Borders and Difference the Politics of Delineating Europe
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BORDERS AND DIFFERENCE THE POLITICS OF DELINEATING EUROPE by Ira Bliatka A Thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of International Politics ABERYSTWYTH UNIVERSITY 2016 Thesis Summary This thesis is about the making of the European Union (EU) as a political actor through the delineation of borders and border spaces. It speaks to one of the key questions of an ongoing scholarly and policy debate, regarding the dialectic nature of the EU’s borders; internal and external, present and absent, murderous and humanitarian are only some of the binaries that have been deployed to speak of these paradoxical hybrid constructs, which, as literature has argued, have long stopped acting and looking like simple lines on maps. As such, the project lies at the intersection of EU studies, Border Studies and Political Geography, and engages themes that have been common in these fields; borders, biopolitics, and security logics of risk. The biopolitical border is found behind an ever-expanding range of border technologies that regulate global mobilities; biometric passports, databases, surveillance systems, and techniques of risk-profiling, outsourcing, and off-shoring the border. My thesis seeks to add to these literatures, arguing for the need to embed the study of the EU’s biopolitical borders within geographical and historical analytical frames. To this end, it makes a Foucauldian contribution, by bringing in Foucault’s underdeveloped concept of a heterotopia, to study the spaces that these borders produce and re-articulate. Heterotopias are ‘loose’ space-times that unfold in multiple thresholds between inside and outside, mirroring and exaggerating the contradictions of the wider polities to which they belong, and enabling us to think in flexible ways about the physical and temporal boundaries of milieus of power. Through the heterotopic lens, mobility and immobility, inclusion and exclusion, emerge not only as acts that permit and forbid bodies from accessing an internal and prosperous subworld, but as performances of difference and otherness in the process of constituting the EU as such. Acknowledgments At first instance, would like to thank my supervisors, Jenny Edkins and Alistair Shepherd, for their mentorship, knowledge, sense of humour, and patient approach to tackling what felt at times like an unfinishable project. Also, many thanks go out to Felix Ciuta, for supervising the Master’s dissertation out of which my PhD questions emerged, and for his continuous support and friendship up until submission. My gratitude also goes to Elena Korosteleva, for supervision at the initial stages of the project, and to Ian Klinke for questions and comments on early drafts. I also wish to thank Javier Baluja, Thodoris Paraskevopoulos, and Antony Smith, for precious help with maps. The support of my family was invaluable while working through the trickiest parts of the thesis. Gratitude goes to my mother Anna Mastoraki for courage, support, and for her memorable “there’s no problem without a solution”; my father Kostas Bliatkas for pointing me to the intricacies of the EU institutions; Hionia Vlachou for crisis-averting influence; my brother Dimitris for being an incredible person; Tania Mastoraki for calling me on the phone in 2010 to ask “why on earth would they build a fence?” thus starting everything; Youli Mastoraki for technical support and for blessing our family with two wonderful babies, putting things in perspective; Konstantina Mintzia for being infinitely more than a cousin; and my grandmother Eleni Mastoraki for patience, persistence, hospitality, and love to us all. Special thanks go out to Nour Hawaa, for taking me to a border-crossing shopping trip and for grounding conversations; to Alexandros Koutsoukis for late-night departmental writing sessions, and for his inspiring determination; to Alexandros Chatzispyrou for being my guide in Piraeus and my companion during the final year of the thesis; and to Desiree Poets whose friendship and contribution to my emotional well-being deserves a thesis of its own. It would exceed the customary one-page note, if I were to thank by name all that lent me their support to complete this project. I still want to acknowledge however the staff at Frontex Liaison Office for insights and conversations in both official and unofficial capacity, the volunteers at the refugee camp of Piraeus, and, importantly, fellow PhDs here in Aberystwyth for camaraderie and good humour. Finally, I want to express my gratitude to the Centre for European Studies, and to the Department of International Politics, who funded this project. TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgments ............................................................................................................................... 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................................................... 1 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..................................................................................................................... 3 LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................................. 4 LIST OF TABLES .................................................................................................................................... 4 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 5 How We Write about Borders ............................................................................................................ 7 Structure of Thesis ............................................................................................................................ 15 Methodology ..................................................................................................................................... 18 The EU’s Crisis at the Borders of Greece: Governing through Immobility and Exclusion .................... 21 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 21 The EU as an Area to Migrate to ....................................................................................................... 24 Greece as Immobilised Borderland ................................................................................................... 35 Conclusions ....................................................................................................................................... 63 Power and Life in Situ: The Refugee Camp of Piraeus as Biopolitical Heterotopia .............................. 66 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 66 Theorising Camps .............................................................................................................................. 69 A Walk in the Camp ........................................................................................................................... 79 Different/Other Spaces ..................................................................................................................... 85 Spaces of Piraeus .............................................................................................................................. 95 Contending Logics of Distribution ................................................................................................... 113 Conclusions ..................................................................................................................................... 126 Frontex’s Europe ................................................................................................................................. 129 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 129 Deathcount and Milestones ............................................................................................................ 130 Situating Frontex: Intelligence Agent or Boots on the Ground?..................................................... 136 Frontex as Author of Risks .............................................................................................................. 149 Making Borders Smart .................................................................................................................... 161 Conclusions ..................................................................................................................................... 169 The Local Border Traffic Agreement in Kaliningrad Governing through Mobility and Inclusion ........ 172 Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 172 What Kind of Exception for what Kind of Security.......................................................................... 176 1 The Border Area and its Population ................................................................................................ 179 EU External Relations and Polish Foreign Policy ............................................................................. 199 Situating the LBT in the Schengen Acquis ......................................................................................