Fragmenting Modernisms
China Studies
Edited by
Glen Dudbridge
Frank Pieke
VOLUME 24
The titles published in this series are listed at brill.com/CHS
Fragmenting Modernisms
Chinese Wartime Literature, Art, and Film, 1937–49
By
Carolyn FitzGerald
•
LEiDEnꢀ ꢀbOStOn
2013
Cover illustration: Ye Qianyu, “Stage Set,” from the 1940 sketch-cartoon series Wartime Chongqing. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data FitzGerald, Carolyn. ꢁFragmenting modernisms : Chinese wartime literature, art, and film, 1937-49 / by Carolyn FitzGerald. ꢁꢁpages cm. — (China studies ; v. 24) ꢁincludes bibliographical references and index. ꢁiSbn 978-90-04-25098-7 (hardback : alk. paper) — iSbn 978-90-04-25099-4 (e-book)ꢀ 1.ꢀChinese literature—20th century—History and criticism.ꢀ2.ꢀSino-Japanese War, 1937–1945—Literature and the war.ꢀ3.ꢀSino-Japanese War, 1937–1945—Art and the war.ꢀ 4.ꢀChina—History—Civil War, 1945–1949—Literature and the war.ꢀ5.ꢀChina—History— Civil War, 1945–1949—Art and the war.ꢀ6.ꢀMotion pictures—China—History—20th century.ꢀ 7.ꢀArt, Chinese—20th century.ꢀ8. ꢀModernism (Literature)—China.ꢀ9.ꢀModernism (Art)— China.ꢀi. title.
ꢁPL2302.F58 2013 ꢁ895.1’09005—dc23
2013003681
this publication has been typeset in the multilingual “brill” typeface. With over 5,100 characters covering Latin, iPA, Greek, and Cyrillic, this typeface is especially suitable for use in the humanities. For more information, please see www.brill.com/brill-typeface.
iSSn 1570-1344 iSbn 978-90-04-25098-7 (hardback) iSbn 978-90-04-25099-4 (e-book)
Copyright 2013 by Koninklijke brill nV, Leiden, the netherlands. Koninklijke brill nV incorporates the imprints brill, Global Oriental, Hotei Publishing, iDC Publishers and Martinus nijhoff Publishers.
All rights reserved. no part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher.
Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Koninklijke brill nV provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change.
brill has made all reasonable efforts to trace all rights holders to any copyrighted material used in this work. in cases where these efforts have not been successful the publisher welcomes communications from copyright holders, so that the appropriate acknowledgements can be made in future editions, and to settle other permission matters.
this book is printed on acid-free paper.
COntEntS
- List of illustrationsꢀ.......................................................................................
- vii
- xi
- Acknowledgmentsꢀ .......................................................................................
introductionꢁOut of the Ashes: towards a Wartime Aesthetics
- of Dissolutionꢀ...........................................................................................
- 1
31
Chapter OneꢁA Sonnet in an Air-Raid Shelter: Mu Dan and the new Lyricismꢀ............................................................................................
Chapter twoꢁintersections between Cartoon and national Art:
- Ye Qianyu’s Search for the Sinicized Cartoonꢀ ...............................
- 79
Chapter threeꢁWang Zengqi’s Collection of Chance Encounters:
- the Shifting Essence of the Wartime Short Storyꢀ ........................
- 125
Chapter Fourꢁbetween Forgetting and the Repetitions of Memory: Fei Mu’s Aesthetics of Desolation in Spring
- in a Small Townꢀ .......................................................................................
- 169
217 265
Chapter FiveꢁFei Ming’s After Mr. Neverwas Rides a Plane:
Wartime Autobiography as Historyꢀ ..................................................
EpilogueꢁSearching for Roots: Modernist Echoes in the
Post-Mao Eraꢀ............................................................................................
- bibliographyꢀ ..................................................................................................
- 299
- 313
- indexꢀ................................................................................................................
Plate Section
LiSt OF iLLUStRAtiOnS
Fig. 1.1ꢁPhotograph of Wen Yiduo listening to a student reciting poetry during a February 1945 field trip to the town of Lunan.
Photograph from Lianda: A Chinese University in War and
Revolution, by John israelꢀ ........................................................................... 33
Fig. 1.2ꢁPhotograph of Lianda students and teachers marching
to Kunming. Photograph from Lianda: A Chinese University in
War and Revolution, by John israelꢀ ......................................................... 37
Fig. 1.3ꢁnational Changsha temporary University Hunan—
Guizhou-Sichuan traveling Corps arrives in the city of Kunmingꢀ.......................................................................................................... 38
Fig. 2.1ꢁnational Cartoon Propaganda Corps member Zhang Leping painting a wall mural of soldiers (1938)ꢀ................................................ 80
Fig. 2.2ꢁtruck covered in cartoon propaganda, used to accompany dramatic performances promoting the cause of resistance (1938)ꢀ............................................................................................ 80
Fig. 2.3ꢁPhotograph of Ye Qianyu (left) with Yue Yiqin (right) in front of the propaganda poster, “Four Heroes of the Air Force”ꢀ......................................................................................................... 83
Fig. 2.4ꢁYe Qianyu, illustrated cover of first edition of
Resistance Cartoons, January 1938ꢀ ........................................................... 85
Fig. 2.5ꢁYe Qianyu, “Living for Hatred,” illustrated cover of
Resistance Cartoons, March 15, 1938ꢀ .................................. Plate Section
Fig. 2.6ꢁGeorge McManus, “bringing up Father,”
Feb. 10, 1935ꢀ................................................................................................
Fig. 2.7ꢁYe Qianyu, “Quitting Alcohol,” from his cartoon strip
Mr. Wangꢀ.....................................................................................................
Fig. 2.8ꢁYe Qianyu, “Abandon the Civilian Life, Join the Army,”
Xin dongxiang 2.10 (30 June 1939)ꢀ ......................................................
Fig. 2.9ꢁYe Qianyu, “Stage Set,” from the 1940 sketch-cartoon series Wartime Chongqingꢀ......................................................................
Fig. 2.10ꢁYe Qianyu, “the Artery of transportation in the
Hinterland,” from Wartime Chongqingꢀ...............................................
Fig. 2.11ꢁYe Qianyu, “After Exhaustive bombing,” from Wartime
Chongqingꢀ....................................................................................................
87 88 90 94 96 97
viii
list of illustrations
Fig. 2.12ꢁYe Qianyu, “new Appreciation for Antiques,” from
Wartime Chongqingꢀ................................................................................... 100
Fig. 2.13ꢁYe Qianyu, “Frontline at Shatian,” from his 1942 sketch-cartoon series Escape from Hong Kongꢀ ................................. 103
Fig. 2.14ꢁYe Qianyu, “inspection,” from Escape from
Hong Kongꢀ.................................................................................................... 104
Fig. 2.15ꢁYe Qianyu, “Leaving Kowloon,” from Escape from
Hong Kongꢀ.................................................................................................... 105
Fig. 2.16ꢁYe Qianyu, “the Road to Free China,” from Escape from
Hong Kongꢀ.................................................................................................... 106
Fig. 2.17ꢁYe Qianyu, Cock fi ght, 1942 painting produced using watercolor painting and taijiang leather paperꢀ ........... Plate Section
Fig. 2.18ꢁYe Qianyu, “in a Miao Village in Guizhou,” sketch-cartoon produced during his visit to Guizhou in 1942ꢀ ........................................................................................................... 110
Fig. 2.19ꢁZhang Daqian, 1942 copy of wall painting of buddha image in the Mogao Cavesꢀ................................................... Plate Section
Fig. 2.20ꢁZhang Daqian, 1942 copy of Dunhuang wall painting of saint image of West Wei in the Mogao Cavesꢀ.......... Plate Section
Fig. 2.21ꢁYe Qianyu, “Drum of the Yao People,” 1944 sketch of Dai Ailian performing a regional minority danceꢀ ... Plate Section
Fig. 2.22ꢁYe Qianyu, Indian Dance, 1945 oil painting based on his sketches of indian women performing the buddhist “Dance of the Offering of Flowers.”ꢀ................................... Plate Section
Fig. 2.23ꢁYe Qianyu, Indian Dance Pose, 1948 oil paintingꢀ................................................................................ Plate Section
Fig. 2.24ꢁYe Qianyu, Dance of the O f fering of Flowers, 1949
oil paintingꢀ................................................................................ Plate Section
Fig. 2.25ꢁZhang Daqian, Dance of the O f fering of Flowers,
1949 oil painting based on Ye Qianyu’s sketches of indian dancersꢀ ......................................................................... Plate Section
Fig. 2.26ꢁYe Qianyu, “Large Painting table,” from his 1945 sketch-cartoon series Six Portraits of Zhang Daqianꢀ....................... 117
Fig. 2.27ꢁYe Qianyu, “Painting a beard with a beard,” from
Six Portraits of Zhang Daqianꢀ................................................................. 118
Fig. 2.28ꢁMaurits Cornelis Escher, 1948 lithograph,
“Drawing Hands”ꢀ........................................................................................ 119
Fig. 2.29ꢁYe Qianyu, “Comprehensive Scene within Four Meters,” from Six Portraits of Zhang Daqianꢀ...................................................... 120
list of illustrations
ix
Fig. 4.1ꢁYuwen walks daily along the ruins of the city wall in
Spring in a Small Townꢀ............................................................................. 172
Fig. 4.2ꢁ1948 advertisement for Spring in a
Small Townꢀ................................................................................ Plate Section
Fig. 4.3ꢁYuwen and Liyan watch Zhichen leave at the end of
Spring in a Small Townꢀ............................................................................. 179
Fig. 4.4ꢁAdvertisement for Fei Mu’s 1940 film
Confuciusꢀ.................................................................................... Plate Section
Fig. 4.5ꢁAdvertisement for China’s first color production,
Fei Mu’s 1948 film Regret that Surpasses Life and Death
(translated here as A Wedding in the Dream)ꢀ................ Plate Section
Fig. 4.6-4.8ꢁFei Mu positions the camera behind
Liyan’s bed curtain to film Zhichen’s shadow as he enters Liyan’s bedroomꢀ......................................................................................... 201
Fig. 4.9ꢁLong take of Yuwen and Zhichen with a chicken walking in the foregroundꢀ....................................................................................... 205
Fig. 4.10ꢁA sickly Liyan sits in the bombed ruins of his home in
Spring in a Small Townꢀ............................................................................. 209
Fig. 6.1ꢁYe Qianyu, “Jiang Qing Pulls out my tendons by imperial
Edict,” from his 1987 sketch-cartoon series Ten Years of an Absurd Dreamꢀ ............................................................................................. 275
Fig. 6.2ꢁYe Qianyu, “the End of the Qing Dynasty, Leaving behind Childhood,” from his 1993 sketch-cartoon series An Old Brush Recalls Childhoodꢀ............................................................. 275
Fig. 6.3ꢁYe Qianyu, “i am in You, You are in Me, May 1983,
Ye Qianyu, Mr. Wang together.”ꢀ........................................................... 277
Fig. 6.4ꢁYe Qianyu, “He is in Me, i am in Him,” 1987ꢀ.... Plate Section Fig. 6.5ꢁWang Zengqi on a return visit to his hometown of
Gaoyou during the late 1980sꢀ ................................................................ 279
ACKnOWLEDGMEntS this book has been a very long time in the making, and numerous people have aided me in every conceivable way throughout the process of writing and research. First, i am grateful to my doctoral advisor Lydia H. Liu, who encouraged me to follow my interest in wartime culture and in the writings of Wang Zengqi, and whose scholarship has in many ways inspired my research. David Rolston provided meticulous and lucid corrections, guidance, advice, and suggestions. in particular, i am indebted to Jin Feng for her willingness to read ongoing drafts and different versions of my chapters and give me insightful feedback on them. thanks as well to Miranda brown for her constructive critique and encouragement. Other readers whose advice and suggestions i greatly benefited from include Jason McGrath, Alina Clej, Shuen-fu Lin, Chris berry, Xiaobing tang, ben Ridgway, Jing Jiang, Desmond Cheung, Linda FitzGerald, and Qiang ning. in addition, Paul Sorrell meticulously copy-edited my manuscript, and Cynthia Col did an excellent job of compiling the index. Finally, i am indebted to Yi-tsi Feuerwerker for her superb teaching and mentoring.
Scholars in China were also instrumental in helping me complete my research. Su Guanxin, Wen Liming, Xie Zhixi, Qian Liqun, Liu Dong, Wu Xiaodong, and Zhang Yongjie shared with me some of their extensive knowledge of wartime culture. in addition, they helped me access archives, locate books, and in many cases generously gave me books they felt would be helpful for my research. Also, Feng Yaoping kindly shared with me many of her memories of wartime Kunming.
At the University of Michigan, i greatly benefited from the help of
Mr. beni at the international institute and Calvin Hsu, formerly of the Asia Library. At Stanford’s Hoover Archives Cissie Hill enabled me to find lots of useful materials. in addition, this project was made possible by generous funding from a Fulbright Grant, a Chiang Ching-kuo Dissertation Fellowship, and a Rackham One-term Dissertation Fellowship.
Since coming to Auburn University four years ago, i have been very fortunate to be recipient of an Auburn University College of Liberal Arts semester release from teaching and a summer grant. i am particularly grateful to my colleagues Makiko Mori, Morris bian, and Samia Spencer for their encouragement and feedback on several chapter drafts and on
xii
acknowledgments
my book proposal. Moreover, Makiko Mori was of great assistance in taking over department responsibilities while i was on research leave.
At brill, Qin Higley, Matt Kawecki, Katie Chin, Yoona Wagener, Rachel
Crofut, and tom begley have been extremely patient and helpful in answering my many questions and guiding me through the process of preparing my manuscript for publication. Also, i would like to express my deep appreciation to the two anonymous reviewers of my manuscript whose comments and suggestions were tremendously helpful in giving me a new perspective on my manuscript.
Portions of Chapter Four were previously published under the title
“Spring in a Small Town—Gazing at Ruins,” in Chris berry, ed., Chinese
Films in Focus 2. Grateful acknowledgment is given to the british Film institute for granting permission to reprint this material. Stanford University Press gave permission to publish two photos from John israel’s
Lianda: A Chinese University in War and Revolution. King Features Syn-
dicate allowed the reproduction of the Feb. 10, 1935 edition of George McManus, “bringing up Father.”
Above all, i would like to thank my family for their unflagging encouragement and support throughout the process of researching and writing this book. i dedicate this book to my family.
intRODUCtiOn
OUt OF tHE ASHES: tOWARDS A WARtiME AEStHEtiCS OF DiSSOLUtiOn
Critiquing what he saw as the failure of many modern short stories to portray a reality inherently marked by chaos and uncertainty, in his essay “the Essence of the Short Story” (Duanpian xiaoshuo de benzhi 短篇小
说
的本质; 1947), Wang Zengqi 汪曾祺 (1920–97) wrote:
Life is scattered, not organized in a clear progression, filled with coincidence, with thousands of possible beginnings and tens of thousands of potential outcomes. there has never been a person for whom every second of life equates to the paragraphs, sentences, words, punctuation, or empty spaces in fiction—but, preeminently, writers of novels brazenly ignore this situation.1
As a result of his dissatisfaction with fiction organized around neat and well-defined plots, Wang advocated that the short story should instead borrow from other genres: “We are willing that the short story resemble poetry, the essay, or drama. Or if it doesn’t resemble anything, that’s fine, so long as it doesn’t seem too much like a short story.”2
Wang’s rejection of linear plots and his criticism of the inadequacy of the short story in capturing “scattered” (sanman 散漫) wartime realities echoed similar sentiments voiced by other writers and artists during China’s War of Resistance against Japan (1937–45)3 and the ensuing Chinese Civil War (1945–49). in her essay “Days and nights of China” (Zhongguo de riye 中国的日夜; 1946), written as an epilogue for her 1946 edition of Romances (Chuanqi 传奇), Eileen Chang 张爱玲 (1920–95) described her sense of the transiency of life, wherein “not only will hopes turn to
1 Wang Zengqi, “Duanpian xiaoshuo de benzhi,” in Zhong Jingwen 钟敬文 and Deng
Jiuping 邓九平, eds., Wang Zengqi quanji 汪曾
祺全集 (Complete Works of Wang Zengqi),
8 vols. (beijing: beijing shifan daxue, 1998), iii: 22.
2 ibid., pp. 27–28. 3 Although Japanese troops had occupied Manchuria since 1931, it is generally agreed that the War of Resistance did not officially begin until July 7, 1937 after Japanese troops attacked the Marco Polo bridge outside beijing in what is referred to as the “Marco Polo bridge incident” (Lugouqiao shibian 卢沟桥事变) or the “July 7 incident” (Qi qi shibian 七七事变). this study will only look at works produced following the outbreak of fullscale war.
2
introduction
ash, but anything and everything one touches will ultimately crumble to nothingness.”4 Similarly, in “Out of the Ashes” (Jinyu lu 烬余录; 1944), Chang criticized historians for writing teleological, thematically determined historical narratives and thereby producing fiction instead:
this thing we call reality is unsystematic, like seven or eight talking machines playing all at once in a chaos of sound, each singing its own song. From within that incomprehensible cacophony, however, there sometimes happens to emerge a moment of sad and luminous clarity, when the musicality of a melody can be heard, just before it is engulfed once more by layer after layer of darkness, snuffing out this unexpected moment of lucidity. Painters, writers, and composers string together these random and accidentally discovered moments of harmony in order to create artistic coherence. When history insists on the same sort of coherence, it becomes fiction. the reason that H.G. Wells’s [1866–1946] Outline of History cannot stand as a proper history is that it is a little too rationalized, chronicling as it does the struggle between the individual and the group from start to finish.5
While Chang draws from musical imagery here in her description of the “incomprehensible cacophony” of reality and the “musicality of a melody” of artistic coherence, in many of her other wartime writings she crossed generic divisions between popular fiction, the essay, drama, and film.
As in the case of Wang and Chang, the chaos of the war years served as the impetus for cross-generic formal experimentation in art and literature as intellectuals searched for a language to express chaotic wartime realities. the aim of this study is to analyze this aesthetic response to the turbulence of war during the War of Resistance and Chinese Civil War. in particular, this book examines developments in wartime modernism, focusing on its high degree of formal looseness, or what Shu-mei Shih has describedasthe“aestheticsofdissolution,”ablurringofboundariesbetween popular and elite and Chinese and Western culture, as well as among genres, styles, and narrative points of view.6 Further, by contextualizing
4ꢀEileen Chang, “Epilogue: Days and nights of China,” in nicole Huang, ed., and Andrew Jones, tr., Written on Water (new York: Columbia University Press, 2004), p. 216; Zhang Ailing, Chuanqi zengding ben 传奇增订本 (Romances, Enlarged Edition; Shanghai: Shanhe tushu gongsi, 1946), p. 391.
5ꢀAndrew Jones translates the title of this essay as “From the Ashes.” See Eileen Chang,
“From the Ashes,” in Written on Water, pp. 39–40; Zhang Ailing, “Jin yulu,” in Qian Liqun
钱理群, ed., Ershi shiji Zhongguo xiaoshuo lilun ziliao 二十世纪中国小说
理论资料
(twentieth-century Fiction theory Materials; beijing: beijing daxue, 1997), pp. 248–49.
6ꢀSee Shu-mei Shih, The Lure of the Modern: Writing Modernism in Semicolonial China,
1917–1937 (berkeley: University of California Press, 2001), p. 383; also see Shih’s epilogue, “Later Modernisms: the War Years and beyond,” pp. 379–85.
out of the ashes
3
the study of modernism within the history of the war period and wartime intellectuals’ writings on the topic of form, this book illustrates how such aesthetic fluidity was a product of the violence and displacement of the war years. the War of Resistance was a particularly tumultuous and bloody chapter in modern Chinese history. the number of deaths resulting from the war is difficult to calculate since no formal population census was taken before it began, but estimates range from between 10 and 37 million.7 Following the outbreak of full-scale war on July 7, 1937, widespread displacement ensued and tens of millions of people fled from urban coastal cities to the southwest and to Hong Kong.8 in the wake of the War of Resistance, China was once again thrown into turmoil when civil war between the nationalists and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) raged from 1945 to 1949.
Although the War of Resistance brought about tremendous destruction, prior to this period China was racked by ongoing war and repeated foreign invasions throughout most of the nineteenth and early decades of the twentieth century. Since the Opium War of 1839 and the subsequent ceding of Hong Kong to the british, China had been forced to give territorial and jurisdictional rights to britain, France, Japan, Russia, Germany, Portugal, and the United States. As a result of semi-colonial occupation, an influx of Western culture fostered the development of a kind of “translingual” modernity born out of the exchange between foreign and native