European Ornamental Garden Flora As an Invasion Debt Under Climate Change
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Erschienen in: Journal of Applied Ecology ; 55 (2018), 5. - S. 2386-2395. https://dx.doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.13197 European ornamental garden flora as an invasion debt under climate change Emily Haeuser1,2 Պ|Պ)-m; -vom3 Պ|Պ)bѴ=ub;7$_bѴѴ;u4 Պ|Պ"|;=-m ѴѴbm];u5 Պ|Պ ";mf-Ѵo1h6 Պ|ՊѴb;uovv7ou=6 Պ|Պ-u|--u0omb4 Պ|Պbv-om|b7 Պ|Պ om- ѴѴbm];u5,8Պ|Պ u-m vvѴ5 Պ|Պুm|_;uѴomm;u5 Պ|Պ b;|l-uov;u5 Պ|Պ $-l-u-ুmh;lুѴѴ;u4Պ|Պ-7-Ѵbm-u;r-6Պ|Պ-||_;(ĺ$-ѴѴ|o4 Պ|ՊoѴ];uu;=|9 Պ|Պ -m;u]Ѵ10 Պ|Պ;|u;h10,11 Պ|Պ-|ub1h);b];Ѵ|9 Պ|Պ-u|;m)bm|;u12 Պ|Պ-u|bm Hermy13 Պ|Պ";0-v|b--m(-m7;u(;h;m14Պ|Պubv|bm-!ot;|4 Պ|Պ-uh-mѴ;m;m2,15 1boѴo]ķ"-m b;]o"|-|;&mb;uvb|ķ"-m b;]oķ-Ѵb=oumb-ĸ2 ;r-u|l;m|o=boѴo]ķ&mb;uvb|o=omv|-mķomv|-mķ;ul-mĸ3omv;u-|bom 1oѴo] uorķ ;r-u|l;m|o=bov1b;m1;vķ u_-l&mb;uvb|ķ u_-lķ&ĸƓ Ŋ-0ou-|obu;7Ľ 1oѴo]b;Ѵrbm;ķ!"ķ&mbĺ"-ob;om|ŊѴ-m1ķ&mbĺu;mo0Ѵ; Ѵr;vķu;mo0Ѵ;ķ u-m1;ĸ5o|-m-m7bo7b;uvb|!;v;-u1_ķ -1Ѵ|o=b=;"1b;m1;vķ&mb;uvb|o=(b;mm-ķ(b;mm-ķv|ub-ĸ6mv|b||;o= oѴ|bomş -1Ѵ|o="1b;m1;vķ&mb;uvb|o="o|_o_;lb-ķݭ;vh࣐7࣒fob1;ķ ;r-u|l;m|o=o|-mķ 1oѴo]ķ&mb;uvb|o=$ু0bm];mķ$ু0bm];mķ;ul-mĸ7 ;1_!;r0Ѵb1ĸ8mv|b||;o="o1b-Ѵ 1oѴo]ķ -1Ѵ|=oum|;u7bv1brѴbm-u"|7b;vķѴrv7ub-&mb;uvb|ķ(b;mm-ķv|ub-ĸ9bo7b;uvb|ķ-1uo;1oѴo]-m7 bo];o]u-r_ķ&mb;uvb|o=o;||bm];mķक़||bm];mķ;ul-mĸ10 ;r-u|l;m|o=m-vbom 1oѴo]ķmv|b||;o=o|-mķ$_;;1_1-7;lo="1b;m1;vķ uৄ_omb1;ķ;1_!;r0Ѵb1ĸ11 ;r-u|l;m|o= 1oѴo]ķ -1Ѵ|o="1b;m1;ķ_-uѴ;v&mb;uvb|ķu-];ķ;1_!;r0Ѵb1ĸ12;ul-m;m|u;=oum|;]u-|b; bo7b;uvb|!;v;-u1_ķ-ѴѴ;Ŋ;m-Ŋ;brb]ķ;brb]ķ;ul-mĸ13 bbvbomo= ou;v|ķ-|u;-m7-m7v1-r;ķ ;r-u|l;m|o= -u|_ş mbuoml;m|-Ѵ"1b;m1;vķ& Leuven, Leuven, Belgium; ƐƓ!;]bom--Ѵ-m7v1_-rѴ;bm;;muo|;;|;ķ-v|;uѴ;;ķ;Ѵ]bl-m715,_;fb-m]uobm1b-Ѵ;-0ou-|ouo=Ѵ-m| oѴ|bom-u 1oѴo]-m7omv;u-|bomķ$-b_o&mb;uvb|ķ$-b_oķ_bm- ouu;vrom7;m1; lbѴ-;v;uķboѴo]ķ"-m b;]o"|-|; Abstract &mb;uvb|ķ"-m b;]oķĺ Ɛĺ ov| m-|u-Ѵbv;7 -m7 bm-vb; -Ѵb;m rѴ-m| vr;1b;v ;u; oub]bm-ѴѴbm|uo71;7|o l-bѴĹ;_-;v;uŠv7vĺ;7 u;]bomv=ou_ou|b1Ѵ|u-Ѵrurov;vĺo;;uķl-mu;]bomvmo=-1;-mbm-vbom 7;0|=uoloum-l;m|-Ѵ-Ѵb;mvr;1b;vķ_b1__-;mo|;|m-|u-Ѵbv;7ĺm|_bvu;]-u7ķ 1Ѵbl-|;1_-m];u;ru;v;m|v-|_u;-|-vb|l-Ѵo;u|_;0-uub;uv|om-|u-Ѵbv-|bom =ouvol;oum-l;m|-Ѵ-Ѵb;mvr;1b;vĺ7;m|b=bm]|_ov;vr;1b;vbv;|u;l;Ѵblrou- |-m|=ou-m|b1br-|bm]blr;m7bm]bm-vbomvĺ Ƒĺ $ob7;m|b=ru;7b1|ouvo=m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomķ;lo7;ѴѴ;7|_;;==;1|vo=1Ѵbl-|;ķmuv- ;u--bѴ-0bѴb|-m7vr;1b;v1_-u-1|;ubv|b1vom|_;1uu;m| uor;-mm-|u-Ѵbv-|bom v11;vvo=ƑķƏƕƒoum-l;m|-Ѵ-Ѵb;mv1ollomѴrѴ-m|;7bm uor;-m]-u7;mvĺ); |_;mv;7|_;u;vѴ|bm]lo7;Ѵ|o];|_;ub|_1Ѵbl-|;ruof;1|bomv=ouƑƏƔƏ|o=ou;- 1-v|=|u;m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomubvhv=ou|_;ƐķƔѶƒvr;1b;vmo|;|m-|u-Ѵbv;7bm uor;ĺ ƒĺ );=om7|_-|momŊ uor;-mm-|u-Ѵbv;7u-m];vb;ķ1Ѵbl-|b1vb|-0bѴb|ķruor-]Ѵ; ru;vvu;ķ_-bm]-7bo;1bovv;-Ѵvv|;l-m7rѴ-m|_;b]_|fobm|Ѵ;rѴ-bm;71u- u;m|m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv11;vvbm uor;ĺƑƏƔƏķm-|u-Ѵbv-|bomruo0-0bѴb|ruof;1- |bomvbm1u;-v;70lou;|_-mƏĺƐ=ouƓƐvr;1b;vķ-m7omѴ7;1u;-v;70lou;|_-m ƏĺƐ=ouom;vr;1b;vĺ Ɠĺ Policy implications.&vbm]ru;7b1|bomv0-v;7omoubm|;]u-|;7lo7;Ѵo=-Ѵb;moum-- l;m|-Ѵm-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv11;vvķ;b7;m|b=b;7vr;1b;vb|__b]_=|u;m-|u-Ѵbv-- |bomubvh-m7vr;1b;vb|__b]_ruof;1|;7bm1u;-v;vbmm-|u-Ѵbv-|bomro|;m|b-Ѵbm Konstanzer Online-Publikations-System (KOPS) URL: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bsz:352-2-1sosdlh5c1ph79 ƑƒѶƕ uor;m7;u1Ѵbl-|;1_-m];ĺ$_bvvr;1b;vѴbv|-ѴѴov=ouruboub|bv-|bomo=lomb|ou- bm]-m7u;]Ѵ-|bomo=oum-l;m|-ѴrѴ-m|v|olb|b]-|;|_;bm-vbom7;0|ĺ +)! " 0boѴo]b1-Ѵbm-vbomvķ1Ѵbl-|b1vb|-0bѴb|ķ]-u7;mrѴ-m|vķbm-vbomlo7;ѴѴbm]ķbm-vb;rѴ-m|vķ m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv11;vvķruor-]Ѵ;ru;vvu;ķubvh-vv;vvl;m| ƐՊ Պ$! &$ ";;u-Ѵ=-1|ouvo|_;u|_-m1Ѵbl-|b1vb|-0bѴb|_-;0;;mѴbmh;7 |om-|u-Ѵbv-|bom-m7m;;7|o0;1omvb7;u;7_;m-vv;vvbm]-vr;- u;;m|bm]-Ѵb;mvr;1b;vbm-vbomvbv-]Ѵo0-Ѵ;mbuoml;m|-Ѵrubou- 1b;vĽm-|u-Ѵbv-|bomro|;m|b-ѴŐ!b1_-u7vomş;hķƑƏƐƑőĺ$_;v;bm- b| Ő";1u;|-ub-| o= |_; om;m|bom om boѴo]b1-Ѵ b;uvb|ķ ƑƏƏƏőĺ 1Ѵ7;_b]_ruor-]Ѵ;ru;vvu;Ő ;_m;mŊ"1_l|ķ$o-ķ;uubm]vķ Ѵo0-ѴѴķ-Ѵu;-7o;uƐƒķƏƏƏ-Ѵb;m-v1Ѵ-urѴ-m|vr;1b;v_-;;v- ş )bѴѴb-lvomķ ƑƏƏƕ-ĸ oѴ-u ş o7];ķ ƑƏƏƐĸ o1hoo7ķ -vv;ķ |-0Ѵbv_;7 r;uvbv|;m| bѴ7 rorѴ-|bomv o|vb7; o= 1Ѵ|b-|bom Ő;h ş Ѵ-1h0umķ ƑƏƏƔőķ m-|u-Ѵbv-|bom v11;vv ;Ѵv;_;u; Ő;ĺ]ĺ oѴ-u ;|-Ѵĺķ ƑƏƐƕĸ -m Ѵ;m;m ;|-Ѵĺķ ƑƏƐƔő v0v;| o= |_;v; voŊ1-ѴѴ;7 şo7];ķƑƏƏƐĸ-;u;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐƕőķm-|b;u-m];vb;Ő-u;Ѵķ m-|u-Ѵbv;7 vr;1b;v Őv;mv !b1_-u7vom ;|-Ѵĺķ ƑƏƏƏő -u; hmom |o -mvr-1_ķ ু_mķ ;hķ ş -m Ѵ;m;mķ ƑƏƐѵĸ ;h ;|-Ѵĺķ _-;m;]-|b;;1oѴo]b1-Ѵblr-1|v-m7-u;1omvb7;u;7bm-vb;Őv;mv ƑƏƏƖ-ķƑƏƐƔĸ!--m-f-|oo;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐѵő-m71;u|-bmvr;1b;v|u-b|v ";1u;|-ub-|o=|_;om;m|bomomboѴo]b1-Ѵ b;uvb|ķƑƏƏƏőĺov| Ő1_-uo࢙ş-mѴ;m;mķƑƏƏƖĸ-mvr-1_ķু_mķ;hķoovķ m-|u-Ѵbv;7-Ѵb;mrѴ-m|v_-;oub]bm-ѴѴ0;;mbm|uo71;7bm|;m|bom-ѴѴ şѴo|ķƑƏƏѶĸ;hķub-m;hķş-uoझhķƑƏƏƖ0ĸ;h;|-Ѵĺķ =uol|_;bum-|b;u;]bomvbm|oo|_;uu;]bomv=ou1Ѵ|b-|bombm7ol;v- ƑƏƏƖ-ķ ƑƏƐƔĸ !--m-f-|oo ;|-Ѵĺķ ƑƏƐѵĸ -m Ѵ;m;mķ -vomķ |b1ou0o|-mb1]-u7;mvŐ-mѴ;m;m;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐѶőĺb;m|_-|]Ѵo0-ѴѴķ "1_Ѵ-;r=;uķ ;v1_h;ķ ş bv1_;uķ ƑƏƐƏőĺ ou;o;uķ |_; 7ub;uv o= -|Ѵ;-v|ƐƕƏķƏƏƏrѴ-m|vr;1b;v-u;bm1Ѵ|b-|bomŐ-mѴ;m;m;|-Ѵĺķ m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv11;vvl-bm|;u-1|Őুv|;uķু_mķu;Ѵ_;b7;ķş ƑƏƐѶőķ|_;]-u7;m=Ѵou-1omv|b||;v-m;moulovrooѴo=ro|;m|b-Ѵ Ѵo|ķƑƏƏѶőĺ"o=-uķ=;v|7b;v_-;;-lbm;7_om-|u-Ѵbv-|bom -Ѵb;mbm-7;uvŐ;u]Ѵ;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐѵőĺ v11;vvbvbm=Ѵ;m1;7fobm|Ѵ0-ѴѴo=|_;v;=-1|ouv-m7|_;bubm|;u- m uor;ķcĺƓķƏƏƏ-Ѵb;mrѴ-m|vr;1b;v-u;1uu;m|Ѵm-|u-Ѵbv;7 -1|bomvķ-m7mom;_-;v;7|_bv-rruo-1_|o=ou;1-v|ro|;m|b-Ѵ Ő;h;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐƕĸ-mѴ;m;m;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐƔőķ-m7|_;ml0;ubvv|bѴѴ =|u;m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomvĺ bm1u;-vbm] Ő";;0;mv ;|-Ѵĺķ ƑƏƐƕőĺ u;;m|bm] =|u; m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv ;u;ķ;=bѴѴ|_bv]-r01ol0bmbm]1Ѵbl-|b1vb|-0bѴb|7-|-b|_ u;tbu;vb7;m|b=bm]vr;1b;vb|_m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomro|;m|b-Ѵĺm;1ol- 7-|-omruor-]Ѵ;ru;vvu;ķm-|u-Ѵbv;7u-m];vb;o|vb7;o= uor;ķ lomv|u-|;]bv|oru;;m|bm|uo71|bomvo=vr;1b;v|_-|-u;bm-vb; m-|b;u-m];vb;ķ-m7v;;u-Ѵvr;1b;v|u-b|vŐ]uo|_=oulķru;v;m1; ;Ѵv;_;u;Ő;ĺ]ĺ_;Ѵom]ķ)bѴѴb-lvķş-ѴѴoķƐƖƖƖőĺ$_bv-rruo-1_ķ o=v|ou-];ou]-mvķruor-]-|boml;|_o7ķv;-Ѵvv|;lķrѴ-m|_;b]_| _o;;uķb]mou;v|_;ubvhrov;70-Ѵb;mvr;1b;v|_-|_-;-Ѵu;-7 -m7bm|;u_-u7bm;vvő|o0bѴ7-r_Ѵo];m;|b1-ѴѴ1ouu;1|;7lo7;Ѵo= 0;;m bm|uo71;7 -v ]-u7;m rѴ-m|v 0| _-; mo| ;| 0;1ol; m-|- uor;-mm-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv11;vv=ouƑķƏƕƒvr;1b;vo=|_; uor;-m u-Ѵbv;7ĺv|_;u;bvo=|;m-|bl;ŊѴ-]0;|;;mbm|uo71|bom-m7m-|- -u7;m Ѵou-ŐѴѴ;mķm;;vķ0;ķş"_-ķƑƏƐƑőĺ&vbm]vb|-0bѴ- u-Ѵbv-|bom Ő vvѴ ;|-Ѵĺķ ƑƏƐƐĸ o-ubhķ ;hķ u-1_ķ !;fl࢙m;hķ ş b| ruof;1|bomv 0-v;7 om u;1;m| -m7 ruof;1|;7 =|u; 1Ѵbl-|;vķ; )-7;ķƐƖƖƔőķb|bvѴbh;Ѵ|_-|vol;o=|_;|_ov-m7vo=-Ѵu;-7bm|uo- =ou;1-v|=|u;ruo0-0bѴb|o=m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv11;vv=ou|_;ƐķƔѶƒ 71;7]-u7;mrѴ-m|vbm uor;bѴѴm-|u-Ѵbv;-m70;1ol;bm-vb; mo|Ŋ;|Ŋm-|u-Ѵbv;7oum-l;m|-Ѵ-Ѵb;mvr;1b;vĺ$_bvruob7;v-Ѵbv|o= bm|_;=|u;ĺ vr;1b;vlov|Ѵbh;Ѵ|om-|u-Ѵbv;bm uor;bm|_;m;-u=|u;ĺ -moum-l;m|-Ѵvr;1b;v-u;0;bm]1Ѵ|b-|;7-|Ѵ-|b|7;v_b]_;u |_-m |_ov; o= |_;bu m-|u-Ѵ 7bv|ub0|bomv Ő(-m 7;u (;h;mķ ;ulķ (;ѴѴ;m7ķm-r;mķş(;u_;;mķƑƏƏѶőķ-m7|_;bu-0bѴb||om-|u-Ѵbv;7 ƑՊ Պ$ !" $ " bvѴbh;ѴѴblb|;70v0or|bl-Ѵ1Ѵbl-|;Ő0|v;;-ѴѴb;m;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐѵőĺ m]obm]1Ѵbl-|;1_-m];l-Ѵo;u|_bv0-uub;u=oul-m-Ѵb;moum-- ); lo7;ѴѴ;7 u;1;m| m-|u-Ѵbv-|bom v11;vv -m7 =|u; m-|u-Ѵbv-- l;m|-ѴvŐ)-Ѵ|_;u;|-ѴĺķƑƏƏƖőĺ$_;v;ro|;m|b-Ѵ=|u;bm-7;uv-u; |bomubvho=ƑķƏƕƒ-Ѵb;moum-l;m|-ѴrѴ-m|vbm uor;bm|_u;;v|;rv 1omvb7;u;7|o0;-mbm-vbom7;0|Ő vvѴ;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐƐőĺ$_uo]_1Ѵbl-|; Ő b]u;ƐőĺŐ-ő$o;v|bl-|;|_;u;1;m|-m7=|u;1Ѵbl-|b1vb|-0bѴb| l-|1_bm]o=|_;m-|b;-m7momŊm-|b;u-m];vķb|bvrovvb0Ѵ;|oru;- =ou;-1_vr;1b;vbm uor;ķ;=buv|lo7;ѴѴ;7|_;Ѵbmh0;|;;mu;- 7b1|bm-vbomv11;vvŐ-;vş-uuķƑƏƏѶőĺ&vbm]1Ѵbl-|b1vb|-0bѴ- 1;m|1Ѵbl-|;v-m7vr;1b;vru;v;m1;o|vb7;o= uor;-m7ruof;1|;7 b|lo7;ѴѴbm]ķ ѴѴbm];u;|-ѴĺŐƑƏƐƕőv_o;7|_-||_;m-|u-Ѵbv-|bom |_bvom|o uor;=ou|_;u;1;m|-m7=|u;ruof;1|;71Ѵbl-|;vĺŐ0ő); ubvh=uoloum-l;m|-Ѵ-Ѵb;mvr;1b;vbѴѴbm1u;-v;=oul1_o= uor; |_;mv;7u;1;m|1Ѵbl-|b1vb|-0bѴb|bm1ol0bm-|bomb|_o|_;uvr;- m7;uruof;1|;7=|u;1Ѵbl-|;vĺ7;m|b=bm]|_;ubvhb;v|oum-l;m|-Ѵ 1b;v1_-u-1|;ubv|b1v|o7;;Ѵor-lbmbl-Ѵlo7;Ѵ;rѴ-bmbm]1uu;m| vr;1b;vbv;vv;m|b-Ѵ|oru;;m|m;m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomvķ-m7|o-vvu;|_-| m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv11;vvo=|_;vr;1b;vbm uor;ĺŐ1ő bm-ѴѴķ=ou|_; l-m-];l;m|u;vou1;v-u;mo|-v|;7omvr;1b;v|_-|rov;Ѵ;vvubvh v0v;|o=vr;1b;vmo|;|m-|u-Ѵbv;7bm uor;ķ;r-u-l;|;ubv;7 m7;u=|u;1Ѵbl-|b11om7b|bomvĺ |_; lo7;Ѵ b|_ u;1;m| -m7 ruof;1|;7 =|u; 1Ѵbl-|b1 vb|-0bѴb||o ƑƒѶѶՊ (a) Climatic suitability Species distribution data Climate Occurrences Pseudo-absences Recent climates Future climates GBIF Randomly-generated WorldClim: 6 bioclim vars Horizon 2050: RCP 4.5 Global, excluding Europe Europe only Europe only Distribution modeling Ensemble projections Models weighted by TSS GLM, GAM, RF, and GBM algorithms Recent Future Recent median Future median climatic suitability climatic suitability (b) Naturalization success modeling (c) Naturalization risk projections Predictors Single-variable and Minimum adequate Recent median two-way interaction model climatic suitability model testing Native range size Naturalized range size Saturated model predict function Availability in nurseries Recent median Future median Species traits Saturated model Growth form climatic suitability climatic suitability Storage organs reduction Winter hardiness Propagation method Sexual system Height Minimum adequate model Recent risk Future risk Model quality testing &! ƐՊ)ouh=Ѵoo=-m-Ѵ|b1-Ѵl;|_o7vķbm1Ѵ7bm]Ő-ő1Ѵbl-|b1vb|-0bѴb|lo7;ѴѴbm]ĸŐ0őm-|u-Ѵbv-|bomv11;vvlo7;ѴѴbm]ĸŐ1őu;1;m| -m7=|u;m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomubvhruof;1|bomvo=momŊm-|u-Ѵbv;7-Ѵb;mvr;1b;vĺ"oѴb7Ѵbm;vbm7b1-|;o0f;1|vŐ;ĺ]ĺvr;1b;v1_-u-1|;ubv|b1vķlo7;Ѵvķ ruof;1|bomvő-m77-v_;7Ѵbm;vbm7b1-|;-m-Ѵ|b1-Ѵl;|_o7vŐ;ĺ]ĺlo7;Ѵu;71|bomőĺbh;1oѴouvbm7b1-|;|;ulv1-uub;7o;u0;|;;m|_;|_u;; v|;rv -vv;vv|_;-0voѴ|;=|u;m-|u-Ѵbv-|bomubvh-m7|_;1_-m];bmm-|- |;lr;u-|u;|oѴ;u-m1;vķv;;0;Ѵoő;u;--bѴ-0Ѵ;=ouƑķƏƕƒvr;1b;v u-Ѵbv-|bomubvh=uol|_-|m7;uu;1;m|1Ѵbl-|;vĺ -Ѵb;m|o uor;ĺ ); v;Ѵ;1|;7 vr;1b;v =uol |_; uor;-m -u7;m Ѵou- Ő ķ ѴѴ;m;|-ѴĺķƑƏƐƑőķ-m;m11Ѵor-;7b-o=ƻƑƒķƏƏƏvr;1b;v-m7-ub- ƑĺƐՊ Պ"r;1b;v1_-u-1|;ubv|b1v ;|b;v1ollomѴrѴ-m|;7bm uor;-m]-u7;mvķo=_b1_c.