APPENDIX A SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS as at 30 September 2011 (Q1 + Q2 11/12) Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) ON-GOING APPEALS P/00021/09 Cornwall Light R Three wind turbine generators with hub 30 March 10 I DISMISSED 64 & Power Ltd height of 80m & rotor diameter of 90m (tip 8 March – 30 Aug 11 height 125m); control building, access tracks, 13 May 11 underground electrical cables & temporary construction compound – Cheverton Farm, Cheverton Down, Cheverton Shute, Shorwell P/00748/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of house in multiple 22 Sept 10 WR ALLOWED 30+ occupation – 38 Station Avenue, Sandown 21 April 11 P/00749/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of house in multiple 22 Sept 10 WR ALLOWED 30+ occupation – 9 Carter Street, Sandown 21 April 11 P/00411/10 Mr L Thorne RLDC Proposed single storey rear extension – 29 Sept 10 WR DISMISSED 27+ Beach Cottage, Castlehaven Lane, Niton 08 April 11 E/17926/T Mr C Prew E Alleged material change of use from a hotel 14 April 11 I NO FURTHER 24+ to a large house in multiple occupation – 25 Oct 11 ACTION/ Willowbank, 36 Atherley Road, Shanklin ENFORCEMENT NOTICE WITHDRAWN 30 Sept 11 58 E/17926/T Mr C Prew E Allegation of unauthorised siting of 3 14 April 11 I residential mobile homes together with 25 Oct 11 associated services – Willowbank, 36 Atherley Road, Shanklin E/27582/B Mr C Prew E Alleged material change of use from a hotel 21 Dec 10 H UPHELD 22+ to a large house in multiple occupation and 05 May 11 2 June 11 permanent residential – 8 Leed Street, Sandown P/00610/10 Mr & Mrs R Conversion and extension of coach 10 Dec 10 WR DISMISSED 16+ Turner house/stables to form residential unit to 07 April 11 include provision of first floor and balconies on front and rear elevations; parking; fencing and retaining wall (revised scheme) – land between Latton House and Sentry Mead Hotel, Madeira Road, Totland Bay P/00606/10 Clydesdale R Demolition of annexed holiday unit; outline for 13 Oct 10 WR DISMISSED 25+ Estates residential bungalow – land adjacent The 08 April 11 Fens, and North of Fairhaven, Lower Woodside Road, Wootton Bridge P/01122/10 Mr & Mrs Smith R Demolition of detached chalet; single storey 30 Nov 10 WR PART ALLOW 18 extension to enlarge kitchen and form garden 12 April 11 room (revised scheme) – Hill Farm Cottage, Gatcombe P/01123/10 Mr & Mrs Smith R LBC for demolition of detached chalet; single 30 Nov 10 WR PART ALLOW 18 storey extension to enlarge kitchen and form 12 April 11 garden room (revised scheme) – Hill Farm Cottage, Gatcombe 59 P/01284/10 A M Structures RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for proposed 21 Dec 10 WR ALLOWED 25+ single/two storey extension on south east 15 June 11 elevation; turning/parking area – Woodlands House, Embassy Way, Sandown P/00923/10 Mr S Harris R Demolition of dwelling; proposed residential 08 Dec 10 WR ALLOWED 22+ development of 5 detached houses and a 12 May 11 pair of semi-detached houses with parking; vehicular access off Colenutts Road with vehicular access for plot 5 off Grove Road (revised scheme) (re-advertised application) – The Grove, Grove Road, Ryde P/00101/10 D Farrow R Residential development comprising pair of 10 Dec 10 H ALLOWED 23+ Developments semi-detached houses and 1 detached house 29 March 10 25 May 11 with garages and access from Elmbank Gardens, to include extension of access road (revised scheme) (revised plans) ( re- advertised application) – Land rear of 24 Nunwell Street, Sandown P/01224/09 Pier Road R Residential development comprising 6 04 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 15+ Properties Ltd dwellings to include access and parking off 21 April 11 Pier Road; courtyard and associated landscaping; new retaining wall for Old Boathouse (revised scheme) (revised plans) (re-advertised application) – land adjoining The Old Boathouse, Pier Road, Seaview P/01078/10 Mr A Palmer R Proposed detached dwelling with parking – 21 Dec 10 WR DISMISSED 16+ Land rear of 2 & 4 Percy Road, fronting White 14 April 11 Mead, Sandown 60 P/01346/10 Mr N Stephens R Utility room, w.c & lounge/dining area with a 29 Dec 10 WR PART 12+ study area provided within the loft space – (HAS) ALLOWED Cross Cottage, West Street, Seaview 01 April 11 P/00970/10 Mr S Wren R Detached house with parking & vehicular 04 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 18+ access off Worcester Road (revised scheme) 14 June 11 – land rear of 11 Argyle Road, Newport P/01365/10 Mr L Speller R Removal of condition 3 on TCP/04655/J to 03 May 11 WR DISMISSED 15+ enable the continued use of the premises as 18 Aug 11 a (discount) retail outlet, which includes the sale of household goods and pet foods for a period of 18 months (revised description) – Vectis Animal Feeds, Prestwood Dairy, Smallbrook Lane, Ryde E/26271/A D Smith E Siting of a mobile home to form a separate 24 Feb 11 I UPHELD 27+ unit of residential accommodation – 2 16 Aug 2011 02 Sept 11 Matthews Cottages, Barton Estate, East Cowes P/00725/10 CHG Holdings R Demolition of redundant buildings and 31 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 18 Ltd infrastructure; construction of 3-storey (57 6 June 11 bedrooms) hotel with bin stores and cycle bay – former site of Wight Motors, Lind Hill, Ryde P/00826/10 Little Orchard R Demolition of bungalow; construction of 2/3 19 Jan 11 WR ALLOWED 22+ Properties storey block of 10 retirement apartments; bin 27 June 11 store; parking & associated landscaping; relocation of vehicular access – Little Orchard, Elliston Road, Totland Bay P/00892/09 Ms Wheeler R Temporary siting of mobile home for use as 21 Jan 11 H DISMISSED 15+ owners residential accommodation – Harbors 18 May 11 9 June 11 Lake Nursery, Harbors Lake Lane, Newchurch 61 P/00155/09 Mr B Atkinson- R Detached bungalow with vehicular access & 14 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 12+ Goffe parking/turning area – land adjacent 29 14 April 11 Chatsworth Avenue, Shanklin P/01584/10 Mr S King R Proposed detached chalet bungalow with 21 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 24+ access off Culver Way (revised scheme) – 12 July 11 land adjacent 1 Culver Way, Sandown P/01561/10 Mrs J Mew R Variation of condition 5 on TCP/16934/G to 21 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 12+ allow permanent residential occupation of 20 April 11 converted barn – Middle Bramstone Farm, Chale Street, Chale P/01366/10 Mr A Lockyer R Conversion of single dwelling into 2 units of 21 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 14+ accommodation (revised scheme) – 122 04 May 11 Carisbrooke Road, Newport P/00947/10 Mr T Ward & R Outline for dwelling; vehicular access off 26 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 23+ Mrs G Barnes Culver Way – land at 2 Whitecliff Close, 12 July 11 Sandown P/00897/10 Arun Estate R Proposed change of use from retail (A1) to 24 Jan 11 WR ALLOWED 19+ Agencies Ltd estate agency (A2) – 1 Church Street, 8 June 11 Ventnor P/01411/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of property as house in 27 Jan 11 H DISMISSED 18 multiple occupation – Claremont Hotel, 8 05 May 11 2 June 11 Leed Street, Sandown P/01021/10 Mr A Wylde R Demolition of shed; construction of detached 15 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 12 garage and parking space (revised scheme) 12 April 11 – 88 Pallance Road, Cowes 62 P/01412/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of property as house in 31 Jan 11 WR ALLOWED 14+ (from multiple occupation – Willowbank Hotel, 36 Re- 06 Sept 11 re- Atherley Road, Shanklin validated 26 validation) May 11 P/00726/10 CHG Holdings R Conservation Area Consent for demolition of 31 Jan 11 WR DISMISSED 18 Ltd redundant buildings and infrastructure in 6 June 11 connection with the construction of 3-storey (57 bedrooms) hotel with bin stores and cycle bay – former site of Wight Motors, Lind Hill, Ryde P/00794/10 Mr F Watts R Replacement of planning permission 28 Jan 11 WR ALLOWED 24+ (P/01271/05 – TCP/10102/C Bungalow with 21 July 11 detached garage; formation of vehicular access) in ordewr to extend the time limit for implementation – land adjacent Little Cedars, Main Road, Havenstreet P/00767/10 Mr & Mrs Key R Replacement of planning permission 28 Jan 10 WR WITHDRAWN - (P/01301/07/TCP/12753/B: demolition of 30 March 11 garage; detached house with parking and alterations to vehicular access) in order to extend the time limit for implementation – Ashey View, 113 High Park Road, Ryde E/17741/G Mr R Cowley E Change of use of the land from a mixed use 08 Feb 11 H QUASHED 24+ of agriculture and holiday let to a mixed use 12 July 10 27 July 11 of agriculture, holiday let and bus and coach operation centre/depot, including the siting of a portacabin – Lee Farm, Main Road, Wellow P/01583/10 Mr R Abbott R Alteration & conversion of vacant barn into 10 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 15+ residential dwelling to include single storey 8 June 11 extension on south east elevation – Isle of Wight Lavender, Staplehurst Grange, Long Lane, Newport 63 P/00874/10 IW Home R Demolition of single storey store; proposed 07 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 18+ Rentals construction of two storey detached house 14 June 11 with parking – store adjacent 15 Laundry Lane, Newport P/00349/10 Mr M Byrne RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for continued Received 08 WR WITHDRAWN - use of vehicular acess & hardstanding – 1 Feb 11 (not 16 Feb 11 Henley Villas, Tennyson Road, Freshwater validated) P/01164/10 Mr L Jones R 2 pairs of semi-detached bungalows with 17 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 28+ pedestrian access – The Secret Garden, 60- 06 Sept 11 61 High Street, Brading P/01542/10 Wightlight R Demolition of dwelling and garage; residential 10 Feb 11 WR DISMISSED 25+ Developments development comprising two/three storey 20 July 11 Limited block of five flats with associated parking,