DOCSLIB.ORG

Introduction

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Introduction Introduction Schools of economic thought become popular or obsolete from time to time, much like fashion, but David Ricardo’s formulation of land, labor and capital wears well. Now known as “factors of production”, land, labor and capital are identified by Ricardo as crucial elements determining the value of produce.1 An inquiry into one or all of these three “factors of production” will shed important light on how an economy works and how a society is organized. Working from this assumption, I study the salt certificate in the Ming dynasty. I tell a story of the accidental rise and the unintended fall of a public capital market in Ming China, in the form of speculation in salt certificates, between the early sixteenth century and the year 1617. Salt administration, defined as government control over the produc- tion, distribution and consumption of salt, was a long tradition in imperial China. Samuel A. M. Adshead observes that, in a global context, the Chinese salt administration “had the longest and most continuous history”, and “in intellectual sophistication, with its administrative handbooks, technical lan- guages and tradition of expert argument, it had no rival.”2 The rich heritage of Chinese salt administration poses a challenge to researchers. Edmund Worthy shows us that scholars of several generations have contributed to the Western scholarship on the Chinese salt administrations of various dynasties.3 Hans Ulrich Vogel has devoted much effort to exploring the technical and cultural aspects of salt in Chinese history.4 It is the mission of this book to use the same official archives but tell a story beyond salt administration, a story about finan- cial capitalism in Ming China. 1 David Ricardo did not discuss land, labor and capital in terms of “factors of production”, but in terms of rent, wages and profits belonging to landlords, labourers and capitalists, respectively. For a succinct statement of this point, see his On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation, in Piero Sraffa ed., The Works and Correspondence of David Ricardo (Cambridge: University Press for the Royal Economic Society, 1951–1973), vol. 1, 49. 2 Samuel A. M. Adshead, Salt and Civilization (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1992), 178, 321. 3 Edmund H. Worthy, “ ‘Regional Control in the Southern Sung Salt Administration’ ”, in John Winthrop Haeger ed., Crisis and Prosperity in Sung China (Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1975), 101 ff. To Edmund Worthy’s literature review can at least be added Saeki Tomi’s paper, “Economie et Absolutisme dans la Chine Moderne: Le Cas des Marchands de Sel de Yangchow”, trans. Michel Cartier, Revue historique, T. 238, Fasc. 1 (1967), 15–30. 4 Yoshida Tora, Salt Production Techniques in Ancient China: The ‘Aobo Tu’, trans. Hans Ulrich Vogel (Leiden: Brill, 1993); Hans Ulrich Vogel, “Salt and Chinese culture: Some comparative aspects”, paper for the 8th Symposium on Chinese Dietary Culture (Sichuan University, 2003). © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���6 | doi ��.��63/9789004306400_00� 2 Introduction The Ming salt certificate was a product of the salt monopoly, known as the “grain-salt exchange” [kaizhongfa]. Along the eastern coastline of China, men from saltern households toiled in the salt fields, producing salt for the gov- ernment monopoly. The Ming government divided the entire country into salt production and consumption areas; designated consumption areas were supposed to consume salt from particular production areas. Although the government monopolized salt production and supervised salt consumption, it delegated the task of salt transportation in a very peculiar way. The govern- ment invited merchants to deliver grain to its frontier garrisons; in return, merchants were given salt certificates with which they could draw salt directly from the salt fields. In essence this grain-salt exchange was a promise the Ming government made to merchants in return for their service in providing grain to soldiers at the borders. The salt certificate therefore was a public debt of grain, denominated in salt, that the government owed merchants. Certainly, the Ming government did not perceive the “grain-salt exchange” in terms of borrowing from the public, but in terms of “salt administration”. However, if one is looking for public credit in early modern China, the salt certificate must constitute the closest evidence. Once created, the salt certificate very quickly deviated from the itinerary the state planned for it and ventured into the unknown. Merchants found the salt certificate more convenient and valuable than real salt, so much so that they did not care to redeem the salt certificate for salt. A speculative market for the salt certificate emerged in the fifteenth century, leading to chronic collapse of the salt administration. Starting from the sixteenth century, the use of silver further fuelled speculation in salt certificates. In the early seventeenth century this phenomenon brought into being a group of powerful financiers, many of whom originated from Huizhou. Regarding the speculative “bubble” as a seri- ous breach of its administration, the Ming government struck a deal with these financiers, granting them a hereditary franchise in the salt trade, but at the same time imposing on them the hereditary obligation of paying a salt cer- tificate tax. This “syndicate system”, established in 1617, effectively terminated the speculation in salt certificates and therefore also abolished the market for public debt. From 1617 onward, and throughout most of the Qing dynasty, the salt certificate was no longer a form of public debt, but a tax receipt. Such is the story of the Ming salt certificate in a nutshell. Before unfolding the story, however, it is important to delineate the theoretical context. To do so, we will have to turn back to capital, one of the three “factors of production”, identified by Ricardo, and briefly review its history in both China and the West. The capital market, in which capital circulates in varying forms (IOUs, notes of debt, securities, bonds, stocks, and futures), has long drawn the attention .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • William Furmval, H. E. Falk and the Salt Chamber of Commerce, 1815-1889: "Ome Chapters in the Economic History of Cheshire
    WILLIAM FURMVAL, H. E. FALK AND THE SALT CHAMBER OF COMMERCE, 1815-1889: "OME CHAPTERS IN THE ECONOMIC HISTORY OF CHESHIRE BY W. H. CHALONER, M.A., PH.D. Read 17 November 1960 N the second volume of his Economic History of Modern I Britain (p. 145), Sir John Clapham, writing of the chambers of commerce and trade associations which multiplied rapidly after 1860, suggested that between 1850 and 1875 "there was rather less co-operation among 'capitalist' producers than there had been in the more difficult first and second quarters" of the nineteenth century. He mentioned that in the British salt industry there had been price-fixing associations "based on a local monopoly" in the early nineteenth century, and added that after 1825 the industry "witnessed alternations of gentle­ men's agreements and 'fighting trade' " until the formation of the Salt Union in 1888. This combine has been called "the first British trust", but to the salt proprietors of the time it was merely "a new device, made easier by limited liability, for handling an old problem". (1) The purpose of this study is to examine in greater detail the business organisation of the natural local monopoly enjoyed by the Cheshire saltmakers in the nineteenth century and to trace the part played by "The Coalition" and the Salt Chamber of Commerce in fostering price regulation and output restriction between the end of the Napoleonic Wars and 1889.< 2 > 111 Op. cit., pp. 147-8; see also Accounts and Papers, 1817, III, 123, p. 22, and E. Hughes, Studies in Administration and Finance, 1558-1825 (1934), pp.
    [Show full text]
  • Identification and Evaluation of the South San Francisco Bay Solar Salt Industry Landscape (Alameda, Santa Clara, and San Mateo Counties, California)
    APPENDIX E: Identification and Evaluation of the South San Francisco Bay Solar Salt Industry Landscape (Alameda, Santa Clara, and San Mateo Counties, California) For the Don Edwards San Francisco Bay National Wildlife Refuge and California Department of Fish and Game Archimedes Screw pumps, Oliver Salt Works, Eden Landing, view to S (2007-12-01:57). By Lou Ann Speulda-Drews and Nicholas Valentine U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Region 8 Sacramento, California March 9, 2009 Introduction The South Bay Salt Pond Restoration Project’s (SBSPRP) goal is to convert the heavily modified environment of the solar salt industry back to native salt marsh. The restoration is focused on portions of San Mateo, Santa Clara, and Alameda Counties, and comprises approximately 15,100 acres of former salt ponds located around the edge of South San Francisco Bay. The SBSPRP encompasses property managed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) and the California Department of Fish and Game (DFG). The agencies are working together along with the California State Coastal Conservancy (Conservancy) and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) to develop a cohesive approach to restoration and complying with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA). The project overlaps five USGS 7.5’ topographical quadrangle maps: Newark, Redwood Point, Palo Alto, Milpitas, and Mountain View. The SBSPRP’s goal is to restore the industrial salt production ponds in South San Francisco Bay to a more natural mix of tidal wetland habitats and managed ponds. The SBSPP is composed of three noncontiguous units, including Eden Landing on the east side of the Bay near the San Mateo bridge; the Alviso unit at the southern end of the bay; and the West Bay-Ravenswood unit located on the west side of the Bay near the Dumbarton Bridge (Figure 1 and Appendix A).
    [Show full text]
  • 1. Introduction: Salt, Sodium Chloride, Has Probably Been with Us from The
    1. Introduction: Salt, sodium chloride, has probably been with us from the beginnings of geologic time, and has been necessary directly or indirectly through all stages of evolution of living things. The first oceans undoubtedly contained traces of salt, and our unicellular ancestors first appeared and thrived in this salty marine environment. In the process of evolution, these unicellular ancestors became multi-cellular, and some left their salty marine environment but still required salt. Our herbivorous ancestors used salt licks, and our carnivorous ones obtained their salt form the flesh and blood of their prey. This demand is necessity of/or all living for things for salt in one form or another continues today.Our bodies contain relatively large quantities of salt, as we may infer from the taste of “blood, sweat, and tears.”(Dalf.w.Knutmann, 1971) Salt, NaCl, is a chemical compound made of sodium and chloride which has been exceptionally important to humans for thousands of years, because it is one of the substances upon which all of life evolved to depend. Humans, like all life, need a supply of salt in order to simply survive. Salt's ability to preserve food was a foundation of civilization. It helped to eliminate the dependence on the seasonal availability of food and it allowed travel over long distances. However, salt was difficult to obtain, and so it was a highly valued trade item to the point of being considered a form of currency by certain peoples. Many salt roads, such as via salaria in Italy, had been established by the Bronze Age.
    [Show full text]
  • The Rise and Fall of the Marshalls of Northwich, Salt Proprietors: a Saga of the Industrial Era in Cheshire, 1720-1917
    THE RISE AND FALL OF THE MARSHALLS OF NORTHWICH, SALT PROPRIETORS: A SAGA OF THE INDUSTRIAL ERA IN CHESHIRE, 1720-1917 BY D. A. IREDALE, M.A., PH.D. HEN Thomas Marshall from the Hartford Beach, near WNorthwich, appeared before a parliamentary committee in London in 1817, he proudly proclaimed himself the largest salt proprietor in the kingdom. The wealthiest merchant in mid-Cheshire, Marshall determined that his family should one day sit on committees and at table with the greatest in the land. To this end he sent his son to Eton, Cambridge, and the Middle Temple. And his grandson did indeed climb towards the highest levels of society. I FOUNDING THE FAMILY FORTUNE During the seventeenth century the Marshalls lived in Nant- wich. They began business as shoemakers, then as framework knitters. By hard work they grew prosperous, so that when Richard Marshall died in 1692 the family owned a fine "dwelling house in the welshrow" and valuable textile machinery. But living in one of Cheshire's salt towns, the family naturally acquired a "wich-house & twelve leads walling", that is, equip­ ment for raising and boiling brine to produce salt. Salt had long been valued as a preservative and seasoner of food by the fisheries and the navy, by dairy farmers and every housewife, but during the industrial age it was to become an important raw material in the glass, soap, and chemical industries. To invest in salt, therefore, was to plan sensibly for future prosperity. The Marshalls sent much of their cloth and, probably, small loads of salt overland to Northwich, and then by river or road to Liverpool.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Science Department Summer Assignments
    SOCIAL SCIENCE DEPARTMENT SUMMER ASSIGNMENT 16-17 SOCIAL SCIENCE DEPARTMENT SUMMER ASSIGNMENTS: Sophomore: AP WORLD HISTORY CONGRATULATIONS! You have decided to take on the greatest challenge of your academic career. AP World History is a college level course covering "everything that has ever happened ever." It can sometimes be overwhelming. Do not take this challenge lightly. If you think this class is going to be a breeze... don't take it. If you do not complete assignments... don't take it. If you are not dedicated to accruing a wealth of knowledge about the world and its peoples... don't take it. If you are not up to the challenge... don't take it. However, if you are willing to work hard and take a fully comprehensive look at World History; you've come to the right place. THE ASSIGNMENT: You may think I am going overboard with this assignment, but I assure you, it is necessary. Once you get going on it, it won’t be too bad. Download the textbook immediately. You may also want to purchase the Princeton Review book Cracking the AP World History Exam 2017 ed.; you will find it very useful all year, and then of course it will be especially helpful when reviewing for the exam. Our course textbook is located here: https://www.dropbox.com/sh/gg67f3zgz38ahcp/AAAYE2F6ZVCdZxZejNxRO6iUa?oref=e&n=422522508 PART I: The Review Please read unit 1 (ch. 2-6 & 8) carefully and prepare Cornell notes on them1. There will be a reading check based on these readings (any and all material is fair game!) on the first full 80-minute day of class.
    [Show full text]
  • Canal and Salt Town Middlewich, Cheshire Heritage Research
    Canal and Salt Town Middlewich, Cheshire Heritage Research Report Middlewich Town Counci April 2009 SLR Ref: 406.1788.00002 406.1788.00002 Middlewich: Canal and Salt Town MIDDLEWICH CANAL AND SALT TOWN Introduction This report is one of the products of an exciting project started by Middlewich Town Council under their Middlewich Vision programme. The idea was to celebrate the salt and canal tradition of this historic town, and a successful bid to the Heritage Lottery Fund in 2007 allowed the Canal and Salt Town project to begin. The project included a canal boat festival and design of a trail along the canal, with interpretation boards to explain the history of the area. Research into the salt industry and canals, as well as gypsies and canal families at Middlewich resulted in information which was used for interpretation boards, an exhibition and a trail leaflet. It has also led to this report and archive that is available for educational purposes and for study by anyone who wishes to explore further, as well as a popular booklet which is a summary of the two aspects that has made Middlewich the place it is today. The sources used in this report are fully referenced at the end of each chapter. The report is presented in seven sections separated by blue dividers: 1 Salt 2 Canals 3 Gypsies 4 Geology 5 Flint Mill 6 Historic maps 7 Figures including photographs, reconstruction drawings and diagrams The report describes how the main focus for past communities at Middlewich was dominated by salt production. Salt was always important as a means to preserve food, and, as well as having a large number of other economic benefits, the uses that salt was put to by the people of Middlewich developed over the centuries into a highly sophisticated chemical industry.
    [Show full text]
  • The South Bay Salt Pond Restoration Project
    Copyright 2008 By Ellen Joslin Johnck ii AUTHORIZATION FOR REPRODUCTION OF MASTER’S THESIS I grant permission for the reproduction of this thesis in its entirety, without further authorization from me, on the condition that the person or agency requesting reproduction absorb the cost and provide proper acknowledgment of authorship. DATE:_________________ ______________________ Signature: Ellen Joslin Johnck 101 Lombard Street #217E Street Address San Francisco, CA 94111 City, State, Zip Code iii THE SOUTH BAY SALT POND RESTORATION PROJECT: A CULTURAL LANDSCAPE APPROACH FOR THE RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PLAN Thesis by Ellen Joslin Johnck ABSTRACT Purpose of the Thesis: The salt ponds and levees of southern San Francisco Bay are a culturally significant landscape wherein culture and nature have been linked over 150 years of industrial salt production through solar evaporation in an extensive wetland ecosystem. This 15,100-acre landscape is the subject of the South Bay Salt Pond Restoration Project (SBSPRP), the cultural resources of which are receiving scant attention relative to the SPSPRP’s primary resource management goals for wildlife habitat, flood prevention and public recreation. The intent of this thesis is to show how a cultural landscape analysis can be used in the SBSPRP to: 1) document the landscape’s cultural resources for the purpose of including them in the SBSPRP’s Resource Management Plan (RMP); 2) demonstrate how the landscape provides the organic and unifying context for the study of the interaction between humans and the natural environment characterized by revolving and cyclical patterns of exchange and adaptation over time and across space; 3) develop a heritage tourism plan, including a public interpretation program; 4) establish a basis for justifying the salt pond landscape’s cultural significance and potential eligibility for listing on the National Register of Historic Places.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Primitivity 1. for Two Examples of Commodity History One Large, the Other Small, See Robert Delort, Lecommerce Desfourrures En
    Notes 1 Primitivity 1. For two examples of commodity history one large, the other small, see Robert Delort, LeCommerce desFourrures enOccident iliafin du Moyen Age(vers 1300-vers 1450) (Ecole Francaise de Rome, Rome, 1978);F. M. L. Thompson, 'Nineteenth Century Horse Sense', Economic History Review, XXIX, No.1 (February 1976) pp. 6~1. 2. Jacques Nenquin, Salt A Study in Economic Prehistory (de Tempel, Brugge, 1961); Bernard Edeine, 'Les Techniques de Fabrication du Sel dans les sauneries pre et protohistoriques ainsi que Gallo-Romaines', Annales de Bretagne et des Pays de l'Ouest, Vol. 82 (1975) pp . 11-18; Jean-Paul Bertraux, 'L'Archeolog le du Sel en Lorraine: Le Briquetage de la Seille', Guy Cabour­ din (ed.), Le Sel et Son Histoire (Universite de Nancy II, Nancy, 1981) pp .519-38. 3. Peter S. Wells, 'Iron-Age Central Europe', Archaeology, Vol. 33, No . 5 (September-October 1980) pp. 6-11. 4. Nenquin, p. 53. 5. Giraldus Cambrensis, The Itinerary through Wales and the Description of Wales (Dent, London, 1919) p. 176. 6. Anthony P. Andrews, 'The Salt Trade of the Maya', Archaeology, Vol. 33, No.4 (July-August 1980) pp . 16-33. 7. Eric C. Thompson, Thomas Gage's Travels in the New World (University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, 1958) pp. 167, 204. 8. Ibid., p. 61. 9. Antonio Vazquez de Espinosa , Description of the Indies (c. 1620), tr, Charles Upson Clark (Smithsonian Institute Press, Washington, 1968) para 467. 10. Miguel O. de Mendizabal, Influencia delaSol enladistribucion geographica delos grupos indigenas de Mexico (Mexico, 1928). 11. Father Joseph de Acosta, The Natural and Moral History of the Indies, 2 vols (Hakluyt Society, London, 1880) p.
    [Show full text]
  • An Optimal Tax That Destroyed the Government
    An Optimal Tax That Destroyed the Government 論説 An Optimal Tax That Destroyed the Government ―An Economic Analysis of the Decline of the Tang (唐) Dynasty Professor, The University of Tokyo Minoru NAKAZATO Ⅰ．Introduction Ⅰ．Introduction Ⅱ．History of Salt 1 Importance of Salt in European History In our book “Japanese Law: An Economic 2 Ancient Chinese Salt Approach,” Professor Mark Ramseyer and I explained modern Japanese behavior through Ⅲ．History of Taxation in Ancient and micro-economic theory. I believe we can do Medieval China the same in the Chinese context. This short 1 Before the Tang (唐) Dynasty paper is a micro-economic analysis of one as- 2 Tang (唐) Dynasty pect of ancient Chinese history. ⑴ Brief History In this paper, I illustrate the way that ancient ⑵ Zuyongdiao (租庸調) System Chinese people behaved in essentially the ⑶ Salt Monopoly same way, that is rationally, as people in mod- ⑷ The Double-Tax System (liangshuifa, 兩 ern wealthy democracies. A micro-economic 税法) analysis of the ancient Chinese people would ⑸ Development of Manors (zhuangyuan, be possible, for example, in such various cases 莊園) in Tang (唐) Dynasty as the following: One would be a study of the stories about Ⅳ．History of Salt Tax and State Monopoly merchants recorded in the famous “Historian’s of Salt in Ancient and Medieval China Records” (Shiji, 史記) written by Sima Qian 1 Salt and State Budget (司馬遷). Chapter 69 of its Biographies of Fa- 2 Salt and Budget in China mous People (Liezhuan, 列傳) is entitled “Bi- 3 History of salt smuggling in Tang (唐) ographies of Merchants” (貨殖列傳).
    [Show full text]
  • Carol Litchfield Collection on the History of Salt 2012.219
    Carol Litchfield collection on the history of salt 2012.219 This finding aid was produced using ArchivesSpace on September 14, 2021. Description is written in: English. Describing Archives: A Content Standard Audiovisual Collections PO Box 3630 Wilmington, Delaware 19807 [email protected] URL: http://www.hagley.org/library Carol Litchfield collection on the history of salt 2012.219 Table of Contents Summary Information .................................................................................................................................... 7 Historical Note ............................................................................................................................................... 8 Scope and Content ....................................................................................................................................... 11 Administrative Information .......................................................................................................................... 16 Controlled Access Headings ........................................................................................................................ 17 Collection Inventory ..................................................................................................................................... 17 United States .............................................................................................................................................. 17 Alabama .................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Salt a World History 1St Edition Ebook
    SALT A WORLD HISTORY 1ST EDITION PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Mark Kurlansky | 9780142001615 | | | | | Salt A World History 1st edition PDF Book The red pepper, today a central ingredient of Sichuan cooking, did not arrive until the sixteenth century, carried to Europe by Columbus, to India by the Portuguese, and to China by either the Indians, Portuguese, Andalusians, or Basques. Cod and herring, two of the staple foods of Europe for much of its history, frequent cold northern seas. One wonders if his gimmick isn't getting a bit old. New England and parts of the Nordic countries were able to profit significantly through this method, which was sometimes paired with their cod stocks to create salted cod to sell on the world market, providing financial stability for the region. Retrieved 1 November This book is filled with many interesting bits of history, and was very enjoyable to read. According to a passage written in B. Shelves: non-fiction , food , favorites. I cannot tell you how many times I picked up and put down this book in stores across the nation It is worth mentioning that, while Kurlansky does make mention of many forms of salt through the narrative, the significant portion of the book relates to sodium chloride NaCl , common table salt. Great book, Salt: A World History pdf is enough to raise the goose bumps alone. For example, the unusual arrangement of roads visible on any detailed map of North America is largely the result of a desire for salt. Skip to main content. Something so simple now can have a wonderful and complex history.
    [Show full text]
  • Salty Sisters: the Women of Halophiles
    ORIGINAL RESEARCH ARTICLE published: 04 June 2014 doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2014.00192 Salty sisters: the women of halophiles Bonnie K. Baxter 1*, Nina Gunde-Cimerman 2,3 and Aharon Oren 4 1 Great Salt Lake Institute, Westminster College, Salt Lake City, UT, USA 2 Molecular Genetics and Microbiology, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia 3 Centre of Excellence for Integrated Approaches in Chemistry and Biology of Proteins, Ljubljana, Slovenia 4 Department of Plant and Environmental Sciences, The Institute of Life Sciences, The Edmond J. Safra Campus, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Givat Ram, Israel Edited by: A history of halophile research reveals the commitment of scientists to uncovering R. Thane Papke, University of the secrets of the limits of life, in particular life in high salt concentration and under Connecticut, USA extreme osmotic pressure. During the last 40 years, halophile scientists have indeed Reviewed by: made important contributions to extremophile research, and prior international halophiles Jocelyne DiRuggiero, The Johns Hopkins University, USA congresses have documented both the historical and the current work. During this period Meral Birbir, Marmara University, of salty discoveries, female scientists, in general, have grown in number worldwide. But Turkey those who worked in the field when there were small numbers of women sometimes *Correspondence: saw their important contributions overshadowed by their male counterparts. Recent Bonnie K. Baxter, Great Salt Lake studies suggest that modern female scientists experience gender bias in matters such Institute, Westminster College, 1840 S 1300 E, Salt Lake City, UT 84105, as conference invitations and even representation among full professors. In the field of USA halophilic microbiology, what is the impact of gender bias? How has the participation of e-mail: bbaxter@westminstercollege.
    [Show full text]