WWNESDAY, OCTOBER 27 Ie·IN TIlE F RANKLIN ROOM Registration: 5:30 - 10:00 P.M. Washington Plaza Hotel Lobby THE WORK OF ART: STYLE AND IDENTITY Chair: Richard Shusterman Philosophy, Temple University Please Note: All room assignments subject to change. Speakers: Dale Jacquene Philosophy, Pennsylv:mia State University, 9:00 - 11:00 A.M. Budget Committee Meeting-Hotel Board Room ~Goodman on the Concept of Style" Julie C. Van CamP'\. 1:00 - 5:30 P.M. Trustees Meeting-Hotel Board Room Philosophy, California State University· Long Beach, "A Pragmatic Approach 6:00 - 8:00 P.M. Trustees Dinner-Diplomats Room to the Identity of Works of Art" Commentator: John Dilworth 8:00 - 11:00 P.M. Opening Reception-Hotel Lounge Philosophy, Western Michigan University

BOOK DISPLAy·LINCOLN ROOM 8:30 A.M. - 4:30 P.M. THURSDAY·FRIDAY 8,}0 A.M. - },OO P.M. SATURDAY Thursday, October 28 Session II . 11:10A.M. -l:00P.M_

THURSDAY, OCTOBER 28 ITa·1N TIlE FRANKLIN R OOM Registration: 8:30 A.M. - 4:30 P.M. Washington Plaza Hotel Lobby SESSION I - 9:00 · 10:50 A.M. THE AESTHETICS OF PLACE: THE SHAPING OF EXPERIENCE, MEANING, AND VALUES la-IN TIlE ADAMS ROOM Chair: Anthony J. Cascardi Hwnanities, University of California.Berkeley, THINKING THROUGH CINEMA: "Recent Directions in the Aesthetics of SpaceD THE PERFORMANCE OF NEW SELYES Speakers: Dean MacCannell Chair: Angela Curran Environmental Design and Landscape Philosophy, Mt. Holyoke College Architecture, University of California-Davis Speakers: Cynthia Fredand Pauline von Bonsdorff Philosophy, University of Houston, "Horrific Aesthetics, University of Helsinki New Flesh: The Appeal of Evil in Crash" Karsten Harries Thomas Wartenberg Philosophy, Philosophy and Film Studies, Me Holyoke Grant Hildebrand College, "Pygmalion's Critique of Social Architecture and Art History, Univeristy of Hierarchy" Washington Commentator: Carl Plantinga English, Hollins College ITb·IN THE ADAMS ROOM ANGLO-AMERICAN AESTHETICS: A VIEW FROM FRANCE Ib-IN THE JEFFERSON ROOM Chair: Jerrold Levinson ACTION POINTS FOR AESTHETICS· ASA's COMMITTEE Philosophy, University of Maryland ON THE STATUS OF AESTHETICS Speakers: Jean-Pierre Cometti Mary Devereaux Universite de Provence-Aix-Marseille Philosophy, University of California-San Diego Roger Pouivet Deborah Knight Universite de Rennes·Bretagne Philosophy, Queen's University, Jacques Morizet "Aesthetics: Status and Strategies" Universite de Paris VIII-Saint-Denis Dominic Lopes Jean-Maurice Monnoyer Philosophy, Indiana University-Kokomo, Universite Pierre Mendes-Grenoble ~ Th e Aesthetics Market: Bull or Bear?" Denis Dutton IT e-1N TIlE H OTEL RESTAURANT ALCOVE Philosophy, University of Canterbury, FEMINIST CAUCUS PANEL AND LUNCH MEETING: ~ A New Empiricism for Aesthetics" Michael Kelly THE AESTHETICS OF AGING Philosophy, , 11 :00 A.M. - 2:30 P.M. ~ Aesthetics, History, Art" Chair: Jo Ellen Jacobs Philosophy, Millikin University THURSDAY, OCTOBER 28 PLENARY SESSION (Can't.) Speakers: Kathleen Marie Higgins SESSION III - 2:30 - 4:30 P.M. Philosophy, University of Texas-Austin Dawn Perlmutter Philosophy, Cheyney University lIla-IN THE JEFFERSON ROOM Eva Kit Wah Man TED COHEN'SlOKES Religion and Philosophy, Hong Kong Baptist Chair: Timothy Gould University Philosophy, Metropolitan State College Anita Silvers Speakers: Peter Kivy Philosophy, San Francisco State University Philosophy, Hilary Robinson Robert Solomon Art and Design, University of Ulster-Belfast Philosophy, University of Texas-Austin Sally Banes Commemator: Ted Cohen Theater/Dance, University of Wisconsin-Madison Philosophy,

IIIb-1N THE ADAMS ROOM IN THE BOARD ROOM MUSIC: EMOTION AND MEANING JAAC EDITORIAL BOARD MEETING Chair: Garry Hagberg PHILIP ALPERSON, EDITOR Philosophy, Bard College THURSDAY, 8,00 P.M . Speakers: Charles Nussbaum Philosophy, University of Texas-Arlington, "The Musical Touch Effect" Nick Zangwill FRIDAY, OCTOBER 29 Philosophy, University of Glasgow, "Against Registration 8:30 A.M. · 4:30 P.M. Washington Plaza Hotel Lobby Emotion: Hanslick Was Right About Music" Commentator: Lydia Goehr A Philosophy, Columbia University U

IN THE BOARD ROOM 2000 PROGRAM COMMITTEE MEETING CHAIR: STEPHEN DAVIES, PHILOSOPHY, UNIVERSITY OF AUCKLAND IDe- IN THE FRANKLIN ROOM FRIDAY, 7:30 A.M. EXPERIENCING THE AESTHETIC Jonathan Gilmore Society of Fellows, Columbia University FRIDAY, OCTOBER 29 Barbara Savedoff SESSION I - 9:00 · 10:50 A.M. Philosophy, Baruch College, CUNY "Photography and Vision" Sarah Worth Philosophy, Miami University·Ohio, la-IN T HE FRANKUN ROOM "Getting into Fiction" DEMOCRACY AND PUBLIC SUPPORT OF THE ARTS Commentator: Allan Casebier Chair: Curtis L. Carter Communications, University of Miami Philosophy, Marquette University Speakers: Paul Mattick Philosophy, Adelphi University, "Art and the IN THE ADAMS AND FRANKLIN ROOMS Mixed Economy: Reflections on NEA vs. Finley" PLENARY SESSION: BEAUTY MAneRS Steven Weil 5:00 - 7:00 P.M. Museum Studies, Smithsonian Institute, "If Content is Out, Aesthetics Must be In" Chair: Peg Brand James Woods PhiIosophy and Gender Studies, Indiana Studio Watts Housing Corporation., Los Angeles, University ~Community Interests and Public Support Speakers: Arthur Danto for the Arts" Philosophy, Emeritus, Columbia University Marcia Muelder Eaton Philosophy, Ib-IN THE ADAMS R OOM lIb-IN THE ADAMS R OOM MARx W ARTOFSKY'S UNFINISHED AESlliETIC THEOR Y STAGING INTERPRETA nONS Berel Lang Chair: James Hamilton Philosophy, Trinity College Philosophy, Kansas State University Gregg M. Horowitz David Sa1tz Philosophy, Vanderbilt University, "Humanizing Theater, University of Georgia-Athens, "\X' hat Praxis and Reflective Praxis: On Marx Theatrical Performance Is (Not): The Wanofsky's Philosophy of Art~ Interpretation Fal lacy" Michael Kelly James Hamilton Philosophy, Columbia University, ~Marx "Interpretations and Performances" Wartofsky's Historical Aesthetics" Commentator: Noel Carroll Tom Huhn Philosophy, University of Wisconsin-Madison Philosophy, Wesleyan University, "Marx Wartofsky and Aesthetic Pleasure" Commentator: Berel Lang lIe-IN THE FRANKLIN ROOM UNDERSTANDING MUSICAL WORKS Chair: Dabney Townsend Ic-IN THE JEFFERSON R OOM Ans and Sciences, Armstrong Adantic State PHILOSOPHY AND LITERATURE: University Speakers: Fred Maus Gary Iseminger Music, University of Virgin ia, "One Way to Ph ilosophy, Carleton College Explain Music· Berys Gaut Lee B. Brown Moral Philosophy, University of St. Andrews, Philosophy, Ohio State University, "Literature and Knowledge" "Phonography, Rock Records, and The Ontology Pradeep Dhillon of Recorded Music" Educational Policy Studies, University of tII inois­ Commentator: David Maier Urbana·Champaign, "Literary Form and Philosophy, Columbia University Philoiophical Argument in Pre- and Early Modern Texts" Commentator: Carol Gould Philosophy, Florida Atlantic University

IN THE BOARD ROOM BOARD OF TRUSTEES LUNCH MEETING 1,00 - 2JO P.M. FRIDAY, OCTOBER 29 SESSION II - 11:10 A.M. - 1:00 P.M.

FRIDAY, OCTOBER 29 IIa-IN THE J EFFERSON R OOM SESSION III . 2:30 - 4:30 P.M. PHILOSOPHICAL THOUGHT IN THE FIlMS OF ERIC ROHMER Chair: Will iam Rothman IlIa-IN THE JEFFERSON R OOM Communications, University of Miami TIMOTHY GOULD'S HEARING THINGS: VOICE AND Speakers: William Rothman METHOD IN mE WRITING OF STANLEY CA VELL Marian Keane Chair: Paul Guyer Film, University of Colorado Philosophy, University of Pennsylvania Daniel Herwitz Speakers: Karen Hanson Philosophy, University of Natal, Durban, South Philosophy, Indiana University Africa Stephen Melville Commentator: Stanley Cavell An History, Ohio State University Philosophy, Emeritus, Commentator: Timothy Gould Metropolitan State College· Denver )tMERlCAN SOCIETY FORjfESTHETICS IIIb-IN THE ADAMS ROOM 1999 BOARD OF DIRECTORS BEAUTY, NEGATIVITY, AND AUTONOMY:

PRESIDENT ART AND SOCIETY IN ADORNO'S AESmETICS Noel Carroll, University of Wisconsin-Madison Speakers: J. M. Bernstein Philosophy, Vanderbilt University,"It is for the VICE-PRESIDENT Sake of the Beautiful That There is No Longer Jerrold Levinson, University of Maryland Beauty, Or, Can Beauty End?" Lambert Zuidervaart SECRETARy-TREASURER Philosophy, Calvin College, "Autonomy, Curtis L. Carter, Marquette University Negativity, and TIlusory Transgression: Menke's Deconstruction of Adorno's Aesthetics" EDITOR-THE JOURNAL OF AES7HE71CS AND AR T CRITICISM Commentator: Max Pensky Philip Alperson, Temple University Philosophy, SUNY Binghamton

TRUSTEES Philip Alperson, Temple University, ex officio TIle-IN THE FRANKLIN ROOM Ted Cohen, University of Chicago THE CRITIQUE FROM DIFFERENCE Tim Gould, Metropolitan State College-Denver Chair: Deborah Fitzgerald Garry Hagberg, Bard College Tryon, Nonh Carolina Karen Hanson, Indiana University Speakers: Larry Shiner Deborah Knight, Queen's University Philosophy, University of Illinois-Springfield, Dominic Lopes, Indiana University-Kokomo "Rewriting the History of Aesthetics with Mary Cynthia Rostankowski, San Jose State University Wollstonecraft" Dabney Townsend, Armstrong Atlantic State University Monique Roelofs Julie Van Camp, California State University-Long Beach Pembroke Center for Teaching and Research on Women, , "Addressing and 1999 PROGRAM COMMrITEE CHAIR Sharing; The Aesthetic as a Sphere of Public Stanley Bates, Middlebury College Exchange" Commentator: Sondra Bacharach PROGRAM COlv1MfITEE MEMBERS Philosophy, Ohio State University Curtis L. Carter, Marquette University Angela Curran, Mt. Holyoke College Francis Dauer, University of California-Santa Barbara Garry Hagberg, Bard College James Hamilton, Kansas State University Karen Hanson, Indiana University Patricia Herzog, Brookline, Massachusetts Stephen Melville, Ohio State University IN THE ADAMS AND FRANKLIN ROOMS BUSINESS MEETING LOCAL ARRANGEMENTS CHAIR 00 -6,00 P.M. John Brown, University of Maryland-College Park

ACKNO\VLEDG~1ENTS IN THE WASHINGTON ROOM University of Maryland-College Park for host and support PLENARY SESSION Washington Plaza Hotel for accommodations Scholar's Choice for book exhibit A READING BY POET LINDA PASTAN Author of: Nicole K. Hauser for program design and layout Cami-;;al Evening, An Early After-Life, Heroes in Disguise, The Impe1ect Paradise, The Five Stages ofGrief, Aspects ofEve and Others Introduction: Stanley Bates, Philosophy, Middlebury College The American Society for Aesthetics Marquette University 6,15-7,15 P.M. Cudahy Hall 404 PO Box 1881 Milwaukee, WI 53201-1881 414-288-7831 phone, 414-288-5415 fax [email protected] http:\\www.aesthetics-online.org IN THE NATIONAL HALL FRIDAY NIGHT RECEPTION Printed by Anderson Graphics 7,30-9,00 P.M. SAllJRDAY, OCTOBER 30 SAllJRDAY, OCTOBER 30 Registration 8:30 A.M. - 4:30 P.M. Washington Plaza Hotel Lobby SESSION II - 11: 10 A.M. - 1:00 P.M. SESSION I - 9:00 - 10:50 A.M.

ITa-IN THE JEFFERSON ROOM THE SIllJATION OF PAINTING AFTER MICHAEL la-IN THE JEFFERSON ROOM FRIED'S ART AND OBJECmOOD THE LOVE OF ART: PIERRE BOURDIEU ON TASTE, Chair: Stephen Melville CLASS, AND AESTHETIC AUTONOMY An History, Ohio State University Speakers: Sally Markowitz Speakers: Richard Moran Philosophy, Willamette University, Philosophy, Harvard University "Disinterest and its Discontents" Norton Batkin Paul Mattick Philosophy, Bard College Philosophy, Adelphi University, "Class Taste" Howard Singerman Alan Wallach Art History, ArtlArt History, College of William and Commentator: Michael Fried Mary, "The Love of Art Thirty Years Later" Art History, Johns Hopkins University Commentator: Susan Weisser English, Adelphi University ITb-1N THE ADAMS ROOM THE ANALYSIS OF THE AESTHETIC Ib-IN THE ADAMS ROOM Chair: Casey Haskins JOSEPH MARGOLIS' WHAT, AFTER ALL, Philosophy, SUNY Purchase ISA WORK OF AR T? Speakers: John MacKinnon Chair: Peter Lamarque Philosophy, St. Mary's University, "Heroism and Philosophy, University of Hull Reversal: Sibley on Aesthetic Supervenience" Speakers: Susan Feagin Jason Kawall Philosophy. University of Missouri-Kansas City Philosophy, Brown University, John Carvalho "Ideal Observers and Aesthetics" Philosophy, Villanova University Commentator: Robert Stecker Commentator: Joseph Margolis Philosophy, Central Michigan University Philosophy, Temple University

lie-IN THE FRANKLIN ROOM Ic-IN THE FRANKLIN ROOM FICTIONALITY AND PHILOSOPHY THE 'OTHER' AND THE IMAGE OF THE OTHER Chair: Nickolas Pappas Philosophy, CUNY, City College Chair: Hilde Hein Speakers: Ira Newman Philosophy, College of the Holy Cross Philosophy, Mansfield University, "It·s the Speakers: Yuriko Saito Thought that Counts: Dissolving the Paradox:of Philosophy, Rhode Island School of Design, "An­ Compassion for Fictions" based Aesthetics vs. Everyday Aesthetics~ Gary Kemp Claire Detels Philosophy, University of Glasgow, Music, University of Arkansas, "Is Cia-Cia-San "Wittgenstein and Beckett" Puccini's 'Other'? Gender and Race in the Commentator: Alex Neill Leitmotifs of Puccini's Madame Butterfly" Mora.1 Philosophy, University of St. Andrews Elizabeth Ann Dobie Human Studies, Alfred University, "Hair Art: Identity Matters" Commentator: Estella Lauter SAllJRDAY, OCTOBER 30 English, University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh SESSION III . 2:30 - 4:30 P.M.

IlIa-IN THE JEFFERSON ROOM ELLEN HANDLER SPITZ'S PICTURING CHIWHOOD SPONSORED BY THE COMMITfEE ON AESTHETIC EDUCATION Chair: Dominic Lopes Philosophy, Indiana University-Kokomo SESSION lila (con't.) Speakers: Tom Leddy Philosophy, San Jose State University Karen Haas ~ERICAN San jose, California Gareth Matthews Philosophy, University of Massachusetts­ Amherst Cynthia Rostankowski Philosophy, San jose State University SOCIETY FOR Commentator: Ellen Handler Spitz Art History, ~STHETICS IN THE H OTEL RESTAURANT ALCOVE LUNCHEON FOR COMMIITEE ON AESTHETIC EDUCATION 1,00 - no P.M. 57th ANNUAL MEETING fib-IN THE ADAMS ROOM ORNAMENT, FUNCTION, AND TRUTH: ADORNO AND WASHINGTON PLAZA HOTEL HEIDEGGER/PHILOSOPHY AND ARCHITECTURE OCTOBER 27-30, 1999 Fred L. Rush,jr. Philosophy, University of Kansas Speakers: Andrew Benjamin Philosophy, University of Warwick, "Ornament's Function Today: Adorno, Loos and the Philosophy of Architecture" Fred l. Rush,jr. WASHINGTON, DC "Heidegger on the Truth of Architecture" Commentator: Tom Brockelman Philosophy, Le Moyne College fie-IN THE FRANKLIN ROOM KANT IHEGEL/NIETZSCHE Chair: Richard Eldridge Philosophy, Swarthmore College Speakers: Eric Boynton Philosophy, Rice University, ~Beauty, Truth, and the Strife Between Nature and Art in K:mt and Hegel" Gary Shapiro Philosophy, University of Richmond, ~This Is Not a Christ: Nietzsche's Transfiguration of Raphael~ AN ASSOCIATION FOR AESTHETICS, Philip Pothen Philosophy, University of Sussex, "The Case of CRITICISM, AND THE THEORY OF ARTS Wagner: Nietzsche, Decadence, and the End of An" Commentator: Rachel Nussbaum History, Cornell University

HOST AND SUPPORT FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND, COLLEGE PARK