poi Pet Area (occupato Tailandia) - Buri=Prachin Buri Area (occupato Tailandia). Dispute con Vietnam per: - Cocincina Occidentale e altri territori (occupati Vietnam) - alcune isole (occupate Vietnam): - Dak Jerman=Dak Duyt - Dak Dang=Dak Huyt - La Drang Area - Baie=Koh Ta Kiev Island - Milieu=Koh Thmey Island - Eau=Koh Sep Island - Pic=Koh Tonsay Island - Northern Pirates=Koh Po Island Rivendica parte delle Scarborough Shoals (insieme a Cina, Taivan, Vietnam, Corea, Malaisia, Nuova Zelanda). Dispute con Tailandia per acque territoriali. Dispute con Vietnam per acque territoriali. Movimento indipendentista Hmon Chao Fa. Movimento indipendentista Khmer Krom. Ab. 7.650.000---11.700.000 Cambogiani=Cmeri=Khmer (90%) - Cmeri Candali=Khmer Kandal=Cmeri Centrali=Central Khmers (indigeni) - Cmeri Cromi=Khmer Krom (cmeri insediati nella Cambogia SE e nel Vietnam Meridionale) - Cmeri Surini=Khmer Surin (cmeri insediati nella Cambogia NO e nelle province tailandesi di Surin, Buriram, Sisaket - Cmeri Loeu=Cmeri Leu=Khmer Loeu (termine ombrello per designare tutte le tribù collinari della Cambogia)(ca. 100.000 in tutto): - Parlanti il Mon-Cmero=Mon-Khmer (94%) - Cacioco=Kachok - Crungo=Krung - Cui=Kuy - Fnongo=Phnong - Tampuano=Tampuan (nella provincia di Ratanakiri NE)
    [Show full text]
  • Kambujadesa Which Forms the Subject-Matter of This Course of Lectures
    PREFACE In July 1942 I was invited by the university of Madras to deliver a course of lectures under the Sir William Meyer (Endowment) Lectureship, 1942-43. These lectures are published here in the form in which I delivered them, early in March 1943, with the addition of the footnotes and a list of Inscriptions, on which the study of the subject is primarily based. The scope and object of these lectures have been sufficiently indicated at the beginning of Lecture I, and I shall consider my labours amply rewarded if they serve to awaken an interest in, and promote the study of a highly important but little-known subject. The series of works on ancient Indian colonisation in the Far East which I planned nearly twenty years ago have not yet been completed. Three volumes dealing with Champa (Annam) and Suvarniadvipa (Malayasia) are out, the and remaining two volumes dealing with Kambuja (Cambodia) , Burma and Siam still await publication. These two volumes will deal more comprehensively with the subject covered by these lectures. In view of the present situation in the country, it is diffi- cult to say when, if ever, those two volumes will see the light of the day. Till then, the present work may be regarded as completing the series of my studies on the history of ancient Indian colonies in the Far East. As inscriptions have been frequently referred to in the course of these lectures, I have added at the end a list of old Kambuja inscriptions, arranged chronologically as far as possible. The serial number is quoted in the text against each inscription to enable the reader to find out the necessary details by a reference to the list.
    [Show full text]