Hate Speech, Racism and Other Discriminatory Behaviour in Sport

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Hate Speech, Racism and Other Discriminatory Behaviour in Sport STANDING COMMITTEE (T-RV) EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON SPECTATOR VIOLENCE AND MISBEHAVIOUR AT SPORT EVENTS AND IN PARTICULAR AT FOOTBALL MATCHES Strasbourg, 14 September 2020 T-RV(2020)6 FINAL Hate speech, racism and other discriminatory behaviour in sport Report of the topical tour de table of the 48th T-RV meeting (Strasbourg, 5-6 June 2019) Prepared by the Secretariat Adopted by written procedure T-RV(2020)6 Table of Contents 1. Background ............................................................................................................................ 4 2. Work of the Council of Europe ............................................................................................ 6 i) PACE… ...........................................................................................................................................6 ii) European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) ...............................................................................9 iii) European Commission against Racism and Intolerance (ECRI) ............................................14 iv) «No Hate Speech Movement» Youth Campaign .......................................................................16 3. Update by States Parties, Observers and guests ............................................................... 21 i) Austria …………………………………………………………………………………………...22 ii) Azerbaijan .....................................................................................................................................23 iii) Belgium .........................................................................................................................................23 iv) Bulgaria .........................................................................................................................................24 v) Croatia ...........................................................................................................................................24 vi) Cyprus …………………………………………………………………………………………...24 vii) Czech Republic .............................................................................................................................24 viii) Estonia ...........................................................................................................................................24 ix) Finland ..........................................................................................................................................25 x) France. ...........................................................................................................................................25 xi) Germany .......................................................................................................................................28 xii) Greece. ...........................................................................................................................................29 xiii) Italy………………………………………………………………………………………………30 xiv) Lithuania .......................................................................................................................................30 xv) Monaco ..........................................................................................................................................31 xvi) Netherlands ...................................................................................................................................31 xvii) Norway ..........................................................................................................................................32 xviii) Portugal .........................................................................................................................................32 xix) Poland. ...........................................................................................................................................32 xx) Romania ........................................................................................................................................33 xxi) Russian Federation.......................................................................................................................33 xxii) Serbia.. ...........................................................................................................................................33 xxiii) Slovakia .........................................................................................................................................34 xxiv) Slovenia .........................................................................................................................................35 xxv) Spain……………………………………………………………………………………………...35 xxvi) Sweden...........................................................................................................................................35 2 T-RV(2020)6 xxvii) Switzerland .................................................................................................................................36 xxviii) Turkey ........................................................................................................................................36 xxix) United Kingdom ...........................................................................................................................36 4. Update by Observers ........................................................................................................... 37 i) Georgia ..........................................................................................................................................37 ii) Israel… ..........................................................................................................................................38 iii) Centre for Access to Football in Europe (CAFE) ......................................................................39 iv) Football Supporters Europe (FSE) .............................................................................................39 v) Supporters Direct Europe (SD Europe) .....................................................................................39 vi) UEFA… .........................................................................................................................................40 vii) FIFA……………………………………………………………………………………………...41 5. Update by Guests ................................................................................................................. 41 i) European Group of Safety and Security Experts (Think Tank)..............................................41 6. Future steps .......................................................................................................................... 42 7. Appendixes ........................................................................................................................... 43 Appendix 1 - Programme - Tour de table on racism and discrimination in sport…. .......... 43 Appendix 2 - Council of Europe - Inclusion and Anti-Discrimination programmes - Mission statement .............................................................................................................. 44 Appendix 3 - Council of Europe’s “No Hate Speech Movement” Youth Campaign ............ 46 Appendix 4 - Council of Europe - Conclusions of the Evaluation Conference of the No Hate Speech Movement Youth Campaign ................................................................. 54 Appendix 5 - Contribution from Belgium ................................................................................ 58 Appendix 6 - Contribution from France ................................................................................... 94 Appendix 7 - UEFA Safety and Security Regulations (edition 2019) ................................... 105 Appendix 8 - Contribution from FIFA .................................................................................... 109 Appendix 9 - Links to relevant sources ................................................................................... 111 3 T-RV(2020)6 1. Background Fighting all types of discrimination and hate speech has been and will continue to be one of the Council of Europe priorities and challenges, since it undermines the core values of democratic societies. The European Convention on Spectator Violence (ETS No. 120), or T-RV Convention, from 1985, in its Article 1 (Aim of the Convention), paragraph 1, establishes a positive obligation for the States Parties to prevent and fight against violence and misbehaviour: “The Parties, with a view to preventing and controlling violence and misbehaviour by spectators at football matches, undertake, within the limits of their respective constitutional provisions, to take the necessary steps to give effect to the provisions of this Convention”. Furthermore, Article 3 (Measures), paragraph 1, stresses the need to bring this positive obligation into practice: “The Parties undertake to ensure the formulation and implementation of measures designed to prevent and control violence and misbehaviour by spectators”. The topic of hate speech and discrimination was always a matter of concern both for the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) and the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe, in particular, in the case of sports events, since the adoption of the T-RV Convention. The PACE, recalling the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the T-RV Convention, adopted in 1999 an innovative Recommendation on football hooliganism - Recommendation 1434 (1999).
Recommended publications
  • The Portrayal of Black Female Athletes in Children's Picturebooks
    Strides Toward Equality: The Portrayal of Black Female Athletes in Children’s Picturebooks Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Rebekah May Bruce, M.A. Graduate Program in Education: Teaching and Learning The Ohio State University 2018 Dissertation Committee: Michelle Ann Abate, Advisor Patricia Enciso Ruth Lowery Alia Dietsch Copyright by Rebekah May Bruce 2018 Abstract This dissertation examines nine narrative non-fiction picturebooks about Black American female athletes. Contextualized within the history of children’s literature and American sport as inequitable institutions, this project highlights texts that provide insights into the past and present dominant cultural perceptions of Black female athletes. I begin by discussing an eighteen-month ethnographic study conducted with racially minoritized middle school girls where participants analyzed picturebooks about Black female athletes. This chapter recognizes Black girls as readers and intellectuals, as well as highlights how this project serves as an example of a white scholar conducting crossover scholarship. Throughout the remaining chapters, I rely on cultural studies, critical race theory, visual theory, Black feminist theory, and Marxist theory to provide critical textual and visual analysis of the focal picturebooks. Applying these methodologies, I analyze the authors and illustrators’ representations of gender, race, and class. Chapter Two discusses the ways in which the portrayals of track star Wilma Rudolph in Wilma Unlimited and The Quickest Kid in Clarksville demonstrate shifting cultural understandings of Black female athletes. Chapter Three argues that Nothing but Trouble and Playing to Win draw on stereotypes of Black Americans as “deviant” in order to construe tennis player Althea Gibson as a “wild child.” Chapter Four discusses the role of family support in the representations of Alice Coachman in Queen of the Track and Touch the Sky.
    [Show full text]
  • Anti-Black Racism and the Foreign Black Other: Constructing Blackness and the Sporting Migrant
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Illinois Digital Environment for Access to Learning and Scholarship Repository ANTI-BLACK RACISM AND THE FOREIGN BLACK OTHER: CONSTRUCTING BLACKNESS AND THE SPORTING MIGRANT BY MUNENE FRANJO MWANIKI DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology in the Graduate College of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2014 Urbana, Illinois Doctoral Committee: Associate Professor Margaret Kelley, Chair Professor Tim Liao Associate Professor Moon-Kie Jung Associate Professor Monica McDermott ABSTRACT The popularity and globalization of sport has led to an ever-increasing black athletic labor migration from the global South to, primarily, the U.S. and Western European countries. While the hegemonic ideology surrounding sport is that it brings different people together and ameliorates social boundaries, sociologists of sport have shown this to be a gross simplification. Instead, sport is often seen to reinforce and recreate social stereotypes and boundaries, especially as it regards race and the black athlete in body and culture. At best we can think of sport as a contested terrain for both maintaining and challenging racial norms and boundaries. The mediated black athlete has thus always, for better or worse, impacted popular white perceptions of blackness broadly and globally. While much work has been done to expose the workings of race and racism in sport, studies have tended to homogenize black populations and have not taken into account the varying histories and complexities of, specifically, black African migrant athletes.
    [Show full text]
  • Relationship Marketing in Sports – the Fan Perspective
    CHAPTER 4 Relationship Marketing in Sports – The Fan Perspective Learning Outcomes CONTENTS On completion of this chapter the reader should be able to: Overview of Chapter - describe the nature of supporters Introduction - explain why fans are so important for professional sporting organisations The Importance of - provide examples of special offers to fans Fans for Professional Sporting - discuss the various opportunities for sporting organisations to obtain information about their fans Organisations - describe how sporting organisations can react to fans’ complaints The Nature of Fans - illustrate how sports entities can build good relationships with their fans The Relationship Between Sporting Organisations and their Fans OVERVIEW OF CHAPTER Establishing and Maintaining Healthy This chapter starts off with a brief section on the importance of fans for Relationships with professional sporting organisations, followed by a detailed description of the Fans nature of sports fans. Then the relationship between sports entities and their Conclusions fans will be analysed and specific examples of relationship marketing Discussion Questions instruments provided. The chapter includes various case studies, involving the English Football Association as well as clubs from the NHL, the NBA and Guided Reading different football leagues around the world. Websites INTRODUCTION Imagine the business of sports without fans. No spectators at sports matches, no buyers of merchandising, no potential customers for sponsoring 63 64 CHAPTER 4: Relationship Marketing in Sports – The Fan Perspective companies, no recipients for the sports media. Such a scenario would be unthinkable. The sports business in general (and professional sporting organisations in particular) need fans who are willing to spend their time, their emotions and their money for their favourite sports team.
    [Show full text]
  • An Agenda for Fairness and Unity
    An Agenda for Fairness and Unity A proactive plan for fairness and unity in our communities, politics, the economy and the law TK THE COMPACT FOR RACIAL JUSTICE T K TABLE OF CONTENTS T K T 1 INTRODUCTION 2 PREAMBLE 5 BUSH OVERVIEW Dominique Apollon: Director of Research, Applied Research Center 10 CIVIL RIGHTS Karin Wang, Esq.:Vice-President, Programs, Asian Pacific American Legal Center Vincent Eng: Deputy Director, Asian American Justice Center 14 BIOTECHNOLOGY Sujatha Jesudason, PhD: Executive Director of Generations Ahead 18 CRIMINAL JUSTICE Ashley Nellis: The Sentencing Project Judy Greene: Policy Analyst, Justice Strategies Patricia Allard: Justice Strategies Tanya Krupat: Program Director, N.Y. Initiative for Children of Incarcerated Parents, The Osborne Association Angelyn Frazer: Families Against Mandatory Minimums 23 GREEN ECONOMIES Van Jones: Founder and President of Green for All 27 HEALTHCARE LeeAnn Hall: Executive Director, Northwest Federation of Community Organizations 31 EDUCATION Tammy Johnson: Director of Strategic Partnerships, Applied Research Center 36 ECONOMY Amaad Rivera: Racial Wealth Divide Director, United for a Fair Economy 40 IMMIGRATION Rinku Sen: President & Executive Director, Applied Research Center Seth Wessler: Research Associate, Applied Research Center TK IN T THE COMPACT FOR RACIAL JUSTICE T RODU INTRODUCTION K T K T The Compact for Racial Justice is a proactive agenda for fairness and unity in our communities, politics, the CT economy and the law. It offers concrete strategies and proposals to reverse racial disparities and move our society towards full equity, inclusion and dignity for all people. The Compact transcends talk of personal prejudice ION with compelling evidence of institutional racism and realistic proactive solutions.
    [Show full text]
  • Anti-Racism Educational Pack
    Anti-Racism Educational Pack www.theredcard.org Compiled by: Kate Hollinshead Written by: Kate Hollinshead, Sarah Soyei, Lizz Bennett, Laura Pidcock, Simon Richards, Jo Wallis. Special thanks go to: Amnesty International, Christopher Bloore, Catch22, ChildLine, Patti DeRosa, Chris Derrington (University of Northampton), Echo Research Company, GLSEN, Paul Kearns, Dee Kinning, Berenice Miles, NASUWT, Luke Scanlon (guardian.co.uk), Chris Stokes, TNS Media, Tony Waddle, Michael Wood (BBC). Major Sponsors 2 ANTI-RACISM EDUCATION PACK This education pack has been developed collaboratively with help and support from many organisations and individuals. Show Racism the Red Card would like to thank everyone for their valuable contributions. CONTENTS Introduction to Racism 07 Where does Racism come from?: Exploring Stereotypes and the Influence of the Media 12 The History of Racism 19 Experiences of Racism 25 Dealing with and Campaigning against Racism 32 Celebrating Diversity 40 Key: This icon illustrates the relevant parts of the DVD which support and enhance delivery of the activities within each section. Look out for the speech bubble to find relevant discussion points. This pack is filled with a range of engaging activities, indicated by this icon. 3 ANTI-RACISM EDUCATION PACK FILM USER GUIDE – HOW DO I USE THIS RESOURCE? This 22 minute film is an excellent introduction to the subject About this education pack… of racism. With recognisable sporting personalities, such as Thierry Henry, Ryan Giggs, Florent Malouda and Leon Best, This resource has been designed to help educators as well as personal accounts of racism from young people, effectively challenge racism and promote equality amongst young people, across formal and informal educational this film is a fantastic and engaging way to begin talking settings.
    [Show full text]
  • View Early Day Motions PDF File 0.08 MB
    Published: Tuesday 20 July 2021 Early Day Motions tabled on Monday 19 July 2021 Early Day Motions (EDMs) are motions for which no days have been fixed. The number of signatories includes all members who have added their names in support of the Early Day Motion (EDM), including the Member in charge of the Motion. EDMs and added names are also published on the EDM database at www.parliament.uk/edm [R] Indicates that a relevant interest has been declared. New EDMs 330 Negotiating a peace settlement on the Korean Peninsula Tabled: 19/07/21 Signatories: 1 Ed Davey That this House notes the work by Congressman Brad Sherman to encourage new efforts towards formally ending the state of war on the Korean Peninsula through his Peace on the Korean Peninsula Act that was recently introduced in the US House of Representatives; recognises that that symbolic move could play a vital role in the next stage of reducing tensions on that peninsula; further notes that the Korean War hostilities were ended by an armistice in 1953, and that no formal peace treaty has been negotiated since that armistice; reiterates support for the 2018 Panmunjom Declaration in which the governments of North Korea and South Korea declared their intention to work towards negotiating a peace treaty to formally end the Korean War; acknowledges the role the UK Government has played in multilateral efforts to facilitate peace and denuclearisation on that peninsula; and calls on the UK Government to actively engage with all relevant parties and the wider international community to accelerate those efforts.
    [Show full text]
  • Challenging Hateful Extremism
    Challenging Hateful Extremism October 2019 Our Vision for Challenging Hateful Extremism Our vision is one where together we uphold our democratic way of life in a peaceful, plural and inclusive society that opposes intolerance; where people exercise individual liberty and take personal responsibility for promoting equal citizenship, recognising the harm extremist behaviours cause to everyone; and where our communities and institutions robustly challenge and resist hateful extremism and support those affected by it. Commission for Countering Extremism Foreword Hateful extremism demands a response. reviewed the Strategy and its delivery it is my From inspiring terrorist attacks, to hateful view that the current response is insufficient extremist groups engaging in persistent and too broad. hostility, we are grappling with what is a global challenge. If we are to be successful in reducing the extremist threat in our country, we must However, extremism, and how we counter it, focus on challenging hateful extremism. is a complex and contested policy area. The My report shows the destructive effect debate is often polarised and abusive; not hateful extremism is having on the lives helped by the overuse of the E-word. This of individuals, our communities and is particularly evident in these politically wider society. febrile times. Counter extremism policy over the years This climate makes serious discussions has also been characterised by a top-down about extremism challenging. And yet it is approach. The voices of the wider public, vital that we have those discussions. victims and counter extremism practitioners have been missing. That is why I have I have worked in the field of counter invested in extensive engagement, meeting extremism for over ten years.
    [Show full text]
  • “I'm Not Sitting Next to You”: Education and Racism in Afro-Mexican Communities
    Diálogos sobre educación. Temas actuales en investigación educativa ISSN: 2007-2171 [email protected] Universidad de Guadalajara México “I’m Not Sitting Next To You”: Education and Racism in Afro-Mexican Communities Masferrer León, Cristina V. “I’m Not Sitting Next To You”: Education and Racism in Afro-Mexican Communities Diálogos sobre educación. Temas actuales en investigación educativa, vol. 7, no. 13, 2016 Universidad de Guadalajara, México Available in: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=553458105006 This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International. PDF generated from XML JATS4R by Redalyc Project academic non-profit, developed under the open access initiative Eje Temático “I’m Not Sitting Next To You”: Education and Racism in Afro-Mexican Communities Cristina V. Masferrer León [email protected] INAH, México Abstract: Today, the biggest concentration of Afro-Mexican communities is found in the Costa Chica region of Guerrero and Oaxaca, although their presence is also important in other areas and states of Mexico. e social, cultural, economic, and political contributions of Africans and their descendants were significant during the colonial period throughout the territory known today as Mexico. Still, historic processes of racism and discrimination have led to their invisibilization and exclusion. is paper is a reflection on racism in schools of Afro-Mexican communities in the Costa Chica region. It presents an analysis of interactions between students, showing how bullying Diálogos sobre educación. Temas actuales en investigación educativa, vol. 7, no. 13, reproduces racism in school, as well as the role of teachers in this process, with some 2016 confronting the problem and collaborating to eradicate it and others reproducing racist ideas and discriminatory practices.
    [Show full text]
  • Football Discipline As a Barometer of Racism in English Sport and Society, 2004-2007: Spatial Dimensions
    Middle States Geographer, 2012, 44:27-35 FOOTBALL DISCIPLINE AS A BAROMETER OF RACISM IN ENGLISH SPORT AND SOCIETY, 2004-2007: SPATIAL DIMENSIONS M.T. Sullivan*1, J. Strauss*2 and D.S. Friedman*3 1Department of Geography Binghamton University Binghamton, New York 13902 2Dept. of Psychology Macalester College 1600 Grand Avenue St. Paul, MN 55105 3MacArthur High School Old Jerusalem Road Levittown, NY 11756 ABSTRACT: In 1990 Glamser demonstrated a significant difference in the disciplinary treatment of Black and White soccer players in England. The current study builds on this observation to examine the extent to which the Football Association’s antiracism programs have changed referee as well as fan behavior over the past several years. Analysis of data involving 421 players and over 10,500 matches – contested between 2003-04 and 2006-07 – indicates that a significant difference still exists in referees’ treatment of London-based Black footballers as compared with their White teammates at non-London matches (p=.004). At away matches in other London stadia, the difference was not significant (p=.200). Given the concentration of England’s Black population in the capital city, this suggests that it is fan reaction/overreaction to Black players’ fouls and dissent that unconsciously influences referee behavior. Keywords: racism, sport, home field advantage, referee discipline, match location INTRODUCTION The governing bodies of international football (FIFA) and English football (The FA or Football Association) have certainly tried to address racism in sport – a “microcosm of society.” In April of 2006, FIFA expelled five Spanish fans from a Zaragoza stadium and fined each 600 Euros for monkey chants directed towards Cameroonian striker Samuel Eto’o.
    [Show full text]
  • The Durban Diaries
    THE DURBAN DIARIES What really happened at the UN Conference against Racism in Durban (2001) JOËLLE FISS The mission of American Jewish Committee is: THE DURBAN DIARIES —To safeguard the welfare and security of Jews in the United States, in Israel, and throughout the world; What really happened at the UN Conference against Racism in Durban (2001) —To strengthen the basic principles of pluralism around the world as the best defense against anti-Semitism and other forms of bigotry; —To enhance the quality of American Jewish life by helping to ensure Joëlle Fiss Jewish continuity, and; —To deepen ties between American and Israeli Jews. To learn more about our mission, programs, and publications, and to join and contribute to our efforts, please visit us at www.ajc.org or contact us by phone at 212-751-4000 or by e-mail at [email protected]. The European Union of Jewish Students (EUJS) is the umbrella organi- zation for thirty-four national Jewish student unions in Europe and the Former Soviet Union, representing over 200,000 Jewish students. Cog- nizant of the religious, linguistic, and cultural diversity that make up the European Jewish community, EUJS is a constituent member of the Euro- pean Youth Forum and is the only Jewish organization represented at that level. It is a member of the World Union of Jewish Students (WUJS), is one of the largest international student organizations worldwide, and the first Jewish youth NGO to obtain consultative status to the Economic and So- cial Council of the United Nations. AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE EUROPEAN UNION OF JEWISH STUDENTS Contents Joëlle Fiss was born in Brighton, UK, and moved to The Durban Diaries 1 Geneva, Switzerland, where she studied at the Gradu- ate Institute of International Studies.
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Understandingfootball Hooliganism Amón Spaaij Understanding Football Hooliganism
    UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository) Understanding football hooliganism : a comparison of six Western European football clubs Spaaij, R.F.J. Publication date 2007 Document Version Final published version Link to publication Citation for published version (APA): Spaaij, R. F. J. (2007). Understanding football hooliganism : a comparison of six Western European football clubs. Vossiuspers. http://nl.aup.nl/books/9789056294458-understanding- football-hooliganism.html General rights It is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), other than for strictly personal, individual use, unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). Disclaimer/Complaints regulations If you believe that digital publication of certain material infringes any of your rights or (privacy) interests, please let the Library know, stating your reasons. In case of a legitimate complaint, the Library will make the material inaccessible and/or remove it from the website. Please Ask the Library: https://uba.uva.nl/en/contact, or a letter to: Library of the University of Amsterdam, Secretariat, Singel 425, 1012 WP Amsterdam, The Netherlands. You will be contacted as soon as possible. UvA-DARE is a service provided by the library of the University of Amsterdam (https://dare.uva.nl) Download date:01 Oct 2021 AUP/Spaaij 11-10-2006 12:54 Pagina 1 R UvA Thesis amón Spaaij Hooliganism Understanding Football Understanding Football Hooliganism Faculty of A Comparison of Social and Behavioural Sciences Six Western European Football Clubs Ramón Spaaij Ramón Spaaij is Lecturer in Sociology at the University of Amsterdam and a Research Fellow at the Amsterdam School for Social Science Research.
    [Show full text]
  • Racism and Its Impact on Young People Call for a Renewed Youth Commitment
    EUROPEAN YOUTH FORUM REPORT - 2008 Racism and its impact on young people call for a renewed youth commitment FOREWORD BY THOMAS HAMMARBERG ISBN: 978-92-990049-9-9 EDITORIAL TEAM: Luiza Bara Amanda Brunt Marco Perolini Diogo Pinto PROOFREADING: Amanda Brunt LAY OUT: Marta Gomez This publication has been produced with the financial support of the European Union. Texts represent the opinions of the European Youth Forum and do not necessarily reflect the views of the EU FOREWORD Racism, xenophobia and discrimination continue to be serious problems in all parts of Europe today. They are often manifested through the discriminatory treatment of minorities and migrants in education, employment, housing and access to health care. Racism may also be compounded by multiple forms of discrimination when members of ethnic and religious minorities become victims of discrimination on additional grounds such as their gender, disability, age or sexual orientation. THomas Hammarberg Council of Europe Commissioner While patterns of discrimination and intolerance for Human Rights continue, there are also reports about violent hate crimes against minorities. Such incidents include crimes related to racism, anti-Semitism, anti-Gypsism, Islamophobia and homophobia. Black Africans have been stabbed or beaten to death; Roma groups targeted in mob violence; Jews physically attacked; synagogues and cemeteries vandalised; Muslims have been assaulted, and their mosques and Islamic schools damaged; gay and lesbian demonstrators and persons with disabilities have also been targets of hate crimes and violent attacks. Physical attacks on individuals from minority groups are often perpetrated in communities where extremists have spread hate propaganda. I have personally seen examples of how minor incidents under such conditions can ignite mob tendencies against, for instance, Roma communities.
    [Show full text]