Final Thesis MULTICRITERIA ANALYSIS to RELAUNCH SANGRITANA S.P.A. RAILWAYS in the LANCIANO AREA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FACULTY OF CIVIL AND INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING MASTER’S DEGREE IN TRANSPORT SYSTEMS ENGINEERING Final Thesis MULTICRITERIA ANALYSIS TO RELAUNCH SANGRITANA S.p.A. RAILWAYS IN THE LANCIANO AREA SEVKET OGUZ KAGAN CAPKIN Matricola.1784288 Relatore PROF. MARIA VITTORIA CORAZZA A.Y. 2018-2019 Summary ABSTRACT ........................................................................................................................................ 3 BACKGROUND ................................................................................................................................ 4 LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................................... 5 LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................................................. 7 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 8 1. Information about Travel Mode Chosen by The Users .................................................... 8 2. Public Transportation in Italy ............................................................................................ 11 3. Definition of Tram-Train ..................................................................................................... 15 4. Features of the Tram-Train Systems .................................................................................. 17 5. Examples of Tram-Train Services in European Union ................................................... 23 Karlsruhe (Germany) .............................................................................................................. 23 Kassel (Germany) .................................................................................................................... 24 Saarbrucken (Germany) ......................................................................................................... 25 Saint Etienne-Firminy (France) ............................................................................................. 26 Cagliari (Italy) .......................................................................................................................... 27 Sassari (Italy) ............................................................................................................................ 28 6. Light Rail Systems ................................................................................................................ 29 7. CargoTram Systems ............................................................................................................. 32 Cargo-Tram Services in Europe ............................................................................................ 33 8. Environmental Effects of Transportation Services .......................................................... 37 STUDY CASE: LANCIANO TRAM-TRAIN PROJECT............................................................. 41 9. Information about Abruzzo Region (Italy)....................................................................... 41 10. The Geography of the Region ......................................................................................... 42 11. The Study Area ................................................................................................................. 43 12. Railway Network of Abruzzo Region ........................................................................... 44 13. Supply Services of the Abruzzo Region ........................................................................ 45 14. Demand of in the Study Area ......................................................................................... 46 15. Public Transport Patterns in the Study Area ................................................................ 49 The Overall Applications and Potential Directives ............................................................ 49 The Pubic Transport Types .................................................................................................... 51 16. The Environmental Situation of Abruzzo Region ....................................................... 56 1 THE ASSESSMENT APPROACH ................................................................................................ 60 17. Multicriteria Analysis Techniques ................................................................................. 60 Information about Multicriteria Analysis (MCA) .............................................................. 60 Key features of Multicriteria Analysis (MCA) .................................................................... 61 Advantages of MCA related to informal knowledge ........................................................ 62 The Performance Matrix ........................................................................................................ 62 The Weighted Summation Approach .................................................................................. 64 18. Processes of Analysis ....................................................................................................... 66 Economic Situation ................................................................................................................. 66 Social Reactions ....................................................................................................................... 69 Environmental Situation ........................................................................................................ 70 Operational Issue .................................................................................................................... 76 RESULTS .......................................................................................................................................... 78 CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................................ 80 COMMENTS .................................................................................................................................... 81 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................................................... 82 BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................................. 83 2 ABSTRACT MULTICRITERIA ANALYSIS TO RELAUNCH SANGRITANA S.p.A. RAILWAYS IN THE LANCIANO AREA CAPKIN, Sevket Oguz Kagan Transport Systems Engineering Master’s Degree Final Thesis Supervisor: Prof. Maria Vittoria CORAZZA Rome, October 2019 The tram-train system is an innovative, at least for the Italian panorama interoperable public transport system, which allows to bond between urban centers and extra-urban zones, by using a single type of public transport vehicle (tram or LRT) adapted or redesigned to operate both on public transport infrastructure (tram lines or LRT lines) and existing railway lines. This is the case of the dismissed Sangritana railway, now under the preliminary phases of rehabilitation in the Lanciano area, as prospective tram-train service. To assess its feasibility, a multi-criteria analysis is carried out, coherently with the operator’s approach. For the comparison, three different transport modes, which are tram-train; light rail train; and bike service (according to the possible options in the area), are chosen and the analysis is done concerning criteria focused on the assessment of the environmental effects, operational situations, social acceptance, and economical perspective. The four criteria are weighted (environmental effects-35%, operational situations-25%, social reactions-20%, and economical perspective-35%) according to importance levels. Then, the three transport modes are compared, resulting into a best score for the bike service. Light rail train is the second best option and tram-train service is the third one. Key Words: Tram-Train System, Multi-Criteria Analysis, Light Rail Train, Bike Service 3 BACKGROUND The purpose of the study is by answering the following research questions: ▪ What is the tram-train service and its concept? ▪ Which innovative systems have a similar concept to tram-train service? ▪ What are the Multi-criteria Analysis and its procedure? ▪ Can the tram-train service be successfully operational in the Lanciano area, in line with the local operators’ vision? ▪ Which transport mode (comparison of three modes which are tram-train, light rail train, and bike service) is better to implement according to multi- criteria analysis concerning four main criteria which are the economic situation, environmental issue, social effect, an operational issue, to assess the relaunch of the rail supply in the study area? After that, in this study, there are six main parts which are “Introduction, Study Case: Lanciano Tram-Train Project, Technical Approach, Results of Study, Conclusion, and Comments”. First part, which is Introduction, includes the tram-train system’s definition; concepts; features; requirements; existing implemented examples around the European Union, light rail train systems’ definition; features; requirements; examples of implementation around the World, cargo-tram systems and examples around the European Union, and environmental effects of transportation systems. The second part, which is Study Case: Lanciano Tram-Train Project, gives some information about Abruzzo Region (Italy)’s geography, existing