DOCSLIB.ORG

Applying Translation Quality Standards to a Certification Procedure for U.S

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Applying Translation Quality Standards to a Certification Procedure for U.S Applying Translation Quality Standards to a Certification Procedure for U.S. Language Service Providers Jason Hall University of Denver, University College Capstone Project for Master of Liberal Studies November 15, 2011 Cris Silva, M.A. Capstone Advisor Alison Nishi, M.A. Academic Director Upon the Recommendation of the Department James Davis, Ph.D. Dean Hall -ii Abstract Many translation quality standards have been implemented to regulate the provision and procurement of language services. However, in the absence of a standardized procedure to certify U.S. language service providers (LSPs), the industry lacks consensus with regard to requirements, procedures, and expectations. This project establishes the need for such a procedure and proposes an LSP Certification Procedure based on existing quality standards. Through a review and analysis of existing translation quality standards, an interview with a key stakeholder, and the presentation of an LSP Certification Procedure, this project concludes that the U.S. language services industry requires a procedure to certify LSPs and that such a procedure may be designed and implemented based on existing standards. Hall -iii Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................. ii Table of Contents ................................................................................ iii Introduction ....................................................................................... 1 Problem Statement ..................................................................... 1 Goals and Objectives ................................................................... 2 Literature Review ................................................................................ 3 Review of Translation Quality Standards ........................................ 4 Provider-Oriented Translation Quality Standards ..................... 5 Product-Oriented Translation Quality Standards ...................... 7 Process-Oriented Translation Quality Standards ...................... 9 International Standard ISO 9001 ................................. 10 European Standard EN 15038:2006 ............................. 11 U.S. Standard ASTM F2575-06 .................................... 13 Discussion ......................................................................................... 17 Analysis of Translation Quality Standards ...................................... 17 Summary and Analysis of Interview ............................................. 21 Summary ......................................................................... 22 Analysis ........................................................................... 24 Design of the LSP Certification Procedure .............................................. 25 Areas for Further Research .................................................................. 26 References ........................................................................................ 28 Hall -iv Appendix 1: LSP Certification Procedure ................................................ 31 Objective .......................................................................... 31 Application ....................................................................... 31 Eligibility .......................................................................... 31 Required Resources .................................................................... 32 Human Resources .............................................................. 32 Requirements for Translators ...................................... 32 Requirements for Editors ............................................ 34 Requirements for Project Managers .............................. 34 Technical Resources ........................................................... 34 Required Procedures .................................................................. 35 Pre-Production Procedures .................................................. 35 Defining Project Specifications ..................................... 35 Service Agreement .................................................... 37 Production Procedures ........................................................ 37 Project Management Procedure ................................... 37 Translation Procedure ................................................ 38 Editing Procedure ...................................................... 38 Post-Production Procedures ................................................. 39 Client Sign-off Procedure ............................................ 39 Certification .............................................................................. 39 LSP Self-Certification ......................................................... 39 Hall -v Audited Certification .......................................................... 40 Appendix 1.1: Sample Project Specifications Questionnaire .............. 41 Appendix 1.2: Sample Project Quotation & Service Agreement ......... 42 Appendix 1.3: Sample Project Management Checklist ..................... 43 Appendix 1.4: Sample Translation Procedure ................................. 44 Appendix 1.5: Sample Editing Checklist ........................................ 45 Appendix 1.6: Sample Client Sign-off Checklist .............................. 46 Appendix 1.7: LSP Self-Certification Checklist ................................ 47 Appendix 1.8: Client LSP Audit Checklist ....................................... 48 Appendix 2: Transcript of 10-25-2011 Interview with Steve Lank ............. 49 Hall -1 Introduction The British Standards Institute defines a standard as “a document, established by consensus and approved by a recognized body, that provides, for common and repeated use, rules, guidelines or characteristics for activities or their results, aimed at the achievement of the optimum degree of order in a given context” (BSI 2011). Quality standards benefit consumers in a variety of industries by ensuring that services will meet certain pre- established criteria. For example, anyone who wishes to hire an electrician in the state of Colorado would find that the Department of Regulatory Agencies (DORA) provides an array of rules and regulations for the provision of electrical services (2011). In this case, industry standards create a sense of confidence that critical services will be provided in a safe and reliable fashion. In the same manner that an unregulated electrical industry would lead to unpredictable or unsafe services, unregulated professional translation of legally binding contracts, patient information leaflets, or other critical documents can also have costly or dangerous consequences. Nevertheless, the U.S. language services industry currently has no standardized procedure for certifying language service providers (LSPs) (Yunker 2010). Problem Statement The U.S. language services industry is currently plagued by a lack of consensus in a number of crucial areas. First, in the absence of any minimum requirements for providers, the barriers to entry in the industry Hall -2 are so low that there are tens of thousands of individual LSPs serving the market and clients are left to sort through a deluge of improbable promises of “the highest quality” at “the lowest price” with little formal regulation to guide them (Yunker 2010). Second, given that U.S. LSPs range in size from individual professionals to multinational corporations, there is tremendous variation in the resources, practices, and procedures used to carry out translation projects. Finally, a lack of public awareness of what is required to produce accurate translations of industry-specific documents has also created tremendous variation in price and quality expectations for professional language services. Therefore, in light of the lack of minimum requirements for LSPs, the absence of standard procedures for translation projects, and the lack of consensus on price and quality expectations for professional translation services, the U.S. language services industry requires a standardized procedure to certify language service providers. Goals and Objectives The objective of this project is to propose a standardized procedure for certifying LSPs suitable for the U.S. language services industry. Accomplishing this objective requires first proving that the industry has a need to certify LSPs, and then demonstrating that it is practical to design and implement such a procedure based on existing translation quality standards. This is done through a review of current quality standards, an Hall -3 interview with a key stakeholder, and finally, by proposing an LSP Certification Procedure based on existing translation quality standards. Literature Review The language services industry can be defined in a number of ways according to which related services are included in the definition. For example, the U.S. Census Bureau’s North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) defines Industry NAICS 54193, Translation and Interpretation Services, as “establishments primarily engaged in translating written material and interpreting speech from one language to another,” while another common definition places languages services within the globalization, international, localization, and translation (GILT) industry (U.S. Census Bureau 2007). In light of the existence of so many different definitions, it comes as no surprise that there is also a wide variation in the statistics available on the size of the language services industry. For
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Cultural Dislocation Through Translation
    Intercultural Communication Studies XIV: 4 2005 Said Faiq CULTURAL DISLOCATION THROUGH TRANSLATION Said Faiq American University of Sharjah Introduction Translation, in its academic, professional and anthropological meanings, remains one of the main means through which texts of one culture are made available in another. It should, in theory, be the site of a potentially fruitful clash of different cultures and particularly vital in the case of translation from those supposedly weaker and subordinate cultures into dominant ones, as in the case of translation from Arabic into English and French, for example (cf. Faiq, 2004). This notion of translating not only covers the traditional definition of translation, transfer of texts from one language to another, but also, and more importantly, texts written in one language but which originate in or concern cultures other than that of the language in which they are written. Over the last two decades or so, many translation scholars have stressed that translation, by necessity, involves manipulation and subversion of linguistic and cultural traditions, particularly those emanating from the so- called third world. Of course, within translation studies this shift of focus, from issues of fidelity and equivalence still shocks traditionalists who persist in their belief in value-free translation, as well as in the fact that translation cannot but refer to the transfer of texts from one language to another, rather than subsuming representation of others without any actual transfer of texts. This is more ideologically relevant particularly to post-colonial contexts. Referring to Venuti’s (1995) notions of transparency, invisibility and fluency, Susan Bassnett (1998) appropriately argues that such a translation project always favours the target readers, so much so that the source text, its culture and readers become insignificant.
    [Show full text]
  • Gerd Brantenberg's Egalias Døtre in Translation
    Lexis Journal in English Lexicology 17 | 2021 Humor, creativity and lexical creation Laughing at “normality”: Gerd Brantenberg’s Egalias døtre in translation Luise von Flotow, Ida Hove Solberg and Enora Lessinger Electronic version URL: https://journals.openedition.org/lexis/5429 DOI: 10.4000/lexis.5429 ISSN: 1951-6215 Publisher Université Jean Moulin - Lyon 3 Electronic reference Luise von Flotow, Ida Hove Solberg and Enora Lessinger, “Laughing at “normality”: Gerd Brantenberg’s Egalias døtre in translation”, Lexis [Online], 17 | 2021, Online since 15 August 2021, connection on 20 August 2021. URL: http://journals.openedition.org/lexis/5429 ; DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/lexis.5429 This text was automatically generated on 20 August 2021. Lexis is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. Laughing at “normality”: Gerd Brantenberg’s Egalias døtre in translation 1 Laughing at “normality”: Gerd Brantenberg’s Egalias døtre in translation Luise von Flotow, Ida Hove Solberg and Enora Lessinger Introduction1 1 Introduced to feminist wordplay and neologism in the books I read as I was nursing small children in the late 1970s, I remember laughing till the tears came: Mary Daly’s Gyn/Ecology. The Metaethics of Radical Feminism (1978) was my first exposure to the daringly creative and inventive subversion of conventional language or “malespeak” a subversion she deploys provocatively in the preface and introduction to this book. Her work and other contemporary writers’ disruption of mainstream “malestream” language that had arrogantly placed “man” in first position as the representative of the human race and denigrated women, girls, and female pre-occupations were absolutely hilarious.
    [Show full text]
  • Post-Editing in Practice – Process, Product and Networks
    The Journal of Specialised Translation Issue 31 – January 2019 Introduction: Post-editing in practice – Process, product and networks Lucas Nunes Vieira, University of Bristol Elisa Alonso, Universidad Pablo de Olavide, Seville Lindsay Bywood, University of Westminster, London ABSTRACT The potential benefits of integrating machine translation into human translation workflows are now widely recognised. In many sectors of the translation industry, translators’ throughput is improved with the use of machine translation as a tool in the translating process. Post-editing of machine translation is also a service in its own right, with specific guidelines and, more recently, an international standard. We introduce this special issue by providing a brief overview of post-editing as a practice, service and research topic. Contributions to the issue are then presented. The issue moves from a magnified perspective of translators’ work to important aspects of translation products, translators’ attitudes and translator training. It has four themes: the post-editing process; reception of post-edited products; attitudes and perceptions; and competence, training and education. KEYWORDS Post-editing, machine translation, computer-assisted translation, CAT, MT, MTPE, PEMT, translation technology, translator education, human-computer interaction. Machine translation (MT) quality has improved considerably in previous years. Recent MT improvements are largely due to the rise of neural MT, a relatively new approach to MT development based on artificial neural networks (Bahdanau et al. 2014). Neural MT has significantly advanced MT research, but it too has weaknesses (Castilho et al. 2017). In professional contexts where translations are public-facing products, therefore, MT usually requires human post-editing. This was the case decades ago when MT systems first appeared, and it is still the case now.
    [Show full text]
  • Translating the Exiled Self: Reflections on Translation and Censorship*
    Intercultural Communication Studies XIV: 4 2005 Samar Attar TRANSLATING THE EXILED SELF: REFLECTIONS ON TRANSLATION AND CENSORSHIP* Samar Attar Independent Researcher Self-Translating and censorship Translators tend to select foreign literary texts for translation into their mother-tongue for different reasons. Sometimes, their selection is based on the fame of a certain writer among his or her own people, or for the awarding of a prestigious international prize to a writer, or on the recommendation of an authoritative figure: a scholar, a critic, or a publisher. At other times, however, the opposite can be true. A writer who is not known among his or her own people is translated into another language, because his or her writing subverts the values of the national tradition, or destroys certain clichés about other nations, or simply because his or her work appeals to the translator.1 But we should not entertain the illusion that literary translators are always free agents. Although their literary taste and ideology may play an important role in their selection of foreign texts they often have to consider the literary, political and economic climate of their time. They simply do not translate texts because they like them. They are very much aware of the fact that translation cannot be brought to a fruitful end unless other authoritative bodies support them, and unless a publisher is found at the end of the ordeal. In short, personal, literary, social, political and economic factors always play an important role in the selection and translation of a foreign text. Normally the literary translator, who selects or is helped in selecting a foreign text, is expected to be a master of at least two languages including his or her own native tongue.
    [Show full text]
  • Solar Decathlon Website: English to Chinese Translation a Major Qualifying Project Report (Professional Writing)
    Solar Decathlon Website: English to Chinese Translation A Major Qualifying Project Report (Professional Writing) Submitted to the Faculty of WORCESTER POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Science Submitted By Yunqiu Sun 05/30/13 Advisors: Professor Lorraine Higgins Professor Jennifer Rudolph P a g e | 2 Abstract WPI is part of a team competing in Solar Decathlon China. For its Communications Contest, our team is generating a website, brochure, and signage to engage the audience in learning about the house we designed, “Solatrium”, and get inspired from our Solar Decathlon experience. This MQP incorporates an English to Chinese translation of the website, brochure, signage, video walkthrough, and dinner menu. It also provides information on the house design, the target audience for the Chinese website, and experts’ advice on translation. I compared my actual translation challenges and strategies to those proposed by literature. I conclude translation is not just about literal translation or reproducing sources into another language. It is also about making persuasive and culturally appropriate adaptations to attract the audience through their interests. This project reflects language and cultural differences through the experience of translation. P a g e | 3 Acknowledgements I would like to acknowledge the support of Professor Lorraine Higgins and Professor Jennifer Rudolph who provided helpful comments and encouragement throughout this project, and Professor Xin Xin who proofread
    [Show full text]
  • The Best of Both Worlds: from Volunteer Subtitling to Professional Subtitling
    transLogos 2020 Vol 3 Issue 2 Çavuşoğlu, Ebru, pp. 83–102 © Diye Global Communications https://dx.doi.org/10.29228/transLogos.28 diye.com.tr | [email protected] The Best of Both Worlds: From Volunteer Subtitling to Professional Subtitling * Ebru ÇAVUŞOĞLU The prevailing technological feasibility has enabled the rise of the digital era and has contributed to the seemingly changing nature of translation. One of the implications of this shift has been articulated in the area of Audiovisual Translation with the emergence of online communities of volunteer subtitle translators. This paper explores the emerging phenomenon of ‘volunteer subtitling’ and tries to shed light on its role in the transition to ‘professional subtitling.’ Volunteer subtitling platforms are broad communities of practice that consist of thousands of actively involved members. Despite the increasing interest in investigating various issues regarding online volunteer translation, not much is known about the process of transition from the volunteering world into the professional one. Using the most popular Turkish subtitling platforms (Turkcealtyazi.org and Planetdp.org) as a case study, this paper will present the very first insights into this transition through an analysis of a survey with translators who started their subtitling practice as volunteers and then moved into the professional world. Based on the analysis of the respondents’ experiences, it will be argued that the volunteer praxis and the active support of the online community strategically contribute to the improvement of a wide array of translation skills and open up the door for the move into the professional world. In doing so, this paper will also shed a light on both volunteer and professional environments from various perspectives like working conditions, the translation process, types of the work, and translator motivation.
    [Show full text]
  • The Retranslation Phenomenon
    The Retranslation Phenomenon A Sociological Approach to the English Translations of Dickens’ Great Expectations into Arabic Shatha Abdullah Abdulrahman Al-Shaye Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of PhD Centre for Translation Studies (CenTraS) University College London July 2018 The candidate confirms that the work submitted is her own and that appropriate credit has been given where reference has been made to the work of others. This copy has been supplied on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. Contents Contents ......................................................................................................................... i Figures .......................................................................................................................... ix Tables ............................................................................................................................ xi Abstract and keywords ............................................................................................. xiii Declaration ................................................................................................................. xvi Acknowledgements ................................................................................................. xviii Abbreviations .............................................................................................................. xx 1 Introduction .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • WPTP 2015: Post-Editing Technology and Practice
    Machine Translation Summit XV http://www.amtaweb.org/mt-summit-xv WPTP 2015: Post-editing Technology and Practice Organizers: Sharon O’Brien (Dublin City University) Michel Simard (National Research Council Canada) Joss Moorkens (Dublin City University) WORKSHOP MT Summit XV October 30 – November 3, 2015 -- Miami, FL, USA Proceedings of 4th Workshop on Post-Editing Technology and Practice (WPTP4) Sharon O'Brien & Michel Simard, Eds. Association for Machine Translation in the Americas http://www.amtaweb.org ©2015 The Authors. These articles are licensed under a Creative Commons 3.0 license, no derivative works, attribution, CC-BY-ND. Introduction The fourth Workshop on Post-Editing Technology and Practice (WPTP4) was organised for November 3rd, 2015, in Miami, USA, as a workshop of the XVth MT Summit. This was the fourth in a series of workshops organised since 2012 (WPTP1 – San Diego 2012, WPTP2 – Nice 2013, WPTP3 – Vancouver 2014). The accepted papers for WPTP4 cover a range of topics such as the teaching of post- editing skills, measuring the cognitive effort of post-editing, and quality assessment of post-edited output. The papers were also book-ended by two invited talks by Elliott Macklovitch (Independent Consultant) and John Tinsley (Iconic Translation Machines). Elliott Macklovitch’s talk was entitled “What Translators Need to Become Happy Post- Editors” while John Tinsley’s talk was entitled “What MT Developers Are Doing to Make Post-Editors Happy”. By juxtaposing these two points of view we hoped to provide an interesting frame for attendees where the views of users and developers were represented. We sincerely thank the authors of the papers as well as our two invited speakers for sharing their research.
    [Show full text]
  • Translation Project Organizations: a Perspective on KALIMA
    Arab World English Journal AWEJ INTERNATIONAL PEER REVIEWED JOURNAL ISSN: 2229-9327 جمةل اللغة الانلكزيية يف العامل العريب AWEJ Special issue on Translation No. (2) 2013 Pp.51-66 Translation Project Organizations: A perspective on KALIMA Radia Kesseiri Arabic and Middle Eastern Studies, Leeds University Mariam Bani Hashem Arabic and Middle Eastern Studies, Leeds University Abstract In recent years, Globalisation has entailed an increasingly expanding and prosperous development of translation projects with high volume translations in the Arab World. This brings up to surface the issue of quality in translation and in particular quality in translation project organizations, which is a crucial factor to their success and longevity. This paper aims at providing a brief account of how the concept of Translation Projects has developed, with particular insight into the Arab world, and attempt to decipher how quality in translation project organizations is achieved through an extensive process of editing and revising. The study will look at KALIMA as an example for a translation project in the Arab World. KALIMA is an Arabic word with an English equivalent that is ‗word‘. The KALIMA Project is based in the United Arab Emirates, and is a very ambitious initiative funded by the Abu Dhabi Authority for Culture and Heritage. This study will be accordingly divided into four main sections. Firstly, this paper will look at the development of translation projects in general and in the Arab world in particular. Secondly, it will explore theories behind translation and quality by looking into scholarly works in order to epitomise the various strategies and techniques used by translation project organizations to produce and ensure quality in translation.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Language, Translation and the Web Mark Shuttleworth
    Language, Translation and the Web Mark Shuttleworth 1 INTRODUCTION AND DEFINITIONS The area of ‘translation and the Web’ represents a novel alignment of concepts and subsumes how translation is implemented, enabled, supported, promoted, discussed and made available over the Web. While part of translation studies, it also interrelates with the interlocking lines of enquiry referred to as ‘Web studies’, ‘Web science’, ‘internet studies’ or ‘internet science’ (see Consalvo & Ess 2011; O’Hara & Hall 2013). Two terms need to be defined before we launch into the discussion: Web 2.0 (or the ‘read/write Web’) Since the early 2000s this term has been used to reflect the collaborativity built into many websites and on-line applications that permits users to interact within virtual communities, creating their own content and contributing to that of other users. UGC (User-Generated Content) UGC is ‘any form of content such as blogs, wikis, discussion forums, posts, chats, tweets, podcasting, digital images, video, audio files, advertisements and other forms of media that was created by users of an online system or service’ (Moens, Li & Chua 2014: 7). 2 HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVES Folaron (2010) approaches translation and the Web from the perspective of Web studies (2010: 449). The present chapter follows Gaspari’s (2015) more recent 1 discussion of what he terms ‘online translation’, placing it in the context of language on the Web and adding further topics to his discussion’s already extensive repertoire. 3 CORE ISSUES AND TOPICS 3.1 The language of the English Web This section describes the English Web; the situation in other languages is believed to be parallel to what is discussed here.
    [Show full text]
  • ISO Standards and Working Processes at the United Nations Language Services: a Comparison
    ISO standards and working processes at the United Nations language services: a comparison María Barros Senior Reviser, STS/DGACM, UNHQ United Nations Sabbatical Leave Programme 2017 Abstract International standards, in particular those developed by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO), are a universally recognized means of guaranteeing service quality. In the translation and language industries, the demand for ISO-certified services has been growing steadily since the publication of ISO 17100, on requirements for translation service providers, which addresses translation-specific processes that are essential for ensuring quality. ISO 17100 covers a wide range of aspects, from the competences of translators, revisers and project managers, to technology and quality management requirements, or the need to assess client satisfaction and take corrective action if necessary. All these tasks are performed by the language services of the 1 | Page United Nations, which therefore can benefit from an in-depth analysis of both the standard requirements and the changes implemented by private sector providers that have obtained certification. The present study covers all the tasks included in ISO 17100, with a focus on improving and harmonizing existing working processes and suggesting their establishment where they are lacking. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: First of all, I would like to thank Professor Sue Ellen Wright, from Kent State University, for her collaboration, support and expert guidance in this study. I am also grateful to my colleagues from the Documentation Division of DGACM who kindly agreed to be interviewed and provided me with insights into the daily work of their units: Martine Azubuike (French Translation Service), Kieran Burns (English Translation Service), Luke Croll (Editing Section), José Carlos Fernández-Gancedo and Carmen Peris (Spanish Translation Service), Mario Gatti and Frank Scharm (German Translation Section), Pyotr Knyazev (Russian Translation Service) and Dexin Yuan (Chinese Translation Service).
    [Show full text]
  • A Study of Selective Turkish Translations of Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot
    Hacettepe University Graduate School of Social Sciences Department of Translation and Interpretation Translation and Interpretation in English Programme TRANSLATING THE SELF-TRANSLATION: A STUDY OF SELECTIVE TURKISH TRANSLATIONS OF SAMUEL BECKETT’S WAITING FOR GODOT Çise İrem CANDAN Master’s Thesis Ankara, 2019 TRANSLATING THE SELF-TRANSLATION: A STUDY OF SELECTIVE TURKISH TRANSLATIONS OF SAMUEL BECKETT’S WAITING FOR GODOT Çise İrem CANDAN Hacettepe University Graduate School of Social Sciences Department of Translation and Interpretation Translation and Interpretation in English Programme Master’s Thesis Ankara, 2019 KABUL VE ONAY YAYIMLAMA VE FİKRİ MÜLKİYET HAKLARI BEYANI ETİK BEYAN iv DEDICATION To my father, who did not see the completion of this thesis. (1957-2016) v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to express first my utmost gratitude to my dear supervisor Asst. Prof. Dr. Sinem BOZKURT, for her limitless patience, support and guidance. Without the motivation she provided and her trust in me, I could not complete this study. I cannot thank her enough. I am also very grateful to my lecturers in the Department of Translation and Interpretation at Hacettepe University and in the Department of Translation of Interpretation at Bilkent University for their utmost guidance and support and for sharing their knowledge in the courses I attended during my graduate and undergraduate studies. I am indeed very grateful to my family, especially my husband, my mother and my brother, who never let me give up while writing this thesis and who supported me in every condition. I also would like to thank to my colleagues and my friends, especially those with whom I attended graduate courses.
    [Show full text]