April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8329 Mr. EVANS. Were you a sponsor of that? which lasted quite a long while. Then when staff the school again. "Over my dead body Mrs. BOLTON. No, but I worked behind the the second war came along, two or three the Army will do any nursing," he said. Oh, scenes and bumped everybody off who was in of the nurses and I went to see the Surgeon we were crushed. We now have nurses very my way. We finally got our school established General and we said we were quite ready to well established in the services.
Senate completes its business today, it APPOINTMENT OF SENATOR WIL SENATE stand in adjournment until 12 o'clock LIAMS OF NEW JERSEY TO 18TH noon Monday next. FRIDAy, APRIL 23, 1965 ASSEMBLY OF WORLD HEALTH The VICE PRESIDENT. Without ob ORGANIZATION jection, it is so ordered. The Senate met at 12 o'clock meridian, The VICE PRESIDENT. The Chair and was called to order by the Vice announces the appointment of the Sena President. LIMITATION ON STATEMENTS DUR tor from New Jersey [Mr. WILLIAMS] to Rev. Edward B. Lewis, pastor, Capitol ING TRANSACTION OF ROUTINE the 18th Assembly of the World Health Hill Methodist Church, Washington, Organization to be held at Geneva, D.C., offered the following prayer: MORNING BUSINESS On request by Mr. MANSFIELD, and by Switzerland, May 4-21, 1965. Our Heavenly Father, inspiration is the unanimous consent, statements during need of this moment as we join together the transaction of routine morning busi ~UTIVE COMMUNICATIONS, in another session of the U.S. Senate. ness were ordered limited to 3 minutes. Endow these worthy men and women ETC. with purpose, integrity, and faith. In The VICE PRESIDENT laid before the spire them with Thy presence. SENATOR FROM SOUTH CAROLINA Senate the following letters, which were In order that man's inhumanity to referred as indicated: man will cease, we need information Mr. THURMOND. Mr. President, I REPORT ON NUMBER OF OFFICERS ASSIGNED OR information that will acquaint neighbor advise the Senate that DONALD S. Rus DETAILED TO PERMANENT DUTY AT THE SEAT with neighbor, friend with enemy, light SELL has been appointed by the Governor OF GOVERNMENT with darkness. Inform us, O God, as of South Carolina as a Senator from the A letter from the Secretary of the Air Force, citizens and leaders. Inspire us to put State of South Carolina to represent reporting, pursuant to law, that, as of March into practice what we learn to be right that State in the Senate of the United 31, 1965, there was an aggregate of 2,177 of for all men. States until the vacal}CY thereof, caused ficers assigned or detailed to permanent duty Dear Lord, we pause with the words of by the death of the late Senator Olin D. in the executive part of the Department of the Psalmist: Johnston, is filled by election as pro the Air Force at the seat of government; to "My soul, wait Thou upon God, for vided by law. the Committee on Armed Services. my expectation is from Him. He only is I send the certificate of appointment AMENDMENT OF SMALL BUSINESS ACT AND my rock and my salvation; He is my to the desk. SMALL BUSINESS INVESTMENT ACT OF 1958 defense; I shall not be moved. In God The certificate of appointment was A letter from the Administrator, Small is my salvation and my glory; the rock read, and ordered to be placed on :file, as Business Administration, Washington, D.C., transmitting a draft of proposed legislation of my strength, and my refuge, is in follows: to amend the Small Business Act and the God. Trust in Him at all times, ye peo To the PRESIDENT OF THE SENATE OF THE Small Business Investment Act of 1958 (with ple; pour out your heart before Him. God UNITED STATES: accompanying papers) ; to the Committee on is a refuge for us." This is to certify that, pursuant to the Banking and Currency. power vested in me by the Constitution of Thus we believe, our Heavenly Father; REPORT ON PROVISION OF AVIATION WAR RISK we receive inspiration, information, and the United States and the laws of the State of South Carolina, r, · Robert E. McNair, the INSURANCE have expectation as we :find ourselves in Governor of said State, do hereby appoint A letter from the Secretary of Commerce, Thee-our salvation, our defense, our DONALD RUSSELL a Senator from said State transmitting, pursuant to law, a report on refuge, and rock in time of storm. to represent said State in the Senate of the the provision of aviation war risk insurance, We pray in the name and spirit of our United States until the vacancy therein, as of March 31, 1965 (with an accompanying Lord. Amen. caused by the death of Olin D. Johnston, is report); to the Committee on Commerce. filled by election as provided by law. REPORTS OF COMPTROLLER GENERAL Witness: His Excellency our Governor A letter from the Comptroller General of THE JOURNAL Robert E. McNair, and our seal hereto af the United States, transmitting, pursuant to fixed at Columbia, S.C., this 22d day of On request of Mr. MANSFIELD, and by law, a report on unnecessary retention of April, in the year of our Lord 1965. high-value land, Fort Gordon, Ga., Depart unanimous consent, the reading of the ROBERT E. McNAm, ment of the Army, dated April 1965 (with Journal of the proceedings of Thursday, Governor. an accompanying report); to the Committee April 22, 1965, was dispensed with. By the Governor: on Government Operations. 0. FRANK THORNTON, A letter from the Comptroller General of Secretary of State. the United States, transmitting, pursuant to MESSAGES FROM THE PRESIDENT The VICE PRESIDENT. If the Sena law, a report on overpricing of ammunition Messages in writing from the President tor-designate will present himself at the components purchased from Honeywell, desk, the oath of office will be admin Inc., Hopkins, Minn., Department of the of the United States, submitting nomi Army, dated April 1965 (with an accompany nations, were communicated to the Sen istered to him. ing report); to the Committee on Govern ate by Mr. Geisler, one of his secretaries. Mr. RUSSELL of South Carolina, es ment Operations. corted by Mr. THURMOND, advanced to A letter from the Comptroller General of the Vice President's desk, and the oath the United States, transmitting, pursuant to EXECUTIVE MESSAGES REFERRED of office prescribed by law was admin law, a report on the procurements of spare As in executive session, istered to him by the Vice President and parts and assemblies in excess of current was subscribed by him. [Applause, Sen needs by the U.S. Marine Corps, Department The VICE PRESIDENT laid before the of the Navy, dated April 1965 (with an ac Senate messages from the President of ators rising.] companying report); to the Committee on the United States submitting sundry Government Operations. nominations, which were referred to the A letter from the Comptroller General of appropriate committees. COMMITI'EE MEETING DURING the United States, transmitting pursuant to (For nominations this day received, SENATE SESSION law, a report on unnecessary procurement of office furniture, Department of Labor, dated see the end of Senate proceedings.) Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, I April 1965 (with an accompanying report); to ask unanimous consent that the Com the Committee on Government Operations. mittee on Interior and Insular Affairs be ORDER FOR ADJOURNMENT UNTIL REPORT OF DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, EDUCA- authorized to meet during the session of TION, AND WELFARE MONDAY the Senate today. A letter from the Secretary of Health. Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, I The VICE PRESIDENT. Without ob Education, and Welfare, transmitting, pur ask unanimous consent that when the jection, it is so ordered. suant to law, a report of that Department. 8330 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 for the fiscal year 1964 (with an accompany "Resolved, That the secretary of state "Whereas it is their belief that there is a ing report) ; to the Committee on Labor and transmit a copy of these resolutions to the great need to instill in the hearts and minds Public Welfare. presiding officer of each branch of the Con of our youth proper respect and reverence AMENDMENT OF CIVIL SERVICE RETIREMENT gress, and to each Member thereof from the to a Supreme Being; and ACT, RELATING TO CERTAIN ANNUITIES Commonwealth. "Whereas the recital of voluntary prayers "Senate, adopted, March 25, 1965. in our public schools will accomplish that A letter from the Director, Administrative "THOMAS A. CHADWICK, purpose and will help maintain traditions Office of the United States Courts, Washing "Clerk. cherished by so many of our citizens: Now, ton, D.C., transmitting a draft of proposed "House of representatives, adopted in con therefore, be it · legislation to amend the Civil Service Retire currence, April 7, 1965. "Resolved, That the General Court of Mas ment Act to authorize the payment of an "WILLIAM C. MAIERS, sachusetts respectfully urges the Congress annuity to a secretary of a justice or judge "Clerk. of the United States to enact legislation pre of the United States on the same basis as an "Attest: senting to the States a proposed constitu annuity to a congressional employee or for "KEVIN H. WHITE, tional amendment permitting the recital of mer congressional employee (with: an accom "Secretary of the Commonwealth." a nonsectarian prayer in our public schools; panying paper); to the Committee on Post and be it further Office and Civil Service. A resolution of the General Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts; to the "Resolved, That copies of these resolutions Committee on Government Operations: be transmitted forthwith by the secretary PETITIONS AND MEMORIALS of the Commonwealth to the President of "RESOLUTION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF the United States, the presiding officer of Petitions, etc., were laid before the MASSACHUSETTS each branch of the Congress, and to the Senate, or presented, and referred as "Resolution memorializing the Administra Members thereof from the Commonwealth. indicated: tor of Veterans' Affairs relative to the "House of representatives, adopted, March office of the Commissioner of Veterans' By the VICE PRESIDENT: 29, 1965. A resolution of the General Assembly of the Services of the Commonwealth "WILLIAM C. MAIERS, State of Rhode Island; to the Committee on "Resolved, That the General Court of "Clerk. Finance: Massachusetts respectfully urges the Admin "Senate, adopted in concurrence, April 1, istrator of Veterans' Affairs to recognize the 1965. "HOUSE RESOLUTION 1623 office of the Commissioner of Veterans' Serv "THOMAS A. CHADWICK, "Resolution of the General Assembly memo ices of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts "Clerk. rializing the Senators and Representatives as an agency authorized and accredited to "Attest: from Rhode Island in Congress to take im represent veterans and other persons in mat "KEVIN H. WHITE, mediate action to abolish the quota restric ters dealing with affairs of veterans before the "Secretar y of the Commonwealth." t ion on the import of residual oil Veterans' Administration; and be it further A resolution adopted by the Southern In "Whereas residual oil is the energy source "Resolved, Tha\ the General Court of terstate Nuclear Board of Hollywood Beach, in generating electricity used by all our in Massachusetts further respectfully urges the Fla., favoring the enactment of legislation to dustries, businesses, institutions, municipal Administrator of Veterans' Affairs to procure amend the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, to ex ities, and homes; and from the Administrator of the General Serv tend the provisions of the Price-Anderson "Whereas because of the restrictions im ices' Administration office space in the John indemnity legislation for an additional pe posed on the import of residual oil into this Fitzgerald Kennedy Federal Building in the riod of 10 years; to the Joint Committee on area, our electric rates in Rhode Island are city of Boston for the office of the Commis Atomic Energy. among the highest in the Nation; and sioner of Veterans' Services of the Common "Whereas our industries, business and wealth of Massachusetts in order to provide homeowners who are dependent on electricity better service for the veterans of the Com RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF GARY, are at an economical disadvantage in com monwealth; and be it further parison to other areas; and "Resolved, That the General Court of IND., COMMON COUNCIL ON SEC "Whereas because of this economic dis Massachusetts further respectfully urges the TION 14(b), TAFT-HARTLEY advantage our industries are in an unfavor Administrator of Veterans' Affairs to initiate Mr. HARTKE. Mr. President, I have able competitive position; and legislation, if necessary, to accomplish these "Whereas new industries are detracted from ends; and be it further received from the office of the city of establishing in Rhode Island because of this "Resolved, That copies of these resolutions Gary, Ind., a resolution passed by the competitive disadvantage caused by the high be transmitted forthwith by the secretary of Gary Common Council recently urging electric rates that are dependent upon the the commonwealth to the Administrator of Congress to repeal the well-known sec cost of the residual oil: Now, therefore, be it Veterans' Affairs, the Administrator of the tion 14(b) of the National Labor Rela " Resolved, That the Members of Congress General Services' Administration, the presid tions Act. This is an official resolution from the State of Rhode Island are hereby ing officer of each branch of the Congress of direct to the Congress. I ask unanimous respectfully requested to take proper and im the United States, and to the Members consent that it may appear in the CON mediate necessary action to have all restric thereof from the Commonwealth. tions on the import of residual oil abolished; "House of representatives, adopted, March GRESSIONAL RECORD, and request that it directing the Secretary of State to transmit 29, 1965. be referred to the appropriate committee. duly certified copies of this resolution to the "WILLIAM C. MAIERS, There being no objection, the resolu Secretary of the Senate, the clerk of the "Clerk. tion was referred to the Committee on House of Representatives and to each Mem "Senate, adopted in concurrence, April 5, Labor and Public Welfare, as follows: ber of Congress elected from the State of 1965. RESOLUTION 952 Rhode Island." "THOMAS A. CHADWICK, Resolution of the city of · Gary urging Con A resolution of the General Court of the "Clerk. "Attest: gress to enact legislation to restore full Commonwealth of Massachusetts; to the freedom of collective bargaining as uni Committee on Finance: "KEVIN H. WHITE, form national labor policy and practice "RESOLUTION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF "Secretary of the Commonwealth." throughout the United States, by repeal MASSACHUSETTS A resolution of the General Court of the ing existing sanctions of State right-to "Resolution memorializing the Congress of Commonwealth of Massachusetts; to the work laws contained in section 14(b) of the United States to enact legislation pro Committee on the Judiciary: the National Labor Relations Act, as viding medical care for the elderly through "RESOLUTION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF amended, and section 705(b) of the Labor social security financing MASSACHUSETTS Management Reporting and Disclosure Act "Whereas a major problem facing a large "Resolution memorializing the Congress of of 1959, and by other appropriate action number of elderly citizens ls how to meet the the United States to enact legislation pre Whereas section 14(b) of the National rising cost of medical care with fixed or de senting to the States a proposed constitu Labor Relations Act, as amended, and section clining income; and tional amendment permitting the recital 705(b) of the Labor-Management Reporting "Whereas the social security system has of a nonsectarian prayer in the public and Disclosure Act of 1959 sanction the en enabled large numbers of elderly citizens to schools actment of State right-to-work laws pro maintain a way of life which preserves their "Whereas in the recent case of Engel v. hibiting the negotiation of agreements dignity and their independence; and Vitale, the Supreme Court of the United between unions and employers assuring "Whereas adding medical care would be a States declared the use of a voluntary prayer union security during the terms of such natural extension of the social security idea: as prepared by the board of regents of the agreement; and Now, therefore, be it State of New York to be unconstitutional; Whereas by constitutional provision or "Resolved, That the General Court of Mas and statute 19 States have such right-to-work sachusetts respectfully urges the Congress of "Whereas it ls the will and desire of the laws in effect, and by ordinance or other en the ·united States to enact legislation to pro majority of our citizens to recognize the actment numerous municipalities, counties, vide medical care for the elderly thrbugh existence of God and our dependence on and other local bodies have adopted and put social security :fl.nancing; and be · it further Him; such laws into effect; and April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8331 Whereas such laws are contrary to and in inventions made through the expenditure of The bill also authorizes the assign derogation of provisions of Federal law con public funds, and for other purposes; to the ment of qualified prisoners to commu tained in sections 8(a) (3) and 8(f) of the Committee on the Judiciary. nity residential treatment centers pat National Labor Relations Act, as amended, (See the remarks of Mr. McCLELLAN when which in the absence of section 14(b) of the he introduced the above bill, which appear terned on the Federal halfway houses National Labor Relations Act, as amended, under a separate heading.) that have proven so successful for juve and section 705(b) of the Labor-Manage By Mr. McCLELLAN (by request): niles and youths released to Los Angeles, ment Reporting and Disclosure Act of 1959, S. 1810. A bill to amend section 1498 of Chicag·o, Detroit, and New York City. permit under specified conditions the ne title 28, United States Code, to define the The centers serve as a bridge between in ... gotiation of agreements between unions and word "owner"; to the Committee on the stitutional rehabilitation and reintroduc employers assuring union security during the Judiciary. tion to the community. We are con term of such agreements; and (See the remarks of Mr. McCLELLAN when vinced that they are part of the answer Whereas State right-to-work laws under he introduced the above bill, which appear mine union organization and interfere with under a separate heading.) to the President's question concerning full freedom of collective bargaining between By Mr. COTTON: correctional programs which would help unions and employers; tend to depress wages S. 1811. A bill for the relief of Catalina to prevent a first offense from leading to and working conditions and to promote Vera-Pericas; to the Committee on the Judi a career in crime. strikes and instability and antagonism in ciary. Over the past few years, I have visited labor-management relations; and unfairly a large number of Federal penal and compel unions to represent and bargain for correctional facilities, from the camps workers who are unwilling to bear the cost MORE EFFECTIVE CORRECTIONAL and responsibility of participation in union and halfway houses to fairly secure pris organization and collective bargaining; and PROGRAMS ons. I am convinced that the Federal Whereas State right-to-work laws are un Mr. LONG of Missouri. Mr. President, prison system has developed the techni fair and antilabor in their effects and are not long ago the President of the United cal competence to expand its correction designed to weaken and harass labor unions States sent to the Congress a message on al programs into the community with in their organization efforts and in represent virtually no risk to citizens and property. ing workers in bargaining with their em crime. He proposed the enactment of ployers; and the Law Enforcement Assistance Act of Certainly if prisoners can be trusted at Whereas labor unions are generally ren 1965 which among other things would the open camps that I have seen in Ari dered less effective in promoting the welfare authorize a search for ways of making zona and the completely open institu of wage earners, and wages and working con the correctional process more effective. tion near Dallas, Tex., they can be se ditions are generally lower in States having He also established the President's Com lected with similarly skilled analysis for right-to-work laws than in States where such mission on Law Enforcement and Ad assignment to community-oriented pro laws exist; and ministration of Justice, charging this grams. Whereas successful implementation of the national labor policy in support of union or body with finding the answers to a num The bill will provide desirable :flexibil ganization and collective bargaining is not ber of specific questions relating to the ity that will greatly assist the Federal possible unless unions and union security are crime problem. One of these questions Bureau of Prisons in its mission of in accepted by management as '1esirable forms was: "What correctional programs are mate rehabilitation. of industrial dealings: Now, therefore, be it most promising in preventing a first of Mr. President, I introduce for appro Resolved, That the City Council of Gary, fense from leading to a career in crime?" priate reference, on behalf of myself and Ind., urgently requests that the Congress of T:tie Judiciary Committee's Subcom the Senator from Nebraska [Mr. the United States enact such legislation as may be necessary and appropriate to repeal mittee on National Penitentiaries, of HRUSKA] a bill to amend section 4082 of section 14(b) of the National Labor Relations which I am chairman, has long been con title 18, United States Code, to facili Act, as amended, and section 705(b) of the cerned by the need for improvements in tate the rehabilitation of persons con Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure the correctional process. Our inspec victed of offenses against the United Act of 1959, which sanction State right-to tions of Federal facilities over the years States. I ask unanimous consent that work laws, and to restore full freedom of col has indicated that if we are more effec the bill be held at the desk until April lective bargaining as uniform national labor tively to salvage the off ender we must 30 so othet Senators may join as co policy and practice throughout the United sponsors. I also ask unanimous consent States; and be it further provide a wider range of facilities and Resolved, That copies of these resolutions more flexible procedures for their cor that the bill be printed at this point in be sent forthwith by the clerk of the city of rectional treatment. Our report of Feb the RECORD. Gary to the President and Vice President of ruary 27, 1964, requested that the At The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. Moss the United States, to the Speaker of the torney General give study to several in the chair). The bill will be received House of Representatives of the Congress, and suggestions that came up in our January and appropriately referred; and, without to the Senators and Representatives repre hearings. It also expressed the inten objection, the bill will be printed in the senting their State in the Congress of the RECORD and held at the desk, as requested United States. tion of the subcommittee to develop leg Adopted by the common council this 16th islation which would adapt the Huber by the Senator from Missouri. of March 1965. law principle to the Federal jurisdiction The bill (S. 1808) to amend section LOUIS G. KARRAS, and extend the halfway house idea to se 4082 of title 18, United States Code, to Presiding Officer. lected adult prisoners. facilitate the rehabilitation of persons Attest: Recently the Attorney General trans convicted of offenses against the United BETTY MALINKA, mitted to Congress· such a measure. It States, introduced by Mr. LONG of Mis City Clerk. is my pleasure to join with the distin Approved and signed by me this 19th day souri (for himself and Mr. HRUSKA) was of March 1965. guished Senator from Nebraska [Mr. received, read twice by its title, ref~rred A. MARTIN KATZ, Mayor. HRUSKA] in introducing the bill. to the Committee on the Judiciary, and The proposal provides a plan under ordered to be printed in the RECORD, as which selected Federal prisoners may follows: BILLS INTRODUCED work at paid employment or undertake Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Bills were introduced, read the first training courses in nearby communities, Representatives of the United States of time, and, by unanimous consent, the each day leaving from and returning to America in Congress assembled, That section second time, and referred as follows: the institutions in which they are serv 4082 of title 18, United States Code, is ing sentences. The prisoners given this amended to read: By Mr. LONG of Missouri (for him privilege would be chosen from those "§ 4082. Commitment to Attorney General; self and Mr. HRUSKA) : residential treatment centers; extension of S. 1808. A bill to amend section 4082 of who are considered to be trustworthy limits of confinement; work furlough. title 18, United States Code, to facilitate the and who can be expected to benefit from "(a) A person convicted of an offense rehabilitation of persons convicted of of the program. This so-called work-re against the United States shall be committed, fenses against the United States; to the lease plan has been adopted in various Committee on the Judiciary. for such term of imprisonment as the court forms by 17 States and has proven suc may direct, to the custody of the Attorney ( See the remarks of Mr. LONG of Missouri cessful. It promotes rehabilitation, when he introduced the above bill, which General of the United States, who shall desig appear under a separate heading.) enables prisoners to continue supporting nate the place of confinement where the sen- By Mr. McCLELLAN: families, and reduces costs of imprison tence shall be served. • S. 1809. A bill to establish a uniform na ment. It should be made available for "(b) The Attorney General may designate tional policy concerning property rights 1n application to Federal prisoners. as a place of confinement any available. 8332 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 suitable, and appropriate institution or fa oners to residential community treat way house concept in the Federal prison cility, whether maintained by the Federal ment centers, or more commonly called system. Government or otherwise, and whether halfway houses. Mr. President, I aslk unanimous con within or without the judicial district in sent that the speech be placed in the which the person was convicted, and may at Second. The Attorney General could any time transfer a person from one place of grant brief periods of leave under emer RECORD at the conclusion of my remarks. confinement to another. gency conditions or for purposes related The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without " ( c) The Attorney General may extend the to release preparation. objection it is so ordered. limits of the place of confinement of a pris Third. Finally, the Attorney General (See exhibit 1.) oner as to whom there is reasonable cause to would be able to permit prisoners to work REHABILITATION LEAVE believe he will honor his trust, by authoriz ing him, under prescribed conditions, to: in private employment or to participate Mr. HRUSKA. The second major pro " ( 1) visit a specifically designated place or in community training programs while vision of this bill has to do with emer places for a period not to exceed thirty days continuing as inmates in the institution gency or rehabilitation leave. It also is and return to the same or another institution to which they have been committed. not a new concept, having been incorpo or facility. An extension of limits may be Now, ·1 would like to comment on the rated into the prison systems of at least granted only to permit a visit to a dying rela three major provisions briefly: 10 States and several European nations. tive, attendance at the funeral of a relative, TO EXPAND A TRIED CONCEPT As with the halfway house, the leave con the obtaining of medical services not other wise available, the contacting of prospective First. The bill grants authority to ex cept has already found its way into the employers, or for any other compelling reason pand the halfway house concept. It Federal system under the Federal Youth consistent with the public interest; or now applies to juvenile and youthful of Corrections Act and the Federal Juvenile "(2) work at paid employment or partici f enders in the Federal correctional sys Delinquency Act. pate in a training program in the community tem. This idea ought to be extended to It may be that the emergency leave or voluntarily serve a public or nonprofit more mature offenders who, in the opin provision of the bill can be demonstrated agency, while continuing as a prisoner of the ion of the Federal authorities, should be to be a valuable tool. Our subcommittee institution or facility to which he is will want to examine this concept in de committed. given partial correctional treatment in "(d) The willful failure of a prisoner to re a wholesome community setting. Re tail in its deliberations on the bill. main within the extended limits of his con gardless of the efficiency and humanity The work release provision of the bill finement, or to return within the time pre with which a Federal correctional insti would greatly enhance the resources scribed to an institution or facility desig tution may be administered, the daily available to the Federal institutions. nated by the Attorney General, shall be life there is much different than that of Like Senator LONG, I feel that the super deemed an escape from the custody of the the free community or the free world as visory personnel of the Federal system Attorney General punishable as provided in the inmates term it. The contrast is in have the technical know-how and judg chapter 35 of this title. herent and largely unavoidable. The re ment to use these additional resources "(e) The authority conferred upon the At with the welfare of the public uppermost torney General by this section shall extend sult too often · is that when a prisoner to all persons committed to the National has finished his sentence or is paroled, in mind. This has already been demon Training School for Boys. his abrupt release to the community im strated by the experimental application "(f) As used in this section: The term mediately confronts him with an array of work-release procedures to juvenile 'facility' shall include a residential com of problems that often comes as a severe and youthful offenders. But two-thirds munity treatment center: and the term shock and tends to overwhelm him: ·If of the prisoners released from Federal 'relative' shall mean a spouse, child (includ part of his correctional treatment could institutions are over 25 years of age. We ing stepchild, adopted child or child as to be undertaken in the community, or if should not overlook any plan that prom whom the prisoner, though not a natural ises to create more rehabilitative oppor parent, has acted in the place of a parent), he could be gradually reintroduced to parent (including a person who, though not community living, some of these prob tunities for them. a natural parent, has acted in the place of a lems could be resolved and he could be STATE EXPERIENCE parent), brother or sister." • adjusted to others in such a way that he The work release concept has been SEC. 2. The chapter analysis of section 4082 could not panic and revert to undesirable tried in many States and has proved to of title 18, United States Code, is amended ways. be a valuable penological tool. Started to read: "SEC. 4082. Commitment to Attorney Gen The problems of a released inmate are in the State of Wisconsin in 1913 with eral; residential treatment centers; extension many. He needs to find a job. He needs the enactment of the first Huber law, it of limits of confinement; work furlough." ·a place to live. He needs clothing and he has now spread to at least 16 other SEC. 3. Sections 751 and 752 of title 18, needs food. In many instances he needs States. An excellent article on "Work United States Code, are amended by insert to find a way to become reassimilated as Release in the United States" appeared ing the words "or facility" following the word a member of a family that has closed in the Journal of Criminal Law, Crimi 0 institution". ranks while he was gone. He also faces nology and Police Science recently. Mr. HRUSKA. Mr. President, I wish the plight imposed upon him by his sta Written by Stanley E. Grupp for the to join the subcommittee chairman, the tus as an ex-convict. These are all basic September 1963 edition of that journal, Senator from Missouri [Mr. LONG] in and crucial problems that really must be the article outlines the concept in detail sponsoring the bill that he has just out resolved in the community. The author and summarizes State experience with it. lined. Over the several years that I have ity provided by this bill would give the Mr. President, I ask unanimous con been a member of the National Peniten Federal prison system some means to sent that the article be placed in the tiaries Subcommittee I have been priv deal directly with them. RECORD at the conclusion of my remarks. ileged to visit most of the facilities of The halfway house concept has been The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without the Federal prison system. These visits tried out for almost 4 years in the Fed objection, it is so ordered. have convinced me that the system op eral prison system for juvenile and All the way to Columbus I sat built a kitchen and dining room area. up their basic feelings of inadequacy and in the back with my hand over my eyes." Another guidance center was opened dur anxiety. Just before I came up here Miss Bowman, ing January of this year in Detroit. This Jack was about as seriously handicapped our superintendent at Alderson, sent me a center is unique in that it is a joint opera a boy as we ever had to take over from other letter she had received from an 18-year-old tion involving the Federal Bureau of Prisons agencies. Coming as he did from a home girl who had been discharged to a remotely and the Michigan Department of Corrections. broken by alcoholism and poverty no one related aunt. She had no family worthy of We have leased a building similar to the one much cared what happened to him when he the name, no friends, just nothing. She was we use in Los Angeles. One of the staff lost the use of his arms and shoulders due begging Miss Bowman and her cottage offi members in Detroit is an employee of the to infantile paralysis. Among the almost in· cer to write her. She said she was going to Michigan Department of Corrections while numerable operations he had had was a 8334 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 facial transplant. He became rebellious and human values as well. No better way to ful must be said that savings in cost of prisoners' hostile and of course used his handicaps as fill this responsibility can be found, I believe, board in jail and in public relief for their im a crutch and excuse for stealing and forgery. than through establishing a halfway house poverished families have proved greater in Finally, of course, he was committed and we for women here in Boston where so many ducements to apply the law." Be this as it tried to help him at our medical center pioneering and rewarding experiments in hu may, wisely administered, the program serves without too much success. We decided, how man betterment were undertaken. I wish sound objectives of sentencing and correc ever, to try him at our Los Angeles guidance you well and pledge my assistance. tion. center. At first he gave us a pretty hard 'IMPLEM!ENTATION time. But later he changed and one day he EXHIBIT 2 Those interested in the expansion of work said to his counselor, "I like this center. I WORK RELEASE IN THE UNITED STATES release legislation should not be content with have lived in orphans homes, in foster (By Stanley E. Grupp.) statutory enactments alone. An unused work homes, with relatives and there was no feel release law is of no value. Information re ing for me at all. Now, I finally am home (NoTE.-The author is assistant professor garding current implementation of work re and found that there are people who really of sociology in the Department of Social Sci lease statutes is incomplete. Wisconsin ap care." ences of the Illinois State Normal University. pears to be the only State with relatively in This change came when we finally got him He received the M.A. degree from the Uni clusive statewide data concerning the extent a job in a photographic studio. This turned versity of Iowa. Professor Grupp's publica to which work release sentencing is utilized. out to be Jack's dish. He really liked the tions include articles in the fields of anthro Data from most of the other States is either work, developed some real talent, and now we pology, penology, and criminology. spotty or nonexistent, probably because the think he's on the high road to success, and {What are the objectives of a work release program is usually administered on a county incidentally, having married and become a program? What are the comparative merits basis, because there is no central data col father, and continuing to earn something of the various types of work release legisla lecting agency, and undoubtedly because the over $400 a month. He goes back to the tion? What are the major difficulties en laws are new. Hopefully, more data will be center occasionally and tells the other boys countered in implementation of work release? available in the years to come. Minnesota, the joys of being a square. And how does work release measure up to for example, has recently passed legislation It is a little too early to make a conclusive society's requirements for effective penal requiring that counties make annual reports evaluation of our experience but everything sanctions? In the following article, Professor to the department of corrections. seems to indicate the guidance centers have Grupp considers these and other questions Available evidence indicates that work re been most helpful. The Brooklyn guidance growing out of the increasing use of work lease is applied most extensively in Wiscon center has had 88 residents of whom 45 have release in U.S. penological practice.-EDITOR.) sin, California, and North Carolina. It will been discharged and up to now have not re In U.S. penological practice, the work re be noted that these States are among those lapsed. Eighteen we found were not yet lease program is well underway. Inaugurated with the longest experience with the law. ready for release and have been returned for in 1913 by Wisconsin's Huber law, the accept Not all of the 71 Wisconsin counties make further training at an institution. Please do ance and expansion of work release has use of the Huber law. Available informa not conclude this group committed another gained momentum in recent years. Cer tion is summarized in the accompanying offense. They did not. We felt that they tainly we have moved too slowly in applying table. Though use of work release varies needed a little more training, or psycho sound penological practices to the misde considerably from county to county, state therapy or to complete some vocational meanant problem. Thus, the growth of work wide statistics indicate that in 1956 and 1960, course. We know of only two who have ac release programs is encouraging to penolo "Huberites" comprised 35 and 33 percent, tually committed another offense. However gists and enlightened citizenry alike. respectively, of the total Wisconsin county you figure it, this has been a pretty good Under the typical work release program, the jail population. Sanger Powers hopefully record if you remember that almost half of prisoner is employed outside the jail during predicts the day when they will comprise 60 those who are discharged without guidance working hours and returns to the jail at the to 70 percent thereof. get into trouble again before their parole close of his workday. His wages go directly Commitment under the Huber law does period expires. to the program's administrator, who is re Now what we can do with young men can not ipso facto assure employment for the sponsible for the allocation thereof. In some prisoner. And we may assume that a com also be done I am sure with women. As a States provision may also be made for the matter of fact, I think the need is even great parable situation exists under work release prisoner to attend school and church, as laws in other States. The problems of secur er for women. To be sure there are relatively well as activities such as union and Alcoholics much fewer women in prison than men but ing employment will be discussed below. In Anonymous meetings. Work release is gen 1960, 71 percent of the Huber prisoners were . their problems of community adjustment are erally limited to misdemeanants, but North more serious. Many of them have been re employed. Urban counties of 100,000 and Carolina has led the way in applying the over accounted for 82 percent of the em jected by their families and friends, if they program to felons with sentences up to 5 ever had any. There are fewer job oppor ployed Huberites. In the words of the Wis years, and Maryland has recently authorized consin report, 1960, "Over half * * * of the tunities available to them. Many are not a similar program. acceptable as marriage partners by any self Huber law sentences were in Milwaukee and At least 17 States currently have laws for Dane Counties and well over half * * * respecting man because of the kind of sex mally providing for the work release sentence. lives they have lived. I have noticed, too, prisoners actually employed u nder the law In addition to Wisconsin (1913) these are: were from the same two counties, which that proportionately they have more mental West Virginia {1917), Virginia (1956), Cali and physical handicaps. comprise less than one-third of the State's All of this clearly means that women are fornia (1957), Idaho (1957), North Carolina population." It is clear that sentencing un (1957), Minnesota (1957), North Dakota der the Huber law occurs principally in the in greater need of help if they are to over come their handicaps, their fears and the (1957), Wyoming (1957), Montana (1959), large urban centers. urge for the one big night they have been Oregon (1959) , Illinois (1959), Washington Wisconsin counties reporting use of the dreaming about as one dreary day followed (1961), Missouri (1961), Michigan (1962), Huber law Maryland {1963), and Indiana (1963). Dates another. I do not need in this presence, I Number of am sure, to illustrate these understandable in parentheses indicate the first year work re counties temptations or cite particular cases. You lease sentences were formally provided by 1914 ______28 know them. You also know that in the case statute in the respective States. Clearly the 1939 ______11 of many female offenders their basic problem development has come in the last 7 years. 1956 ______50 is some social inadequacy. They are the fe In addition, in a number of jurisdictions 1960 ______52 male alcoholics, sex deviates, mental defec apparently some use is made of work release tives, and the physically unfit. These are the without any formal legislative sanction. This Work release in California, as promulgated grist of our women's institutions. They need practice contains built-in limitations, since it under the work furlough rehabilitation law help and help not of the prayerful go-thou expands responsibilities beyond the formal of 1957, section 1208 of the Penal Code of and-sin-no-more type but practical, down to legislative specifications. Nevertheless, it ap California, requires an ordinance by the earth aid, support, and guidance. A decent pears that some judges have undertaken to county board of supervision for full im meal, a clean bed, and new hairdo or brassiere impose work release sentences on their own plementation. The law of 1957 was ante could make a world of difference. And they initiative. dated by experiments in Fresno and Santa need all these at the peril point which is OBJECTIVES Clara· Counties. The work of these counties when they are ready for release. The major objectives of work release are was briefly reported in the 1957 California It's all very well to seek that support rehabilitation of the offender and provision State report, "The County Jails of Califor through volunteers. Many of these whom I for the support of both the prisoner and his nia: An Evaluation,'' which re·commended personally know have done magnificent bits family. It may well be that the interests of passage of a work release law. Work release of personal charity that way but after awhile economy have served as the major impetus to programs are currently underway in Marin, they get tired or something else attracts their the inauguration of work release laws. The Del Norte, Orange, Santa Clara, and Stanis energies. evidence indicates that the State is saved laus Counties; and one is now being estab Sincere volunteers can always be useful literally thousands of dollars. Work release lished in San Mateo. but after all reintegrating hard cases of the costs only a fraction of the amount required North Carolina's program, as mentioned kind I have in mind into the community is a to maintain a prisoner full time in the county above, includes felons with sentences up to public responsibility. Discharging it fully jail. The Wisconsin Service Association has 5 years. Work release applies to the entire pays large dividends in crime prevention and stated, for example, "But in all candor it State, and the prison department is em- April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-·SENATE 8335 powered by statute to establish programs value because it keeps them occupied and ministrator may be exposed to undue polit where the need exists. On May 9, 1962, there we also find work for individuals who could ical pressure. The best administrator may were 179 misdemeanants and 22 felons in the not find work themselves." well be a civil service appointee, who is rela program. Most other work release States appear to tively removed from potential political pres SELECTION AND EMPLOYMENT make at best a moderate effort. North Car sures, possibly one with social work training olina does not usually try to find employ Careful selection of work release partici and one who can work closely with the ment, but the door is kept open for includ sheriff's office. In two California counties, pants is imperative. There is general agree ing those inmates who, though not sen ment that work release is most appropriately Marin and Orange, probation officers serve tenced to the program, are somehow able to as work release administrators. In California used for certain classes of offenders. Among find employment after commitment. these are nonsupport cases, traffic offenders, the county board of supervisors is required In a number of work release States, the by statute to prescribe whether the proba selected check offenders, and individuals for inmate may seek employment. Wisconsin, whom alcohol is a problem-though the lat tion officer or the sheriff is to perform the Michigan, and Maryland allow the prisoner function of administrator-a wise policy in ter undoubtedly call for special considera to leave jail to seek employment for himself. tion. Certainly the individuals selected that it provides for an appropriate considera Section 36.63.260 of the Revised Code of tion of factors peculiar to the given com should possess sufficient stability not to pose Washington, 1961, provides for the continu a security problem. munity. As a result, small counties may be ation of regular employment, but also speci able to adopt a work release program which In no instances should such objectives as fies that the court "may authorize the sheriff the relief of overcrowding in the jail be the would not otherwise be possible under rigid or other appropriate officer to make every State requirements. The requirement of a major consideration in the program. Fur effort to secure some suitable employment or ther officials responsible for selecting, find full-time administrator, for example, would may authorize the person to secure employ be out of the question for small counties. ing ~mployment for, and supervising the work ment for himself in the county." Idaho, release prisoners should not be subject to It is noteworthy here that the statewide sys Minnesota, Missouri, and Oregon have simi tem in North Carolina seems to be moving political or other pressures either fro?? pris lar statutory provisions. oners with "influence" or from potential em along quite well. As we move toward in The Montana and Wyoming statutes make creasing cooperation between counties, an ployers. At its worst, work release can be express provision for the continuation of a means of prisoner exploitation whereby per inter-county administration system may be regular employment, but fail to say anything worthy of experimentation in other States sonal friends of the work release administra about finding jobs for the unemployed. tive personnel are provided with cheap labor. as well. The Virginia Code similarly applies to those Should separate jail facilities be provided A statutory provision requiring employment "regularly employed." at the prevailing wage for similar work may for work release prisoners? Positions on this Limiting work release to those already question vary; most, however, see an impera be of some help. California and Oregon have having employment is a questionable policy. such provisions. tive need for separate housing. The Wiscon It may tend to include only the best risks, sin Service Association, while recognizing the At the same time the implementa ticn of ease administration, and minimize costs. At work release must be realistic and bear a confronting difficulties, takes a definite stand the same time, it probably excludes those in favor of separate facilities. Certainly work reasonable relationship to the prevailing eco who have the most to gain from a well con nomic conditions of the community. In our releases do not require traditional confine trived and well implemented program. If ment, and separate facilities help to reduce desire to implement the sound objectives of the objectives of work release are to be at the program, care must be taken not to be so the need for security safeguards made neces tained, every reasonable effort should be sary by intermingling the two groups of zealous that we deprive law-abiding citizens made to secure work for the work release in of employment. But it would be absurd to mate without a job. In those States where prisoners. But need the implementation of wait un~ all law-abiding citizens have jobs. either sta tute or practice excludes the in work release necessarily await separate hous The work release program must stand on its mate without employment at the time of ing facilities? It is the feeling of this writer own merits. This of course is but one of sentencing, serious consideration should be that a county need not await the ideal to im the many problems in the art of punishment. given to a change of policy. plement the law. The decision must be made What type of work do work release pris at the local level and take into account the One further consideration must be men existing jail facilities as well as the availabil oners do? Among those jobs commonly men tioned in connection with the Stat.e's effort tioned are positions as laborer, salesman, ity of the personnel necessary to carry out the to secure employment for the work release .Program. painter, construction worker, and gas sta inmate. If sentences under work release tion attendant. Under the Wisconsin pro are too short, the expenditure of time, effort, These are but several of the many prob gram, in addition to the more usual types and money made in seeking employment may lems encountered in the implementation of of employment, the prisoner may leave jail be unjustified. As we become more "work work release programs. Other problems in to conduct his own business, to obtain medi release-minded," we must recognize the need clude the extensive bookkeeping necessary in cal treatment, to attend school, and, if the for intensified scrutiny of our sentencing collecting and disbursing the inmate's wages, prisoner is a woman, to attend to housekeep policies. This is but another of the prob the development of a standardized basis of ing tasks. lems in balancing the interests of the in recordkeeping, the development of reciprocal In most jurisdictions work release author dividual with those of society, an endless provisions between counties, the education of ization is in the hands of the court, which road in the implementation of punishment. the public to the advantages of the program, in some jurisdictions must act in conjunc and the provision of adequate casework serv tion with the sheriff, the State's attorney, or SPECIAL PROBLEMS ices in helping both the prisoner and his both. In North Carolina the parole board, Administrative duties, recordkeeping, family. too, may authorize work release assignments. checking prisoners in and out, job finding, WORK RELEASE AND PUNISHMENT Of the 222 participating inmates on May 9, et cetera, encumbent upon already over 1962, 96 were recommended by the courts and burdened offices, rank high in the list of so Cursory observation reveals the potential 126 by the parole board. called disadvantages of work release pro advantages of work release. Further inspec tion suggests that work release may be one of Information from Wisconsin and North grams. In 1956 and 1960, Wisconsin sheriffs ranked "lack of personnel" among the im the more fruitful methods of implementing Carolina suggests that work release prisoners the integrative or inclusive theory of pun are apt to be those inma tes who had employ portant reasons for the limited use of the law. In most work release States, the ad ishment. The integrative theory recognizes ment at the time of sentencing. In 1960 that in the punishment of the criminal, so many of the Huberites continued with their ministrative burden falls on the sheriff. It is unwise to burden the office of sheriff with ciety demands the fulfillment of a number of usual employment. The same pattern pre functions; namely, deterrence, rehabilitation vails in North Carolina. The statute as in the multiple work release administrative and retribution; further, this position main terpreted by the North Caro.Una Prison De duties without providing him with adequate personnel to do the job. Too, it may be tains that under sound penal-correctional partment is "primarily set up for those in practice, it is both necessary and possible to mates who have employment with a reputable that the administrative and supervisory work toward the fulfillment of these mul firm or person who is willing to continue him duties inherent in the work release program on the job under this plan." call for specialized skills that we cannot tiple functions. Attention will now be given legitimately expect of the sheriff. This is to work release viewed within this context. States vary in their efforts to find employ The rehabilitative function as well as the ment for the work release inmate. Wiscon not to imply a lack of confidence in the sheriff nor to suggest that his role is in pecuniary advantages of the program have sin illustrates an active effort on the part of been discussed elsewhere. Of major impor the State. Wisconsin law requires the sher herently inconsistent with the requisite re habilitative orientation. But in relatively tance is the fact that the prisoner is able to iff to seek employment for work release pris retain some degree of self-respect because he oners. In 1960 the sheriff's offices of 29 coun large counties an ext.ensive and well con ties helped in finding jobs for at least some ceived program calls for a full-time work re remains a self-supporting and contributing prisoners. Conscientious implementation of lease administrator. Since work releasers are member of society. The implications of these this law requires the sheriff and his staff to prisoners, a "work-release-minded" deputy values alone make the program worthwhile be what Sheriff Hass of Dane County has sheriff might be the logical person for this in terms of the rehabilitative function of termed "Huber-law-minded." With regard position. punishment. to his office's function in finding jobs, Sher At the same time there seems to be merit In addition, work release informs the of iff Hass says, "We • • • keep up the solicit in the position that the administrative re fenders that the community means busi ing of jobs every day so that ls the reason sponsib1lities of work release should be re ness. The nights and weekends in the cell for • • • success. It has. great therapeutic moved from political offices, where the ad- provide ample opportunity for penitence and 8336 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 self-castigation while also helping meet the suggestions as to how the bill could be The bill (S. 1810) to amend section public's demand that prisoners not be cod 1mprovedw A number of constructive 1498 of title 28, United States Code, to dled. and that they receive their just de comments were submitted and these define the word "owner," introduced by sert. Clearly, work release prisoners bear have all been given the most careful Mr. McCLELLAN, by request, was received, the stigma of the criminal label. Viewed in terms of retribution, when it is remembered study. read twice by its title, and referred to the that most work release inmates are misde After the introduction of my bill, the Committee on the Judiciary. meanants, the work release sentence is late President John F. Kennedy, on Oc The letter presented by Mr. McCLEL sound. tober 10, 1963, issued a memorandum of LAN is as follows: The deterrent function also appears to be Government patent policy. I stated in OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, served by the work release sentence. Bear the Senate on October 15, 1963, that I Washington, D.O., January 26, 1965. ing more stigma than probation and involv regarded President Kennedy's state The VICE PRESIDENT, ing additional punishment in that the indi ment as a constructive contribution U.S. Senate, Washington, D.O. vidual is removed from society for the greater which would be of considerable assist DEAR MR. VICE PRESIDENT: There is at portion of the week, such a sentence should ance to the Congress, but that the need tached. for your consideration and appropri well be sufficient to cause the potential re ate reference a draft bill "To amend section peater to think twice. for legislation persisted. I believe sub 1498 of title 28, United States Code, to define Viewed within the context of the integra sequent events have amply confirmed the word 'owner'." A somewhat similar bill tive theory of punishment, work release pro the desirability of Congress finally re was submitted in the 88th Congress and in grams are worthy of serious exploration: solving this matter by the enactment of troduced as S. 1655 but received no action. CONCLUSION general Government patent policy Subsection (a) of section 1498 of title 28, legislation. United States Code, provides for suit against What does the future hold for work re the United States by the owner of a patent lease? Work release is sound penology, and The most significant revision of my earlier bill concerns the procedures gov used or manufactured. by or for the United it is heartening to observe evidences of grow States without license of the owner. Be ing interest in the program. Maryland and erning the determination of patent cause of the lack of a statutory definition Indiana have recently passed work release rights as between the Government and of the word "owner" as used in section 1498, laws, and work release bills were introduced the contractor. S. 1290 precluded final there has been considerable litigation in the in the recent sessions of the Florida and determinations being made until the Court of Claims as to the meaning of that Iowa Legislatures. Recently the Cook Coun inventions were actually disclosed. The term. In comparatively recent decisions that ty, Ill., chapter of the League of Wom revised bill, while containing adequate court, which has exclusive jurisdiction of en Voters has become interested in work re suits under the section, has interpreted lease. On May 14, 1962, E. H. Shomo, CBS safeguards to protect the public inter Radio vice president and general manager est, affords greater flexibility as to the "owner" to include licensees who held no of WBBM radio, Chicago, spoke in favor of time when the determination of owner legal title interest in the patents alleged to implementing a work release program in Il ship rights may be made. have been infringed. In some of such cases linois. The National Jail Association at a the owners have voluntarily joined the I am sure that further improvements licensees as plaintiffs, while in other cases regional forum in Sioux City, Iowa, in 1962, may be made in the bill, and I once gave attention to the subject. These con the court has permitted. licensees to main crete examples of interest in work release again invite those who have an interest tain suits by including the names of the are encouraging, and there are undoubtedly in this matter to communicate to me owners of the patents as joint plaintiffs, more. Hopefully, this growing interest will their views and any proposed amend without their consent. We are concerned that this will open the door to multiple suits continue to result in both new State statutes ments. by multiple licensees under the same patent and greater use of existing provisions. The PRESIDING OFFICER. The for the same alleged infringement. bill will be received and appropriately Permitting suits by licensees having no referred. legal title interest in a patent is contrary GOVERNMENT PATENT POLICY The bill (S. 1809) to establish a uni not only to the uniform decisions of the Mr. McCLELLAN. Mr. President, I form national policy concerning prop Supreme Court interpreting the language of introduce, for appropriate reference, a erty rights in inventions made through the section, but also to the intention of the bill to establish a uniform national pol the expenditure of public funds, and for Congress when it enacted the statute. In other purposes, introduced by Mr. Mc the congressional proceedings on the original icy concerning property rights in inven act of June 25, 1910, it was stated that the tions made through the expenditure of CLELLAN, was received, read twice by its measure was intended to waive sovereign public funds, and for other purposes. title, and referred to the Committee on immunity as to, and provide a remedy for, The subcommittee on Patents, Trade the Judiciary. only the owners of patents, and also that marks, and Copyrights, of which I am the b111 was not intended to permit suits chairman, of the Committee on the Ju by licensees under the patents (H. Rept. No. diciary has been engaged for some time AMENDMENT OF SECTION 1498 OF 1288, 61st Cong.; 45 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD in a study of the patent policies and TITLE 28, UNITED STATES CODE, 8755-8785) . practices of the various Government TO DEFINE THE WORD "OWNER" The draft bill would amend subsection (a) of section 1498 to define the word "owner" departments and agencies. The sub Mr. McCLELLAN. Mr. President, by to mean the person who, at the time of the committee has given particular atten request, I introduce, for appropriate ref alleged use or manufacture, held legal title tion to the equitable allocation of pat erence, a bill to amend section 1498 of to the whole patent or an undivided part or ent rights in inventions arising from title 28, United States Code, to define the share of the whole patent throughout the Government-:flnanced research and de word "owner." United States, or to the whole patent within, velopment contracts. In recent years the This proposed legislation is being intro and throughout a specified geographic part Congress has frequently considered the duced at the request of the Department of the United States. Also, the amendment inclusion of patent provisions in legisla would provide that legal title comprises the of Justice. According to the Attorney right to exclude others from making, using, or tion authorizing new Government re General, the purpose of this bill is to per selling the invention throughout the United search programs. It is clearly the in mit only the "owner" of a patent as de States or any specified part of the United tent of Congress that the basic fined by the Supreme Court to bring suit States. This amendment adopts the defini guidelines of Government patent policy under section 1498. During the 88th tion given by the Supreme Court in Water should be determined by the Congress. Congress, at the request of the Depart man v. Mackenzie, 138 U.S. 252, 255-256; However, the preferred method of ac ment of Justice, I introduced a somewhat Crown Co. v. Nye Tool Works, 261 U.S. 24, complishing this objective is by the similar bill, S. 1655, but no action was 40-41, and other cases cited in those enactment of a comprehensive bill taken on the measure. decisions. rather than by individual amendments The Bureau of the Budget has advised I ask unanimous consent that a letter that there is no objection to the submission to every bill authorizing Government addressed to the Vice President from the of this recommendation from the standpoint research programs. Office of the Attorney General, which of the administration's program. In an effort to make a contribution to sets forth additional justification and Sincerely, a reasonable solution of this complex background on the proposed legislation, NICHOLAS DEB. KATZENBACH, question, I introduced during the 88th be printed in the RECORD at this point as Acting Attorney General. Congress, S. 1290. I then indicated that part of my remarks. while I believed the bill reflected a sound The PRESIDING OFFICER. The approach, it was not the definitive ex bill will be received and appropriately ADDITIONAL COSPONSORS OF BILLS .pression of my views. I accordingly referred; and, without objection, the let Mr. LONG of Missouri. Mr. Presi invited all interested parties to make ter will be printed In the RBcou. dent, on April 9, 1965, I introduced a bill April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8337 (S. 1758), which was cosponsored by sev NOTICE OF HEARINGS ON TITLES II taken to effectively solve this Nation's eral other Senators, to provide for the AND IV OF THE PUBLIC WORKS payments deficit. Our able colleague, right of persons to be represented by at AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT the Senator from Louisiana [Mr. LONG], torneys in matters before Federal agen ACT and others, told the Senate of the role cies. that excessive petroleum imports has · I ask unanimous consent that at its Mr. DOUGLAS. Mr. President, I played over the years in contributing to next printing the names of the senior should like to announce that the Pro our payments deficit. I wish to associate Senator from Mississippi [Mr. EASTLAND] duction and Stabilization Subcommit myself with Senator LONG'S recom and the senior Senator from Nebraska tee of the Senate Banking and Currency mended solutions pertaining to petroleum [Mr. HRUSKA] be added as cosponsors. Committee will begin hearings on titles imports and military purchases of for The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without II and IV of S. 1648, the Public Works eign petroleum. I am particularly con objection, it is so ordered. and Economic Development Act, on cerned over the 35,000 barrels of un Mr. HARTKE. Mr. President, on Tuesday, May 4, 1965. This bill has _been needed light petroleum products brought March 18 I introduced again my bill referred to the Public Works Committee. into the United States each day for the calling for a reinsurance program for However, titles II and IV of S. 1648 are use by the military. I am at a loss to un similar to provisions of the Area Re derstand how the Department of De private pension funds, in order to pre development Act, which has been con vent the loss to employees which is in fense, in spite of Presidential directives sidered on previous occasions by the to do otherwise, has seen flt over the volved when such an event as the clos Banking and Currency Committee; ing of a company or plant occurs. I years to increase its petroleum purchases am pleased that Congressman JOHN therefore, the chairman of the Public abroad. We can hardly ask our business Works Committee has requested that community and our fellow citizens to BRADEMAS, of Indiana's Third Dist~ct, the Banking and Currency Committee whose home is in South Bend, has ii:i voluntarily restrain themselves from informally review these titles and advise spending dollars abroad when the De troduced a parallel bill, H.R. 6944, m the Public Works Committee of the the House. I am also pleased that the partment of Defense completely ignores Banking and Currency Committee's governmental appeals and Presidential Senator from Washington [Mr. MAG views on these titles of S. 1648. NUSON J has expressed his desire to directives to reduce its purchases of for associate himself with this bill. There The hearings by the Production and eign goods such as petroleum. fore I ask unanimous consent that his Stabilization Subcommittee will begin at Mr. President, I am hopeful that those name may be added to the bill, S. 1575, .10 a.m., on Tuesday, May 4, and will charged with military procurement will at its next printing. continue, if necessary, through May 7. not take lightly what has been said in The PRESIDING OFFICER. With Persons wishing to testify on titles II this :floor discussion of the important out objection, it is so ordered. and IV should contact Mr. Jonathan matter. Mr. MONDALE. Mr. President, I ask Lindley, Senate Banking and Currency I can state emphatically that this Na unanimous consent that at the next Committee, 5300 New Senate Office tion's small independent oil producers printing of S. 1793, a bill to amend the Building, Washington, D.C., 20510. are in real trouble. However, I would Federal Disaster Act, that the names of Telephone: 225-3921. like to confl.ne my remarks to the eco the distinguished Senators from Wiscon nomic position of independent producers sin [Mr. PROXMIRE and Mr. NELSON] be OIL IMPORTS in my own State of Kansas. Kansas has added as cosponsors of that bill. been a leading petroleum producer for The PRESIDING OFFICER. With Mr. CARLSON. Mr. President, yester many, many years. In 1956, in the year out objection, it is so ordered. day the distinguished Senator from of the Suez crisis, my State was produc Mr. TYDINGS. Mr. President, on b~ Louisiana [Mr. LONG] and other Members ing 340 ,000 barrels of crude oil eac day. half of the senior Senator from Connecti of the Senate discussed at some length Last year daily production of crude oil cut [Mr. Donn], I ask unanimous con the. affect of oil imports and military in Kansas had dropped 50,000 barrels per sent that at the next printing, the name purchases on our balance of payments. day or 14 percent less than in 1956. This of the distinguished Senator from Illi I regret sincerely that I was unable to is a reduction of more than $50 million nois [Mr. DOUGLAS] be added as a co be present in the Senate at the time this annually in the dollars :flowing into the sponsor of s. 1591, a bill to amend the discussion took place, as I would have economy of my State. Instead of these National Firearms Act, and S. 1592, a liked to have expressed my views on it dollars :flowing into Kansas, they have bill to amend the Federal Firearms Act. at that time. _ gone overseas. While production in The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without Balance of payments is a problem that Kansas since 1956 has been reduced 14 objection, it is so ordered. · we must face realistically. percent, oil imparts into the United Mr. McCARTHY. Mr. President, on As we all recognize, this matter is re States have risen by more than 800,000 Wednesday I joined with Senator MON ceiving more and more attention as more barrels per day for an increase of 57 per DALE in introducing S. 1793, a bill to pro and more people realize the seriousness cent. It is small wonder that we are vide assistance for the rehabilitation and of the situation. suffering an imbalance in our interna reconstruction of areas damaged by As far back as 1959, we were told by tional payments in view of this fact. :floods. We are pleased to have the Sen President Eisenhower that the United We have had a drop of almost 50 per ator from North Dakota [Mr. BURDICK] States had been facing continuous .def cent in the number of rotary rigs active join as a sponsor. I ask unanimous con icits in its balance of payments. Presi in 1964 over 1956. The rotary rig is the sent that at the next printing of the bill dent Eisenhower told us then that a defi tool with which oil is found. When you the name of Mr. BURDICK be added as a nite improvement in our balance-of-pay have a drop from 166 active rigs in 1956 sponsor. ments situation was mandatory in order to 87 in 1964, it can be easily seen why The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without to insure our economic well-being and the proved reserves of crude oil in Kan objection, it is so ordered. military security here at home. He also sas have declined every year since 1956. declared that an improvement in our Today we have 150 million barrels less of Mr TYDINGS. Mr. President, on be balance-of-payments situation was nec proved reserves of crude oil in Kansas half ~f the senior Senator from Connecti essary in the interest of the economic than we had in 1956. This, Mr. Presi cut [Mr. DoDnJ, I ask unanimous con growth and military strength of t?-e f~ee dent, does not only hurt the State of sent that at the next prtnting of S. 1483, world. President Kennedy likewise Kansas, but it is a threat to our Nation's a bill to provide for the establishment sounded the alarm in 1963, and now security. of the National Foundation on the Arts President Johnson has urged measures Employment in the oil producing in and the Humanities to promote progress that would help solve this payments dustry in Kansas is down 25 percent over and scholarship in the humanities and deficit. what it was in 1956. The price our pro the arts in the United States, and for Mr. President, it would appear that ducers receive for their oil has declined other purposes, the name of the senior our balance-of-payments situation is from an average price of $3.01 per barrel Senator from Connecticut [Mr. Donn] be something akin to the weather. We in 1957 to $2.91 per barrel in 1963, the added as a cosponsor. talk an awful lot about it, but never latest :figures available, and I am in The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without are we able to do anything about it. For formed that there have been further objection, it is so ordered. tunately, there are measures that can be price reductions since 1963. Although 8338 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 the price the producer receives for his oil and farm suppliers such as machinery, auto, I have been urging that if the President has gone down since 1957, the cost of fertilizer, hardware and petroleum dealers. is going to make the move that he says 7. There is no need or demand for the pro drilling and equipping his wells rose vision which would permit sale or lease of al he contemplates, he ought to ask Con 10 percent. Add to this the fact that the lotments. This provision, if enacted, could gress for a joint resolution which would cost of labor during this period has risen lead to fraud and scandal. follow and supplement the joint resolu some 15 percent, and one can see why 8. Protection and encouragement for the tion of August 10, 1964, and thus provide there exists in the State of Kansas a sour family farm be woven into the language of Congress and the country with an oppor economic climate in the oil producing the legislation. tunity to give this subject the considera industry. The Kansas Farmers Union wishes to reiter tion it deserves. The President as Com ate its historic position of the goal of full While a substantial reduction in oil parity for American agriculture. We support mander in Chief could take the action imports and a meaningful drop in the this legislation and the recommended addi that is said to be under consideration, military purchases of foreign oil will not tions because we believe their enactment into but I have urged that he should not do solve all of the economic problems facing law will move the income of farm families to so without coming to Congress again. I the oil producing industry, such actions ward full parity. wonder whether the Senator from Penn would go a long way·toward encouraging We also wish to use this message to express sylvania, who, I believe, feels much as I the independent wildcatter to continue the appreciation of the Kansas Farmers Un do about this matter, has done any his search for new oil reserves in this ion for your many efforts through the years thinking about that question. to improve the income of farm families. country. A reduction in imports and Respectfully yours, Mr. CLARK. I would hope very much military purchases of foreign oil would MARTIN J. BYRNE, that the suggestion of the Senator from also help ease our balance-of-payments President. New York would be taken, although I deficit. I am hopeful that effective ac agree with the Senator that legally there tion on both can be taken promptly. is no need to do so. DISPATCH OF TROOPS TO Mr. JAVITS. I thank the Senator VIETNAM from Pennsylvania. SUGGESTIONS FOR THE STRENGTH Mr. CLARK. Mr. President, the morn ENING OF PROPOSED PENDING ing newspapers carry some rather dis FARM LEGISLATION turbing columns on the present situation INVASIONS OF PRIVACY Mr. CARLSON. Mr. President, the in Vietnam. One by the vitriolic and Mr. LONG of Missouri. Mr. Presi members of the Kansas Farmers Union somewhat pyrotechnic columnist Joseph dent, our hearings on invasions of pri at a recent meeting in McPherson, Kans., Alsop refers to the "endless, silly public vacy have turned up a number of inter approved several suggestions ·for the talk" about negotiations; another by the esting items. strengthening of the proposed pending well-informed and accurate reporters One of these is an excellent recent farm legislation. Rowland Evans and Robert Novak con-. statement over the ABC radio network I ask unanimous consent that the letter tains the disturbing prediction that Pres by the distinguished commentator, Mr. from Martin J. Byrne, president of the ident Johnson will shortly dispatch up to Edward P. Morgan. I ask unanimous Kansas Farmers Union, containing these 100,000 U.S. ground troops to Vietnam consent that his statement be printed in suggestions, be made a part of these re starting in the next several weeks. the RECORD. marks. From where I sit there is nothing silly There being no objection, the state There being no objection, the letter was about the public discussion and the great ment was ordered to be printed in the ordered to be printed in the RECORD, as debate as to the validity of our Vietnam RECORD, as follows: policy. I would hope very much that we follows: EDWARD P. MORGAN AND THE NEWS KANSAS FARMERS UNION, would not be sending 100,000 ground Topeka, Kans., April 19, 1965. troops to Vietnam within the next few (Sponsored by the AFL-CIO, American Hon. FRANK CARLSON, Broadcasting Co. radio network, Apr. 15, weeks. 1965) Senate Office Building, As an indication of public opinion in Washington, D.C. Even in an open society like ours, the big DEAR SENATOR CARLSON: The members of my State, I should like to read into the brother of bureaucracy can rear his head the Kansas Farmers Union assembled at a RECORD the following statement: I have with ugly arrogance unless he, too, is statewide meeting at McPherson, Kans., April received since the first of the year 1,390 watched. The Federal Government has been 19, 1965. The purpose of the meeting was to individual communications, plus peti caught invading the public's privacy a little discuss, in depth, the proposals on farm legis tions bearing an additional 500 signa too aggressively of late and it is time to list a lation now before the Congress. The Kansas tures, protesting the continuation of the bill of particulars and raise a loud cry of Farmers Union supports the proposed legis war in Vietnam, and expressing support rightful indignation. The bureaucracy is lation and urges that it be passed. for negotiations and opposition to accel not only watching us, sometimes through We do believe, however, the following pro peepholes, it turns out, but listening in visions should be added to strengthen the bill eration of the war. increasingly on our conversations, probing and improve income for farm families. We During that period, I have received the sexual history of stenographers and other respectfully request they be included in the only 16 communications advocating a citizens applying for Federal jobs, telling proposed legislation. continuation of the war. I have had 82 people where they cannot travel and even, 1. The program be effective for 5 years in communications protesting the use of in some instances, seizing and reading their stead of 2 years to give farm operators an op gas, and 11 supporting the use of gas. first-class mail. portunity to carry out long-range manage Certainly, so far as my mail is any in Day before yesterday it was revealed that ment plans. the State Department had refused permis 2. The full parity provision for domestic dication, the people of Pennsylvania sup sion to editors of 13 college and university consumption on wheat be written into law port every effort to enter into meaning newspapers to send student journalists on rather than left to the discretion of the De- ful negotiations in Vietnam. There is Easter vacation assignments to report on life partment of Agriculture. _ every indication that they support the in Cuba. 3. A minimum value of at least 25 cents per President in his efforts to bring the war In their written request, campus editors bushel placed on the export certificates by to a close with honor to us, and it is from Yale, Harvard, Princeton, and other legislation and authority be provided the Sec equally plain that they are strong in their prominent schools had said: "A knowledge retary of Agriculture to declare a higher opposition to t.he very belligerent posi of the conditions within Cuba is prerequisite value. to our forming intelligent opinions as to our 4. Congressional approval be given the Sec tion which has been taken by Mr. Joseph relations with that country. As student retary of Agriculture to move upward the 105 Alsop, Mr. William S. White, Miss editors in a free and democratic society, we percent of support price plus costs affecting Marguerite Higgins, and various other consider the freedom to travel a necessary release of Government-stored wheat. columnists, the validity of whose judg condition for the freedom to learn." 5. A strategic reserve of agricultural com ment I question. Their request was rejected by the Depart modities sealed from the market be estab Mr. JAVITS. Mr. President, will the ment's Administrator of Security and Con lished. Senator from Pennsylvania yield? sular Affairs, ·Abba P. Schwartz, on the ques 6. The bill prohibit placing whole farms in tionable technicality that they were not the cropland adjustment reserve to protect Mr. CLARK. I yield to the Senator legitimate newspapermen and implying that renters of land and especially the younger from New York. anyway their presence would somehow im farm operators and to preclude the disruption Mr. JAVITS. I should like to ask the pede U.S. efforts to isolate Castro's dictator of the economic base of farm communities Senator from Pennsylvania a question. ship from the rest of the hemisphere. April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8339 To which the New York Times today There being no objection, the article Here is a partial list of other everyday uses angrily replies: was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, o.f bugs of one type or another: "The right to know and the right to Federal security agents have microphones travel-except in wartime--ought to be as follows: . installed in certain rooms in popular hotels sacred. Americans should be swarming over Is BIG BROTHER TAPING You? in many major cities. When guests under the island with magnifying glasses. The (By Arthur Whitman) surveillance are expected to register, the man American public in general has a right to Last September, a car pulled up beside a agement is notified and the guests are as know what is going on in Cuba; and so, ob 36-year-old West German diplomat named signed the bugged rooms. viously, does every segment of our society, Horst Schwirkmann on a quiet street in the Agents of the Food and Drug Administra including the residents of college campuses outskirts of Bonn. The rear window opened, tion carry concealed tape recorders on rou and the readers of college newspapers." and a mass of oily liquid flew out, splatter tine inspections, to record possible bribe at In a recent report by the House Committee ing over Schwirkmann's face and body. He tempts. So do food and building inspectors on Government Operations critical of the use screamed in agony. The car roared off. The in some large cities. So do police "shooflys" of lie detectors by the Federal Government, substance. thrown at Schwirkmann was mus the special squads maintained in some cities Representatiye CORNELIUS E. GALLAGHER, tard gas, the viscous killer developed for to police the police themselves. Democrat, of New Jersey, termed compulsory trench warfare in the First World War. Local investigators almost everywhere use polygraph tests "unconstitutional," said they Rushed to a hospital, Schwirkmann sur illegal phone taps to tape evidence against should be discontinued immediately until vived. However, his lungs are so severely bookies, panderers, and the occasional dope proved "infallible." Recalling his own testi damaged and his torso and legs so badly pushers who do business by telephone. The mony that a 17-year-old girl, just out of high burned that it seems unlikely he will ever evidence cannot be used in most courts, but school, had been subjected to humiliating work again. Thus the attack served its pur it does provide useful leads to evidence that questions about sexual matters when she pose-to remove Schwirkmann from the in may be admissable. applied for a typist's job with the National ternational eavesdropping war. Difficult as it is to sympathize too deeply Security Agency, GALLAGHER charged that with suspected spies and known criminals, An electronics wizard, Schwirkmann 's spe the fact remains that what can be done to "the threat of outright voyeurism runs cial job in the diplomatic service was to clear throughout too many of the cases that have German embassies of "bugs," or electronic them can be done to the rest of us. Thus, the come t o my attention regarding the use of use of bugs and wiretaps has spread into eavesdropping devioos. On his last periodic other areas : the lie detector." visit to the Russian Embassy, he had installed A Senate judiciary subcommittee, headed Classrooms in many school systems are an ingenious device of his own design that bugged so that principals can flick a switch by Missouri's Democratic Senator EDWARD V. administered a severe electric shock to any LONG, investigating Federal invasion of pri one who tried to tap an embassy phone. and listen to class discussions without the vacy, questioned the use of mail covers--a Nothing will ever be proved, but there is no knowledge of teachers and pupils. Going process of checking on, without opening, the question that the mustard-gas attack on him the educators one better, students have, on many occasions, used hidden recorders to m ail received by a person under suspicion of was a direct retaliation for installing the some criminal violation. The subcommittee "get the goods" on teachers suspected of lib shock device. eral political views and other heresies. was also concerned about a Post Office De News of the incident was particularly up partment practice of spying on employees Business firms regularly bug the offices of setting to me. As the victim of an eaves key rivals to learn trade secrets or get inside through peepholes. Last month, Chairman dropping outrage myself, Schwirkmann,. LoNG said Postmaster General Gronouski had whose job was to prevent such things, was knowledge about sales and other strategies. agreed to improve controls over mail cover one of the best friends I ever had. Engaged Corporations, as we've seen, monitor execu procedure and plug up the peepholes which in a project in behalf of one publisher, I tives' phone calls. Others have bugs to mon had been used to prevent depredation of the was approached by another to do a similar itor conversations at spots where employees mails by postal workers. job. For reasons only the good Lord knows, congregate such as time clocks, locker rooms, But on April 5, still another practice came this second man recorded his conversa'!ion cafeterias and washrooms. One large com to light. Congressman DURWARD G. HALL, with me, without my knowledge. When I pany recently was faced with a strike because Republican, of Missouri, revealed on the floor refused him on the grounds of my prior it has installed a hidden TV camera in thA of the House that the Internal Revenue Serv commitment, he edited the tape, leaving men's washroom. Another installed bugs in ice was opening the first-class mail of delin in some ill-considered remarks I had made, the toilet paper containers in the ladies' quent taxpayers. He charged a collusion in but leaving out the substance of our talk john. volving t h e Treasury, the Post Office Depart his offer and my refusal. I lost the commis Politicians, each election season, tap ment, and the Director of Internal Revenue sion and the substantial sum of money that phones and bug campaign headquarters to had resulted in 14 such levies since 1962. went with it. learn rivals' plans and strategies. Today HALL'S office said the Post Office now I regret my loss, but I regret even more that Individuals involved in civil suits bug admits 34 cases are involved. One person I was the only participant in this reechy each others' premises to gather useful in a "tax deviate" might be the bureaucratic affair who seemed to find anything unusual, formation and evidence. The prime area term for him-allegedly had all his mail with let alone outrageous, in it. With my radar for this is divorce actions, particularly in held for a month. Revenue Commissioner now out on the subject, I've discovered that States with restrictive codes. So little is Sheldon Cotten wrote HALL citing one case no one else seems to think twice about elec sacred in this line of endeavor that bugs in which a delinquent had been persuaded tronic prying, either. It has become so much routinely are discovered under the beds of by seizure of his mail· to pay up his tax lia a part of the landscape that when "bugs" estranged husbands and wives who suspect bility in full. were discovered embedded in the walls of the each other of errant ways. The latest twist The Government argues this practice is American Embassy in Warsaw in November in this game is the installation of tiny radio legal. But several Members of Congress, 1964, it hardly caused any stir in the press. transmitters in cars that relay to prying Missouri's HALL foremost among them, main On the earlier discovery that our Moscow ears and tape recorders any conversations tain it is an outrageous violation of privacy, Embassy had been bugged for at least 11 or other sounds produced by drivers and pas comprising, in effect, unwarranted search and years, there was some press outcry, but no sengers. seizure and demand new legislation specifi one in the know was even half horrified. A Thoughtful connoisseurs of electronic pry cally outlawing the practice. State Department man, filling friends in on ing attribute its spread to several factors. On Tuesday a somewhat contrite Govern.:. the incident, commented that it was "as One is the cold war fears that have given ment lawyer, Deputy General Counsel Harvey surprising as the sun rising in the east." us a McCarthy and a Goldwater in a single H. Hannah, of the Post Office, told Senator When you consider how deeply the practice decade and have produced such national LONG'S committee, "we've been doing it has penetrated our daily life, the official's phenomena as the John Birchers. wrong, no question about it." comment is . hardly shocking. Eavesdrop Perhaps the greatest single boost to pry Manifestly, the Government has been do ing techonolgy is space research, which makes ing a lot of things wrong in respect to the ping has apparently become as much a part of the American way as apple pie and fantastic budgets available for the develop private rights of citizens. Human beings, ment of miniaturized sensors and transmit unhappily perhaps, are not always saints but mother, though it is hardly as savory as the one or as beneficent as the other. Numbers ters used to monitor men and modules orbit if somebody isn't constantly watching the ing at vast distances from the earth. Government agencies watching their foibles, are difficult to establish in an enterprise that is by definition clandestine, but here are a Among the results of this research are pow there can be the devil to pay. erful transmitters so small they can be em This is Edward P. Morgan saying good night couple that are available. In 1962, a House bedded in sugar lumps for placement at your from Washington. committee reported that at least 5,000 phones favorite restaurant. Women can carry po in Federal offices in Washington were tent transmitters in a cigarette case or lip Mr. LONG of Missouri. Mr. President, bugged-not by Russians, but by American I ask unanimous consent to have printed stick tube. Men use chapstick holders. bureaucrats spying on each other. Not long There are devices so thin that a trans at this point in the RECORD an article en ago, an official of the San Francisco Tele mLtter, plus microphone and antenna wire titled "Is Big Brother Taping You?" phone Co. estimated that 10,000 firms in flt between a framed print and its paper written by Arthur Whitman and pub northern California alone monitor the calls backing, leaving a budge no greater than that lished in the February issue of the maga of their executive employees without the ex ca.used by normal warpage and wrinkling of zine Tape Recording. ecutives' knowledge. the backing. Microphone-and-transmitter 8340 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 combinations flt inside :fountain pens. They distance of 200 feet away when used with And then there is the telephone pickup also fit into quarter-inch-thick pads of wireless FM transmitter and FM receiver. "which starts recorder when phone call sponge rubber. These may be slid under A highly versatile unit which is a complete doors or placed under rugs and carpets in package and includes (separate list prices is started and stops when receiver is re small squares cut out of their normal pad shown): turned to phone-completely automati ding. Ingenious as all this is, it is rapidly 1. Specially modified 330 high-fidelity AC cally in your absence." This would ap becoming obsolete. There are directional DC multipurpose tape recorder: $199. pear to be in direct violation of FCC regu mikes now available that are so sensitive 2. High impact attache case with best lations in effect--if not in force-today. that elaborate placement techniques are un quality interior housing of polyfoam insula In addition to the tie clasp, cuff link, necessary. They can pick up conversational tion for safety and silent security. It con and fountain pen microphones, there is tones from distances up to 500 feet. tains precision built-in concealed subminia Curiously, no one knows whether the uses ture ultrasensitive microphone and sub a new gadget, similar in principle to the to which all this prying gimmickry are put is miniature microswitch: $115. one used by the Soviets to "bug" our Em legai or not. The fourth amendment as 3. Uni-Con telephone pick-up adapter bassy in Moscow. It is the keyhole ex sures us of "the right of the people to be se which starts recorder when phone call is tension microphone, described as "an cure in their persons, houses, papers and ef started and stops when receiver is returned extended flexible tube just three-six fects against unreasonable searches and seiz to phone-completely automatically in your teenths inch in diameter-fits about ures," and the fifth amendment guarantees absence: $69.50. any keyhole." that no person will be deprived of liberty 4. AC adapter: $18.95. It is my intention to question the FCC without due process of law. These certainly 5. Special tape for 6 hours of recording: would seem to assure us of the right not to $4.75. officials about the sale and use of this be bugged, but the Supreme Court has been 6. Foot control (another excellent way of type of equipment when they appear be very slow to consider electronic prying as un recording control) : $18.95. fore our subcommittee on May 5. reasonable search. 7. Complete set of batteries: $1.50. You This has led to rather moonstruck inci save almost $80 by purchasing this entire dents. In one of the very few arrests Fed package at the low price of $349 (add $2.25 RECONSTRUCTION ASSISTANCE TO eral officers have ever made on private com postage, handling, and insurance). You may OREGON, WASHINGTON, CALI plaint for eavesdropping (in a recent Wash of course purchase and use one or more of FORNIA, AND IDAHO ington, D.C., case of industrial spying), the these devices at the list price above. Total culprits had planted a tiny transmitter in a cost at list price is $427.65 (our package is a Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, I hotel room. When apprehended, they were low $349 for the same devices (add $1.25 ask unanimous consent that the Senate charged by the Justice Department not with postage and handling per separate i tern) . proceed to the consideration of Calen trespass or violation of privacy, but with The "440" security sound system is the dar No. 153, S. 327. broadcasting without a license. cumulative result of years of research into The PRESIDING OFFICER. The bill It's doubtful how much good would be recording important matters inconspicuously will be stated by title. done even if our Federal laws did take on and, if need be, without the distraction of better definition in the area. For example, obviously fumbling around with switches The LEGISLATIVE CLERK. A bill (S. if Congress got interested, the most it could while recording and by remote wireless con 327) to provide assistance to the States do would be to ban the shipment and sale trol. of Oregon, Washington, California, and of bugging devices in interstate commerce. OPTIONAL ACCESSORIES Idaho for the reconstruction of areas Even if such laws ever did come into exist Wireless ".007" FM transmitter (which you damaged by recent floods and high wa ence, circumvention would be laughably carry around in your shirt pocket) with ters. easy. Manufacture and sell within the same built-in pinhead microphone: $49.50. The PRESIDING OFFICER. Is there State and you're home free. If you do ship AM-FM receiver, used for remote record objection to the present consideration of out of State, be sure you ship only to police iiig: $39.50. organizations and such other exceptions as Tie clasp or cuff link microphone (incon the bill? the law is sure to provide for. Suppres spicuous) : $24.95. There being no objection, the Senate sion of the devices in these circumstances is Fountain pen microphone (who will proceeded to consider the bill, which had about as promising as hunting butterflies know?): $24.95. been reported from the Committee on with a harpoon. And new, the keyhole extension micro Public Works, with an amendment, to The States doubtless could provide much phone-many will find this an indispensable strike out all after the enacting clause more effective control, but so far New York is accessory. Unique device is an extended and insert: the only State with a statute making the flexible tube just three-sixteenths inch in use of bugging devices a felony. Pressures diameter-fits about any keyhole. One end That Congress hereby recognizes (1) that on our notoriously susceptible State legisla of the extension mike fits neatly and sim the States of California, Oregon, Washington, tures by manufacturers and distributors of ply into the FM transmitter-FM receiver and Idaho have experienced extensive prop the bugs, as well as by satisfied users, doubt setup which connects to the "Continental erty loss and damage as t he result of floods less will prevent the enactment of statutes 440"; other end contains the smallest and and high waters during December 1964, and similar to New York's by many other States most easily concealed microphone you have January and February 1965, (2) that much unless there is coherent and persistent ac ever seen-just three-sixteenths inch by five of the affected area is federally owned and tion by their citizens. This is an action I thirty-seconds inch in size-and you can administered, and (3) that the livelihood of would support. In a time and place where poke it through the door, crack, over the wall, the people in the area is dependent on anyone with a few hundred dollars and a under the rug and even unreel it like a fish prompt restoration of transportation facili reason can appoint himself big brother, the ing line out the window down to the next ties, and therefore Congress declares the little brothers have very few options. They story. Its uses are many as you can well need for special measures designed to aid and can either learn to act together in the inter imagine: $119.50 (add 85 cents postage and accelerate those States in their efforts to ests of preserving their rights-or they can handling). provide for the reconstruction of devastated learn to keep their thoughts pure on an in Ten-day money back guarantee if not rep areas. dividual basis. resented as advertised. Up to now the "Con SEC. 2. (a) Notwithstanding provisions of tinental 440" security recording package was existing contracts, the Secretary of the In Mr. LONG of Missouri. Mr. President, made expressly for, and available only, to terior and the Secretary of Agriculture, sep no less a publication than the Wall Street registered private investigators. All sales arately, with funds and authorizations avail Journal published in its edition of April final. able to him for the construction and main 22, 1965, at page 10, an advertisement tenance of highways, roads, and trails, shall for sophisticated "bugging gear." I Mr. LONG of Missouri. Mr. President, reimburse timber sale contractors to the ex have eliminated the manufacturer's the ad and its placement in the Wall tent of costs estimated by the Secretary's name and address, but I ask unanimous Street Journal almost speak for them representative as incurred or to be incurred selves. The availability and relative in by the contractor for restoring roads in any consent that the bulk of the advertise stage of construction authorized by a timber ment be printed at this point in the expensiveness of this gear illustrates very sale contract to substantially the same con RECORD. vividly that "big brother" is alreadY here. dition existing prior to the damage resulting There being no objection, the adver The manUfacturers are quite blatant from the floods of December 1964, and Jan tisement was ordered to be printed in about the surveillance features of their uary and February 1965 in California, Idaho, the RECORD, as follows: wares. Oregon, and Washington, and to the extent The recorder "can also record perfectly costs estimated by the Secretary's represent World's first fully voice-activated auto controlled inconspicuously by remote ative as incurred or to be incurred by the matic security recording system completely contractor for completing road construction self-contained in an attractive security-proof control from the outside with case open not performed prior to the floods but which, standard-looking attache case and it can also or closed and can be operated from a dis because of changed conditions resulting from record perfectly controlled inconspicuously tance of 200 feet away when used with the floods, exceed road construction costs by remote control from the outside with case wireless FM transmitter and FM re originally estimated by the Secretary's repre open or closed and can be operated from a ceiver." sentative: The estimated costs for such road April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE 8341 restoration, reconstruction, and construction by railroad and shall report to Congress the The abnormal weather conditions of warm under any single timber purchase contract results of such survey together with the cost rain falling on snow and frozen ground which on roads not accepted prior to the floods, of any recommended work within one hun caused the floods were summarized in the whether construction was complete, partial, dred and twenty days after the date of enact U.S. Weather Bureau publication "Pacific or not yet begun, shall be borne as follows: ment of this Act. The Secretary is author Northwest Monthly Precipitation and Tem The timber purchaser shall bear 16 per ized ( 1) to perform such of the recommended perature," December 1964, as follows: centum o! all amounts: Provided, That the work as may be approved prior to June 30, "December 1964 will long be remembered purchaser shall not be required to bear costs 1966, by resolution adopted by the Commit in Oregon and southern Idaho for the un o! more than $4,500. The Secretary shall tees on Public Works of the Senate and the precedented winter rainfall which fell dur bear the remaining portion of such costs. House of Representatives, and (2) after the ing the period December 19-27. • • • Pre (b) Where the Secretary determines that adoption of such a resolution, to reimburse cipitation for the month was 200 percent or damages are so great that restoration, recon any common carrier for any such recom more of average southeast of a line extend struction, or construction is not practical un mended work approved by such resolution ing from Brookings, Oreg., Yakima, Wash., der the above cost-sharing arrangement, the which is undertaken before the date of adop Spokane, Wash., Kalispell, Mont. Over much Secretary may allow cancellation of the con tion of such resolution. of this area the precipitation for the De tract notwithstanding provisions therein. (b) The costs of the survey authorized in cember just past far exceeded that for any SEC. 3. (a) That section 125 of title 23, this section shall be paid from funds hereto previous December. • • • The series o.f United States Code, is amended to delete the fore appropriated for general investigations. storms moving inland from the Southwest second sentence of paragraph (a) and insert Such costs shall not exceed $250,000. during the period December 19-27 brought in lieu thereof the following: "There is au (c) There is authorized to be appropriated abnormally heavy precipitation over Oregon thorized to be appropriated not to exceed such amount as may be necessary for carry and southern Idaho. Prior to the beginning $80,000,000 for the fiscal year ending June 30, ing out work and making reimbursements of the storm, the ground was frozen and snow 1965, nor to exceed $50,000,000 for each fiscal authorized in accordance with this section. covered over nearly all areas of the Pacific year thereafter, for the establishment and SEC. 9. This Act, other than sections 3, 4, Northwest. This combination of warm rain annual replenishment of this fund." and 8, shall not be in effect after June 30, falling on frozen ground and snow resulted (b) That section 125 of title 23, United 1966, except with respect to payment o! ex in the greatest winter flood on record 1n States Code, is amended to delete the period penditures for obligations and commitments western Oregon and in a number of other at the end of the second sentence of para entered into under this Act on or before such basins east of the Cascade Range." graph (b) and insert in lieu thereof the fol date. The same public~tlon revealed the extent lowing: ", and unless the Secretary has re SEC. 10. This Act may be cited as the "Pa of runoff created by the abnormal precipita ported the proposed expenditure to the Pub cific Northwest Disaster Relief Act of 1965". tion: lic Works Committees of the Senate and "Runoff in December ranged from high to House of Representatives and has not re The PRESIDING OFFICER. The record high for December over southern ceived disapproval of the proposed expend question is on agreeing to the committee Washingt.on, all of Oregon, nearly all of iture from either committee within thirty amendment. Idaho. • • • Floods of record or near-record days following submission of his report ." The amendment was agreed to. proportions occurred in all of this area • • • SEC. 4. Paragraph (3) of section 2 of the Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, in the last 10 days of the month. Eighteen Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1964 is amended deaths in Oregon and two in Idaho were at to read as follows: hearings were conducted on this measure tributed to this flood. • • • Runoff was low "(3) For forest development roads and on April 1, by the Subcommittee on Pub in only a few rivers in the region." trails, $123,000,000 for the fiscal year ending lic Roads under the chairmanship of the The floods brought destruction or exten June 30, 1966, of which not to exceed $38,000,- capable senior Senator from West Vir sive damage to more than 12,000 homes, se 000 shall be used solely for the construction, ginia [Mr. RANDOLPH]. rious economic dislocation of some 18,000 repair, an d reconstruction of forest develop It is my understanding that there is families, disruption of industrial facilities, ment roads and trails in the States of Cali complete concurrence between the Com and widespread des·truction of transportation fornia, Oregon, Washington, and Idaho nec mittee on Public Works, which reported facilities. essary because of the floods and high waters Estimates of the Office of Emergency Plan in such States during December 1964, and the amended bill unanimously, and the ning, supplied on March 29, place the total January and February 1965, and $85,000,000 chief sponsor of the original measure, damages incurred in the flood-stricken area for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1967." the distinguished senior Senator from at $461,500,000: SEC. 5. The Secretary of Agriculture is au Oregon [Mr. MORSE]. thorized to reduce to seven days the mini Also there is basic agreement between Public Private Total mum period of advance public notice re the administration and the spokesman quired by the first section of the Act of June of the timber industry, which was so Oregon ______$95, 000, 000 $147, 000, 000 $242, 000, 000 4, 1897 (16 U.S.C. 476), in connection with the severely affected by the floods in the Washington ___ 9,000,000 3,000, 000 12,000,000 sale of timber from national forests, when California _____ 140, 000, 000 60, 000, 000 200, 000, 000 ever the Secretary determines that the sale Pacific Northwest, and only minor dif 5,500, 000 2,000, 000 7,500,000 ferences remain between this measure Idaho_------of such timber will assist in the reconstruc TotaL __ tion of any area of California, Oregon, Wash and similar legislation pending before 249, 500, 000 212, 000, 000 461, 500, 000 ington, and Idaho damaged by floods or high the Public Works Committee of the waters during December 1964, and January House of Representatives. Though the committee does not minimize and February 1965. Mr. President, I suggest the absence of the extent of this destruction, it should be SEC. 6. The Secretary o! the Interior is au a quorum. noted that the above damages would have thorized to give any public land entryman been greatly exceeded but for the protection such additional time in which to comply The PRESIDING OFFICER. The of existing flood control projects. In the with any requirement of law in connection clerk will call the roll. Willamette Basin alone, projects authorized with any public land entry for lands in Ore The legislative clerk proceeded to call by the Congress and constructed by the Corps gon, Washington, California, and Idaho as the roll. of Engineers prevented some $572 million the Secretary finds appropriate because of in Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, I worth of damage, a figure exceeding the total terference with the entryman's ability to ask unanimous consent that the order cost of all facilities constructed in the basin. comply with such requirement resulting from for the quorum call be rescinded. Of most critical importance to the economy floods and high waters during December of the region was the disruption and de 1964, and January and February 1965. The PRESIDING OFFICER. With struction of transportation facilities. S. 327 SEC. 7. Loans made pursuant to paragraph out objection, it is so ordered. is principally addressed to the problems of (1) of section 7(b) of the Small Business Act Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, I reconstructing and restoring these facilities. (15 U.S.C. 636(b)) for the purpose of re ask unanimous consent to have printed The Bureau of Public Roads of the U.S. placing, reconstructing, or repairing dwell at this point in the RECORD certain por Department of Commerce estimates that the ings in Oregon, Washington, California, and tions of the committee report. Federal share of reconstructing Federal-aid Idaho, damaged or destroyed by the floods There being no objection, the excerpts and forest highways will be $56 million. Un and high water of December 1964, and Janu der Public Law 88-658 the basic 60-percent ary and February 1965, may have a maturity from the report (Rept. No. 166) were Federal share is increased by a percentage of up to thirty years, except that section ordered to be pril'llted in the RECORD, as equal to the percentage which the area of 7 ( c) of such Act shall not apply to such follows: certain nontaxable Indian and public do loans. THE NEED FOR S. 327 main lands is to the total land area of the SEC. 8(a) The Secretary of the Army is au During Christmas week, 1964, and again 1n State. Thus, the presently authorized thorized and directed to make a survey to January and February 1965 the States of matching Federal share for the States in determine what protective works would be Oregon, California, Washington, and Idaho volved in S. 327 is: California 69.78, Idaho necessary to prevent the recurrence of dam were struck by catastrophic floods which were 62.91, Oregon 63.46, and Washington 63.51 age by floods or high waters to those banks unprecedented in terms of high water and percent o! the cost of emergency repairs to of the Eel River, California, which are adja subsequent damage to roads, farms, resi the A-B-C and Interstate System highways cent to the trackage of any common carrier dences, and industrial installations. located 1n these States. 8342 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 Of the total $56 million required by the Section 2 of the bill would facilitate this nition that the operator should take some of Bureau of Public Roads, $8.1 million has action by authorizing the Secretaries of Ag the risks of normal winter maintenance on already been approved under existing au riculture and the Interior to reimburse tim roads which have not stabilized. But it also thorizations; an additional $4 million can be ber sale contractors for reconstruction and recognizes that such natural catastrophes as financed under present authorizations, leav restoration of roads which were under con floods and earthquakes are an inherent risk ing an unfunded balance of $44 million. struction but had not been accepted by the of landownership and provides that contracts The Forest Service reported damages to Government as part of the national system of may be adjusted so that the Government as approximately 12,000 miles of forest devel forest development roads and trails at the sumes a major share of such risk of loss if opment roads and trails under its adminis time of the floods. damage occurs. This principle is equitable to tration, with a cost of restoration of approx At the time of these floods, many purchas both the Government and the purchasers of imately $47 million. Of this amount, $3 ers of timber from lands under the jurisdic its timber. m11lion will be reprogramed and $8 million tion of the Secretaries of Agriculture and Section 3 (b) provides the Secretaries with will be financed from unused authorizations, the Interior were in the process of construct discretionary authority to cancel a timber leaving an unfunded balance of $36 million. ing roads under the terms of their timber purchase contract where it is determined that In addition to the damages to Govern sale contracts. Some had substantially the damages are so great that restoration, ment-owned forest development roads and completed the construction of such roads reconstruction, or construction is not practi trails, there were damages in excess of $3 mil but the roads had not been accepted. The cal under the above cost-sharing arrange lion to roads constructed under timber pur damage to roads of this type was in many ment. chase contracts with the Forest Service and instances severe. In some instances the ac Increased authorization for emergency funds with the Bureau of Land Management of the tual road location was either destroyed or so for Federal-aid highway systems damaged that the replacement road would Department of the Interior. These roads, in Section 3(a) would amend section 125 of various stages of completion at the time the have to be construct ed on a new location. floods struck, were constructed by purchasers Thus, the damage resulting from the floods title 23, United States Code, to increase the has m ade it necessary to reconstruct all or annual authorization for emergency road of Government timber according to stand funds for the Federal-aid systems from $30 ards and specifications of the Forest Service portions of many roads for which the timber and the Bureau of Land Management. On purchasers were responsible under their tim to $80 million for fiscal year 1965 and $50 completion, they will be accepted by the re ber sale contracts. Also, the flood damage million for each fiscal year thereafter. spective administrative agencies and will be has in some instances resulted in such The recommended increase of $50 million come part of the federally owned and ad changed conditions that the estimated cost in the authorization for fiscal year 1965 ministered system of forest development of completing the construction of roads would provide for the estimated $44 million roads and trails. which had been partially constructed will ex of unfunded reconstruction work on the Finally, in assessing the damages to vital ceed the original estimated cost. Federal-aid systems required to restore the transportation facilities, the committee Section 2 (a ) supersedes existing timber flood damages, and the annual increase after notes the ext ensive destruction of t rackage, sale contracts which would impose the en fl.seal year 1965 from $30 to $50 million is bridge and embankment structures, and tire loss on the purchaser, and provides that consistent with the increasing flood damages other facilities of the North western Pacific the purchaser shall bear 15 percent of the due to the growth in the capital investment Railroad on t h e Eel River, Calif. Manage costs of reconstruction and restoration, up in the Nation's highway system. ment of the railroad h as estimated total to a m aximum cost to the purchaser of This emergency fund is not cumulative; damages of $10.7 million, including an esti $4,500; the Government shall bear 85 percent it is the product of annual replenishment, m ated $3 ,625,000 required for minimum of the costs, and 100 percent of all amounts and withdrawals for this purpose from the bank st abilization and protective works nec above $30,000 on a single timber purchase highway trust fund will be reimbursed by essary to prevent further damage from floods contract. appropriations from the general fund. or high water. Though the committee does It is the intention of the committee that Increased authorization for forest develop- not propose that the railroad be reimbursed the provisions of subsection (a) of section 2, ment roads and trails for fiscal year 1966 for damages to its trackage or for clearance including the provisions for proration, shall apply to the entire cost of restoring or re Section 4 would authorize an additional of debris and wreckage, S. 327 would author $38 million for forest development roads and ize $250,000 for a survey of the Eel River and constructing those portions of roads which timber purchasers had wholly or partially trails for the fl.seal year ending June 30, 1966, would authorize the necessary funds to per bringing the total authorization for that form the stream-bank stabilization work constructed prior to the floods but which had not yet been accepted. The provisions year to $123 million. This section stipulates recommended by the Secretary of the Army that the additional $38 million shall be used on the basis of the survey. also apply to that portion of the estimated cost of completing road construction not ac solely for the construction, repair, and re MAJOR PROVISIONS OF THE BILL complished prior to the floods which exceeds construction of forest development roads Shared costs for reconstruction of timber the road construction costs originally esti and trails in the States of California, Oregon, purchase roads mated for such portions where the excess was Washington, and Idaho damaged by the re The forest industry is a major segment of the result of changed conditions brought cent floods. the economy of the Pacific Northwest, with about by the floods. The estimates of cost in The $38 million recommended by the com much of the industry being dependent for each case would be made by the appropriate mittee will finance the remaining unfunded its raw material supply on lands owned by Secretary's representative. balance of repair work on the 12,000 miles of the Federal Government. In the four States In the case of roads that timber purchasers damaged roads reported by the Forest Serv which come under the provisions of S. 327, were required to construct under their tim ice, which is estimated at $36 million, and the federally owned forests comprise 44,- ber sale contracts on which work had not will provide $2 million to enable the Gov 508,000 acres, or 56 percent of all commercial been started at the time of the floods, the ernment to reimburse timber purchasers in forest land, and provide 54 percent of the provisions of subsection (a) of section 2 accordance with the provisions of section total timber supply of these four States. would also apply to that portion of the cur 2(a) of S. 327. The committee assumes that Approximately 400,000 people in the re rent estimate of road construction costs this authority will be administered by the gion are employed by the industry, and in which exceeds the original estimate because Forest Service as part of its general construc Oregon alone it provides a payroll of $470 of changed conditions resulting from the tion program for forest development roads million for 80,000 people and directly gen..: floods. For work not performed prior to the and trails. erates approximately 60 percent of the in floods, and for which the original cost esti Reduction of minimum time required for come of that State. Thus, it is imperative mates still prevail, costs shall be assigned un advertising sale of national forest that access to both public and private com der the terms of the original timber con timber tract. mercial forest lands be restored as quickly One of the effects of the disastrous storms as possible in order to avoid further severe Thus, section 2(a) provides for reimburse and floods in the Pacific Northwest last win economic dislocation in the region. ment for three kinds of costs: ter has been the complete disruption or seri In western Oregon, where the Federal 1. Costs necessary to reproduce in replica ous impairment of access to sources of tim Government owns two-thirds of the timber, work formerly done which was destroyed by ber supply from the national forests for the impaired access to Federal forests has already the floods. wood-using industries of the region. Until created significant unemployment. Log in 2. Costs necessary to replace the damaged this access can be restored, other sources of ventories are abnormally low for this time of or destroyed facility in a new location be timber must be provided if the affected in year, and because of impaired access they cause the old location is no longer usable as dustries are to continue operation. other were not replaced in many areas where a result of the floods. wise, communities dependent on the timber winter and early spring logging are nor 3. Costs in excess of original estimates for mally conducted. A survey made in early contemplated construction which had not industry will face the imminent prospect of · March of 142 forest products operations been performed but which costs will be in mills shut down and severe unemployment. employing 26,285 persons in western Oregon curred upon constructing the needed facility. To help avert this condition, section 5 and southwestern Washington revealed 15 The reimbursements authorized in this sec would authorize the Secretary of Agricul mills which would have to close and lay off tion are mandatory, not permissive, and are ture to reduce from 30 days to 7 days the 1,721 persons if access to Federal forests in recognition of the Government's responsi minimum time required to advertise the were not- quickly restored so that logging bility as a landowner and proprietor. The sale of national forest timber in the affected could be resumed. small deductible of 15 percent is in recog- area. April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8343 Compliance with requirements of law Section 8(a) would authorize the Secre Expeditious enactment of this measure regarding entry on public lands · tary of the Army to conduct a survey of the by the Senate will extend a helping hand Because of the havoc created by the floods Eel River to determine what protective to the hard-working and energetic citi and high waters, persons seeking to perfect works would be necessary to prevent the re zens who, through no fault of their own, their rights in entries under the various currence of damage by floods or high waters public land laws have been disadvantaged. to the railroad lines, and directs the Sec must now attempt to pick up the pieces Section 6 would grant authority to the Sec retary to report to the Committees on Public and rebuild their homes and commu retary of the Interior to suspend the time Works of the Senate and the House of Rep nities. limits embodied in those laws for the per resentatives within 120 days. By resolution Mr. JORDAN of Idaho. Mr. Presi formance of certain acts where appropriate the committees would authorize the Secre dent, I am pleased that S. 327 which will in cases where the entryman's ability to tary to perform such recommended work provide assistance to the States of Cali comply has been interfered with by the as the committees approve and to reimburse fornia, Oregon, Washington, and Idaho floods and high waters. the Northwestern Pacific for its expenditures on such approved work prior to the date of for the reconstruction of areas damaged Maturity date of loans made under the adoption of the resolution. by floods and high waters during the Small Business Act Section 8(b) authorizes the expenditure of past winter has been reported by the In many cases a person whose home has $250,000 from funds already appropriated Senate Committee on Public Works. I been destroyed or extensively damaged is for general investigations. join other Senators from these States in placed in serious financial straits. Although Section 8(c) authorizes the appropriation his resources may be very. limited, he must urging prompt and favorable action by of such funds as may be necessary for car the Senate on this important legisla find some means of financing replacement or rying out work and making reimbursements repairs and, at the same time, continue authorized in accordance with this section. tion. meeting his existing mortgage obligations. In December of 1964 and January of Thus the Small Business Administration is TERMINATION 1965 many parts of these four States had often compelled to refuse a loan because Section 9 stipulates that except for sec unprecedented falls of snow and rain. the applicant cannot demonstrate ability to tions 3, 4, and 8, and except for payment of This along with unseasonably warm repay on a 20-year amortization basis. expenditures for obligations and commit Section 7 of S. 327 would amend the ments entered into prior to June 30, 1966, weather caused most of the streams and Small Business Act to allow for the matu this act will not be in effect after June 30, rivers in these areas to become raging, rity of such loans up to 30 years. 1966. unmanageable torrents. Bridges were Title Survey of bank stabilization of the Eel River, washed out, roads and railroad tracks Calif., and proVision for reimbursement of Section 10 entitled the act as the "Pacific destroyed and millions of dollars worth work performed Northwest Disaster Relief Act of 1965." of livestock were killed. Logs, lumber Of primary importance to a large area of Mr. KUCHEL. Mr. President, I desire and wood products were carried a way by northwestern California is the restoration to have the RECORD show that I whole these waters and made unfit for use. of the Northwestern Pacific Railroad, which heartedly endorse the proposed legisla Towns and farms were inundated and carries approximately 80 percent of the littered with debris of every sort. Many freight in its service area-an area in which tion, which is also endorsed by my col league from California [Mr. MURPHY], towns were isolated for days and could the timber industry comprises 70 percent of only be reached by helicopters. The the economy. by the two Senators from Alaska [Mr. Northwestern Pacific Railroad lines extend BARTLETT and Mr. GRUENING], and by the people in these communities responded from San Rafael, Calif., to Eureka, Calif., a Senator from Idaho [Mr. JORDAN]. in true American tradition to start re distance of about 285 miles. For approxi When the bill reaches the House, cer pairs on the property damaged such as mately 100 miles the line follows the precip tain problems affecting the people of my homes, farms, mills, and plants. Before itous canyon of the Eel River, between Long State may possibly give rise to some the usual full economy of these areas can vale, 30 miles north of Willits, and the river's be restored it is necessary to repair and outlet to the· Pacific in the Eureka area. It amendments. However, because we are dealing with an urgent situation, the bill rebuild their transportation systems. was this 100-mile section which was virtually The economy of most of the communi wiped out by the flooding of the Eel River should be moved through the Senate. ties is tied in with timber, agriculture, or during Christmas week of 1964. Mr. MURPHY. Mr. President, as a In some areas, not only were the rails minerals. We need emergency repairs cosponsor of S. 327, and a member of the to highways, bridges, and forest roads washed away, but also the complete road Senate Public Works Committee, I rise bed, including the protective riprap between and trails. The purpose of this bill is the river and the roadbed. Huge redwood to urge its enactment. Words are in to authorize funds for this necessary logs, carried by the raging floodwaters, adequate to properly convey the catas work. Many of these facilities are lo knocked out three large steel bridges and in trophic damages that occurred during cated on Federal lands. Our State and many areas completely covered the track the late December and early January local agencies as well as private property age. floods in the Northwest. Only a per owners are responding magnificently. The cost of restoring the line has been sonal inspection of the area would fully Our Idaho State Highway Department is estimated by the management of the North enable one to comprehend this disaster. western Pacific at $10,700,000, including $3,- working closely with the Federal Bureau 625,000 in protective works to stabilize the My first job as a U.S. Senator was to of Public Roads and with our local streambanks and prevent further damage tour the stricken areas, and observe first counties. The counties affected are from recurrent floods or high water. hand the result of uncontrolled nature. straining every fiber to meet the needs The railway management has acted with The flood damage was widespread and of local communities in restoring county great dispatch and with high regard for its touched every activity in the area. roads and bridges. Some of our Idaho responsibility to the economy of the region Homes, schools, factories, and the trans cities have actually expended money al by taking emergency action to restore the portation system were among the flood's located to other necessary local needs in lines and resume operations at the earliest victims. possible date. Between 750 and 800 work order to meet this emergency· restora men have been employed with much over The Office of Emergency Planning esti tion program. time work at 10 different locations. As of mated that the total damage to the This amendment to S. 327 along with April 12 the company had expended in ex Northwestern United States exceeded other purposes of the bill will provide cess of $5,600,000 on reconstruction work. $450 million and my State of California for accelerated emergency relief funds S. 327 would not authorize reimburse alone suffered $200 million in damages. by authorizing $80 million for restora ment of the line for such items of work as These citizens need assistance and need tion purposes for the remainder of this wreckage and debris clearance or recon it immediately. Although Federal and struction of its trackage. In addition to fiscal year and $50 million annually for this kind of work, however, and of major State programs are alleviating the dam future years. While the damage in importance in expediting the restoration age, it is clear that further Federal as Idaho is not as great as in California of the railroad and in preventing further sistance is required. Delay will tend to or Oregon, preliminary figures indicate permanent damage, is correction of the Eel aggravate the already overwhelming it will require more than $11 million of River Channel by providing essential mini difficulties the region and people are Federal, State, and local funds to restore mum riprap protection along the stream experiencing. our damaged highways, bridges, roads, channel. This would include clearing the channel where debris, large boulders, and All of the witnesses who appeared be and forest trails. In addition the dam rocky point projections in the channel fore the Public Works Committee and age to private property will run into mil forced the stream against the river channel all of my colleagues on the committee lions of dollars. Property owners will and subsequently undermined the raqroad appreciated the emergency nature of the pay this from their own funds or in embankment. Much of this work is not on situation and the necessity for urgent some instances fr.om borrowed funds. the railroad right-of-way. action. · Had it not been for the fact that the 8344 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE April 23, 1965 dams and reservoirs built for multipur In the same spirit, the Senate has voted By the middle of the 20th century malap pose use on our rivers were operated in financial assistance to these flood ravaged portionment in State legislatures had reached an efficient and effective manner to sta areas. epidemic proportions. Justice Frankfurter I am proud to be a cosponsor of this bUl. in his dissenting opinion in Baker v. Carr ac bilize and equalize the water runoff, our knowledged "the gross inequality among damage would have been much greater. legislative electoral units within almost every Mr. President, I am attaching a list LEGISLATIVE APPORTIONMENT State," but he did not believe that these to this statement indicating the amounts gross inequalities would yield to judicial cor of money that are estimated to be neces Mr. DOUGLAS. Mr. President, the rection. His reasons were two: First, he sary along with the agencies and coun February issue of the American Bar As doubted that courts could devise workable ties involved in this undertaking in the sociation Journal contains an excellent standards because of his conviction that article on the Supreme Court decisions courts would shrink "from asserting that in State of Idaho. I am sure when you districting at least substantial equality is a study this list, you will agree with me on reapportionment of the State legisla tures. Its author, Robert McKay, is the constitutional requirement enforceable by that the individuals, the counties, the associate dean and a professor of law at courts." Second, he reminded that the Fed States and local governments are co eral courts lack direct enforcement powers ordinating their program in an excellent New York University. He is the author and so might be unable to devise workable manner. of the forthcoming book, "Reapportion remedies. "The courts' authority-possessed ment: The Law and Politics of Equality." Total estimated. flood repair needs neither of the purse nor the sword-ulti Army Engineers______$3, 460, 000 In his article, Dean McKay develops mately rests on sustained public confidence the background of the present rotten in its moral sanction." Idaho State Highway Depart- borough system, which deprives many of These arguments, which seemed weighty ment------·------2,093,000 in 1962, were proved surprising insubstantial U.S. Forest Service ______3,974,560 our citizens of a full vote simply because U.S. Bureau of Reclamation____ _ of where they live. This situation by 1964. The Supreme Court did not shrink 65,000 from defining equality to mean equality, and U.S. Bureau of Land Management 180,000 brought about the Supreme Court rul Idaho counties (incomplete) ___ _ it did devise a comprehensible standard 1,815,800 ings, beginning in 1962, that to dilute the which could be applied by courts without strength of a p·erson's vote because of examination in each case of the political TotaL------·------11, 078, 860 his place of residence denies him the factors which motivate legislative decision Breakaown of Idaho counties reported. to equal protection of the laws guaranteed making. The anticipated enforcement diffi aate him by our Constitution. The Court's culties also did not arise. The feared crisis Ada------ $25,000 finding was clear: the malapportioned of "public confidence" did not materialize Blaine------·------35,000 legislatures give many citizens drastically when the State legislatures and State courts Butte------ 6,640 less representation than others, in viola themselves took principal responsib111ty for ElmoreCassia------______6,000 compliance with the equal population prin 125,000 tion of the 14th amendment and the basic ciple enunciated by the Supreme Court. Lewis------·------8,800 principles of representative democracy. In Baker the Court professed to decide only The Senate Subcommittee on Consti NezMlnldoka Perce------·------______217,600 three things: (1) That Federal courts have Madison______100,000 tutional Amendments now has before it jurisdiction of suits challenging State legis 22,000 lative apportionment formulas for alleged Washington ______. ______several proposed constitutional amend Power______311, 760 ments designed to allow States to con violation of the equal protection clause of 460,000 tinue to deny the standards of fair rep the Constitution of the United States; (2) resentation which the Court has correct that such suits state justiciable causes of TotaL------··------1, 315, 800 action for which Federal courts may give ly held are required by the Constitution. appropriate relief; and (3) that qualified The PRESIDING OFFICER. The bill I ask unanimous consent that Dean Mc voters from underrepresented districts have is open to further amendment. If there Kay's article entitled "The Reapportion standing to raise the issue. be no further amendment to be proposed, ment Decisions: Retrospect and Pros With the advant9.ge of only a reasonable the question is on the engrossment and pect," be printed at this point in the amount of hindsight, it is not difficult to third reading of the bill. RECORD. realize now that decision of these issues The bill (S. 327) was ordered to be came perilously close to resolution of the There being no objection, the article substantive issue of standards as well. Jus engrossed for a third reading, was read was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, tices Frankfurter and Harlan, dissenting, the third time, and passed. as follows: recognized that Baker was the crucial case. Mr. KUCHEL. Mr. President, I move THE REAPPORTIONMENT DECISIONS; RETRO- Once the courts penetrated tha.t "political that the Senate reconsider the vote by , SPECT AND PROSPECT thicket," 2 there was no rational stopping which the bill was passed. ' (By Robert B. McKay, associate dean and place short of real implementation of the Mr. MANSFIELD. I move to lay that professor of law at New York University equal-population principle, in both houses motion on the table. School of Law} of State legislatures. It is difficult, bordering on the impossible, to explain how the 14th The motion to lay on the table was By the end of 1964 it already had become a amendment can require application of the agreed to. cliche of constitutional law to state that equal-population principle in one house of a Mr. MANSFIELD subsequently said: Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186 (1962), and State legista.ture but not in the other. At Reynolds v. Sims, 377 U.S. 533 ( 1964), had or least that is true unless one is willing to ac Mr. President, on behalf of the Senator dained a constitutional revolution in State from Alaska [Mr. BARTLETT], I ask cept the so-called Federal analogy as a basis legislative representation,! and that Wesberry for differentiation between the constitutional unanimous consent to insert his state v. Sanders, 376 U.S. 1 (1964}, had decreed the requirements for representation in the two ment on S. 327 into the RECORD. necessity for similar, although somewhat less houses. There being no objection, the state dramatic, changes in congressional district ment was ordered to be printed in the ing. The short of it is that substantial equal FEDERAL ANALOGY JUST ISN'T ANALOGOUS RECORD, as follows: ity in terms of population was held to be the Proponents of the Federal analogy in jus guideline principle for each house of all State tification of State legislative malapportion STATEMENT BY SENATOR BARTLETl' legislatures and for all congressional districts ment had pointed to the U.S. Congress as a It was with great satisfaction that I noted Within each State. There were, to be sure, model for inequality, with its Senate based the Senate took prompt action on aid for refinements of the "equal population princi on equal representation for each State re flood stricken areas of Oregon, Washington, ple" (as the Supreme Court labeled it), but gardless of population and the House rep California, and Idaho. the qualifications were not many. resentation closely related to population. We Alaskans know too well the havoc and With equality thus definitively fixed as the However, in Reynolds the Supreme Court financial loss inflicted by nature on the basic standard, inquiry must now be made as rejected the Federal analogy as inapplicable. rampage. to what these decisions portend for the ju Chief Justice Warren said that reliance on We are well aware that commercial in dicial process and for the political process in it was an "after-the-fact rationalization of surance only covers a fraction of the financial a representative democracy. fered in defense of maladjusted State appor loss. tionment arrangements." Certainly, the congressional formula had We know the importance of promptly bend 1 Companion cases decided at the same time ing our back to the task of rebuilding strick as Reynolas V. Sims were WMCA, Inc. v. Lo not been widely copied by the States. In en communities. menzo, 377 U.S. 633; Maryland Committee for 1964, when the Chief Justice wrote, no more In the true tradition of America, the peo Fair Representation v. Tawes, 377 U.S. 656; ple of the Nation, through their Government, Davis v. Mann, 377 U.S. 678; Roman v. Sin 2 This phrase comes from Justice Frank came to the aid of Alaska last year. We know cock, 377 U.S. 695; and Lucas v. Forty-Fourth furter's opinion in Colegrove v. Green; 328 the value of that help. General Assembly of Coloraao, 377 U.S. 713. U.S. 549 at 556 (1946). April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8345 than 10 States could have been described sented favored interest groups; and in the would have meant in nearly all States a grad as having a legislative apportionment for House of Commons "rotten boroughism" was ual shift of political power from the county mula even closely approximating that of at its height, so that large numbers of the seats in the rural areas to the cities. So the U.S. Congress,3 and each of those States people were not represented at all. changes were made, accompanied by aston departed to some extent, usually substan Apparently, these considerations were ishingly frank expressions of distrust for tially, from the alleged Federal model. much in the minds of those who drafted the majority rule. Behind those sentiments, Even more important are the historical Constitution of the United States. The first however, we can be sure lay the perfectly reasons for rejecting the Federal analogy. comprehensive constitutional scheme pre natural fear of diminished political power, State representation formulas commonly ad sented to the Constitutional Convention in specifically loss of legislative seats to the hered to the population standard until after 1787 was the Virginia plan. As originally population-gaining areas largely at the ex 1890 and the later departures from the equal proposed, it provided for representation in pense of the rural areas. accordance with popUlation in both Houses population principles were ordinarily moti HOW THE URBAN AREAS WERE DENIED POWER vated by considerations of selfish advantage of the Congress. At one time during the to particular interest groups. To under Convention a majority of the States voted for The response was of two kinds: :stand how and why this should have oc that plan in principle; but, as is well known, 1. In many States, including such popu curred in nearly every instance more than a it was ultimately agreed that the small lous States as California, I111nois, Michigan, ,century after the ratification of the Consti States would be allowed representation equal New York, Ohio, and Pennsylvania, the con tution, it is necessary to see why it was that to that of the large States in the Senate, stitutional formula was adjusted to preserve State representation formulas were origi the price necessary to secure their agree legislative control in the areas of declining nally most often based on population in both ment to form a union. And so the sovereign population regardless of subsequent shifts in houses of bicameral State legislatures and States entered into a consensual union based population. The device was, of course, to why it was that these formulas were later almost exclusively on representation in rela make population of slight of at least dimin modified or abandoned in many States. The tion to population in one House and not at ished importance in one or both houses. simple truth is that the original constitu all in the other. These formulas tended to become locked into tions in 36 of the 50 States provided for Further striking evidence that population the constitutions, because with continuing representation largely in accordance with equality as a basis for electoral representa population shifts, the number of legislators population in both houses of the legisla tion was a view wid·ely accepted at that time who would be prejudiced by a return to ture.' But by 1964 the vast majority of is the fact that article II, section 14, of the emphasis on population was bound to in the representation formulas allowed sub Northwest Ordinance of 1787, intended by crease. Change often became a virtual 1m stantial departure from population in one Congress for the future governance of all possib111ty. or both houses of the legislature. that vast territory, included the following 2. Where amendment of the constitutional During the first century of U.S. history rep requirement: "The inhabitants of the said formula was not practicable for one reason resentation in State legislatures throughout territory shall always be entitled to the or another, a number of State legislatures the Nation bore a close relationship to popu benefits • • • of a proportionate represen simply ignored the State constitutional pro lation, usually in response to requirements tation of the people in the legislature." visions for periodic (usually decennial) re apportionment to take into account popu of the State constitutions. But even where MAJORITARIAN IMPULSES GOVERN THE STATE the representation formula in the State con lation changes. Tennessee, from whence stitution was to some extent dependent on The story of the development of repre came Baker, and Alabama, the source of Rey local political subdivisions, counties or towns, sentation formulas for State constitutions nolds, were such States. So was Maryland, the deviations from population equality were reflects similar majoritarian impulses for which produced Maryland Committee for Fair usually not large. Malapportionment, in the more than a century after 1776, when the Representation v. Tawes, where the legisla first of the constitutions of the Original ture simply ignored repeated popular votes sense we have come to know it in recent Thirteen States were being drafted. Al decades, was not a factor that seriously dis calling for the convening of a constitutional though several of the Original Thirteen convention. And, of course, some States, not torted the representation process until late States adopted apportionment formulas in the 19th century. content to rely on constitutional change which today produce substantial inequality or on legislative foot dragging alone, did a THE BACKGROUND OF POPULATION among election districts, the population at little of both. REPRESENTATION the time those formulas were approved was The result was malapportionment, tested The reasons for the original emphasis on much more evenly spread among the coun by any measurable standard. By 1962, when population as the basis for legislative repre ties that were given equal representation the Supreme Court first held that this was sentation are rooted in the American philos (as in Delaware and New Jersey) and among a matter for judicial cognizance, the popula ophy of representative government, as the towns that were given equal represen tion disparities among election districts were adapted to the pragmatic realities of Ameri tation ( as in Connecticut, Rhode Island, as high as 987 to 1 (the Vermont House) and can federalism. American constitutionalism and Vermont). Today the situation has 422 to 1 (the California Senate); and in has always included three principal themes been vastly altered by the shift of popUla 1962, immediately before the decision in liberty, equality, and m ajority rule. All tion to the great urban centers. Baker, a voting majority could be elected in were derivative to some extent, but the amal The various formulas in the State con each of eight State senates by less than 20 gam was a distinctively American contribu stitutions adopted before 1787 did not, how percent of the population, including Cali tion. ever, furnish the pattern for the National fornia (10.7 percent), Florida (12.3 percent), The notion of liberty may be t raced to the Congress. Even more significant is the fact and Nevada (8 percent). English Revolution of 1688 and the resulting that the congressional formUla, ordained The original decision to give equal repre bill of rights promulgated the following by the great compromise, did not serve as a sentation in one house of Congress to each year. The influence of John Locke had been model for States later admitted to the Un State had been grounded on another fact substantial then, and his writings continued ion. Between 1790, when Vermont was of political life relevant to the States but to be important in the formation of the Gov admitted, and 1889, when Montana was ad not to their political subdivisions. That is ernment of the United States a century later. mitted, almost 100 years later, every State the fact that States are themselves sovereign The important theme of equality may be admitted to the Union entered with a con governmental entities whose borders are im credited in part to Rousseau, the principal stitution providing for representation mune from alteration without their consent philosopher of the then looming French based principally on population in both and whose retained authority ts guaranteed Revolution, with its motto of "liberte, egalite, houses of the legislature.5 by the Constitution. Counties, cities, towns, fraternite." These ideas were well known to To speak of those 19th century legisla villages, and other local subdivisions are Jefferson, who included in the Declaration tures in terms of acceptance of the prin solely creatures of the State, subject to al of Independence the broad assertion that "all ciple of population as the basis for appor teration or obliteration at the discretion of men a.re created equal" and thus showed him tionment is not, however, to suggest that their parent authority, and altogether lack self already ahead of his times. there was mathematically precise equality ing in assurance of any residuum of retained Majority rule, however logical an outgrowth among the districts at that time. A num authority.6 ber of States, particularly in the West, re of liberty and equality, was the boldly new REAPPORTIONMENT DECISIONS WERE NO SURPRISE American contribution to the philosophy of lied on county boundaries in drawing their government. Even the limited experiments apportionment formulas, but the distor For the reasons already stated, the decision with democracy known to the world up to tions which resulted from assuring each in Reynolds requiring substantial popula this time were not genuinely based on ma county at least one representative, for ex tion equality among election districts should jority rule. In 18th century England the ample, or from grouping whole counties to have come as no great surprise. Once the House of Lords, without any pretense of form election districts, were much less in equal protection clause was ruled applicable representing people, unashamedly repre- agricultural and rural America, as it then and the Federal analogy shown to be inap was, than in industrial and urban America, plicable, the already fammar facts of mal apportionment pointed inescapably in the s Arizona, Connecticut, Idaho, Montana, as it now ls. As the United States became primarily direction of the Court's command for sub Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, Rhode stantial equality among election districts. Island, South Carolina, and Vermont. an industrial and urban nation, honest ap 'Advisory Commission on Intergovernmen plication of the representation formulas tal Relations, Report on Apportionment of 6 See the discussion in Reynolds v. Sims, State Legislatures, 10-11, 35, 69 (1962). •Id. at 11. 377 U.S. 533 at 575 (1964). 8346 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE April 23, 1965 Similarly, the 1964 decision in Wesberry parently satisfactory compliance, in most of along political subdivision lines to det er the v. Sanders, requiring near-population equal the States.10 When there are added the possibilities of gerrymandering." 1a ity among congressional districts, should not States in which the present formula is val This receptiveness to individualized appor have been particularly surprising, even id, of which there are probably a few, and tionment formulas should encourage stu dy of though that ruling was groun ded on the re the States in which initial legislative action local government to determine what State quirement of article I, section 2, of the Con is probable in 1965, one might speculate that governmental function is served by each of stitution that Members of the House of Rep the prospects for ratification of a constitu the local units--the counties, cities, towns, resentatives be chosen "by the people." The tional amendment by three-fourths of the villages, school districts, and other special same underlying doctrine--faith in the prin State legislatures would be dim indeed, even purpose districts. If, for example, the town ciple of majority rule--was found to have if, as now appears unlikely, approval of such is found to be the significant instrument of been incorporated into the Constitution as an amendment could be secured by the neces local government, county lines may not be to the choice of Representatives. Any other sary two-thirds vote of each House of Con relevant in legislative representation. When decision would have made a mockery of the gress. inquiry is made into these matters and into plain sense of the compromise which pro The propositions advanced in the earlier the extent of county and city home rule, it duced the equal representation of all States part of this paper-that the equal-popula m ay be that duplication of function will be in the Senate, while assuring representation tion principle is sound constitutional doc revealed. in accordance with population in the House trine and that the decisions seem now des The local governmental process ordinarily of Representatives. tined for implementation and not reversal has proved quite unyielding to demands for The reaction to these decisions was inter suggest the appropriateness of giving brief change; but improvement may prove less dif esting. To whatever extent there may have attention to a third point. What problems ficult when legislatures are no longer tied been doctrinal disagreement with the re of implementation and interpretation lie exclusively to local units of government and quirement of equality in congressional dis ahead? What benefits may be anticipated thus become more directly responsible to the tricting, it was largely swallowed up in the from full compliance with the equal-popula voters. Return to majority rule in State leg fact of acquiescence. A number of States tion principle? islatures holds promise of giving to the de made legislative adjustments almost at once The equal-population principle now held mand for States rights a new dignity -and to come into compliance with the mandate applicable to State legislatures has been urgency. of near equality.7 Where there was initial criticized, principally perhaps by those who 2. TO WHAT EXTENT, IF ANY, DOES THE CONSTI failure to act, the problem seemed not to in have not read the decisions or refuse to be volve dispute as to whether equality should lieve what they read, on the ground that TUTION FORBID THE PARTISAN GERRYMANDER? be legislated, but involved instead the the Court has required the absurdity of By the end of 1964 the Supreme Co-urt had familiar issue of whether the lines should mathematical equality among congressional offered no direct guidance on this obviously be drawn in one way or another. These districts and in State legislative representa troublesome problem. In Wright v. Rockefel difficulties can eventually be surmounted, tion. But the Court denied that implications ler, 376 U.S. 52 (1964), in which appellants and it must be assumed that the decision as plainly as words can speak: claimed that the election district lines in the in Wesberry has been accepted as part of "Mathematical exactness or precision is four congressional districts in Manhattan had the Iiving law. hardly a workable constitutional require been drawn along lines based on racial con The situation in relation to Reynolds is, siderations, the Court affirmed the lower however, rather different. The initial re ment. What is marginally permissible in one State may be unsatisfactory in another, court's d ismissal of the complaint for failure action was mixed and, it must be said, some to show legislative contrivance to segregate what confusing. As might be anticipated, depending on the particular circums,tances of the case. So long as the divergencies from on the basis of race or place of origin. But many State legislators, particularly those even that case did not raise the ultimate whose seats were placed in jeopardy, objected a strict population standard are based on legitimate considerations incident to the question whether an artful arrangement of strenuously; the Republican Party (perhaps election districts to promote political advan inadvisedly, even from a partisan standpoint) effectuation of a rational State policy, some derivations from the equal population prin tage ( as opposed to racial discrimination) is stated support in its platform for a constitu forbidden by the equal protection clause or tional amendment; and efforts were m ade in ciple are constitutionally permissible with re spect to the apportionment of seats in either by any other provision of t h e Constitution. Congress, ultimately unsuccessful, to deny Elimination of gross population dispari or to postpone the exercise of jurisdiction by or both of the two Houses of a bicameral State legislature." 11 ties removes one of the devices by which Federal courts in connection with apportion partisan advantage has in the past been ment matters, When State experimentation with various secured. There is no difficulty, however, in It was hard to believe, however, that this representation plans was thus invited, the imagining instances in which equality is reaction represented majority sentiment; it Court was of course aware that further liti satisfied but the representative function was, after all, the majority of the voters, gation would be necessary to distinguish that nevertheless is seriously undermined by the until then frequently underrepresented in which might be marginally permissible in gerrymander. congressional districts and in State legisla one State from that which may be unsatis factory in another. Prediction as to which It is clear at least that Congress can, as tive representation, who stood to benefit from it once did,14 require compactness and con these decisions. Not surprisingly, when the of the myriad of possible variations will be upheld and which rejected is too specula tiguity in the drawing of congressional dis voters learned the significance of the de t rict lines. This requirement should be re cisions (in part from the largely favorable tive to be worthwhile at this juncture, but instated for congressional districting; the press reactions), they reacted as might have it may be helpful at least to outline some of adoption of similar requirements would be been expected. A Gallup poll conducted in the questions that are likely to arise. useful additions to State legislative repre August 1964 recorded a 3-to-2 support for 1. TO WHAT EXTENT MAY ELECTION DISTRICT sentation formulas. It is difficult to see how the decision ; mayors of the principal LINES BE BASED ON E XISTING POLITICAL SUB any political party could raise good-faith cities importuned the White House to oppose DIVISIONS SUCH AS COUNTIES AND TOWNS? objections to such a requirement in supple the restrictions on Federal court jurisdiction The Court specifically recognized that some ment to the constitutional necessity for then being debated in Congress; and the deviations from population might be based equality.:IE Democratic Party, although silent on the on State preference for "insuring some voice issue in its platform, gave important behind 3. MAY A STATE ESTABLISH MULTIMEMBER to political subdivisions, as political subdi AS WELL AS SINGLE-MEMBER ELECTION the-scenes support to the Court and the 2 visions." 1 Although the distortion cannot DISTRICTS? decisions.s be so great as to subvert the basic norm of Meanwhile, the lower Federal courts, the The equal-population principle, as formu population equality, considerable latitude lated by the Supreme Cour t, does not in so State courts and even the State legislatures remains. moved with almost surprising alacrity to many words address itself to the question ward good faith compliance. The Court had "Local governmental entit ies are frequently whether State legislators and Representa warned that "once a State's legislative ap charged with various responsibilities incident tives to Congress may be chosen, within the portionment scheme has been found to be to the operation of State government. In discretion of each State, from single-member unconstitutional, it would be the unusual many States much of the legislature's activity constituencies or from multimember dis case in which a court would be justified in involves the enactment of so-called local leg tricts. In commenting on the possible ways not taking appropriate action to insure that islation , directed only to the concerns of par in which varied bases of representation no further elections are conducted under the ticular political subdivisions. And a State could be achieved between the two houses invalid plan." 9 By the end of 1964 reappor may legitimately desire to construct dist ricts tionment had either been completed, or sub 13 377 U.S. at 580-581. stantial steps had been taken toward ap- 10 By the end of 1964 changes had been 14 See, for example, 17 Stat. 28 (1872 ) , 31 effected in 16 States, and in at least as many Stat. 733 (1901). 7 States the existing systems had been held For example, Colorado, Connecticut, 1o Several courts have suggested that com Georgia, Michigan, and Wisconsin. invalid, in many cases with a judicially im pactness, equality, and "neutrality" may be s I have reviewed that congressional epi posed date (most often 1965) by which com secured by the use of computer techniques. sode in "Court, Congress and Reapportion pliance was to be completed. For a discussion, · see Weaver and Hess, "A ment," 63 Mich. L. Rev. 255 (1964). 11377 U.S. 577-579 (1964). Procedure for Nonpartisan Districting: De II Chief Justice Warren in Reynolds v. Sims, 12 This language is from 377 U.S. at 580, velopment of Computer Techniques," 73 377 U.S. 533 at 585 (1964). with emphasis supplied. Yale~- J. 288 (1963). April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE 8347 of a bicameral legislature, Chief Justice plan.is In Vermont the court ordered that a By reminding ourselves of the Armenian Warren observed in Reynolds v. Sims, with new plan be established by April 1, 1965, and tragedy, however, we should see more all the casualness of unstudied dictum, that that State legislators elected under the in clearly the vital necessity for seeking a "One body could be composed of single valid apportionment enact no legislation ex world in which such events cannot re member districts while the other could have cept that relating to reapportionment.20 at least some multimember districts." But And in Georgia the court enjoined submis cur. it may not be quite that easy. ·sion to the voters for ratification of a pro Approximately 250,000 persons of Ar The issue is presented in Fortson v. Dorsey, posed new State constitution approved by menian origin now live in the United 228 F. Supp. 259 ' (N.D. Ga. 1964), a case the malapportioned legislature. But the Su States, and I am proud that several challenging the validity of the 1962 Georgia preme Court, in a somewhat inconclusive thousand of them make their homes in senatorial apportionment.16 By that act the per curiam order, vacated and remanded for my State of Indiana. State was divided into 54 senatorial districts, reconsideration in the light of subsequent Mr. President, I salute the Armenian generally adhering to county boundary lines. developments.21 people for their courage and their dedi In order to conform to some extent to the Whether the Court will uphold or reject equality requirement, some of the districts particular judicial restraints imposed by the cation to human freedom. included two or more counties, some were lower Federal courts on legislative action is, single counties, and some consisted of por of course, difficult to predict. What does tions of counties. All were single-member seem moderately clear is that some discre SPEECH OF SECRETARY FOWLER districts except that, where more than one tion will be continued in the Federal courts Mr. HARTKE. Mr. President, I have senator was assigned to a single county, all charged with protecting against further en received a copy of the first speech de senators were to be elected at large. The croachment on the equal-population prin livered publicly by Secretary of the three-judge Federal district court held that ciple. Treasury Henry H. Fowler following his the provisions for ·county-at-large elections 5. WHAT ADVICE SHOULD BE GIVEN TO STATE in the populous counties violated the equal confirmation by the Senate and his as LEGISLATURES IN DEVISING NEW APPORTION sumption of office. It was delivered be protection clause of the 14th amendment. MENT FORMULAS? On January 18, 1965, the Supreme Court fore the Washington Conference of the reversed the district court, repeating what The Supreme Court ruled that legislative Advertising Council on Tuesday, April 6. had been said as dictum in Reynolds, now as compliance with the equal-population prin While it is a short speech, it touches up the holding of the Court, that one body of a ciple will be tested by a good-faith stand ard, including the possibility of individual on a number of the areas which lie within bicameral legislature could have at least some the Secretary's responsibility and affirms multimember districts. Justice Brennan, for. variations among the States. The local gov the majority, emphasized that the Court did ernmental process has been made to seem his desire to maintain a continuity of no more than uphold the statute on its face. mysterious only because of too-long neglect policies while, as he says: and lack of careful study. If the premises "It might well be that, designedly or other Further sharpening the tools we have de wise, a multimember constituency appor of the State and local representation func veloped, and patiently applying the lessons tionment scheme, under the circumstances of tion are now reexamined conscientiously, the we have learned in recent years to the tasks a particular case, would operate to minimize benefit result ing to government from that of sustaining our domestic economic mo or cancel out the voting strength of racial study alone would justify the temporary dis mentum and at the same time bringing our or political elements of the voting popula locations attendant upon reapportionment. international accounts into balance. tion." Thus, the validity of the gerrymander Once the study has been made which is to serve racial or political ends has not yet here suggested, there should be little dif Mr. President, I ask unanimous con been passed upon. ficulty in devising a system that is fair and sent that the speech be printed in the workable. RECORD. 4. TO WHAT EXTENT MAY THE FEDERAL COURTS To facilitate adjustments that may prove INTERVENE IN THE STATE LEGISLATION PROCESS necessary, the most useful device is likely to There being no objection, the speech TO ASSURE SATISFACTION OF THE EQUAL-POPU be an effective apportionment commission was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, LATION PRINCIPLE? which can be charged with a continuing as follows: In Reynolds the Court recognized that study of the reasons why particular appor REMARKS BY THE HONORABLE HENRY H. FOW "legislative reapportionment is primarily a tionment plans prove to be well or poorly LER, SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY, BEFORE matter for legislative consideration and de adapted to the needs of the State. If this THE WASHINGTON CONFERENCE OF THE AD termination, and that judicial relief becomes commission cart be nonpartisan, so much the VERTISING COUNCIL, APRIL 6, 1965 appropriate only when a legislature fails to better. The political side of the govern Had your conference been but a week reapportion according to Federal constitu mental process has quite enough with which earlier, I might have found myself on the tional requisites in a timely fashion after to concern itself without insisting that other side of this platform, among the ques having had an adequate opportunity to do the "thicket" of legislative representation tioners. The passage of a week's time and so." Only in that case, and in the Oklahoma continue forever to be "political." 1 the change in seating arrangements are case, 1 has the Supreme Court approved hardly enough to alter my basic role in your affirmative judicial intervention as a remedy session. So I count it a privilege to listen for an existing apportionment formula found ARMENIAN MEMORIAL DAY and learn. to be invalid, and both of those were excep But even a recently returned sojourner tional cases of legislative failure to reappor Mr. BAYH. Mr. President, a half cen tury ago the world was sickened and from private life may be permitted a few tion after repeated judicial attempts to general observations. First, the national secure legislative reapportionment. saddened by the virtual eradication of economic goals referred to have the same Subsequently, three-judge Federal district the proud little nation of Armenia. familiar ring as they did when I left the courts have sought in several instances to Hundreds of thousands of Armenians Treasury 12 months ago. · limit legislative action in connection with were executed or died from other causes Second, I do feel and hear a more insistent anticipated reapportionment. Four ex directly related to their persecution. A and welcome emphasis on the fact that the amples will suffice. In New York the court quarter of a million Armenians escaped challenges and opportunities in our national limited the term of legislators elected in terror by fleeing to Russia. economy arise in large part out of the in 1964 to 1 instead of the usual 2 years and herent dynamics of our free market system, fixed April 1, 1965, as the time within which April 24 has been established as Ar 18 menian Memorial Day. That date in as it ceaselessly changes and grows, and they reapportionment was required. In Con can and must be met in that same frame necticut the court ordered that no legislative 1915 marked the beginning of horrible work. elections be held in November 1964, and that brutalities against the Armenian people. Third, there is a considerable consensus on the holdover legislature prepare a temporary Why should the anniversary of this the fact that Government has an affirmative apportionment and prepare for a constitu tragic occurrence be observed? Nothing role, namely, a responsibility for helping to tional convention to establish a permanent can be done now to redress the wrongs shape a fiscal and financial environment in that were committed in the Armenian which business can flourish, and in which is Probable jurisdiction was noted by the massacre, which is a page of history the collective energies of business, labor, and Supreme Court on Oct. 12, 1964, and the Government can be applied to the achieve case was placed on the summary calendar. that cannot be erased. What happened ment of these goals. A joint motion to advance the case was to the Armenians was not the first, nor Achieving the proper mix of economic poli granted by the Court on Nov. 23, and it was the last, episode of genocide in the world. cies-both fiscal and monetary-is vital to argued on Dec. 10, 1964. successfully meeting the responsibilities of 17 W illiams v. Moss, 378 U.S. 558 (1964). 1s Pinney v. Butterworth, - F. Supp. - (D. the Treasury. The proper course ahead, as For the opinion on remand, see Reynolds v. Conn. 1964) . I see it, lies in carrying forward the main State Election Board, 233 F. Supp. 823 (W.D. 20 Buckley v. Hoff, 284 F. Supp. 191 (D. Vt. lines of existing policies, further sharpening Okla. 1964) . 1964), modified and affirmed per curiam, 33 the tools we have developed, and patiently 1s WMCA, Inc. v. Lomenzo, - F. Supp. - Law Week 3243 (Jan. 28, 1965). applying the lessons we have learned in re (S.D. N.Y. 1964), petition for cert. filed 88 21Fortson v. Toombs, 38 Law Week 4172 cent years to the tasks of sustaining our Law Week 8174 (Nos. 611, 623). ( Jan. 18, 1965) • domestic economic momentum and at the 8348 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE April 23, 1965 same time bringing our international ac pelled to ask for special efforts to curb that AMERICA'S GREAT AGRICULTURAL counts into balance. outflow-is evidence enough that our prog This is the course already clearly laid out ress is still incomplete. But, as I take up my EXTENSION SERVICE in the President's economic program for this new responsibilit ies, I do so in confidence Mr. MUNDT. Mr. President, now that year. The excise t ax reduction planned for that the main elements in our program are our Senate Agriculture Appropriations midyear is an excellent illustration of the sound, and that business and Government Subcommittee is underway with hear creative application of econ omic experience and all the people of our Nation working to ings, I think it is appropriate to point up to maintain a healthy and balanced expan gether have both the capacity and will to sion. ach ieve our national objectives at home and an agency of the Department which has Coming so soon after the liberalization of abroad . been neglected over the years but which depreciation and the enactment of the in has done outstanding work for th] farm vestment credit of 1962 and the income tax ers of our Nation. cut of 1964, it underscores a willingness to FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY OF TURK The Cooperative Extension Service use fiscal policy-and tax reduction in par ISH GENOCIDE OF ARMENIANS probably has as close contact with our ticular-as a more effective and flexible in farn_iers as any other agency, branch, or strument for sustaining our economic growth Mr. HARTKE. Mr. President, tomor by lifting burdensome or discriminatory t axes row is the 50th anniversary of the Ar service of the Department. The budget from the private sector while keeping sensi menian massacres of 1915 and following recommendation this year calls for an ble and effective limits on increases in Gov which shocked the conscience of the increase of $700,000. This increase rec ernment expenditures. world at the time. On April 24, 1915, ognizes the problem but only begins to Recent events abroad have made it plain the campaign began which was to last solve it. for all to see that the international stability If divided among the 3,000 counties in and standing of the dollar is not only a mat through 1918 and which resulted in the death of a million Armenians and the the United States, each would receive an ter of concern to world business and trade, average increase of about $233. but also directly affects our national security displacement and exile of another mil and our capacity for effective diplomatic ac lion. The total of 2 million Armenians Much more than this amount is tion throughout the world. A strong cur comprised about half of all Armenians needed just to help bring the salaries of rency is an essential underpinning for world living in 1915. Extension workers in line with prevail wide responsibilities, and we cannot--and we April 24 has been set as the official ing pay scales. Last year all classified will not fail in the job of keeping the dollar Armenian Memorial Day. On that date civil sezyice employees and postal work strong. ers received a substantial pay increase. This determination to balance our inter 50 years ago more than a hundred Ar menian intellectuals of Constantinople But nothing was provided in Federal leg national accounts is an essential prerequisite islation to raise the salaries of the 15,- to the successful negotiation of a sound were arrested, later to be transported modification of the international monetary into the interior of Turkey and killed. 000 Extension Service employees in the system to adapt it to the changing require The Turkish atrocities against these peo States. ments of an expanding free world economy. ple, who had once been proudly inde These 15,000 Extension workers prob The intensified balance-of-payments pro pendent but who were believed a threat ably contribute as much to the progress gram announced by the President in Feb to the Ottoman Empire, comprised per of agriculture and the Nation's overall ruary is already yielding good results. But economy as any other group of similar much more remains to be done before we can haps the greatest example of genocide in history prior to the advent of Hitler and size. They have the responsibility of claim success-for we need results not only providing educational support to every this month, or through the spring and sum his genocide of the Jews. Indeed, it was mer, but for the months and years ahead. Hitler who asked, speaking before the facet of our farm programs and to help Sometimes we hear the complaint that the Third Reich in 1939 just before the open ing to raise the standards of living for new elements in our total balance-of-pay ing of operations against Poland, "Who, families and youth throughout rural ments program-the voluntary efforts of pray say, remembers the Armenian mas America. business and financial institutions to achieve sacres today?" Too much emphasis is being given to savings through their own operations-repre a decline in number of farms. The true sent no fundamental solution. Instead, Perhaps if the world had recalled rather than seemingly forgotten the measure of agricultural needs is the prod some have suggested that we should, in effect uct. The farmers of this country are don a protective shell of tight direct con events of the generation before, there trols-or accept instead the risks and hazards would have been a greater and earlier producing more and better food and fiber for our domestic economy that would come understanding of the monstrous plot of than any nation in the world has ever from applying a hard brake to credit expan Hitler to exterminate an entire people seen. And they are doing it with the sion. I share none of that skepticism. within his borders. On this 50th anni least help and fewest acres since the start American business, I am confident, will not of this century. This is the current relax its early response to the President's call versary of the helpless martyrdom of the Armenians, against whom was turned miracle in American enterprise. for cooperation with the first sign of success. Such an achievement does not come But, I am equally certain that this kind of the might of a nation which was the voluntary program cannot, and should not, be ally of an earlier imperial Germany, we automatically. Without taking any looked upon as a permanent solution. The need to call to mind their plight. We credit from the many other agencies clear need remains to make our own economy need to recall that the United States has helping on farm programs, I emphasize even more competitive in world markets and not yet joined in official endorsement again that Extension workers have given to encourage capital flows into the United of the international Genocide Conven the educational service that has helped States. Nor can we relax our efforts to econ farmers and other rural people most in omize in dollar outlays for defense and aid tion, and that we need to maintain alert ness to the first beginnings of any such meeting the many challenges of the last abroad. And perhaps even more important, half century. we cannot escape the complex and difficult oppression of peoples by governments in task-a task that must be shared by our Eu any part of the world. Cooperative Extension is now starting ropean friends-of attacking at its roots the There are many Armenians in Amer its second 50 years of service to American basic source of the disequilibrium in world ica, men and women who came here, or agriculture. We should give it the sup capital markets. whose parents arrived, as a result of the port it deserves in meeting the many That is the fundamental approach that has events of 50 years ago. They have been problems still facing us. motivated the entire balance-of-payments ef a welcome addition to our melting-pot South Dakota alone could use nearly fort since 1961. Moreover our unequaled a third of the proposed increase in Ex record of price stability and sustained ad population, and they have enriched the vances in productivity are beginning to pay Nation. We owe it to them, and to Ar tension funds for the next fiscal year. off in a rising trade balance. Substantial menians wherever they are, to join them That much is needed to help keep the economies in Government spending abroad most skilled workers in extension and to have been achieved. The investment climate in remembrance of this 50th anniversary hire more specialists to meet the prob in the United States has vastly improved, of an event which can never die in their lems of farmers, families, and rural com with the result that greater outlets are de memories. munities in our State. veloping at home to absorb our vast savings. For the Armenian martyrs of 1915 con Although our Nation enjoyed the most And there are encouraging signs that Euro tributed to the success of America and peans more clearly recognize, and are begin prosperous year in its history in 1964, the ning to deal with, deficiencies in their own its allies in World War I against the income of farmers and ranchers in South capital markets. Turks, the Germans, and their alliance. Dakota was at a 5-year low. This has The fact that an extraordinary flow of As President Woodrow Wilson put it at been a result of drought, diseases, low capital abroad could undermine our progress the time, "The Armenians are our little prices for livestock, and high prices of last year-and that the President was com- ally." things they must buy. April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE 8349 Our farm people need the advice and better family living. Added educational exposed a vast area in both the United assistance of men and women with spe services are provided for youth-many of States and Canada to greater participation in cial training in the problems of agri whom have not found it possible to finish foreign trade. It provided access for the average size ocean carrier into the very heart cultural production and marketing. Re high school. land of the North American Continent, a search is giving us a vast amount of val We are especially proud of the success distance of approximately 2,400 miles from uable information. We should have of 4-H Club programs in our States. In salt water. It actually provided the United more and better-trained people to help 1964, membership in these clubs reached States with its fourth seacoast, a coast ad them interpret that research and to help a new high of 19,588 boys and girls be jacent to one of the Nation's greatest con them apply the knowledge gained to tween the ages of 9 and 19. centration of heavy and light industries, as everyday problems. The youth phase of the Cooperative well as rich farmlands producing farm prod Extension Service programs is compli ucts, of which grains are the dominating Extension workers are doing their production. It is estimated that better than share in training for greater service. mented by the fact that 75 other coun 40 percent of our Nation's industries, as well Two-thirds of the 59 State extension tries have established youth programs as population, are located either on the specialists in South Dakota, for example, similar to our 4-H Club program. Simi waterway or within a reasonable distance have master's or doctor's degrees in their larly, many other countries already have thereof. In due time, this waterway sys special lines of work. Five years ago only or are now setting up Extension programs tem will change many habits and practices one-third of the State's specialists were patterned after the Extension Service in of importing and exporting that previously as advanced in their training. the United States. What better proof applied to the Atlantic and gulf coast ports. It will provide a cheaper avenue of trans I am convinced that every dollar we do we need of the benefits of this service? portation for those already so engaged, and appropriate for extension work returns South Dakota might well be called a will make possible, through cheaper overall far more than that in increased agricul "feeder" State. Not only do we feed lots transportation costs, the entrance into for tural efficiency, better products for the of livestock and poultry, but we send out eign markets by industries that were re consumer, and improvement in rural of the State more than three-fourths of stricted by reason of the high cost of rail communities. the products of our farms. These fine transportation to other coastal ports. Con Let me give you one striking example products go into the marketing channels versely, it will open new markets for ex for consumers throughout our Nation porters in Europe and other continents on in that first category. the globe. It definitely provides a two-way A serious outbreak of western corn and also to other countries around the road for trade. rootworm damage in 1963 cost South world. When the seaway opened in 1959, ship Dakota corngrowers an estimated $2 mil We also supply large numbers of our owners and operators encountered many lion in yield losses. Extension entomol youth to industry and government in frustrating problems, some of such serious ogists and county agents conducted tests other States and foreign countries to proportions that many refused to return which showed that chemicals which improve the total skills and products of their vessels to the waterway system. In growers had been using were ineffective this land of ours. effect, the new waterway, as we say in the against this species. Sou.th Dakota has the good fortune of United States, received a "black eye," and being host to an international seminar many predicted it was doomed to failure. They quickly analyzed results from re There were a number of factors responsible search and some extension demonstra this summer. We look forward to this for the fiasco of 1959, as I experienced it in tion plots which helped provide informa opportunity of being the "show window" the port of Duluth. First and foremost, in tion on the proper treatment. Before of the United States for many foreign my opinion, was the inexperience of those in the 1964 planting season, they conducted friends. volved in port operations, port authorities, an intensive educational program on the In all of these activities I have men vessel agents, terminal operators, and long rootworm problem, chemicals that should tioned, you see the hand of our Coopera shore labor (stevedores). Every port, both tive Extension Service. Let us give large and small, envisioned being a second be used, how they should be used, how New York port overnight, at least that is they should be applied, and precautions them the support they need to main what their propaganda indicated. Very few to be taken in handling them. They tain-yes, to increase--the pace of prog ports were prepared for the onslaught of held many meetings for growers and ress for rural America. ocean-type vessels that surged through the dealers, issued thousands of fact sheets seaway locks when they were first swung open. They were, however, well prepared and bulletins, and used newspapers, ra THE PORT OF DULUTH, MINN. with welcoming ceremonies for the first ves dio, and television to reach farmers with sel to enter their harbor, and with gifts information about the program to con Mr. McCARTHY. Mr. President, be to shower upon the captain, and that is about trol western corn rootworm. fore the opening of the Great Lakes-St. as far as it went. Result was that 600,000 acres were Lawrence Seaway, in 1959, the port of In the major ports there were not suffi treated with the proper insecticides last Duluth was considered an inland port- cient modern transit shed berths and other spring. Savings from these treatments the largest inland port in the world, be docking areas. Many of the grain elevators' are estimated to be over $4 million to cause of the large tonnage of iron ore, loading spouts were not high enough to coal, and grain moving in and out of the effectively reach a vessel's hatch when she South Dakota comgrowers in that 1 was light. Tugboat crews, when available, year. port in Great Lakes shipping. lacked in the knowledge of docking and This estimated savings is more than Since the opening of the Seaway, the undocking safely this new type of vessel. twice as much as the total money spent port of Duluth is classified as a seaport, Longshore labor was inexperienced and in for all extension work in South Dakota in even though it is 2,400 miles from salt sufficient in number to meet the demands. 1964. And this is only one of the dozens water; and it is the fourth seaport in size Many ports' navigation channels had a depth of programs carried on by the coopera in the United States. The port of Du less than the seaway depth of 27 feet. Many luth includes the facilities at Duluth and marine terminals and grain elevators failed tive extension service in our State. You to deepen their slips even to the depth of can point to many similar results in your also those on the other side of the har their main harbor channels. Vessel agents State. bor, at Superior, Wis. increased in number, but not in experience, Extension takes a problem-solving Robert T. Smith, port director of the and above all, there was a shortage of quali approach. Another program on which port of Duluth, recently spoke to various fied pilots to direct vessels through the they have used this approach is that of vessel owners and shipping interests in strange waters. resource development. One of the prin Europe concerning the development of My heart ached for every shipmaster that cipal means of economic growth in the Great Lakes seaway in the past 6 came into the Seaway during that eventful years and the facilities offered by the year, and it was only through their constant South Dakota is agricultural develop vigilance that accidents were held to a mini ment. And a key to agricultural devel port of Duluth. I ask unanimous con mum under the circumstances. opment is water supply. sent that excerpts from his speech be The waterways connecting the lakes, re With Extension assistance, three water printed at this point in the RECORD. ferred to as connecting channels-to be spe conservancy districts have been orga There being no objection, the excerpts cific, those connecting Lake Erie with Lake nized to obtain better management of from the speech were ordered to be Huron, and Lake Huron with Lake Michigan water resources. printed in the RECORD, as follows: and Lake Superior, did not have a depth PORT OF DULUTH, MINN., U.S.A. corresponding with the Seaway's 27 feet. It Extension workers in home economics was not until the early part of the 1963 ship likewise devote their efforts toward help (By Robert T. Smith, port director) ping season that these areas had the 27-foot ing families solve problems in the use of The Great Lakes-St. Lawrence Seaway depth. At this time many of the ports con both human and financial resources for system of navigation, when opened in 1959, sidered as major ports do not have the 27-foot 8350 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 channel within their harbor district, and it nal, and grain elevator ship berths all have terminals where their usage ls confined ex may be as late as 1967 before they do. the seaway depth of 27 feet. clusively to general cargo handled by ship's Added to all the woes of 1959 was an atti Prior to the opening of the St. Lawrence gear. I can say, without fear of contradic tude of resentment on the part of many to Seaway, Duluth was considered as an exclu tion, that shipmasters I have talked with what they referred to as invasion by ocean sive domestic bulk shipping port, and further concerning the efficiency of our port have ships, because they thought they were in di had the distinction of being the world's all stated our public marine terminal is the rect competition with domestic lake vessels largest inland port, because of the millions best on the Great Lakes; our longshore labor through which they derived their livelihood. of tons of iron ore, coal, grain, and other is excellent; and the harbor leaves nothing This attitude had a direct bearing on the ac bulk commodities carried on what are known to be desired. These unsolicited compli tivities of port authorities. Many were de as lake-type vessels. As much as 80 million ments are usually concluded with a remark prived of funds to effectively promote a flow tons of bulk commodities moved through the to the effect that they wished all other ports of traffic. As would be expected, opposition port in one shipping season of approximately were like Duluth, as it is a true seaport. groups on the Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico 8 months. Because of its seaport status, The Port of Duluth, because of it.s geo seaboards continued their harassment of acquired when the seaway opened in 1959, graphical location, affords considerable sav Great Lakes shipping, and I might add, there · it is designated by the U.S. Army Corps of ings in inland transportation cost to a vast has been no letup in their tactics to this Engineers as the fourth port in size in the area that heretofore had little exposure to date. · United States. Because of its geographical the benefits of foreign trade. The savings The Seaway has had 6 years of experience, location, it serves a tremendous trade area have enabled a number of industries for the that has seen foreign trade-other than bulk that prior to the opening of the seaway had first time to become exporters and/or im grain-increase from 20,593,142 tons in 1959 little exposure to foreign trade. The trade porters. Industries within the area, now to 39,309,029 tons in 1964. During this pe area encompasses some 580,000 square miles, forced to use a Lake Michigan port, do so at riod there has been a marked improvement containing a population in excess of 10 mil additional expense of inland transportation. lion persons. It is primarily a grain, dairy, If they could use the Port of Duluth, their in efficiency on the part of all industries in cattle, and ore-producing area . There are, savings could very well result in increased volved in the handling of waterborne carriers. however, considerable manufacturing and business, producing more traffic for the ship Government agencies of all lake-bordering processing industries constantly expanding. operator, and from my experience in the States, consisting of Governors, congressional Because of the farming area we serve, we steamship business, the aim of all ship op representatives, mayors and other officials are the largest grain exporting port on the erators is the production of more and more have begun to take a keen interest in their American side of the Great Lakes, exceeded waterborne commerce. respective port's problems. They are begin only by Port Arthur and Fort William on the With the aid of regular liner services on a ning to effectively counter the moves of Canadian side. We have 11 grain elevators frequently scheduled basis, Duluth could be opposition groups. This was clearly evident with a combined capacity of nearly .70 million come the major import distribution port on when the Seaway toll structure was not bushels, and with ship's loading berths total the North American Continent. Imports changed in 1964. Another indication of the ing 13. Counting the weight of grain ex through the Atlantic coast ports can only Seaway's maturity was the forming several ported, and other commodities in direct for be directed in one way-west; from the gulf years ago of the International Association of eign trade, our port has held the No. 1 ports-north; and from the west coast Great Lakes . Ports, and just recently, the position since the advent of the seaway in ports-east. Whereas in Duluth, because of Great Lakes Terminals Association. Both 1959. its location in the very heartland of the associations were formed for the express pur During the 1964.shipping season, a total of North American Continent, imports can be pose of close cooperation in the promotion 3,273,005 tons moved through our port, nearly directed to the 4 points of the compass. of efficiency, and a solid front against the double the tonnage of the No. 2 port, Chi There is a manufacturer of small diesel en ever-pressing and m anipulated opposition cago. The port of Duluth has what is con gines in Germany who has seized upon this groups. sidered the best marine terminal complex opportunity by using our port as a distribu My remarks concerning the Seaway in gen of any Great Lakes port. In addition to tion center. We h ave shipped his engines to eral were a prelude to the specific reason for having transit shed berths and backup ware Los Angeles on the west coast, New York on my visit to your great country. As you no house, there is a tank farm consisting of 13 the east coast, New Orleans on the gulf coast, doubt have surmised, I am here to tell you storage t anks with a total capacity of 6,000 and to m any in-between areas. There are about the Port of Duluth, Minn. When I tons, and trackage for railroad tank cars ample storage facilities for this purpose. speak of Duluth, remember I am also re capable of holding 50 units at one time. During the 1964 shipping season, some 10,000 ferring to Superior, Wis. The two ports There is sufficient boiler capacity to heat the tons of various commodities were stored with serve a common harbor, separated by a very liquid contents of all the cars and tanks us for distribution durin g winter months narrow navigable river, and are considered as simultaneously. when the lakes are closed to navigation. one port of entry by U.S. Customs, Immigra There are four pumps with a total capacity tion, and other Federal agencies having juris of 270 tons per hour. The terminal also diction in the harbor. Vessel agents, Cus is equipped with two traveling gantry cranes, EXHIBIT toms, Immigration and other agencies having each with a safe working load of 90 tons, Predicted and actual tonnages moving to do with the port are domiciled in Duluth. and in tandem can lift 180 tons. Our through St. Lawrence Seaway, 1959 through There is one mark of distinction, and that ls heaviest lifts to date have been 125 tons. 1964 harborfront workers' unions. Each port has It is of interest to ~now that the arrange [In tons] its own union headquarters, but work in close ment of our facilities permits the pumping harmony with each other. In domestic lake of bulk liquids into a vessel's deep tanks Year Predicted Actual shipping circles, Duluth and Superior are re while loading and/ or discharging general ferred to as the "twin ports." cargo. The docking area accommodating There is a similar situation existing at the General cargo: our two gantry cranes permits the handling 1959 ______• 2, 500, 000 1, 950, 163 northern part of Lake Superior, where the of heavy lifts and steel directly between 1960 .. ------____------_ 2, 900, 000 2, 253,897 twin ports of Fort William and Port Arthur, railroad cars and vessel while the handling 1961 .. ------___ ---__ - - _ 3, 300,000 2,074, 183 1962 ______------3, 700, 000 2, 517, 608 Canada, are referred to as "lakehead ports." of general cargo by vessel's gear is being 1963. ______--___ ---__ Duluth's side of the harbor contains all of 4, 100, 000 2, 940, 795 performed. Another feature of our terminal 1964. ------4,400, 000 3, 676, 587 the general cargo terminals, as well as tank is the location of 11-m111ion-bushel grain Bulk cargo: farm, heavy-lift cranes, and some grain ele elevator complex on the opposite side of a 1q 59 __ • _-- _-- - - _--- ___ - 22, 500, 000 18,642, 979 vators. The Superior side at the present 1960 .• __ --_-- ______26, 100, 000 18, 056,449 325-foot-wide slip. Vessels loading parcel 1961. ___- - _-- __ ------__ 29, 700, 000 21,343,537 time consists only of grain elevators. lots of grain are permitted to use their own 1962 .. ------___ ---- __ 33,300, 000 23, 075, 992 Duluth ls the westernmost port on the lines i.n crossing to the terminal for load 1963 •. __ ------__ --__ 36, 900, 000 28, 002,095 Great Lakes-St. Lawrence Waterway. It ls ing of general cargo. 1964. -----_-- --__-- __ _ _ 39,600, 000 35,632,442 !~-----!------some 1,400 miles west of Montreal, and 2,400 The total area of the terminal site con Total, general miles from salt water. By direct steamer sists of 120 acres. Eighty acres are un cargo and bulk: 1959 ______25, 000, 000 20,593, 142 track we are only 90 miles farther from developed and held in reserve for additional 1960 ______yet terminal facilities when needed. This un 29, 000, 000 20, 310, 346 Montreal than Chicago, we penetrate the 1961. ______33, 000, 000 23,417, 720 very heartland of the North American Conti developed area is completely bulkheaded, 1962 ______37, 000, 000 25, 593, 600 1963 ______nent by 500 miles over the port of Chicago. with mooring bollards installed, and is used 1964 ______41, 000, 000 30, 942, 890 Our port is located in what is considered for temporary berthing by vessels preparing 44, 000, 000 39, 309,029 one of the world's best natural harbors. It their holds for grain, or waiting for a grain contains over 17 square miles of water sur berth. The design of the terminal provides for docking and undocking of vessels with LEGISLATION IN THE HEAT OF PAS face, with 49% miles of established harbor out the aid of tugs. Its location in relation SION DOES VIOLENCE TO THE line, well protected from Lake Superior by to Lake Superior eliminates the hazards of CONSTITUTION a sand spit 9 miles in length and approxi passing through swinging bridges, a prob mately one-half mile in width. The sand lem of many other Great Lakes ports. Eight Mr. ERVIN. Mr. President, I have spit is covered with vegetation, contains major railroad lines have access to the fa pointed out recently that 46.8 percent of many fine homes, and small boat docking fa cility, and, of course, there ls roadway ac all the nonwhites in North Carolina are cilities. Navigation channels, marine termi- cess for trucks. There are other marine registered on a statewide basis, accord- April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8351 ing to the figures supplied me 1by the U.S. overcome by passion and what, unfor judicial decision or from congressional Civil Rights Commission for the year tunately, appears in some instances to enactment of legislation which tends to 1965i be vindictiveness. destroy the traditional State-Federal Furthermore, 76 percent of · the totaiJ. !Mr. President, the emotional climate balance. Into this latter category, of voting age population in North Carolina Which surrounds· the 'President's goal to leg'islation· falls the· present voting rights were registered in 1964. implement the 15th amendment has en.:. bill, I It would appear that some of the rea tangled this well-intentioned goal with If it is true that S. 1564 is validly based sons attributed by the proponents of S. blatantly unconstiiutional prescr,iptions. on the 15th amendment, a supposition 1564 for the small percentage of North It occurs to me that before ,acting in the with which I disagree, it must conform, Carolina Negroes voting might also be heat of legislative passion to pass a vot nevertheless,. with -other sections of the applicable to New York and New York ing -r.ights bill, we should first delve deep Constitution in order to be valid. I be County where only 51.3 percent of the ly into the basic constitutional issue in lieve that this bill, which abolishes people of voting age voted, and particu v.olved: Does the President's proposal to States literacy tests, does violence to larly in New York's 17th, 18th, 19th, and enforce the ;I.5th amendment do violence article I, section 2; article II, section 1, 20th Congressional Districts which voted to other sections of the Constitution? clause 2, and the 17th amendment. 62, 146.7, 43 .5, and 52.1 percent, respec Of the administration's voting rights My opinion is that under these sections tively. These districts are largely lo bill two definite statements can be made: of the Constitution the States alone pos cated within New York County. First, the bill abolishes, in certain arbi sess the right to establish qualification13 The 18th Congressional District, which trarily selected areas of the country, a for voting. The very first article pro voted 46.7 percent of its voting age popu State's ,prerogative to prescribe literacy vides that, in choosing Members of the lation, is one of the few districts in the tests. Second, the bill abolishes by a House of Representatives, the electors United States represented by a Negro, simple legislative act State poll taxes. shall have the same qualifications re Congressman ADAM CLAYTON POWELL, Mr. President, I think most of us would quired for electors of·the most numerous and includes the heart of Harlem. It is agree that if there is any provision of the branch of the State legislature. The interesting to note that this ])eavily Constitution which prohibits the enact same propo~ition is enunciated by the Negro popularted congressional district ment of this bill, that provision will pre 17th amendment with respect to elec voted one-tenth of 1 percent less persons vail, and I maintain that the provisions tions of U.S. Senators. Under the only than the percentage of nonwhites regis of S. 1564 which abolish or suspend lit reasonable interpretation of article I, tered to vote in North Caroli~a. Can eracy tests and poll taxes, fly in the face section 2, and the 17th amendment, any anyone reasonably say that there is a of numerous provisions of the Constitu one qualified to vote for members of the widespread discrimination in Harlem, tion. most numerous branch of the State leg or would it not be more accurate to assert There is little doubt about the author1.. islature also is entitled to vote for Mem that general apathy is the reason for such ity of Congress and the States to amend bers of Congress and for Senators. Con little participation at the polls? the Constitution and to abolish literacy versely, those who do not have the right Yet, North Carolina is somehow dif tests and poll taxes. Indeed, only re to vote for State legislators are i.l.eligible ferent, according to the experts, notwith cently ,this deliberative body played a to vote for Members of the House and standing the fact that she has 76 per role in abolishing poll taxes in Federal Senate. Article I, section ·2, and the 17th cent of her voting age population ;regis elections by a constitutional amendment, amendment reveal unmistakably that tered to vote as compared to 74.5 percent and it did so by constitutional amend the qualifications for electors in the sen of the voting age population of New York ment because it realized it had no author atorial and congressional elections shall State. be the same as those for the election of ity to legislate in the area. State legislators, and it seems highly un Although the percentage of North Proponents of S. 1564 fail to recognize Carolinians of voting age who voted in likely that, either when the Constitution the last presidential election was only the existence of conditions precedent to was originally adopted, or at the time the exercise of the power of Congress to the 17th amendment was adopted, there 52 percent as compared to New York protect the right to vote. After the State's 63 percent, it is well to remem was any intent to ·give the Federal Gov ber that North Carolina had no hotly State determines who its voters are to ernment any power over State elections. be, after it sets uniform standards to In fact, when the 17th amendment re contested statewide election to draw out apply to all prospective voters, then the electorate whereas New , York had garding election of Senators was ratified perhaps the most vigorously contested Congress~ constitutionally may legislate in 1913, it in effect recognized and sanc senatorial race of the entire election and to insure that persons ,who meet those tioned anew the principles of article ,I, certainly one which stimulated a great standards are able to cast their ballot. section 2. Toe words in article I, section deal more voter interest and participa Congress has authority, under the 15th 4, of the Constitution, taken in conjunc tion. Notwithstanding the interest gen amendment, only to enact appropriate tion with section 2 of the same article, erated by that race, in the 18th Congres legislation to insure that no person is lead inevitably to the conclusion recited sional District of New York fewer people deprived of the right to vote because of by Mr. Justice Field in Ex parte Clark, of voting age voted than did the p~ple race, color, or previous condition of lOO _U.S: 399-1879-that: servitude. This amendment does not of two-thirds of the counties in North Regulations as to the manner of holding Carolina. Yet, no part of New York gtant a rright to vote where it did not elections cannot extend beyond the,designa comes under this bill whereas virtually formerly exist; it only prohibits the tion of ,the mode in which the will of the States from denying suffrage on the voters will be ~xpressed and ascertained.· Th~ one:..third of North Carolina would. 1 This, notwithstanding the assertion 6f ground of race or color. The essentially power does not authorize Congress,to d~ter the North Carolina Advisory Commit negative mandate _of the 15th amend mine' wlio shall participate in the electio~. tee to the U.S . . Commission on Cjvil ment, in effect, declares that if a person or what shall be the qualification of the vot can qualify under State laws to vote for ers. These are matters not pertaining to or Rights that the lack of voting rights involved in the manner of holding the eiec' complaints "may mean that the dispro members of the most numerous branch tion, and their regulation rests exclusively portionately low registration and low of his State legislature, the State may with the States. The only restriction upop. voting of Negroes in North Carolina is not deny him that ~ight because of his them with respect to these matters is found due more to apathy, or, as the registrars race, color, or previous condition of in t~e provision that the electors . of repre in Bertie and -Greene Counties suggested, servitude .. sentatives in Congress shall have the quali to poor schooling and poor school attend It is clear that under the Constitution fications required for electors of the most as it exists today, and under the deci numerous branch of the State legislature, ance, than to election officials' arbitrary arid the provision relating to the suffrage of denial of the right to register on account sions of the U.S. Supreme Court, when the colored race. And whatever regulations of race." Congress considers_ a bill to .establish Congress may prescribe as to the manner of The proponents of this bill have failed voter· qualifications, as ft is attempting llolding the election for representatives must to make a logical case for its discrimina to-do in S. 1564, it· considhs an amend be, so framed as to leave the election of State tory triggering provisions. The atmos ment to the Constitution. If the Con officers free, otherwise they cannot be main 1 tained.' phere in which the bill has been consid stitution is to be amended, ;r prefer that r ered has nqt been a dispassionate one or these amendments be adopted openly in According to James Madison's "Jour- one that was calculated to generate more the manner authorized by that' document nal of the Constitutional Convention," light than heat. Instead, logic has been itself, rather than result indirectly from article I, section 2, would appear to be CXI--628 8352 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - -SENATE April 23, 1965 the provision that met with .the most qualified voters. Additionally, the Court The Court also indicated that the re complete approval of ·the delegates to the in the Lassiter case said: quirement did not violate the equal pro Constitutional Convention. The over The present requirement, applicable to tection clause of the 14th amendment whelming majority there felt that the :q1embers of all races, is that the prospec,tive despite the fact that it exempted from right of the States ·to prescribe qualifi voter "be able to read and write any section payment the blind males under 21 and cations should remain unfet,tered; and of the Constitution of North Carolina in the over 60, and all females not voting. they were· loathe to authorize the Na English language." Tha.t seems to us to be Butler Thompson, ·one fair way of determining whether a per It is, perhaps, in v. _tional Legislature to decide who might son is literate, not a calculated scheme to 97 F. Supp. _17 We shall overcome. And it is the energy, creativity, and innova Ten years ago this week in Montgomery, AWARD TO VICE PRESIDENT HUM tion brought by Americans to the task of an average American decided to stand up PHREY BY ANTI-DEFAMATION democratic government· which has preserved fearlessly in defense of her God-given liberty. LEAGUE OF B'NAI B'RITH this Nation as a beacon of hope in a weary Mrs. Rosa Parks, the Negro seamstress, re and struggling world. ' fuseq. to move to the back of the bus. And Mr. RIBICOFF. Mr. President, on What was new in America after the nor an unknown young Baptist minister, Martin April 8 the Anti-Defamation League o.f malcy , of the 19~0's was the New Deal' of !-tuther King, Jr., found . himself leaping the B'nai B'rith honored Vice President Franklin D. Roosevelt, with its compassionate historic Montgomery bus boycott. · HUBERT H. HUMPHREY with its Human and realistic social programs for America, and Almost one decade later Martin Luther its good neighbor policy for nations 'of the Rights Award for 1965., 1 King returned to Montgomery. He returndd In my opinion, this .award could not world. not as an unknown Baptist preacher-not as What was new in Americ~and the world~ the leader of a spontaneous boycott-but as have been given to a more deserving after the desecratt'on of World War II was the the Nobel lau:r_eate who symbolizes America's man. Indeed, Vice· President HUM c,reative force of the Marshall' plan and point commitmept to fulfill the promise of the PHREY'S many years in public ·service 4 of Harry ,s. Truman which ·helped restore Emancipation Proclamation. have been a living tribute to the energy dignity and optimism to the Western World. These past io years will be known as the and imagination, the faith and courage, What was new in America after the lull of freedom dedade in American history. These that have made America great., ,The the fifties was the New Frontier of John F. past 10 years have demonstrated that Amer speech with which he responded to the Kennedy with i~ infusion of youth, talent, ica· still possesses the energy, faith, and spirit vigor, and confidence into our national life. which first established freedom on these honor given him on April 8, 1965, con 1 tained one of the finest descriptions I And what is new in America today is the shores. energy, yisiop, and faith of Lyndon B. John We ·know this battle is not yet over. But have heard of these very qualities and son as he challenges us to join with him in we also know that victory is certain. .And what they mean : in our quest to give building the Great Society. in winn~ng, America-and all mankind-will equal rights to .all the people of our Read any period o:( our history, and the know that the last, best hope of earth en- Nation. lesson -is alwayf! th,e ~an:ie: democracy ·in dures. ( I therefore ask unanimous consent to America is a difficult business. In fact, -!ll"nold Toynbee, the· noted British' histo man's eternal struggle to govern himself is rian, described the greatness of our genera insert in the RECORD the speech Vice the most dema:p.ding of all human endeavors. tion with these wo,rds: "Our age will be re President HUMPHREY delivered to the This is just as true today as it was ln th.e membered not for its horrifying crimes nor Anti-Defamation League of B'nai B'rith. days of this Nation's birth. its astonishing inventions, but because it is 8356 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE April 23, 1965 the first generation since the dawn of his I was privileged to be among the par China also insists on promoting Commu tory in which m-an dared to make the bene ticipants in the current series on Com nist forms of government-abetting revolu fits of civilization available to the whole tion and promoting violence in the develop human race." munist China, as were seven of my col ing nations, even where the people are op America--above all other lands--dares to leagues: Senators AIKEN, DODD, DOMI posed to this ideology. believe this is possible. NICK, KUCHEL, PROXMIRE, SALTONSTALL, Under such circumstances, the United Through such programs as the Peace and WILLIAMS of New Jersey. States cannot enter into trade relations with Corps, food for peace, and foreign economic Since the complete set of statements China nor consider her eligible for member assistance, we have given living meaning to would be too long for publication in the ship in the respected society of nations. We the historic words of John F. Kennedy that RECORD, I ask unanimous consent to have must, however, realize that China does exist, "here on earth God's work must truly be printed at this point in the RECORD a list that she is making progress, that her people our own." are better equipped to enjoy life, that she is Thus we must resolve to make no small of the other participants in the series militarily strong. plans-to accept no small results-and to and the statements made by Members If China will cease her efforts to foist regard each partial success as a stepping of the Senate. her ideology on weaker nations, renounce stone in the exhilarating task of extending There being no objection, the material her claims to lands to which she has no title the benefits of civilization to people every was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, and indicate by word and deed a desire to where. as follows: get along with the rest of the world, then All these great plans require only energy, we should be prepared to renew both trade creativity, and willingness of the spirit--the OTHER PARTICIPANTS IN "SEARCH OF A SOLU and diplomatic relations with the Chinese very qualities that built America into the TION: COMMUNIST CHINA" people. great Nation it is today. And while we need Dr. Derk Bodde, Department of Oriental an America with the wisdom of experience, Studies, University of Pennsylvania. STATEMENT BY SENATOR PETER DOMINICK, OF let us never permit America to grow old in Howard L. Boorman, modern China project. • COLORADO spirit. Benjamin Brad.lee, managing editor, News • There's no single issue of American foreign Let us always continue to be an America week. policy which commands such widespread of new faith in old dreams. Let us continue W1lliam Bundy, Assistant Secretary of agreement as does U.S. policy toward Com to be an America eternally vigorous and State for the Far East. munist China. This policy of strength and creative. Let us retain compassion in the Adm. Arleigh Burke, former Chief, U.S. firmness in dealing with the aggressive Pei midst of indifference, ideals in the midst of Naval Operations. ping regime has prevailed under four admin cynicism, belief in the midst of despair. 0. Edmund Clubb, former American Consul istrations. It reflects the sentiment of the Let America continue to be what it was General at Peiping. overwhelming majority of the American peo meant to be by its founders-a place for the John K. Cooley, correspondent, Christian ple toward a Communist-dominated China renewal of the human spirit and the libera Science Monitor. which grows bolder and more aggressive each tion of human energy. Norman Cousins, editor, Saturday Review. year. Indications of this sentiment were If there is anything new under the sun, Everett Drumwright, former Ambassador evident in the Democratic and Republican let it always be America. to Taiwan. , platforms of 1964. The Democratic platform Felix Greene, author of "A Curtain of carried a plank which states categorically, . Ignorance." and I quote, "We continue to oppose the ad EXCEPTIONAL PUBLIC SERVICE Roger Hilsman, former Assistant Secretary mission of Red China to the United Na RENDERED BY RKO GENERAL of State for Foreign Affairs. tions." The Republican platform included Joseph E. Johnson, president, Carnegie En- a plank, which said, and again I quote, "We BROADCASTING CO. dowment for International Peace. are opposed to the recognition of Red China, Mr. JAVITS. Mr. President, I call at- Former Congressman Walter Judd. we oppose its admission to the U.N., we tention to an exceptional public service Arthur Krock, of the New York Times. steadfastly support free China." by RKO General Broadcasting. This Max Lerner, of the New York Post; profes- As of this moment, more than 313 Mem· sor, Brandeis University. hers of the new 89th Congress, from both group of 5 TV and 7 radio sta Sol M. Linowitz, chairman of the board of parties, and from both the House and the tions, including WOR-TV and radio in the American Association for the United Na Senate, have endorsed a resolution which New York, has produced and is current tions. states their opposition not only to diplo ly broadcasting a special series · of 30 Henry Cabot Lodge, former Ambassador to matic recognition and admittance of Red statements in answer to a crucial and the United Nations. China into the U.N., but also their opposi timely question: "The United States and Robert Murphy, former Ambassador to sition to establishi.ng trade relations between Communist China: What Should Our Japan. the United States and Red China. This Dr. David N. Rowe, Yale University. widely accepted resolution also spells out Policy Be?" Harrison Salisbury, of the New York Times. their opposition to any policy of accommo The overall name for this RKO Gen Eustace Selig111an, honorary chairman, For- dation which might be interpreted as U.S. eral project-a continuing national sym eign Policy Association. acquiescence in, or approval of, Communist posium-is "In Search of a Solution," George Taylor, director, Russian and Far China's aggression, direct or indirect, against This is the third such search for a solu East Institute, University of Washington. her neighbors. tion undertaken by this firm. Previous Now Communist China, which in the ones have concerned the questions: STATEMENT BY SENATOR GEORGE D. AIKEN, OF early 1950's was feared not so much for VERMONT her own military strength as for her Russian ''What Should Be Done To Resolve the Some people resolve the problem of U.S. support, has now, in the 1960's, become an Civil Rights Crisis Peacefully and Just policy toward China by simply ignoring the open threat to Asian and worldwide secu ly?" broadcast in 1963, and "How Can existence of this great land area and its rity. While keeping more than 600 million We Solve the Problem of Presidential population of 700 million people. mainland Chinese in bondage, her Commu Succession and Disability?" broadcast Others have felt that in the course of time nist masters have murdered more than 18 in 1964. the forces of Chiang Kai-shek would return million of her own people, and have forcibly In this pioneering and original pub to the mainland and oust the Communists overrun and enslaved the Tibetan and Mon from power. golian states. They have conducted aggres lic service concept, RK.O General focuses Both schools of thought should be dis sion as far w_est as India, and have con public attention on an urgent problem, illusioned by now. t inually fomented civil disorder, rebellion, permits untrammeled expression of vary Since the Communists have come into and revolution throughout southeast Asia. ing points of view, points to the need of power, China has steadily grown stronger Our State Department has Just recently a solution, and helps raise the level of economically, militarily, and industrially. released a white paper clearly documenting public understanding and interest. Each Where once ostracized by the Western the hand of Red China around the throat statement is heard individually and fre World, the Chinese now have established of South Vietnam. And we now have thou trade relations with most of the non-Com s3,nds of American boys in that theater of quently, on an around-the-clock sched munist nations-the United States being the operation attempting to break the Commu· ule on all RKO stations for 6 weeks, so principal exception. nist stranglehold. Communist Chinese ag as to reach the widest possible audience. The Chinese pay their bills promptly and gression has not been limited to nations Credit for this unusually worthwhile are found to be good customers of those having contiguous borders with her own, nor public service effort is due to the presi nations that deal with them. even to those on the Asian continent. They dent of RKO General, Hathaway Wat China has, up to now, been refused ad have also actively supported the revolu son, its two executive vice presidents, mittance to the United Nations since she tionary activities of Fidel Castro, who now refuses to renounce violence as a means for maintains the second most powerful mili Sam J. Slate and Jerome Bess: and its settling international disputes and since t ary force in the entire Western Hemisphere, director of public affairs, Martin Wel she will not consider membership rxcept as And these same Chinese Communists are don, who conceived the project and pro such membership carri.es with it the right working feverishly to subvert many of the duced the series. to absorb Taiwan. newly independent states of continental April 23, 1 !J65 CONGRESSIONAL R'ECORD - "SENATE 8357 Africa. Wherever the Chin¢se Communists However, I believe we have got to find ways with a veto over any action the Security have seen an opportunity to subvert the to open the doors somewhat between us, Council can take. cause of freedom they have not hesitated and I think the best openings will come in Red China has declared that her present to move in quickly and, in far too many some type of exchanges of journalists and policy is against coexistence. She believes in cases, effectively. · students, which conceivably might be fol using war as an instrument of national Recognizing that the Communist Chinese lowed by something in the economic field. policy. Now any nation which takes that have no intention of working with the policy has no place on the Security Council United States ·toward a just and lasting STATEMENT BY SENATOR THOMAS H. KUCHEL, and no place in the United Nations, because peace, the American people and their Gov OF CALIFORNIA on the Security Council with a veto power ernment believe that the maintenance of a There is nothing in the recent history of Red China would be in a position to block strong opposition to Red China is absolutely. Red China-the so-called Chinese Repub any effective action by the United Nations. necessary to our own national security. We lic-to indicate any peaceful intentions Now this doesn't mean that I feel that our cannot afford to do less, even though we can whatsoever. She continues to supply war policies.must be inflexible. After all, nations have diplomatic discussions with them materiel to Hanoi, North Vietnam, and to aren't entrenched in concrete. They change, through outside sources other than the U.N.; give them all the aid and encouragement of and Red China may change. But until she or through recognized circles. does change, with specific actions, definite which she is capable of giving. Recently, actions that show that she has changed, it she has threatened Thailand. A few seems to me it would be a great mistake for STATEMENT BY SENATOR THOMAS J. DODD, OF months ago she raped Tibet. She has had CONNECTICUT . us either to recognize Red China or to favor many border incidents ~nd confli.cts with her her admission to the United Nations. The question of Red China looms large in neighbor, India. One final point. Of course, most of us are the public mind. Despite the record of ex In all this background how different the deeply concerned with the situation in South perience with dictators and aggressors in our policy of the people and the Government of Vietnam. Here we're opposing Red China, time there are some who say that we should the United States. The American people because Red China is undoubtedly behind admit Red China t;o the United Nations and believe in peace. That is why we joined the North Vietnam's aggression against South establish diplomatic and commercial ties with United Nations. That, indeed, is why we Vietnam, and I feel very, very strongly that her. Apparently they believe that such con have responded to the people and the Gov we must be firm here. I feel that we should cessions to Red China will somehow contrib ernment of South Vietnam today. We be support the President, that Red China un ute to the peace and stability of the world. lieve in peace. We want the nations of the derstands this kind of language, that big as But nothing could be further from the truth. world to be let alone, to.live out their own Red China is, she's a weak country eco The Chinese Communist regime is, without lives. nomically, and therefore cannot be strong any doubt, the most ruthless and aggressive I think it quite fair to say that the Amer militarily. If we persist, if we're patient, regime in human history, and while its peo ican people and both their political parties, eventually I think we can win. This kind of ple live near the starvation level, a very sub the Republican Party and the Democratic policy toward Red China is more likely to stantial portion of its income is devoted to Party, are correct in objecting to recognition change her attitude than anything else. aggressive and subversive activities in every by the American Government of Red China part of the world. It has played a key role and of opposing her admission into the STATEMENT BY SENATOR LEvERETT SA_LTONSTALL, in organizing and supplying the pro-Com United Nations. As a matter of fact, the OF MASSACHUSETTS munist rebels in the Congo. It is the prime United Nations, itself, branded Red China Our most pressing major objective is to instigator of the war at Laos and South Viet as an aggressor in the recent lamentable and assure that Red China will not swallow up nam. It has declared its intention of liberat bloody Korean conflict. or take over the other countries of south ing Thailand. It bears a heavy share of the Let Red China demonstrate to the world, east Asia. And if we are to assist those free responsibility for Sukarno's aggression if she can, that she has changed her position countries in need of, and requesting, our against Malaysia. Its agents are active in vir and now desires to work for peace. Until military or economic assistance, then the tually every part of Latin America. that kind of a happy day arrives, I see no United States must remain strong. We know The admission of Red China to the United reason for the people and the Government that Red China wlll understand firmness and Nations or its recognition by the United of our country to change their position with strength on our part. The free countries States would make peace in the Far East less respect to her. neighboring Red China cannot either resist secure, not more secure. Instead of pro the Red Chinese alone or progress sufficiently tecting China's neighbors against the pos STATEMENT BY SENATOR WILLIAM D. PROX without our help. We must, therefore, con sibility of aggression it would only serve to MIRE, OF WISCONSIN tinue to help them achieve the economic stimulate the Chinese Communists to fur These are my ideas on what our policy base which will give them the confidence and ther aggression, and to stepped-up subversive should be regarding Red China. How about ability to resist Red Chinese economic or activities, and it would undermine the con recognition? Should we recognize Red political or military aggression. fidence and the will to resist of the non China? My answer is no. There can be no Munich; no appeasement Communist nations on China's periphery. I think that few people realize that from of the Red Chinese Communist Govern The free world will pay a very heavy penalty the time Red China came into existence in ment--and this means we must remain firm if it fails to draw the line now, against Com 1949 until the present date, it's been almost in our determination to oppose expansion munist Chinese expansion, in the naive hope impossible for our country to recognize her. of the Chinese Communist empire. We must that we can satiate its desire for expansion Shortly after Red China came into exist solicit increased support and cooperation and power by yielding a few countries like ence she burned down our consulate. She from other free countries to join with us Laos and Vietnam on its periphery. arrested our consular officers. And then a in confronting the Red Chinese with united few months after that--and of course that opposition against their aggressive aims. We STATEMENT BY SENATOR JACOB K. JAVITS made it very difficult for us to recognize her must continue to resist strenuously efforts One of the most critical questions for the then, when some other nations were recog of other Communist nations to allow R"ld United States is the question of U.S. policy nizing Red China--a short time after this China to shoot her way into the United with regard to Communist China. China the Korean war broke out and Red China, Nations. We should renew our efforts to dis occupies an enormous strategic land mass of course, came in on the side of the North courage any trade with Red China that will in Asia with a population of more than Koreans and was guilty of aggression against serve to strengihen her strategic position. 700 m1111ou people. These basic factors are the United Nations as wen as guilty of ag We know that we cannot trust the govern compounded by the facts that (1) the Com gression against South Korea. ment leaders of Red China and we cannot, munist Chinese have exploded a nuclear No nation recognized Red China from that therefore, hope to negotiate successfully with device; (2) they are pushing very hard time until France recognized her a short those leaders. American boys are dying in against the forces of freedom in Asia, Africa, time ago. Now the nations that did recog Vietnam in support of this policy. Eventu and Latin America; (3) they are engaged in nize Red China in 1949 have gained almost ally a political settlement of that particular an intensified campaign against the United nothing from it. The relationships have not conflict may be possible. Certainly a civic Nations; and (4) they are involved in an been improved. Great Britain has gained government which all elements in South enormous schism with the Soviet Union, virtually nothing from the fact that she did Vietnam will respect is a fundamental need. which of course has affected Soviet policy recognize Red China. But, to give up in Vietnam in frustration, toward us. How about Red China's admission to the or to be less than firm in our comrni tments In my judgment we cannot stand at the United Nations? Should we favor that? to maintain the independence of the other door of the United Nations and welcome Again I say emphatically no. The fact is free Asian nations, would more surely result them. We cannot even recognize them. Nor that the United Nations is not a reform in further Red Chinese affronts to our coun can we condone the past, when in Korea we school. We certainly can't expect Red try. We must not allow this to happen, and suffered enormous casualties at the hands of China to change as drastically as some peo it will not happen if we remain strong and the Communist Chinese, or the present, ple optimistically assume if she comes in. firm. where in South Vietnam we know that they Furthermore, if Red China comes into the are a material factor behind the effort to United Nations, she comes in with a per STATEMENT BY SENATOR HARRISON A. overwhelm our own forces and to bring the manent seat on the Security Council-be WILLIAMS, OF NEW JERSEY South Vietnamese into the slavery of com cause the charter provides that China shall President Johnson recently said that this munism. have that permanent seat. She comes in Nation looks forward to the day when the 8358 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE April 23, .1965 people and governments of all southeast The provisions of this bill, as I stated an, amendment. In my own judgment, Asia may be free from terror, subversion, yesterday, are designed, we should hope, if I had to make the sole decision as a and assassination. When they will no longer to be consistent with the views of a great need military support and assistance against l~wyer on the interpretation of section aggression, but only economic and social co majority of the committee, which has 4(a) as to a county covered by the so operation for progress and peace. That was undertaken the burden of proof to sub called 25 percent trigger, I should say a clear expression of our ultimate goal in stantiate the need for this bill. We that it is not absolutely certain in my Asia, and a clear statement that our interest should hope that the ·provisions of this own mind at all. I went along with the in the Asian nations is· not just in helping bill are adequate to enable States and overwhelming view of the members of them to fight off the neocolonialism of Red subdivisions which should not be under the committee. I subscribe to that and China, but in helping them to peaceful and the provisions of the bill to come out from stand by it. But it is not absolutely prosperous economic, social, and political stability. But for 15 years Communist under these provisions. We should hope certain in my own mind that a court may China has pursued a policy of territorial and that the practices that we have set up, by not construe section 4 (a) , as it is now ideological expansion through subversion, which we would permit this procedure, written, as stating that such a county aggression, and outright acts of war. No are reasonably to be availed of. shall come out under the 60 percent pro neighbor is safe, as Korea, India, and the As I stated yesterday, if that is not so, vision, or that the court could hold that, nations of southeast Asia have discovered. and there are deep feelings upon that as there is no violation of the 15th If we condone this conduct by extending subject, and it can be shown to us how amendment on a purported showing of diplomatic recognition, or by giving the Red Chinese a seat in the United Nations, we without basically changing the effort fact, the act does not apply at all. will be giving the aggressors 'an invitation that we are engaged in-we can more Iri that case, there would be no need to expand their activities, using all the new greatly facilitate a determination as to to utilize either the 60-percent mecha avenues which would be open to them. which counties and States should not· be nism or the 5-year mechanism specified In a changing' world we must be ready to under the statute, I would welcome the in section 4 (a) . meet that change; and the President, it seems information. The provision would be suscel)tible to to me, has moved creatively to let the Red that kind of interpretation, too. I have Chinese and all those within their orbit know I do not claim to be the seat of all that we are, in fact, ready and eager to find knowledge or the last word in legisla joined with the great majority of com evidence in their conduct which would jus tive draftsmanship or legislative ideas. mittee members in the construction tify a change in our policy. Unfortunately I do not believe that the Attorney Gen which is set forth in our views and op t}ll the evidence, so far, points in the other eral is. I do not believe· that any one pose the 60-percent provision. direction. And so, for the present, we must person is, no matter how . competent, I now yield to the Senator from continue our policy of treating Red China skilled, or experienced he may be. The Florida. as an outlaw among_nations, acting in fun process of debate has the enormous ad The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. DOM d,amental violation of the principles of in ternational conduct. vantage of enabling people whose in INICK in the chair). The Senator from terests are adversely affected to develop Florida is recognized. an idea which otherwise may never Mr. HOLLAND. Mr. President, I ORDER OF BUSINESS have been received. I welcome it. thank the Senator for his consideration , The PRESIDING OFFICER. Is there I repeat what I have said many times. of the problem which we discussed yes further morning business? If not, morn To me, proudest words in the English terday. i,ng busi~ess is closed. language are, "I am persuaded." Noth I firmly feel that the 5-year provision ing · would please me more than to find applies in the cases that the Senator has arrangements by which accommodations mentioned, in which the 25-percent trig · VOTING RIGHTS ACT OF 1965 may be made without destroying the gering mechanism is applied to a par Mr. MANSFIELD. · Mr. President, I fundamental intent of the bill. ticular county, State, or other subdivi ask unanimous consent that the un I note the presence in the Chamber sion. finished business be laid before the of the distinguished Senator from Flor There is very little doubt that such is Senate. ida [Mr. HoLLANDL We had a discus the case. The fact that the distin ' The PRESIDING OFFICER. The sion yesterday with respect to untrigger guished Senator from New York ex Chair lays before the Senate the unfin ing the trigger. It is a fact that as to presses a doubt about it is what I appre ished business. the particular trigger that I was dis ciate. cussing with the Senator at that time I ask the Senator what method is I The Senate resumed the consideration of the bill articu- Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, North preserved by the Constitution, in the ab lar aspects of the facts within the con and South Carolina, and Tennessee. sence of the violation or threatened vio text of these principles. That does not That·was on September 30, 1963. Com lation of the rights of citizens of the make the scheme of the legislation any pare these findings with the findings of United States. less appropriate, so long as the basic the Attorney General in his testimony The cases are legion to the effect that order of magnitude of the facts remains before us on March 27, 1965, with re once that trigger of all triggers has been provable and valid. spect to the States to which he specifi touched-namely, violation to an extent The test is 'One laid down in the most cally referred: Alabama, Louisiana, and and magnitude· warranting general leg modern language by the Supreme Court Mississippi---direct figures and quota islation-the Congress may adopt means in sustaining the constitutionality of the tions on which I will ,later cite-and it appropriate to the end which it would Civil Rights Act 01 1964 in the case of Will be seen that progress has been l CXI--529 8360 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 minuscule not only since 1963 but also cases relate to the response of voting I state parenthetically as a fact that since 1958 when the first civil rights law registrars even to orders if the court. in those 21 parishes, although the regis with relation to voting took effect. Reference is also made to appendix C tration of. white persons was increasing, That is the factual basis for the of the joint statement of 12 of the 15 the registration of Negroes dropped. proponents' case. Also, our conclusions members of the Judiciary Committee, Under the State's statutes and constitu are sustained in order of magnitude, not- · showing the pattern and relationship be tional provisions the registrars, without any withstanding the legitimate differences tween registration of whites and regis objective standard to guide them, deter about some of the individual figures, by tration of nonwhites in the States of mine the manner in which the interpreta the document entitled "Registration and Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, tion test is to be given, whether it is to be and South Carolina. oral or written, the length and complexity Voting Statistics," issued by the U.S. of the sections of the State or Federal Con Commission on Civil Rights on March Mr. President, I ask unanimous con stitutions to be understood and interpreted 19, 1965. Indeed, they are also sustained sent to have that table printed in the and what interpretation is to be considered by the findings in the Louisiana case, RECORD, together with appended notes. correct. recently decided in the U.S. Supreme There being no objection, the table and Court, and in two lower court cases in notes were ordered to be printed in the Here is a profound statement by the Louisiana and Alabama, which latter two RECORD, as follows: Supreme Court: There was ample evidence to support the .APPENDIX C district court's finding that registrars in the 21 parishes where the test was found to Voting age popu?ation and registered voters classified by race in those States where use of have been used had exercised their broad tests and devices is suspended by S. 1564 powers to deprive otherwise qualified Negro citizens of their right to vote; and that the White voting Nonwhite existence of the test as a hurdle to voter State age popull}.- White regis- Percent voting age Nonwhite Percent qualification has in itself deterred and will tion, 1964 1 tration 2 population, registration 2 19641 continue to deter Negroes from attempting .-i r· to register in Louisiana . Alabama_____ • ______Because of the virtually unlimited discre 1, 413, 270 a 935, 695 66. 2 501, 730 3 92, 737 18. 5 tion vested by the Louisiana laws in the reg Georgia _____ ------__ ------_-- --_-- 1, 966, 456 41, 124, 415 57. 2 669, 544 4 167, 663 25.0 Louisiana ______1,353, 495 • 1. 037, 184 76.6 539, 505 6164,601 30. 5 istrars of voters, and because in the 21 par 794, 277 6 525, 000 66.1 448, 723 6 28, 500 6.4 ishes where the interpretation test was ap 975,660 7 677, 914 69. 5 404,340 7138, 544 34.3 plied that discretion had been exercised to t:~&i~una::======, keep Negroes from voting because of their race, the district court held the interpreta 1 The total voting age population for the respective States is taken from an estimate by the Bureau of Census as of Nov. 1, 1964, in a memorandum issued by the Department of Commerce, dated Sept. 8, 1964, No. CB64-93. It tion test invalid on its face and as applied includes aliens and persons In active military service and their dependents. The voting age population for white as a violation of the 14th and 15th amend and nonwhite in1964 was computed by taking the voting age population statistics for white and nonwhite as reported ments to the U.S. Constitution and of 42 in the Census of Population: 1960, determining the ratio of each group to the total voting age population in 1960, and applying that ratio to the total voting age population as estimated by the Bureau of Census for Nov. 1, 1964. U.S.C. 1971(a) .1 2 These statisti~~excepting those for Virginia, are based on findings published in U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Registration and voting Statistics, Mar. 19, 1965. They are not based on official State sources due to the lack of Mr. LONG of Louisiana. Mr. Presi official State information classifying registrants by race. dent, will the Senator yield? The registration data based on official State sources in the chart containing voting and registration statistics for all States (master chart) reflect registration as of a later date than the data published by the Commission. For this Mr. JAVITS. I shall yield in a mo reason, the registration figures in this chart, when totaled, differ slightly from the registration figures in the master ment. chart. The totals here are as follows: Alabama, 1,028,432;· Georgia, 1,292,078; Louisiana, 1,201,785; Mississippi, 653,500; South Carolina, 816,458; Virginia, 1,311,023. It will be argued: "All right, that is s U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Registration and Voting Statistics, Mar. 19, 1965. true. In 21 parishes the Supreme Court 4lbid. •Ibid. found that there was widespread sup • Ibid. pression and denial of the right to vote, 1 Ibid. but the Court struck it down; the district Mr. JAVITS. Mr. President, I have segregation committee to seek means of ac court struck it down. Now there is no mentioned cases. Let us see what the complishing this goal. The chairman of test. It has been outlawed as a matter Supreme Court has said as recently as this committee also helped to organize a of law. What are you complaining March 8, 1965, in Louisiana against semiprivate group called the Ass.ociation of about? The test will not be applied. Oitizens' Councils, which thereafter acted The courts have taken care of the sit United States. I read from page 2 of in close cooperation with the legislative the memorandum of opinion: committee to preserve white supremacy. uation." From the adoption of the 1921 interpre If that were the whole of it, that would tation test until 1944-- I remind the Senate that I am still be just fine, but it is not. After the reading the opinion of the U.S. Supreme Supreme Court has struck these matters That is, 23 years-- Court. It is not my opinion. It is down, all kinds of strategems have been the district court's opinion stated, the per theirs. employed in order to vitiate what the centage of registered voters in Louisiana Continuing reading: courts are trying to do. who were Negroes never exceeded· 1 percent. Prior to 1944 Negro interest in voting in The legislative committee and the citi Let me give a few examples, including Louisiana had been slight, largely because zens' councils set up programs, which par one in Louisiana. ish voting registrars were required to attend, I quote from page 15 of the joint state the State's white primary law had kept Ne to instruct the registrars on how to promote groes from voting in the Democratic Party white political control. The committee and ·ment of the majority of the Judiciary primary election, the only election that the citizens' councils also began a wholesale Committee: mattered in the poli t1cal climate of that challenging of Negro names already on the The undersigned support the provisions of State. In 1944, however, this Court invali voting polls, with the result that thousands the bill which provide for the appointment of dated the substantially identical white pri of Negroes, but virtually no whites, were examiners under the circumstances set forth mary law of Texas, and with t;he explicit purged from the rolls of voters. Beginning in the blll. History has shown that suspen statutory bar to their voting in the primary in the middle 1950's, registrars of at least 21 sion of the tests and devices alone would not removed and because of a generally height assure access of all persons to voting and ened political interest, Negroes in increas parishes began to apply the interpretation test. registration without regard to race or color. ing numbers began to register in Louisiana. The maladministration of tests and devices The white primary system had been so effec In 1960 the State constitution was amended to require every applicant there has been the major problem. Other tactics tive in barring Negroes from voting that the of discrimination, however, have been used interpretation test as a disfranchising device after to "be able to understand" as well as "give a reasonable interpretation" of any and could readily be resorted to by State or had fallen into disuse. Many registrars con local election officials where tests and devices tinued to ignore it after 1944, and in the next section of the State or Federal Constitution dozen years the proportion of registered vot "when read to him by the registrar." The have been suspended. ers who were Negroes rose frqm two-tenths State board of registration in cooperation of 1 percent to approximately 15 percent by with the segregation committee issued or 1 "Although the vote-abridging purpose March 1956. This fact, coupled with this ders that all parish registrars must strictly and effect of the [interpretation] test ren Court's 1954 invalidation of laws requiring comply with the new provisions. der it per se invalid under the 15th amend school segregation, prompted the State to The interpretation test, the court found, ment, it is also per se invalid under the try new devices to keep the white citizens in vested in the voting registrars a virtually 14th amendment. The vices cannot be cured control. The Louisiana Legislature created uncontrolled discretion as to who should by an injunction enjoining its unfair ap a committee which became known as the vote and who should not. plication," 225 F. Supp., at 391-392. April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8361 That this is so is demonstrated by two re ment-again, we are mutable and we can able, well intentioned, and successful cent actions in Louisiana and Alabama. The be wrong, although we are deeply con efforts here and there to deal with the registrars in East and West Feliciana Parishes were enjoined by the three-judge district vinced that we are right-that we need situation? Second, can we draft generic court in United States v. Loui siana (225 F. a 5-year test for a catch-up period, so legislation which will be so reasonably Supp. 353 (E.D. La. 1963), affirmed, - U.S. - to speak. It is the best we can do. appropriate to our situation as to be least (Mar. 8, 1963)) , from using various State If the Senator will bear with me, I onerous to those who are really trying? literacy tests. Their response was to close should like to say to him that this is The problem is grave. I wish that the registration office thus freezing the exist a fairly leisurely day, and it is possible southern Senators such as the Senator ing unlawful registration disparity in those for us to discuss these matters in some from Louisiana-and I know his attitude parishes. In Dallas County, Ala., the regis trars ( as found by the district court) slowed detail and in a deliberate way. on the bill is a little different from that down the pace of registration so as to prevent I have the highest respect for the Sen of a number of his colleagues---would be any appreciable number of Negroes, qualified ator from Louisiana. He owes complete able to give us the benefit of their great or not, from completing the registration proc fidelity to his State and its people, and brainpower and expertise in helping us to ess. The appointment of examiners is the is one who is really trying to lead, not draft regulatory language which would, effective answer to such tactics. follow. as nearly as possible, reward rather than I now yield to the Senator from Loui I have noticed it in many ways. The penalize those who are trying. siana. Senator and I have not always agreed. Mr. LONG of Louisiana. The bill be Mr. LONG of Louisiana. Mr. Presi I have sometimes found his remedies to fore the Senate proposes some very un dent, as a Senator who has run for pub be a little too populist for me to take. usual, and I believe even harsh methods, lic office in Louisiana, I should like to say He and I have engaged in some fairly with regarci to parishes in which there that I have repeatedly criticized the same spirited debate on many of these sub is no discrimination and to counties in test that the Senator from New York is jects. I respect the Senator's liveliness which there is no discrimination. I be criticizing. I believe the Senator will and his desire to find out and not be lieve the Senator would find in most concede, however, that a registrar, con afraid of new trends. Southern States, and perhaps in all of fronted with a law which requires that The Senator's statement now indicates them, that there are counties and par such questions be asked of a voter appli what we all know, namely, that no case, ishes in which there is absolutely no dis cant, in the absence of a court decision, no situation is black or white. At best it crimination. would be under the burden of applying has various shades of gray. I feel sure I should like to cite one example to the test, when the citizens in his commu there are parishes in the Senator's State, the Senator. Several years ago a sher nity have stated to him, "You are bound and in other States, where there are iff was running for reelection in a rela by the law. You must follow it." groups of people who are thus disposed. tively large county. He was trailing go Notwithstanding that law, there were Our problem has been that, as a peo ing into a runoff. Usually, when an in other parishe&--the Senator mentioned ple, we have gotten into a situation in cumbent sheriff is trailing going into a 21 but there are 64 parishes in the which individually laudable efforts need runoff, it means he is beaten, because St~te--in some of those other 43 parishes to be accommodated as much as possible. the incumbent is usually far out in front the registrars not only were applying that I wish to accommodate them. As I said in the first primary. I presume it is that test, but they were in effect, flouting the to the Senator from Florida [Mr. HOL way even in New York. If the candidate law and registering Negro citizens, feel LAND], and I now say to the Senator from is not ahead in the first primary, in the ing that they should be permitted to vote. Louisiana, if there are any other ways runoff he would usually be hopelessly The sympathy of the community and of in which Senators think we can accom behind. the elected officials there felt that the modate them, I assure them that I, for But the man about whom I am speak Negroes should be accepted as voters, and one, would give their suggestions the ing observed that the Negroes were vot.;;. they assisted Negroes in filling out the most profound consideration. ing for him, and in the 2 weeks the books complicated form that was required to be But we are faced with the reality of a were open between the first primary and filled out by prospective voters, so that burning situation in the Nation. It is a the second primary, he put all of his burning of the kind that we cannot wave deputies out on the highways driving in they could be properly registered to vote. aside and say, "We are not going to be all directions looking for Negro citizens The law that is proposed to be en persuaded by demonstrations of strong and getting them in to register. He had acted would off er no reward to regis feelings, because we are doing our duty. the cooperation of the local registrar. trars in those parishes where registrars We know what is right." But we would He registered everyone he could find be had gone to great effort to help Negro be wrong. The fact is that the times tween the time the books were open and citizens to register and to vote. I should have caught up with us, and great ·the time they were closed again between like to ask the Senator if he favors a masses of the people will stand for it no those two elections. measure which would seek to substitute longer. The result of the vote was the differ by Federal flat a Federal official for a I believe the question-and I am not ence between winning and losing. local official under such circumstances asking it of the Senator, for I do not I can assure the Senate that, in that and why this should be done in parishes wish to embarrass him-which the South instance, there was no discrimination where registrars went the extra mile. must ask itself is as follows: Must not against those citizens. If there was any The Senator mentioned the fact that we, too, awaken to .the opportunity, not discrimination, it was in their favor, to the number of Negroes registered in 21 merely in the isolated or relatively non see that they had an opportunity to parishes declined during a certain pe majority instances in which we have register. I suspect that that philosophy riod. However, the overall percentage awakened, but in a far more widespread had something to do with many of the of Negroes registered remained constant, manner? For example, the business parishes going out as they did. because of the increase in registration in community of the South is beginning to The Third Congressional District is an the other parishes. think about . the problem. We see in example. We have heard that 4,500 of Does not the Senator feel that if there stance after instance of that develop the Negro citizens who registered cannot is to be some legislation on this subject, ment. In Alabama and Mississippi, actually read and write. They could as a minimum we ought to try to give chambers of commerce are going far not have registered in the Senator's State some recognition and show some appre beyond what is popularly supposed to be of New York. Under the present law ciation to those registrars who went the the local temperament or the local so in Louisiana they would not be eligible extra mile in assisting the Negro citizens cial order because they realize that to register in Louisiana. But they are to vote? economically they cannot stand against registered. The fact that the local offi Mr. JAVITS. My answer to the Sen that kind of a situation. cials there desired to cooperate and help ator is that provisions in the bill will So our problem is a grave, deep, and them to register would certainly indicate enable the parishes which have gone the troublesome one, because deep feelings that there was no discrimination against extra mile to come out from under. the are involved, heads are broken, and peo them in those parishes. bill, assuming that there has been for 5 ple are killed. No one knows that bet Mr. Preside.nt, I know what it is to be years an absence of discrimination in ter than I. Our problem is this: Is the chastised and criticized for saying that those parishes. other than that, the time such that we must have generic a Negro citizen is entitled to register. I Senator is well familiar with our argu- legislation, notwithstanding many desir- have made that statement in my State, 8362 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 and on occasions it has caused emer pulled by the Attorney General, and that factual discrimination, if nothing else. gency meetings of citizens' councils at there :s a provision in the bill in that For example, the Attorney General took which when they undertook to resolute regard with respect to the Attorney Gen- the attitude that he should not be re against their junior Senator. Tha_t _atti eral having discretion. , quired to take a census or to look at the tude has very much upset the Ku Klux That language appears at the top of registration rolls and see what percent Klan, and some of those · people can page 21; lines 1 to 6. I should like to read age was white and what percentage was terrify one sometimes with some of .the it into the RECORD . . I am sure that the colored, compared to the percentage of things they do to try to back one down. Senator is very well acquainted with it. white and colored citizens in a com ..
At meetings of local officials in parishes The provision is- •J munity. We could supply those figures in which there might be segregation, · That the Attorney General may req1Jire for Louisiana. We could make them resolutions have been adopted condemn the applicant in such State or political sub available. At a minimum, if in a parish ing the junior Senator from Louisiana division to allege further t hat, within ninety the percentage of Negroes registered for taking the attitude that Negro cit d ays preceding his application, he has been equaled or exceeded the percentage of izens were entitled to vote. denied under colo;r of law the opportunity white citizens ·registered, there would be to register or to vote or has been found not I have repeatedly condemned the very qualified to vote by a person acting under no triggering of the act in that instance. practices which tne Senator has talked color of law. · ' 1 Ordinarily, it would seem to me that if about. I refer to questions of applicants the percentage of Negro voters in a coun in relation to an interpretation of the , That is 'section '7(a) with relation ~to ty was substantially in line with the per Constitution. Registrars have said, the I,"ight of the' examiner when appointed centage of white citizens registered, that "The Constitution states that no State to register a voter. So I think we have should take that county or parish out shall pass any ex post facto law or bill made an effort. Again I invite the crea from· under the act. of attainder. What is a bill of •attain tive· resoti.rces of the Senator in relation I admJ.t that it is a little more difficult der?" to that point, but I think we have made and requires a little more work to check Most lawyers cannot answer that an effort to deal with it. out the registration roll or to get figures. question. · ;In fact, even as to the triggers, so That is more difficult than merely to say Frankly, my uncle, whom I supported called, in section 4 (b) , which are really that in the last Presidential election less for Governor of Louisiana, and who sup tbe h.eart of this bill, it, must be :q.ote<;t than 50 percent of the people voted. ported me for, the Senate repeatedly, that m every case, even w:here there is I am suggesting that at least that worked as hard as any southerner has an automatic trigger the Attorney Gen makes more sense·, because there would and against adverse circumstances.in an ei;-al ·must p~ess it~ In other words, the be some showing that the.re was actually effort to see that fairness prevailed and action will :i:iot happen by itself. The discrimination when the percentage of that colored citizens were protected, as Attorney General must press the trigger, whites registered greatly exceeded the all other citizens :should be protected, in if the vote is less than 50 percent, and percentage of Negroes. their right to vote. So I have great sym 20 percent of th!;? population is Negro. The Senator.from New York is making pathy for anyone who wishes to see that The· Attorney General will get a petition, his case logically. If in a parish or a qualified citizens are entitled to vote. and he must decide: Yes, he will; or no, county x percentage of whites was reg
A great number of southern people hewiffnot. 1 istered and a much lesser percentage wish to do the right thing. S.ome are He must press it when less- than 25 of Negroes registered, that pro being pressed by the Ku Klux Klan and per~ent o~ tlle Negro p6pulation ];las vides a basis upon which a case can citizens councils not to register any more voted. That is another Qne of f::he trig'i be made. ' Following that philosophy, Negroes. But my guess is that if there gers. There, again, he ·must act. He there should be a showing that the wei:e a statut;~ pi;oviding that those peo must put the machinery in motion. H'e percentage of Negroes registered was low ple should have an opportunity to regis must put it in gear, if he is 'going 'to seek compared with the percentage of white ter, and i,f th~ regi.,strars d~d not regis examiners. Even ip. the case of examin citizens registered in a community, if we ter them, Federal registrars w:ould be ers, he must determine what qualifica are to proceed on the basis that discrimi appointed, . we 1 would have a better tions shall apply. For example, the Sen:. nation in fact is presumed to exist. statute. , a~or from Louisia:i:ia ~poke of an effort ·The·fact that people do not vote at a We have before us a bill that would to qualify in good parishes before regis~ particular election, does · not prove.' a punisti people for something that had trations are actually begun by an ex- thing. In Louisiana, the act .would have happened under a law which they were 1:).miner. ' · ' ., been triggered because less than 50 per entitled to regard as valid, and under the Here is an area of creativity. I see cent of ,the people 1voted in the presiden: pressure of local people who contended no reason why, · Senators from · the tial race between Lyndon Johnson and that that law was valid and shouid be Sou~h-al}d again, I do not include the Barry Goldwater. People do not usual1 respected. Senator from Louisiana [Mr. LONG l, be ly vote plied to white be used if the court finds that' there .of future voting discrimination. With persons already registered. is no further racial discrimination in such clarification the amendment would Finally, subsection 4(d) (3) requires voting and that either of the following be workable. a finding tpat there is no reasonable conditions exists: Fir-st, the percentage , Mr. DOUG:.LAE!. I see no us~ful pur probability of the recurrence of the dis of persons in the State or political subdi pose that the 60-percent clause fulfills; criminatory use of tests or devices in vision that voted in the next, pre:c~ding I can see,a _great deal of damage that it the future. For example, this might presidential election exceeded the na might do. r believe that the use of the require a showing that , a substantial tional average percentage of persons ,second clause; nai:µely, if a court finds percentage of the qualified Negroes in voting in such election;' .or, second, the that restrictive tests or devices have been the area were then registered and had percent of persons in the State or politi used, would throw the case immedi~tely been allowed to vote in recent elections. cal subdivision that have been registered into the judicial process, which we found -The preceding subsections, all of which to vote by State or local election offi was ineffective in the 1957, 1960, and are contained in section 4 of the bill, cials-not including persons listed by 1964 acts, involving delays which the are the principal provisions governing Federal examiners-,exceeds 60 percent judicial process has inevitably involved. the suspension of tests and devices. Let .of the persons of voting age meeting res I hope we will reject the so-called us tl,lrn now to the second key feature idence requirements in the St~te or sub Dirksen amendment1 cqmpletely , . and of the bill-the Federal examiner ap divisions. ,1.~tterly. , Pointment provisions. This provision w~ added in the Judi i (_At this point, Mr. KE~N.EDY of New ciary Committee at the suggestion of.the York took the chair.) THE EXAMINER APPOINTMENT PROVIS:J;ONS distinguished Senator from Illinois [Mr. , Mr. TYDINGS: In.concluding my re ·Eight years of unrewarding civil liti DIRKSEN]. Some of us had misgivings marks on the suspension of tests and gation have taught us that the voter about this escape clause at that time, devices. let me· ad,vert briefly to a few registration process cannot be left in and 10 of us on the committee still pre technical points relating to judicial pro- the hands of local officials in areas'where fer the original version. ce~ding~ under section~·. , . such officials are determined to resist It has been suggested that the second Subs~ction 4(~) also provides that -in the legitimate aspirations of Negro cit- "escape clause" provision-subsection 4 any proceeding brought pursuant to it, 1izens to participate in the franchise and 8368 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE April 23, 1965 in the political process. Accordingly. persons might be subject to various eco name has been removed from the list in section 6 of the bill, which was substi nomic pressures, physical threats, and accordance with subsection 7(d). tuted for section 4 (a) of the bill as in the like. Subsection 7(c) provides that the ex troduced, provides for the appointment The duties of examiners also are set aminer shall issue a certificate of vot of Federal examiners. A crucial differ out in this section. Their functions are ing eligibility to each person whose name ence between the provisions for the sus to examine applicants who present them appears on a list of eligible voters. This pension of tests and devices and the selves, determine ·if they are qualified, concludes my remarks on the examiner examiner appointment provisions should and prepare and maintain lists of per appointment provisions. be noted at this point. Under subsec sons eligible to vote in Federal, State, and OTHER PROVISIONS tions 4(b) (1) and 4(b) (2), the Attorney local elections. In addition to the key provisions re General and the Director of the Census The Civil Service Commission may, as have mandatory duties to make the de lating ·to the suspension of "tests and required by circumstances, have one ex devices" and the appointment of exam terminations which will have the effect aminer serve one or more subdivisions so iners, the bill contains a number of other of suspending the use of tests and de that it will not be necessary to have one vices under subsection 4 (a) if the con important provisions which I should like examiner in each subdivision that may to discuss briefly. ditions specified in those subsections in be covered. But each examiner would fact exist. By contrast, activation of be assigned to a specific subdivision or FREEZING OF STATE VOTER QUALIFICATIONS AN~ the Federal examiner machinery is dis subdivisions. PROCEDURES cretionary with the Attorney General. Section 7 deals with the mechanics of Section 5 deals with attempts by States The examiner machinery is activated by processing and listing applicants by Fed of political subdivisions whose tests or a certification by the Attorney General. eral examiners. devises have been suspended under Sec The actual appointment of examiners Subsection 7 (a) provides that exam tion 4 to alter voting qualifications and by the Civil Service Commission is not, iners appointed pursuant to section 6 procedures which were in effect on No however. discretionary with the Com are to examine applicants to determine vember 1, 1964. Section 5 permits a mission. Following a section 6 certifica their qualifications for voting at such State or political subdivision to enforce tion by the Attorney General, the Com places as the Civil Service Commission new requirements only if it submits the mission has a ministerial duty to ap shall designate. This subsection re new requirements to the Attorney Gen point an appropriate number of exam quires the applicant to allege in his ap eral and the Attorney General does not iners. plication that he is not otherwise reg interpose objections within 60 days Examiners are to be appointed by the istered to vote and that he has been de thereafter. Civil Service Commission in areas which prived of the right to register or vote If the new qualifications are not sub fall within the scope of section 4(b) after on account of race or color. A person mitted to the Attorney General, or if the Attorney General makes one of two may be "deprived of the right to regis they are submiitted and he interposes possible certifications. · ter or vote on account of race or color" an objection, then the State or subdivi First, the Attorney General may cer not only when his registration applica sion will not be able to enforce the new tify that he has received 20 or more meri tion is rejected, or when he is turned requirements without obtaining a ju torious complaints of voting discrimina away from the polls but also when de dicial determination that such new quali.;. tion from residents of a political lay, unavailability of registrars, or some fl.cations or procedures do not have the subdivision which falls within the scope similar difficulty deprives him of an ef purpose "or" will not have the effect of of section 4(b). The Attorney General's fective opportunity to register or vote. denying or abridging rights guaranteed determination that the complaints are The Attorney General in his discretion by the 15th amendment. Although the meritorious may n6t be reviewed by the may require the applicant further to al word "or", which frequently has a dis courts. · lege that, within 90 days preceding his junctive meaning, is used, it is intended In the alternative, the Attorney Gen application he has been denied under that the petitioning State or subdivision eral may certify that in his judgment the color of law the opportunity to register must prove an absence of both discrim appointment of examiners in a subdivi or to vote or has been found not qualified inatory purpose and effect. Any such sion within the scope of section 4(b) is to vote by a person acting under color action must be brought in a three-judge necessary to enforce the 15th amend of law. District Court for the District of Colum.,. ment. A provision has been added by the Subsection 7 (b) provides that the ex bia. Direct appeal lies ·to the Supreme Judiciary Committee to the bill as in aminer is to place on a list of eligible Court of the United States. troduced, directing that in making this voters any person whom he finds, in ac Neither the Attorney General's failure determination, the Attorney General is cordance with instructions received to interpose an objection nor the entry to consider, among other things, whether under subsection 8(b), to have the quali of a declaratory judgment under this the ratio of nonwhite registered persons section will bar any subsequent action to to white registered persons in the sub fications prescribed by State law not in consistent with the Constitution and laws enjoin the enforcement of a new voting division appears to him to be fairly at of the United States. This latter pro qualification, or procedure whose purpose tributable to violations of the 15th is to prohibit the franchise. amendment, a determination he is par vision was inserted by the Judiciary ticularly well -suited to make due to the Committee to spell out specifically that ELIMINATION OF POCKETS OF DISCRIMINATION 'broad knowledge of the Department of while State law is to govern, this means Section 3 provides a means of dealing Justice of the history and scope of racial only such State laws as are not incon with a violation of the 15th amend discrimination in voting. Under express sistent with Federal law, including this ment wherever it may occur throughout language in subsection 4(b), section 6, act. Subsection 7 (b) also specifies ·the the United States. The crucial feature determinations and certifications of the times for transmitting and certifying the of this provision is that it will not affect Attorney General are final and unre lists of eligible voters to the offices of the registration or voting procedures in any ·viewable by the courts. -appropriate election officia1s, w1th copies area unless and until there has been a Section 6 also authorizes the Civil to the Attorney General· and the attorney judicial proceeding in which racial dis Service Commission to appoint more than general of the State, as well as the times crimination is proved, at least sufficiently one examiner for each subdivision with when the list is· to be made available for to warrant interlocutory relief. The use respect to which certifications have been public inspection. . in the State or political subdivision of made if this is deemed necessary. To This· subsection expressly confers a -a "test" or "device," as defined in sec the extent the Civil Service ·commission Federal right to vote on any person tion 4(c), must be suspended by the court thinks it practicable, the examiners are whose name appears on a list transmitted in such subdivisions as is deemed ap to be residents of the State in which they by a Federal examiner to appropriate propriate and for so · long as is deemed will serve, but not necessarily residents election officials-at least 45 days prior to necessary, upon proof that any citizen of the subdivision. However, the Com ah election. Such transmittal can be has been deprived of his right to vote mission is free to appoint examiners accomplished by · depositing the list in on account of race or color by means from other States arid should do so when, the mail on.or before the 45th day. Any of such a test or device. The section in its judgment, impartial persons. can person whose name appears on such a also provides for the appointment of not be found to do the job or where such list mu~t be allowed to vote_unless his examinei:s and the "freezing" of voting April 23, 1965 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - SENATE 8369 qualifications and procedures in appro decision declaring a person's entitlement CONCLUSION priate circumstances. But it is impor to vote. In conclusion, this review of its key tant to note that this section does not SANCTIONS provisions shows that S. 1564 is a prac limit in any way the provisions of sec The statute is to be entorced by the tical and effective answer to the problem tion 4 or the appointment of examiners Attorney General by civil proceedings of racial discrimination in voting. And, under section 6 (b) . for injunctive or other appropriate in view of the circumstances which pro ABOLITION OF THE POLL TAX equitable relief or by criminal prosecu duced it, the bill is, in my judgment, a Section 9 abolishes poll taxes by pro restrained and completely appropriate tions, or both. congressional response to a national viding that no State or political sub Subsection 12 (a) provides for the im need. The bill should be enacted with division shall deny any person the right position of criminal penalties for "will to register or vote because of his failure fully and knowingly" depriving or at out delay. to pay a poll tax or any other payment tempting to deprive other persons of as a precondition of registration or vot rights secured by certain enumerated UNFAffi TREATMENT RECEIVED BY ing. The bill as introduced originally sections of the act or for "willfully and OTTO OTEPKA dealt with poll taxes in subsection 5(e). knowingly" violating section 11. The Mr. MILLER. Mr. President, on sev That provision provided that a person phrase "willfully and knowingly" was in eral occasions, I have called attention to could not be denied the right to vote if he serted by the Judiciary Committee to the unfair treatment the career civil tendered payment of his current poll make it clear that no criminal violation servant Mr. Otto Otepka has received at tax to an examiner, whether or not such is involved where a person acts with due the hands of the State Department. tender was timely or adequate under care and without knowledge of the rele Here is a civil service employee who State law. The effect of this provision vant facts. To put it another way, ac began his Government service in 1934 was to waive payment of poll taxes for tion or inaction which deprives others and who started working at a high level the years prior to the one in which the of rights secured by the act but which is in the State Department in 1953. He re applicant sought to make payment to done or omitted inadvertently is not a ceived the highest ratings possible, and an examiner. Under former section basis for prosecution. This language was given the Meritorious Service Award 5(e) examiners were required to trans was not intended to require a showing of by the late Secretary of State, John Fos mit such current poll tax payments to any specific intent similar, for example, ter Dulles, in 1958. the appropriate State or local officials. to that presently required under judicial Then, when Mr. Otepka cooperated In my judgment, Mr. President, and constructions of 18 U.S.C. 242. The with the Senate Internal Security Sub in the opinion which was shared by a same language was inserted by the com committee and provided information, as majority of the members of the Judiciary mittee in section 12 (c) for the same he testified under oath, showing the Committee, the bill as introduced did not reason. laxity which had occurred in security go far enough in dealing with the poll Subsection 12(d) provides for a civil clearance matters in the Department, he tax. We were and are convinced that all action by the Attorney General for pre was removed from his security work and poll tax requirements can and should ventive relief whenever he has reason given a make-work Job pending a long be abolished by the exercise of the power able grounds to believe that any person and drawn out hearing procedure and in of Congress to enact appropriate legis is about to engage in any act or practice vestigation undertaken by the Depart lation to enforce not only the 15th but prohibited by certain enumerated sec ment. also 14th amendment. tions of the act. The court may issue I have called attention to the Depart The distinguished junior Senator from appropriate orders including an order ment's transfers of personnel who the State of Massachusetts [Mr. KEN directed to a State and State or local shared Mr. Otepka's concern over se NEDY] made a very masterful defense of election officials requiring them to per curity procedures-this apparently in re the constitutionality of the poll tax mit persons listed under the act to vote taliation for their sympathy with Mr. amendment on the floor of the Senate and to count their votes. These exam Otepka. last Friday. I do not believe that there ples of orders that may be cUrected Now it appears that further retaliation is any need to repeat what he has already against a State or against election against Mr. Otepka himself is to take so well stated. officials are not intended to be exclusive. place. He recently received notice that CHALLENGE PROCEDURE One of the most important sanctions an automatic in-grade promotion, which Subsection 8(a) provides for challenges is contained in subsection 12(e). This would amount to $570 per year, sched to listings on the Federal examiners' eli subsection provides in certain circum uled for June 6, will not be granted him gibility lists and sets forth the procedure stances for the judicial suspension of because, so they say, he has not been to be followed in making such a chal election results unless and until persons performing up to standards required of lenge. This subsection provides that· a who have been listed by a Federal ex his job. , · hearing officer appointed by and respon aminer have been allowed to vote and The peculiar thing about this notice sible to the Civil Service Commission their votes have been counted. Subsec is that, according tq my information, shall hear and determine such challenges. tion 12 (e) provides that, in political sub there ~ have been no ·job description Challenges must be filed in an office with divisions for which an examiner has been standards published for this make-work in the State designated by the Civil appointed, if any person alleges to the job to which he has been assigned .for the Service Commission within 10 days after examiner within 24 hours after the polls past 2 years. How, it may be asked, can the listing . of the challenged person is close that he has not been permitted some administrative official in the State made available to public inspection and to vote, that he has been listed under Department say that Mr. Otepka has not must be supported by affidavits of at the act or registered by appropriate been performing up to standards when least two persons having personal knowl State officials, and that he is presently there are no standards? · edge of the facts constituting grounds eligible to vote, the examiner must im:.. Mr. Opteka's outstanding record of for the challenge. A copy of the chal mediately notify the U.S. attorney for service, his superior performance rat lenge and affidavits must be served up the judicial · district, if the allegations ings, and nis Meritorious Service Award on the person challenged. appear "to the examiner to be . well constitute powerful evidence indicat founded. Upon receipt of such notifi ing that someone in the Department is The decision of the hearing officer on cation, the U.S. attorney may, within 72 not playing fair with this man. All of the challenge may be appealed to the hours after the closing of the polls, apply us know how easy it is to hide prejudice court of appeals for the circuit in which to the Federal district court for an of an administrative officer under the the person challenged resides within ·15 order requiring the casting or count cloak of "not performing up to stand days after the person appealing has been ing of the votes of the complainants ards" even where there are standards served with the decision. The hearing and the inclusion of their votes in the set forth in a job description. But officer's decision on the facts, however, total vote before the results of the where there are no job description may not be overturned unless it is clear election may be, given effect. The dis standards, it is even easier to try to ly erroneous and the person listed is en trict court is required to hold a hearing cover up the prejudice. titled to vote pending the outcome of - and determine · the issues immediately I have said before, and I say again, the challenge on appeal. No court or after the U.S. attorney's application is all of this is bound to result in contin judge may issue a stay of an examiner's filed. ued suspicion on the part of many people 8370 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD--SENATE April 23, 1965 that the security procedures in the State James L. Cropper Earl A. Boles Donald J. Bowers David A. Carter Department have been lax; and ,that Newton P. Caddell, Jr. James M. Mauldin Henry G. Jett Forrest W. Peil someone has been trying to cover this Louis L. Bayers John H. Bunting Gerald W. Hayes Beecher D. Rapp Randall H. Spooner John H. Westbury Robert L. Perkins Preston Mason up. We have, I know, received assur Harold W . Collins Gustave F. Scholtz Lee Bradford, Jr. Hassen S. Salem, Jr. ance that the security procedures now Herbert L. Gorfion Harold R. Dycus Eugene R. Lytton Robert A. Bhend, Jr. ·are proper; but that does not satisfy the Raymond L. Williams Melvin E . Ginn William B. Clark Lowell W. Waplehorst question of what has occurred previ James R . Kane Charles W . Grlffiths Howard M. Seaton Stephen Sperlak ously. The people want to be satisfied Thomas J. Hushion Charles E. Bunkley George W . Todd Harold V. Smith on that point, and if some State Depart Charles E. Holden Eugene L. Murphy Anthony Simoncini ment officials hav,e been lax, they ought The following named persons to be' per William C. Cumming Louis De Jessie to be fired and not just permitted to manent commissioned warrant officers in John W. Collins Paul B. Robertson gracefully resign, keeping all of the the Coast Guard in the grade of chief war Arthur R. Whittum Robert L. Southern rant officer, W-3: Ralph M. Dobson John F . Bresnehan benefits which resignation permits and Robert E. Jefferson Robert A. Fleming firing does-not permit. Raymond H. Mathison Richard E. Simpson Roger J. Conard Frederic G. Cook Whoever in the State Department John V. A. Thompson Edward D. Phelps Gary R. Klinkman Carlton P. Smith Frank E. Braman Raymond E. Aholt Stanley W. Haney Hugh D. Dasher, Jr. made the decision to reassign Mr. Otepka Richard Meagher Harlan Kaley and then to compound the action by Merrie! A. Smith Richard B. Lewis William C. Bart Alfred R. Kolar· Victor L. Popplewell Robert E. Halstead passing him over for a $570 per year Giles·M. Bailey, Jr. Eddie Brophy George H. Yarrington Edward L. Amos automatic in-grade promotion has exer John S. Kennedy Robert H. Neuman Lynald "W" Hendricks Robert E. Mustard cised very poor judgment if his ob Clifford R. Wattam, Clifford A. Gustavson Ellis W. Grimes Frank A. Christoph jective is to improve the Department's Jr. Richard M. Eberhardt David E. Ford Louis R. Stowe public relations. This is the poorest Leo L. Richmond Charles R. Hug Larry B. Brown William G. Wohlfarth time that could have been selected to Melvin D. Mabry Harold C. Harris William J . Gesser Norman B . Bourque Dale E. Strohecker Constantine J. Ralph Dennis Forrest D. Fesler cause a weakening in the public trust Braxton B. Bell Kosloski and confidence, and I hope that we may George R. Thomas Howard E. Wales Charles A. Thornton Gordon L. Anderson Robert D. Fiester Howard A. Hirst soon be told that the officer who made Robert F. Stager William F. Mueller Floyd H. McGowan Frank M. Alonzo such a blunder has left the Department. Harold C. Wadey Johnnie Broussard Rodger G . Biehl Leroy J. Rathbun John W . Parker Frank J. Miller, Jr. Douglas J . Hymers Charles A. Lummus Edwin M. Smithers Harry S. Huggins Joseph R. Levesque James V. Simons ADJOURNMENT UNTIL MONDAY Horace F. Stephens Raymond Teichrow Delbert F. Gustafson Harrold M. Cooke Tugg P. Heimerl William W. Cloer Billy G. Bailey William Chestnutt . Mr. TYDINGS. Mr. President, I Michael Baron, Jr. Harold L. Brackett, Jr . . move, pursuant to the order previously Jackie S. Thornhill Isaac W. Lance IN THE NAVY entered, that the Senate adjourn until Laurence R. Fillinger Patrick J. Mahon Vice Adm. Harold T. Deutermann, U.S. Monday next at noon. Charles A. Lester Richard Dickinson Navy, when retired, f_or appointment to the The motion was agreed to; and Richard E. Carlburg Robert V. Golling John Kiselyk Thomas A. Murawski Bobby J. Shannon , Thomas A. Treadon Stephen D. Sheehan Martin B. Treuhaft Steven S. Carter Thomas 1W. Gorge,s James R. Klein ,.. Dennis P. Murphy Bennie H . Castro Samuel B. Graves ·, Rickell D. Knoll John T. Murphy, Jr. Harvey W. C. Shelton James D. Turinetti III William H. Cathey Timothy J. -:_Graves Joseph A. Koenig Ronald W. Murray ' Donald J . Shinafelt Armond A. Turner Raymond Chojnacki Victor W. Grazier·1 '· Joseph R. Kolek, Jr. Mark H. Mutchler Michael C. Short Larry M. Twitchell Michael F. Chorvat Bradford C. Grems Norman L. KomnicJ:t James D. Mynar Richard W. Shuey Richard L. Umbarger Kenneth H . Clark II III Eugene Korotky Dennis M. Nagy John Sidor, Jr. Dennis E. Valentine Gary A. Close Alfred W . Grieshaber, Thomas E. Koss Allen F. Natella Lance P. Sijan Jeffrey H. Valentine John E . Coblentz Jr. . Kenneth E. Krause James C. Navarra Gary H. Silence Jeffrey F . Vendetti James G . Codling John R. Gritsavage Michael d. Krause Donald E. Neireiter Jeffrey D. Silliman Malcolm E. Verdict William L. Cole Stephen R. · Grohs ' Leonard R. Kruczyn- Curtis D. Nelson Richard E. Siner James L. Vick Charles B. Coleman John B. Gross ski James V. Newendorp Julius A. Small John M. Vickery III Bruce D. Grossetta James P. LaBounty, George W. Nicholas Dennis A. Smith William T. Vinson William L. Coleman Willard Grosvenor Jr. Terry L. Nicholas Joseph C. H. Smith John D. Vrettos Charles T. C. ComptonMarvin w. GuthrJ.e; Kary R. LaFors Christopher G. Nied Lester E. Smith Roger M. Vrooman John C. Conn, Jr. Jr. Robert G. Lambert William C. Nielsen, Jr. Michael D . Smith Brian E. Wages David M. Connaughtoncharles D. Haas William M. Landes I Michael P. Nolan Rocky 0. Smith John C. Wagner Sidney A. Cook John J. Haas III Robert W. Langley David L. Nolting Victor A. Smith William F. Wall David R. Cooper Harley B. Hackett III Robert A. Larsen -Tad J. Oelstrom Wayne O. Smith Bruce A. Wallace John W. Corman Robert P. Raffa, Jr. · Stephen H. Lawrenc~ I James R. Oliver. Edward C. Sois,tman,Steven E. E. Wallach John C. Cowan John M. Haggerty James G. Lawson Richard C. Oliver Jr. Robert E. Walsh Barry L. Cox L. Kirk Hall Joseph A. LeM1re Richard E. Olsen Robert S. Sonier Jerry T. Walton Fred J. Cox III Henry G. Hamby III Bruce G. Leonard, Jr. Theodore E. Olson James W. Soulek John A. Warden III Harvey B . Cox III Albert T. Hamilton Eric L. Lindemann James L. Ough Charles W. Specht Gray D. Warren ~ax A. Creamer Robert L. Hanley Charles B . Lingam- ' Jesse·U. Overall IV James E. Spittler, Jr. Robert K. Waterman James A. Crew Brendan A. Hanniffy , felter II Thomas A. Owens John R . Stephenson Craig K. Waterstraat Stephen P. Cronen- Don R. Hanson Gerald R. Linn Roland J. Page George A. Stetz Barry D. Watts wett ' ' · Eric A. Ham.ishek James C. Lipham, Jr . . Robert K. Panke Lawrence A. Stone William T. Wayne Lorenzo M. Crowell, Wendell J. Harkleroad William H. Little,__ Jr. Phil_ip M. Parker, Jr. Neil H . Stone Edward E. Webber, Jr. Jr. William H . Hartis Marvin R. Loper , Jock P. Patterson Kenny W. Sublett William J. Weida Christopher C. CurrieHarry ·c. Harrison James!,.. Lotteri Robert L. }>enry Peter L. Supp Douglas T. Weidner Thomas C. Daffron William R. Harwood, John J. Love tu ·. Wllliam L. Pepper Roy N. Suzuki ~ Timothy T. Wheeler - Charles W. Dahlberg Jr. Albin E. Lucki ,~• ~aymond P. Perkowski Robert S. Sv.ob, Jr. John F. White II Anderson E. Ha tfleld Lynw,ooq .,H. L'!eb,SeJJ Japies M. Perry , James F. Swallow III Michael B. White Robert D. Davenport III Lionel H. Luxich, Jr. Peter G. Pfendler John T. Swan Michael A. Whitehorn Robert R. Davies Carl M. Hatlelid Carl V. Lyday . J\,iioh~el A. Phillips Allan R. Sweeny Robert C. Wilburn Joseph P. Davis Robert K. Heaton Michael ;r. Lynch , rr T)lomas D. Pilsch . Wijliam A. Swick IH ;Fletcher H. Wiley Ralph S. Davis, Jr. Joseph M. Henderson, Theodore J. Lynn, Jr. James R. Piper, Jr.,) John C. Tait Paul L. Wilke Frederick J. DeGroot Jr. Glen!! M. M;acDonaltj. Thomas H. Plank Donald R. Talbott ,, Jerome S. Wilkowski , Walter E. Deacon II Stephen Henderson ~ Paul D. MacP~Vw'.:ell , : Bentley V. Plummer , John s. Talley Charles H. Williams Gerald P. J. DeMockoJames F. Henkelma:qn Wllliam E. Malerba Michael R. Polich John W. Tankersley James S . Wilson Richard M. Dewing William c. Harrick . William N. Mangan Loren R. Pool Michael F . Tedesco Bruce A. Witty David A. Dick Peter D. Hesford , ._. Michael f. Manley • William A. Powers Jude H. Terhall Curtis L. Wolfe Paul B . Dickey · John A. Hewitt, Ji'. · Charles A. Marks Gerald E . Preston Charles A. Thomas Timothy R. Wolte Steven K. Dingman James D. High • •· Randolph M. Martin Charles E. Price James L. Thomas Charles P. Wood, Jr. We'sley B. Dixon Howard J.r Hill I Michael J. Mason Robert H. Price, Jr. Paul R. Thomas James W. Wood Harry T. Doerer Merrill C. Hiscock • . • Garey T .1Matsuyama Gene T. Puhl Howard C. Thompson Wendell B. Wood r Myron L. _Donald Willard E. Hobbs, Jr. ThomasrT. Maxwell John S. Puster Jack E. Thompson · Grady A. Wright Donald M. Douglas G~rald w. Hodgson Kenneth E. McAlear John M. Raby Thomas N. Thompson George 0. Young III · Wllliam G. Douglas , Stephen D. Hoffman Roger McAniff John T. Rademacher Robert R. Tindall Robert G. Zepecki Terrance M. Drabant 'Alva B. Holaday James E. Mc'Ardle, Jr: Orvin H. Rimlo, Jr. Gary W. Titmas Edwin T. Zimny, J_r. Edward A. Duff Robert R. Holder Francis X. Mccann Larry I. Rank Zoltan J. Tober, J;r. Richard A. Zucker Stewart S. Duncan David M.' Holdren Robert B. Mccollough William B. Raspotnik' John B. Torsey 1 George H. Dunkel- · Dennis R. Hollars Timothy F. McConnellLeon' L. Rausch The following cadets, U.S. Air Force Acad berg, J.r. L'ee E. Hollingsworth James C. McCracken, David H . Rawlins emy, for appointment in the Regular Alf David L. Dye Daniel R. J. Holoviak Jr. , Paul D . Ra~ond 1 Forc·e, th the graqe of second lieutenant, ,ef James C. Edwards James M. Hopkins Lawrence L. • Frank L. Reid fective upon their graduation, 'under th~ Jerry L. Elder Earl P. Hopper, Jr. McCracken Errol G. Reiner provisions of section 8284, title 10, United William R. Kenneth R. Hough Michael W. McCroskeyPhillip A.· Richardson States Code, with a view to designation un Engebretson John R. Howard Patrick J. McDaniel · David M. Richey der the provisions of section 8067, title 10, Guy G. Engler Gerald D. Huff William E. McDermottRichard' J. Robbins United States Code, to perform the duties of Brian E. Esterby Bruce V. Huneke James P. McGorry Ross M. Roberts medical service officers. Date of rank to be Howell M. Estes III Wilbur· J. Hunt Douglas A. McGrath William A. Roberts determined. by the Secreta,ry of the Air Force: Steven A. Eszenyi Richard C. Husemann Peter T. Mcinerney, Clinton B. Robertson J.ohn R. Buscher Lowell A. Schuknecht, Douglas M. Fain Robert W. Hutter Jr. ' Garr.E, Robison I ' Craig L. McKinney James T. Robison, Jr. John R. Mootz Jr. Edward P. Farrell Steven E. Icard! Eric B. Zurbrugg Lawrence P. Farrell, i}lphonse Iudicello George H. McKinney, Harry E. Rodman, Jr. Jr. Neil A. Jacobs Jr. r Donald W : Rogers · Tqe following cadets, U.S. Milit1:1,ry Acad Edward A. Faust! Alfred R. Jacox, Jr. William C. McLeod II Wayne R. Rogers emy, for appointment in the Regular Air Peter F. Fazio Charles F. Johnson , Joseph V. McNabb, Jr. Reuel Y. RQlston Fo ce, in the grade of second lieutenant, Jackson R. Ferguson.Elmer P. Johnson, James D. Meiggs Howard C. Rose, Jr. effective upon their "graduation, under 'the Jr. ;Keith A. Johnson Robert J. Mefaen- • Perry T. Rose provisions of section 8284, title 10, United Daniel K. Fetzer Mark A. Johnson helder II Albert A. Rowe States Code. Date of rank to be determineq WUliam S. Finch Theodore w. Johnson Steven B. Melnick Harold L. Rust by the Secretary of the Air Force: , Ronald R. Flake Robert F . Jones ' Douglas M. Melson Johµ D. Ryan, Jr. Edward T. Meschko Michael E. Ryan Ralph W. Adams, Jr. Donald C. Exelby Robert Y. Foerster William K. Jones Edwin L. Armstrong William J. Fields Joseph L. Forinash, Edward P. Jordan Jo.hn H. Metz Charl~ w. Ryers~n Ronald F. Miazga Marc L. Sabin , Robert L. Bedetl Ernest G . Forrest III Jr. Stanley K. Jordan John A. Bell Robert F. Fritz, Jr. ' William B. Fortney J<;>hn A. Judd Preben R. Miller, Jr. Qp.arles A. Saletta, Jr. Gary F. Mills ' . Larry K. Sanborn William J. Bradbur"n Thomas C. Genoni Roy A. Fricke John A. Justice , 1 Gerald A. Buckosky Douglas K. Gentzkow ' Peter s. Miner I William A. Sanches I Ronald G. Gados James L. Kaltenbach Thomas M. Bumpass, ;Hershall D. Hall Earles. Monroe' Van C. Sanders, Jr. Charles B. GannawayMichael J. Keefe ' Jr. James H. Hall , , John T. Garner George R . Kellei: Ira J. Moore,•Jr. Dennis·G . Scarborough Robert M. Carini William T. Heller Victor L. Genez John J. Kelly, Jr. Patr(ck C. Moore Scott A. Schafer · Milburn K. Concan- Kenneth E. Hjelm Thomas E. Gibbs, Jr.Robert G. Kemniere"t William T. Morgan Terry L. Schilling non, Jr. . Robert W. Huffhines, Robert B. Giffen III , William S. Morris Richard T. Schlosberg Eric T. DeJonckheere, Jr. Darrell D. Giffin William F. Kemp William J. Morrison III Jr. Jack M . Jannarone Donald F. Giglio William J. Kennedy Roger W. Morte1:1sen Jeffrey P. Schmidt Dominic A. DeSantis, Thomas H. Johnson Gil L. Glllespie Gerald L. Keyser, Jr. Boyd P. Mossman LeRoy B. Schroeder Jr. Robert C. Jones Robert F. Golden Roy R. Kilgore Anthony E. Mras .John G. Sellers Glenn R. Doughty, Jr. Nathan Kantor Brian E. Goldner Robert K. Kirch Michael D. Muldoon James C. Selser III Jeroq:ie P. ~our, i]r_. Thomas J. Kelly , 1 I J 8372 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - HOUSE April .~6, 1965 Albert E. Knauf, Jr. Anthony P . Pyrz His sacrifice, that we may live freely the Consent Calendar and the Private John W. Koletty Thomas A. Ridenour with joy and happiness amidst all the Calendar will be called today. Joseph P . Kosciusko Dennis J . Sellers glories of Thy creation. Amen. Richard E. Kramer Dennis A. Shantz The Clerk will call the first bill on the David B. Kuhn, Jr. Charles F. Shaw, Jr. Consent Calendar. Richard A. Leary Thomas R. Sheckells Anthony G. Livic Michael T. Shulick THE JOURNAL Gordon A. Long Grover C. Starling The Journal of the proceedings of SECTION 502 OF THE MERCHANT John A. Madia Jerry R. Stockton Thursday, April 22, 1965, was read and MARINE ACT David V. Mastran Francis P . Tantalo approved. Walter H. Oehrlein Thomas D. Thompson The Clerk called the bill (H.R. 4346) Richard M . Osgood, Terrence R. Tutchings to amend section 502 of the Merchant Jr. James R. Webb III MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT Marine Act, 1936, relating to construc Karl J . Plotkin Richard G. Wirth tion differential subsidies. Frank J . Prokop Adolf H. Zabka A message in writing from the Presi The SPEAKER. Is there objection to Richard E. Pullen Andrew A. Zaleski II dent of the United States was communi the present consideration of the bill? The following midshipmen, U.S. Naval cated to the House by Mr. Geisler, one Mr. GROSS. Mr. Speaker, reserving Academy, for appointment in the Regular of his secretaries, who also informed the the right to object, I would like to ask Air Force, in the grade of second lieutenant, House that on the following dates the someone how much longer it is antici effective upon their graduation, under the President approved and signed bills of pated it will be necessary to pay a 60- provisions of section 8284, title 10, United . the House of the following titles: percent subsidy for the construction of States Code. Date of rank to be determined On April 11, 1965: by the Secretary of the Air Force: passenger vessels and 55-percent sub H.R. 2362. An act to strengthen and im sidies for the construction of freight and Richard D. Bayer . Boyd K. Knowles prove, educational quality and educational Robert F. Cook Thomas 0. Koch opportunities in the Nation's elementary and other vessels. Robert D. Hennessy Bernd McConnell secondary schools. Mr. BONNER. Mr. Speaker, let me Jan M. Jobanek Nicholas A. Paldino On April 16, 1965: say as chairman of the Committee on Henry B. Keese Furman E. Thomas H .R. 5721. An act to amend the Agricul Merchant Marine and Fisheries that the tural Adjustment Act of 1938, as amended, gentleman raises a very good question. to provide for acreage-poundage marketing If we are going to have an American quotas for tobacco, to amend the tobacco merchant marine, we are going to have HOUSE OF.REPRESENTATIVES price support provisions of the Agricultural to subsidize the construction of vessels Act of 1949, as amended, and for other and the operation of American-flag ves MONDAY, APRIL 26, 1965 purposes. On April 20, 1965: sels. So you can take your choice. We The House met at 12 o'clock noon. H.R. 4527. An act to authorize appropria recently held hearings and were advised Archbishop Hrant Katchadoorian, tions for procurement of vessels and aircraft by high officials of the Navy that the prelate of Armenians of North America, and construction of shore and offshore es American merchant marine was essen offered the following prayer: tablishments for the Coast Guard. tial to the operation of the national de fense. This bill is a continuation of the In the name of the Father, and of existing law. It extends it for 1 year. the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen. MESSAGE FROM THE SENATE It is just that plain, I say to my fine Almighty God, divine Guide of all na A message from the Senate by Mr. friend; we are going to have to have this tions and people, direct us along the path Arrington, one of its clerks, announced or we are just not going to construct any of justice and honor in the conduct of that the Senate had passed a bill of the more vessels. our daily affairs. Shower Thy blessings following title, in which the concurrence Mr. GROSS. Would the distinguished on this noble Nation so that it may con of the House is requested: · gentleman from North Carolina be able tinue to shine with a warm brilliance S. 327. An act to provide assistance· to the to give us any assurance that these sub amidst the darkening clouds of tyranny States of Oregon, Washington, California, sidies can be reduced in the foreseeable and oppression. Give of Thy eternal and Idaho for the reconstruction of areas future or must they continue at the high wisdom to the several Members of this damaged by recent floods and high waters. rate of 55 and 60 percent? august body, that they may be inspired The message also announced that the Mr. BONNER. There is a matter of toward a greatness of purpose, that they accelerating costs under the situations may be ennobled in the urgent search for Senate disagrees to the amendments of the House to the joint resolution (S.J. that now exist. The gentleman knows peace, freedom, and justice for all of what those costs are due to. mankind. Res. 1) entitled "Joint resolution propos ing an amendment to the Constitution of Mr. GROSS. In other words, if infla In particular, we beseech Thee, O God, tion continues in this country-- to be mindful of the Armenian people the United States relating to succession to the Presidency and Vice-Presidency Mr. BONNER. I do not think it is who this year sorrowfully commemorate inflation so . much. I think it is the the 50th anniversary of the martyrdom and to cases where the President is un able to discharge the powers and duties manner in which they operate with re of one and a half million Armenians in spect to labor contracts. the Turkish massacres of 1915. Mindful of his office," requests a conference with of the teachings of Thy Son, our Lord, the House on the disagreeing votes of the Mr. GROSS. Of course, inflation and Jesus Christ, we ask not for retribution two Houses thereon, and appoints Mr. increasing costs enter into that. or vengeance but for repentance and BAYH, Mr. EASTLAND, Mr. ERVIN, Mr. Mr. BONNER. If you want to call that redemption. The Armenians have suf DIRKSEN, and Mr. HRUSKA to be the con inflation then, of course, that is your fered too long the pain of tyranny and ferees on the part of the Senate. privilege. I am not opposed to unionism, oppression. They, too, wish to share in but we do have a difficult time keeping Thy most precious gifts of liberty and our ships and our merchant marine COMMITTEE ON BANKING AND operating. We have difficulty on the justice. Their once joyous land, that CURRENCY nation of Christian warrors, O Lord, is shore side as well as the floating side. now but a barren wasteland of sad and Mr. ALBERT. Mr. Speaker, I ask So, I feel very much concerned about painful memories. Grant that they and unanimous consent that the Committee this. I know we must have these ships Thy other homeless children be soon on Banking and currency have permis and I know the position of the gentle given the hope and re~lity of freedom. sion to sit today while the House is in man from Iowa. We pray, Almighty God, that never session, during general debate. Mr. GROSS. One further question: again on this earth will the horror of The SPEAKER. Is there objection to Are the American shipyard owners genocide afflict any of Thy children. the request of the gentleman from Okla spending any money to modernize the Spare them, through Thy divine inter homa? shipyards of this country to meet the cession, the pain and grief which we try There was no objection. modernization and lower costs of foreign to forget but in our human weakness yards? cannot. Mr. BONNER. If the gentleman will Grant to all of the nations of the CONSENT CALENDAR yield further, I believe ,we have good family of mankind, the compassion and The SPEAKER. · Pursuant to the management in our American yards. I love which Thy Son offered to us through unanimous-consent request of April 14, believe they have modern equipment.