Vol. VII — No. 4 — Nov. 1973 Nihil philosophici a nobis alienum putamus

Richard Rorty / Criteria and Necessity — Nicholas Rescher and Zane Parks / Possible Individuals, Trans-World Identity, and Quantified Modal Logic — Baruch Brody / Why Settle for Anything Less Than Good Old-Fashioned Aristotelian Essentialism — Kenneth Friedman / Son of Grue: Simplicity vs. Entrenchment — Kathryn Parsons /Ambiguity and the Truth Definition — Adam Morton / The Possible In the Actual — Lou Goble / Opacity and the Ought-to-Be — Recent Publications in Philsophy — Index to Vol. VII

A quarterly, NOUS is published in March, September, and November each year. For individuals the subscription rates are: one year, )8.00; two years, $15.00; three years, $22.00. For bona fide students: $6.00 per year. For institutions: $12.00 per year. Add 45 cents per year for foreign subscriptions.

Order from The Secretary, NOUS, Department of Philosophy, Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana 47401

An International Quarterly Journal The Monist of General Philosophical Inquiry Founded 1888 by Edward C. Hegeler Editor, Eugene FREEMAN Editorial Board: William P. Alston, Monroe C. Beardsley, Lewis White Beck, William A. Earle, Dagfinn Follesdal, William Frankena, Maurice Mandelbaum, R. Barcan Marcus, Richard Martin, Mary Mothersill, Joseph Owens, Richard Rorty, J. B. Schneewind, Wilfrid Sellars, John E. Smith, Richard Wasserstrom. Managing Editor, Ann FREEMAN EACH ISSUE IS LIMITED TO ARTICLES ON A SINGLE GENERAL TOPIC. Submitted papers should be received by the editor nine months prior to the scheduled publication date of the issue. GENERAL TOPICS for recent and forthcoming issues: SCHEDULED PUBLICATION DATES: Vol. 57, No. 2 Apr., 1973 Pragmatism Reconsidered Vol. 57, No. 3 July, 1973 Philosophic Analysis and Deep Structure Vol. 57, No. 4 Oct., 1973 Philosophy of War Vol. 58, No. 1 Jan., 1974 The Philosophy of Thomas Aquinas Vol. 58, No. 2 Apr., 1974 Languages of Art Vol. 58, No. 3 July, 1974 Sidgwick and Moral Philosophy Vol. 58, No. 4 Oct., 1974 The Philosophy of Moral Education Vol. 59, No. 1 Jan., 1975 The Philosophy of Husserl Vol. 59, No. 2 Apr., 1975 Philosophical Problems of Death Vol. 59, No. 3 July, 1975 Language, Thought, and Reality Vol. 59, No. 4 Oct., 1975 The Philosophy of Mysticism Editorial Office: Department of Philosophy, California State University San Jose, California 95192 Business Office: Box 599, La Salle, Illinois 61301 SUBSCRIPTION RATES: United States: Annual (4 issues): Institutions, $8.00; Indi­ viduals, $6.00. Single copies: $2.25. Foreign postage: Add 15 cents to single copy rate or 60 cents to subscription rate. THE SOUTHERN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY Tenth Anniversary Issue, Volume XI, 1 & 2 ARTICLES: Skinner on Freedom and Dignity E. M. Adams Unmasking the Person Edward G. Ballard An Introduction to Heidegger's What Is a Thing? W. B. Barton, Jr. Objects and Events Charles P. Bigger Ethics and Ecology William T. Blackstone Time and The Religious Consciousness Carroll R. Bowman Responsibility and Agency John J. Compton Philosophical Speculation and BiomedicalTnnovation Ronald H. Epp Philosophy and Poetry Lewis M. Hammond Analysis and Cultural Lag in Philosophy Charles Hartshorne Armstrong's Concept of a Mental State David R. Hiley Socrates on Civil Disobedience and Rebellion Gene G. James On the Study, the Cafe, and the Cloister as Sites for Philosophizing Iredell Jenkins The Metaphysical Status of Regulative Maxims in Leibniz and Kant....Leroy E. Loemker Note on Instances of Invalid Elementary Argument Forms Nancy D. Simco Scholarly Publishing, 1973 James D. Simmons Notes Toward a Theory of Time Dwight Van de Vate, Jr. THE SOUTHERN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY is published quarterly by The Department of Philosophy, Memphis State University, Memphis, Tennessee 38152. Editors: Carroll R. Bowman and W. B. Barton, Jr. Annual subscription rate to individuals, $8.00; for institutions, $12.00; for students, $4.00; prices for single copies available on request.

ARCHIVES DE PHILOSOPHIE

REVUE TRIMESTRIELLE PUBLIEE AVEC LE CONCOURS DU CENTRE NATIONAL DE LA RECHERCHE SCIENTIFIQUE

TOME 36 — CAHIER 4 — OCTOBRE-DECEMBRE 1973

Pierre FRUCHON Herme'neutique, Language et Ontologie. Un discernement du platonisme chez H.-G. Gadamer. Pierre-Jean LABARRIERE L'Homme et l'Absolu {Fin) Gabrielle DUFOUR-KOWALSKA Michel Henry lecteur de Maitre Eckhart. Giovanni SALA La metaphysique comme structure heuri- stique selon Bernard Lonergan. {Fin). Ludger OEING-HANHOFF Note sur l'argument ontologique chez Descartes et Bonaventure.

Comptes rendus REDACTION : LES FONTAINES — F60500 CHANTILLY ABONNEMENTS : BEAUCHESNE, 117, RUE DE RENNES, 75006 PARIS Prix de l'abonnement annuel (4 cahiers): France: 50F. — Etranger: 60F. — Cahier isole: 18 et 20F. C.C.P. Beauchesne, PARIS 39-29 THE BRITISH JOURNAL OF AESTHETICS

A Journal for the understanding of the principles of criticism and appreciation.

Editor: Harold Osborne

Volume 13, No. 4 — Autumn 1973

CONTENTS Architectural Aesthetics Roger Scruton The Trend in Contemporary Aesthetics R. W. Beardsmore Black's Metaphors Martin Warner The Dehumanization of Art Colin Lyas A Colour Vision Defective Artist R. W. Pickford A Phenomenology of Cinematic Time and Space R. P. Kolker and J. Douglas Cusley Oscar Wilde's Intentions: An Early Modernist Manifesto R. J. Green Book reviews and Books Received.

Published quarterly for the British Society of Aesthetics by Thomas and Hudson, Ltd., 30 Bloomsbury Street, W.C.1. Price £3 per annum (single issues 80p) from the publishers or through any bookseller. The Journal is supplied free to members of the Society: subscription £2.10 per annum. Forms of Application from the Hon. Secretary, c/o Department of Philosophy, Birkbeck College, Malet Street, London, W.C.1.

Vol. LXXXII, No. 328 October 1973

Edited by DAVID HAMLYN

I. Seeing-As: T. E. WILKERSON — II. Rival Explanations: L. WRIGHT — III. Resemblances and Universals: J. NAMMOUR — IV. Theory in Miniature: M. HOLLIS — V. Identity and References: T. CHAPMAN — VI. Counterfactuals, Dispositions, and Capacities: R. S. W00LH0USE — VII. The Perils of Physi- calism: J. MARGOLIS — VIII. Discussions: The Form of Reductio ad Absurdum: P. FOULKES — Scherer on Reductio ad Absurdum: C. H. LAMBROS — Moral Conflict and Prescriptivism: H. STEINER — In Defence of Turing: G. SAMPSON — On the Point of the Imitation Game: P. H. MILLAR — The Logic of Aquinas' Tenia Via: T. P. M. SOLON — Russell on Memory: R. K. PERKINS — Crombie on Republic 597c: K. W. MILLS — Explanation by Reasons and by Causes Again: L. F. MUCCIOLO — Avowed Reasons and the Covering Law Model: P. W. BENNETT — Austin on Ryle on Seeing and 'Seeing': H. V. STAINSBY — Frege on Definition: V. H. DUDHAM — In Defence of Principia Mathematica: R. BLACK — Reply to V. H. Dudman and R. Black: E. Z. & E. A. NEMESSAZEGHY — IX. New Books — X. Notes.

Published for the MIND ASSOCIATION by BASIL BLACKWELL

Single Issues: 40p Annual Subscription: £1.25 net Philosophy of the Social Sciences A new quarterly journal Editors J. O. Wisdom, John O'Neill, Harold Kaplan, I. C. Jarvie, J. N. Hattiangadi

VOLUME 3, NUMBER 1, MARCH 1973 ERNEST GELLNER Scale and Nation A.D.SMITH 'Ideas' and 'Structure' in the Formation of Independent Ideals JOHN KING-FARLOW Pronouns, Primacy and Falsification in Linguistics MICHAEL RUSE The Nature of Scientific Models: Formal versus Material Analogy JOHN W. YOLTON Action Theory as the Foundation for the Science of Man

VOLUME 3, NUMBER 2, JUNE 1973 JOHNSKORUPSKI Science and Traditional Religious Thought I and II IAN 1. MITROFF and FRANCISCO SAGASTI Episiemology as General Systems Theory: An Approach to the Design of Complex Decision-Making Experiments T.A. MCCARTHY A Theory of Communicative Competence JURGEN HABERMAS A Postscript to Knowledge and Human Interest

Subscriptions to: Aberdeen University Press, Farmers Hall, Aberdeen, Scotland AB9 2XT Subscriptions payable in advance—4 issues $8 or £3. Manuscripts to: Editorial Secretary, Department of Philosophy, York University, 4700 Keele Street, Downsview M3J 1P3, Ontario, Canada.

8WUU1KY" An Interdisciplinary Journal of INQUIRY Philosophy and the Social Sciences INQUIRY Edited by Arne Naess and Alastair Hannay INQUIRY Number 3 Autumn 1973 Volume 16 The Experience of Values Frithjof Bergmann Systems of Modal Logic for INQUIRY Impossible Worlds Charles G. Morgan Thinking about Non-Being Charles Crittenden INQUIRY DISCUSSION: Ideal Chronicles and Future INQUIRY Knowledge Per Stromholm REVIEW DISCUSSIONS: INQUIRY History. Man, and Reason (Maurice Mandelbaum, History, Man, INQUIRY and Reason. A Study in Nineteenth-Century Thought) Leon Pompa Humanism and Ideology (James R. Flynn, INQUIRY Humanism and Ideology: an Aristotelian View) H. J. N. Horsburgh INQUIRY Onward to Yesterday (Rene Dubos, INQUIRY The God Within) Joseph W. Meeker Published Quarterly by Universitetsforlaget INQUIRY P.O. Box 307. Blindern, Oslo 3, Norway Annual Subscription: Institutions: N.kr. 75.00, INQUIRY £4.90, $12.50. INQUIRY Individuals: N.kr. 60.00, £3.90, $10.00. FOUNDATIONS OF LANGUAGE

International Journal of Language and Philosophy

Board of Editors: Morris Halle, M.I.T.; Peter Hartmann, Konstanz; K. kunjunni Raja, Madras; Benson Mates, Univ. of California; J. F. Staal, Univ. of California; Pieter A. Verburg, Groningen; John W. M. Verhaar, Djakarta. Editorial Assistants: W. G. Klooster, H. J. Verkuyl, W. Abraham, and A. Tomberg

Contents of Volume 10, No. 1 May 1973 Ann Banfield / Narrative Style and the Grammar of Direct and Indirect Speech. C. L Hamblin / Questions in Montague English. Maria-Luisa Rivero / Ante­ cedents of Contemporary Logical and Linguistic Analysis in Scholastic Logic. Tim Shopen / Ellipsi as Grammatical Indeterminacy. Edward R. Hope / Non- Syntactic Constraints on Lisu Noun Phrase Order. Hugh W. Buckingham / The Comitative and Case Grammar. J. Miller / A Note on So-Called Discovery Pro­ cedures. Jonathan Bennett / The Meaning-Nominalist Strategy.

Subscription price per volume of four issues Dfl. 115, including postage. About six or seven issues are published yearly. Personal subscription price on request.

D. REIDEL PUBLISHING COMPANY DORDRECHT—HOLLAND / BOSTON—U.S.A.

ZEITSCHRIFT FUR ALLGEMEINE WISSENSCHAFTSTHEORIE Journal of General Philosophy of Science Edited by Alwin Diemer . Lutz Geldsetzer . Gert Konig Per year 2 issues of 208 pp. each Annual subscription DM 64,—

From the contents of vol. 111/2 Aufastze WILLIAM H. AUSTIN: Paradigms, Rationality, and Partial Communication — DIETRICH BOHLER: Paradigmawechsel in analytischer Wissenschafts theorie? Wissen- schaftsgeschichtliche und wissenschaftstheoretische Aufgaben der Philosophie — JURGEN KLUVER and WILFRIED MULLER, Wissenschaftstheorie und Wissen- schaftsgeschichte: Die Entdeckung^der Benzolformel — WILLI MEYER, Wissen­ schaftstheorie und Erfahrung: Zur Uberwindung des methodologischen Dogmatismus LOTHAR PROX: Strukturalistische Kunstforschung — PAUL T. SAGAL: Incommen­ surability Then and Now Diskussion WERNER BECKER: Dialektik als Ideologie: Hegel und Marx. Eine kritische Bedeutung uber Zustandekommen, Sinn und Funktion der dialektischen Methode — HERBERT KEUTH, Eine Revolte in the Psychologic Bemerkungen zu Holzkamps Vorschlag einer "kritisch-emanzipatorischen Psychologie" — VICTOR KRAFT: 1st die Zukunft eine Extrapolation? Bibliographic Berichte Rezensionen Franz Steiner Verlag GMBH Wiesbaden, Germany