Subsidence, Sea Level Rise, and Seismicity in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UC Davis San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science Title Subsidence, Sea Level Rise, and Seismicity in the Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/4k44725p Journal San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science, 3(1) ISSN 1546-2366 Authors Mount, Jeffrey Twiss, Robert Publication Date 2005 DOI https://10.15447/sfews.2005v3iss1art7 License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ 4.0 Peer reviewed eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California MARCH 2005 Subsidence, Sea Level Rise, and Seismicity in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Jeffrey Mount University of California, Davis [email protected] Robert Twiss University of California, Berkeley ABSTRACT years demonstrating regional increases in the potential for island flooding. Based on continuing increases in Anthropogenic accommodation space, or that space in the Levee Force Index and the Accommodation Space the Delta that lies below sea level and is filled neither Index, and limited support for Delta levee upgrades, with sediment nor water, serves as a useful measure of there will be a tendency for increases in and impacts the regional consequences of Delta subsidence and sea of island flooding, with escalating costs for repairs. level rise. Microbial oxidation and compaction of Additionally, there is a two-in-three chance that 100- organic-rich soils due to farming activity is the pri- year recurrence interval floods or earthquakes will mary cause of Delta subsidence. During the period cause catastrophic flooding and significant change in 1900-2000, subsidence created approximately 2.5 bil- the Delta by 2050. Currently, the California Bay-Delta lion cubic meters of anthropogenic accommodation Authority has no overarching policy that addresses the space in the Delta. From 2000-2050, subsidence rates consequences of, and potential responses to, gradual or will slow due to depletion of organic material and bet- abrupt landscape change in the Delta. ter land use practices. However, by 2050 the Delta will contain more than 3 billion cubic meters of anthro- pogenic accommodation space due to continued subsi- KEYWORDS dence and sea level rise. An Accommodation Space Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, subsidence, levee Index, which relates subaqueous accommodation space integrity, seismicity, accommodation space, to anthropogenic accommodation space, provides an levee failure indicator of past and projected Delta conditions. While subsidence and sea level rise create increasing anthro- pogenic accommodation space in the Delta, they also SUGGESTED CITATION lead to a regional increase in the forces that can cause Mount J, Twiss R. 2005. Subsidence, sea level rise, levee failure. Although these forces take many forms, a seismicity in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta. Levee Force Index can be calculated that is a proxy for San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science. the cumulative forces acting on levees. The Levee Vol. 3, Issue 1 (March 2005), Article 5. Force Index increases significantly over the next 50 http://repositories.cdlib.org/jmie/sfews/vol3/iss1/art5 SAN FRANCISCO ESTUARY & WATERSHED SCIENCE INTRODUCTION1 The CALFED Bay-Delta Program (CALFED) is an outcome of a 1994 agreement among agencies and environmental and water user stake- holders (the so-called “Delta Accord”) that was intended to pro- vide interim environmental guide- lines while CALFED worked with the agencies and stakeholders to develop a long-term solution to environmen- tal and water supply problems in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta (Delta). The Delta provides at least a portion of the water supply for about two-thirds of California’s pop- ulation, and provides a migratory pathway for four fish that are listed as endangered or threatened pur- suant to the federal Endangered Species Act. Two of the overriding CALFED goals are to maintain the reliability of water supplies from the Delta and to restore the Delta ecosystem and that of its watershed. More information about the CALFED Program can be found at http://calwater.ca.gov/. Figure 1. Generalized map of subsided portion of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta indicating regions discussed in text. The hydraulic integrity of the locally more than 8 m below mean sea level Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta is maintained by more (Ingebritsen et al. 2000). Island subsidence has than 1700 km of levees, most of which are privately reduced the stability of Delta levees, increasing the owned and maintained (DWR 1995). Microbial oxida- risk of failure (DWR 1986, 1989). Embankment and tion and consolidation of organic-rich soils on Delta foundation materials for most Delta levees are sub- islands is causing widespread subsidence (Figure 1), standard, adding the risk of failure during seismic with island elevations in the west and central Delta events (Torres et al. 2000). It is generally acknowl- 1. The following article is the first in our new category, Policy and Program edged that the current channel network of the Delta Analyses. The paper itself has been adapted from a report the authors sub- and the hydraulic disconnection between islands and mitted to the Independent Science Board, a standing panel of distinguished surrounding channels is necessary for meeting water scientists and engineers convened to help the CALFED Bay-Delta Authority (Authority) establish an independent and objective view of the science issues quality standards at the south Delta pumping plants underlying important policy decisions. The authors are members of the that support the Central Valley Project, State Water Independent Science Board. Project and Contra Costa Water District (NHI 1998; The Authority itself arose out of a 1994 accord among federal and state agen- CALFED 2000). CALFED (2000) and the California cies and stakeholders designed to improve the reliability of water supplies Department of Water Resources (DWR 1986, 1989, diverted from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta and to restore the health of the San Francisco Estuary and its watershed. The Authority is charged with 1995) have noted that failure of the levees and the meeting the water supply and ecosystem goals. More details about Authority flooding of subsided islands, particularly during the goals and programs can be found at http://calwater.ca.gov/ MARCH 2005 spring and summer months, has the potential to signif- production of organic sediment within the Delta, and icantly degrade Delta water quality by (1) drawing the export of sediment to the San Francisco Bay. A brackish water into the Delta during rapid flooding of preserved stratigraphic record of intertidal conditions Delta islands and (2) changing the dynamics of the indicates that regional tectonic subsidence and sea tidal prism in the west Delta. Additionally, CALFED’s level rise were sufficient to allow net accumulation of Ecosystem Restoration Program (CALFED 2004) has sediment in the Delta during that time (Atwater et al. concluded that subsided islands and deeply flooded 1979; Atwater and Belknap 1980; Orr et al. 2003). This islands provide poor quality habitat for native aquatic record reflects the long-term formation of accommo- plant and animal communities, and are generally dation space, or space that is available for the accu- viewed as undesirable. mulation and preservation of deposited sediment. The concept of accommodation space is well-established With the exception of recognizing the impacts of pop- within the geologic literature and forms the underpin- ulation growth and increased water demand, federal nings of modern concepts of depositional sequence and state programs that seek to improve water quality, stratigraphy (Emery and Meyers 1996). water supply reliability, and ecosystem health in the Delta are predicated upon maintaining the existing In estuarine settings like the Sacramento-San Joaquin levee and channel network. We found no comprehen- Delta, the formation and destruction of accommoda- sive CALFED plan or policy that addresses response to tion space controls the distribution and character of gradual or abrupt changes in hydrologic, geomorphic, sediment deposition and related environmental condi- geotechnical and cultural factors that influence levee tions at large scales. For any given interval of time, integrity. In this report we present low-resolution sim- accommodation space is created by eustatic (global) ulations of potential changes in Delta levee integrity sea level rise and subsidence of the bed, typically asso- through 2050. These simulations assume business-as- ciated with sediment compaction and tectonic subsi- usual approaches to management of the Delta, princi- dence of the crust. The eustatic rise (or fall) of sea level and the rate of subsidence control the rate at pally for agriculture. Continued island subsidence, which accommodation space is either created or, in the coupled with eustatic rise in sea level, will threaten case of falling sea level or crustal uplift, lost. In inter- levee stability significantly by 2050, leading to tidal systems, accommodation space is filled with increased potential for island flooding. Additionally, it water and sediment. is likely that a seismic event or regional flood will impact the levee network of the Delta. Landscape Where rates of organic and inorganic sediment deposi- change, whether gradual or abrupt, will affect CALFED tion keep pace with accommodation space formation, programs in the San Francisco Bay, Sacramento-San intertidal conditions persist; where rates of accommo- Joaquin Delta, and the watershed,