8 G 0 A ASME UI UCA IG $4.00 e co y $2.00. ii E AME ICA SOCIE Y O MEC A ICA E GI EE S 4 E 4 S ., ew Yo k, .Y. 00 The Society shall not be responsible for statements or opinions advanced in papers or in discussion at meetings of the Society or of its Divisions or Sections, r printed in its publications. Discussion is printed only d the paper is published in an ASME Journal r Proceedrngs.Released for general publication upon presentation. Felt credit h t t b v r, t ASME. th hn . t v n, nd th authorfs).
-=MiVM7Sr "`".' Copyright © 1981 by ASME Downloaded from http://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/GT/proceedings-pdf/GT1981/79627/V002T06A015/2393594/v002t06a015-81-gt-50.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021 Com us io o Me a o a S. Ka i a t En n v n ique ie u a e i a Gas u i e
. Ki a ima Com us o hn l In t t t Combustion tests with a gas turbine combustor were carried out to clarify the technical problems caused when liquefied butane was supplied and burned in the . Kimu a liquid phase in addition to evaluating methanol and liquefied butane as an alter- hn l In t t t native fuel. For methanol, a conventional dual-orifice type fuel injector, and for liquefied butane, the same dual-orifice type injector and two types of multi-hole K v Ind tr , td., injectors were tested. The results of combustion tests with both fuels were compared A t , p n with those of conventional gas turbine fuels—kerosene and natural gas with respect to combustion performances and exhaust emissions. It was found that both fuels had some advantages over conventional fuels.
I O UC IO A A A US A OCE U E
h r nt n r r h r d h nt r t l t t n th t l z t n f lt rn t v f l f r h t t f l t h n n r . A r t rb n n n . M n f l h h dr n, l ppl d fr pr r, t r d b n r f h l , l f d p tr l , l nd n t r, h t d b n nd r tl f r d pr h t r nd t . r n d r d lt rn t v f l t nv n r l t d t n t nt pr r l v l b b tt rfl t n l t rb n f l r n nd n t r l . v lv n n xh t d t. In th p p r th n l nd l f d b t n r h f l f l t l h n n r . h n fr n th f l , nd b t n t t K r n p p d b pl n r p p nd t r d b r rr d t t v l t b th f l . t rb n fl t r. t r l ppl d fr bl pr nt ph l nd th r d n r l l nd r , r l t d b v lv nd pr p rt f b th f l n p r n th th f t r d b n r f t r. M th n l nd l f d nv nt n l f l . S n th n l h dv n b t n r pr r z d b n tr n fr r l t , n xp r nt b t t t l z t n f r l nd r nd t r d b t rb n fl t r. t rb n n n h v b n rr d t nd v r l h xh t t p r t r r r d b 24 p p r h v b n pr nt d ( , (2 . On th th r C A th r pl t th b t r x t. h f ll h nd, th t l z t n f l f d b t n h b n n p nt d f r n l : r r b f pl t n r lt n fr t l f d t t , . . pl t d ppl t Exh t n t t nt In tr nt r r d. h ppl t pr v l d n l d d p p h t n pp r t f r th pr v nt t n f r O, Ox n d. A Ch l f t n nd v p r z r h n l f d b t n l n n n tr nt ppl d t t rb n n n n ph . v d th t hn l d ff lt , l CO Y n t d. EI 6 f d b t n ppl d t th b t r n l d I ph n th xp r nt. h r lt f b t n t t th b th f l C n d. 402 I r p r d th th f r n nd n t r l . C b t r nd l Inj t r A nv nt n l n t p b t r f th nd tr l t rb n n n , KAWASAKI M A h n p rt l r r h n n bl 2, d t t t f r t p f f l th t n d f t n . It h n n r 2. v t p f f l nj t r h n n r nd bl r d n th xp r nt. r r n , nv nt n l d l r f t p f l nj t r ( O. d. r th n l, th t p f l C ntr b t d b th G rb n v n f E AME ICA SOCIE Y O MEC A ICA E GI EE S f r pr nt t n t th G rb n C nf r n & nj t r ( O.2 d, b t t n p r d t Sh , M r h 2, 8 , t n, x . M n r pt r v d t nl r d t p r t d t f l fl . h ASME d rt r b r , 80. nj t r ( O.2 d f r th n l nd t t p C p ll b v l bl nt l b r , 8 . f lt h l t p nj t r ( 0. ,4 r d f r bl . l pr p rt
f d t r l G M th n l t n K r n (M th n
Ch l r l C O C C C 4 0 2 24 4 M l l r W ht 2.0 8. 68 6.0
Sp f Gr v t t °C 0. 6 0. 8 0.800 Downloaded from http://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/GT/proceedings-pdf/GT1981/79627/V002T06A015/2393594/v002t06a015-81-gt-50.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021 r t f C b t n (M 20. 4 . , 4 .2 0.0
l n p r t r t t ( °C 6 0.6 0 00 6 .
t f p r z t n (M . 0 0. 86 0. 06
St h tr A b M 6.48 .46 4. 8 .20
l b l t t (% v l, f l . 6.0 .8 8.4 0. .0 .0 .0
Sp nt n I n t n p r t r ( °C 4 44 2 4 6 2
° t t 20 C ( 2 S 0. 2 0. .6
h v l r pr nt v r .
ESS. EGU A O
U GE n l 0 2 CY I E S C 4 CY I E S
C O r C4 0 S O AGE ESS. EGU A O
O I ICE COO I G WA E U I E OW ME E
• E
U E Y A E MO O E • UE I
O I ICE AI GAS SAM E
COM ESSO AI EA E E MOCOU ES (4 x 6
ES SEC IO
r . S h t f th t t f l t
2 bl 2. M n p rt l r f KAWASAKI M A bl . t f f l nj t r
p S pl p n l , S n l h ft . Inj t r t p l r
C pr r 2 t , C ntr f l l r f K r n
C b t r S n l , C n t p 2 , M th n l, Enl r d M n f d t n p rb n t , Ax l ° M lt h l f d t n 40.4 x 6 t d O tp t , KW t C nd l v l Downloaded from http://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/GT/proceedings-pdf/GT1981/79627/V002T06A015/2393594/v002t06a015-81-gt-50.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021 4 " II , 40.6 x 8 t d Sp d 22,000 rp ( n h ft
" t r l G 4 .6 x 6 , 00 r ,800 rp ( tp t h ft
C pr n t 8
A r l t .
U G n r t r dr v
M n f t r r KAWASAKI EA Y I US IES, ., AKAS I, A A
r . t d f l nj t r
b t n n d r bl d ff r nt fr th f r n nd th n l. h pr n l h n d fr ° ° t 66 th n r f th pr pr r . In dd t n, th xt n n f th pr xtr l n rr , p rt l rl f r h h r pr pr r n b n n r 4. h r f r , l n r fl l n th t b nt p t d f r th b t n th l f d b t n b nv nt n l d l r f t p nj t r.
l Ch r t r t . h fl h r t r t f r 2. KAWASAKI M A t rb n b t r O.2 d l r f t p nj t r r h n n r . h fl r t f r n nd th n l r pr p r t n l t th d ff r nt l pr pr r b th p r l f d b t n . An th r lt h l nj t r ( O. f 0. f r b th n nd pr r n zzl . v r, d f r n t r l . th fl r t f l f d b t n pr p rt n l t th p r f 0. f r th n n zzl nd 0. 4 f r th t C nd t n pr r n zzl , nd r p dl d r d f r l r pr Ex pt f r n t n p rf r n t t , ll t t pr r . r nd t d nd r th f ll n nd t n : ( r 6 h th fl h r t r t f lt th b t r nl t r t p r t r 600 K nd th h l t p nj t r . r r n , th fl r t b t r r f r n v l t 20 S. h nd l pr p rt n l t th d ff r nt l pr pr r t n r l t th n n p r t n nd t n b th p r f 0. . Wh r , t pr p rt n l t nd (2 th b t r nl t pr r 2 t h h th p r f 0.88 f r l f d b t n . d f n d b th p t f th f l t . h r n f h r lt nd t th t th fl f l f d r f l r t h n fr th p r t n r n f b t n b t ph fl n th p p f r l r th n n . pr pr r .
ESU S A ISCUSSIO I n t n rf r n r pr nt th n t n p rf r n t t Inj t r rf r n r lt . l b l t l t nd th t h tr Spr tt rn. h pr p tt rn f th nv n r t n th pr r b t n z n r l h n n t n l d l r f t p nj t r f r r n , th f r . r r n nd n t r l , th n t n th n l nd l f d b t n r h n n r 4. rr d h n th r f l r t n th pr r b In th , th pr r n zzl d t t n z n r h d th t h tr r t . Wh r , l r f th d ff r n f p r p tt rn th f l . th n t n p rf r n f th n l nd l f d h pr p tt rn f r n nd th n l r b t n r b tt r th n th f th b v f l f r l t th , nd pr n l f b th f l h n d th n l, t rr d n r th l n fl b l t ° ° fr 8 t 82 th n r f th pr pr r . l t f r l f d b t n , t rr d b t n th On th th r h nd, th pr p tt rn f l f d l n fl b l t l t nd th t h tr r t ,
•
A n UE 2. . 0 2. 4 KE OSE E
ME A O Downloaded from http://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/GT/proceedings-pdf/GT1981/79627/V002T06A015/2393594/v002t06a015-81-gt-50.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021
I QUE IE
U A E
A : d ff r nt l pr pr r ( f 2
r 4. Eff t f f l n th pr h r t r t f th d l r f t p f l nj t r. C nv r n f t r: ( f 2 (0.0 8066 (M
000 000
00 00
ce
0 00 =
O 00 2 0
0 E w 0 2
0
0 0. 0. 0 0
I E E IA S AY ESSU E (kg cm 2 0 r . h fl h r t r t f th O.2 d l 0 0 r f t p f l nj t r. I E E IA S AY ESSU E (kg cm 2 C nv r n f t r: ( f 2 (0.0 8066 (M
b t n d r bl tt r d b th fl b r 6. h fl h r t r t f lt h l t p t ph fl t th nj t r r f . f l nj t r . C nv r n f t r: ( f 2 (0.0 8066 (M l Ob rv t n f th l l r f th h r t r t f th fl f r v r f l , v l b rv t n f th fl r Und r t ph r nd t n , th fl f r rr d t pr d n th b t n p rf r n t t. n l t ll , nd th f n t r l nd h l r f th fl h n d th th f l t p th n l r bl . r l f d b t n , t f ll , l ht bl , b t th ll fl fr nt.
4 00 00 rn IC IMI
Ir I IC IMI 0 S OIC IOME IC A IO 0 0 2 0 EGIO O EGIO O
2 Downloaded from http://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/GT/proceedings-pdf/GT1981/79627/V002T06A015/2393594/v002t06a015-81-gt-50.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021 I G I IO I G I IO
0 EGIO S OIC IOME IC O IG I IO A IO
EA IMI EGIO O EA IMI O IG I IO 0 0 0 0. .0 0 0. .0 AI MASS OW A E (kg s AI MASS OW A E (kg s
( KE OSE E (b A U A GAS
00 00
SYM O I EC O
0 . 2 ( IMA Y
. rn IC IMI w I . 4 w IC IMI I S OIC IOME IC A IO 0 EGIO O S O IC IOME IC 0 w 0 _ 0 IG I IO A IO I EGIO O 0 I G I IO 0 I 2 EA IMI 0 EGIO O EGIO O O IG I IO O IG I IO EA IMI 0 0 0 0. .0 0 0. 0 AI MASS OW A E (kg s AI MASS OW A E (kg s
( ME A O (d I QUE IE U A E
r . C p r n f n t n p rf r n
On th th r h nd, nd r th pr h t d nd pr d t l l t d fr n r nt r h n n r z d nd t n, th fl f r n n r 8. In th p p r, th fl r t f th n l, xtr l br ht r d nt ll . Al t th l f d b t n nd n t r l nv rt d nt th t r lt bt n d f r l f d b t n , b t t fl f r n th t l r h t f b t n t n d r bl tr n p r nt. r n t r l , th d r tl p r th r lt f th f r t p f f l . fl bl th ll fr nt. r th n l, th h b t n ff n th r n nd fl bl p n . th n l r r t r th n % f r l r r f l r th r lt , t xp t d th t th r d r t . Wh l f r h h r r f l r t , th ff t n fr th fl xtr l l f r th n l nd n f ll ff b f d t r r t n pr n t r l . nd t n . h t nd n n f nt f r th n l b f t l r b t n t p r t r nd th C b t n rf r n n r d nt f b t bl n h d b th f l C b t n Eff n . h b t n ff n l n r n th b t r ll.
h b t n ff n th n t r l r h r x th x xh t t p r t r r t r th n % f r ll r f l r t . r l r d t th b t r x t n th ht d f d b t n th th d l r f t p nj t r, v r t p r t r f th xh t n th r l t th r lt bt n d. Ev n f r lt t p r t r t th b t r nl t. h l t p nj t r , th ff n r v r %. A n b n n r , 8t th th n l nd h r lt xh b t th t th t z t n f n t r l f r l r r f l r t n d r bl l f d b t n xtr l . l r th n th t th r n . Wh l f r l f d b t n , l r d ff r n r f nd n th thr 00 t p f nj t r ft th th O. nj t r l t th th t th n t r l . ft th th O.4 nj t r l r r th n th t th r n , p ll f r h h r r f l r t . Wh l drt th
th O.2 d l r f t p nj t r xtr l h h Downloaded from http://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/GT/proceedings-pdf/GT1981/79627/V002T06A015/2393594/v002t06a015-81-gt-50.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021 p r d th th f th b v t t p f nj t r b th pr n l nd xt nt n r n f ntl n rr r pr v l d r b d.
C b t r W ll p r t r . h b t r ll UE I EC O SYM O t p r t r , r d b t p r t r nd t n KE OSE E o. 0 p nt, r h n n ph t r ph n r 0. A No. 5 C 4 xp t d, th th n l nd n t r l , th b t r 0 C O o. 2 ll t p r t r r xtr l l . M t f th ° C 4 . No. 2 b t r° ll v r d th r n f 4 0 C C4 o. 4 0 C. r l f d b t n , th b t r ll • C o. 4 t p r t r h n d l htl th f l nj t r th th O.4 nj t r, th r lt l t th th t th th n l nd n t r l : th th O.2 0 d l r f t p nj t r nd th O. nj t r, th 0 00 0 b t r ll t p r t r r l htl h h r th n th t th th O.4 nj t r. W th r n , th AI — UE A IO t p r t r r xtr l h h, nd t f th ° b t r° ll v r d° th r n° C f 4 0 C r 8. C b t n ff n C nd r n f C 800 C. ( All r f l r t n th p p r r nv rt d t r n r f l r t . E n lt Unb rn d dr rb n . h n f h dr r b n r pr nt d n r . h h dr rb n n th n t r l r n rl z r f r ll Ex t p r t r tt rn t r . h x t t p r t r p tt rn f t r r h n n r . r f l r t . r l f d b t n , th h dr rb n h x t t p r t r p tt rn f t r 8t n th f r n h n d h t th th t p f nj t r th lt h l t p nj t r , th r lt r l t d f n d b th f ll n t n th f r ll r f l r t nd 80% l th n th t th r n f r h h r r f l r t th th x n O.2 d l r f t p nj t r, th h dr rb n t — n r l th n h lf th t bt n d th lt n n h l t p nj t r . h "h dr rb n" n r lt n fr b t n th th n l r xtr l h h r th n 0.4 th r n . h r n f r th th ht t r lt SYM O UE I EC O fr th n h n n th b t r ll b f l l n O KE OSE E r. S n th r r d th n l fl r t r p C , th n t th t f r n , th nt f b t bl ❑ C ,O 2 r h n th b t r ll n r d. O C, ,„ 2 4 C, ,„ . C rb n M n x d . C b t n th l f d b t n • C, ,„ 4 pr d d l rb n n x d th n th r n f r ll r f l r t h n n r 2 th lt h l nj t r , th r lt r ppr x t l h lf th t th 0.2 r n th th O.2 d l r f t p nj t r, th r lt r 6 0% l th n th t th r n . t ll r lt r l htl r th n th t th n t r l . C b t n th th n l pr d d xtr l h h r rb n n x d th n th r n r lt n fr th n h n b f l l n r nd th l r b t n t p r t r pr v l nt n d.
0 Ox d f tr n. C b t n f l f d b t n 0 00 0 th th O.2 nd O. nj t r pr d d l htl AI — UE A IO l r n tr n x d n th n th t f r n t l r f l r t , b t 0% h h r f r h h r r f l r t b th b t n ff n f r . Ex t t p r t r p tt rn f t r r n r p dl d r d. h r lt r h n n
6 •
( KE OSE E (d IQUE IE U A E ( O.2 I . Downloaded from http://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/GT/proceedings-pdf/GT1981/79627/V002T06A015/2393594/v002t06a015-81-gt-50.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021
(b A U A GAS ( IQUE IE U A E ( O. I .
( ME A O (f IQUE IE U A E ( O.4 I .
EM E A U E CO E O COM US O WA
A < 4 0°C ° 4 0 4 0 C ° C 4 0 C ° 800 C E > 800°C
r 0. C b t r ll t p r t r
0 00 SYM O UE I EC O SYM O UE I EC O I A C O KE OSE E . O KE OSE E . z 4 C , . z . ❑ CI ,0 . 2 O CI 0 . 2 z w 0 . 2 . 2 O C4 ,„ . . • C 4 , 0 No. 4 I I E CC • C., . . 4 W w 0° W CC 2 W 0 O > ` cc Z U 0 2 cc 0 0 CC
0 0 00 0 00 0 AI — UE A IO AI — UE A IO r . dr rb n n r 2. C rb n n x d n
r . CO C USIO S C b t n f l f d b t n th th O.4 nj t r pr d d ppr x t l % l r n tr n h r lt f b t n t t n th n l nd x d n th n th th b v t nj t r , l f d b t n nd t th t b th f l h v b t th n r 4% h h r th n th fr dv nt v r nv nt n l f l r n d n t r l . n t n p rf r n , r d t n f p ll t nt n h n f n tr n x d r lt n fr nd l n th n d b t r l f ll b xp t d. b t n th th n l r 0% l r th n th v r, n n th f l , th f ll n p nt pr d d fr r n . h r d t n n n tr n r n f nt: x d n r lt pr r l fr th l r b t n t p r t r f th n l. . C b t n th th n l pr d h h r rb n n x d nd "h dr rb n" n , Downloaded from http://asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/GT/proceedings-pdf/GT1981/79627/V002T06A015/2393594/v002t06a015-81-gt-50.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021 t n r t t bl t z SYM O UE I EC O t n th d, h n r t d f l O KE OSE E . nj t r. A C , ❑ C 2O . 2 2. A nv nt n l d l r f t p f l nj t r . 2 n t bl f r l f d b t n b t n xtr l p r t p r t r d tr • C.4 0 . 4 b t n t th b t r x t.
. r l f d b t n , lt h l t p f l nj t r t bl , b t n pt n b r f h l nd th r d t r h v t b d t r n d fr xp r nt .
h nj t r th l r n b r f h l h d t p r t r d tr b t n b t t l pr d h h l v l f n tr n x d n .
4. S n l f d b t n v p r z l , pr r z n t t l t v r t t r t n pr r n r t pr v nt t v p r z t n n p p . 0 0 00 0 E E E CES AI — UE A IO r r, .C., "M th n l A l S r ," G rb n Int rn t n l, M n , pp. 8 40 r . Ox d f n tr n n 2 ll nt l, .W., ddl , S.G., nd nd, .C., r., "C b t n f M th n l n n A t t v G rb n ," t r A t t v l , l n , , pp.2 262
8