The Cause and Consequence of Human Trafficking: Human Rights Violations
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Cause and Consequence of Human Trafficking: Human Rights Violations The Cause and Consequence of Human Trafficking: Human Rights Violations Jacquelyn C.A. Meshelemiah and Raven E. Lynch COLUMBUS The Cause and Consequence of Human Trafficking: Human Rights Violations by Jacquelyn Meshelemiah is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted. Dedication This book is dedicated to “Queen” and every trafficking victim and survivor in the world. I know that you are out there and this book is intended to amplify your voice, describe your horrid experiences and to seek justice and action on your behalf. Human rights are a “right” and not a privilege. Everyone deserves to live freely! “branch” is licensed under CC0 1.0 Contents About the Authors ix Acknowledgements xiii Introduction 1 Preface 3 Overview of Human Trafficking Section 11 Chapter 1: Social Work, Social Justice, 13 Human Rights and Human Trafficking Chapter 2: Landmark Policies in 43 Trafficking in the USA and Trafficking in Persons Ratings Across the Globe Chapter 3: Theories and Human Trafficking 75 Sex Trafficking Section 95 Chapter 4: Sex Trafficking 97 Chapter 5: The Weaponization of Drugs 127 Labor Trafficking Section 143 Chapter 6: Labor Trafficking and Supply 145 Chain Transparency Various Forms of Human Trafficking 183 Section Chapter 7: Child Brides and Mail Order 185 Brides Chapter 8: Child Soldiers 207 Chapter 9: Organ Trafficking 225 Action Section 243 Chapter 10: Leadership Among Survivors 245 in the Anti-Trafficking Movement Chapter 11: Certification of Foreign 261 National Sex Trafficking Victims Chapter 12: Identifying Trafficking Victims 287 in Healthcare Settings Resources Section 311 Chapter 13: Resources 313 About the Authors Dr. Jacquelyn C.A. Meshelemiah is a three-time alum of The Ohio State University. She currently holds a joint appointment as an Associate Professor in the College of Social Work and as a Faculty Fellow and Director of Leadership Initiatives for Women of Color in the Office of Diversity and Inclusion at The Ohio State University. She earned her Bachelor of Science in Social ix x Jacquelyn C.A. Meshelemiah and Raven E. Lynch Work (BSSW), Master of Social Work (MSW) and Doctorate (PhD) from the College of Social Work. She taught at the State University of New York (SUNY) at Buffalo (1995-1998) before returning to OSU in 1998. She is the author and co-author of numerous publications, presentations, and trainings on human rights and anti-trafficking work at the university, local, national and international levels. Professional travels have taken her to over half of the United States as well as to Africa, Europe, Asia and Central America in the capacity of a visiting scholar, presenter and researcher. Dr. Meshelemiah is a former Graduate Studies Chair, President and Provost’s Leadership Institute graduate, BSSW Program Director, MSW Program Director, President and Provost’s Council on Women (PPCW) Chair/Past Chair/Member, and Office of Academic Affairs (OAA) Faculty Fellow. Raven E. Lynch, MSW, is a two-time alum and current PhD student at The Ohio State University, earning her BA in Psychology in 2014 and MSW in 2017. She also serves as a Graduate Research Associate to Dr. Meshelemiah in the College of Social Work, and a Graduate Administrative Human Trafficking xi Associate for Leadership Initiatives for Women of Color (LIWOC) in the Office of Diversity and Inclusion. Her current research interests beyond human trafficking and human rights include racial identity and multiracial adolescents. Acknowledgements Jacquelyn C.A. Meshelemiah The writing of this book was partially funded by the Affordable Learning Exchange (ALX) program at The Ohio State University. I am thankful for the weekly check- ins with Alexis Duffy who kept me on track and apprised me of tips to make my writing smoother. I am also thankful to Dr. Tom Gregoire, the Dean of the College of Social Work, who allowed me time away from the classroom to write this book. My co-author, doctoral student, Graduate Research Associate, Graduate Administrative Associate, and mentee—Raven E. Lynch, thank you for writing this book with me. I could not have written this book without you. You are simply amazing!! My children—thank you for allowing me to write for hours at a time without interruptions while applauding me for caring so much about human rights and trafficked children, women and men. My siblings—thank you for believing in your “smart”, “go-getter” and “focused” sister. I cannot ask for better siblings. You are the best. My friends—thank you for encouraging me to write this book. My mom… I wish you were here to read this book. Raven E. Lynch To the Affordable Learning Exchange Program and the College of Social Work at The Ohio State University, I am so appreciative of the opportunity to co-write this book. Specifically, to Dr. Jacquelyn Meshelemiah, I thank you for choosing and putting your trust in me as a student to xiii xiv Jacquelyn C.A. Meshelemiah and Raven E. Lynch collaborate on such a big project, as well as your guidance and mentoring throughout this whole process. My cohort friends and colleagues – thank you for all the reference suggestions, hours spent in coffee shops, and pep talks along the way! Introduction This book, “The Cause and Consequence of Human Trafficking: Human Rights Violations” is a call for education and action. The authors of this book are both social workers who are passionate about justice, human rights, and anti-trafficking work. We have written this book in an effort to educate the reader about human trafficking and human rights violations from multiple lenses. The book is broken down into six sections. They include: 1. Introduction to Human Trafficking 2. Sex Trafficking 3. Labor Trafficking 4. Various Forms of Human Trafficking 5. Action 6. Resources The sections contain chapters that include an abstract, learning objectives, key words, definitions, content on a specific aspect of trafficking, images, interactive quiz items, a case study, a summary and supplemental learning materials. Each chapter is intended to educate the reader, engage the reader and equip you with the tools (information, steps, etc.) to do something. “Doing something” will look different from person to person, but this book is a call to action. We all can do something. As 1 2 Jacquelyn C.A. Meshelemiah and Raven E. Lynch you read through this book, you will start to realize what you are able to do. Section I is intended to give an Overview of Human Trafficking. Content includes social work’s background and charge to promote social justice and human rights; the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights articles; landmark trafficking legislation; Trafficking in Persons (TIP) ratings, and theories to provide a context for human trafficking. This introductory chapter gives the reader the basics of human trafficking and human rights. Section II covers Sex Trafficking. Content includes sex trafficking in the context of forced prostitution, the male entertainment industry, pornography and Domestic Minor Sex Trafficking. This section also contains a chapter on substance use and sex trafficking. Section III covers Labor Trafficking and Supply Chains. Common household products that most people consume on a regular basis will be discussed along with the behind the scenes processes in the making of the product as it relates to supply chains. Section IV highlights Various Forms of Human Trafficking as it presents around the world. Content includes child brides, child soldiers and organ trafficking. Section V includes content on how to go into Action mode based on a diverse range of trafficking situations. Chapters are on survivor led leadership, certification of foreign nationals who are sex trafficked, and identifying trafficking victims in healthcare settings. Section VI is a list of Resources available to deepen your understanding of human trafficking and to equip you with tools to take action. Preface How Queen Changed My Career Trajectory While living in Buffalo, I met a woman in 1996 who I will call, “Queen”. She was a 26 year old African American female who had been forced into prostitution for 10 years prior to our meeting. Although I met her when she was 26, her story, however, goes back to when she was 16. Back then, minors like Queen were called child prostitutes. They were viewed as promiscuous girls, incorrigible youth, and kids who were “too grown for their own good”. Well, Queen was not any of those things. She was a child who met a man in his 20s, fell in love for the first time and was manipulated into believing whatever he said. When Queen met and started to date “Marcus”, he gave her everything that she was not getting at home— security, attention, material things, a clean place to live, peace, good food and more importantly—love. She fell hard and fast for Marcus. Their first few months together was a honeymoon. Marcus was the best “boyfriend” that Queen could have hoped for. She could not believe her good fortune. Her life was now going to be better. And it was—for a while. Then Marcus slowly started to criticize her, then he verbally abused her and then he progressed to the point of physically abusing her. Queen was lost, confused and madly in love with Marcus. Her world did not make sense. Her home life made even less sense—returning there was not an option. So she stayed hoping and praying that the old Marcus would surface again. Little did she know or understand 3 4 Jacquelyn C.A. Meshelemiah and Raven E. Lynch that the emotional and physical abuse that she was enduring was about to be compounded with sexual violence.