Laser Therapy of Pigmented Lesions: Pro and Contra
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Acta Dermatovenerol Croat 2010;18(3):185-189 REVIEW Laser Therapy of Pigmented Lesions: Pro and Contra Zrinka Bukvić Mokos, Jasna Lipozenčić, Romana Čeović, Daška Štulhofer Buzina, Krešimir Kostović University Hospital Center Zagreb, Department of Dermatology and Venereology, School of Medicine University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia Corresponding author: SUMMARY Although frequently performed, laser removal of Assist. Prof. Zrinka Bukvić Mokos, MD, PhD pigmented lesions still contains certain controversial issues. Epidermal pigmented lesions include solar lentigines, ephelides, University Hospital Center Zagreb café au lait macules and seborrheic keratoses. Dermal lesions Department of Dermatology and Venereology include melanocytic nevi, blue nevi, drug induced hyperpigmentation School of Medicine University of Zagreb and nevus of Ota and Ito. Some lesions exhibit both an epidermal and dermal component like Becker’s nevus, postinflammatory Šalata 4 hyperpigmentations, melasma and nevus spilus. Due to the wide HR-10000 Zagreb absorption spectrum of melanin (500-1100 nm), several laser systems Croatia are effective in removal of pigmented lesions. These lasers include [email protected] the pigmented lesion pulsed dye laser (510 nm), the Q-switched ruby laser (694 nm), the Q-switched alexandrite laser (755 nm) and the Q-switched Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm), which can be frequency- Received: July 7, 2010 doubled to produce visible green light with a wavelength of 532 Accepted: July 30, 2010 nm. The results of laser therapy are usually successful. However, there are still many controversies regarding the use of lasers in treating certain pigmented lesions. Actually, the essential question in removing pigmented lesions with lasers is whether the lesion has atypical features or has a malignant potential. Dermoscopy, used as a routine first-level diagnostic technique, is helpful in most cases. If there is any doubt whether the lesion is benign, then a biopsy for histologic evaluation is obligatory. KEY WORDS: laser, pigmented lesions, nevi INTRODUCTION In recent years, lasers have been frequently dermal and mixed (epidermal/dermal) pigmented successfully used in treating various pigmented lesions. Epidermal pigmented lesions include so- lesions. The results are usually successful. How- lar lentigines, ephelides, café au lait macules and ever, there are still many controversies regarding seborrheic keratoses. Dermal lesions include me- laser therapy of certain pigmented lesions. lanocytic nevi, blue nevi, drug induced hyperpig- In general, pigmented lesions are categorized mentation and nevus of Ota and Ito. Some lesions by location of pigment in three groups: epidermal, exhibit both an epidermal and dermal component: 185 Bukvić Mokos et al. Acta Dermatovenerol Croat Laser Therapy of Pigmented Lesions: Pro and Contra 2010;18(3):185-189 Becker’s nevus, postinflammatory hyperpigmen- due to absorption of laser energy by oxyhemo- tations, melasma and nevus spilus (1). globin. A fine crust typically forms over the laser Melanin is the main natural cutaneous pigment treated area and peels off after one week (6,7). to be considered when dealing with pigmented le- sions. It is contained in melanosomes within the QS ruby laser (QSRL) epidermis and dermoepidermal junction (melanin The Q-switched ruby laser emits visible red light horizontal distribution). Also, it is highly concen- at a wavelength of 694 nm and pulse duration of trated in hair follicles and vertical growth compo- 25-40 nanoseconds. This wavelength is strongly nents of nevomelanocytic nevi (2). absorbed by superficial melanin, which can lead to To obtain selective photothermolysis of mela- permanent hypopigmentation and depigmentation nin, pigmented lesions must be treated with laser in darker-skinned individuals. The absorption of light having a wavelength appropriate to absorp- ruby laser energy by hemoglobin is minimal. After tion characteristics of melanin. Due to the wide ab- treatment, the crust is formed at the site of laser sorption spectrum of melanin (500-1100 nm), sev- irradiation and peels off after several days (8,9). eral laser systems are effective in the removal of pigmented lesions: pigmented lesion pulsed dye QS alexandrite laser laser (510 nm), Q-switched ruby laser (694 nm), This laser operates at a wavelength of 755 nm Q-switched alexandrite laser (755 nm) and Q- and a pulse duration of 50-100 nanoseconds. Its switched Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm), which can be longer wavelength permits deeper tissue penetra- frequency-doubled to produce visible green light tion and less unwanted hypopigmentation com- with a wavelength of 532 nm. Lasers which emit pared with QSRL. Postoperative healing is similar green light with shorter wavelengths penetrate op- to other QS pigment-specific lasers, but is consid- tically very little into skin layers and require rela- ered less severe (10). tively less energy to produce irreversible thermal damage to melanosomes; therefore, they should QS Nd:YAG laser be selected to treat epidermal lesions. Lasers that emit red light with longer wavelengths are more It emits 1064 nm light, but it can also be fre- successful in treating deeper dermal melano- quency-doubled using a potassium diphosphate somes, i.e. dermal lesions (3). crystal to produce visible green light with a wave- length of 532 nm (a pulse duration of 5-10 nano- Selective pigment destruction depends not only seconds). Melanin has a strong affinity for 532 on wavelength but also on pulse duration. Submi- nm green light, whereas the longer 1064 nm red crosecond laser pulses are required for selective wavelength penetrates deeper in the dermis but disruption of melanosomes because their thermal with a lower melanin absorption coefficient. After relaxation time ranges from 250 to 1000 nanosec- the use of smaller spot sizes, tissue splatter usu- onds, depending on their size. Therefore, short- ally occurs, leading to crusting that may take sev- pulsed lasers with pulse durations from 40 to 750 eral weeks to fully resolve (11,12). nanoseconds are used, whereas longer pulse du- rations, in millisecond domain, do not cause spe- EPIDERMAL PIGMENTED LESIONS cific melanosome damage. At these pulsewidths, laser-tissue interaction produces a combination of Epidermal pigmented lesions can be effectively photothermal and photomechanical effects (4). In treated with both shorter wavelengths (green light addition, shorter wavelengths (<600 nm) require lasers) and longer wavelengths (red light lasers). relatively less energy fluences, while at longer Ephelides are very difficult to treat because wavelengths higher fluences are required to pro- they recur frequently after laser therapy. Before duce an efficient photothermal reaction (5). treatment, bleaching agents like hydroquinone may be used (1,13). Pigmented lesion dye laser Among all pigmented lesions, lentigines show The pigmented lesion dye laser emits light of probably the best response to laser therapy. They a 510 nm wavelength and a pulse duration of 300 typically fade by 50% or more after one treatment nanoseconds, which enables targeting superficial session. Complete eradication is usually observed melanosomes. This laser is effective in the treat- after three treatments in 6- to 8-week intervals ment of lentigines and other epidermal pigmented (14,15). lesions. Up to 50% of patients develop purpura Café au lait macules respond variably to laser 186 ACTA DERMATOVENEROLOGICA CROATICA Bukvić Mokos et al. Acta Dermatovenerol Croat Laser Therapy of Pigmented Lesions: Pro and Contra 2010;18(3):185-189 therapy and recur in as many as 50% of patients. types of melanocytic nevi require longer wave- Repeated treatments over a long period (several lengths, higher fluences and longer pulsewidths, months or even years) are needed to achieve max- and still tend to recur (1,13,20,21). In some treat- imal clearing of the lesion. Repigmentation occurs ed nevi, irregular repigmentation is observed af- from adjacent untreated melanocytes; therefore, ter laser treatment, termed pseudomelanoma. In the entire lesion should be treated at each session these cases, excisional biopsy must always be (1,13). performed, followed by dermopathology. For the above-mentioned reasons, surgical excision must MIXED EPIDERMAL/DERMAL be considered as the treatment of choice in these PIGMENTED LESIONS indications, while one must keep in mind the pos- sible risks when treating melanocytic nevi with la- Laser removal of Becker’s nevus is difficult. sers (22,23). Again, there is a variable response and a high rate of recurrences. Long pulsed lasers may prove Congenital nevi may pose a risk of melanoma most effective in treating both epidermal and fol- that increases with the size of lesion. Therefore, licular melanocytes (13,16). surgical excision is primary treatment of choice, while laser treatment should always be remem- Postinflammatory hyperpigmentations are bered as a secondary option performed in an at- often resistant to laser treatment. Multiple sessions tempt to either reduce the pigment or to remove are required to assess a slight improvement. associated hair growth. Laser treatment is asso- Melasma is often a therapeutic problem. Pig- ciated with several problems: variable response, ment can be located in epidermis, or in dermis, or permanent hypopigmentation, local scarring and in both of them. Similar to other traditional meth- rarely achieved complete clinical response. Ad- ods (sunscreen, retinoic acid, hydroquinone and ditionally, incomplete nevus