Integrated Production of Algal Biomass
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INTEGRATED PRODUCTION OF ALGAL BIOMASS By Alessandro Marco Lizzul A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for graduation of an Engineering Doctorate (EngD). From the Department of Civil, Environmental and Geomatic Engineering, Centre for Urban Sustainability and Resilience. Academic Supervisors: Dr Luiza Campos, Dr Saul Purton, Dr Frank Baganz Industrial Supervisor: Mr Joe McDonald UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON SEPTEMBER 2015 Declaration of Authorship I, Alessandro Marco Lizzul declare that this thesis and the work presented within are my own, generated as the result of original research. Likewise, I can confirm that this work was done wholly while in candidature for a research degree at University College London. Any reference or quotation from the published work of others is always clearly attributed. I have also gone to great lengths to acknowledge all sources of assistance during the project. This includes contributions from work done in collaboration with others, which are stated in the contributions section. Due to the industrial relevance of this project care has been taken to ensure that none of the proprietary intellectual property of the involved parties has been plagiarised or misrepresented. Some sections within this thesis have already undergone publication and are declared as such in the publications section. Signed…………………………………………………… ALESSANDRO MARCO LIZZUL Date……………………………………………………… 2 Publications A.M. Lizzul, P. Hellier, S. Purton, F. Baganz, N. Ladommatos, L. Campos (2013). Combined remediation and lipid production using Chlorella sorokiniana grown on wastewater and exhaust gases. Bioresource Technology. 151:12-18. K. Koutita, A.M. Lizzul, L. Campos, N. Rai, T. Smith, J. Stegemann (2015). A Theoretical Fluid Dynamic Model for Estimation of the Hold-up and Liquid Velocity in an External Loop Airlift Bioreactor. International Journal of Applied Science and Technology, 5, 1-29. A. M. Lizzul, M. Allen (Article in Press). Book Chapter. Algal Cultivation Technologies. Biofuels and Bioenergy. Wiley-Blackwell. Acknowledgements In the first instance I would like to acknowledge the financial support received from the engineering and physical sciences research council (EPSRC) in providing provision for the urban sustainability and resilience (USAR) EngD centre alongside my doctoral project. I would also like to thank the generous support of University College London, Varicon Aqua Solutions and the Royal Commission for the Exhibition of 1851, without whom the full scope of my project would have been largely unrealised. The considerable support, guidance and financial assistance I have received from my academic supervisors were of particular importance to the completion of this thesis. I owe a debt of gratitude to Dr Luiza Campos who has given me considerable academic freedom during the undertaking of this project, allowing me to better develop my own research ideas and themes. Secondly, I would like to thank Dr Saul Purton and Dr Frank Baganz who as second and third supervisors respectively, have provided me with extensive theoretical and practical insight into the applied aspects of algal cultivation. I would also like to thank my industrial supervisor Mr Joe McDonald (Varicon Aqua Solutions) for his guidance, both in 3 terms of my personal development and with regards to his significant expertise in applied phycology and photobioreactor design. Furthermore, a special thank you goes to my long term collaborators; Dr Paul Hellier, with whom I undertook considerable work growing algae from waste, as well as co-authoring my first research paper. I must also take the opportunity to thank Konstantina Koutita whose considerable expertise in fluid dynamic and biological modelling made for an excellent collaboration during the course of my research, and allowed for the co-authoring of a second research paper. Finally, the assistance and collaboration with Richard Beckett of The Bartlett deserves a particular mention, as it offered a different perspective on my research, as well as generating some of the technical illustrations used within the thesis. I must also thank the army of students who have worked on various aspects of the project at different times, both for the input, headache and joy they generated. In chronological order of involvement that includes; Gregory Nordberg, Yasmine Nazmy, Hugo Averalo-Bacon, Xin Jin, Hayder Al Emera, Brendan O’Connor, Matthew Kaczmarczyk, Aitor Lekuona, Eric Dai, Yidong Chen and Peter Sinner. A very special mention has to go to Aitor Lekuona and Peter Sinner, who as visiting research students contributed greatly to many aspects of the practical work during their internships at UCL. This included work with Haematococcus pluvialis at various scales, microscale platform development, measurements for reactor modelling, as well as membrane reactor testing. It has to be said that without the involvement of all of these students the project would have undoubtedly been more constrained in its scope. Finally, a special thank you has to go to all the other members of Algae@UCL, for their help with day to day laboratory activities, queries, equipment and the sharing of practical techniques. I would also like to acknowledge the advice and technical support received by the Environmental Engineering technicians Ian Sturtevant, Ian Seaton, Catherine Unsworth and Dr Judith Zho. Furthermore, I would like to thank Dr Cecile Standford (Southern Water) and Rokiah Yaman (Community By Design) for supplying suitable wastewaters for parts of the project. Last and most importantly of all, I would like to thank my friends, family and girlfriend; Stacey Joanne Hemmings. All of whom have put up with me and my algal obsession over the five years it has taken me to complete my doctorate. 4 Contributions Chapter 1 - Introduction written by A. M. Lizzul, using some sections of re-worked material from previous submissions within his MRes and EngD programme. Chapter 2 - Background written by A. M. Lizzul, using some re-written material from his MRes report as part of the EngD programme. Chapter 3 - Written by A M. Lizzul. Chapter 4 - Microscale work planned and directed by A. M. Lizzul and undertaken with the assistance of P. Sinner. Chapter 5 - Growth of Chlorella sorokiniana on waste; Material submitted for publication in Bioresource Technology (Lizzul et al. 2014). Biological growth experiments and wastewater quantification undertaken by A. M. Lizzul, with gas analysis undertaken by Dr P. Hellier, Department of Mechanical Engineering. Chapter 6 - Chapter contains several excerpts from the book Chapter ‘Algal Cultivation Technologies,’ written by A. M. Lizzul and supervised by M. Allen (PML) (Lizzul and Allen 2015). Chapter 7 - Experimentation, data collection and original reactor modelling undertaken by A. M. Lizzul. Further novel model development undertaken by K. Koutita, and summarised in Appendix 10.1.4.1 and 10.1.5.2 (K. Koutita 2015). Subsequent validation experiments undertaken by A. M. Lizzul with assistance from A. Lekuona, P. Sinner and Y. Chen. Chapter 8 - Cost model developed by A. M. Lizzul in collaboration with E. Dai, under supervision of S. Balboni (ME, UCL), using literature values and experimental data from A. M. Lizzul. Chapter 9 - Written by A. M. Lizzul. Chapter 10 - Written by A. M. Lizzul. 5 The Engineering Doctorate (EngD) A Note The Engineering doctorate (EngD) is a postgraduate qualification scheme initiated in 1992 and is supported by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC). The programme is split between a Masters of Research (MRes) component in the first year and a three year doctoral component. It is similar in many respects to a PhD, except for the added requirement for an industrial sponsor and a component consisting of taught modules. The fundamental purpose of an EngD is to undertake research that is of PhD standard but with greater industrial relevance to the sponsoring company. In this respect an EngD may differ somewhat from a traditional PhD, with the research usually found to be more application orientated. In practice this means that many EngD projects will give particular consideration to factors and findings that would add commercial advantage to a sponsoring company. Industrial Sponsor The project was initiated by Battle McCarthy (Ltd), an architectural design consultancy based in London. As a result the original aims of the project were orientated more towards the built environment, and included the development of a suitable photobioreactor for use as a building façade. Litigation with UCL resulted in the sponsorship being rescinded, and a new sponsor was sought out. After a period of undertaking research with no industrial sponsor, the current industrial partnership with Varicon Aqua Solutions (Ltd) was initiated, with Mr Joe McDonald (Managing Director) taking the role of industrial supervisor. Varicon Aqua Solutions is an original equipment manufacturer based in the UK. They have over 20 years' experience in the design, construction and deployment of algal photobioreactors and aquaculture production systems. A major part of their business is the supply, installation and commissioning of both laboratory and industrial platforms for the cultivation of algae to a broad range of global partners. To date they have deployed over 120 photobioreactor systems across the world. These installations include horizontal tubular systems such as the BioFence™ platform, as well as serpentine systems such as the Phyco-Flow™, and an internally illuminated