Influence of Landscape Diversity and Agricultural Practices on Spider
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
COMMUNITY AND ECOSYSTEM ECOLOGY Influence of Landscape Diversity and Agricultural Practices on Spider Assemblage in Italian Vineyards of Langa Astigiana (Northwest Italy) 1 M. ISAIA, F. BONA, AND G. BADINO Environ. Entomol. 35(2): 297Ð307 (2006) ABSTRACT The purpose of this study was to investigate spider assemblages of the Italian vineyards of Langa Astigiana (northwest Italy). Pitfall trapping and standardized hand collecting were combined to have an overall idea of the spider fauna living in this agroecosystem. A total of 138 samples for pitfall sampling and 92 for hand collecting sites were collected at 23 different times over a period of 2 yr (2003 and 2004). The vineyards differ mainly from agricultural practices (certiÞed organic production, production according to EECÕs Council Regulation 2092/91 on biological agriculture and intensive production) and for the heterogeneity of landscape matrix surrounding them. We studied the inßuence of these two factors on spider assemblages applying canonical correspondence analysis and multiresponse permutation procedures (MRPPs). SigniÞcant results of MRPP were analyzed in terms of hunting strategies. SigniÞcant differences are found among groups according to both landscape heterogeneity and agricultural practices, the Þrst resulting more signiÞcantly. Analyzed in terms of hunting strategies, an increase in landscape heterogeneity seems to provide an increase in ambush spiders and specialized predators, whereas an increase in sheet web weavers seems to be related to homogeneous landscapes. KEY WORDS spider assemblages, vineyards, landscape diversity, agricultural practices, hunting strategies BECAUSE OF THEIR ABUNDANCE and feeding habits, spi- al. 2004). The main conclusions of their research are ders play an important role in the trophic web of that (1) despite their vegetation structure, vineyards terrestrial ecosystems (Turnbull 1973, Wise 1993, can host a very diversiÞed and abundant spider com- Hlivko and Rypstra 2003). According to Ekschmit et al. munity, and (2) the maintenance of ground cover (1997), they are a necessary component of efÞcient, between vine rows can play a very important role in sustainable, and low-input agricultural systems. maintaining a spider community. A spider community can undergo rapid changes in In Piedmont (northwest Italy), as in other coun- species composition because of its quick reaction to tries, this kind of agroecosystem is facing intense variations in vegetation structure (Asselin and Baudry transformations, consisting in two apparently opposite 1989). It is inßuenced by agricultural practices (Luc- processes: land abandonment and agricultural inten- zak 1979, Reichert and Lockley 1984) and chemical siÞcation. IntensiÞcation results in the progressive re- treatments (Bajwa and Niazee 2001, Horton et al. moval of small natural landscape elements, thus en- 2001, Koss et al. 2005, see Marc et al. 1999 for an overall hancing the overall loss of heterogeneity and its review). Moreover, landscape ecology gives many ex- consequences on biotic communities (Ruthsatz and amples of the inßuence of landscape heterogeneity, Haber 1981, Harms et al. 1987). spatial structure, and fragmentation on species distri- In this study, we used two sampling techniques bution and community composition (Burel and (pitfall traps and hand collecting on standard areas of Baudry 1999, Vandergast and Gillespie 2004). How- 9m2) to sample both ground-dwellers and spiders that ever, it seems that agricultural practices affect pitfall- live above ground level (web weavers and ambush collected spider community composition more than spiders) and to give an overall idea of the spider landscape heterogeneity (Jeanneret et al. 2003). assemblages living in vineyards. We analyzed the re- Only a few authors have focused on spider assem- sponse of spider assemblages to different agricultural blages in vineyards (Costello and Daane 1997, 1998, practices and to landscape heterogeneity and which of 2003, Beck 1991, Groppali et al. 1997, Genini 2000, the above-mentioned factors is affecting spider assem- Nobre and Meierrose 2000, Nobre et al. 2000, Isaia et blages more. This study also contributes to the knowledge of the spider fauna in vineyards and of the ecology of Italian 1 Corresponding author: Dipartimento di Biologia Animale e dellÕUomo, Universita` di Torino, Via Accademia Albertina, 13Ð10123 species. Indeed, the Italian spider fauna is far from Torino, Italy (e-mail: [email protected]). being satisfactorily known (Pesarini 1995). 0046-225X/06/0297Ð0307$04.00/0 ᭧ 2006 Entomological Society of America 298 ENVIRONMENTAL ENTOMOLOGY Vol. 35, no. 2 Table 1. Sampling sites characterized by Shannon index di- Table 2. Groups according to agricultural practices performed versity applied to the landscape (SHL) of a 200-m-radius circle in the vineyards chosen for the research centered in the vineyard centroid and agricultural practices sorted into three groups Vineyards Description treatments Landscape Agricultural Sites SHL group practices Group B No chemical treatments except sulphur and copper sulfate spraying. In some cases pyrethrum is V1 1.192 1 E sprayed against ßavescence dore`e. V2 1.192 1 E The presence of the herbaceous layer is constant over V3 1.192 1 E the whole year. Grass is mowed once or twice a V4 1.502 2 B year, according to need. V5 1.502 2 B Group E Chemical treatments with insecticides against V6 1.502 1 B ßavescence dore`e, anti-rot compounds (most V7 0.659 0 B treatments are against Botrytis cinerea using V8 0.659 0 B dicarboximidic fungicides like Procymidone), V9 0.659 0 B sulphur spraying, copper, zinc, products with V10 0.604 0 H esaconazol and copper oxiclorur sulphate against V11 0.604 0 H oidium and rots, carbamate pesticides and fungicide V12 1.310 2 H (Mancozeb), mean use of mineral feeds with P, K V13 1.310 2 H and N of 4.5 q/ha. V14 0.697 0 H The presence of the herbaceous layer is not constant V15 0.697 0 E over the whole year. Grass mowing and tilling are V16 0.697 0 E performed once or twice a year, according to need. V17 1.073 0 H Group H Chemical treatments with pre- and post- emergence V18 1.073 0 H herbicides and (mostly glufosinate), insecticides V19 1.073 1 H (mostly against ßavescence dore`e), anti-rot V20 0.663 0 E compounds, sulphur spraying, copper, zinc, V21 0.663 0 E products with esaconazol and copper oxiclorur V22 0.774 0 E sulphate against oidium and rots, carbamate V23 0.774 0 E pesticides and fungicide (different from Mancozeb), mean use of mineral feeds with P, K See Table 2 for details on agricultural practices. and N of 6.5 q/ha. According to SHL values, sites have been assigned to group 0 Agricultural practices reduce dramatically the ground (SHL Ͻ 0.8), group 2 (SHL Ͼ 1.3), or group 1 (in-between values). cover because of the use of herbicides and tilling. B, certiÞed organic production; E, production according to Euro- pean Council Regulation 2092/91; H, intensive production. The environmental characterization of the sampling Materials and Methods sites used for multivariate statistics is based on the Study Area following metrics: Shannon diversity index (Shannon and Weaver 1949) applied to the landscape (SLH), The study area is located in the Langa Astigiana which estimates the evenness of land use categories in (northwest Italy), a zone with a high density of vine- a circle area of 200 m; distance from woods; and mean yards with an annual precipitation of nearly 900 mm. height of the ground cover. We chose 23 sites across Þve areas of Ϸ20 ha each. These are located in the municipalities of Loazzolo, Canelli, Cassinasco, and Costigliole dÕAsti, all of them Spider Sampling belong to the Province of Asti, worldwide known for Following Marc et al. (1999), we used two methods the production of wine. All sampling sites have clay to collect spider assemblages. loam as the prevailing soil texture, a south or south- Pitfall Traps. Pitfall traps of 6.5 cm diameter Þlled west exposure, and roughly the same altitude (250Ð with 20 ml of ethylene glycol 50% were replaced every 350 m a.s.l.) and slope (10Ð15%). The vineyards cho- 3 wk. Sites were randomly selected and sampled in sen for the analysis have a vertical trellis system, the 2003 and 2004. Three samples per year for each of the cultivars are mainly ÔBarberaÕ and ÔMoscatoÕ, and vine 23 selected vineyards were taken from April to July age varies from 8 to 25 yr. Vineyards have been according to Table 3. grouped into three groups (group B, group E, group Hand Collecting in 9-m2 Sample Plots. As suggested H) according to cultural practices (Table 1). Con- by Canard (1981), 9-m2 plots are an optimal choice for cerning agricultural practices, group B is composed of Þeld surveys of hand-collected spider fauna. In our vineyards of certiÞed organic production, group E follows European Council Regulation 2092/91 on bi- ological agriculture, and group H includes intensive Table 3. Sampling design at the 23 vineyards chosen for the analysis farms (see Table 2 for details). With reference to landscape heterogeneity, vineyards are grouped into Collection methods 2003 2004 three groups (group 0, group 1, and group 2) accord- Hand collecting 2 by 23 2 by 23 ing to Shannon index values (SHL) calculated for a (June 21 and July 28) (June 11 and July 30) 200-m-radius circle around the center of each vine- Pitfall traps 3 by 23 3 by 23 yard, deÞned using a geographic information system. (April 27 to May 18 (April 1 to April 21 Shannon indices Ͼ1.3 belong to group 2, Ͻ0.8 to group May 14 to May 27 May 12 to June 2 0, and between values to group 1 (Table 1). June 17 to July 8) June 19 to July 10) April 2006 ISAIA ET AL.: SPIDERS IN ITALIAN VINEYARDS 299 Table 4.