DOCSLIB.ORG

ARNOLD-THESIS-2012.Pdf (2.589Mb)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
ARNOLD-THESIS-2012.Pdf (2.589Mb) Copyright by Timothy Jason Arnold 2012 The Thesis committee for Timothy Jason Arnold Certifies that this is the approved version of the following thesis: THE LIMITS OF STRUCTURAL THEORIES OF REVOLUTION: EGYPT, SCALE, AND TWITTER AS “HISTORY 2” APPROVED BY SUPERVISING COMMITTEE: Co-Supervisor: _____________________________________ Megan Winget Co-Supervisor: _____________________________________ Tarek El-Ariss THE LIMITS OF STRUCTURAL THEORIES OF REVOLUTION: EGYPT, SCALE, AND TWITTER AS “HISTORY 2” by Timothy Jason Arnold, B.A. Thesis Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts and Master of Science in Information Studies The University of Texas at Austin December 2012 Acknowledgements I would not have been able to put this thesis together without the help of many people. I would like to thank my thesis advisors Megan Winget and Tarek El-Ariss. Data collection presented a number of unique obstacles, but not so great that they could not be overcome with the help of Stephen Pipkin, Walker Sampson, Thomas Elliott, and Devin Gaffney. Thank you, Ipsita Chatterjee, Kamran Aghaie, and Benjamin Brower for presenting me with concepts that I could use to navigate my way through this uncharted territory. I would like to give a very special thanks to my research partners Matthew Rafalow and Amber Tierney. Working with you has been an absolute delight. iv Abstract THE LIMITS OF STRUCTURAL THEORIES OF REVOLUTION: EGYPT, SCALE, AND TWITTER AS “HISTORY 2” Timothy Jason Arnold, M.A./M.S.Info.Studs. The University of Texas at Austin, 2012 Co-Supervisors: Megan Winget, Tarek El-Ariss. Through a qualitative analysis of messages posted on the micro-blogging application, Twitter, and qualitative research interviews with people from Egypt and the United States who were active on Twitter during the eighteen day Egyptian Revolution in 2011, this study considers why Dr. Theda Skocpol’s theory of revolution proffered in States and Social Revolutions (1979) does not work in the case of the Egyptian Revolution. Skocpol asserts that a weakening of the state vis-à-vis a dominant class within the state or other states is a necessary precondition for revolution. By examining Twitter as a mechanism through which on-the-ground activists in Egypt were able to circumvent repressive state structures and “jump-scales” to a transnational configuration of resistance, this thesis asserts that emergent technologies complicate Skocpol’s assertion that states must be weakened politically and financially prior to the execution of a successful social revolution. v Table of Contents List of Tables ....................................................................................................... viii List of Figures ........................................................................................................ ix List of Illustrations ...................................................................................................x Introduction ............................................................................................................1 Twitter .....................................................................................................................7 Literature Review ................................................................................................12 REVIEW OF SOCIAL MEDIA LITERATURE ...................................................12 Influence.....................................................................................12 Use ……………………………………………………………14 Information Diffusion................................................................16 Social Change ............................................................................18 Gaps in the Literature ................................................................20 SKOCPOL’S STRUCTURAL THEORY OF REVOLUTION .................................21 CHAKRABARTY’S “HISTORY 1” AND “HISTORY 2” ....................................25 SCALE............................................................................................................30 Methodology .........................................................................................................35 SCRAPING TWEETS .......................................................................................35 USER SELECTION CRITERIA ..........................................................................37 TWEET CODING ............................................................................................39 INTERVIEWS ..................................................................................................39 Findings .................................................................................................................41 COLLECTIVE ACTION ...................................................................................41 CITIZEN REPORTAGE ...................................................................................45 Reports of Censorship .................................................................46 Reports of Corruption .................................................................47 Reports of Complicity .................................................................48 vi Framing through Media ..............................................................48 TRANSNATIONAL SOLIDARITY .....................................................................55 Conclusion ............................................................................................................59 Appendix A Interview Protocol ..........................................................................61 Appendix B Interview Transcripts .....................................................................68 INTERVIEW WITH AHMED AWADALLA ........................................................68 INTERVIEW WITH MAJDA GHADA ...............................................................95 INTERVIEW WITH LANCE FRIZZELL-REYNOLDS ......................................122 Appendix C Code Tree ......................................................................................142 Bibliography .......................................................................................................386 Vita …………………………………………………………………………….392 vii List of Tables Table 1: List of Twitter Symbols........................................................................8 Table 2: List of search terms used for scraping tweets ...................................37 viii List of Figures Figure 1: Interaction on Twitter .........................................................................7 Figure 2: Scale-jumping ...................................................................................33 ix List of Illustrations Illustration 1: Twitter interface ..........................................................................10 Illustration 2: “Mubarak must go!” Provided by @Zenobia. Artist Unknown .50 Illustration 3: “People Should Not Be Afraid of their Governments.” Taken by @RamyRaoof. .............................................................................51 Illustration 4: “Mubarak Went Mad.” Taken by @RamyRaoof ........................52 Illustration 5: “The Blood of the Martyrs is Not Wasted.” Taken by @GSqaure86 .....................................................................................................53 Illustration 6: “Freedom” Cross and Crescent. Taken by @Ssirgany ..............54 Illustration 7: “Who Killed President Sadat? You [Mubarak], you coward?” Taken by @waelabbas ...........................................................................55 x But this much remains correct: modern technology too is a means to an end. That is why the instrumental conception of technology conditions every attempt to bring man into the right relation to technology. Everything depends on our manipulating technology in the proper manner as a means. We will, as we say, “get” technology “spiritually in hand.” We will master it. The will to mastery becomes all the more urgent the more technology threatens to slip from human control. -Martin Heidegger Introduction On 17 December 2010, a man named Mohamed Bouazizi lit himself on fire in front of the governor’s office in a small town named Sidi Bouzid in Tunisia. Bouazizi was a street vendor. His father had died and as the eldest child in a large family, many of the responsibilities of providing for his family fell on him. He had graduated from university with a Bachelor’s degree in Computer Science, but, like many in his generation, he was unable to find a job and the financial need of his family drew him to informal labor. He started selling fruits and vegetables from a small cart on the roadside. Bouazizi was constantly harassed by the police for not having a vendor’s permit. He was forced to go into debt in order to buy his fruits, vegetables, his cart, and his electronic weighing scales however he was unable to make enough money to bribe the police so that they would allow him continue to sell his produce. Bouazizi was unable to pay-off his debts, the police, and make enough money after those obligations to support his family. The final straw came when, on 17 December, he was slapped in the face by a police officer who also confiscated his scales. The story of Bouazizi is not atypical. Across the Middle East, young people are finding that although they have dedicated many years of their lives to education and 1 career-building,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Utrecht University Vernacular Spaces in the Year of Dreams: A
    Utrecht University Research Master’s Thesis Vernacular Spaces in the Year of Dreams: A Comparison Between Occupy Wall Street and the Egyptian Revolution Author: Supervisor: Alex Strete Prof. Dr. Ismee Tames Submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the Research Master’s of History Faculty of Humanities 15th June, 2021 Chapter Outline Table of Contents Introduction: The Global Occupation Movement of 2011 ............................................................. 1 Chapter One: The Vernacular Space as an Ideal Type ................................................................. 11 Chapter Two: “The People” of Tahrir Square .............................................................................. 35 Chapter Three: “The 99%” of Zuccotti Park ................................................................................ 52 Chapter Four: Tahrir Square and Zuccotti Park in Perspective .................................................... 67 Conclusion: Occupy Everything? ................................................................................................. 79 Bibliography ................................................................................................................................. 85 Abstract The year 2011 was a year of dreams. From the revolutionaries in the Arab Spring to the occupiers of Wall Street, people around the world organized in order to find alternative ways of living. However, they did not do so in a vacuum. Protesters were part of the same international
    [Show full text]
  • In May 2011, Freedom House Issued a Press Release Announcing the Findings of a Survey Recording the State of Media Freedom Worldwide
    Media in North Africa: the Case of Egypt 10 Lourdes Pullicino In May 2011, Freedom House issued a press release announcing the findings of a survey recording the state of media freedom worldwide. It reported that the number of people worldwide with access to free and independent media had declined to its lowest level in over a decade.1 The survey recorded a substantial deterioration in the Middle East and North Africa region. In this region, Egypt suffered the greatest set-back, slipping into the Not Free category in 2010 as a result of a severe crackdown preceding the November 2010 parliamentary elections. In Tunisia, traditional media were also censored and tightly controlled by government while internet restriction increased extensively in 2009 and 2010 as Tunisians sought to use it as an alternative field for public debate.2 Furthermore Libya was included in the report as one of the world’s worst ten countries where independent media are considered either non-existent or barely able to operate and where dissent is crushed through imprisonment, torture and other forms of repression.3 The United Nations Development Programme’s (UNDP) Arab Knowledge Report published in 2009 corroborates these findings and view the prospects of a dynamic, free space for freedom of thought and expression in Arab states as particularly dismal. 1 Freedom House, (2011): World Freedom Report, Press Release dated May 2, 2011. The report assessed 196 countries and territories during 2010 and found that only one in six people live in countries with a press that is designated Free. The Freedom of the Press index assesses the degree of print, broadcast and internet freedom in every country, analyzing the events and developments of each calendar year.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 During the Opening Months of 2011, the World Witnessed a Series Of
    FREEDOM HOUSE Freedom on the Net 2012 1 EGYPT 2011 2012 Partly Partly POPULATION: 82 million INTERNET FREEDOM STATUS Free Free INTERNET PENETRATION 2011: 36 percent Obstacles to Access (0-25) 12 14 WEB 2.0 APPLICATIONS BLOCKED: Yes NOTABLE POLITICAL CENSORSHIP: No Limits on Content (0-35) 14 12 BLOGGERS/ ICT USERS ARRESTED: Yes Violations of User Rights (0-40) 28 33 PRESS FREEDOM STATUS: Partly Free Total (0-100) 54 59 * 0=most free, 100=least free NTRODUCTION I During the opening months of 2011, the world witnessed a series of demonstrations that soon toppled Hosni Mubarak’s 30-year presidency. The Egyptian revolution received widespread media coverage during the Arab Spring not only because of Egypt’s position as a main political hub in the Middle East and North Africa, but also because activists were using different forms of media to communicate the events of the movement to the world. While the Egyptian government employed numerous tactics to suppress the uprising’s roots online—including by shutting down internet connectivity, cutting off mobile communications, imprisoning dissenters, blocking media websites, confiscating newspapers, and disrupting satellite signals in a desperate measure to limit media coverage—online dissidents were able to evade government pressure and spread their cause through social- networking websites. This led many to label the Egyptian revolution the Facebook or Twitter Revolution. Since the introduction of the internet in 1993, the Egyptian government has invested in internet infrastructure as part of its strategy to boost the economy and create job opportunities. The Telecommunication Act was passed in 2003 to liberalize the private sector while keeping government supervision and control over information and communication technologies (ICTs) in place.
    [Show full text]
  • Palgrave Studies in Young People and Politics
    Palgrave Studies in Young People and Politics Series Editors James Sloam Department of Politics and International Relations Royal Holloway, University of London Egham, UK Constance Flanagan School of Human Ecology University of Wisconsin–Madison Madison, WI, USA Bronwyn Hayward School of Social and Political Sciences University of Canterbury Christchurch, New Zealand Over the past few decades, many democracies have experienced low or falling voter turnout and a sharp decline in the members of mainstream political parties. These trends are most striking amongst young people, who have become alienated from mainstream electoral politics in many countries across the world. Young people are today faced by a particu- larly tough environment. From worsening levels of child poverty, to large increases in youth unemployment, to cuts in youth services and educa- tion budgets, public policy responses to the fnancial crisis have placed a disproportionate burden on the young. This book series will provide an in-depth investigation of the changing nature of youth civic and political engagement. We particularly welcome contributions looking at: • Youth political participation: for example, voting, demonstrations, and consumer politics • The engagement of young people in civic and political institutions, such as political parties, NGOs and new social movements • The infuence of technology, the news media and social media on young people’s politics • How democratic innovations, such as social institutions, electoral reform, civic education, can rejuvenate democracy • The civic and political development of young people during their transition from childhood to adulthood (political socialisation) • Young people’s diverse civic and political identities, as defned by issues of gender, class and ethnicity • Key themes in public policy affecting younger citizens—e.g.
    [Show full text]
  • Al Jazeera's Expansion: News Media Moments and Growth in Australia
    Al Jazeera’s Expansion: News Media Moments and Growth in Australia PhD thesis by publication, 2017 Scott Bridges Institute of Governance and Policy Analysis University of Canberra ABSTRACT Al Jazeera was launched in 1996 by the government of Qatar as a small terrestrial news channel. In 2016 it is a global media company broadcasting news, sport and entertainment around the world in multiple languages. Devised as an outward- looking news organisation by the small nation’s then new emir, Al Jazeera was, and is, a key part of a larger soft diplomatic and brand-building project — through Al Jazeera, Qatar projects a liberal face to the world and exerts influence in regional and global affairs. Expansion is central to Al Jazeera’s mission as its soft diplomatic goals are only achieved through its audience being put to work on behalf of the state benefactor, much as a commercial broadcaster’s profit is achieved through its audience being put to work on behalf of advertisers. This thesis focuses on Al Jazeera English’s non-conventional expansion into the Australian market, helped along as it was by the channel’s turning point coverage of the 2011 Egyptian protests. This so-called “moment” attracted critical and popular acclaim for the network, especially in markets where there was still widespread suspicion about the Arab network, and it coincided with Al Jazeera’s signing of reciprocal broadcast agreements with the Australian public broadcasters. Through these deals, Al Jazeera has experienced the most success with building a broadcast audience in Australia. After unpacking Al Jazeera English’s Egyptian Revolution “moment”, and problematising the concept, this thesis seeks to formulate a theoretical framework for a news media turning point.
    [Show full text]
  • Egypt: a Repression Made in France Executive Summary
    Egypt: A Repression Made in France Exports of Weapons and Surveillance Technologies June 2018 / N° 716a Cover photo: Sherpa MIDS, photographed in Cairo on April 15, 2016. Table of contents Executive Summary 5 Introduction: The Establishment of a “partenariat privilégié” (Special Partnership) with the Egyptian Security Forces 8 Chapter 1: the consolidation in Egypt of a dictatorship of the security forces since 2013 imposed through unprecedented repression and grave human rights violations 11 1. The establishment of a highly repressive security apparatus that proliferates human rights violations 11 1.1. Strengthened military power 11 1.2. Increasingly powerful intelligence services 12 1.3 Repression of the opposition, civil society and all dissident voices 13 1.4. Repression giving rise to ongoing grave human rights violations 15 Use of lethal force against demonstrators 15 Mass arbitrary arrests 17 Enforced disappearances 17 Torture, abuse and death in prisons 17 Extrajudicial executions 18 Resurgence of the death penalty 18 The countless abuses of the antiterrorist campaign in the Sinai 18 2. At the heart of the repressive measures: widespread surveillance of the population 19 2.1. Digital arms race 19 2.2. From targeted surveillance to mass interception of communications 20 2.3. A totalitarian plan to monitor digital activities 21 2.4. Collecting personal data 23 2.5. Monitoring social networks 23 2.6. Intruding into personal data and monitoring private communications 24 2.7. Surveillance at the origin of grave and repeated human rights violations 25 Fabrication of evidence for use against suspected dissidents 25 Targets of surveillance: opponents, human rights defenders, and LGBTI people 25 Chapter 2: The enormous increase in French exports of surveillance technologies to Egypt: an unconditional partnership in the name of the «fight against terrorism» 27 1.
    [Show full text]
  • A Youtube Call to Action in the Egyptian Revolution
    International Journal of Communication 5 (2011), Feature 1333–1343 1932–8036/2011FEA1333 “I’ll Be Waiting for You Guys”: A YouTube Call to Action in the Egyptian Revolution MELISSSA WALL California State University, Northridge SAHAR EL ZAHED Claremont University In this essay, we consider the ways the YouTube videos of Egyptian youth activist, Asmaa Mafouz, may be contributing to the development of a new political language for Egypt, providing a space to create an individual public political self, and modeling a new form of citizenship and activism for Egyptians. “If you stay home, you deserve all that’s being done to you, and you will be guilty before your nation and your people. Go down to the street, send SMSes, post it on the ‘Net, make people aware.” ~YouTube video of Asmaa Mahfouz, a leader in Egypt’s April 6, 2011 Youth Movement On January 18, 2011, a week before the massive street protests in Cairo’s Tahrir Square, Asmaa Mahfouz, a 26-year-old business graduate of Cairo University, recorded a 4-minute, 36-second video of herself and placed it on her Facebook page, from where it was quickly reposted to YouTube. In classic vlog style, the only image is a close-up of her face, in this case veiled, as she looks directly into the camera, passionately calling in Arabic for her fellow Egyptians to join her in protesting against the government. Despite the Egyptian government’s control of most of the country’s news media, Mahfouz’s video quickly spread among Egypt’s youth, many of whom had turned to social-networking sites as the only consistent arena for free political expression open to them.
    [Show full text]
  • Five Years of Egypt's War on Terror
    FIVE YEARS OF EGYPT’S WAR ON TERROR The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy (TIMEP) is dedicated to influencing policy toward the Middle East and North Africa through rigorous research and targeted advocacy efforts that promote local voices. TIMEP is fully registered and acknowledged under Section501(c)(3) in the District of Columbia. For more information about TIMEP’s mission, programming, or upcoming events, please visit timep.org. This report is the product of the collaborative efforts of TIMEP's staff and fellows. Cover image: A security checkpoint in the Egyptian Western Desert and the Bahariya Oasis in Siwa, Egypt, May 15, 2015 (photo by Amr Abdallah Dalsh for Reuters) CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 4 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5 TERRORISM 5 COUNTER-TERRORISM 10 LEGAL AND POLITICAL CONTEXT 14 FINDINGS 15 TERRORISM 17 ACROSS EGYPT: Intensification and evolution in terror attacks after 2013 17 NORTH SINAI: Violence has become an entrenched insurgency 19 MAINLAND: Low-scale violence gives way to sporadic, deadly attacks 26 COUNTER-TERRORISM 35 ACROSS EGYPT: Tens of thousands of citizens ensnared in the war on terror 35 NORTH SINAI: Continuous military occupation 36 MAINLAND: Sweeping and broad crackdown 39 LEGAL AND POLITICAL CONTEXT 43 LEGAL AND JUDICIAL CONTEXT: The war on terror trumps rule of law 43 DOMESTIC POLITICAL CONTEXT: The war on terror as pretext for political consolidation 46 GEOPOLITICAL CONTEXT: Continued global support 49 FINDINGS 52 METHODOLOGY 54 Egypt Security Watch 3 Five Years of Egypt’s War on Terror INTRODUCTION On July 24, 2013, then-Defense Minister Abdel-Fattah El Sisi asked for a popular mandate to fight terrorism, marking the declaration of the “war on terror” that has lasted five years.
    [Show full text]
  • 2019 Annual General Meeting Speaker Bios
    Last Updated 2/26/19 2019 ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING SPEAKER BIOS Rasha Abdul-Rahim | International Secretariat of Amnesty Tech Rasha Abdul Rahim is Deputy Director of Amnesty Tech and oversees its work on Big Data and artificial intelligence and leads Amnesty’s work on autonomous weapons. Before that, she was a Researcher/Advisor in the Military, Security and Police Team, where she worked on various arms control issues, including the Arms Trade Treaty. Session: Humanity at Risk: Climate Change, Artificial Intelligence & the Future of Human Rights Alireza Azizi | Country Specialist for Amnesty International USA Member of the Middle East Coordination Group of Amnesty International USA, covering Yemen, UAE, and Qatar. He has participated in three research missions to Yemen as part of the AI delegation. He has been a member of AI for over three decades and has served in various positions from local group coordinator to serving on the AIUSA board of directors. He has also participated in several international meetings representing AIUSA. Session: U.S. Arms Sales and the Hidden War in Yemen: Campaign Opportunities Ahead Eduardo Beckett | Immigration Lawyer Eduardo Beckett is a private immigration attorney with Beckett Law Firm, P.C. in El Paso, Texas. Since 2008, he has represented many asylum seekers from around the globe before the El Paso Immigration Court. Before private practice, he was the managing attorney at Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center, a non-profit dedicated to immigrant defense in El Paso. Session: Campaign Plenary – Families Belong Together and Free: Supporting Refugee Families in This Time of Crisis Simon Billonness | Co-chair of the AIUSA Business and Human Rights Group Described by the New York Times as “a super-specialist” in human rights advocacy, Simon Billenness serves as co-chair of the AIUSA Business and Human Rights Group (BHRG), where he helps develop and implement AI’s strategies to hold corporations accountable.
    [Show full text]
  • Egypt Looks to Monitor Popular Social Media Users 28 June 2018, by Bassem Aboualabass and Aziz El Massassi
    Egypt looks to monitor popular social media users 28 June 2018, by Bassem Aboualabass And Aziz El Massassi and television programmes accused of violating public morals, would oversee "every personal website, blog or electronic account of any person with 5,000 followers or more". It would also have the right to suspend or block such accounts if they "publish or broadcast false news" or information inciting "breaking the law, violence or hatred". "Every citizen will think 1,000 times before they can write a post in which they criticise the action of the government or the regime," said Mohamed Abdelsalam, director of research at AFTE. Under the bill, internet users with at least 5,000 followers He urged social media companies to "reject the would be placed under the supervision of Egypt's Supreme Council for Media Regulation practices of the Egyptian government and stand on the side of the rights (of citizens) and civil society organisations". Freedom of expression may shrink further in Egypt Waves of arrests where lawmakers have approved the first reading of a bill that would monitor popular social media In another move in early June, lawmakers passed a users in the name of combating "false news". law on cyber-crime that allows authorities to block any website or account that threatens Egypt's Platforms such as Twitter and Facebook have national security or economy. become one of the last forums for public debate in Egypt since a November 2013 ban on all but police- Those who administer such websites face jail time approved gatherings. or fines.
    [Show full text]
  • The Army and the People Wasn't Ever One Hand
    The army and the people wasn’t ever one hand Activists tortured and Killed by the Army, Even after Mubarak’s resigning (A study supported with documents) 08 MARCH 2011 http://www.maikelnabil.com/2011/03/army-and-people-wasnt-ever-one-hand.html Is The Egyptian Army Standing Beside the Revolution? On the 11th of February 2011, after the President’s stepping down speech that was delivered by Omar Suliman (Vice-President of the Republic, and the former head of the Egyptian intelligence), many Egyptian powers rushed into declaring the victory and the end of the revolution…. I regret having to say the following, mostly because that many of them are my friends, but the people have the right to know the truth… Some of them wanted to take advantage of the presence of the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces to get some political positions by making deals with the Supreme council. They knew that they cannot achieve such positions through regular democratic process…. And some of them had connections with the secret service before the revolution was declared and supported the secret service institution per default (I don’t want to describe them as Secret Service’s agents) and some others thought that the army was not a part of the July Military Regime!!! And therefore was misled by the Army declarations (Press Releases) and have accepted the Army’s role in the transitional Phase. In fact the revolution has so far managed to get rid of the dictator but not of the dictatorship. A broad sector of Egyptian political Elite and rebels share this same vision with me.
    [Show full text]
  • Putting the Genie Back in the Bottle: Ruling Regimes and the New Media in the Arab World
    D e c e m b e r 2 0 0 8 A N A L Y S I S DAVID HARDAKER Putting the Genie Back in Tel: +61 2 9427 7959 Mob: 0424 033 700 the Bottle: Ruling david@middleeastgulfconnection. com.au Regimes and the New Media in the Arab World E x e c u t i v e s u m m a r y The rapid growth of satellite television and the internet has shaken Arab governments’ traditional control over the media. This development has given unprecedented power to voices of dissent, both secular and religious. It has enabled popular participation in public debate and has given citizens the ability to mobilise mass protests. In the face of this threat to their authority, regimes have typically responded with heightened repression and censorship, in the name of stability. In some cases they have also attempted to co-opt the new media to their own advantage. However, Arab regimes are faced with competing demands: one the one hand they must ensure the take-up of communication technologies so as to keep pace with global change, but on the other hand they must limit the use of these technologies as a means of undermining regime control. In the long term, resolving this tension will only become more difficult; the genie is well and truly out of the bottle. LOWY INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL POLICY 31 Bligh Street Sydney NSW 2000 Tel: +61 2 8238 9000 Fax: +61 2 8238 9005 www.lowyinstitute.org = qÜÉ=içïó=fåëíáíìíÉ=Ñçê=fåíÉêå~íáçå~ä=mçäáÅó=áë=~å=áåÇÉéÉåÇÉåí=áåíÉêå~íáçå~ä=éçäáÅó=íÜáåâ=í~åâ= Ä~ëÉÇ=áå=póÇåÉóI=^ìëíê~äá~K==fíë=ã~åÇ~íÉ=ê~åÖÉë=~Åêçëë=~ää=íÜÉ=ÇáãÉåëáçåë=çÑ=áåíÉêå~íáçå~ä=éçäáÅó= ÇÉÄ~íÉ=áå=^ìëíê~äá~=Ô=ÉÅçåçãáÅI=éçäáíáÅ~ä=~åÇ=ëíê~íÉÖáÅ=Ô=~åÇ=áí=áë=åçí=äáãáíÉÇ=íç=~=é~êíáÅìä~ê=
    [Show full text]