Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas.
Jonathan Keeling1 N. G. Berloff1, P. R. Eastham1, P. B. Littlewood1, F. M. Marchetti2, M. H. Szyma´nska1 1University of Cambridge, 2University of Oxford
July 24th 2007
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton condensation vs W.I.D.B.G
Non-interacting Bose gas
• Three dimensional
• Non-interacting bosons
• Structureless bosons
• Infinite lifetime
• Solved 80 years ago
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 1 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton condensation vs W.I.D.B.G
Non-interacting Bose gas Polariton Condensate
• Three dimensional • Two dimensions
• Non-interacting bosons
• Structureless bosons
• Infinite lifetime
• Solved 80 years ago
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 1 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton condensation vs W.I.D.B.G
Non-interacting Bose gas Polariton Condensate
• Three dimensional • Two dimensions
• Non-interacting bosons • Coulomb/saturation interactions
• Structureless bosons
• Infinite lifetime
• Solved 80 years ago
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 1 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton condensation vs W.I.D.B.G
Non-interacting Bose gas Polariton Condensate
• Three dimensional • Two dimensions
• Non-interacting bosons • Coulomb/saturation interactions
• Structureless bosons • Tc comparable to ΩR, Ry
• Infinite lifetime
• Solved 80 years ago
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 1 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton condensation vs W.I.D.B.G
Non-interacting Bose gas Polariton Condensate
• Three dimensional • Two dimensions
• Non-interacting bosons • Coulomb/saturation interactions
• Structureless bosons • Tc comparable to ΩR, Ry
• Infinite lifetime • Pumped, decaying
• Solved 80 years ago
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 1 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton condensation vs W.I.D.B.G
Non-interacting Bose gas Polariton Condensate
• Three dimensional • Two dimensions
• Non-interacting bosons • Coulomb/saturation interactions
• Structureless bosons • Tc comparable to ΩR, Ry
• Infinite lifetime • Pumped, decaying
• Solved 80 years ago • Open questions remain
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 1 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Overview
• Polariton internal structure
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 2 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Overview
• Polariton internal structure ◦ Polariton blueshift
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 2 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Overview
• Polariton internal structure ◦ Polariton blueshift ◦ Equilibrium phase diagram
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 2 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Overview
• Polariton internal structure ◦ Polariton blueshift ◦ Equilibrium phase diagram
• Pumping and decay
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 2 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Overview
• Polariton internal structure ◦ Polariton blueshift ◦ Equilibrium phase diagram
• Pumping and decay ◦ Relevant energy scales
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 2 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Overview
• Polariton internal structure ◦ Polariton blueshift ◦ Equilibrium phase diagram
• Pumping and decay ◦ Relevant energy scales ◦ Lineshape, linewidth
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 2 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Overview
• Polariton internal structure ◦ Polariton blueshift ◦ Equilibrium phase diagram
• Pumping and decay ◦ Relevant energy scales ◦ Lineshape, linewidth ◦ Density profile
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 2 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Excitons in a disordered Quantum well
Cavity
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 3 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Excitons in a disordered Quantum well
Centre-of-mass wavefunction satisfies:
· 2 ¸ ∇R − + V (R) Φα(R) = ²αΦα(R) Cavity Quantum Wells 2mX
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 3 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Excitons in a disordered Quantum well
Centre-of-mass wavefunction satisfies:
· 2 ¸ ∇R − + V (R) Φα(R) = ²αΦα(R) Cavity Quantum Wells 2mX
V (R) smoothed by exciton Bohr radius
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 3 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Excitons in a disordered Quantum well
Centre-of-mass wavefunction satisfies:
· 2 ¸ ∇R − + V (R) Φα(R) = ²αΦα(R) Cavity Quantum Wells 2mX
V (R) smoothed by exciton Bohr radius
Want distribution of: Energies, ²α
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 3 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Excitons in a disordered Quantum well
Centre-of-mass wavefunction satisfies:
· 2 ¸ ∇R − + V (R) Φα(R) = ²αΦα(R) Cavity Quantum Wells 2mX
V (R) smoothed by exciton Bohr radius
Want distribution of: Energies, ²α Oscillator strengths: gα,p ∝ ψ1s(0)Φα,p
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 3 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Exciton energies and oscillator strengths
DoS(ε) [arb. units] 2 | p=0 α
|g 2 g (ε,0)
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 ε -Ex [meV]
[FMM, JK, MHS, PBL cond-mat/0608096]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 4 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Exciton energies and oscillator strengths
θ[degrees] 0 50 60 70 80 2 ε=p2/2m 1 g2(ε,p) ε DoS( ) 0 [arb. units] 2 [mev] | x -1 p=0 - E α ε
|g 2 g (ε,0) -2 -3 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ε p/105 cm-1 -Ex [meV]
[FMM, JK, MHS, PBL cond-mat/0608096]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 4 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model:
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect)
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions Energy ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect) Position
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions Energy ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect) Position
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions Energy ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect) Position
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions Energy ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect) Position
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions Energy ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect) Position Represent sites as two-level systems (spins):
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions Energy ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect) Position Represent sites as two-level systems (spins):
X † H = ωkψkψk k
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions Energy ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect) Position Represent sites as two-level systems (spins): " # X X † z H = ωkψkψk + ²αSα k α
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Polariton model
• Couple excitons to photons
• Consider exciton-exciton interactions Energy ◦ WIDBG model: Average interaction ◦ Our model: ∗ Strong on-site interaction ∗ Weak inter-site (neglect) Position Represent sites as two-level systems (spins): " # X X X † z 1 + H = ωkψkψk + ²αSα + √ gα,kψkSα + H.c. k α Area k
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 5 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Blueshift
10
1
0.1 Energy [meV] 0.01 threshold mean−field δ =5.3meV, kBTeff=17K 0.001 107 108 109 1010 n [cm−2]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 6 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Blueshift
Clean limit: 10 2 2 δELP 'RyXaXn + ΩRaXn 1
0.1 Energy [meV] 0.01 threshold mean−field δ =5.3meV, kBTeff=17K 0.001 107 108 109 1010 n [cm−2]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 6 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Blueshift
Clean limit: 10 2 2 δELP 'RyXaXn + ΩRaXn 1
0.1 Here: 2 2 ΩRaX → ΩRξ Energy [meV] 0.01 threshold mean−field δ =5.3meV, kBTeff=17K 0.001 107 108 109 1010 n [cm−2]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 6 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Blueshift
Clean limit: 10 2 2 δELP 'RyXaXn + ΩRaXn 1
0.1 Here: 2 2 ΩRaX → ΩRξ Energy [meV] 0.01 threshold mean−field For CdTe, ×100 larger δ =5.3meV, kBTeff=17K 0.001 107 108 109 1010 n [cm−2]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 6 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Blueshift
Clean limit: 10 2 2 δELP 'RyXaXn + ΩRaXn 1
0.1 Here: 2 2 ΩRaX → ΩRξ Energy [meV] 0.01 threshold mean−field For CdTe, ×100 larger δ =5.3meV, kBTeff=17K 0.001 Upper polariton: 107 108 109 1010 n [cm−2] 2 2 δEUP 'RyXaXn − ΩRaXn
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 6 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Phase diagram
40 non-condensed
30 condensed T
B 20 k
10
0 9 9 0 1×10 2×10 n [cm-2]
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 7 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Phase diagram
40 non-condensed 40 30 condensed 30 UP Photon 20 T
B 20 k 10
Energy [meV] Exciton 10 0
-10 LP 0 0 10 20 30 40 0 9 9 1×10 2×10 Angle [degrees] n [cm-2]
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 7 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Phase diagram
40 non-condensed 40 30 condensed 30 100 UP Photon 20 T
B 20 k 10 10
Energy [meV] Exciton 10 0
-10 1 7 8 9 10 LP 10 10 10 10 0 0 10 20 30 40 0 9 9 1×10 2×10 Angle [degrees] n [cm-2]
[JK, FMM, MHS, PBL Semicond. Sci. Technol. 22 R1 (2007)]
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 7 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Pumping and decay; energy scales
Lifetime Thermalisation Polaritons Atoms
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 8 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Pumping and decay; energy scales
Lifetime Thermalisation Polaritons 5ps 0.5ps Atoms
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 8 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Pumping and decay; energy scales
Lifetime Thermalisation Polaritons 5ps 0.5ps Atoms 10s 10ms
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 8 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Pumping and decay; energy scales
Lifetime Thermalisation Linewidth Temperature Polaritons 5ps 0.5ps 0.5meV Atoms 10s 10ms
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 8 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Pumping and decay; energy scales
Lifetime Thermalisation Linewidth Temperature Polaritons 5ps 0.5ps 0.5meV 20K 2meV Atoms 10s 10ms
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 8 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Pumping and decay; energy scales
Lifetime Thermalisation Linewidth Temperature Polaritons 5ps 0.5ps 0.5meV 20K 2meV Atoms 10s 10ms 2.5 × 10−13meV
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 8 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Pumping and decay; energy scales
Lifetime Thermalisation Linewidth Temperature Polaritons 5ps 0.5ps 0.5meV 20K 2meV Atoms 10s 10ms 2.5 × 10−13meV 10−8K 10−9meV
J. Keeling, FOPS, July 2007 8 Polariton condensation, beyond the weakly interacting Bose gas. Pumping and decay; energy scales
Lifetime Thermalisation Linewidth Temperature Polaritons 5ps 0.5ps 0.5meV 20K 2meV Atoms 10s 10ms 2.5 × 10−13meV 10−8K 10−9meV Pumping Bath