History, Anthropology and the Study of Communities: Some Problems in Macfarlane's Proposal

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

History, Anthropology and the Study of Communities: Some Problems in Macfarlane's Proposal C. J. Calhoun History, anthropology and the study of communities: some problems in Macfarlanes proposal' In a recent paper, Alan Macfarlane advertises a new approach to the study of communities in which 'a combination of the anthropological techniques and the historical material could be extremely fruitful'.2 Unfortunately, he fails to make clear just what the approach he advocates is, and with what problems and phenomena it is intended to deal. He thus exacerbates rather than solves the methodological and conceptual problems which face social historians who would study community. The present paper is primarily polemical in intention. It is in agreement that community can be the object of coherent and productive study by historians and social scientists, working together and/or drawing on the products of each other's labours. It argues, however, that Macfarlane's conceptual apparatus is seriously problematic, and does not constitute a coherent approach. I have outlined elsewhere what I consider to be such a coherent approach.3 It makes community a comparative and historical variable. Macfarlane dismisses the concept as meaningless at the beginning of his paper, but then finds it necessary to reintroduce it in quotation marks in the latter part - without ever defining it. He introduces several potentially useful anthropological concepts, but vitiates their value by both a misleading treatment and the implication that they are replacements for, rather than supplements to, the concept of community. In the following I attempt to give a more accurate background to and interpretation of these concepts, and to correct several logical and methodological errors in Macfarlane's presentation. The various concepts and techniques which he proposes can indeed be meaningful and useful, but require greater attention to level of analysis and theoretical context. I suggest, finally, that the concept of community has not been 'superceded' because it does refer to something we do want to understand. l This paper was written while the author was in have actually had a much longer history of inter- residence at St Antony's College, Oxford, where he relationship than Macfarlane seems to realize, from had the benefit of numerous conversations on its the disciplinary origins of the former, through Evans- subject matter and especially the detailed comments Pritchard among others, to the creation of the 'new of Thomas Laqueur, which he gratefully social history'. acknowledges. 3 See Calhoun in Bibliography. 2 Macfarlane (1977), 637. Anthropology and history 363 364 Social History VOL 3: NO 3 Macfarlanetreats conceptsas holes in the groundto be filled in with data. In the first place, he does not distinguishbetween concepts and propositions.In the secondplace, he does not distinguish between the analytic use of concepts in tackling particular problems,and the mere discoverythat there are data to which a given conceptcan be applied. The result is that, in Macfarlane'sview, historiansare the possessorsof great banks of 'information' and 'material' over which they preside while waiting for 'sociologicalquestions' and 'anthropologicaltechniques'.' The programmewhich he advocatestransgresses the reasonablelimits of naivety5in the borrowingof tools from anotheracademic discipline. It involvesconcepts torn from their theoreticalmoorings, so that they do not even providea coherentlanguage, let alonea majorhelp in analysis. This is largelybecause of two relatederrors, one methodological,one strictlylogical. The logicalerror is the fallaciousassumption that namingis the same as explaining. Thus Macfarlanesuggests a programmeof takingconcepts and then findingdata to fit them. At one point he takes up the concept of the 'action-set'and tells us happilythat Englishcourt records are full of 'case studies',so that' everybaptism, marriage and burial where severalnames are given will give one a fragmentaryaction-set, just as each land transfer, will, or deed likewise does so'.6 Given that most concepts can find some applicationanywhere, this tells us very little. Macfarlanedoes not indicateany problems which the finding of action-setsin court recordswill help us to solve. We are simply told to find action-sets- when we ought to be told to differentiateamong them - find their characteristicform in socialorder, discover how they workor analyseone or more to understandsome importantevent. Macfarlaneis more concerned,however, that we use historicalmaterial 'to test and refinesociological concepts'.7 This is nonsensical,a category mistake. The only way in which concepts can conceivablybe tested is pragmatically;we may evaluatetheir performance in the solutionof particularproblems, the analysisof particularsituations. The methodologicalerror is the neglect of the importanceof asking questions, as opposed to merely proliferatinga method. Macfarlaneproposes, however erratically, a set of tools for historicalresearch. He wishesto select the 'best' fromamong these tools, but he does not considerthat such an evaluationis dependenton application.In other words, a workmanmust select his tools with some task in mind. The way in whichthe historian and/or social scientist chooses and formulates his problems is thus of fundamentalimportance. How he will do so is in largepart the productof the theoretical approachwith which he works, either implicitlyor explicitly.When there is no theory to orderthe selectionand formulationof problems(not to mentiontheir solution), the result is not pure empiricismbut chaos.8Theory is necessaryto provideorder to any 4 Macfarlane(1977), 637, 641- assumptions. None the less, very little of even I Devons and Gluckman (1964). self-proclaimed empiricist history could be done f Macfarlane(0977), 637. without some implicit or ad hocassumptions about the ' Macfarlane (1977), 640. way in which people behave, the nature of social 8 Chronologymay be used to lend a minimal bonds, etc. structurewithout implyingtoo much in the way of OctoberI978 History, anthropology and communities 365 research,and to enableit to penetratebeneath the surfaceof 'facticity'. It providesfor a systematicdefinition of the elementsunder analysis, and a consistenttreatment of their connectionsto eachother. It encapsulatesthe resultsof comparisonsin propositionsabout the connectionsof its elements.Although it must rest on unprovenassumptions, it allows for the testing of propositionswithin its assumptions.An agglomerationof definitions, no matterhow huge, does not makea theory. And conceptswithin a theorytake their meaning, and their utility, not just from formaldefinitions but from their relationship to the theory as a whole. Macfarlaneneglects theory in all the aspectswe have listed. Further, he lifts concepts out of theoreticalcontexts without care even for their relationshipswith each other. Conceptsare designedto aid in analysis,not to substitutefor analysis.Macfarlane in the courseof his papertosses them out by the handful.At one point, he lists four from a commonlineage: 'social drama,case study, quasi-groupand action-set',but does not notice that these are of differentorders.9 The firsttwo describeanalytic procedures, the second two refer to constituentelements. Greaterattention to the context from which the conceptswere borrowedcould have helpedMacfarlane to avoid this confusion.The four conceptslisted abovecome from a relativelyunified approach to problemsof social continuityand change. They are ratherless new, less settled, and less exclusivethan Macfarlanesuggests. The developers of these concepts were seeking solutions to theoretical,methodological and empiricalproblems. Max Gluckmanwas 'pater' to this family of innovators.10The approachwhich he pioneeredin anthropologywas that of identifyingand analysingkey social situationsin orderto understandbetter the overall social order and the directionof its change.11The new approachwas intendedto deal with a numberof problems,many of whichstemmed from structural-functionalist theory. Among these was the tendencyto minimizeconflict, assuming that particularstrife was integratedat a more inclusive level or over a longer duration.The possibilityof both structuralcontradictions and structuralchange due to internalstruggles was neglected. Equilibriumwas assumedto be self-regulating,rather than regulated through the agency of membersof the society. Furthermore,the attentionto functionalintegration meant that the society was treatedas relativelystatic.12 9 Macfarlane ( 1977), 637. (1956). 10 The family is commonly referredto as the 12 Others had certainlyrealized the static impli- 'Manchesterschool'. It includesthe largenumber of cations of structural-functionalanalysis. Radcliffe- anthropologistswho either studied with or were Brownsuggested it as a replacementfor conjectural closely influencedby Gluckmanand his colleagues. history,but as complement,not alternative,to sound The broadly senior generation includes, among historicalargument (the pointis madein manyplaces; others,Turner, Mitchell, Barnes, Colson, Cunnison, the openingpages of his ir4i presidentialaddress are Epstein,Marwick, Worsley, Van Velson, Watson and among the clearest). By the 140os a number of Kapferer. Almost all the group did fieldworkin criticismshad been levelledat the extremefunction- centraland/or southern Africa. Lusaka,because of alism of Malinowski,including several by leading the Rhodes-LivingstonInstitute (now Institute of anthropologistswho were in later yearsto be tarred AfricanStudies in the Universityof Zambia)was with the same brush: Evans-Pritchard,Fortes,
Recommended publications
  • 01 Young JOHN ARUNDEL B
    Vol. 29, Complimentary special issue, 2011 Communications to the authors should be addressed to them c/o Cambridge Anthropologtj, in memory of John Barnes Department of Social Anthropology, Free School Lane, Cambridge CB23RF. CONTENTS Articles: Introduction Susan Drucker-Brown 1 John Arundel Barnes (1918 - 2010) EDITORS: Michael Young 4 Susan Drucker-Brown John Barnes - an appreciation Geoffrey Hawthorn Paul Henley 13 Retrait Lignager - some thoughts on an old European familial Production assistant: Bobbie Coe institution Ray Abrahams 16 The snowball state and the perils of oblivion Harri Englund 30 Across the fields: John Barnes in Cambridge Geoffrey Hawthorn 35 IT Sociology in Cambridge: an inaugural lecture J.A. Barnes 45 Cambridge Anthropalagt): Cumulative Index 61 ISSN 0305-7674 4 John Arundel Barnes (1918 - 2010) 5 Medal (1959); he was a Fellow of Churchill College, Cambridge, and an JOHN ARUNDEL BARNES (1918 - 2010)1 Honorary Life Member of the Australian Anthropology Society. The son of a piano-tuner, John Barnes was born in Reading, Berkshire, into what he called 'a lower middle class kin network'. He MICHAEL YOUNG won a scholarship to Christ's Hospital (a public school founded by Edward VI in 1552), and went up to Cambridge on a St John's College scholarship to do the Mathematics Tripos, taking courses in anthropology during his final year and graduating with a B.A. in 1939. Humping my drum, modesty subtitled 'a memoir' in lowercase, which He joked about his choice of anthropology as an option: it was John Barnes wrote towards the end of his long and well-travelled life, is advertised as explaining the meaning of civilisation and the origin of an engaging ramble up and down the years, from his birth in Reading, culture; he thought he would like to find out about that, 'but I never did' Berkshire, to his encroaching blindness in 2007 in a Cambridgeshire (Hiatt 1996: 4-15).
    [Show full text]
  • UC San Diego Electronic Theses and Dissertations
    UC San Diego UC San Diego Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title Ambitious obligations : Pentecostalism, social life, and political economy on the Zambian Copperbelt Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/7jt6190j Author Haynes, Naomi Publication Date 2012 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO Ambitious Obligations: Pentecostalism, Social Life, and Political Economy on the Zambian Copperbelt A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Anthropology by Naomi Haynes Committee in charge: Professor Joel Robbins, Chair Professor Suzanne Brenner Professor Robert Cancel Professor Thomas Csordas Professor Jeremy Prestholdt Professor Rijk van Dijk 2012 The dissertation of Naomi Haynes is approved, and it is acceptable in quality and form for publication on microfilm and electronically: ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Chair University of California, San Diego 2012 iii ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Copyright Naomi Haynes,
    [Show full text]
  • European Bulletin of Himalayan Research (EBHR)
    20-1 2001 Double issue EBHR european Bulletin of Himalayan Research The European Bulletin of Himalayan Research is the product of collaboration between academics and researchers with an interest in the Himalayan region in several European countries. It was founded by the late Professor Richard Burghart in 1991 and has appeared twice yearly ever since. It is edited on a rotating basis between Germany, France and the UK. The British editors are: Michael Hutt (Managing Editor), David Gellner, Will Douglas, Ben Campbell (Reviews Editor), Christian McDonaugh, Joanne Moller, Maria Phylactou, Andrew Russell and Surya Subedi. Email: [email protected] Contributing editors are: France: Marie Lecomte-Tilouine, Pascale Dolfus, Anne de Sales Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, UPR 299 7, rue Guy Moquet F-94801 Villejuif cedex email: [email protected] Germany: Martin Gaenszle, Andras Höfer Südasien Institut Universität Heidelberg Im Neuenheimer Feld 330 D-69120 Heidelberg email: [email protected] Switzerland: Joanna Pfaff-Czarnecka Ethnologisches Seminar der Universität Zurich Freienstraße 5 CH-8032 Zurich email: [email protected] For subscription information, please consult the EBHR website at dakini.orient.ox.ac.uk/ebhr or contact the publishers directly: Publications Office School of Oriental and African Studies Thornhaugh Street, Russell Square London WC1H 0XG Fax: +44 (0) 20 7962 1577 email: [email protected] ebhr SOAS • London CNRS • Paris SAI • HEIdelberg ISSN 0943 8254 EBHR 20-1 • 2001 Double issue ARTICLES Life-Journeys: Rai ritual healers’ narratives on their callings Martin Gaenszle 9 The Construction of Personhood: Two life stories from Garhwal Antje Linkenbach 23 Protecting the Treasures of the Earth: Nominating Dolpo as a World Heritage site Terence Hay-Edie 46 On the Relationship Between Folk and Classical Traditions in South Asia Claus Peter Zoller 77 Sliding Downhill: Some reflections on thirty years of change in a Himalayan village Alan Macfarlane 105 — with responses from Ben Campbell, Kul B.
    [Show full text]
  • Visual Anthropology
    ENCOUNTER WITH VISUAL ANTHROPOLOGY Sarah Harrison and Alan Macfarlane 1 Contents Preface to the Series 3 How to view films and technical information 4 Introduction 5 Peter Loizos 14 September 2002 8 Paul Hockings 11 November 2005 12 Gary Kildea 3 November 2006 19 David MacDougall 29-30 June 2007 24 Karl Heider 30 June 2007 38 Liang Bibo 28 July 2008 46 Appendices 1. Early Ethnographic filming in Britain 52 2. Christoph von Fürer-Haimendorf 61 Other possible volumes 81 Acknowledgements and royalties 82 © Sarah Harrison and Alan Macfarlane 2014 2 Preface to the series There have been many autobiographical accounts of the creative process. These tend to concentrate on one level, and within that one aspect, the cerebral, intellectual working of a single thinker or artist’s mind. Yet if we are really to understand what the conditions are for a really creative and fulfilling life we need to understand the process at five levels. At the widest, there is the level of civilizations, some of which encourage personal creativity, while others dampen it. Then there are institutions such as a university, which encourage the individual or stifle him or her. Then there are personal networks; all thinkers work with others whether they acknowledge it or not. Then there is the level of the individual, his or her character and mind. Finally there is an element of chance or random variation. I have long been interested in these inter-acting levels and since 1982 I have been filming people talking about their life and work. In these interviews, characteristically lasting one to two hours, I have paid particular attention to the family life, childhood, education and friendships which influence us.
    [Show full text]
  • Isaac Schapera: a Bibliography
    The African e-Journals Project has digitized full text of articles of eleven social science and humanities journals. This item is from the digital archive maintained by Michigan State University Library. Find more at: http://digital.lib.msu.edu/projects/africanjournals/ Available through a partnership with Scroll down to read the article. Pula: Botswana Journal of African Studies, vo1.12, nos.1 & 2 (1998) Isaac Schapera: a bibliography Suzette Heald Department of Sociology, University of Botswana, Abstract The extraordinary record of published scholarship by Isaac Schapera stretches from 1923 right up to date, with publications forthcoming in 1999. This bibliography covers almost two hundred titles. His main subject of interest up to 1930 was the Khoesan of South Africa. Thereafter he published on the Tswana of Botswana, beginning with studies of Kgatla society and literature, and moving into general Tswana law and society by the time of his classic Handbookof Tswana Law and Custom in 1938, commissioned by the Bechuanaland Protectorate colonial administration. In the 1940s he produced many studies of Tswana land tenure and history, including unpublished official reports. From the 1950s he definitively edited 19th century source materials on the Tswana, notably the unpublished papers of David Livingstone, and continued producing his own original studies at a prodigious rate into the 1970s. Important latter studies have been in the field of indigenous law and government, many in the Journalof African Law,founded in his honour. Introduction This bibliography has been compiled to honour Isaac Schapera, born 23rd June 1905, and to introduce new generations of scholars to the full range of his work by providing an updated and accessible listing.
    [Show full text]
  • 'The Group and the Individual in History', Alan Macfarlane [From: Space, Hierarchy and Society: Interdisciplinary Studies In
    ‘The Group and the Individual in History’, Alan Macfarlane [From: Space, Hierarchy and Society: Interdisciplinary Studies in Social Area Analysis, eds. Barry C.Burnham and John Kingsbury, BAR International Series 59 (1979)] p.17 ABSTRACT Social scientists have suggested two contrasted models of human societies, those based on the 'group' and those on the 'individual'. Peasant and tribal societies are examples of the former, Hunter-Gatherers and modern post- industrial societies of the latter. In the former, the important boundaries are between large units-clans, castes, villages etc. In the latter, the boundaries are between the individual self and the outside world. The major theories of sociology suggest a change from group to individual (De Tocqueville, Riesman). The change is expressed and caused by many other changes: from status to contract (Maine), from community to Society (Tönnies), from peasant/feudal to capitalist (Marx, Weber), from hierarchy to equality (Dumont). In many of these theories the turning point has been either the industrial /urban revolution of the C18-19, or the earlier Protestant/Capitalist revolution of the C16-C17. But all the theories see societies moving along an evolutionary trail from a. to b. This paper will consider the proposition that this is an oversimplification and that while some societies move in this way, others remain predominantly of the 'group' or 'individual' based kind for all of recorded time. Since England has, above all, been taken as an example of the transition from group to individual in the writings of Maine, Marx, Weber, Tönnies, De Tocqueville and others, the paper will provide a very brief examination of the history of England from the thirteenth to eighteenth centuries.
    [Show full text]
  • And Others Africa South Of
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED C50 000 48 SO 001 213 AUTHOR Duignan, Peter; And Others TITLE Africa South of the Sahara: A Bibliography for Undergraduate Libraries. INSTITUTION National Council of Associations for International Studies, Pittsburgh, Pa.; New York State Education Dept., Albany. SPONS AGENCY Office of Education (DREW), Washington, D.C. REPORT NO OPUB-12 BUREAU NO BR-5-0931 PUE LATE 71 NCTE 127p. AVAILABLE FROM Foreign Area Materials Center, 11 West 42nd Street, New York, New York ($8.95) EDRS PRICE EDRS Price MF-$0.65 HC-$E.58 DESCRIPTORS African Culture, African History, Area Studies, Bibliographies, Higher Education, *Library Collections, Library Materials, *Library Material Selection, *Social Sciences, *Undergraduate Study IDENTIFIERS *Africa, ESEA Title 4 ABSIRACI Library collections are generally ill equipped tc effectively sin:port foreign area students. This bibliography, one of a series on "neglected" foreign areas, attempts to provide guidelines for libraries in meeting these resources needs. Selection of entries was made according to the following guidelines: 1)few works in languages other than English; 2)emphasis on books published in the last 25 years, except for classica works; 3)few government documents; and, 4)an attempt to balance source books and secondary works, while covering all disciplines. Arrangement of entries is by broad geographic category, with subsections based on type of publication (bibliography, reference bcck, journal, general book) and subject area (history and archaeology, philosophy and religion, art and architecture etc.). Each entry is graded as to its degree of necessity for undergraduate collections, from books that should be purchased whether or not any courses on the area are taught, tc books necessary for an undergraduate area studies program.
    [Show full text]
  • Transatlantica, 1 | 2019 “I Am a Freak of Nature”: Tourette’S and the Grotesque in Jonathan Lethem’S M
    Transatlantica Revue d’études américaines. American Studies Journal 1 | 2019 Gone With the Wind after Gone With the Wind “I am a freak of nature”: Tourette’s and the Grotesque in Jonathan Lethem’s Motherless Brooklyn Pascale Antolin Electronic version URL: https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/13941 DOI: 10.4000/transatlantica.13941 ISSN: 1765-2766 Publisher Association française d'Etudes Américaines (AFEA) Electronic reference Pascale Antolin, ““I am a freak of nature”: Tourette’s and the Grotesque in Jonathan Lethem’s Motherless Brooklyn”, Transatlantica [Online], 1 | 2019, Online since 17 July 2020, connection on 03 May 2021. URL: http://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/13941 ; DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/ transatlantica.13941 This text was automatically generated on 3 May 2021. Transatlantica – Revue d'études américaines est mise à disposition selon les termes de la licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas d'Utilisation Commerciale - Pas de Modification 4.0 International. “I am a freak of nature”: Tourette’s and the Grotesque in Jonathan Lethem’s M... 1 “I am a freak of nature”: Tourette’s and the Grotesque in Jonathan Lethem’s Motherless Brooklyn Pascale Antolin Certain essential aspects of the world are accessible only to laughter. (Bakhtin, Rabelais 66) 1 “‘Accusatony! Excusebaloney! Funnymonopoly!’ I squeezed my eyes shut to interrupt the seizure of language” (MB1 175). This short passage provides a significant sample of how the hero narrator’s Tourette’s syndrome manifests itself in Jonathan Lethem’s 1999 detective novel, Motherless Brooklyn. “The distinctiveness” of the narrative lies in the “proliferation of Lionel’s verbal tics” (Fleissner 390). While Tourette’s provokes Lionel Essrog’s linguistic outbursts, it breaks and intrudes upon the narrative, introducing dramatic nonsense into the text—even more dramatic when italics are used and the portmanteau words stand out on the page.
    [Show full text]
  • History, Anthropology and the Study of Communities 1
    (discussi) [This is the draft of an article which appeared in Social History, vol.5, 19777] History, Anthropology and the Study of Communities 1 The belief that stable and tightly knit 'communities' have existed in the past and still survive in distant lands is an important one for highly mobile industrial societies. It is therefore no coincidence that it was in the turmoil of late nineteenth-century industrialization that the idea of 'community' as opposed to modern 'society' was developed extensively, particularly in the work on Tonnies.2It was felt that the quality of life was changing, values were being undermined, an older closeness represented by the idea of 'community' was being lost. This belief both influenced and seemed to find support in the work of anthropologists and historians working in the first half of the twentieth century. Westerners visiting remote areas of the world were able to discern those 'communities' which were already just a memory in their own society. Many would have agreed with the anthropologist Srinivas when he commented that 'nobody can fail to be impressed by the isolation and stability of these (Indian) village communities'.3The work of social and economic historians also seemed to point to a community-based past, later destroyed by industrialization and urbanization. 4If villages in late nineteenth-century Oxfordshire were as Flora Thompson described them, how much more integrated, it might seem, would earlier periods be? 5The contrast, as Tonnies described it, was between life based on bonds of kinship, geographical bonds and the sentiment of belonging to a group (blood, place, mind), which was termed 'community', and the modern phenomenon where all these links had been broken in what he termed 'society'.
    [Show full text]
  • Partha Dasgupta Interviewed by Professor Alan Macfarlane, FBA, on 6Th April 2010, Under the Theme “Life and Works of Partha Dasgupta”
    Partha Dasgupta interviewed by Professor Alan Macfarlane, FBA, on 6th April 2010, under the theme “Life and Works of Partha Dasgupta” 0:05:07 Born in November 1942 in Dhaka, then known as Dacca, now in Bangladesh, but then part of India; my maternal grandfather was the chief purchaser in a prominent jute company in Dacca, which is where my mother was born; my paternal grandfather was born in a village called Goila, which is in Barisal, a district in the Ganges-Brahmaputra delta of East Bengal, now Bangladesh; my father’s mother was from East Bengal as well; by the time my father was born, the Dasguptas of Barisal were impoverished financially, but it was a family with a long scholastic history, as I understand it they were a dynasty of scribes dating back to the seventeenth century; some made considerable reputations as Sanskrit scholars, but that didn’t make them rich; my father's father was an officer in local government; he worked in Bhanga, a court town in Faridpur district; three of my grandparents died before I was born, but I did get to know my mother's mother; she died in 1954; she was a lady of considerable independence of mind; one of my mother's sisters, quite a bit older than she, was married at the age of thirteen and widowed at fifteen; my grandmother took a stance subsequently, which meant that my mother didn’t get married until she was twenty-two: she was encouraged by my grandmother to graduate from Dacca University; my mother had a deep interest in both Bengali and English poetry, but I didn't get to know that until she
    [Show full text]
  • Nepal in Context148 Alan Macfarlane
    Digital Himalaya: Nepal in Context148 Annual Lecture to the British Nepal Association, at the School of Oriental and African Studies in London, on 27th June 2003 Alan Macfarlane Introduction I hope that I may be allowed the indulgence of looking back over work and visits to Nepal and what I have learnt from them. My first visit was part of the research for a Ph.D. in anthropology at the School of Oriental Studies, starting in December 1968, for 15 months. I was only able to return again in 1986 with my second wife Sarah Harrison. Since then we have visited the Gurungs almost every year for between 1-3 months. We have made over 15 visits, and I have spent about 36 months in Nepal. If I add on the time spent with me by my first wife Gill, and Sarah, this makes well over five years of data collection. During that time I have concentrated my work on the Gurungs, and particularly the village of Thak (Gurung, Tolson) to the north of Pokhara, where Sarah and I have been engaged on a longitudinal study. We have gathered what must be one of the most extensive sets of data – annual censuses, crop and land surveys, photographic surveys of every person and house, over 120 hours of film and video and many other kinds of material– that has been made in relation to a Himalayan community over a period of 35 years. Here we are building on the work of earlier anthropologists such as Bernard Pignède, Christoph von Fürer- Haimendorf who have worked in the area.
    [Show full text]
  • African Family and Kinship Brian Siegel
    Furman University Furman University Scholar Exchange Anthropology Publications Anthropology 1996 African Family and Kinship Brian Siegel Originally published in Understanding Contemporary Africa, 2nd edition, edited by April A. Gordon and Donald L. Gordon. Copyright © 1996 by Lynne Rienner Publishers, Inc. Used with permission of the publisher. www.rienner.com Recommended Citation Siegel, Brian, "African Family and Kinship" (1996). Anthropology Publications. Paper 3. http://scholarexchange.furman.edu/ant-publications/3 This Book Chapter is made available online by Anthropology, part of the Furman University Scholar Exchange (FUSE). It has been accepted for inclusion in Anthropology Publications by an authorized FUSE administrator. For terms of use, please refer to the FUSE Institutional Repository Guidelines. For more information, please contact [email protected]. African Family and Kinship Brian Siegel (from "Family and Kinship," pp. 221-47 in April A. Gordon and Donald L. Gordon, eds., Understanding Contemporary Africa, 2nd ed., Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers, 1996) “Don’t be fooled,” advised a senior Zambian bureaucrat. “Here in Africa, the family is first. This will never change.” I was on my way to study the labor strategies of Copperbelt market gardeners, and I had told him my plans to consult the local officials charged with “developing” the “static rural masses.” One should not, he advised, accept such programs at face value, for government offices and officials would never inspire the same loyalties as those of family ties. The significance of such ties was dramatically illustrated in 1983, when 1.3 million migrant workers from Ghana—nearly one-tenth of all Ghanaians—were suddenly deported from Nigeria.
    [Show full text]