New Chapters in the History of Greek Literature
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
New Chapters in the History of Greek Literature 3\(ezv Chapters in the History of Greek Literature SECOND SERIES SOME RECENT DISCOVERIES IN GREEK 1'OETRY AND PROSE, CHIEFLY OF THE FoURTH CENTURY B.C. AND LATER TIMES EDITED BY J. U. POWELL and E. A. BARBER Biblo & Tannen New York 1974 Originally Published 1929 Reprinted 1974 With the Permission of The Clarendon Press by Biblo & Tannen Booksellers & Publishers, Inc. 63 Fourth Avenue New York, N.Y. 10003 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Powell, John Undershell, 1865- ed. New chapters in the history of Greek literature. second series Reprint of the 1929 ed. published by Clarendon Press, Oxford. Includes bibliographies. 1. Greek literature —Addresses, essays, lectures. I. Barber, Eric Arthur, 1888- joint ed. II. Title. PA3061.P6 197U 88o'.9'ooi 7U-2030 ISBN 0-8196-0287-6 Printed In U.S.A. by NOBLE OFFSET PRINTERS, INC, Nsw York, N.Y. 10003 PREFACE The approval which was given by scholars to our First Series published in 192 1 has encouraged us to continue the work, and we hope that in the two series together we have given afi account of most of the chief accessions to the Greek literature of our period which have been published up to the present time. The reasons for choosing this period are given in the Preface to the First Series. But as new accessions continue to be made, so fresh criticism continues to appear ; and even while the book was passing through the Press, we observed instances of this (for the subject is living and growing), but it was too late to incorporate them. We must apologize if we have trespassed too far into the period a. d. ; if we have, it was to render the treat ment of the subject more complete. We have also added in an Appendix an article on the recent accessions to the Hesiodic poems, in order to summarize the important work which has been done on them in England and in other countries. As in the First Scries, while we have exercised a general supervision of the articles, we have allowed each of our contributors to treat his subject in his own way, and hence slight repetition here and there was unavoid able. We have to express our thanks to them, and also to several other scholars ; imprimis to Professor Hunt for his unfailing interest and assistance ; next to Mr. A. D. Knox, Mr. E. Lobel, Mr. R. McKenzie, vi PREFACE Mr. H. J. M. Milne, Professor E. B. Poulton, and Mr. M. N. Tod, who have placed their learning liberally at our disposal. But our chief debt of gratitude is due to the Delegates of the Clarendon Press for their continued approval and support. J. U. P. E. A. B. CONTENTS Preface . List of Contributors POETRY r. new The fragments of Callimachus . E. A. Barber i 2. Menander G. Murray 9 3. Later Epic Poetry . J. U. Powell 35 4. New Epigrams from Inscriptions of the fourth and . following centuries p.. c. J. U. Powki 1. 47 5. Additions to the chapters on Later l.yrir Poetry and the Moralists in the First Scries 1. V. Powki. 1. fio PROSF. 1. New of fragments Historical Works . E. M. Walkkr 65 Timachidas C.C.Richards 76 Addendum : A Catalogue of a Rhodian Library J. U. Powell 83 2. AiuAoyos, AictTpi/??;, M(\(tt] . W. M. EDWARDS S8 3. Letter-writing : The Papyri of Zenon . C. C. Eugar 125 of . Letters private persons . C. J. Ellingham 134 4. The Arts : Greek Music in the Papyri and Inscrip tions . J. F. Mountford 146 Medicine: the 'larpiKa. of Menon . E. T. Withington 183 APPENDICES 1. Recent accessions to the Poetry of the Boeotian School (Hesiodea) . J. U. Powell 189 2. On two lists of Philosophical works . J. U. Powell 211 3. On the proposed identification of Kanarese in Oxyrh. Pap. No. 413 in 'New Chapters', First Series, p. 12 r . E. P. Rice 215 4. of . Corrections the First Series . .224 INDEX --5 CONTRIBUTORS College. E. A. Barber, Fellow and Senior Tutor of Exeter C. C. Edgar, formerly Keeper of the Cairo Museum. Major W. M. Edwards, R.A., Professor of Greek in the University of Leeds. Rev. C. J. Ellingham, Assistant Master at the City of London School. J. F. MouNTFORD, Professor of Latin in the University College, Aberystwyth, University of Wales. Gilbert Murray, Regius Professor of Greek. J. U. Powell, Fellow and Tutor of St. John's College. Rev. Edward P. Rice, London Missionary Society (retired), author of A History of Kanarese Literature. Canon G. C. Richards, Professor of Greek in the University of Durham. Rev. E. M. Walker, Pro-Provost of the Queen's College. E. T. WlTHlNGTON, M.B., author of Medical History from the Earliest Times, and The History of Greek Therapeutics and tlie Malaria Theory. POETRY I CALLIMACHUS New light continues to be shed on the poetry and person ality of Callimachus by the publication of further fragments from his writings, derived from the papyri. It is true that often the material thus furnished is tantalizing in its incom pleteness, and that in most cases the reconstructions of earlier (' ' scholars are refuted by the new discoveries reconstruction is particularly difficult in dealing with an author who made it a principle never to write as the reader might reasonably suppose that he would) ; nevertheless, though we still grope in the twilight, we can be grateful to the papyri that it is no longer a i>i>£ dnopos which surrounds us. Since 1921 Oxyrhynchus has contributed additions to the fragments of Callimachus on two occasions. The earlier but less interesting publication represents to all appearance a branch of the poet's activity of which little has been otherwise pre ' ' served, to wit the occasional elegies which, as Poet Laureate of the day, he was called upon to compose for the Ptolemies and their court. Such elegies no doubt first saw the light separately like the Idylls ofTheocritus ; later either Callimachus himself or more probably some successor, corresponding to Artemidorus and Theon, the editors of Theocritus, made a collection of these stray pieces. The meagre remains of his Oxyrhynchus.1 collection lie before us in our papyrus from This, it seems, contains fragments from at least three elegies, Catullus' viz. (1) the original of Coma Berenices, (2) another elegy mentioning Berenice and her father Magas, (3) the elegiac Epinikion addressed to Sosibius. Only a few muti lated lines survive from the first and second of these poems, ' ' but the Victory of Sosibius (we owe the title to the scholiast on Lycophron. Alex. 522) is better preserved. 1 Oxyrh. Pap. xv. 1793. a POETRY the There has been considerable debate regarding identity the original editor of the Sosibius in question. Professor Hunt, him with a Sosibius of of the papyrus, was inclined to identify Josephus1 of the Tarentum mentioned by as a captain body scholars pin guard of Philadelphus ; Wilamowitz and other Athenaeus,2 their faith to a statement of who after referring to ' ' Theophrastus to Cassander a tract on Kingship addressed by (pb. 297 B. c.) adds that many attribute the work to Sosibius ' for whom the poet Callimachus composed an Epimkion in elegiacs'. Both these identifications, but especially the second, demand that we should date the poem very early in Calli machus' life, and Wilamowitz unconvincingly claims that such dating is confirmed by the internal evidence of the poet's style and attitude towards his patron. There can, however, be little 3 Beloch4 doubt that Herzog and are right in maintaining that the addressee of Callimachus was the notorious Grand Vizier of Ptolemy IV (Philopator) who won the battle of Raphia in Polybius5 ' ' 217 s. C, and is pilloried by as the false guardian (yjrevSeirirpoTros) of the young heir of Philopator. The father of the minister, as we know from inscriptions, was called Dioscurides, and no doubt Call. Fr. 19a Upa, vvv Se AioaKovpiSeco yeverj belongs to the poem that we are discussing. This Sosibius died at an advanced age shortly after 202 B. C, and was there fore, it seems, not born much before 270 B. C, but the probable date of some of the inscriptions which mention his name and the references of Polybius to his career make it likely that he was already a figure of some importance under the third Ptolemy and even as early as 240 B. C It appears probable then that Callimachus wrote his con gratulatory elegy in the forties of the third century ; if so, the ' ' Victory of Sosibius like the Coma Berenices, the Hymn to Apollo, several epigrams, even possibly (see below) the Aetia, 1 2 Ant. xii. 2. 2. iv, p. 144 e. 3 Philol. Ixxix. 4, pp. 424-5 ; ib. lxxxii. 1, pp. 61-3. * Griech. Gesch? iv. 2, pp. 589-90. Athenaeus, toe. cit., has confused the statesman with his namesake, the Lacedaemonian grammarian, designated Xdtikos or imXvriKos, a contemporary of Philadelphus. 6 xv. 25. 1. CALLIMACHUS 3 Callimachus' furnishes proof of continued productivity at the very end of his life. The particular victory or rather victories celebrated by the poet were won in the chariot-races at the Isthmian and Nemean games ; in virtue of this achievement Callimachus hails his patron as . 6Wre$eoc dfji<boTep<p irapa naiSi, Kao-tyvrJTa> r« Atdpyov kcu to Mvpiuaiov tco ydXa dr/<ra/x(vai ('twice-crowned hard by either child, both the brother of Learchus and the infant who was suckled with the milk of Myrina's daughter '). Even the poet's friends at the Alexan drian Museum may have been hard put to it to remember that Learchus' brother was Melicertes-Palaemon.