Enhanced Hydroformylation of 1-Octene in N-Butane Expanded Solvents with Co-Based Complexes
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Reaction Chemistry & Engineering Enhanced hydroformylation of 1-octene in n-butane expanded solvents with Co-based Complexes Journal: Reaction Chemistry & Engineering Manuscript ID RE-ART-02-2018-000034.R1 Article Type: Paper Date Submitted by the Author: 30-Mar-2018 Complete List of Authors: Liu, Dupeng; University of Kansas, Chemical and Petroleum Engineering Xie, Zhuanzhuan; Center for Environmentally Beneficial Catalysis, Chemical and Petroleum Engineering Snavely, W.; University of Kansas, Center for Environmentally Beneficial Catalysis Chaudhari, Raghunath; University of Kansas, Chemical & Petroleum Engineering Subramaniam, Bala; University of Kansas, Center for Environmentally Beneficial Catalysis; University of Kansas, Chemical and Petroleum Engineering Page 1 of 35 Reaction Chemistry & Engineering Enhanced hydroformylation of 1-Octene in n-butane expanded solvents with Co-based Complexes Dupeng Liu,1,2 Zhuanzhuan Xie,2 William Kirk Snavely,2 Raghunath Chaudhari,1,2 and Bala Subramaniam1,2 1Department of Chemical & Petroleum Engineering, 2Center for Environmentally Beneficial Catalysis, University of Kansas Lawrence, KS 66047 Submitted to Reaction Chemistry & Engineering February 2018 1 Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to B. Subramaniam at [email protected] 1 Reaction Chemistry & Engineering Page 2 of 35 Abstract The use of nbutane expanded liquids (BXLs) as reaction media to enhance Co-catalyzed hydroformylation of 1-octene has been successfully demonstrated. Both 1-octene as well as typical hydroformylation mixtures are volumetrically expanded by n-butane at typical hydroformylation conditions (~ 50% expansion at 1.8 MPa of nbutane and 180 °C). By replacing up to 20% of the traditional solvent (toluene) in the reaction mixture with compressed nbutane, the TOF for Co-catalyzed 1-octene hydroformylation with triphenylphosphine ligand was enhanced by approximately 20% in the BXL system. The higher TOF in BXLs is attributed to the improved syngas availability in the pressure-tunable BXL phase compared to the traditional liquid phase. The main impediment to TOF enhancement is catalyst precipitation beyond a certain level of nbutane dissolution in the liquid phase. Hence, catalyst complexes that show improved solubility in the BXL phase are desirable to better harness the potential benefits offered by gasexpanded liquids. Keywords: Hydroformylation, gas-expanded solvent, 1-octene, cobalt complex 2 Page 3 of 35 Reaction Chemistry & Engineering 3 Reaction Chemistry & Engineering Page 4 of 35 Introduction Hydroformylation, also known as oxo synthesis or oxo process, is one of the largest industrial homogeneous catalytic processes with applications in the manufacture of fine chemicals, pharmaceuticals and specialty chemicals. Hydroformylation involves the addition of a formyl group (CHO) to a carbon-carbon double bond. The most commonly used hydroformylation catalysts are either unmodified or modified rhodium and cobalt complexes. Rhodium-based catalysts are widely used in the lower olefin (C<5) hydroformylations. However, they are not well suited for higher olefin hydroformylation because the Rh complexes are unstable at typical temperatures required for product separation/distillation. Hence, the less expensive cobalt-based catalysts are used for industrial higher olefin hydroformylation, even though harsh reaction temperatures (~180°C) and pressures (~20 MPa) are needed to activate and maintain the catalyst complex.1-4 Gas-expanded liquids (GXLs) are generated by dissolving compressible gases such as CO2 and light olefins in an organic solvent. The liquid phase volumetrically expands upon dissolution of the compressed gas.5, 6 Compared to traditional organic solvent, GXLs provide both process and environmental advantages while allowing operation at much lower pressures than supercritical fluids.7-9 Previously, several groups including ours have clearly demonstrated that for phosphine modified rhodium catalyzed 1-octene hydroformylation reaction, turnover frequency (TOF) and regioselectivity (n/i) are 10-13 significantly enhanced as well as pressure tunable in CO2-based media. In the case of carbon dioxide-expanded liquids (CXLs), the observed beneficial effects on hydroformylation activity and selectivity are attributed to the favorable tunability of 4 Page 5 of 35 Reaction Chemistry & Engineering 14 H2/CO ratio in the CXL phase. Besides CO2, the use of other gases as expansion media to create GXLs has also been 15, 16 reported. In comparison to CO2 (Tc = 31.0 °C; Pc = 7.38 MPa), propane (Tc = 96.6 °C; Pc = 4.25 MPa) and n-butane (Tc = 152.0 °C; Pc = 3.70 MPa) possess higher critical temperatures but lower critical pressures. Consequently, propane and n-butane can expand organic solvents at higher temperatures and lower pressures compared to CO2. Recently, we demonstrated that the solubilities of H2 and CO in either propane-expanded or propylene-expanded phase are greater than those in the neat organic solvents, by as high as 78% at 70 °C and 1.5 MPa.17 For rhodium/triphenylphosphine catalyzed propylene hydroformylation performed in the 70-100 °C range and pressures up to 2.0 MPa, the n/i aldehyde ratio is increased by up to 45% in propane-expanded liquids (PXLs). This is attributed to the increased H2/CO ratio in the GXL phase. Like propane, reaction media expanded by n-butane, whose critical temperature is close to typical reaction temperatures (160-180°C) for Co-based hydroformylation, has the potential to enhance activity and selectivity at milder pressures. In this manuscript, we experimentally quantify the volumetric expansion of typical hydroformylation mixtures by n-butane, including the solubility of the Co catalyst complexes in such BXLs. The activity and selectivity of Co-catalyzed hydroformylation of 1-octene were compared in neat solvent media and BXLs. The experimental results reveal that the TOF was enhanced more than 20% in BXL media with a 20% reduction in organic solvent usage. The increased TOF in BXLs is attributed to the improved syngas availability in the BXL phase compared to neat solvent. 5 Reaction Chemistry & Engineering Page 6 of 35 Experimental Materials The purchased materials are listed in Table 1. All organic compounds were used as is unless otherwise noted. Apparatus and methods Volumetric Expansion and Catalyst Solubility Experiments: The experimental setup for investigating catalyst solubilities and solvent expansion with n-butane is illustrated in Error! Reference source not found.. It consists of a ~80 cm3 Jerguson® Series 20™ liquid level gage (Clark-Reliance Corp.), thermocouples (Omega Engineering, Inc., type T, ±1.0 °C), pressure transducer (Omega Engineering Model PX835-2KSI, 0-13.79 MPa ±0.5%) and an oven (from a Applied Separations Model 7700 Speed® SFE unit, <240 °C). A Mitutoyo Digimatic® height gage with Titan® cathetometer is used to measure the expanded liquid volume (each mm division corresponds to a volume of 0.54 cm3). The liquid level gage is located in the oven, and the gage will henceforth be referred to as the ‘view cell’. In a typical run, the system was evacuated with a vacuum pump, and the resulting vacuum was used to pull a known amount of organic liquid into the view cell through a port located in the bottom of the cell. The liquid consists of either pure solvent or a mixture of solvents and reactants at various compositions representative of typical hydroformylation reaction mixtures. Enough liquid was introduced into the system such that the meniscus in the view cell was visible using the cathetometer, looking through a round window located in the oven door. The mixture was then brought to the desired temperature, and the level recorded. Known amounts of n-butane were gradually 6 Page 7 of 35 Reaction Chemistry & Engineering introduced using a syringe pump. The gas was bubbled through a 2-micron frit immersed in the liquid, at the end of a vertical 1/16” stainless steel tube introduced into the view cell through a side port at the top of the cell. The expansion of the organic liquid by n- butane was recorded in terms of the relative increase in the liquid volume from the initial state (n-butane-free, equilibrated pressure, P0) to the final state (n-butane expanded, equilibrated pressure, P) at the same temperature. The volumetric expansion ratio was calculated using Equation 1. ͐ ͐(͎, ͊) = (1) ͐ͤ ͐(͎, ͊ͤ) The volumetric expansion data are also predicted by Peng-Robinson equation of state (PR-EoS) with van der Waals’ mixing rules embedded in the Aspen Plus® software.18, 19 This simulation method has been previously demonstrated to satisfactorily predict the volumetric expansion as well as VLE data for CO2- and propane-expanded solvent systems.10, 17, 20 The equation and parameters used in the VLE simulations are shown in the Supplementary Materials (Section S1 & Table S1). The cloud point pressure at which the dissolved Co catalyst complex precipitates was also measured during the expansion study. Operating pressures below the cloud point are used for performing homogeneous hydroformylation in BXLs, whereas pressures above the cloud point may be exploited for catalyst precipitation post-reaction. Hydroformylation experiments: The hydroformylation reaction was performed in a 50 cm3 high-pressure autoclave reactor in a semi-batch mode. The equipment description and procedures are described elsewhere.14 In a typical run, a known amount of liquid solution containing substrate, 7 Reaction Chemistry & Engineering Page 8 of 35 dissolved