PROTOCOL The Journal of the entertainment technology industry

Stage lighting and the environment: Results from a year-long study

plus training and events at :

PLASA Technical Standards updates and 16 The ESTA Foundation Seminars and Training sessions offered during LDI2013 2013 Rock Our World Awards— 30 Learn more about this year’s finalists PLASA Members’ Choice Product Awards 67

fall 2013 ■ Volume 18 ■ Number 4 fall 2013 92 86 Number 4 67 ■ 82 74 97 Volume Volume 18 ■ 78 96 60 71 72 66 62 fall 2013 2013 fall IATSE shows support for Behind the Scenes IATSE at all levels NEW MEMBERS INDEX ADVERTISERS’ BIZQUESTIONS Indicators Performance Questions about Key and employees on long-term deployment TSP NEWS SOFT SELL Nurturing a customer relationship is worth the long-term investment PERG NEWS ETCP NEWS Raising the bar with ETCP FOUNDATION THE ESTA PLASA London: Dock Victoria Success at Royal PLASA Rigging Conference: The Learning through a lively debate PLASA Focus: Austin— PLASA Focus: not weird It’s Entech 2013: up Down Under? What’s PLASA Members’ Choice PLASA Members’ Product Award nominees

56 18 30 40 46 16 36 3 52 ocolot 4 24 LDI2013 at 10 PROTOCOL 7 9

14 PLASA Seminars CORRECTION OUT OF THE WOOD TLCI Consistency Index – Lighting Television AND TRUTH LIGHT, SHADOW, Initiative Greener Lighting Framework BGA’s WATCH STANDARDS When does a standard become a millstone? PUBLISHER’S NOTE PUBLISHER’S NOTE NA DIRECTIONS EU DIRECTIONS LOOKING AHEAD Upcoming Industry Events in every issue 2013 Rock Awards Our World Smarter buildings for performance technology and infrastructure Continuous improvement at Rosco—A work in progress Developing a security program features STORY COVER the environment: Stage lighting and study Results from a year-long Pr , , How , 2011, , 2011, I Am wards wards 74 A , 2012, , 2012, Photo: 2012, Photo: 18 , 2012, Photo: , 2012, Photo: Or, Photo: , 2012, Photo: Humor Abuse oster. oster. I Am My Own , 2012, Photo: Alan , 2012, Photo: Alan Red , 2011, Photo: Chris , 2011, Photo: Chris , 2011, Photo: Chris , 2011, Photo: Chris Humor Abuse 2012, Photo: Chris 2012, Photo: Chris Sylvia Clybourne Park Or, Circle Mirror Transformation 30 , 2012, Photo: Chris Bennion; , 2012, Photo: Chris Bennion; Clybourne Park

How to Write a New Book for the

k Our VH Hotel. VH Hotel.

, 2011, Photo: Chris Bennion; and Basil , 2011, Photo: Chris Bennion; and Basil , 2012, Photo: Kevin Berne; Alban Dennis , 2012, Photo: Chris Bennion. Fourth row: , 2012, Photo: Chris Bennion. Fourth row: , 2012, Photo: Chris Bennion. wards at the PLASA Cocktail and wards

World awards Roc FINALIST Michael Patten, Anastasia Higham, Peter A. Michael Patten, Anastasia Higham, Peter A. Krich in Jacobs, Elizabeth Raetz, and Gretchen Bennion; Lorenzo Pisoni in Bennion; Lorenzo 2011, Photo: Chris Bennion; Aaron Blakeley, Tyler Tyler Blakeley, 2011, Photo: Chris Bennion; Aaron and Leo Marks in Linda Gehringer, Pierce, Wife Alabastro; and Nick Garrison in Alabastro; Photo: Alan Alabastro; Nick Garrison in Photo: Alan Alabastro; Photo: Chris Bennion; Kim Staunton and Teagle Photo: Chris Bennion; Kim Staunton and Teagle in Bougere F. Red Sylvia Circle Mirror Transformation On the Cover: Fisher Dachs Associates, in collaboration with 2011- gathered Seattle Repertory Theatre, 2012 season data that would help inform decision-making about stage environmental Marya Sea Kaminski and row: lighting. Top in Suzanne Bouchard ong Riders received a warm received The Long Reach Long Riders WI welcome on their visit to ETC in Middleton, F and a full tour by CEO Fred Pisoni in Bennion; and Lorenzo earn who wins the 2013 Rock Our World World Rock Our Learn who wins the 2013 A and Linda K. Morris in Harris and Montana von Fliss in Anastasia Higham in to Write a New Book for the Bible Bennion; Mari Nelson and Linda K. Morris in Bennion; Mari Nelson and Linda K. Morris in Chris Bennion. Third row: Montana von Fliss Montana von Fliss row: Chris Bennion. Third and Kirsten Potter in 2011, Photo: Chris Bennion. Second row: Linda Linda 2011, Photo: Chris Bennion. Second row: Gehringer in My Own Wife Kevin Berne; Denis Arndt in Bible Chris Bennion; Connor Toms and Denis Arndt in Chris Bennion; Connor Toms Reception, November 21 from 5:30 - 7:30 p.m., 5:30 - 7:30 p.m., November 21 from Reception, at the L fall 2013 to higher-efficacy sources. Engineering onfocused switching from incandescent stage lighting’s demand have energy been bogeyman. unknown, anditremains anenvironmental islargely stage lighting poweractual useof alone are hard to come by. measurements for performance lighting more environmental scrutiny, but definitive Europe,of are facilities to cultural subject buildings.cultural I consumption isuncommon in contact me!)C is sub-metering their stage lighting, please to allow accurate power tracking. (I those thatare rarely isolate thestage lighting systems areelectrical notsub-metered, and for thetheatre.stage lighting Most theatre regarding theenvironmental of impact hascomelighting under increasing scrutiny. in environmental reduction, impact stage venuesarts have intensified their interest threat. representslighting anenvironmental lamps, theidea thatstage perpetuating incandescent generalservice production of by proposed the regulations barring been has compounded vilification This and drive upairconditioning loads. produce they light to theamountof heatrelativetungsten lampsemit alotof exorbitant consumption. energy I wattage luminaires show for every suggest I likehas seemed abig environmental villain. to sustainability, ecological stage lighting Ever sinc w e bganpaying attention Results fromayear-long study Stage lightingandtheenvironment: ts offenses are high- many: hundreds of Up to now, toward mostefforts reducing Despite theseconcerns, littledata exists A s theatres andother performing lose attention to energy n theUKandrest A s aresult, the A merican merican nefficient f anyonef conventional incandescent products. would allow usto compare them directly to luminaire efficiency or heatoutput that and littlecomparative dataexists regarding luminaireslighting remain expensive, very accents. B them attractive options for deep washesand luminous efficacymakes lossof without to saturatedcoloredability emit highly light itsoutput. to atinylight of Their fraction incandescentreduce of thetransmission in applications where deeply colored gels havethey record along track success of recently applied to been white front lighting, cost. initial high offer to they isused savings justify their products to themarketplace, andtheenergy advances have brought LEDstage lighting ecological sustainability in achievable ways. inachievable sustainability ecological that would address theorganization help projectslarger study to of identify arange about stage lighting. I environmentalinform decision-making a project to datathatwould gather help S Dachs Fisher firm Theatre planninganddesign power usedata A studytogather name ofecologicalsustainability. eliminating tungstenlampsinthe The datasupportacaseagainst eattle R A ssociates, incollaborationwith epertory Theatre (SR epertory y andlarge, however, LEDstage A fall 2013 lthough LEDshavelthough only 18 t was a part of a of t wasapart T), conceived and onstage rehearsal. that datato tech estimate theuseduring performances andrehearsals andused of show’s usethroughout thenumber energy rehearsal onstage. and tabulated thehoursinfocusand spent recordeddepartment show detailed data then for theentire performance. usefor each cueand calculate theelectricity timing, channel levels, datato andrig R areas, lampuse, andgobo andcolor data. as wellother such information asfocus andcueinput fromrig thecontrol console software, by designed R seat B seat Leo Kreielsheimer Theatre andthe850- productions inSR useover energy lighting theseason’s eight FocusTrack databaseto measure thestage power wasimpractical, feeds we the used measure itconsumes. theenergy thestage lighting, we to had findawayof to units). To examine theenvironmental effects airhandling (replacement aging savings of dollars inannual utility reap thousandsof to costly thatcould systems upgrades the printers andcopiers to double-sided) from ranged These no-brainers(setting ob helped usoptimize ittoob helped usethecue A B ecause sub-metering the stage lighting sub-metering thestageecause lighting s theseason progressed, SR agley agley W right Theatre.right FocusTrack The T’s two spaces: the250- W By e extrapolated eache extrapolated A Katie Oman ob Halliday, records lthough thedata arelthough T’s lighting 3.0 fall 2013 3.0 75kWh 2.5 103kW 206kWh Humor Abuse 137kW Clybourne Park 26kWh 160kWh Circle Mirror Transformation 95kW 75kWh ), we find that these we ), Sylvia 100kWh 2.5 345kW 2.0 103kW 206kWh Humor Abuse 282kWh Clybourne Park 137kW Clybourne Park 26kWh 64kW 120kWh Red Sylvia 147kW 160kWh Circle Mirror 719kWh Transformation 95kW energy use chart, they show up only as brief up only theyenergy show use chart, near rivaling many come don’t and spikes the Examining cues. high-powered other periods of highest energy demand shows’ of 75 kW (in excess cyc incandescent cues where mostly are used at high intensities, washes were This with saturated gel. and often deeply lighting stage overall reduce that to suggests lighting cyc higher-efficiency energy use, LED cyc start. to be a good place may and the market, to not new are luminaires as compared although costly they remain is the lamp life strips, with incandescent not required media are color longer, much and the highly for saturated washes, even of is the luminaires color-control dynamic designers. to attractive 1.5 Sylvia 25kWh 100kWh 345kW 2.0 Red 47kW 227kWh Or, 282kWh Hours Clybourne Park 150kW —only —only 34kWh 64kW Or, 120kWh Red 200kWh Sylvia 43kW 147kW Chart 2 – Possible vs. actual power use vs. Chart 2 – Possible 719kWh 1.0 Red Or, Clybourne Park 136kW 57kWh 1.5 Book for the Bible ee Chart 2 for a How to Write a New How to Write 19 25kWh Total Connected Load Total Peak Cue Total Possible Power Use Total Actual Power Use 318kWh Red 47kW Book for the Bible L PROTOCO How to Write a New How to Write 227kWh Or, 24kW Hours 19kWh 150kW I Am My Own Wife 137kW I Am My Own Wife 253kWh 0.5 34kWh Or, 0 0 50

350 300 250 200 150 100

800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 Power Use (kilowatts) Use Power 200kWh (kilowatt-hours) Performance per Use Power Further, conventional wisdom suggests conventional Further, 43kW 1.0 around 20% of the average total connected connected total 20% ofaround the average less heat than the much load and likely originally were systems HVAC building’s S designed handle. to consumption between shows and from and from shows between consumption Though this variability cue. might cue to of as much a surprisenot come lighting to illustration a valuable of it’s designers, can vary consumption power much how of productions between even similar size The vast majority ofand genre. the shows’ 40 kW fall below demands power possible versus ofcomparison show’s each use. actual power that the curtain call will typically be the Though highest-energy show. cue in a given overall in the identifiable easily they are Red Or, Clybourne Park 136kW 57kWh Book for the Bible How to Write a New How to Write Sylvia a New Book for the Bible How to Write Am My Own Wife I Total Connected Load Total Peak Cue Chart 1 – Production power profile: Seattle Rep 2011-12 season power profile: Chart 1 – Production Total Possible Power Use Total Actual Power Use 318kWh 0.0 Book for the Bible 80 60 40 20

How to Write a New How to Write

100 Power Use (kilowatts) Use Power 24kW 19kWh I Am My Own Wife 137kW I Am My Own Wife 253kWh 0.5 0 0 50

350 300 250 200 150 100

800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 Power Use (kilowatts) Use Power Power Use per Performance (kilowatt-hours) Performance per Use Power Sylvia for the Bible a New Book How to Write Am My Own Wife I t the study’s outset, given stage stage given outset, t the study’s A 0.0

80 60 40 20

t’s not only neat to look at but gives us a us a gives look at but neat to not only t’s 100 Power Use (kilowatts) Use Power illustrates lighting the stage Chart 1 above I econd, we thought we’d get measurements get measurements thought we we’d econd, energy realities of a number both The data offer insights, as a and the season individual shows for whole. energy-guzzling, for reputation lighting’s expectations had some about the results. we thought we that energy the use for First, be to able be so high would season that we’d to attention important pay how it is to show impact of lighting. the environmental stage S the payback help us calculate that would we Third, period lights. LED stage for thought might justify we be to able with equipment existing LEDs on replacing Turns the basis of utility savings alone. cost that easy! quite it wasn’t out, of six use for in the eightpower shows two the first (for the 2011 – 2012 season Mirror and Circle Abuse Humor productions, integrating cue-tracking , Transformation was still in progress). of use for the power holistic representation most obvious Perhaps these productions. is the enormous variability in power Results illustrate Results illustrate not the result of direct power metering, we we metering, of not the result power direct they an accurate believe nevertheless give ofidea energy consumption. fall 2013 N more costly—in andaround wherelocations power is significant cost savings. I amount to aninstitutionally would rig) notan all-LED offered75% (apossibility by powerlighting demand by bill.energy C SR up only 2%of kW per about$0.065power rate of (using S amount to lessthan$1,600 kW out to just under 25,000 for theentire season came byused thestage lighting stage lighting, thetotal power for each year on electricity SR expected to discover that biggest surprises. entire the season yielded financialimplications. important designers’ options could have artistic affecting minimized canbe feeds without I availablepayment megawatt per power. of kilowatt-hours usebut alsoanannual they owners andoperators pay notonly for the Europe, of UK andother parts building pay for power aswe useit. However, in supply systems; electrical wein thecost of reduced forecasts allow load savings might confined mostly where to new construction powerthe availability inabuilding are of 3. on30% lessasshown Chart load, andtheother shows anaverage used of thetotal connected of moreused thanhalf season, only Park Clybourne ’s cue brightest total connected load. I alarge the percentage be production will of powerthat thepeak draw for aparticular used. isactually what guess Onemight between thepowerdisparity available and cuesalsoshows thelarge highest-energy n thiscase, how power anunderstanding of ew York C Examining thepower usetotals for the I C T was spending afortune T wasspending n theUS, theeconomic implicationsof h. N omparing thepower these omparing demand of h), but italsomakes ot only does this eattle’s commercial ity therate can ity utting thestage T’s annual W hile we n SR n T’s 2011–2012

Stage Lighting Stage Power Use (kilowatts) 100

20 40 60 80 2% 0.0

I Am MyOwnWife How toWrite aNewBookfortheBible Sylvia Building Lighting Building Chart 4–SeattleRepannualenergy costprofile

costume, office, and rehearsal spaces, the the building, ithousesscenic, andwhile their stages make of upalarge portion for aregional theatre; thetwo theatres and that S building’s costs. energy I insignificant relative the to the rest of forbill theseason would remain still $0.19or kW be $0.20per 39% Power Use (kilowatts) Power Use per Performance (kilowatt-hours) 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 100 150 200 250 300 350

Hot Water 50 0 eattle R 0

5% 0.5 253kWh Own Wife *source: McKinstryEnergy I Am My I Am 137kW Own Wife

I Am My I Am Heating 19kWh

ep’s are facilities typical pretty 3% 24kW How toWrite aNew fall 2013 Book fortheBible Chart 3– 318kWh Actual PowerUse Total PossiblePowerUse Peak Cue Total ConnectedLoad 20 How toWrite aNew Book fortheBible 57kWh 136kW t should be notedt shouldbe Clybourne Park Or, Red

h—a $5,000

TerminalUnits

Plug Loads Plug & Cooling

1.0 13% 43kW T

otal connectedloadvs. maximumpowerdraw 11% 200kWh Or, 34kWh Audit 2010

150kW Air Handling Units Handling Air Hours Or,

227kWh Pumps 47kW

Red

25% 2% 25kWh 1.5 cooling systems thatcounteract heatgains lighting’s contribution to thetotal. to underscore stage theinsignificance of by small look comparison. only This serves would make power thestage lighting use can’t that hog asanenergy characterized be no restaurant on site. Thus, thebuilding lobbies are relatively small, andthere is Taking into account useof theenergy 719kWh 147kW Sylvia Red 120kWh 64kW Clybourne Park 282kWh absence, thecooling systems rehearsal, intheaudience’s system. tech During and work thecooling required of reduction in the a parallel result in will stage lighting reduction inheatfrom the we canassume thatany presence anaudience, of by imposed the heat loads performances due to the systems are always on during I itswattage alone.basis of from on the stage lighting examine thesensible heat comfort conditions, we can storage inmaintaining zones, thermal andissues of and auditorium cooling stage the complexities of I is abit more difficult. from thestage lighting f, theoretically, cooling quiescent loads,gnoring 2.0 345kW 100kWh Sylvia 95kW Transformation Circle Mirror 160kWh 26kWh Clybourne Park 137kW Humor Abuse 206kWh 103kW 2.5 75kWh 3.0 fall 2013 t rand hanges in hanges T upgraded hile higher-efficacy h, or about $6,000 per year. The G about $6,000 per year. or h, Of course we may find, with further find, Of may we course of size lighting’s stage The relative n fact, prior to this study, SR this study, prior to n fact, set a direction for deeper inquiry for set a direction into the First, ecological profile. lighting’s stage data support a case against eliminating in the name of lamps tungsten ecological W sustainability. will energy offer sources savings in certain (especiallyapplications saturated color non-incandescent to switch a total washes), of that much a make won’t just sources I energy consumption. in a theatre’s dent would be better to replace lobby, shop, and shop, lobby, replace to be better would energy the lighting reap space to circulation worry savings about and to and cost more management, transportation, waste patron more and other systems, building C foes. environmental formidable Ontario has changed in London, Theatre all of compact lights LED or its building to stage lighting sources in existing buildings in existing lightingstage sources oughtthe basis of be on made to artistic not energy savings. objectives, facilities that new with all-LED analysis, of the size their reduce rigs be to able may see capital and thus air handling systems, savings cost and equipment building ofcost significantjustifyenough the to the where in applications Likewise, luminaires. where or is a problem, power to access portion up a bigger ofenergy make costs the be possible it may of costs total production, reasonable a more the case for make to period an energy-efficient on payback relying on However, lighting investment. choice luminaire energy from use reduction than a blip as more not register may alone utility the annual on bill. us from impact frees environmental thinking of it as an ecological villain we that Theatres apologize or for. from hide to have strides great made in have the world around energy their simple building use by reducing onstage. affect the work upgrades that don’t I lightingalmost all the architectural the facilitythroughout use energy- to resulting in an estimated lamps, efficient energy savings of than 100,000 more kW A ep’s data shows shows data ep’s 21 L PROTOCO n spaces where the lighting where n spaces t would appear that theatres should should appear that theatres t would n new construction, these savings, along along these savings, construction, n new I So where do we go from here? corroborationThese from findings need can solid conclusions before studies other help does the study However, be drawn. that the median peak cue power is only is only that the median peak cue power about 30% of load, connected the total and the brightest an average cues last for while the duration of minute, less than one vast majority of is spent every drawing show This the peak. than power less much lighting may that the stage suggests systems be generating than the building less heat handle. designed to were systems HVAC of data monitoring Further lighting stage design systems precise inform more may buildings new savings for and capital cost and systems. with the possibility of dimmer reducing be the justify enough to could capacity, of cost outfit LED lighting to equipment I space. a new in high-efficiency lighting stage invest the basis of on equipment offers benefits it and quality color-control designers for to of light. close examination of examination close the R a large it drives where or on is always spaces as broadcast such demand, cooling equation the payback halls, concert or using very-high-efficacy also favor may theatres in existing However, light sources. investment a large with systems, existing in high-efficiency lighting stage appears of little chance enough saving have to itself for energy pay in a reasonable to savings cost account into Taking period. and gel use can lamp failure reduced from especially considerably, prospects improve energy saving but lighting, through cyc for is likely in high-efficiency sources investing than off-stage effective more be much to I on-. systems with air velocities systems very low HVAC can this space ducts), large (and therefore and volume building to add significantly higher. costs other many drive therefore eattle T because eattle’s climate climate eattle’s T’s 2011 – 2012 season 2011 – 2012 season T’s

n performance halls quiet n performance requiring

f the cooling systems’ load resulting load resulting f systems’ the cooling However, the data does suggest that for a that for suggest the data does However, I enter campus. Further, S Further, campus. enter new building, significant capital cost savings significant capital building, new in the peak a reduction from result could therefore and capacity of systems, cooling of size and the those systems the physical and air supply to devoted space related I return. might not be engaged at all, and energy might from not be engaged all, at the lightingthe stage actually reduce would of required the heating systems. work lighting duringstage the systems from 75% by was reduced performances SR throughout cooling theychilled-water use a central the S throughout that is shared system of required the so work mild, is relatively will systems be far less than in cooling The small climates. humid more hotter, lighting stage ofcost season’s the entire electricity a partial that use suggests will demand in cooling not make reduction in the annual cost difference a significant energy bills. (again using theoretical all-LED rigs), it all-LED(again rigs), using theoretical the season, over about 34m Btu might save about 40% of the heat loads a imposed by implications of The cost rig. conventional impossible these hypothetical savings are ascertain in the case ofto SR C savings. not energy artistic objectives, artistic objectives, on the basis of ought to be made existing buildings sources in stage lighting Changes in fall 2013 LEED-accredited professionalandaCertified aspirations ofcultural organizations. with sensitivitytotheuniqueneeds, values, and expertise inthecomplexitiesofcultural buildings Katie’s approachcombinesdeeptechnical sustainable developmentforartsandheritage. facilities planning, withanemphasison cultural sector. Sheisaspecialistinstrategic management andplanningservicesforthe Arts ConsultingGroup, aleadingproviderof Katie OmanisaSeniorConsultantwith decisions inthefuture. the more datauponwhich to baseinformed consumption, have will all we asanindustry actively monitor andmanage their energy to andbegin sustainability ecological entertainment venues continue to engage turbine.a new wind I itspower from mostof 70% andgetting reducing emissions by carbon of the goal to consumption, minimize energy with systems,its airhandling staff andtrained andcontrols,building lighting upgraded UK’sThe hasaltered Opera Glyndebourne CAD $30,000annually since theupgrade. fluorescent sources andhassaved more than f theatres andother f n She isa adaptive reuse, andGanttcharts. Trinity CollegeDublin. Katielovesdogs, cooking, in PublicHistoryandCultural Heritagefrom Lighting design: L. B. Morse Director: R. Hamilton Wright Bagley WrightTheatre Sylvia Lighting design: Director: Andreallen Bagley WrightTheatre Transformation Mirror Circle Lighting design: BenStanton Director: EricaSchmidt Bagley WrightTheatre buse A Humor SR T 2011-2012season, shows, andpersonnel Andrew Smith fall 2013 University andaMaster’s Architecture fromPrinceton firm. planning anddesign Associates, atheatre manager withFisherDachs A Advisor. Priortojoining Sustainable Building 22 CG, Katiewas aproject She holdsaBAin for the Bible the for Lighting design: Robert Director: JerryManning K. TheatreLeo Wife Own My m A I Nichols design: Alexander Lighting Director: Kent Nicholson Bagley WrightTheatre Book New a Write to How Aguilar Lighting design: L. B. Morse Narver Director: Allison K. TheatreLeo Or, Lighting Design: RobertPetersen E. T.Richard Director: White Bagley WrightTheatre Red Lighting design: L. B. Morse BradenDirector: Abraham Bagley WrightTheatre Park Clybourne