Systematic Quantitative Analysis of H2A And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
El Kennani et al. Epigenetics & Chromatin (2018) 11:2 https://doi.org/10.1186/s13072-017-0172-y Epigenetics & Chromatin METHODOLOGY Open Access Systematic quantitative analysis of H2A and H2B variants by targeted proteomics Sara El Kennani1, Annie Adrait1, Olga Permiakova1, Anne‑Marie Hesse1, Côme Ialy‑Radio2, Myriam Ferro1, Virginie Brun1, Julie Cocquet2, Jérôme Govin1* and Delphine Pfieger1,3* Abstract Background: Histones organize DNA into chromatin through a variety of processes. Among them, a vast diversity of histone variants can be incorporated into chromatin and fnely modulate its organization and functionality. Classically, the study of histone variants has largely relied on antibody-based assays. However, antibodies have a limited ef‑ ciency to discriminate between highly similar histone variants. Results: In this study, we established a mass spectrometry-based analysis to address this challenge. We developed a targeted proteomics method, using selected reaction monitoring or parallel reaction monitoring, to quantify a maxi‑ mum number of histone variants in a single multiplexed assay, even when histones are present in a crude extract. This strategy was developed on H2A and H2B variants, using 55 peptides corresponding to 25 diferent histone sequences, among which a few difer by a single amino acid. The methodology was then applied to mouse testis extracts in which almost all histone variants are expressed. It confrmed the abundance profles of several testis-specifc histones during successive stages of spermatogenesis and the existence of predicted H2A.L.1 isoforms. This methodology was also used to explore the over-expression pattern of H2A.L.1 isoforms in a mouse model of male infertility. Conclusions: Our results demonstrate that targeted proteomics is a powerful method to quantify highly similar his‑ tone variants and isoforms. The developed method can be easily transposed to the study of human histone variants, whose abundance can be deregulated in various diseases. Keywords: Histone variants, Chromatin, Proteomics, Targeted proteomics, SRM, PRM, Spermatogenesis Background existence of histone variants adds a level of complexity to Te basic unit of chromatin is the nucleosome, an these mechanisms. Indeed, 83 histone variants (including octamer of four core histones, H2A, H2B, H3, and H4. splicing isoforms) have been identifed in mouse for his- Te assembly of eight histone molecules into a nucleo- tones H2A, H2B, and H3 that largely expand the diversity some is mediated by the histone fold, a central globular of nucleosomal actors involved in chromatin signaling domain, to form a core particle around which 147 base pathways [8]. pairs of DNA wrap [1]. Antibodies are routinely used to explore the functional Te tight control of nucleosomal organization is criti- roles of histone variants. Many of them are now com- cal for many cellular processes, such as the regulation of mercially available and widely utilized by research groups transcription, DNA replication, and DNA repair [2, 3]. A for the quantifcation and visualization of histones by vast diversity of regulatory mechanisms are involved in classical biochemical approaches, such as western blots, these nuclear processes, such as DNA methylation, his- immunofuorescence, and immunoprecipitation. Tese tone modifcations, and chromatin remodeling by protein bio-reagents have notably the advantage of being highly complexes and noncoding regulatory RNAs [4–7]. Te sensitive when combined with secondary detection methodologies. Tey thus allowed monitoring the abun- *Correspondence: [email protected]; [email protected] dance of histone variants in several cellular or pathologi- 1 INSERM U1038, CEA, BIG‑BGE, Univ. Grenoble Alpes, Grenoble, France cal contexts [9–14]. Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © The Author(s) 2018. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/ publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated. El Kennani et al. Epigenetics & Chromatin (2018) 11:2 Page 2 of 18 However, antibody-based techniques show limitations is able to select, fragment, and quantify the ions corre- regarding specifcity and throughput. For instance, H2A sponding to the peptides of interest (Fig. 1). Briefy, the histone variants exhibit extremely high-sequence simi- frst quadrupole (Q1) allows selecting the m/z ratio cor- larity that can go beyond 90% for H2A.L.1 variants or responding to a desired peptide. Te latter ions then canonical H2A and H2A.X histones. In addition, histones enter a second quadrupole (Q2) in which they get frag- are notoriously decorated by a multitude of post-transla- mented. Finally, some predefned fragment ions are tional modifcations (PTMs), which further complicates selected in the third quadrupole (Q3) to be detected. Te the generation of antibodies [15]. Finally, lot-to-lot vari- m/z ratios of the fragments associated with the m/z of ations of antibodies can result in a lack of reproducibility the original peptide are called transitions. Recording of [16, 17]. the transitions for a given peptide throughout its chro- Mass spectrometry (MS) has now become a power- matographic elution peak informs on its abundance in ful analytical strategy to qualitatively and quantitatively the sample, and by extrapolation, on the amount of the study proteins and their PTMs. Diferent MS-based corresponding protein. Isotopically 13C/15N-labeled syn- approaches have been implemented to characterize thetic peptides are commonly added to the initial protein histones, by analyzing polypeptides of diferent sizes: sample or proteolytic peptide mixture to ascertain proper bottom-up analysis of smaller peptides [18–22], middle- recording of the endogenous peptide transitions [30, 31]. down analysis of larger peptides, typically spanning the Another targeted MS approach, named parallel reaction about 50 N-terminal residues of H3 or H4 [21, 23], and monitoring (PRM), has been developed more recently. top-down analysis of intact proteins [22, 24–27]. Dis- It relies on MS instruments generally used in discovery covery proteomics aims at identifying and quantifying a analyses (e.g., Q-Exactive instruments). Instead of only maximum number of proteins in a biological sample. In recording a selection of peptide-fragment transitions, a bottom-up approach, proteins extracted from biologi- this method allows acquiring on each targeted peptide cal samples are processed into peptides, usually with the a complete MS/MS spectrum with high-resolution and protease trypsin which cleaves peptidic bonds after the mass accuracy on fragment ions [32, 33], which allows basic amino acids lysine and arginine. Te resulting pep- better discriminating fragments of the targeted peptides tides are then separated by liquid chromatography (LC) from possible contaminants. before their on-line analysis by the mass spectrometer. In the context of histone characterization, SRM analy- Following measurement of their accurate mass-to-charge ses have been successfully used to investigate their PTMs. (m/z) ratios, peptides are fragmented to obtain amino Zhang et al. evaluated the level of histone H3 acetylation acid sequence information. In a discovery-based prot- in human brain tissue with advanced Alzheimer’s disease eomics approach, the peptides giving rise to the most as compared to neurological controls [34]. Darwanto intense signals in MS are automatically selected for frag- et al. successfully developed an SRM method to quan- mentation by MS/MS. Te acquired MS/MS spectra are tify low-abundance histone modifcations [35]. Tis work fnally matched to theoretical fragment spectra to deter- notably focused on the correlation between H3K120 mine the most likely peptide sequences. Such approaches ubiquitination and H3K79 methylation. Recently, a study are very powerful to characterize complex samples. Yet, proposed a targeted mass spectrometry approach to in spite of the increased sensitivity and dynamic range of quantify histones H3 and H2B for a clinical application recent mass spectrometry instruments, lower abundance in patients afected by a critical bacteriaemic septic shock proteins may still be hidden by the major protein compo- [36]. Finally, PRM was used to monitor modifcations on nents in the sample. human and mouse H3 and H4 and identifed new meth- Targeted MS analyses have emerged as an alternative ylation and acetylation sites [37, 38]. analytical scheme to quantify a predefned set of pro- In this report, we developed SRM- and PRM-based teins of interest in a complex protein matrix [28, 29]. Te methods to quantify a maximum number of H2A and objective of such analyses compares to the use of anti- H2B variants in a multiplexed assay. Our goal was to bodies against a few proteins of biological interest, yet be able to identify and quantify more reliably histone with the advantages of higher selectivity and straightfor- variants from a crude histone extract (around 1500 pro- ward multiplexing. Targeted proteomics by selected reac- teins) than discovery analyses would allow doing. A list