DOCSLIB.ORG

Ordinum Pietas (1613), Its Context and Seventeenth-Century Reception

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Ordinum Pietas (1613), Its Context and Seventeenth-Century Reception GROTIANA Grotiana 34 (2013) 7–10 brill.com/grot Introduction Dossier: Ordinum pietas (1613), its Context and Seventeenth-Century Reception Hans W. Bloma and Harm-Jan van Damb a) Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam / Universität Potsdam Email: [email protected] b) VU University Amsterdam Email: [email protected] On 13 and 14 June, 2013 the Peace Palace Library (The Hague) hosted a conference in celebration of the 400th anniversary of one of the most con- troversial publications of Hugo Grotius, written during the eventful years of the Twelve Years’ Truce. The story is well-known: in 1611, during the rising tensions of the religious conflict between Arminians and Gomarists over the control of the Reformed Church, the University of Leiden appointed – with the support of the States of Holland – a controversial theologian as successor of Jacobus Arminius: the Steinfurt professor Conrad Vorstius (1569-1622), erstwhile student in Heidelberg and Geneva, whose Steinfurt publications made him to be suspected of the heresy of Socinianism. The Dutch theologian Sibrandus Lubbertus (1555-1625) had started planning a critique of Socinianism some ten years before, and cor- responded with Gomarus and Junius about it. In 1603, David Pareus wrote Lubbertus from Heidelberg about the Socinian leanings of Vorstius in his Theses de trinitate, and about Socinianism in general, and so in 1611 Lubbertus vehemently opposed Vorstius’s appointment. The States of Holland didn’t want to give in, and our Hugo was the one to reply to Lubbertus: this was the tract Der Staten Godsdienstigheid etc. as Ordinum pietas was titled in the Dutch translation of Johannes Uyttenbogaert. The book proved to be oil on the fire, Lubbertus replied and the conflict ended with a defeat of the States of Holland, who had to see Vorstius leave Leiden even before taking office. © Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2013 DOI 10.1163/18760759-03400009 8 H.W. Blom and H.-J. van Dam / Grotiana 34 (2013) 7–10 For Grotius Ordinum pietas was the step towards his more theoretical De imperio circa sacra, on the relationship between church and state. The lat- ter, however, was only published posthumously, in 1647. In Ordinum pietas we find Grotius discussing the Fathers, i.a. Augustine, on predestination, and in general stating his views on the freedom to preach, emphasizing that the Christian church is a public church since its establishment under the Emperor Constantine in 313. Professor Silke-Petra Bergjan (Zurich University) traced this background in her contribution, and detailing the scholarship that was available to and used by Grotius, she argued that in Ordinum pietas we see how Grotius used his sources – with the help of his friend Vossius – to justify semi-Pelagianism (defence of free will), as well as the five fundamental articles of Arminianism. At the other end of the time line, Professor Bas de Gaay Fortman (Utrecht University) commemorated Ordinum Pietas in his keynote lecture ‘Between Principles and Practice. Grotius’s views on Church and State in a Con- temporary Context’, discussing the significance of Ordinum pietas for our present times. In his view, it belongs to the foundational texts for a tolerant and respectful integration of religions into modern society, in the tradition of the Edict of Nantes, the Act of Toleration and the American Constitution. The conference opened with a personal reflection by the editor of Ordinum pietas, professor Edwin Rabbie (Erasmus University), considering the occasion of this edition, as well as the changed technical conditions and editorial principles for early-modern text edition. As professor Rabbie related, in particular Hans Posthumus Meyjes’s discovery of the manuscript of Grotius’s Meletius and its subsequent edition in 1985, mark a renewed interest in Grotius as theologian and writer on church politics in the post- war period. In 1613, an important reason for the composition of Ordinum pietas was to justify the States of Holland to King James, an aim that was partially pre-empted by a secret action of the Regent of the States’ College at Leiden University, Petrus Bertius, who provided the English king with a copy even before it was printed. Later English reactions to Ordinum pietas were discussed at the conference in lectures by Dr. Hugh Dunthorne (Swansea University) and Dr. Charles Prior (University of Hull). The discussions between Arminianism and orthodox Calvinism in the 1610s were connected to the religious debate in German Protestantism, as the Vorstius case demonstrates. Franciscus Junius, one of Grotius’s teachers in Leiden, had been in Heidelberg where Thomas Erastus developed ideas on church-state relations later known as Erastianism, and another impor- tant person involved in the conflict, the Pensionary of the States, Johan van Oldenbarnevelt, had been a student in Heidelberg in about the same .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 4 Reformed Orthodoxy
    Autopistia : the self-convincing authority of scripture in reformed theology Belt, H. van der Citation Belt, H. van der. (2006, October 4). Autopistia : the self-convincing authority of scripture in reformed theology. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/4582 Version: Corrected Publisher’s Version Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the License: Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/4582 Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable). id7775687 pdfMachine by Broadgun Software - a great PDF writer! - a great PDF creator! - http://www.pdfmachine.com http://www.broadgun.com 4 Reformed Orthodoxy The period of Reformed orthodoxy extends from the Reformation to the time that liberal theology became predominant in the European churches and universities. During the period the Lutheran, Reformed, and Anglican churches were the official churches in Protestant countries and religious polemics between Catholicism and Protestantism formed an integral part of the intense political strife that gave birth to modern Europe. Reformed orthodoxy is usually divided into three periods that represent three different stages; there is no watershed between these periods and it is difficult to “ ” determine exact dates. During the period of early orthodoxy the confessional and doctrinal codifications of Reformed theology took place. This period is characterized by polemics against the Counter-Reformation; it starts with the death of the second- generation Reformers (around 1565) and ends in the first decades of the seventeenth century.1 The international Reformed Synod of Dort (1618-1619) is a useful milestone, 2 “ because this synod codified Reformed soteriology.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reformed Presbyterian Theological Journal
    FALL 2019 volume 6 issue 1 3 FROM RUTHERFORD HALL Dr. Barry J. York 4 FOUR CENTURIES AGO: AN HISTORICAL SURVEY OF THE SYNOD OF DORT Dr. David G. Whitla 16 THE FIRST HEADING: DIVINE ELECTION AND REPROBATION Rev. Thomas G. Reid, Jr. 25 THE SECOND HEADING - CHRIST’S DEATH AND HUMAN REDEMPTION THROUGH IT: LIMITED ATONEMENT AT THE SYNOD OF DORDT AND SOME CONTEMPORARY THEOLOGICAL DEBATES Dr. Richard C. Gamble 33 THE THIRD HEADING: HUMAN CORRUPTION Rev. Keith A. Evans 39 THE FOURTH HEADING: “BOTH DELIGHTFUL AND POWERFUL” THE DOCTRINE OF IRRESISTIBLE GRACE IN THE CANONS OF DORT Dr. C. J. Williams 47 THE FIFTH HEADING: THE PERSEVERANCE OF THE SAINTS Dr. Barry J. York STUDY UNDER PASTORS The theological journal of the Reformed Presbyterian Theological Seminary Description Reformed Presbyterian Theological Journal is the online theological journal of the Reformed Presbyterian Theological Seminary. Reformed Presbyterian Theological Journal is provided freely by RPTS faculty and other scholars to encourage the theological growth of the church in the historic, creedal, Reformed faith. Reformed Presbyterian Theological Journal is published biannually online at the RPTS website in html and pdf. Readers are free to use the journal and circulate articles in written, visual, or digital form, but we respectfully request that the content be unaltered and the source be acknowledged by the following statement. “Used by permission. Article first appeared in Reformed Presbyterian Theological Journal, the online theological journal of the Reformed Presbyterian Theological Seminary (rpts.edu).” e d i t o r s General Editor: Senior Editor: Assistant Editor: Contributing Editors: Barry York Richard Gamble Jay Dharan Tom Reid [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] C.
    [Show full text]
  • The Theology of Grace in the Thought of Jacobus Arminius and Philip Van Limborch: a Study in the Development of Seventeenth Century Dutch Arminianism
    The Theology of Grace in the Thought of Jacobus Arminius and Philip van Limborch: A Study in the Development of Seventeenth Century Dutch Arminianism By John Mark Hicks A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Westminster Theological Seminary In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy 1985 Faculty Advisor: Dr. Richard C. Gamble Second Faculty Reader: Mr. David W. Clowney Chairman, Field Committee: Dr. D. Claire Davis External Reader: Dr. Carl W. Bangs 2 Dissertation Abstract The Theology of Grace in the Thought of Jacobus Arminius and Philip van Limborch: A Study in the Development of Seventeenth Century Dutch Arminianism By John Mark Hicks The dissertation addresses the problem of the theological relationship between the theology of Jacobus Arminius (1560-1609) and the theology of Philip van Limborch (1633-1712). Arminius is taken as a representative of original Arminianism and Limborch is viewed as a representative of developed Remonstrantism. The problem of the dissertation is the nature of the relationship between Arminianism and Remonstrantism. Some argue that the two systems are the fundamentally the same, others argue that Arminianism logically entails Remonstrantism and others argue that they ought to be radically distinguished. The thesis of the dissertation is that the presuppositions of Arminianism and Remonstrantism are radically different. The thesis is limited to the doctrine of grace. There is no discussion of predestination. Rather, the thesis is based upon four categories of grace: (1) its need; (2) its nature; (3) its ground; and (4) its appropriation. The method of the dissertation is a careful, separate analysis of the two theologians.
    [Show full text]
  • Textual Notes on Lorenzo Valla's De Falso
    H U M A N I S T I C A L O V A N I E N S I A JOURNAL OF NEO-LATIN STUDIES Vol. LX - 2011 LEUVEN UNIVERSITY PRESS Reprint from Humanistica Lovaniensia LX, 2011 - ISBN 978 90 5867 884 3 - Leuven University Press 94693_Humanistica_2011_VWK.indd III 30/11/11 09:27 Gepubliceerd met de steun van de Universitaire Stichting van België © 2011 Universitaire Pers Leuven / Leuven University Press / Presses Uni versitaires de Louvain, Minderbroedersstraat 4 - B 3000 Leuven/Louvain, Belgium All rights reserved. Except in those cases expressly determined by law, no part of this publication may be multiplied, saved in an automated data file or made public in any way whatsoever without the express prior written consent of the publishers. ISBN 978 90 5867 884 3 D/2011/1869/39 ISSN 0774-2908 NUR: 635 Reprint from Humanistica Lovaniensia LX, 2011 - ISBN 978 90 5867 884 3 - Leuven University Press 94693_Humanistica_2011_VWK.indd IV 30/11/11 09:27 CONSPECTUS RERUM Fifth Annual Jozef IJsewijn Lecture –– Fidel RÄDLE, Mutianus Rufus (1470/1-1526) – ein Lebensentwurf gegen die Realität . 3-33 1. Textus et studia –– J. Cornelia LINDE, Lorenzo Valla and the Authenticity of Sacred Texts . 35-63 –– Paul WHITE, Foolish Pleasures: The Stultiferae naves of Jodocus Badius Ascensius and the poetry of Filippo Beroaldo the Elder . 65-83 –– Nathaël ISTASSE, Les Gingolphi de J. Ravisius Textor et la pseudohutténienne Conférence macaronique (ca. 1519) 85-97 –– Xavier TUBAU, El Consilium cuiusdam de Erasmo y el plan de un tribunal de arbitraje. 99-136 –– Sergio FERNÁNDEZ LÓPEZ, Arias Montano y Cipriano de la Huerga, dos humanistas en deuda con Alfonso de Zamora.
    [Show full text]
  • The Spanish Match and Jacobean Political Thought, 1618-1624
    Opposition in a pre-Republican Age? The Spanish Match and Jacobean Political Thought, 1618-1624 Kimberley Jayne Hackett Ph.D University of York History Department July 2009 Abstract Seventeenth-century English political thought was once viewed as insular and bound by a common law mentality. Significant work has been done to revise this picture and highlight the role played by continental religious resistance theory and what has been termed 'classical republicanism'. In addition to identifying these wider influences, recent work has focused upon the development of a public sphere that reveals a more socially diverse engagement with politics, authority and opposition than has hitherto been acknowledged. Yet for the period before the Civil War our understanding of the way that several intellectual influences were interacting to inform a politically alert 'public' is unclear, and expressions of political opposition are often tied to a pre-determined category of religious affiliation. As religious tension erupted into conflict on the continent, James I's pursuit ofa Spanish bride for Prince Charles and determination to follow a diplomatic solution to the war put his policy direction at odds with a dominant swathe of public opinion. During the last years of his reign, therefore, James experienced an unprecedented amount of opposition to his government of England. This opposition was articulated through a variety of media, and began to raise questions beyond the conduct of policy in addressing fundamental issues of political authority. By examining the deployment of political ideas during the domestic crisis of the early 1620s, this thesis seeks to uncover the varied ways in which differing discourses upon authority and obedience were being articulated against royal government.
    [Show full text]
  • April 2016 Issue of the Protestant Re- Formed Theological Journal
    Editor’s Notes You hold in your hand the April 2016 issue of the Protestant Re- formed Theological Journal. Included in this issue are three articles and a number of book reviews, some of them rather extensive. We are confident that you will find the contents of this issue worth the time you spend in reading—well worth the time. Few doctrines of the faith are more precious to the Reformed be- liever than the doctrine of God’s everlasting covenant of grace. Few books of the Bible are dearer to the saints than the book of Psalms. Prof. Dykstra puts those two together in the first of two articles on “God’s Covenant of Grace in the Psalms.” You will find his article both instructive and edifying. The Reverend Joshua Engelsma, pastor of the Protestant Reformed Church in Doon, Iowa contributes a very worthwhile article on Jo- hannes Bogerman. Bogerman was the man chosen to be president of the great Synod of Dordt, 1618-’19. The article not only traces the life and public ministry of Bogerman, but demonstrates clearly the direct influence that he had on the formulation of the articles in the First Head of doctrine in the Canons of Dordt. This is an especially appropriate article as the Reformed churches around the world prepare to celebrate the 400th anniversary of the Synod of Dordt in 2018-’19. The Protestant Reformed Seminary is planning to hold a conference to commemorate this very significant anniversary. We will keep our readers informed of the specifics of the conference as they are arranged.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Dimittimini, Exite'
    Seite 1 von 13 ‘Dimittimini, exite’ Debating Civil and Ecclesiastical Power in the Dutch Republic 1. Dordrecht, Monday 14 January 1619. ‘You are cast away, go! You have started with lies, you have ended with lies. Dimittimini, exite’. The end was bitter and dramatic. The chairman of the Synod of Dort, Johannes Bogerman, lost his patience. Roaring, as some reports put it, he ordered Simon Episcopius, who had just, in equally outspoken terms, accused Bogerman of committing acts of slavery, to leave. Episcopius and his fellow Arminians left. As usual the two great --indeed massive-- seventeenth century accounts of the Synod, those of Johannes Uytenbogaert on the Arminian and of Jacobus Trigland on the orthodox Calvinist side, differ strongly in their account and appreciation of what happened at the Synod of Dort1. But they agreed Dort marked a schism; Dutch Reformed Protestantism had split apart. In almost all 57 fateful sessions of the synod which had started on 13 November 1618 the debate had been bitter, though invariably participants asked for moderation, temperance and sobriety. The Synod vacillated between the bitterness of intense theological dispute and a longing for religious peace, between the relentless quest for truth and the thirst for toleration. For over ten years Dutch Reformed Protestants had been arguing, with increasing intensity and rancour. Divisions and issues were manifold with those, such as Simon 1 See Johannes Uytenbogaert, Kerckelicke Historie, Rotterdam, 1647, pp. 1135-1136 and Jacobus Trigland, Kerckelycke Geschiedenissen, begrypende de swaere en Bekommerlijcke Geschillen, in de Vereenigde Nederlanden voorgevallen met derselver Beslissinge, Leiden, 1650, p 1137.
    [Show full text]
  • The Nature of God & Predestination in John Davenant's Dissertatio De
    University of Missouri, St. Louis IRL @ UMSL Theses UMSL Graduate Works 7-20-2017 The aN ture of God & Predestination in John Davenant's Dissertatio De Praedestinatione et Reprobatione Jonathan Roberts [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://irl.umsl.edu/thesis Part of the History of Christianity Commons, History of Philosophy Commons, and the Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons Recommended Citation Roberts, Jonathan, "The aN ture of God & Predestination in John Davenant's Dissertatio De Praedestinatione et Reprobatione" (2017). Theses. 303. https://irl.umsl.edu/thesis/303 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the UMSL Graduate Works at IRL @ UMSL. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses by an authorized administrator of IRL @ UMSL. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Nature of God & Predestination in John Davenant's Dissertatio De Praedestinatione et Reprobatione By Jonathan Roberts B. A. Politics, Philosophy, & Economics, The King's College, 2013 A Thesis Submitted to The Graduate School at the University of Missouri-St. Louis in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Master of Arts in Philosophy August 2017 Advisory Committee Jon McGinnis, Ph.D. Chairperson Joshua Blander, Ph.D. David Griesedieck, Ph.D. Abstract: This paper is an exposition and defense of John Davenant's critique of the lapsarian understanding of the ordering of God's decrees. I evaluate Davenant's use of theology proper in his critique of said debate and contend that if Davenant is correct about divine simplicity and divine immutability, his critique of lapsarianism is successful.
    [Show full text]
  • Reconsidering Arminius
    Arminius: a grand divide in theology Reconsidering Arminius The theology of Dutch theologian Jacob Arminius has been misinterpreted and carica- tured in both Reformed and Wesleyan circles. But by revisiting Arminius’s theology, this book hopes to be a constructive voice in the discourse between so-called Calvinists and Arminians. Traditionally, Arminius has been treated as a divisive figure in evangelical theology. In- deed, one might be able to describe classic evangelical theology up into the twentieth century in relation to his work: one was either an Arminian and accepted his theology, or one was a Calvinist and rejected his theology. Although various other movements within evangelicalism have provided additional contour to the movement (fundamentalism, Pentecostalism, and so on), the Calvinist-Arminian “divide” remains a significant one. What this book seeks to correct is the misinterpretation of Arminius as one whose theol- Reconsidering ogy provides a stark contrast to the Reformed tradition as a whole. Indeed, this book will demonstrate instead that Arminius is far more in line with Reformed orthodoxy than popularly believed and will show that what emerges as Arminianism in the theology of Arminius the Remonstrants and Wesleyan movements was in fact not the theology of Arminius but a development of and sometimes departure from it. This book also brings Arminius into conversation with modern theology. To this end, it includes essays on the relationship between Arminius’s theology and open theism and Neo-Reformed theology. In this way, this book fulfills the promise of the title by showing ways in which Arminius’s theology— once properly understood—can serve as a resource for evangelical Wesleyans and Calvinists doing theology together today.
    [Show full text]
  • Joel R. Beeke 2917 Leonard, N.E., Grand Rapids, Michigan 49525 Office: 616-432-3403 • Home: 616-285-8102 E-Mail: [email protected] • Website
    Joel R. Beeke 2917 Leonard, N.E., Grand Rapids, Michigan 49525 Office: 616-432-3403 • Home: 616-285-8102 e-mail: [email protected] • website: www.heritagebooks.org EDUCATION: Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, Michigan (1971-73) Thomas A. Edison College (B.A. with specialization in religion) Netherlands Reformed Theological School, St. Catharines, Ontario (1974-78, equiv. to M. Div. & Licentiate in Ministry) Westminster Theological Seminary (1982-1988; Ph.D. in Reformation and Post-Reformation Theology) EXPERIENCE: 1978-1981: Pastor, Netherlands Reformed Congregation, Sioux Center, Iowa. As sole minister, in charge of the full scope of pastoral duties for the church membership of 687 (1978) to 729 (1981) persons. Additionally, appointed to serve as moderator for the following vacant churches: Neth. Reformed Congregation, Rock Valley, Iowa (membership: 900) Neth. Reformed Congregation, Corsica, South Dakota (membership: 150) Neth. Reformed Congregation, Sioux Falls, South Dakota (membership: 100) Instrumental in establishing and commencing the Netherlands Reformed Christian School, Rock Valley, Iowa, as board president (K-8, 225 students) Denominational appointments: Clerk of the Netherlands Reformed Synod, 1980-92. Clerk of Classes, 1978-79. President of Classes, 1979-81. Vice-president of the Neth. Reformed General Mission, 1980-82. President of Neth. Reformed Book and Publishing Committee, 1980-93. Denominational Appointee to Government for Netherlands Reformed Congregations, 1980-86. Office-bearer Conference Speaker and Committee Member (clerk), 1980-93. 1981-1986: Pastor, Ebenezer Netherlands Reformed Church, Franklin Lakes, New Jersey As sole minister, in charge of the full scope of pastoral duties for the church membership of 689 (1981) to 840 (1986) persons. Additionally, appointed to serve as moderator for the following vacant churches: Neth.
    [Show full text]
  • The Religious History of the Early Dutch Republic
    REMONSTRANTS, CONTRA-REMONSTRANTS AND THE SYNOD OF DORT (1618-1619): THE RELIGIOUS HISTORY OF THE EARLY DUTCH REPUBLIC William van Doodewaard, Huntington University The United Provinces in the Early 17th Century The political events of the Union of Utrecht (1579) and the Act of Abjuration (1581) in part laid the foundations for the seventeenth-century “Golden Age” of the Netherlands. This “Golden Age” of republican independence and Protestant liberty in the northern United Provinces was one of cultural development and national progression. The early Golden Age would be the era of the formation of the prosperous Dutch East and West Indies Companies, with exploration, trade and colonization attempts ranging from the New Netherlands and Suriname to the East Indies and Formosa. Great artists, including Rembrandt van Rijn, Johannes Vermeer, and others, would begin their careers. During this period the increasingly metropolitan and well-connected Republic of the United Provinces, despite its comparatively small size and population, exerted substantial influence globally. While primary conflict with a declining Roman Catholic Spain continued, the influence of the Protestant United Provinces is also attested in episodic tensions with her nearest ally, the ascendant English. English state papers and Privy Council documents evidence this throughout the 1600s, particularly in relation to tensions over trade and colonization in the Americas. King James I of England’s ambassador to The Hague, Sir Dudley Carleton, brought complaints on several occasions before the States-General during the early part of the century, regarding what the English viewed as Dutch incursion into their rightful territory.1 141 Religious History of the Early Dutch Republic In the midst of this era of prosperity and growth the United Provinces were gripped by the Remonstrant controversy – a politically charged theological division and debate over the nature of God, the nature of man, his relationship to, and condition before God, and the nature of salvation, as revealed in the Scriptures.
    [Show full text]
  • Causality and Morality in Politics
    Causality and Morality in Politics The Rise of Naturalism in Dutch Seventeenth-Century Political Thought HansW.Blom Causality and morality in politics Causality and morality in politics The rise of naturalism in Dutch seventeenth-century political thought Hans Willem Blom Rotterdam 1995 cip-gegevens koninklijke bibliotheek, den haag Blom, Hans Willem Causality and morality in politics : the rise of naturalism in Dutch seventeenth-century political thought / Hans Willem Blom. -[S.l. : s.n.] Proefschrift Universiteit Utrecht. -Met index, lit. opg. - Met samenvatting in het Nederlands. isbn 90-9007917-3 Trefw.: naturalisme in de politiek / politieke filosofie / Nederland ; politieke geschiedenis ; 17e eeuw. Typeset in Trinité (roman wide 2), typeface designed by Bram de Does. Printed by Offsetdrukkerij Ridderprint bv, Ridderkerk. Cover illustration: Atlas supporting the heavens, cast plaster model, presumably by Artus Quellien. ‘Burgerzaal’ of the Royal Palace (built 1648 till late 1660’s as town hall), Amsterdam. parentibus uxorique Reproduction by courtesy of the Stichting Koninklijk Paleis te Amsterdam Contents Preface 7 chapter i Morality and causality in politics 9 A naturalist conception of politics /10/ Passions and politics /13/ Naturalism /16/ Is–ought: some caveats /19/ History of political philosophy: distance and similarity /21/ The historical theses /25/ The core of the argument /29/ chapter ii Dutch political thought and institutions 33 Causes and intentions explaining Dutch political thought /34/ Between political strength
    [Show full text]