Restoration of Historic Streetcar Service in Downtown Los Angeles
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Restoration of Historic Streetcar Service in Downtown Los Angeles Alternatives Analysis (AA) FINAL January 13, 2012 This page intentionally left blank Restoration of Historic Streetcar Service in Downtown Los Angeles Alternatives Analysis Table of Contents 1.0 PURPOSE AND NEED ......................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1.1 Previous Planning Efforts ............................................................................................................. 2 1.2 Project Study Area Description ................................................................................................... 4 1.2.1 Project Study Area Overview ....................................................................................................... 4 1.2.2 Characteristics of PSA .................................................................................................................... 7 1.2.3 Demographics in PSA ................................................................................................................. 16 1.2.4 Transit Service and Facilities in the PSA ............................................................................... 25 1.2.5 Traffic Conditions in PSA .......................................................................................................... 35 1.3 Statement of Need ........................................................................................................................ 39 1.3.1 Geographically Disconnected Pedestrian Network ............................................................. 39 1.3.2 Lack of Local Short-Trip Transit Service .............................................................................. 39 1.3.3 Increased Transit Demand ......................................................................................................... 40 1.3.4 Traffic Patterns and Imbalanced Parking Capacity ............................................................. 41 1.3.5 Underutilized Land and Historic Buildings ........................................................................... 41 1.4 Statement of Purpose .................................................................................................................. 42 1.4.1 Enhance Mobility and Transit Circulation in Downtown Los Angeles ......................... 42 1.4.2 Support the Growth and Revitalization of Downtown Los Angeles ............................... 44 2.0 EVALUATION METHODOLOGY ................................................................................. 47 2.1 Evaluation Process ....................................................................................................................... 47 2.2 Initial Screening Evaluation Criteria ...................................................................................... 49 2.3 Final Screening Evaluation Criteria ........................................................................................ 51 3.0 INITIAL SCREENING OF ALTERNATIVES .............................................................. 53 3.1 Initial Screening Alternatives ................................................................................................... 53 3.2 Initial Screening Evaluation ...................................................................................................... 64 3.3 Initial Screening Recommendations ........................................................................................................ 75 4.0 FINAL SCREENING OF ALTERNATIVES .................................................................. 77 4.1 Final Screening Alternatives ..................................................................................................... 77 4.1.1 Changes to Alternatives Prior to Final Screening ............................................................... 77 4.1.2 Combined Alternatives for Final Screening ........................................................................... 79 4.2 Final Screening Evaluation ........................................................................................................ 89 4.2.1 Ridership ......................................................................................................................................... 89 4.2.2 Capital Costs .................................................................................................................................. 93 4.2.3 Operation and Maintenance (O&M) Costs ............................................................................. 95 4.2.4 Cost/Benefit ................................................................................................................................... 96 i 1/13/2012 Restoration of Historic Streetcar Service in Downtown Los Angeles Alternatives Analysis Table of Contents (Continued) 4.2.5 Destinations ................................................................................................................................... 97 4.2.6 Circulation ...................................................................................................................................... 99 4.2.7 Design ........................................................................................................................................... 103 4.2.8 Environmental ............................................................................................................................ 106 4.2.9 Economic Development ............................................................................................................ 110 4.2.10 Results of Final Screening ........................................................................................................ 113 4.3 Final Screening/Locally Preferred Alternative (LPA) Recommendation .................... 115 4.3.1 Future Extension to Union Station ....................................................................................... 116 Appendices Appendix A: Ridership Technical Memo Appendix B: Capital Costs Appendix C: Operation and Maintenance Costs ii 1/13/2012 Restoration of Historic Streetcar Service in Downtown Los Angeles Alternatives Analysis Tables Table 1: Previous Planning Efforts ............................................................................................................ 3 Table 2: Districts in PSA .............................................................................................................................. 8 Table 3: Population and Employment in PSA and Los Angeles County ........................................ 16 Table 4: Race and Ethnicity in PSA ........................................................................................................ 16 Table 5: Demographics of Potential Transit Users in PSA ............................................................... 20 Table 6: Metro Rail in PSA ....................................................................................................................... 27 Table 7: Metro Rail Weekday Boardings/Alightings by Station in PSA ...................................... 28 Table 8: Metro Bus Weekday Boardings/Alightings at Bus Stops in PSA ................................... 29 Table 9: Mode Share for Commute Trips .............................................................................................. 34 Table 10: Traffic Conditions at Intersections in PSA ......................................................................... 36 Table 11: Initial Screening Evaluation Criteria .................................................................................... 50 Table 12: Final Screening Evaluation Criteria ..................................................................................... 52 Table 13: Description of Initial Screening Alternatives by Segment .............................................. 55 Table 14: Initial Screening - Segment A ................................................................................................ 64 Table 15: Initial Screening - Segment B ................................................................................................. 68 Table 16: Initial Screening - Segment C................................................................................................. 69 Table 17: Advantages/Disadvantages of Initial Screening Alternatives ........................................ 71 Table 18: Initial Screening Recommendations ..................................................................................... 75 Table 19: Description of Final Screening Alternatives ....................................................................... 88 Table 20: Existing Streetcar Systems ..................................................................................................... 90 Table 21: Ridership ...................................................................................................................................... 92 Table 22: Capital Costs ............................................................................................................................... 94 Table 23: O&M Costs ................................................................................................................................. 95 Table 24: Cost/Benefit ...............................................................................................................................