04032020Za1dyf5aseacminut

Minutes of the 580 th meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee held on 07/01/2020 at GPCB, Sector 10A, Gandhinagar. The 580 th meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) was held on07 th January 2020 at GPCB, Sector 10A, Gandhinagar. Following members attended the meeting: 1. Dr. Dinesh Misra, Chairman, SEAC 2. Shri Satish Srivastav, Vice Chairman, SEAC

3. Shri V. N. Patel, Member, SEAC 4. Shri R.J.Shah, Member, SEAC 5. Shri A.K.Muley, Member, SEAC Following proposals were considered during meeting.

1. LIMESTONE MINING PROJECT,DIST: JUNAGADH (VIOLATION APPRAISAL )

TOR File Name S Villag Ta Dist Lease ROM Nearest Minera SEAC NO NO e area in human l TOR Ha habitati Meetin on g

SIA/GJ/MIN/ Damasa 110/ Dama Una Junagadh 2.00 57500 Una:7.7 LIMES 29/08/ Lime P sa Ha MTPA 0 km TONE 2018 44972/2019 Stone Mining

Project, TOR (c/o Shree SIA/GJ/MIN/ Vikram 26379/2018 Chemical Co.

Project proponent attended the meeting and informed that they could not submit the hard copies of final EIA and Approved Mine plan. Committee noted that hard copies of final EIA and approved mine plan along with other documents are not submitted by the PP. Hence, after deliberation, it is decided to defer the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

2. LIMESTONE MINING PROJECT,DIST: JUNAGADH (VIOLATION APPRAISAL )

TOR File Name S Villag Ta Dist Lease ROM Nearest Minera SEAC NO NO e area in human l TOR Ha habitati Meetin on g

SIA/GJ/MIN/ Shri 389 Ajotha Ver Junagad 2.00 Ha 46,300 Ajotha:1 Limest 29/08/ ArjabhaiKhi aval h MTPA .58 km one 2018 44550/2019 mabhai Rathod,(Li

me stone (TOR mine lease Proposal Area: 2.00 NO: SIA /GJ Ha / MIN /23285 /2018).

3. BENTONITE MINERALS MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Application No Nam S.N Village Talu Dist Leas RO Neares End Use Investm Date of e of o. ka e M t ent in Applicat Proje Area Human Rs ion ct Habitat Receive ion d by SEAC

SIA/GJ/MIN/3443 Vinay 219 Nana Man Kut 2.06. 601 Nana For 4.01 Cr. 25/11/2 2/2019 ak pai Asamb dvi ch 00 34 Asamb construc 019 Miner ki iya ha MT iya – tion als PA 0.55 purpose Km

nearby villages. There will be no industrial effluent discharge from proposed project. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include use of water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Cluster of 2 leases is formed having total cluster area of 05.06.00Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist.

After scoping for the aforementioned proposal, committee decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation & Hon’ble National Green Tribunal Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non sand mining without blasting for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA.

1. PP shall ensure participation of people during public hearing with equality in genders so as to encourage women participation in public hearing and at the same time the issues of women shall also be given weightage. 2. Carry out need based survey for CER and give details of budgetary provision for five years for effective utilization of the same. 3. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities similar to the measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

The draft EIA report also covering the above TOR shall be prepared and submitted to the GPCB for conducting the public hearing / consultation process as per the provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006. The project shall be appraised after submission of the final EIA report.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

4. BENTONITE MINERALS MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Application No Name S.N Villa Talu Dist Leas RO Neares End Use Investm Date of of o. ge ka e M t ent in Applicat Project Area Human Rs ion Habitat Receive ion d by SEAC

SIA/GJ/MIN/3939 KALYA 183 Ham Man Kut 4.00. 999 Hamla- For 13.72 25/11/2 4/2019 NJI la dvi ch 00 98 0.740 construc Cr. 019 SHAMJI ha MT Km tion PATARI PA purpose YA

Project proponent along with consultant represented above proposal before the committee. The mining will be done by Mechanized Opencast method. There will be no blasting. There will be no intersection of ground water due to working.Total water requirement is about 4.2 KLD = 1.0 KLD (Drinking & Domestic Uses) + 1.4 KLD (Plantation) KLD + 1.8 KLD (Dust Suppression). There will be no industrial effluent generation. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include use of water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Cluster of 57 leases is formed having total cluster area of 111.14.79 Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

3. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities similar to the measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

5. RIVER BED ORDINARY SAND MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Application Name of S. Villa Tal Dis Rive Lea RO Near End Invest Date No Project No ge uka t r se M est Use ment of . Are Hum in Rs Applic a an ation Habit Recei ation ved by SEAC

SIA/GJ/MIN/3 VelabhaiRana 63 Kun Bh Ku Kun 1.00 78 Kuna For 60.73 25/11/ 8281/2019 bhaiDangar 6 ariya uj tch ariya .00 09 riya- constr lacs 2019 Pai ha 0 1.32 uction ky MT Km purpos PA e

The project proponent along with consultant remained present.The mining will be done by Opencast Semi Mechanized method.No waste or overburden will be generated from the mine site. Mining will be done on the dry part of the river bed.The daily water demand will be only 10.0 KLD. Water for Drinking, dust suppression and plantation will be collected from nearby villages.There will be no industrial effluent discharge from prosed project. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. There will be dust emission from the handling of mineral and excavation process. Water sprinkling will be done to suppress the fugitive dust emission. The transport and handling of mineral likely to emit fugitive dust which will be controlled by- regular water sprinkling on the site, dispatch trucks carrying ore will be covered with tarpaulin.There are no bridge piers / water intake wells / irrigation structures within 500 m distance from boundary of above lease area.Minimum set back distance to be maintained is 10 meter to prevent bank erosion.Depth of the working will be maintained as 3 meter or water whichever is earlier. District geologist has validated that block is falling in cluster and it is not an in-stream mining and located in dry river bed. Cluster of 3 leases is formed having total cluster area of 09.46 Ha.

After scoping for the aforementioned proposal, committee decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation & Hon’ble National Green Tribunal

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non sand mining without blasting for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA.

1. To ensure participation of people during public hearing with equality in genders so as to encourage women participation in public hearing and at the same time the issues of women shall also be given weightage. 2. To Carry out need based survey for CER and give details of budgetary provision for five years for effective utilization of the same. 3. To incorporate study of rate of replenishment in approved mine planand proposed rate of mining shall be in accordance to rate of replenishment rate. 4. To carry out dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities similar to the measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

6. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Applicati Name of S.No Village Taluka Dist Lease RO Near End Use Invest Date of on No Project . Area M est ment Applicati Hum in Rs on an Receive Habi d by tatio SEAC n

SIA/GJ/ Parag Liya 327 Laxmi Nakhtra Kutch 2.30.00 1090 Lax For 90.08 25/11/20 MIN/386 paiki par na, ha 84 mipa construc lacs 19 38/2019 r- tion TPA 1.96 purpose km

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

ground level hence working will not intersect ground water table. Adequate control measures to prevent soil erosion and washing off of the stacked material are proposed that include making of garland drain and maintaining height of the stackedmaterial. The daily water demand is only 5.0 KLD. The domestic water demand is met from the village Laxmipar.Water will be used for sprinkling, green belt development and domestic purpose. Sewage will be disposed off to soak pit. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. There will be no generation of industrial wastewater. Diesel will be used as fuel. Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Clusteris formed having total cluster area of 43.74.90 Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist.

After scoping for the aforementioned proposal, committee decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation & Hon’ble National Green Tribunal Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non sand mining with blasting for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

7. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Applic Name of S.No. Village Taluka Dist Lease ROM Neare End Invest Date of ation Project Area st Use ment Applicati No Huma in Rs on n Receive Habita d by tion SEAC

SIA/G Parag P Liya 327 Laxmipa Nakhtrana Kutc 1.00.0 99958 Laxmi For 70.98 25/11/2 J/MIN/ paiki r , h 0 ha par- construc Lacs 019 38659/ TPA 1.97 tion 2019 km purpose

The project proponent along with their consultant remained present. They informed that method of mining will be semi mechanized open cast mining. Over burden during mining is proposed to be stacked temporarily at the site. Height and width of the benches will be 6 meter and more than 6 meter respectively with slope of 45 degree. Controlled blasting with carried out with compliance of all the conditions of safety prescribed by the DGMS. Maximum working depth is 45 meter and depth of water table is 80 meter below ground level hence working will not intersect ground water table. Adequate control measures to prevent soil erosion and washing off of the stacked material are proposed that include making of garland drain and maintaining height of the The daily water demand is only 5.0 KLD. The domestic water demand is met from the village Laxmipar. Water will be used for sprinkling, green belt development and domestic purpose. Sewage will be disposed off to soak pit. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. There will be no generation of industrial wastewater. Diesel will be used as fuel.Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Cluster is formed having total cluster area of 43.74.90 Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist.

After scoping for the aforementioned proposal, committee decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation & Hon’ble National Green Tribunal Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non sand mining with blasting for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA.

8. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Applicati Name S.No. Village Taluka Dist Leas RO Neare End Investm Date of on No of e M st Use ent in Rs Applicatio Project Area Huma n n Received Habita by SEAC tion

SIA/GJ/ PirTah 327 paiki Laxmi Nakhtra Kutch 3.22. 1000 Laxmi For 60 lacs 25/11/201 MIN/386 eraban par na, 00 07 par- constr 9 58/2019 uAbdul ha 2.12 uction shah TPA km purpos e

Project proponent remained absent during meeting. Hence, after deliberation, it is decided to defer the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting.

9. LIMESTONE MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Applica Name S.No. Village Taluka Dist Riv Lea RO Neares End Invest Date of tion No of er se M t Use ment Applicati Projec Are Human in Rs on t a Habitati Receive on d by SEAC

SIA/GJ/ SAMA 386 Ratadiy Bhuj Kutch Ors 4.21 109 Ratadiy Cement 2.65 10/10/20 MIN/39 ALAN a ang .00 040 a- Industr Cr 19 413/201 A ha MT 0.853 y 9 IBRAH PA km IM

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

The project proponent along with their consultant remained present. They informed that method of mining will be semi mechanized open cast mining. Over burden during mining is proposed to be stacked temporarily at the site. Height and width of the benches will be 2-6 meter and more than 6 meter respectively. Maximum working depth is 13 meter and depth of water table is 50-55 meter below ground level hence working will not intersect ground water table. There will be no blasting involved. Adequate control measures to prevent soil erosion and washing off of the stacked material are proposed that include making of garland drain and maintaining height of the stacked material. Total water requirement is about 4.3 KLD =1.0 KLD (Drinking & Domestic Uses) + 1.6KLD (Plantation) + 1.7 KLD (Dust Suppression). Water will be used for sprinkling, green belt development and domestic purpose. Sewage will be disposed off to soak pit. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. There will be no generation of industrial wastewater. Diesel will be used as fuel. Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

10. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : VADODARA

Applicati Name S.No. Village Taluka Dist Leas RO Neare End Investm Date of on No of e M st Use ent in Rs Applicatio Project Area Huma n n Received Habita by SEAC tion

SIA/GJ/ ShivSh 218/56 Jambu Savli Vadodar 1.00. 6554 Jambu For 2.65 cr. 25/11/201 MIN/392 akti private goral a 00 2 goral- constr 9 35/2019 Quarry land ha MTP 1.15 uction Works A km purpos e

The project proponent along with their consultant remained present. They informed that method of mining will be semi mechanized open cast mining. Over burden during mining is proposed to be stacked temporarily at the site. Height and width of the benches will be 6 meter and more than 6 meter respectively. Controlled blasting with carried out with compliance of all the conditions of safety prescribed by the DGMS. Maximum working depth is 35 meter and depth of water table is 50-55 meter below ground level hence working will not intersect ground water table. Adequate control measures to prevent soil erosion and washing off of the stacked material are proposed that include making of garland drain and maintaining height of the stacked material. Water requirement of the proposal is 3 KLPD to be sourced from the nearby Tankers. Water will be used for sprinkling, green belt development and domestic purpose. Sewage will be disposed off to soak pit. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. There will be no generation of industrial wastewater. Diesel will be used as fuel.Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Cluster of 586 leases is formed having total cluster area of 117.25.22 Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

After scoping for the aforementioned proposal, committee decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation & Hon’ble National Green Tribunal Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non sand mining with blasting for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA.

11. RIVER BED ORDINARY SAND MINING, DIST : BHARUCH

Applica Name S.No. Village Taluka Dist Riv Lea RO Neares End Invest Date of tion No of er se M t Use ment Applicati Projec Are Human in Rs on t a Habitati Receive on d by SEAC

SIA/GJ/ Minaxi 124, 125 Shukalt Bharuc Bharu Nar 1.00 269 Shukalt For 3.18 25/11/20 MIN/45 benGa ni same irth h ch ma .00 97 irth - constru Cr. 19 792/201 npatbh Naramad da ha MT 0.703 ction 9 ai River Bed PA km purpos Patel e

Project proponent remained absent during meeting. Hence, after deliberation, it is decided to defer the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

12. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Application No Name S.No. Villa Talu Dist Lease ROM Neare End Invest Date of of ge ka Area st Use ment in Applica Projec Huma Rs tion t n Receiv Habita ed by tion SEAC

Pares Sr.no. Anja Anja Kut 3.00.0 2000 Anjar For 90 25/11/2 SIA/GJ/MIN/420 h 975 r r ch 0 ha 11 – 1.21 construc Lacs 019 33/2019 Chhot paiki MTP km tion alal (Existi A purpose Thakk ng) ar

Water requirement of the proposal is 8.5 KLPD to be sourced from the nearby Tankers. Water will be used for sprinkling, green belt development and domestic purpose. Sewage will be disposed off to soak pit. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. There will be no generation of industrial wastewater. Diesel will be used as fuel. Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Cluster of 48 is formed having total cluster area of 107.51.86 Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

Referring to location of proposed lease, committee unanimously decided to ask PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP.

1. Shortest aerial distance between nearest human habitation and proposed lease to be verified by concerned District geologist by visiting the site.

13. ORDINARY SAND & GRAVEL MINING, DIST : NARMADA

Application Name of Project S.N Vill Tal Dist Rive Lea R Near End Inves Date No o. ag uka r se O est Use tment of e Are M Huma in Rs Appli a n catio Habit n ation Recei ved by SEA C

SIA/GJ/MIN/ AmishabenBhadr 43 Ru Nan Nar Nar 4.0 66 Juna For 102.6 25/11 46509/2019 eshbhaiVasava ne nd dod mad mad 0.0 24 Rund constr 2 /2019 lagu h a a 0 0 h - uction Lakh Nar ha MT 0.91 purpo mad PA Km se a Rive rbed paiki

The project proponent along with consultant remained present.The mining will be done by Opencast Semi Mechanized method.No waste or overburden will be generated from the mine site. Water will be used for Drinking, dust suppression and plantation will be collected from nearby villages.There will be dust emission from the handling of mineraland excavation process. Water sprinkling will be done to suppress the fugitive dust emission.The transport and handling of mineral likely to emit fugitive dust which will be controlled by- regular water sprinkling on the site, dispatch trucks carrying ore will be covered with tarpaulin.There are no bridge piers / water intake wells / irrigation structures within 500 m distance from boundary of above lease area.Minimum set back distance to be maintained is 10 meter to prevent bank erosion.Depth of the working will be maintained as 3 meter or water whichever is earlier. Cluster of 22 leases is formed having total cluster area of 76.85 Ha.

Referring to location of proposed lease, committee unanimously decided to ask PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

1. To submit details of proposed lease area whether located in dry river or it is located in stream to be verified by concerned District geologist by visiting the site.

14. ORDINARY SAND MINING, DIST : NARMADA

Application Name of S.No Vill Talu Dist River Lea RO Neare End Invest Date No Project . age ka se M st Use ment of Are Huma in Rs Applic a n ation Habita Recei tion ved by SEAC

SIA/GJ/MIN/4 SHRI 43 Ru Nan Nar Nar 4.00 64 JunaR For 57 25/11/ 6534/2019 BHADRE ne ndh dod mad mad .00 32 undh - constr Lacs 2019 SHBHAI lagu a a ha 0 0.91 uction BHOGILA Nar MT Km purpos L mad PA e VASAVA a River bed paiki

The project proponent along with consultant remained present. The mining will be done by Opencast Semi Mechanized method. No waste or overburden will be generated from the mine site. Water will be used for Drinking, dust suppression and plantation will be collected from nearby villages. There will be dust emission from the handling of mineral and excavation process. Water sprinkling will be done to suppress the fugitive dust emission. The transport and handling of mineral likely to emit fugitive dust which will be controlled by- regular water sprinkling on the site, dispatch trucks carrying ore will be covered with tarpaulin.There are no bridge piers / water intake wells / irrigation structures within 500 m distance from boundary of above lease area. Minimum set back distance to be maintained is 10 meter to prevent bank erosion. Depth of the working will be maintained as 3 meter or water whichever is earlier. Cluster of 22 leases is formed having total cluster area of 76.85 Ha.

Referring to location of proposed lease, committee unanimously decided to ask PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP.

1. To submit details of proposed lease area whether located in dry river or it is located in stream to be verified by concerned District geologist by visiting the site.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

15. BAUXITE MINING, DIST : KHEDA

Applon No Nam S.N Villa Taluka Dist Leas ROM Neare End Invest Date of e of o. ge e st Use ment Applic Proj Area Huma in Rs ation ect n Receiv Habita ed by tion SEAC

SIA/GJ/MIN/37 Sorn 551 Sor Kapad Khe 26.2 4,62, Sorna Alumi 1 cr 04/12/ 568/2019 a (p) na vanj da 196 968 - num 2019 Bau ha 0.850 extrac xite TPA km tion Mini ng Proj ect, Surv ey No. 551( P)

Project proponent attended the meeting and informed that they could not submit the presentation within prescribed time limit mentioned in schedule. After deliberation, it is decided to defer the proposal to 09/01/2020.

16. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Application No Name of S. Villa Tal Dis Lea RO Neare End Invest Date Project No. ge uka t se M st Use ment of Area Huma in Rs Applic n ation Habit Receiv ation ed by SEAC

SIA/GJ/MIN/34 Dhanes 34 Nilp Rap Kut 5.49 200 Nilpar For 14 Cr. 03/12/ 019/2019 h 7 ar ar ch .52 000 -0.715 constru 2019 Hasmuk pai ha MTP Km ction hbhai ky A purpos Parmar e

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

The project proponent along with their consultant remained present. They informed that method of mining will be semi mechanized open cast mining.Over burden during mining is proposed to be stacked temporarily at the site. Height and width of the benches will be 3 to 6 meter and more than 3 to 6 meter respectively with slope of 45 degree. Controlled blasting with carried out with compliance of all the conditions of safety prescribed by the DGMS.Maximum working depth is 26 meter and depth of water table is 50-55 meter below ground level hence working will not intersect ground water table.Adequate control measures to prevent soil erosion and washing off of the stacked material are proposed that include making of garland drain and maintaining height of the stacked material.Total water requirement is about 5.2 KLD =1.0 KLD (Drinking & Domestic Uses) + 2.20KLD (Plantation) + 1.5 KLD (Dust Suppression). Sewage will be disposed off to soak pit. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. There will be no generation of industrial wastewater. Diesel will be used as fuel. Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Cluster of 2 leases is formed having total cluster area of 5.95 Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist.

After scoping for the aforementioned proposal, committee decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation & Hon’ble National Green Tribunal Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non sand mining with blasting for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

ADDITONAL AGENDA

Following proposals were considered after receipt of reply for the additional details sought during various SEAC meeting and details are as below:

1. ORDINARY SAND MINING PROJECT, DIST.: ANAND

Online Name of S.No. Village Talu Dist Lea RO Riv Neare End Invest Proposa Project ka se M er st Use ment l No. Are Huma a n Habita tion

SIA/GJ/ M/S. 402,3 Sundal Umr Ana 3.0 490 Ma 1.01 Constru 100 MIN/ Jadeja 96, pura eth nd 0 20 hi km ction Lacs 41757/2 Constru Ne HA MT 019 ction lagu PA C/O Mahi Hardipsi River nh B. Bed Jadeja

Proposal was considered during SEAC meeting on 15/11/2019 and after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

(1) Validation of the district geologist specifically mentioning about the proposed river bed sand mining is not an in-stream mining and lease area is located in dry river bed on the merits of fact with google image mentioning all pillars of the proposed lease area.

On 20/12/2019, PP submitted reply with revised project details mentioning about the proposed river bed sand mining is not an in-stream mining and lease area is located in dry river bed validated by the district geologist.

After scoping, referring to the pillars mentioned in approved mining plan, committee decided to ask District geologist to visit the location and verify the proposed lease whether falls in dry river bed and is not an instream mining and upon receipt of the visit

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

report, it is decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting. It is further decided not to reopen the delisted proposal.

2. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : DEVBHUMIDWARKA

Name S. Vill Taluka Dist Leas ROM Neare End Investm Date of age e st Use ent in Application of Project No. Area Huma Rs Received by n SEAC Habita tion

Shiv- River Nav Bhanv Devbh 1.00 31,87 Navag Const 50 lakh 25/10/2019 Shakti bed aga ad umidw Ha 5 am: ructio Stone Paiki m arka MTPA 560 n Crusher meter

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019,after deliberation, committee unanimously decided to ask PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP.

1. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 2. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 3. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP.

PP submitted reply on 21/12/2019. PP submitted revised project cost, need based CER and baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise. Referring to the baseline details for surface water, it is noted that proposed black trap lease area is located in the river bed. Further, PP has addressed environmental impact identification and assessment covering cause effect relationship. Referring to the details, it is found devoid of environmental impact study covering physical characteristics like river stability, flood risk, environmental degradation, loss of habitat, decline in bio diversity, change/alteration in river morphology and other associated environmental aspects due to mining through institute of national repute with reference to the order of Order of Honorable National Green Tribunal dated 13/09/2018. Hence, It is decided not to reopen the delisted proposal considering the reply not satisfactory.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

3. QUARTZITE MINING PROJECT, DIST : PANCHMAHAL

Name of S.N Villa Taluka Dist Lease ROM Neare End Investm Date of Project o. ge Area st Use ent in Applicat Huma Rs ion n Receive Habita d by tion SEAC

Mumtaz 24/ Zan Halol Panch 1.00 27,64 Zankh Const 26lakh 25/10/2 Mehbubbh 2 khari mahal Ha 1 ariya: ructio 019 ai Shaikh pai ya MTP 600 n ki A meter

1. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 2. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 3. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP.

PP submitted reply on 21/12/2019 as below: 1. PP submitted the cost of the project as 26 Lacs. 2. PP submitted need based CER of 0.52 Lacs. 3. PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Noise which are within the norms.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

1. A brick/stone parapet wall of 3.5 feet surrounding to the excavated mine pit shall be constructed to prevent casualty. 2. There shall not be use of blasting for working of mine. 3. Transportation route for vehicles carrying mineral shall have lease minimum pass near human habitation. 4. PP shall spend amount of CER after identifying activities in consultation with village gram panchayat. 5. Validity of the EC shall be coterminous with validity of lease. 6. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities shall be implemented in letter and spirit similar to the applicable measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

4. BUILDING LIMESTONE MINING, DIST : DEVBHUMI DWARKA

Name of S. Vill Taluka Dist Lease RO Neares End Investm Date of Project No. age Area M t Use ent in Application Human Rs Received by Habitat SEAC ion

Gorinja 15 Gor Okham Devbh 1.721 43,9 Gorinja Constr 344 19/10/2019 Building 9 inja andal umi 6 Ha 02 : 520 uction lacs Limestone pai Dwark MTP meter ki, a A Shri Blo Sharadbhai ck Mansukhbh 1 ai Modi

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019,after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

(1) Revised Project cost with details of each component. (2) Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. (3) Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP.

PP submitted reply on 21/12/2019 as below: 1. PP submitted the cost of the project as 344 Lacs. 2. PP submitted need based CER of 6.88 Lacs. 3. PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Noise which are within the norms.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

5. ORDINARY SAND MINING PROJECT, DIST.: ANAND

Name S No Village Ta Dist Leas ROM Riv Nearest End Use Investme of e er Human nt in Rs. Project Area Habitati in on Ha Keshav Surv Gambhi Ankl Anan 02- 1,00,00 Mah Gambhir Constructi 85 Lacs Enterpri ey ra av d 75- 00 i a – 1.40 on se No. 80 MTPA km 1020 Ha

During SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019,after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

1. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. 2. Revised need based CER details with budgetary provision.

PP submitted reply on 21/12/2019 as below:

1. PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Noise which are within the norms. 2. PP submitted need based CER of Rs.1.70 Lakh.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

Considering reply, committee noted that rate of mining proposed by PP is 1,00,000 MTPA however study report pertaining to replenishment rate justifying proposed rate of mining is not addressed. Hence, Committee decided to ask PP to justify the aforementioned details and upon submission of the said details, it is decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting.

6. LIME STONE MINING, DIST : GIR SOMNATH

Application Name S. Villa Talu Dist Lea RO Neare End Use Invest Date of No ge ka se M st ment in of No Project . Are Huma Rs Applic a n ation Habit Recei ation ved by SEAC

Kodidr 81/ Kodi Ver Girs 4.70 280 Kodid Soda 17 25/11/ SIA/GJ/MIN a Lime P dra aval omn .00 00 ra – 2 ash Lacs 2019 / Stone ath ha MT km manufac mine PA turing 4861/2015

During SEAC meeting on 18/12/2019, Proposal was considered and after deliberation, committee unanimously decided to ask PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting after submission of the said details: 1. Details of action initiated by GPCB under section 15 and 19 of the EPACT 1986. 2. Letter from the district geologist mentioning production details along with details of working stopped at mine. PP submitted reply on 26/12/2019 and 06/01/2020.giving details of action initiated by GPCB under section 15 and 19 of the EPACT 1986 and letter of district geologist mentioning last production taken. Considering above, committee unanimously decided to recommend for TOR amendment as per Annexure II for the aforementioned proposal as the Proposal was submitted to SEAC before 13/04/2018.

7. BLACKTRAP MINING, DIST : PANCHMAHAL

Applicat Name of S.No. Village Taluka Dist Lease ROM Nearest End Investm Date of ion No Project Area Human Use ent in Applicatio Habitati Rs n on Received

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

by SEAC

SIA/GJ/ Shri 199 Gopipu Halol Panc 0.50. 2309 Gopipu Constru 35 lacs 17/10/201 MIN/44 Kamleshbh paiki ra hmah 00 ha 9 ra- 0.57 ction 9 539/201 ai al MTP km 9 Gordhanbh A ai Patel

During SEAC meeting on 27/11/2019, After deliberation, committee unanimously decided to ask the following details from the PP. 1. To submit the cluster map mentioning the aforementioned lease area. 2. To submit the revised project details mentioning the nearest human habitation from the lease area validated by the district geologist. PP submitted reply on 27/12/2019. PP submitted cluster map mentioning the aforementioned lease area and project details mentioning the nearest human habitation from the lease area validated by the district geologist. After scoping, it was decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation& Hon’ble National Green Tribunal Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non Sand mining for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA. 1. PP shall ensure participation of people during public hearing with equality in genders so as to encourage women participation in public hearing and at the same time the issues of women shall also be given weightage.

2. Carry out need based survey for CER and give details of budgetary provision for five years for effective utilization of the same. The draft EIA report also covering the above TOR shall be prepared and submitted to the GPCB for conducting the public hearing / consultation process as per the provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006. The project shall be appraised after submission of the final EIA report. 8. ORDINARY CLAY MINING PROJECT,DIST.: BHARUCH

Name of S No Village Ta Dist Lease ROM Nearest End Use Investment Project Area Human in Rs. in Ha Habitation

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

Narmada 171/3, Pungam Ankleshwar Bharuch 03- 11,700 Pungam- Bricks 15 Lacs Bricks 177/1/2, 72-30 MTPA 0.85 km Manufacturing Work 177/5, Ha 182/6

During SEAC meeting on 06/11/2019, after deliberation, committee sought following additional details from the PP and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting:

1. Copy of EC application submitted to DEIAA. 2. Letter from the district geologist showing shortest aerial distance of lease from the GIDC, Ankleshwar. 3. Copies of Form 1, PFR and project details validated by all the concerned. 4. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 5. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view.

PP submitted reply on 27/12/2019 as below: 1. Application for EC to DEIAA on 13/02/2019 vide application No: DIA/GJ/MIN/19843/2019. 2. Letter from the district geologist mentioning shortest aerial distance of lease from the GIDC, Ankleshwar is 7.62 km 3. Copies of Form 1, PFR and project details validated by all the concerned. 4. Revised project cost which comes out as Rs. 72 Lakh . 5. Need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. Considering reply satisfactory with anticipated impacts of mining and mitigation measures proposed by the lease holder, proposed CER, committee unanimously decided to recommend the above proposal for grant of environmental clearance to SEIAA, subject to the strict implementation of the conditions approved by SEAC on 09/08/2017 and by SEIAA on 16/09/2017 along with additional and project specific conditions as per Annexure I.

9. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : JAMNAGAR

Name of S.N Villa Taluka Dist Lease ROM Nea End Investm Date of Project o. ge Area rest Use ent in Applicat Hu Rs ion man Receive Habi d by tatio SEAC n

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

KeshiyaBla 535 Kes Jodiya Jamn 1.00 ha 1499 Kes Constru 1.46 19/10/2 cktrap /1/2 hiya agar 5 hiya ction 019 Quarry /1 MTP :8.3 Cr. Lease Area Pai A 7 ki Km

Proposal was considered during SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019. After deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

1. PP submitted the cost of the project as 1.46 Cr. 2. PP submitted need based CER of Rs 2.93 Lakh. 3. PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Noise which are within the norms. 4. PP submitted revised EMP with capital cost of Rs. 56000/- and recurring cost of 24000/-

During meeting on 07/01/2020,Considering reply satisfactory and anticipated impacts of mining on environment and its mitigation measures, proposed CER, committee unanimously decided to recommend the above proposal for grant of environmental clearance to SEIAA, subject to the strict implementation of conditions mentioned for Non-Sand mining project with blasting approved by SEAC on 09/08/2017 and by SEIAA on 16/09/2017 with specific conditions as below :

1. A brick/stone parapet wall of 3.5 feet surrounding to the excavated mine pit shall be constructed to prevent casualty. 2. Transportation route for vehicles carrying mineral shall have lease minimum pass near human habitation. 3. PP shall spend amount of CER after identifying activities in consultation with village gram panchayat. 4. Validity of EC shall be coterminous with the lease grant period. 5. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities shall be implemented in letter and spirit similar to the applicable measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

10. HARD MURRUM MINING, DIST : JAMNAGAR

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

Name of S.N Villa Taluka Dist Lease ROM Nea End Invest Date of Project o. ge Area rest Use ment Applicatio Hu in n man Received Habi Rs by SEAC tatio n

Keshiya 535 Kes Jodiya Jamn 1.00 3998 Kes Constru 1.52 19/10/201 Hard /1 hiya agar Ha 5 hiya ction Cr. 9 Murrum pai MTP : Quarry ki A Lease Area 2.67 km

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

1. PP submitted the cost of the project as 1.52 Cr. 2. PP submitted need based CER of Rs 3.05 Lakh. 3. PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Noise which are within the norms. 4. PP submitted revised EMP with capital cost of Rs. 56000/- and recurring cost of 24000/-

During meeting on 07/01/2020, Considering reply satisfactory and anticipated impacts of mining on environment and its mitigation measures, proposed CER, committee unanimously decided to recommend the above proposal for grant of environmental clearance to SEIAA, subject to the strict implementation of conditions mentioned for Non-Sand mining project without blasting approved by SEAC on 09/08/2017 and by SEIAA on 16/09/2017 with following specific conditions:

1. Transportation route for vehicles carrying mineral shall have lease minimum pass near human habitation. 2. PP shall spend amount of CER after identifying activities in consultation with village gram panchayat. 3. Validity of EC shall be coterminous with the lease grant period. 4. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities shall be implemented in letter and spirit

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

similar to the applicable measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

11. BUILDING LIMESTONE MINING, DIST : PORBANDAR

Name of S.No. Villa Tal Dist Lease ROM Nearest End Invest Date of Project ge uka Area Human Use ment in Applicat Habitati Rs ion on Receive d by SEAC

Odadar 1283 Oda Por Porba 1.0 Ha 20,00 Odadar Cons 25 lakh 25/10/2 Building dar ban ndar Existin 0 : 4 km tructi 019 Limestone dar g MTP on Mine C/O A JashibenJes abhaiSadiya

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee sought following additional details from the PP and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting:

1. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 2. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 3. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. 4. Verify applicability of CRZ Notification. 5. Re-verify shortest aerial distance from State Highway/National Highway from District Geologist. PP submitted reply on 30/12/2019 as below: 1. PP submitted the cost of the project as 25 Lakh. 2. PP submitted need based CER of Rs 0.72 Lakh.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

3. PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Noise which are within the norms. 4. PP submitted letter of district geologist mentioning that proposed lease area does not fall within radius of sea coast line. 5. PP submitted letter of district geologist mentioning that proposed lease area is 200 meter away from Porbandar-Madhavpur State highwayNo:6.

During meeting on 07/01/2020, Considering reply satisfactory and anticipated impacts of mining on environment and its mitigation measures, proposed CER, committee unanimously decided to recommend the above proposal for grant of environmental clearance to SEIAA, subject to the strict implementation of conditions mentioned for Non-Sand mining project without blasting approved by SEAC on 09/08/2017 and by SEIAA on 16/09/2017 with following specific conditions :

12. ORDINARY SAND MINING, DIST : KUTCH

Name of S.N Villa Taluka Dist Lease ROM Rive Nea End Investm Date of Project o. ge Area r rest Use ent in Application Hu Rs Received man by SEAC Habi tatio n

Rauma 501 Kum Rapar Kutch 3.00 81,00 Kum Kum construc 1.51 Cr. 19/10/2019 AkbaraliAla pai bhar Ha 0 bhar bhar tion rakha ki iya MTP iya iya: A river 814 met er

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

1. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 2. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 3. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. PP submitted reply on 31/12/2019 as below: 1. PP submitted the cost of the project as 1.51 Cr. 2. PP submitted need based CER of Rs 3.02 Lakh. 3. PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Noise which are within the norms.

Considering reply and EMP, committee noted that rate of mining proposed by PP is 81,000 MTPA however details pertaining to replenishment rate justifying proposed rate of mining is not addressed. Hence, Committee decided to ask PP to justify the aforementioned details and upon submission of the said details, it is decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting.

13. WHITE CLAY MINING, DIST: KUTCH

Name of S.N Villa Taluka Dist Lease ROM Neare End Investm Date of Project o. ge Area st Use ent in Application Huma Rs Received n by SEAC Habita tion

Shri Ajay P 363 Suk Bhach Kutch 3.77.60 50,00 Sukhp Cera 4.14 Cr. 19/10/2019 Gadhvi Pai hpar au Ha 0 ar: mic ki MTP 1.79 Ind A km

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

1. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 2. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 3. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. PP submitted reply on 31/12/2019 as below: 1. PP submitted the cost of the project as 4.14 Cr. 2. PP submitted need based CER of Rs 8.28 Lakh. 3. PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Noise which are within the norms.

During meeting on 07/01/2020000, Considering reply satisfactory and anticipated impacts of mining on environment and its mitigation measures, proposed CER, committee unanimously decided to recommend the above proposal for grant of th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

environmental clearance to SEIAA, subject to the strict implementation of conditions mentioned for Non-Sand mining project without blasting approved by SEAC on 09/08/2017 and by SEIAA on 16/09/2017 with following specific conditions:

14. CHINA CLAY MINING PROJECT, DIST: KUTCH

Applicant Survey Villag Talu Distri Lease Rate Neare Use of Cost Name No. e ka ct Area of st Minera of the Minin Huma l project g n in lakh Habita (In Rs) tion Shri 99/1,99 Soma Rap Kutch 4.5796 50,03 Vekra: Cerami 50 Rameshbh /2,104, niVan ar Ha 0 1.18 c Ind. aiBhudarb Travers dh MTP km hai Goyal e No: A 1318 Paiki

During SEAC meeting on 20/08/2019 after deliberation, Committee asked PP to submit the following details within 15 days and decided to consider the proposal after the submission of the details in upcoming SEAC meeting.

1. Valid lease document in the name of lessee issued by competent authority. 2. Letter from DFO regarding location of the proposed lease whether falling in eco sensitive zone of wild ass sanctuary and shortest aerial distance of the lease from the notified sanctuary. 3. Salient features of the post closure of mine.

PP submitted reply on 31/12/2019 as below:

1. PP submitted letter of district geologist dtd 21/12/2019 mentioning that lease order dated10/07/2014 vide No: MCR/102013/ML-72/CHH by Government of Gujarat is issued in the name of RameshbhaiBhudarbhai Goyal and lease execution requires EC.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

2. PP submitted letter of DFO dated 03/07/2019 with annexure mentioning that distance of proposed lease is 15 km from eco-sensitive zone and does not fall in eco-sensitive zone. 3. PP submitted salient features of the post closure mine plan.

During meeting on 07/01/2020, Considering reply satisfactory and anticipated impacts of mining on environment and its mitigation measures, proposed CER, committee unanimously decided to recommend the above proposal for grant of environmental clearance to SEIAA, subject to the strict implementation of conditions mentioned for Non-Sand mining project without blasting approved by SEAC on 09/08/2017 and by SEIAA on 16/09/2017 with following specific conditions:

15. BLACKTRAP MINING PROJECT, DIST.: DEVBHUMI DWARKA

Name of Project S No Village Ta Dist Lea RO Ri Neare End Invest se M ver st Use ment Are Huma in Rs. a n Habita in tion Ha

Shree Survey Harsha Khamb Dev 01- 318 Tel 0.54 Constr 60 ManojbhaiNagshi No. 15,16 dpur halia Bhu 00- 75 i Harsha uction Lakh bhaiGadhvi ne mi 00 dpur laguTeliN Dwa Ha adiPatt rka

This proposal was considered during SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019 and after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

(1) Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. (2) Revised project details mentioning S.No. of this lease. PP submitted reply on 03/01/2020 as below:

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

(1). PP submitted baseline data of Air, Water and Soil. (2). PP submitted revised project details with Survey numbers of proposed lease.

Referring to the baseline data and EMP, Committee noted that proposed black trap lease area is located in the Teli river bed and project proponent submitted details of impact of mining in river bed which is not satisfactory. Committee noted that the additional details were sought during SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019 and after considerable time is lapsed and reply submitted is dissatisfactory, it is decided to delist the proposal from pending application list of SEAC.

16. RIVERBED SAND MINING, DIST : PORBANDAR

Name of S.No. Vill Taluka Dist Lease ROM Rive Near End Use Investm Date of Project age Area r est ent in Rs Applicati Hum on an Receive Habi d by tatio SEAC n Mayurbhai 385 ne Fat Porban Porban 1.0 Ha 70,00 Nart Fata Construc 50.23 24/10/20 Virambhai lagu ana dar dar Existing 0 u na: tion lakh 19 Karavadar MTPA 790 a Nartu Nadi mete r NadiPa ttPaiki During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP. 1. Copy of valid lease document or LOI. 2. Detailed study report of replenishment of the river bed sand. Compliance of sustainable sand mining guideline of MoEF&CC. 3. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 4. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 5. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. PP submitted reply on 03/01/2020 as below:

1. Letter of district geologist mentioning that the proposed lease is extendable up to 31/03/2030 vide letter No: BP/QL/1433/4292 dated 18/12/2019. 2. Replenishment study is submitted by the PP wherein it is concluded that 35% replenishment occurs and replenishment rate of Vartu river around lease area is high enough. 3. Revised project cost submitted is Rs. 50.23 Lakh.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

4. Revised need based CER submitted for the amount of Rs. 1.0 Lakh. 5. Baseline data is collected on 25/11/2019 and incorporated in EMP.

Considering reply, committee noted that rate of mining proposed by PP is 70,000 MTPA and replenishment rate is 26,300 MTPA which is less than production proposed. Hence, committee unanimously decided to ask PP to justify proposed rate of mining keeping rate of replenishment in view.

17. RIVERBED SAND MINING, DIST : PORBANDAR

Name of S.No. Vil Taluka Dist Lease ROM Rive Nea End Investm Date of Project la Area r rest Use ent in Applicat ge Hu Rs ion man Receive Habi d by tatio SEAC n

Modhav Sorathi Ad Porban Porba 3.00 2,20, Sor Adv Constru 129.50 24/10/2 adiya Nadi va dar ndar HA 000 athi ana: ctiob Lakh 019 na MTP Nadi 970 Vanrajb Patt A met haiLakh er ansibhai Paiki

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP.

1. Copy of valid lease document or LOI. 2. Detailed study report of replenishment of the river bed sand. Compliance of sustainable sand mining guideline of MoEF&CC. 3. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 4. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 5. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP.

PP submitted reply on 03/01/2020 as below: 1. Letter of district geologist mentioning that the proposed lease is extendable up to 31/03/2030 vide letter No: BP/QL/1339/4296 dated 18/12/2019.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

2. Replenishment study is submitted by the PP wherein it is concluded that 35% replenishment occurs and replenishment rate of Sorthi river around lease area is high enough. 3. Revised project cost submitted is Rs. 129.5023 Lakh. 4. Revised need based CER submitted for the amount of Rs.2.60 Lakh. 5. Baseline data is collected on 25/11/2019 and incorporated in EMP.

Considering reply, committee noted that rate of mining proposed by PP is 2,20,000 MTPA and replenishment rate is 78,900 MTPA which is less than production proposed. Hence, committee unanimously decided to ask PP to justify proposed rate of mining keeping rate of replenishment in view.

18. ORDINARY SAND AND ORDINARY CLAY MINING, DIST : PORBANDAR

Name of S.No Villa Taluka Dist Lease ROM Nearest End Investm Date of Project . ge Area Human Use ent in Application Habitati Rs Received by on SEAC

Mer 180 Nera Ranav Porb 1.45.6 Ordin Nerana: Const 21.77L 24/10/2019 Polabhai paiky na av and 9 Ha ary 660 ructio akh Viram 2 ar Clay: Meter n Giga 2892 MTPA

Ordin ary Sand: 13778 MTPA

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP. 1. Copy of valid lease document or LOI. 2. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 3. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 4. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. 5. Revise Form – 1 with revised production quantity.

PP submitted reply on 03/01/2020 as below:

1. Letter of district geologist mentioning that the proposed lease is extendable up to 31/03/2030 vide letter No: BP/QL/1485/4294 dated 18/12/2019. 2. Revised project cost submitted is Rs. 21.77 Lakh. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

3. Revised need based CER submitted for the amount of Rs.0.44 Lakh. 4. Baseline data is collected on 25/11/2019 and incorporated in EMP. 5. Revised Form – 1 with production quantity.

19. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : PORBANDAR

Name of S.N Villag Tal Dist Lease ROM Near End Investm Date of Project o. e uka Area est Use ent in Applicat Hum Rs ion an Receive Habit d by ation SEAC Arjun 38 Amar Kuti Porba 1.00 1800 Rana Constr 65.60 24/10/2 Construction paik yan ndar Ha 0 kand uction Lakh 019 Company y a MTP oran A a: 890 mete r

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP.

1. Revised project cost submitted is Rs. 65.60 Lakh. 2. Revised need based CER submitted for the amount of Rs.1.50 Lakh. 3. Baseline data is collected on 25/11/2019 and incorporated in EMP. 4. Letter of district geologist mentioning that the proposed lease is extendable up to 31/03/2030 vide letter No: BP/QL/327/4288 dated 18/12/2019.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

1. A brick/stone parapet wall of 3.5 feet surrounding to the excavated mine pit shall be constructed to prevent casualty. 2. Transportation route for vehicles carrying mineral shall have lease minimum pass near human habitation. 3. PP shall spend amount of CER after identifying activities in consultation with village gram panchayat. 4. Validity of the EC shall be coterminous with validity of lease. 5. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities shall be implemented in letter and spirit similar to the applicable measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

20. BLACK TRAP MINING, DIST : PORBANDAR

Name of S.N Vil Taluka Dist Lease ROM Neare End Investm Date of Project o. la Area st Use ent in Applicat ge Huma Rs ion n Receive Habita d by tion SEAC

SajanbenKa S A Kutiya Porba 1.0 Ha 1800 Rana Const 45.60L 24/10/2 rshanbhaiO NO m na ndar 0 Kando ructio akh 019 dedara 38 ar MTP rana: n Paik A 970 y meter

During SEAC meeting on 20/11/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit the following details and decided to consider the proposal after submission of the said details by PP. 1. Copy of Valid lease document or LOI 2. Revised Project cost with details of each component. 3. Revised need based CER keeping revised project cost in view. 4. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. PP submitted reply on 03/01/2020 as below:

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

1. Letter of district geologist mentioning that the proposed lease is extendable up to 31/03/2030 vide letter No: BP/QL/325/4290 dated 18/12/2019. 2. Revised project cost submitted is Rs. 45.60 Lakh. 3. Revised need based CER submitted for the amount of Rs.1.00 Lakh. 4. Baseline data is collected on 25/11/2019 and incorporated in EMP. 5. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities shall be implemented in letter and spirit similar to the applicable measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

Considering reply of additional details sought by PP satisfactory, anticipated impacts of mining on environment, its mitigation measures and proposed CER, committee unanimously decided to recommend the above proposal for grant of environmental clearance to SEIAA, subject to the strict implementation of conditions mentioned for Non-Sand mining project with blasting approved by SEAC on 09/08/2017 and by SEIAA on 16/09/2017 with following specific conditions: 1. A brick/stone parapet wall of 3.5 feet surrounding to the excavated mine pit shall be constructed to prevent casualty. 2. Transportation route for vehicles carrying mineral shall have lease minimum pass near human habitation. 3. PP shall spend amount of CER after identifying activities in consultation with village gram panchayat. 4. Validity of the EC shall be coterminous with validity of lease. 5. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities shall be implemented in letter and spirit similar to the applicable measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

21. ORDINARY CLAY MINING, DIST.: ANAND

Name of S. No. Villag Taluk Dis Lease RO Nearest End Use Invest Date of Project e a t Area M Human ment Applicat Habitatio in Rs i on n Receive d by SEAC

SHRI 1419 Sojitr Sojitr An 1.49.7 413 Virol – Brick 15 lakh 10.10.2 VIPINBHAI ,142 a a a 3 Ha 0 0.51 km. Manufact 0 19 RAMBHAI 0/1,1 nd MTP u ring DALWADI 420/ A 2

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

During SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

1. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. 2. Dust Suppression Plan consists of type and capacity of vehicles, no. of vehicle movement per day, transportation route length and quantity of water to be used for sprinkling with justification. PP submitted reply on 04/01/2019 as below. 1. PP submitted Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise incorporated in EMP.The Baseline data is collected with respect to the project site during month of December 2019. 2. PP submitted that mining area and brick kiln manufacturing area are in same survey number so transportation by truck will not be required.

22. ORDINARY CLAY MINING, DIST.: ANAND

Name S. Villag Taluk Dis Leas RO Nearest End Use Investmen Date of of No. e a t e M Human t in Rs Applicat Projec Area Habitatio i on t n Receive d by SEAC

Soni 397 Kheda Bors Ana 01 - 840 Khedas a - Brick 15 lakh 10.10.2 / 2, sa ad nd 86- 0 0.55 km Manufact 0 19 Bricks 397 13 MTP u ring / 3, A 398, 399

During SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

1. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

2. Dust Suppression Plan consists of type and capacity of vehicles, no. of vehicle movement per day, transportation route length and quantity of water to be used for sprinkling with justification.

PP submitted reply on 04/01/2019 as below. 1. PP submitted Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise incorporated in EMP.The Baseline data is collected with respect to the project site during month of December 2019. 2. PP submitted that mining area and brick kiln manufacturing area are in same survey number so transportation by truck will not be required.

Name S. Villag Taluk Dis Leas ROM Nearest End Use Investmen Date of of No. e a t e Human t in Rs Applicat Projec Area Habitatio i on t n Receive d by SEAC

Maan 152, Virsa Bors Ana 02 - 810 Virsad – Brick 16 lakh 10.10.2 Bricks 153, d ad nd 27- 0MT 1.51 km Manufact 0 19 154 43 P A u ring / 1,

During SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

1. PP submitted Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise incorporated in EMP.The Baseline data is collected with respect to the project site during month of December 2019. 2. PP submitted that mining area and brick kiln manufacturing area are in same survey number so transportation by truck will not be required. Considering reply of additional details sought by PP satisfactory, anticipated impacts of mining on environment, its mitigation measures and proposed CER, committee unanimously decided to recommend the above proposal for grant of environmental clearance to SEIAA, subject to the strict implementation of conditions mentioned for Non-Sand mining project approved by SEAC on 09/08/2017 and by SEIAA on 16/09/2017 with following specific conditions as per Annexure I

24. ORDINARY CLAY MINING, DIST.: ANAND

Name of S. No. Villag Taluk Dis Lease RO Nearest End Use Invest Date of Project e a t Area M Human ment Applicat Habitatio in Rs i on n Receive d by SEAC

M.S.B 148 Kasari Borsa An 2.00.0 950 Kasari Brick 18 lakh 10.10.2 Bricks d a 0 ha. 0 Village – Manufact 0 19 nd MTP 0.78 km. u ring A

During SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

2. PP submitted that mining area and brick kiln manufacturing area are in same survey number so transportation by truck will not be required.

25. ORDINARY CLAY MINING, DIST.: ANAND

Name S. Village Taluka Dist Lease ROM Nearest End Use Investmen Date of of No. Area Human t in Rs Applicat Projec Habitatio i on t n Receive d by SEAC

M.B. 422 Pipli Bors Ana 1.62. 4030 Khedasa Brick 18 lakh 10.10.20 C. ad nd 91 ha Village Manufact 19 Bricks MTP (Paru) – u ring A 0.52 km.

During SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

2. PP submitted that mining area and brick kiln manufacturing area are in same survey number so transportation by truck will not be required.

26. ORDINARY CLAY MINING, DIST.: ANAND

Name S. Villag Taluk Dis Lease RO Nearest End Use Investmen Date of of No. e a t Area M Human t in Rs Applicat Projec Habitatio i on t n Receive d by SEAC

Indian 656 Alasra Bors An 1.30.4 6000 Joshikuva Brick 16 lakh 10.10.2 Bricks / ad a 4 Ha : 0.73 Manufact 0 19 MTP 1/1, nd Km.. u ring 656 A / 2/1, 656 / 2/2, 656 / 3

During SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

PP submitted reply on 04/01/2019 as below.

1. PP submitted Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise incorporated in EMP.The Baseline data is collected with respect to the project site during month of December 2019.

2. PP submitted that mining area and brick kiln manufacturing area are in same survey number so transportation by truck will not be required.

Name of S. No. Villag Taluk Dis Lease RO Nearest End Use Invest Date of Project e a t Area M Human ment Applicat Habitatio in Rs i on n Receive d by SEAC

Gayatri 605 Petlad Petla An 1-57 - 123 Petlad : Brick 15 lakh 10.10.2 Bricks d a 83 ha 70 0.95 Km. Manufact 0 19 nd MTP u ring A

During SEAC meeting on 03/12/2019, after deliberation, committee asked PP to submit following additional details and decided to consider the proposal in one of the upcoming meeting after submission of the said details.

1. Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise to be incorporated in EMP. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

2. Dust Suppression Plan consists of type and capacity of vehicles, no. of vehicle movement per day, transportation route length and quantity of water to be used for sprinkling with justification.

PP submitted reply on 04/01/2019 as below.

1. PP submitted Baseline data of Air, Water, Soil and Noise incorporated in EMP.The Baseline data is collected with respect to the project site during month of December 2019.

2. PP submitted that mining area and brick kiln manufacturing area are in same survey number so transportation by truck will not be required.

1. Dr. Dinesh Misra, Chairman, SEAC

2. Shri Satish Srivastav,Vice Chairman, SEAC

3. Shri V.N.Patel, Member, SEAC

4. Shri R.J.Shah, Member, SEAC

5. Shri A.K.Muley, Member, SEAC

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

ANNEXURE 1

Additional Conditions:

1. Transportation route for vehicles carrying mineral shall have least minimum pass near human habitation. 2. PP shall pursue CER activities as proposed in declaration 3. Validity of the EC shall be coterminous with validity of lease. 4. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities shall be implemented in letter and spirit similar to the applicable measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E).

Project Specific Conditions :

1. All the conditions prescribed in Office Memorandum of Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, New Delhi dated 24 th June 2013 for mining of ordinary earth shall be complied with in a letter and spirit which are as under.

i. The activity associated with borrowing/excavation of ‘brick earth’ and ‘ordinary earth’ for purpose of brick manufacturing, construction of roads, embankments etc. shall not involve blasting. ii. The borrowing/excavation activity shall be restricted to a maximum depth of 2 m below general ground level at the site. iii. The borrowing/excavation activity shall be restricted to 2 m above the ground water table at the site.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

iv. The borrowing/excavation activity shall not alter the natural drainage pattern of the area. v. The borrowed/excavated pit shall be restored by the project proponent for useful purpose(s). vi. Appropriate fencing all around the borrowed/excavated pit shall be made to prevent any mishap. vii. Measures shall be taken to prevent dust emission by covering of borrowed / excavated earth during transportation. viii. Safeguards shall be adopted against health risks on account of breeding of vectors in the water bodies created due to borrowing/excavation of earth. ix. Workers / labourers shall be provided with facilities for drinking water and sanitation. x. A berm shall be left from the boundary of adjoining field having a width equal to at least half the depth depth of proposed excavation. xi. A minimum distance of 15 m from any civil structure shall be kept from the periphery of any excavation area.

ANNEXURE II

Beside above standard TOR, following additional TORs are recommended: 1. Project site specific details such as distance of the project site from nearest (1) Village(Habitation) (2)Water Body : River / Creek / Nallah / Lake / Pond /Check dam/ Reservoir / Canal /French well/ Percolation Well(3) National Highway/Bridge Pier (4) State Highway /Bridge Pier(5) Railway line/Bridge (6) Heritage site (7) National Park / Wild Life Sanctuary /Reserve Forest / Protected Forest shall be included in the rapid EIA report to be prepared covering one season (other than monsoon) data. A map indicating the aerial distance of the lease area from these entities. 2. Distance of nearby mining lease areas from the periphery of the proposed project including a map covering distance of 1 Km from the periphery of the proposed project. In case of no mining lease areas are existing within 500 meter periphery of the proposed project, certificate of the concerned geologist in this regard.ion)Commissioner of Geology & Mining, Indian Bureau of Mines, GPCB, current lease renewal status from Industries and Mine department, Government of Gujarat with opinion of the district geologist regarding compliance of all the conditions in lease deed and copy of renewed lease (if any) etc. to be incorporated.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

3. Approved mining plan including progressive mine closure plan shall be provided with EIA report. Letter of approval of IBM shall also be incorporated with compliance of all the recommendations mentioned in approved mining plan. 4. Specific Terms of Reference for the project on assessment of ecological damage, remediation plan and natural and community resource augmentation plan for the proposals under violation of EIA Notification 2006.

1. Ecological damage shall be assessed with respect to air, water, land and other project & location specific environment attributes. The collection and analysis of data shall be done by an environment laboratory duly notified under Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, or an environment laboratory accredited by NABL, or a laboratory of a council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) institution working in the field of environment.

2. The Environment Management Plan shall be prepared which shall comprise of the remediation plan and community & natural resource augmentation plan corresponding to the ecological damage assessed and economic benefits derived due to violation. The remediation plan and the natural & community resource augmentation plan prepared shall be included as an independent chapter in the EIA report.

3. The project proponent shall submit bank guarantee to Gujarat Pollution Control Board prior to grant of environmental clearance equivalent to the amount of remediation plan and Natural & Community augmentation plans as per the amount assessed in below mentioned table as per the indicative guideline OR equivalent to the CER amount as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO 22-65/2017- IA-III dated 01/05/2018, whichever is higher. The amount shall be recommended by the SEAC and finalized by the regulatory authority. The bank guarantee shall be released after successful implementation of the remediation plan and Natural and Community Resource Augmentation Plan, and after recommendation by regional office of the Ministry followed by recommendations of the SEAC and approval of the regulatory authority.

4. Gujarat Pollution Control Board shall initiate credible legal action against the project proponent under the provisions of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, and further no consent to operate to be issued till the project is granted Environmental Clearance.

5. A notarized undertaking stating that (1).Any such violation shall not be repeated in future, (2). All the statutory requirements shall be fully complied with and (3). A status quo shall be maintained at the project site and remaining activity shall be carried out only after obtaining Environmental Clearance from SEIAA.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

6. Applicability of CRZ Notification, 2011 shall be verified for the project and if found applicable, due procedure shall be followed as per the CRZ Notification,2011.

5. Project Specific Conditions:

Honorable supreme court vide judgment dated 2nd August 2017 with writ petition (Civil) No 114 of 2014 in the matter of common cause versus union of India and others has passed order interpreting section 21(5) of the MMDR Act and directed payment of 100% Penalty for illegal mining operation with reference to the relevant statues, which inter alia include Environment (Protection) Act 1986, the Water( Prevention and Control of Pollution)Act 1974 and Air( Prevention and Control of pollution)Act 1981,The Forest(Conservation)Act 1980 and the Mines and Minerals(Development &Regulation)Act 1957. In this context In order to additionally comply with the direction of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 02/08/2017 vide writ petition (Civil) NO 114 of 2014 Following additional conditions in TOR are required to address and comply.

1. The project proponent shall give an undertaking by way of affidavit to comply with all the statutory requirements and judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 2 nd August 2017 in Writ Petition (Civil) No: 114 of 2014 in the matter of common cause versus Union of India and others before grant of TOR/EC. The undertaking inter alia include commitment of PP not to repeat any such violation in future. 2. In case of violation of above undertaking, the TOR/EC shall be liable to be terminated forthwith. 3. The Environmental Clearance will not be operational till such time the project proponent complies with all the statutory requirements and judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 2nd August 2017 in Writ Petition (Civil) No 114 of 2014 in the matter of Common Cause versus Union of India and others. 4. State government concerned shall ensure that mining operation shall not commence till entire compensation levies, if any, for illegal mining paid by the Project proponent through Their respective department of Mining and Geology in strict compliance of judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 2nd August 2017 in Writ Petition (Civil) No 114 of 2014 in the matter of Common Cause versus Union of India and others.

6. Validity of ToR:

• The ToR prescribed for the project will be valid for a period of three years for submission of EIA & EMP report. ToR will lapse after three years from date of issue. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

• The period of validity could be extended for a maximum period of one year provided an application is made by the applicant to the Regulatory Authority, at least three months before the expiry of valid period together with an updated Form-I, based on proper justification and also recommendation of the SEAC.

The above mentioned project specific TORs/additional TORs and the model TORs available in the MoEFCC’s sector specific EIA Manual for Mining Projects shall be considered as generic TORs for preparation of the EIA report in addition to all the relevant information as per the generic structure of EIA given in Appendix III in the EIA Notification, 2006. The project shall be appraised on receipt of the final EIA report.

INDICATIVE GUIDELINE FOR ASSESSMENT OF ECOLOGICAL DAMAGE:

Assessment of ecological damage and remediation plan shall address the following attributes:

EMP Sub-Components

AP WP SHW TP NV GB HG RH/OHS SC CER

Wat Air er Soil Solid Hydro- Risk Hazards/ Corporate Noise & Poll &Haz. Greenbelt Geolog Occupational Environmental Poll Transpo Vibration Conser utio Waste y Health & Safety Responsibility utio rtation vation n n

Salient Feature of the Project:

Type of Mineral

Lease Area ( In Sq.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

Meter)

Quantity of Mineral in MT

No. of working days

Price of Mineral in Rupees per MT

Total cost of Mineral in Rs

Attributes Scope of Environmental benefits earned EMP COST

Total cost (Rs.)

AP Water requirement per day for sprinkling of water to curb fugitive emission in KL (0.1 Liters per sq.m. )

Cost of 1 KL water for sprinkling in Rupees

WP Major water pollution envisioned : 1. Ground water table intersection if any.2. Run off water outside the lease and estimated damage caused considering period of violation in RS. Per day

SHW When there is an overburden, Quantity of Over Burden in MT * 10 Rs. Per MT O.B.handling charges * 2 ( Lifting and shifting frequency)

When there is no Overburden, only mining waste handling charges are to be considered. Mine waste in MT * 10 Rs Per MT of mineral waste handling *2 ( Lifting and shifting frequency)

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

NV • Existence of House properties/env. entities within 500 meter of blasting site and if damaged due to blasting. • Nos of such properties/env. Entities. • Buiilt up area of each property/env. Entities • Cost of reconstruction of properties ( total) considering current construction cost per Sq. Meter.

GB Green Belt d eveloped in 10% of leased area

Green belt area in M2.

Presume 1 plant per 4 m2 is to be planted.

Cost of single plant:

Total cost of green belt

HG No major HG issues envisioned, considering no ground water interception

If intersection of ground water is made, cost of one time remediation plan after estimating extent of contamination of ground water

RH/OHS •Health Expenditure:

Nos of workers* Rs 1000

PPE expenditure

No of workers*Rs 300

Total expenditure for health and safety for workers* Nos of year

CER 10% of Mineral Value

SC Cost of preservation, Handling and reuse of Top soil : (Cost of Soil preservation is assumed to be Rs 10,000 per 1 Hectare)

Total Assessed Env.Damage Cost

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

in Rupees

Environmental (Total Assessed Env.Damage Cost in Damage Cost in % Rupees/Value of Mineral in Rs.)*100 of Mineral Value

Note: For the aforementioned assessment, following basis are taken:

1. Quantity of water sprinkling for curbing fugitive emission is assumed as 0.1 Liters per sq.m. 2. Cost of water availability is to be considered on prevailing local market 3. Over burden removal and its shifting are considered as two separate activities. 4. For damage of house, entire construction of house considering built up area and local prevailing rate of construction are to be considered. 5. For green belt 1 plant is assumed in 4 sq. meter area and 10% of lease area is proposed to be developed as green belt. 6. It is assumed that One Hectare mine requires 2 workers. 7. Cost of health check up per worker is Rs 1000/-or prevailing local marker rate. 8. Cost of PPE per worker is Rs 300/- or prevailing local marker rate. 9. Cost of preservation, handling and restoration for 1 Ha lease is Rs. 10,000/-.

The project proponent shall submit bank guarantee to Gujarat Pollution Control Board prior to grant of environmental clearance equivalent to the amount of remediation plan and Natural & Community augmentation plan as per the amount assessed in aforementioned table as per the indicative guideline above OR equivalent to the CER amount as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO 22-65/2017-IA-III dated 01/05/2018, whichever is higher.

The proposals under violation shall pursue CER activities for the amount double than that arise from the actual provision as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO 22-65/2017-IA- III dated 01/05/2018 and it shall be incorporated in the EIA report.

Bank Guarantee shall be released only after

1. Successful implementation of the remediation plan and Natural and Community Resource Augmentation Plan, and after recommendation by regional office of the Ministry, State Level Expert Appraisal Committee and approval of the Regulatory Authority. 2. Compliance of all the CER activities for the amount double than that arise from the actual provision.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020

More over (1) Method of environmental damage assessment published by CPCB and (2) Notification issued by Industries and Mine Department, Government of Gujarat dated 10/09/2018 and amended on 29/11/2018 shall also be considered and damage cost which comes the highest shall be considered.

th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020