APPENDIX A SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS as at 30 September 2011 (Q1 + Q2 11/12)

Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks)

ON-GOING APPEALS

P/00021/09 Cornwall Light R Three wind turbine generators with hub 30 March 10 I DISMISSED 64 & Power Ltd height of 80m & rotor diameter of 90m (tip 8 March – 30 Aug 11 height 125m); control building, access tracks, 13 May 11 underground electrical cables & temporary construction compound – Cheverton Farm, Cheverton Down, Cheverton Shute,

P/00748/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of house in multiple 22 Sept 10 WR ALLOWED 30+ occupation – 38 Station Avenue, 21 April 11

P/00749/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of house in multiple 22 Sept 10 WR ALLOWED 30+ occupation – 9 Carter Street, Sandown 21 April 11

P/00411/10 Mr L Thorne RLDC Proposed single storey rear extension – 29 Sept 10 WR DISMISSED 27+ Beach Cottage, Castlehaven Lane, 08 April 11

E/17926/T Mr C Prew E Alleged material change of use from a hotel 14 April 11 I NO FURTHER 24+ to a large house in multiple occupation – 25 Oct 11 ACTION/ Willowbank, 36 Atherley Road, ENFORCEMENT NOTICE WITHDRAWN 30 Sept 11

58 E/17926/T Mr C Prew E Allegation of unauthorised siting of 3 14 April 11 I residential mobile homes together with 25 Oct 11 associated services – Willowbank, 36 Atherley Road, Shanklin

E/27582/B Mr C Prew E Alleged material change of use from a hotel 21 Dec 10 H UPHELD 22+ to a large house in multiple occupation and 05 May 11 2 June 11 permanent residential – 8 Leed Street, Sandown

P/00610/10 Mr & Mrs R Conversion and extension of coach 10 Dec 10 WR DISMISSED 16+ Turner house/stables to form residential unit to 07 April 11 include provision of first floor and balconies on front and rear elevations; parking; fencing and retaining wall (revised scheme) – land between Latton House and Sentry Mead Hotel, Madeira Road, Bay

P/00606/10 Clydesdale R Demolition of annexed holiday unit; outline for 13 Oct 10 WR DISMISSED 25+ Estates residential bungalow – land adjacent The 08 April 11 Fens, and North of Fairhaven, Lower Woodside Road, Wootton Bridge

P/01122/10 Mr & Mrs Smith R Demolition of detached chalet; single storey 30 Nov 10 WR PART ALLOW 18 extension to enlarge kitchen and form garden 12 April 11 room (revised scheme) – Hill Farm Cottage,

P/01123/10 Mr & Mrs Smith R LBC for demolition of detached chalet; single 30 Nov 10 WR PART ALLOW 18 storey extension to enlarge kitchen and form 12 April 11 garden room (revised scheme) – Hill Farm Cottage, Gatcombe

59 P/01284/10 A M Structures RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for proposed 21 Dec 10 WR ALLOWED 25+ single/two storey extension on south east 15 June 11 elevation; turning/parking area – Woodlands House, Embassy Way, Sandown

P/00923/10 Mr S Harris R Demolition of dwelling; proposed residential 08 Dec 10 WR ALLOWED 22+ development of 5 detached houses and a 12 May 11 pair of semi-detached houses with parking; vehicular access off Colenutts Road with vehicular access for plot 5 off Grove Road (revised scheme) (re-advertised application) – The Grove, Grove Road,

P/00101/10 D Farrow R Residential development comprising pair of 10 Dec 10 H ALLOWED 23+ Developments semi-detached houses and 1 detached house 29 March 10 25 May 11 with garages and access from Elmbank Gardens, to include extension of access road (revised scheme) (revised plans) ( re- advertised application) – Land rear of 24 Street, Sandown

P/01224/09 Pier Road R Residential development comprising 6 04 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 15+ Properties Ltd dwellings to include access and parking off 21 April 11 Pier Road; courtyard and associated landscaping; new retaining wall for Old Boathouse (revised scheme) (revised plans) (re-advertised application) – land adjoining The Old Boathouse, Pier Road, Seaview

P/01078/10 Mr A Palmer R Proposed detached dwelling with parking – 21 Dec 10 WR DISMISSED 16+ Land rear of 2 & 4 Percy Road, fronting White 14 April 11 Mead, Sandown

60 P/01346/10 Mr N Stephens R Utility room, w.c & lounge/dining area with a 29 Dec 10 WR PART 12+ study area provided within the loft space – (HAS) ALLOWED Cross Cottage, West Street, Seaview 01 April 11

P/00970/10 Mr S Wren R Detached house with parking & vehicular 04 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 18+ access off Worcester Road (revised scheme) 14 June 11 – land rear of 11 Argyle Road, Newport

P/01365/10 Mr L Speller R Removal of condition 3 on TCP/04655/J to 03 May 11 WR DISMISSED 15+ enable the continued use of the premises as 18 Aug 11 a (discount) retail outlet, which includes the sale of household goods and pet foods for a period of 18 months (revised description) – Vectis Animal Feeds, Prestwood Dairy, Smallbrook Lane, Ryde

E/26271/A D Smith E Siting of a mobile home to form a separate 24 Feb 11 I UPHELD 27+ unit of residential accommodation – 2 16 Aug 2011 02 Sept 11 Matthews Cottages, Barton Estate, East

P/00725/10 CHG Holdings R Demolition of redundant buildings and 31 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 18 Ltd infrastructure; construction of 3-storey (57 6 June 11 bedrooms) hotel with bin stores and cycle bay – former site of Wight Motors, Lind Hill, Ryde

P/00826/10 Little Orchard R Demolition of bungalow; construction of 2/3 19 Jan 11 WR ALLOWED 22+ Properties storey block of 10 retirement apartments; bin 27 June 11 store; parking & associated landscaping; relocation of vehicular access – Little Orchard, Elliston Road,

P/00892/09 Ms Wheeler R Temporary siting of mobile home for use as 21 Jan 11 H DISMISSED 15+ owners residential accommodation – Harbors 18 May 11 9 June 11 Lake Nursery, Harbors Lake Lane, Newchurch

61 P/00155/09 Mr B Atkinson- R Detached bungalow with vehicular access & 14 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 12+ Goffe parking/turning area – land adjacent 29 14 April 11 Chatsworth Avenue, Shanklin

P/01584/10 Mr S King R Proposed detached chalet bungalow with 21 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 24+ access off Culver Way (revised scheme) – 12 July 11 land adjacent 1 Culver Way, Sandown

P/01561/10 Mrs J Mew R Variation of condition 5 on TCP/16934/G to 21 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 12+ allow permanent residential occupation of 20 April 11 converted barn – Middle Bramstone Farm, Street, Chale

P/01366/10 Mr A Lockyer R Conversion of single dwelling into 2 units of 21 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 14+ accommodation (revised scheme) – 122 04 May 11 Road, Newport

P/00947/10 Mr T Ward & R Outline for dwelling; vehicular access off 26 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 23+ Mrs G Barnes Culver Way – land at 2 Whitecliff Close, 12 July 11 Sandown

P/00897/10 Arun Estate R Proposed change of use from retail (A1) to 24 Jan 11 WR ALLOWED 19+ Agencies Ltd estate agency (A2) – 1 Church Street, 8 June 11

P/01411/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of property as house in 27 Jan 11 H DISMISSED 18 multiple occupation – Claremont Hotel, 8 05 May 11 2 June 11 Leed Street, Sandown

P/01021/10 Mr A Wylde R Demolition of shed; construction of detached 15 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 12 garage and parking space (revised scheme) 12 April 11 – 88 Pallance Road, Cowes

62 P/01412/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of property as house in 31 Jan 11 WR ALLOWED 14+ (from multiple occupation – Willowbank Hotel, 36 Re- 06 Sept 11 re- Atherley Road, Shanklin validated 26 validation) May 11 P/00726/10 CHG Holdings R Conservation Area Consent for demolition of 31 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 18 Ltd redundant buildings and infrastructure in 6 June 11 connection with the construction of 3-storey (57 bedrooms) hotel with bin stores and cycle bay – former site of Wight Motors, Lind Hill, Ryde

P/00794/10 Mr F Watts R Replacement of planning permission 28 Jan 11 WR ALLOWED 24+ (P/01271/05 – TCP/10102/C Bungalow with 21 July 11 detached garage; formation of vehicular access) in ordewr to extend the time limit for implementation – land adjacent Little Cedars, Main Road,

P/00767/10 Mr & Mrs Key R Replacement of planning permission 28 Jan 10 WR WITHDRAWN - (P/01301/07/TCP/12753/B: demolition of 30 March 11 garage; detached house with parking and alterations to vehicular access) in order to extend the time limit for implementation – View, 113 High Park Road, Ryde

E/17741/G Mr R Cowley E Change of use of the land from a mixed use 08 Feb 11 H QUASHED 24+ of agriculture and holiday let to a mixed use 12 July 10 27 July 11 of agriculture, holiday let and bus and coach operation centre/depot, including the siting of a portacabin – Lee Farm, Main Road, Wellow

P/01583/10 Mr R Abbott R Alteration & conversion of vacant barn into 10 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 15+ residential dwelling to include single storey 8 June 11 extension on south east elevation – Lavender, Staplehurst Grange, Long Lane, Newport

63 P/00874/10 IW Home R Demolition of single storey store; proposed 07 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 18+ Rentals construction of two storey detached house 14 June 11 with parking – store adjacent 15 Laundry Lane, Newport

P/00349/10 Mr M Byrne RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for continued Received 08 WR WITHDRAWN - use of vehicular acess & hardstanding – 1 Feb 11 (not 16 Feb 11 Henley Villas, Tennyson Road, Freshwater validated)

P/01164/10 Mr L Jones R 2 pairs of semi-detached bungalows with 17 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 28+ pedestrian access – The Secret Garden, 60- 06 Sept 11 61 High Street,

P/01542/10 Wightlight R Demolition of dwelling and garage; residential 10 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 25+ Developments development comprising two/three storey 20 July 11 Limited block of five flats with associated parking, amenity space and vehicular access (revised scheme) – 64 Fairlee Road, Newport

P/00853/10 Mr C Cane R New gated access; alterations to include 1st 28 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 6+ floor window on side elevation and door at (HAS) 12 April 11 ground floor level on rear elevation; 1st floor rear extension; decking; stair landings and new retaining wall (resubmitted scheme) – 10 South Street, Ventnor

P/01375/10 Mr & Mrs Bailey R Bungalow with parking; vehicular access from 25 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 18+ and Mr & Mrs Wrax Road; landscaping & boundary fencing 07 July 11 White (revised scheme) – Land at Hill House, The Mall, Brading

P/00939/10 Mr A Gibbs R Continued use of play area and retention of 04 Mar 11 WR DISMISSED 13+ play equipment and associated fencing; 8 June 11 relocation of 3 coach parking bays – Barns, Main Road, Arreton

64 P/01458/10 Mr J Humphray R Demolition of single storey extensions; 01 Mar 11 WR (HAS) ALLOWED 9 proposed single and two storey extensions to 26 April 11 provide additional living accommodation; demolition of garage; proposed detached double garage and alterations to turning area/driveway – The Old Cottage, Lane End Road,

P/01185/10 Mr F Barsoum R Retention & completion of 2-storey extension 23 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 15 to provide restaurant and sun lounge with 8 June 11 terrace area – Tarvic 2 Hotel, 13-15 Culver Parade, Sandown

P/01697/10 Mr C Taylor R Demolition of 4 accommodation blocks and 1 28 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 24+ lounge block; retention of 3 new detached 25 August 11 blocks comprising 2 accommodation blocks and 1 teachers lounge; landscaping & fencing (revised scheme) – Kingswood Centre, Road, Bembridge

P/00703/10 Mr & Mrs Hilton R Proposed stable block comprising two loose 07 Mar 11 WR DISMISSED 13+ boxes, tack room and hay store; change of 8 June 11 use of land for the keeping of horses; hardstanding and creation of vehicular access off Redhill Lane (revised scheme) – OS Parcel 2363 & Part OS Parcel 1973, Redhill Lane, Sandford

P/01740/10 Mr & Mrs R Demolition of existing kennel block; continued 07 Mar 11 WR ALLOWED 22+ Mayes use of land and structures as dog breeding 09 August 11 establishment; proposed building to form quarantine pens and food store; exercise yard and parking - Hamstead Lodge, Hamstead Drive, , Newport

P/01792/10 Mr & Mrs R Weather board cladding to all elevations - 09 Mar 11 WR WITHDRAWN - Hungerford Dolphin Cottage, Bluett Avenue, Seaview 23 May 11

65 P/00825/10 Mr Bell and Mr R Alterations to dormer windows on rear 14 Mar 11 WR DISMISSED 18+ & Mrs Parkes elevation to create balconies with glazed 20 July 11 balustrading – 2 & 4a, The Ship House, Pier Road, Seaview

P/00849/10 Triple Eight R Demolition of dwelling and outbuildings; 14 Mar 11 WR DISMISSED 22+ Investments construction of 28 warden assisted flats 17 Aug 11 contained within two blocks with glazed link; parking; dedicated mobility buggy parking; associated landscaping - 66 Foreland Road, Bembridge

P/01088/10 Hoyle & Co R Partial demolition of building, retaining 25 Mar 11 H DISMISSED 20+ (Bournemouth) principle façade; outline for residential 6 July 11 16 Aug 11 Ltd development of 14 townhouses with associated access, parking & amenity space – Former A B Cooke (warehouse), Little London, Newport

P/01109/10 Mr M & Mr A R Demolition of single storey extensions; 23 Mar 11 WR PART 15+ Child (As proposed single storey extensions to provide ALLOWED Trustees) additional living accommodation (revised 12 July 11 scheme) (readvertised application) – Ground Floor Apartment, Sandcove, Pier Road, Seaview

P/01807/10 Mr S Williams R Variation of condition 1 on planning 30 Mar 11 WR ALLOWED 7+ permission P/01221/10 to allow for natural (HAS) 24 May 11 landscaping in place of the permanent screen required by that condition – 20 Amos Hill, Totland Bay

P/01641/10 Mr J Green R Detached dwelling with integral double 30 Mar 11 WR DISMISSED 16 garage and associated landscaping (revised 20 July 11 scheme) (corrected information received) ( re-advertised application) – land adjacent 256 Upton Road, Ryde

66

APPEALS RECEIVED BETWEEN 01 APRIL AND 30 SEPTEMBER 2011

P/01916/10 Triple Eight R Demolition of dwelling and outbuildings; 11 April 11 WR DISMISSED 18+ Investments construction of 28 warden assisted flats with 17 Aug 11 glazed link; parking; dedicated mobility buggy parking; associated landscaping (revised scheme) – 66 Foreland Road, Bembridge

P/01908/10 Mr G Ford R Proposed 1.8m high close boarded boundary 12 April 11 WR DISMISSED 6+ fence – 34 Fraser Close, Cowes (HAS) 26 May 11

P/01159/10 Soldebelle Ltd R Two storey extension to form 2 flats and 14 April 11 WR DISMISSED 19 provision of parking area – Bay House, 25 Aug 11 Road, Ventnor

E/25496/J Lord Robin E Breach of holiday occupancy condition to 14 April 11 WR WITHDRAWN - Hamilton permanent residential use – Barnacle 24 June 11 Cottage, Ashey Park, Ashey Road, Ryde

P/01544/10 Mr W Nichols R Proposed end of terrace bungalow – 69 Lake 03 May 11 WR DISMISSED 15+ Green Road, Sandown 18 Aug 11

P/00048/11 Mssrs Day, R Outline for detached cottage, parking & 26 May 11 WR DISMISSED 12+ Steele & shared driveway (revised scheme) – Land 24 Aug 11 Widger adjacent Greystone Cottage, High St, Whitwell

P/00167/11 Mr A Nigh R Demolition of dwelling & outbuildings; 18 May 11 WR ALLOWED 14+ proposed replacement detached house with 26 Aug 11 integral garage; alterations to vehicular access (revised scheme) – Culverthorpe, Skinners Hill, Newchurch

67 P/01452/10 Mr Ryan, Ms R Replacement of planning permission 7 June 11 WR ALLOWED 11+ Nuttal & Mr R & (P/02966/06 – TCP/17559/E: demolition of 26 Aug 11 S Beaton buildings; proposed 3 storey block of 14 flats to include accommodation in roofspace with access off High St) in order to extend time limit for implementation – 91-93b High Street, Ryde

E/22425/D Mr C Whittle E Change of use of the land from a mixed use 7 June 11 WR of agricultural and storage to a mixed use of agricultural/storage and boat servicing & repairs – Newclose Farm Buildings, Hill Place Lane, Thorley, Yarmouth

P/01732/10 Mr & Mrs Patel R Outline for single storey building to provide 1 June 11 WR DISMISSED 12+ two self-contained holiday apartments – land 24 Aug 11 adjacent Cygnet Hotel, Carter Street, Sandown

P/00411/11 Mr T Lawrence R Change of use of lower ground floor and 15 June 11 WR ground floor from retail to a self-contained flat – Kingsview, 23 Church Street, Ventnor

P/00416/11 Mr & Mrs R Proposed two storey extension on front 13 June 11 WR DISMISSED 5+ Brooks elevation to form additional living (HAS) 19 July 11 accommodation (revised scheme) – Mulberry Cottage, Quay Lane, Brading

P/01317/10 Mr G Wilson R Retention & completion of rebuilding & 16 June 11 WR enlargement of former stables & pig sties to create stable block with storage areas at first floor level – Gatcliff Farm, Sheepwash Lane,

P/01316/10 Mr G Wilson R Retention & completion of summer house – 16 June 11 WR Gatcliff Farm, Sheepwash Lane, Godshill

68 P/01692/10 Mr Young RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for proposed 20 July 11 WR siting of caravan for shelter and storage facility ancillary to agricultural operation – land south of Creek Farm, Hamstead Drive, Hamstead

P/00220/11 Mr Pittard R Proposed 2-storey extension to form 1 unit of 22 June 11 WR holiday accommodation; parking (revised scheme) – Old School House, 22 Church Road, Shanklin

P/01426/10 Mr Wilson RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for continued 01 Aug 11 WR use of holiday accommodation as a single dwelling – Gatcliff Farm, Sheepwash Lane, Godshill

P/00109/11 Mr Batchelor R Extension at first floor level to provide en- 24 June 11 WR ALLOWED 8+ suite bedroom (revised scheme) – 35 College (HAS) 22 Aug 11 Road, Newport

P/00224/11 Mr & Mrs R Retention of decking; provision of 1.8, 24 June 11 WR ALLOWED 6+ Olding screening; landscaping – 19 Inglewood Park, (HAS) 22 Aug 11 Ventnor

P/00469/11 Mr Whittle R Continued use of site for boat repairs and 24 June 11 WR servicing (B2 use) – Newclose Farm, Main Road, Thorley, Yarmouth

P/01757/10 Tristmire Ltd R Partial demolition of former Bakery; single 05 July 11 WR storey extension & conversion of dwelling to form residential unit (revised scheme) – Erics Bakery, 10 Clarendon Street, Newport

69 P/01913/10 Mr G Miller R Demolition of single storey extension; Received 30 WR OUT OF TIME - proposed 2-storey extension to enlarge June 11 (HAS) 05 July 11 accommodation; formation of vehicular (not access & shared driveway – Hillview Cottage, validated) Carpenters Road, St Helens

P/01005/10 Taylor R Proposed chalet bungalow; vehicular access 07 July 11 WR Development off Stonepitts Close (revised scheme) (IW) Ltd (revised description) – Land rear of 42 Brookfield Gardens, off Stonepitts Close, Ryde

P/00467/11 Rotapoint Ltd RC Conservation Area Consent for demolition of 12 July 11 WR building; proposed 3/4 storey block of 4 town houses with ground floor parking; vehicular access (revised scheme) – Beachlands, Esplanade, Ventnor

P/00466/11 Rotapoint Ltd R Demolition of building; proposed 3/4 storey 12 July 11 WR block of 4 town houses with ground floor parking; vehicular access (revised scheme) – Beachlands, Esplanade, Ventnor

P/00294/11 Miss C Manning R Proposed 2-storey extension with glazed 19 July 11 WR ALLOWED 7 single storey link to form additional living (HAS) 06 Sept 11 accommodation – The Old Slaughter House, West Street, Brading

P/00182/11 Bloomfield R Alterations to vehicular access to provide new 14 July 11 WR DISMISSED 4+ Developments entrance gates – Le Bel Vie, Redhill Lane, (HAS) 22 Aug 11 Ltd c/o County Sandford, Ventnor Developments Ltd P/00646/11 Miss T R Detached house with parking – land adjacent 26 July 11 WR Tomkinson Gordon Villa, Smithards Lane, Cowes

70 P/00472/11 Mr & Mrs R Alterations and 2-storey side and rear 02 Aug 11 WR ALLOWED 5 Matthews extensions to provide additional living (HAS) 06 Sept 11 accommodation (revised scheme) – 27 Parkhurst Road, Newport

P/00393/11 Mr & Mrs R Demolition of single storey extension; 27 July 11 WR Butcher alterations and 2-storey extension to provide additional living accommodation; 2 new dormer windows and new roof lantern on rear elevation; solar panels – Halletts Thatch, Halletts Shute, Norton, Yarmouth

P/00394/11 Mr & Mrs RL Listed Building Consent for demolition of 27 July 11 WR Butcher single storey extension; alterations and 2- storey extension to provide additional living accommodation; 2 new dormer windows and new roof lantern on rear elevation; solar panels – Halletts Thatch, Halletts Shute, Norton, Yarmouth

P/00405/11 Mr Luck R Demolition of workshop; proposed detached 08 Aug 11 WR dwelling (revised scheme) – Hermans & Luck, The Office, Madeira Road, Seaview

P/00600/11 Mr & Mrs R Single/two storey side extension to provide 12 Aug 11 WR Biggar annexed accommodation – Scotchells, (HAS) Newport Road, Sandown

E/26421/D Mr P Cooper E Unauthorised change of use of the land from Rec’d 02 ? agriculture to storage & distribution (B8) – Aug 11 (H requested Lake Farm, Gatcombe Awaiting by appellant) Validation

71 E/26421/D Mr P Cooper E Non-compliance with condition no 6 on Rec’d 02 ? planning permission P/01192/04 which states Aug 11 (H requested that “ None of the units hereby approved shall Awaiting by appellant) be used other than as holiday Validation accommodation and none of them shall be occupied by any person or persons, family or group of persons for a period, or aggregate periods, exceeding six weeks in total in any consecutive period of 52 weeks” – Lake Farm, Gatcombe

E/12469/S P J Metcalfe E Breach of condition 1 on TCP/3498Z/C/586 30 Aug 11 WR which states that “No shed, outhouse, enclosure or other building shall be erected so as to project in front of the building line or lines of the main wall or walls of the main or principle building erected on the land unless the further consent of the County Council is obtained” – 10 Charles Road, Cowes

P/00173/11 Mr R Bendy R Demolition of store; alterations and single 27 Sep 11 WR storey extension to sub-divide existing flat (Flat 2) to provide additional flat including formation of new courtyard areas – Suffolk House, Broadway, Totland Bay

P/00435/11 Mrs Taylor R Formation of vehicular access – 6 Garfield 17 Aug 11 WR Road, Ryde (HAS)

P/00438/11 Mr J Goodwin R Demolition of detached chalet; replacement 16 Aug 11 WR detached chalet to provide overspill accommodation (revised scheme) – Camelia Cottage, Sandrock Road, Niton Undercliff, Ventnor

P/01831/10 Mr Clarke R Demolition of chalet; outline for detached 22 Aug 11 WR dwelling – Kon-Tiki, , Seaview

72 E/02714/K Chantel E Unauthorised building operation to create a 22 Aug 11 WR Investments 2-storey extension – Tarvic Two Hotel, Culver Limited Parade, Sandown Company P/01961/10 Mr & Mrs R Retention of 2 mobile homes (1 for 19 Aug 11 H Medway permanent occupation and 1 for seasonal 22 November occupation) for a period of 3 years – OS 11 Parcel 9145, Godshill Cherry Orchard, Hollow Lane, Godshill

P/00499/11 Mrs A Noon R Extension at first floor level to provide 24 Aug 11 WR additional living accommodation – (HAS) Woodpeckers Halt, Swains Road, Bembridge

E/29598 Mr & Mrs E Chang of use of the land from agricultural to 01 Sept 11 WR Haworth permanent residential by the siting of a mobile home for permanent residential accommodation and the associated paraphernalia together with the erection of an open sided structure for the storage of domestic paraphernalia – Land north side of Seven Sisters Road, Ventnor

P/00429/11 Mr S R Vincent R Demolition of unauthorised dwelling; 06 Sept 11 H construction of 2-storey dwelling to include 15 November attic bedroom; boundary wall (further revised 11 description) (readvertised application) – 18 Sun Hill, Cowes

P/00430/11 Mr S R Vincent RL Listed Building Consent of the demolition of 06 Sept 11 H unauthorised dwelling; construction of 2- 15 November storey dwelling to include attic bedroom; 11 boundary wall (further revised description) (readvertised application) – 18 Sun Hill, Cowes

73 P/00782/11 Mr A Barker R Raised deck area with balustrading – 23 12 Sep 11 WR Perowne Way, Sandown (HAS)

P/00272/11 William Downer ND Demolition of single storey extensions on 05 Sep 11 WR & Sons IOW Ltd existing dwelling; demolition of outbuildings and joiners shop; construction of a pair of semi-detached houses and one detached house fronting onto York Road; conversion of store into dwelling with two storey extension forming dwelling; associated parking; closure of existing western access and alteration to existing eastern access (revised scheme) – Yorks, York Road, Totland Bay

P/00539/10 RSPCA (Isle of Residential development comprising four 05 Sep 11 WR Wight) Branch R detached houses with garages/parking, associated landscaping, cul-de-sac and vehicular access off Cliff Road – Land between York Road & Cliff Road, Totland E/00891/K Mr H Gallop E Alleged change of use of land from 14 Sep 11 WR agriculture to the salvage and repair of vehicles and vehicle sales including the construction of a workshop – Land at Thornbury, Newport Road,

P/01944/10 Mr & Mrs Ailes R Detached dwelling with vehicular access and 14 Sep 11 WR parking – land adjacent Church Hall, Newman Lane,

P/00982/11 Mt S Painting R Proposed double garage and formation of 22 Sep 11 WR vehicular access and turning area (revised scheme) – land between 17 & 19 Close, Sandown

74 P/00919/11 A M Structures R Variation of condition 2 on 28 Sep 11 WR APP/P2114/A/06/2029858 to allow storage of materials outside the factory unit – Woodlands House, Embassy Way, Sandown

P/00363/11 Mr A Jupe R Demolition of dwelling; construction of 27 Sep 11 H detached dwelling – West Ridge, Road, Yarmouth

P/01769/10 Mrs G Barnes & R Erection of a bungalow for use as self- Rec’d 29 H Mr T Ward catering holiday let with vehicular access off Sep 11 Requested by Culver Way (revised description) – land at 2 Awaiting appellant (not Whitecliff Close, Sandown validation yet validated)

KEY

Type Appeal Procedure

R = Refusal of planning permission WR = written representations RAC = Refusal to approve matters required for a condition WR (HAS) = written representations householder appeal service RL = Refusal of listed building consent H = hearing RC = Refusal of conservation area consent I = public inquiry RA = Refusal of advertisement consent IC = Imposition of condition on planning permission ND = Failure to determine application with prescribed period E= Enforcement notice RLDC= Refusal for lawful development certificate

75

SUMMARY OF SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS FOR HALF YEAR ENDING 30 SEPTEMBER 2011

Number of new appeals 55

Number of appeals in progress 37

Number of appeals withdrawn / invalid 6

Number of appeals determined 65

Dismissed 42 (64.6%) Allowed (inc 4 part-allowed) 23 (35.4 %)

Please note – Enforcement appeal decisions are now reported as ‘quashed’, ‘varied’ or ‘upheld’ which is in line with how they are reported by the planning inspectorate. For the purposes of this summary ‘quashed’ enforcement notices are counted as ‘allowed’, with those notices which are either upheld’ or ‘varied’ counted as dismissed.

76

PERFORMANCE

The Council’s appeals performance is measured by the percentage of appeals against the refusal of planning permission (excluding enforcement, lawful development, advert, and non-determination appeals and appeals against conditions) which are allowed.

Target maximum is 30% allowed (National average is around 32% allowed).

Number of appeals determined 60 (against refusal of planning permission, listed building and conservation area consent only)

Dismissed 39 (65 %) Allowed (inc 4 part-allowed) 21 (35 %)

77