04032020Za1dyf5aseacminut
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Minutes of the 580 th meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee held on 07/01/2020 at GPCB, Sector 10A, Gandhinagar. The 580 th meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) was held on07 th January 2020 at GPCB, Sector 10A, Gandhinagar. Following members attended the meeting: 1. Dr. Dinesh Misra, Chairman, SEAC 2. Shri Satish Srivastav, Vice Chairman, SEAC 3. Shri V. N. Patel, Member, SEAC 4. Shri R.J.Shah, Member, SEAC 5. Shri A.K.Muley, Member, SEAC Following proposals were considered during meeting. 1. LIMESTONE MINING PROJECT,DIST: JUNAGADH (VIOLATION APPRAISAL ) TOR File Name S Villag Ta Dist Lease ROM Nearest Minera SEAC NO NO e area in human l TOR Ha habitati Meetin on g SIA/GJ/MIN/ Damasa 110/ Dama Una Junagadh 2.00 57500 Una:7.7 LIMES 29/08/ Lime P sa Ha MTPA 0 km TONE 2018 44972/2019 Stone Mining Project, TOR (c/o Shree SIA/GJ/MIN/ Vikram 26379/2018 Chemical Co. Project proponent attended the meeting and informed that they could not submit the hard copies of final EIA and Approved Mine plan. Committee noted that hard copies of final EIA and approved mine plan along with other documents are not submitted by the PP. Hence, after deliberation, it is decided to defer the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020 2. LIMESTONE MINING PROJECT,DIST: JUNAGADH (VIOLATION APPRAISAL ) TOR File Name S Villag Ta Dist Lease ROM Nearest Minera SEAC NO NO e area in human l TOR Ha habitati Meetin on g SIA/GJ/MIN/ Shri 389 Ajotha Ver Junagad 2.00 Ha 46,300 Ajotha:1 Limest 29/08/ ArjabhaiKhi aval h MTPA .58 km one 2018 44550/2019 mabhai Rathod,(Li me stone (TOR mine lease Proposal Area: 2.00 NO: SIA /GJ Ha / MIN /23285 /2018). Project proponent attended the meeting and informed that they could not submit the hard copies of final EIA and Approved Mine plan. Committee noted that hard copies of final EIA and approved mine plan along with other documents are not submitted by the PP. Hence, after deliberation, it is decided to defer the proposal in one of the upcoming SEAC meeting. TOR PROPOSALS: 3. BENTONITE MINERALS MINING, DIST : KUTCH Application No Nam S.N Village Talu Dist Leas RO Neares End Use Investm Date of e of o. ka e M t ent in Applicat Proje Area Human Rs ion ct Habitat Receive ion d by SEAC SIA/GJ/MIN/3443 Vinay 219 Nana Man Kut 2.06. 601 Nana For 4.01 Cr. 25/11/2 2/2019 ak pai Asamb dvi ch 00 34 Asamb construc 019 Miner ki iya ha MT iya – tion als PA 0.55 purpose Km Project proponent along with consultant represented above proposal before the committee. The mining will be done by Mechanized Opencast method. There will be no blasting. There will be no intersection of ground water due to working.Total water requirement is about 3.5 KLD = 1.5 KLD (Drinking & Domestic Uses) + 1.3KLD (Plantation) KLD + 0.7KLD (Dust Suppression). Drinking water will be brought from the nearby Tube-wells and water for dust suppression and plantation will be collected from th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020 nearby villages. There will be no industrial effluent discharge from proposed project. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include use of water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Cluster of 2 leases is formed having total cluster area of 05.06.00Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist. After scoping for the aforementioned proposal, committee decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation & Hon’ble National Green Tribunal Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non sand mining without blasting for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA. 1. PP shall ensure participation of people during public hearing with equality in genders so as to encourage women participation in public hearing and at the same time the issues of women shall also be given weightage. 2. Carry out need based survey for CER and give details of budgetary provision for five years for effective utilization of the same. 3. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities similar to the measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E). The draft EIA report also covering the above TOR shall be prepared and submitted to the GPCB for conducting the public hearing / consultation process as per the provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006. The project shall be appraised after submission of the final EIA report. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020 4. BENTONITE MINERALS MINING, DIST : KUTCH Application No Name S.N Villa Talu Dist Leas RO Neares End Use Investm Date of of o. ge ka e M t ent in Applicat Project Area Human Rs ion Habitat Receive ion d by SEAC SIA/GJ/MIN/3939 KALYA 183 Ham Man Kut 4.00. 999 Hamla- For 13.72 25/11/2 4/2019 NJI la dvi ch 00 98 0.740 construc Cr. 019 SHAMJI ha MT Km tion PATARI PA purpose YA Project proponent along with consultant represented above proposal before the committee. The mining will be done by Mechanized Opencast method. There will be no blasting. There will be no intersection of ground water due to working.Total water requirement is about 4.2 KLD = 1.0 KLD (Drinking & Domestic Uses) + 1.4 KLD (Plantation) KLD + 1.8 KLD (Dust Suppression). There will be no industrial effluent generation. Sewage will be disposed off into soak pit. Regular water sprinkling is proposed to curb fugitive emission during loading, unloading and transportation. All the vehicles will be covered during transportation of mineral. Proposed air pollution control measures include use of water sprinkling on haul roads, tree plantation in periphery and road sides, etc. After completion of mining period, pit is proposed to be reclaimed by the overburden and soil and remaining void pit will be used as a water reservoir. Fencing will be made around the proposed pit and plantation will be made to prevent casualty.Cluster of 57 leases is formed having total cluster area of 111.14.79 Ha.PP submitted approved mine plan, Prefeasibility report, project details validated by the district geologist, details of cluster members validated by the district geologist. After scoping for the aforementioned proposal, committee decided to consider the proposal under B1 category keeping cluster situation & Hon’ble National Green Tribunal Order dated 13 September 2018 in view, It was decided to recommend TOR approved by SEIAA on 07/03/2019 for Non sand mining without blasting for conducting the EIA study to be done for the proposals in cluster considering 10 Km radius from the periphery of the mine lease area including public hearing including following additional TOR to SEIAA. 1. PP shall ensure participation of people during public hearing with equality in genders so as to encourage women participation in public hearing and at the same time the issues of women shall also be given weightage. 2. Carry out need based survey for CER and give details of budgetary provision for five years for effective utilization of the same. th 580 meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 07.01.2020 3. Dust mitigation measures due to mining, handling of mineral, loading, unloading, transportation and other allied activities similar to the measures guided in Notification issued by MOEF&CC dated 25/01/2018 vide GSR 94(E). The draft EIA report also covering the above TOR shall be prepared and submitted to the GPCB for conducting the public hearing / consultation process as per the provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006. The project shall be appraised after submission of the final EIA report. 5. RIVER BED ORDINARY SAND MINING, DIST : KUTCH Application Name of S. Villa Tal Dis Rive Lea RO Near End Invest Date No Project No ge uka t r se M est Use ment of . Are Hum in Rs Applic a an ation Habit Recei ation ved by SEAC SIA/GJ/MIN/3 VelabhaiRana 63 Kun Bh Ku Kun 1.00 78 Kuna For 60.73 25/11/ 8281/2019 bhaiDangar 6 ariya uj tch ariya .00 09 riya- constr lacs 2019 Pai ha 0 1.32 uction ky MT Km purpos PA e The project proponent along with consultant remained present.The mining will be done by Opencast Semi Mechanized method.No waste or overburden will be generated from the mine site. Mining will be done on the dry part of the river bed.The daily water demand will be only 10.0 KLD.