Assessment of Safer and Effective Alternatives for Coating Removal Products
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Assessment of Safer and Effective Alternatives for Coating Removal Products Gregory Morose, Jason Marshall, Alicia McCarthy Toxics Use Reduction Institute January 24, 2020 TURI Report 2020-001 All rights to this report belong to the Toxics Use Reduction Institute. The material may be duplicated with permission by contacting the Institute. The Toxics Use Reduction Institute is a multi-disciplinary research, education, and policy center established by the Massachusetts Toxics Use Reduction Act of 1989. The Institute sponsors and conducts research, organizes education and training programs and provides technical support to help Massachusetts companies and communities to reduce the use of toxic chemicals. For more information, visit our website (www.turi.org), write to the Toxics Use Reduction Institute (TURI, University of Massachusetts Lowell, 126 John St., Suite 14, Lowell, Massachusetts 01852), or call 978-934-3275. ©Toxics Use Reduction Institute, University of Massachusetts Lowell Contents I. Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 1 Background ................................................................................................................................ 1 Approach .................................................................................................................................... 1 Determine the Requirements ............................................................................................... 2 Conduct EHS, Cost, and Performance Evaluation ................................................................. 3 Research into New Safer Solvent Blends .............................................................................. 5 II. Evaluation Results ....................................................................................................................... 7 Requirement 1: Environmental, Health, and Safety .................................................................. 7 GreenScreen Assessments .................................................................................................... 7 Dermal Exposure ................................................................................................................. 14 Inhalation Exposure ............................................................................................................. 17 Additional Chemical Mixture Evaluation for New UMass Lowell Formulation .................. 17 Requirement 2: Fire Hazard ..................................................................................................... 18 Evaporation Measurement ................................................................................................. 19 Fire Hazard Test ................................................................................................................... 24 Requirement 3: Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC) Content ................................................. 27 Requirement 4: Cost ................................................................................................................ 28 Requirement 5: Technical Performance for a Range of Coatings and Substrates ................... 32 Test Procedure .................................................................................................................... 33 Methylene Chloride Comparison Test................................................................................. 35 Extended Dwell Time Test ................................................................................................... 36 Coatings on Wood Test Panels ............................................................................................ 36 Coatings on Masonry Blocks ............................................................................................... 42 Automotive Coatings ........................................................................................................... 43 Boat Coatings....................................................................................................................... 49 Chemical Agent Resistant Coatings (CARC) ......................................................................... 52 Adhesive Coatings ............................................................................................................... 55 Bathtub Coatings ................................................................................................................. 57 Asphalt/Tar Coatings ........................................................................................................... 60 Latex Splatter Coatings ........................................................................................................ 62 Furniture Refinishing ........................................................................................................... 64 Requirement 6: Penetration of Multilayer Coatings ............................................................... 66 Requirement 7: Shelf Life ......................................................................................................... 67 III. Conclusions .............................................................................................................................. 69 IV. References ............................................................................................................................... 70 Appendix 1: Coating Removal Product Solvents and TURA .......................................................... 72 Assessment of Safer and Effective Alternatives for Coating Removal Products iii Appendix 2: GreenScreen for Safer Chemicals ............................................................................. 73 Appendix 3: Hansen Solubility Parameters................................................................................... 76 Appendix 4: Dermal Exposure....................................................................................................... 77 Appendix 5: Fire Hazard ................................................................................................................ 81 Flash Point ................................................................................................................................ 81 Fire Hazard Test Method .......................................................................................................... 81 List of Tables Table 1: GreenScreen Benchmark Levels for Chemicals Used in Coating Removal Products ...................... 8 Table 2: GreenScreen Hazard Assessment Results ....................................................................................... 9 Table 3: Solvents Used in Coating Removal Products with Methylene Chloride........................................ 10 Table 4: Solvents Used in Coating Removal Products with Other Benchmark 1 Chemicals ....................... 11 Table 5: Coating Removal Products with NO Benchmark 1 Chemicals ....................................................... 13 Table 6: Coating Removal Products with No Benchmark 1 Chemicals But Containing Solvents with No GreenScreen Evaluation .............................................................................................................................. 14 Table 7: Skin Permeability Results for Solvents in Coating Removal Products ........................................... 16 Table 8: Strypeeze Solvents ........................................................................................................................ 20 Table 9: Evaporation Test Results ............................................................................................................... 24 Table 10: Fire Hazard Mitigation Method for Coating Removal Products .................................................. 26 Table 11: VOC-Exempt Solvents .................................................................................................................. 28 Table 12: Retail Pricing for Coating Removal Products ............................................................................... 29 Table 13: Methylene Chloride Products Used for Performance Testing in TURI Laboratory ..................... 35 Table 14: Performance Testing Conducted ................................................................................................. 35 Table 15: Wood Panel Test Results for Methylene Chloride Products ....................................................... 38 Table 16: Wood Panel Test Results for Products with No Benchmark 1 Chemicals ................................... 39 Table 17: Wood Panel Test Results for Products with Other Benchmark 1 Chemicals .............................. 40 Table 18: Dwell Times for Wood Panels ..................................................................................................... 40 Table 19: Extended Dwell Time Test Results for Wood Panels .................................................................. 41 Table 20: Masonry Block Test Results for Methylene Chloride Products ................................................... 42 Table 21: Masonry Block Test Results for Products with No Benchmark 1 Chemicals ............................... 43 Table 22: Masonry Block Test Results for Products with Other Benchmark 1 Chemicals .......................... 43 Table 23: Oven Dwell Times for Automotive Coatings ............................................................................... 44 Table 24: Dwell Times for