La Jolla Physics Symposium
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Proceedings of the LA JOLLA PHYSICS SYMPOSIUM University of California, San Diego September 6 – 8, 1985 University of California, San Diego Department of Physics 9500 Gilman Drive La Jolla, California 92093-0319 858-534-3968 December 2004 LA JOLLA PHYSICS REUNION/SYMPOSIUM University of California, San Diego September 6 - 8, 1985 TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................ii Preface by Thomas N. Delmer.................................................................................................iv Program of the La Jolla Physics Symposium .......................................................................viii Pictures of the Reunion/Symposium.........................................................................................x Historical pictures of Faculty, Students and Campus ......................................................... xxiv Financial support....................................................................................................................xlviii Acknowledgments................................................................................................................... xlix La Jolla Physics Symposium Session I , Saturday, September 7, 1985................. 1 General Introduction to Session I by George W. Webb........................................... 3 Introduction of Keith A. Brueckner by George W. Webb ............................................... 4 "Early Development of the UCLJ Physics Department" by Keith A. Brueckner................................................................ 5 Introduction of RAdm. Kleber S.(Skid)Masterson, Jr. by Keith A. Brueckner .............10 "National Security in the Year 2005" by RAdm. Kleber S. Masterson, Jr. ...............11 Introduction of Allan S. (Bud) Jacobson by Laurence E. Peterson...............................19 "Astrophysical Gamma Ray Spectroscopy" by Allan S. (Bud) Jacobson .............20 Introduction of William A. Prothero, Jr. by John M. Goodkind......................................31 "Some Interesting Problems in Geophysics/A Physicist's View" ............................ by William A. Prothero, Jr........................................................32 Introduction of Maris A. Abolins by Oreste Piccioni........................................................40 "From the Imperscrutable to the Infinite" by Maris A. Abolins .................................42 Introduction of Herbert J. Bernstein by Professor Norman M. Kroll..............................54 "Pursuit of Simplicity" by Herbert J. Bernstein ............................................................55 La Jolla Physics Symposium Session II , Sunday, September 8, 1985.................63 ii General Introduction to Session II by Richard L. Morse ...........................................65 Introduction of Thomas M. O'Neil by Norman Rostoker ................................................66 "Pure Electron Plasmas" by Thomas M. O'Neil ...........................................................68 Introduction of Richard More by Richard L. Morse..........................................................77 "Statistical Mechanics of Hot Dense Matter" by Richard More ..............................78 Introduction of M. Brian Maple by Walter Kohn..............................................................95 "25 Years of Superconductivity at UCSD" by M. Brian Maple ...............................98 Introduction of Gregory Benford by James Benford....................................................115 "Why Does a Scientist Write Science Fiction" by Gregory Benford ....................118 "Panel Discussion: Future of the University, The Campus and the Department" by William R. Frazer, Harold K. Ticho, Norman M. Kroll Moderator: Herbert F. York............................................................................................124 List of Participants ..................................................................................................141 "Physics on the Beach - - Scape"..................................................................................142 iii PREFACE by Thomas N. Delmer This is a collection of papers presented and photos taken at the La Jolla Physics Symposium held on September 6 - 8, 1985 in conjunction with a Reunion of the people associated with the Physics Department of the University of California at San Diego during the academic years of 1960 to 1965. Historical pictures of the campus and the first five years of graduate students also appear. Those were the founding and formative years of the Department. Several students from that time were asked to give talks on their work since leaving the UCSD. When possible, their thesis advisors introduced their talks, otherwise, someone who was familiar enough with them to make a few incisive remarks was asked to give an introduction. The Symposium opened with a talk that described the beginning of the Department and closed with a panel discussion of the future of the University of California, the San Diego campus, as well as the Physics Department. The response was positive: about thirty percent of all those identified as being associated with the Department in those early days came to the Symposium. The talks, which were informal because of the broad range of subject matter and interests of the audience, showed an emotion that indicated that formation of the Department was a personal and moving experience for all involved. This was not a complete surprise; the choice of the first five years as the central theme, the limitation to those years, was made because after the mid '60's, the University had grown and the calcification mentioned by Greg Benford had begun to set in. But, the degree to which the feeling was universal and deep could not have been known beforehand. This remark is not just sentimentality. As Keith Brueckner describes, the University was started from the top down, from research faculty to graduate students and in 1965, to undergraduate students. The beginning of the Department consisted of a small group located at Scripps Institution of Oceanography in La Jolla (hence the UCLJ of the logo). The small size and the accompanying closeness made the experience unique. Changes took place rapidly. As Karl Eckart once said, "It was not that things were so exciting then, but that things have been pretty dull ever since." The skit, Physics on the Beach -- Scape written by Mike Green, Arnie Sherwood, and others, included here after the papers, qualifies the excitement. The importance of the early days of the Department as a personal experience and a method of starting a University became evident at the Symposium. Remember that physicists have a strong tendency to be arrogant. Read these pages and see how suppressed the arrogance was in the people recalling the events; you will see that even the most self important were in awe of what they experienced. It was not originally intended to produce a Proceedings since the talks were to be informative rather than of iv archival value. But as a whole, they painted a picture of the nascence of an important entity and documented the technical strength of the Department. It is the importance of the composite, the whole of the talks and photographic record, that make these Proceedings of archival value. Nevertheless, this document is of most interest to those readers who were part of the first five years. Other readers will credit that the beginning was unique, but may question the importance and quality of the Department and its product, i.e., the graduates during the years 1960 - 1965. The best way to judge the quality of the graduates is to read this document and form your own opinion; the introductions and talks have many clues to help make a judgment. The reader who is not interested in the technical content can read the opening talk by Keith Brueckner which provides a candid view of the beginning of the Physics Department. For those who want a succinct answer, they should read Norman Kroll's thoughts included in the Panel Discussion. Those who are interested in how the products of those early days of the UCSD Physics Department view various social and physics problems can find the answers in the papers included here. If you want to know how the hard nosed handled international relations and the Soviet threat, read Skid Masterson. If you want to get his advice in a nutshell, just read the summary of his paper; you will find that his desideratum is exactly what is happening in international relations four years later (1989). If you want to see sheer power in the application of physics and the scientific method, read Bud Jacobson; see the attention to detail, to precision. Read between the lines to see the tremendous discipline required to carry out the project from beginning to end. And what about the sea? We started at SIO on the ocean and men are drawn to the sea. Read Prothero. For the reader who thinks that is all saccharin nostalgia, read his remarks about how tough it was, read what Dick Morse says to back him up. It was tough. The linear prediction of the percentage passing the Departmental Exam went through zero in 1964. The behavior of the students preparing for that exam was bizarre, at best. If you think science and scientists are all specialized, arcane; read Herb (Herby Baby) Bernstein's paper on efforts to simplify, to unify. That became part of a book. Or Tom O'Neil's paper on a pure electron plasma. The plasma