Ethical Record the Proceedings of the South Place Ethical Society Vol
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ethical Record The Proceedings of the South Place Ethical Society Vol. 114 No. 3 £1.50 March 2009 A NEW TRANSLATIONOF BAROND'HOLBACH'S CHRISTIANITYUNVEILED RoMtel CsonVobsturity Series by' taron d'Holbach A Ca,n:rówrsvii Documents The fiat new 0.1'mila:ionin over 2134:1yriars "%viala cull inn-min:non mid notes by david I I olOhnn . This edition by David flolohan contains a wealth of biographical material on d'Holbach and his circle, previously only available in French. Illustrated and annotated liberally, it sets all the documents in their biblical, historical, philosophical, political and cultural context. See page 18 Hodgson Press THE SPIDERS OF ALLAH: Travels of an Unbeliever on the Frontline of Holy War James Ilider 3 THE REPUBLIC OF HEAVEN; GERRARD WINSTANLEY AND THE DIGGERS John Severs 7 FIXING OUR BROKEN DEMOCRACY Ken Ritchie Ii THOMAS PAINE, POST-WAR RECONSTRUCTION AND CURRENCY CRISIS Ellen L. Ramsay 17 BARON D'HOLBACH AND THE FRENCH ENLIGHTENMENT 'It's raining bombs on the house of the Lord' aDiderot David Holohan 18 VIEWPOINTS: Sue Mayer, Dick Clifford.Tom Rubens 30 ETHICAL SOCIETY EVENTS 32 SOUTH PLACE ETHICAL SOCIETY Conway Hall Humanist Centre 25 Red Lion Square, London WC I R 4RL. Tel: 020 7242 8031/4 Fax: 020 7242 8036 Website: www.ethicalsoc.org.uk email: [email protected] Chairman: Giles Enders Hun. Rep.: Don Liversedge Vice-chairman: Teny Mullins Treasurer: John Edwards Registrar: Donald Rooum Editor, Ethical Record: Norman Bacrac SPES Staff Executive Officer: .Emma J. Stanford Tel: 020 7242 8031/4 Finance Officer: Linda Alia Tel: 020 7242 8031/4 Lettings Officer: Carina Dvorak Tel: 020 7242 8032 Librarian/Programme Coordinator: Jennifer Jeynes M.Sc. Tel: 020 7242 8037 Lettings Assistant: Marie Aubrechtova Caretakers: Eva Aubrechtova (i/c); Tel: 020 7242 8033 together with: Shaip Bullaku. Angelo Edrozo, Nikola Ivanovski.Alfredo Olivio, Rogerio Retuerna, David Wright Maintenance Operative: Zia Hammd New Members The Society is pleased to welcome to membership Leonard Atkinson of Grays in Essex, Alun Llewelyn of Kenton in Middlesex, John Molson of Harpenden in Hens, Peter Morgan of Ashford in Kent, Tiffany Prince of Wanstead, Sylvette Wyatt of North London Donor The Society is grateful for a donation from Mr L.E. West of 150. Obituary We regret toteport the death of Julien Gross of London NW3 Voltaire Lecture - a joint BHA/SPES event Kenan Malik on THE GUILT OF SCIENCE? Race, Science and Darwin Chair: Polly Toynbee 6.30pm, Thursday 23 April 2009, Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, London WC IR 4RL LS (BHA or SPES), £7 others. Tickets online from www.humanism.org.uk by debit/credit card or by cheque to British Humanist Association marked FOR VOLTAIRE LECTURE with your name and a return address, to 1 Gower Street, London, WC I E 611D. SOUTH PLACE ETHICAL SOCIETY Reg. Charity No. 251396 Founded in 1793, the Society is a progressive movement whose aims are: the study and dissemination of ethical principles based on humanism, the cultivation of a rational and humane way of life, and the advancement of research and education in relevant fields. We invite to membership those who reject supernatural creeds and are in sympathy with our aims. At Conway Hall the programme includes Sunday lectures, discussions, evenine courses and the renowned South Place Sunday Concerts of chamber music. The Society maintains a Humanist Reference Library. The Society's journal, Ethical Record, Is issued monthly. Memorial meetings may be arranged. The annual subscription is £18 (£12 if a full-time student, unwaged or over 65). 2 Ethical Record, March 2009 THE SPIDERS OF ALLAH: Travels of an Unbeliever on the Frontline of Holy War James Hider, Times Middle Eastern Bureau Chief Lecture to the Ethical Society, I I January 2009 What do you say to a man whose cousin has just been ripped apart by a suicide bomber during a Muslim festival in Iraq? I told the young sheikh I was sorry for his loss. Wrong answer. The sheikh brushed aside my condolences. 'I am jealous of him, he has gone straight to heaven' he told me with absolute conviction. 'I'm sure my cousin is being hosted by Imam Hussein even now.' The encounter took place in the Shia holy city of Karbala, south of Baghdad in March 2004, the first time the faithful had been allowed to gather freely to celebrate the festival of Ashoura, marking the death of Imam Hussein, in decades. Outside, pilgrims who had spent the morning beating themselves over the heads with swords until their scalps were bloody, resumed their devotions despite the fact that almost 100 of their fellows had just been blown to pieces by a gang of Sunni suicide bombers who believed they, too, were going to heaven. The remains of the kamikazes could be seen next to their victims — lakes of blood, mangled corpses, a security guard placing a woman's severed head on her body so it wouldn't be lost for burial. A Pathogen Through History Such is the power of ideas - and the absolutism of religious ideals in particular. In the Middle East, you can trace the course of such ideas like a pathogen through human history, as ancient notions of existence spread from one civilization to the next, mutating and taking over large groups of people, forcing them into courses of action that to the rational mind appear insane. In 2006, in the self-proclaimed Islamic Caliphate which Al Qaeda-led rebels had established just 30 miles north of Baghdad, reliaious zealots tried to enforce •their own brand of morality dredged up from the seventh century. Greengrocers were killed for displaying cucumbers next to tomatoes, because one apparently represented masculinity and the other femininity. Bananas had to be sold in discreet black plastic bags for the same reason. Absurd, but disobeying could cost you your life. The pinnacle of this weirdness came in an order for shepherds to make their goats wear underpants so as not to offend (or perhaps arouse) holy warriors. The penalty for violating this Benny Hill-style ruling, was death. And not an easy death either - beheadings were the standard practice for Al Qaeda' killers, while the Shia death squads who roamed Baahdad preferred using electrical drills to off their victims. By that summer of 2006. Iraq was a terrifying Petri dish for examining the way ideas mutate and transform themselves into deadly myths and ideologies. For 35 years, people had lived in a bubble of fear, fed news only by the paranoid, brutal dictator Saddath Hussein. When the American military kicked down the door of the aSylum in 2003, there was a sudden implosion of warped beliefs, conspiracy theories and crazed ideologies that demonstrated just how quickly and violently the human mind can be whisked off into the darkest recesses of madness. Ethical Record, March 2009 3 At first, shortly after the invasion, conspiracy theories emerged through the recent surface of oppression, urban myths developed about American soldiers deserting in droves, or claims arose that the US military was covering up their huge losses by burying dead troops in mass graves out in the desert. Some of these were clearly malicious in intent - the rumour that the ubiquitous Ray-Ban sunglasses worn by US soldiers against the dust and dazzling sunlight were actually said to be X-ray specs that could see through women's clothing was one example. A ridiculous notion, but one that some Iraqi men readily believed: they duly went and got their guns to protect their womenfolk's modesty. With no independent media to rely upon, and no history of normal, rational behaviour to act as a yardstick, it was enough for someone to voice an idea for it to be possible. By keeping his people in the dark - to the point where many would consult magic men in touch with djinns, or genies, to solve crimes rather than going to the corrupt police — Saddam had left Iraqis in a state of almost medieval gullibility: many people I spoke to believed their president, still a fugitive after the war, could never be killed by the Americans because he had a magic stone that he wore around his neck, protecting him from bombs and bullets. The charm had apparently been 'scientifically' tested on chickens and cows to make sure it worked, I was told by a number of people. Fire a bullet at a cow wearing the charm and the projectile would fly around its target. Throughout history, myths have arisen and been adapted by subsequent civilizations. In 701 BCE, the unstoppable Assyrian army laid siege to the city of Jerusalem, capital of the tiny kingdom of Judah, at a time when the Jewish faith was still crystallizing. Some 20 years earlier, the same war machine from what is now Iraq had laid waste to the kingdom of Israel, just north of Judah, carrying the 10 tribes away into slavery and assimilation. But now, The Prophet Isaiah proclaimed in the name of the still-untested god Yahweh, that against all the odds the Assyrians would perish at the hands of an angel of death sent by the Lord. Isaiah's people put their faith in him, while to even the odds the Judean military commanders blocked off the wells around the besieged city. Sure enough, the Assyrian conquering hordes dropped like flies, probably from cholera contracted from drinking unclean water. Birth Of The Giant Spider Myth In the meantime, the pious people of Jerusalem thanked their one all-powerful God for delivering them from slavery. In future, defeats would not be interpreted as god's failure to protect his people, but instead, as punishment for their failure to live up to his ideals.