DOCSLIB.ORG

Newton's Third Law: a Verification with Buoyancy Forces

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Newton's Third Law: a Verification with Buoyancy Forces Newton’s Third Law: A Verification with Buoyancy Forces Barry Feierman - April 2013 SEPS/AAPT Drexel University Newton’s Third Law is the “law of interaction”. For every force that acts on one object, there is an equal force (equal is size, opposite in direction) that acts on a second object. Thus, this law is often called the “Law of Action and Reaction”. This law will be tested using buoyancy forces and a Vernier Force plate and Vernier Dual-Range Force meter. A metal can filled with soup has a density overall slightly greater than water. When the can is lowered into a big beaker of water, the can will sink. But as it sinks, it has an upward (buoyant) force acting on it from the water. The pressure on the bottom of the can from the water pushing the CAN upwards is greater than the pressure on the top of the CAN from the water, pushing the can downwards, since the bottom of the can is at a greater depth in the fluid, the water. Pressure in a fluid increases linearly with depth. Thus, there is an imbalance on the forces acting on the CAN by the WATER. This difference in pressure causes an upwards “buoyancy” force on the can. For more details, consult Archimedes’ Principle relating the buoyant force to the weight of the “displaced” fluid. However, from the point of view of the water in the beaker, what is happening? If the water exerts an upwards force on the CAN, then does the CAN exert an equal and opposite DOWNWARDS force on the water and beaker (Newton’s Third Law)? If so, then the water (and the beaker) should “weigh more” when the CAN is lowered into the WATER. In fact, if the CAN loses N newtons of weight due to the buoyancy of the water, then the BEAKER of WATER should GAIN the same N newtons of force. We will test this idea using two Vernier force sensors, Logger Pro software, a soup CAN, and a large BEAKER and some water. A Vernier Dual-Range Force Meter (0-50N) is used to “weigh” a can of soup when suspended in air. For the moment, ignore the buoyancy effect of the air since it is so small. The CAN of soup is attached to the force sensor by some string. A Vernier Force Plate Meter (0-850N) is used to measure the weight of a large beaker filled partially with water. We will record the weight of the CAN both before and after lowering it into the large beaker of water. We will record the apparent CHANGE in the can’s weight due to the buoyancy of the water. We will also record the weight of the BEAKER of WATER before and after lowering the CAN into the water. We will find the apparent CHANGE in weight of the Beaker of Water due to the buoyant effect it has on the can of soup. Our experiment will use Vernier’s Logger Pro to record data for 20 seconds at 50 samples per second. If the CAN of soup loses a weight N newtons, and if the BEAKER of water gains the same weight N newtons, then it looks like Newton’s Third Law is confirmed. We will now examine each graph in more detail. Here is the graph for the CAN of soup as it is lowered into the water in 20 seconds. Before can is lowered W = 9.8 N After can is lowered under water W = 1.0 N Loss in weight when can is under water = 8.8 N with a margin of error (std dev) of +/- 0.1 N Here is the graph for the BEAKER of WATER before and after the CAN of soup is lowered into the water. Beaker of water before can is lowered: W = 30.6 N Beaker of water after can is lowered: W = 39.5 N Gain in weight of Beaker and Water: W = 8.9 N The Vernier Force Plate sensor readings have a standard deviation of +/- 0.3 N Finally, we ADD the weight of the CAN of soup to the weight of the Beaker of Water by adding the force values of the two Force Sensors. Notice that the SUM of the two force sensors remains constant: W = 40.5 N both before, during, and after the can of soup is lowered into the beaker of water. Have we verified Newton’s Third Law by studying buoyancy of a soup can while lowered into a beaker of water? Barry Feierman [email protected] .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Estimating Your Air Consumption
    10/29/2019 Alert Diver | Estimating Your Air Consumption Estimating Your Air Consumption Advanced Diving Public Safety Diving By Mike Ange Mastering Neutral Buoyancy and Trim Military Diving Technical Diving Scientific Diving and Safety Program Oversight Seeing the Reef in a New Light ADVERTISEMENT Do you have enough breathing gas to complete the next dive? Here's how to find out. It is a warm clear day, and the Atlantic Ocean is like glass. As you drop into the water for a dive on North Carolina's famous U-352 wreck, you can see that the :: captain has hooked the wreck very near the stern. It is your plan to circumnavigate the entire structure and get that perfect photograph near the exposed bow torpedo tube. You descend to slightly below 100 feet, reach the structure and take off toward the bow. Unfortunately, you are only halfway, just approaching the conning tower, when your buddy signals that he is running low on air. Putting safety first, you return with him to the ascent line — cursing the lost opportunity and vowing to find a new buddy. If you've ever experienced the disappointment of ending a dive too soon for lack of breathing gas or, worse, had to make a hurried ascent because you ran out of air, it may surprise you to learn that your predicament was entirely predictable. With a little planning and some basic calculations, you can estimate how much breathing gas you will need to complete a dive and then take steps to ensure an adequate supply. It's a process that technical divers live by and one that can also be applied to basic open-water diving.
    [Show full text]
  • THE SOLUBILITY of GASES in LIQUIDS Introductory Information C
    THE SOLUBILITY OF GASES IN LIQUIDS Introductory Information C. L. Young, R. Battino, and H. L. Clever INTRODUCTION The Solubility Data Project aims to make a comprehensive search of the literature for data on the solubility of gases, liquids and solids in liquids. Data of suitable accuracy are compiled into data sheets set out in a uniform format. The data for each system are evaluated and where data of sufficient accuracy are available values are recommended and in some cases a smoothing equation is given to represent the variation of solubility with pressure and/or temperature. A text giving an evaluation and recommended values and the compiled data sheets are published on consecutive pages. The following paper by E. Wilhelm gives a rigorous thermodynamic treatment on the solubility of gases in liquids. DEFINITION OF GAS SOLUBILITY The distinction between vapor-liquid equilibria and the solubility of gases in liquids is arbitrary. It is generally accepted that the equilibrium set up at 300K between a typical gas such as argon and a liquid such as water is gas-liquid solubility whereas the equilibrium set up between hexane and cyclohexane at 350K is an example of vapor-liquid equilibrium. However, the distinction between gas-liquid solubility and vapor-liquid equilibrium is often not so clear. The equilibria set up between methane and propane above the critical temperature of methane and below the criti­ cal temperature of propane may be classed as vapor-liquid equilibrium or as gas-liquid solubility depending on the particular range of pressure considered and the particular worker concerned.
    [Show full text]
  • Pressure Diffusion Waves in Porous Media
    Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Title Pressure diffusion waves in porous media Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/5bh9f6c4 Authors Silin, Dmitry Korneev, Valeri Goloshubin, Gennady Publication Date 2003-04-08 eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California Pressure diffusion waves in porous media Dmitry Silin* and Valeri Korneev, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Gennady Goloshubin, University of Houston Summary elastic porous medium. Such a model results in a parabolic pressure diffusion equation. Its validity has been Pressure diffusion wave in porous rocks are under confirmed and “canonized”, for instance, in transient consideration. The pressure diffusion mechanism can pressure well test analysis, where it is used as the main tool provide an explanation of the high attenuation of low- since 1930th, see e.g. Earlougher (1977) and Barenblatt et. frequency signals in fluid-saturated rocks. Both single and al., (1990). The basic assumptions of this model make it dual porosity models are considered. In either case, the applicable specifically in the low-frequency range of attenuation coefficient is a function of the frequency. pressure fluctuations. Introduction Theories describing wave propagation in fluid-bearing porous media are usually derived from Biot’s theory of poroelasticity (Biot 1956ab, 1962). However, the observed high attenuation of low-frequency waves (Goloshubin and Korneev, 2000) is not well predicted by this theory. One of possible reasons for difficulties in detecting Biot waves in real rocks is in the limitations imposed by the assumptions underlying Biot’s equations. Biot (1956ab, 1962) derived his main equations characterizing the mechanical motion of elastic porous fluid-saturated rock from the Hamiltonian Principle of Least Action.
    [Show full text]
  • 8. Decompression Procedures Diver
    TDI Standards and Procedures Part 2: TDI Diver Standards 8. Decompression Procedures Diver 8.1 Introduction This course examines the theory, methods and procedures of planned stage decompression diving. This program is designed as a stand-alone course or it may be taught in conjunction with TDI Advanced Nitrox, Advanced Wreck, or Full Cave Course. The objective of this course is to train divers how to plan and conduct a standard staged decompression dive not exceeding a maximum depth of 45 metres / 150 feet. The most common equipment requirements, equipment set-up and decompression techniques are presented. Students are permitted to utilize enriched air nitrox (EAN) mixes or oxygen for decompression provided the gas mix is within their current certification level. 8.2 Qualifications of Graduates Upon successful completion of this course, graduates may engage in decompression diving activities without direct supervision provided: 1. The diving activities approximate those of training 2. The areas of activities approximate those of training 3. Environmental conditions approximate those of training Upon successful completion of this course, graduates are qualified to enroll in: 1. TDI Advanced Nitrox Course 2. TDI Extended Range Course 3. TDI Advanced Wreck Course 4. TDI Trimix Course 8.3 Who May Teach Any active TDI Decompression Procedures Instructor may teach this course Version 0221 67 TDI Standards and Procedures Part 2: TDI Diver Standards 8.4 Student to Instructor Ratio Academic 1. Unlimited, so long as adequate facility, supplies and time are provided to ensure comprehensive and complete training of subject matter Confined Water (swimming pool-like conditions) 1.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is High Blood Pressure?
    ANSWERS Lifestyle + Risk Reduction by heart High Blood Pressure BLOOD PRESSURE SYSTOLIC mm Hg DIASTOLIC mm Hg What is CATEGORY (upper number) (lower number) High Blood NORMAL LESS THAN 120 and LESS THAN 80 ELEVATED 120-129 and LESS THAN 80 Pressure? HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE 130-139 or 80-89 (HYPERTENSION) Blood pressure is the force of blood STAGE 1 pushing against blood vessel walls. It’s measured in millimeters of HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE 140 OR HIGHER or 90 OR HIGHER mercury (mm Hg). (HYPERTENSION) STAGE 2 High blood pressure (HBP) means HYPERTENSIVE the pressure in your arteries is higher CRISIS HIGHER THAN 180 and/ HIGHER THAN 120 than it should be. Another name for (consult your doctor or immediately) high blood pressure is hypertension. Blood pressure is written as two numbers, such as 112/78 mm Hg. The top, or larger, number (called Am I at higher risk of developing HBP? systolic pressure) is the pressure when the heart There are risk factors that increase your chances of developing HBP. Some you can control, and some you can’t. beats. The bottom, or smaller, number (called diastolic pressure) is the pressure when the heart Those that can be controlled are: rests between beats. • Cigarette smoking and exposure to secondhand smoke • Diabetes Normal blood pressure is below 120/80 mm Hg. • Being obese or overweight If you’re an adult and your systolic pressure is 120 to • High cholesterol 129, and your diastolic pressure is less than 80, you have elevated blood pressure. High blood pressure • Unhealthy diet (high in sodium, low in potassium, and drinking too much alcohol) is a systolic pressure of 130 or higher,or a diastolic pressure of 80 or higher, that stays high over time.
    [Show full text]
  • THE SOLUBILITY of GASES in LIQUIDS INTRODUCTION the Solubility Data Project Aims to Make a Comprehensive Search of the Lit- Erat
    THE SOLUBILITY OF GASES IN LIQUIDS R. Battino, H. L. Clever and C. L. Young INTRODUCTION The Solubility Data Project aims to make a comprehensive search of the lit­ erature for data on the solubility of gases, liquids and solids in liquids. Data of suitable accuracy are compiled into data sheets set out in a uni­ form format. The data for each system are evaluated and where data of suf­ ficient accuracy are available values recommended and in some cases a smoothing equation suggested to represent the variation of solubility with pressure and/or temperature. A text giving an evaluation and recommended values and the compiled data sheets are pUblished on consecutive pages. DEFINITION OF GAS SOLUBILITY The distinction between vapor-liquid equilibria and the solUbility of gases in liquids is arbitrary. It is generally accepted that the equilibrium set up at 300K between a typical gas such as argon and a liquid such as water is gas liquid solubility whereas the equilibrium set up between hexane and cyclohexane at 350K is an example of vapor-liquid equilibrium. However, the distinction between gas-liquid solUbility and vapor-liquid equilibrium is often not so clear. The equilibria set up between methane and propane above the critical temperature of methane and below the critical temperature of propane may be classed as vapor-liquid equilibrium or as gas-liquid solu­ bility depending on the particular range of pressure considered and the par­ ticular worker concerned. The difficulty partly stems from our inability to rigorously distinguish between a gas, a vapor, and a liquid, which has been discussed in numerous textbooks.
    [Show full text]
  • Lecture 3 Buoyancy (Archimedes' Principle)
    LECTURE 3 BUOYANCY (ARCHIMEDES’ PRINCIPLE) Lecture Instructor: Kazumi Tolich Lecture 3 2 ¨ Reading chapter 11-7 ¤ Archimedes’ principle and buoyancy Buoyancy and Archimedes’ principle 3 ¨ The force exerted by a fluid on a body wholly or partially submerged in it is called the buoyant force. ¨ Archimedes’ principle: A body wholly or partially submerged in a fluid is buoyed up by a force equal to the weight of the displaced fluid. Fb = wfluid = ρfluidgV V is the volume of the object in the fluid. Demo: 1 4 ¨ Archimedes’ principle ¤ The buoyant force is equal to the weight of the water displaced. Lifting a rock under water 5 ¨ Why is it easier to lift a rock under water? ¨ The buoyant force is acting upward. ¨ Since the density of water is much greater than that of air, the buoyant force is much greater under the water compared to in the air. Fb air = ρair gV Fb water = ρwater gV The crown and the nugget 6 Archimedes (287-212 BC) had been given the task of determining whether a crown made for King Hieron II was pure gold. In the above diagram, crown and nugget balance in air, but not in water because the crown has a lower density. Clicker question: 1 & 2 7 Demo: 2 8 ¨ Helium balloon in helium ¨ Helium balloon in liquid nitrogen ¤ Demonstration of buoyancy and Archimedes’ principle Floatation 9 ¨ When an object floats, the buoyant force equals its weight. ¨ An object floats when it displaces an amount of fluid whose weight is equal to the weight of the object.
    [Show full text]
  • Buoyancy Compensator Owner's Manual
    BUOYANCY COMPENSATOR OWNER’S MANUAL 2020 CE CERTIFICATION INFORMATION ECLIPSE / INFINITY / EVOLVE / EXPLORER BC SYSTEMS CE TYPE APPROVAL CONDUCTED BY: TÜV Rheinland LGA Products GmbH Tillystrasse 2 D-90431 Nürnberg Notified Body 0197 EN 1809:2014+A1:2016 CE CONTACT INFORMATION Halcyon Dive Systems 24587 NW 178th Place High Springs, FL 32643 USA AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE IN EUROPEAN MARKET: Dive Distribution SAS 10 Av. du Fenouil 66600 Rivesaltes France, VAT FR40833868722 REEL Diving Kråketorpsgatan 10 431 53 Mölndal 2 HALCYON.NET HALCYON BUOYANCY COMPENSATOR OWNER’S MANUAL TRADEMARK NOTICE Halcyon® and BC Keel® are registered trademarks of Halcyon Manufacturing, Inc. Halcyon’s BC Keel and Trim Weight system are protected by U.S. Patents #5855454 and 6530725b1. The Halcyon Cinch is a patent-pending design protected by U.S. and European law. Halcyon trademarks and pending patents include Multifunction Compensator™, Cinch™, Pioneer™, Eclipse™, Explorer™, and Evolve™ wings, BC Storage Pak™, Active Control Ballast™, Diver’s Life Raft™, Surf Shuttle™, No-Lock Connector™, Helios™, Proteus™, and Apollo™ lighting systems, Scout Light™, Pathfinder™ reels, Defender™ spools, and the RB80™ rebreather. WARNINGS, CAUTIONS, AND NOTES Pay special attention to information provided in warnings, cautions, and notes accompanied by these icons: A WARNING indicates a procedure or situation that, if not avoided, could result in serious injury or death to the user. A CAUTION indicates any situation or technique that could cause damage to the product, and could subsequently result in injury to the user. WARNING This manual provides essential instructions for the proper fitting, adjustment, inspection, and care of your new Buoyancy Compensator. Because Halcyon’s BCs utilize patented technology, it is very important to take the time to read these instructions in order to understand and fully enjoy the features that are unique to your specific model.
    [Show full text]
  • Future Towed Arrays - Operational Drivers and Technology Solutions
    UDT 2019 Sensors & processing, Sonar arrays for improved operational capability Future towed arrays - operational drivers and technology solutions Prowse D. Atlas Elektronik UK. [email protected] Abstract — Towed array sonars provide a key capability in the suite of ASW sensors employed by undersea assets. The array lengths achievable and stand-off distance from platforms provide an advantage over other types of sonar in terms of the signal to noise ratio for detecting and classifying contacts of interest. This paper identifies the drivers for future towed arrays and explores technology solutions that could enable towed array sonar to provide the capability edge in the 21st Century. 1 Introduction 2.2 Maritime Autonomous Systems and sensors for ASW Towed arrays are a primary sensor for ASW acoustic detection and classification. They are used extensively by Recent advancement in autonomous systems and submarine and ASW surface combatants as part of their technology is opening up a plethora of new ASW armoury of tools against the submarine threat. As the capability opportunities and threats, including concepts nature of ASW evolves, the design and technology that involve the use of a towed array sensor on an incorporated into future ASW towed arrays will also need unmanned underwater or surface vessel in order to support to adapt. This paper examines the drivers behind the shift mission objectives. in ASW and explores the technology space that may provide leading edge for future capability. The use of towed arrays on autonomous systems has been studied to show how effective this type of capability can The scope of towed arrays that this paper considers be.
    [Show full text]
  • Buoyancy Compensator Owner's Manual
    BUOYANCY COMPENSATOR OWNER’S MANUAL BUOYANCY COMPENSATOR OWNER’S MANUAL Thank you for buying a DTD – DARE TO DIVE buoyancy compensator (BC). Our BC’s are manufactured from high quality materials. These materials are selected for their extreme durability and useful properties. Exceptional attention is paid to the technology and technical arrangement of all components during the manufacturing process. The advantages of DTD – DARE TO DIVE compensators are excellent craftsmanship, timeless design and variability; all thanks to production in the Czech Republic. TABLE OF CONTENTS CE certification information 2 Important warnings and precautions 2 Definitions 4 Overview of models 6 1. Wings 6 2. Backplates 7 Adjusting the backplate straps 8 1. Adjusting the shoulder straps and D-rings 8 2. Adjusting the crotch strap and D-rings 9 3. Adjusting the waist belt strap and D-ring 9 4. How to use the QUICK-FIX buckle 9 Threading the waist belt strap through the buckle 10 Tuning the compensator 11 1. Assembly of the compensator for using with single bottle 11 2. Assembly of the compensator for use with doubles 12 Optional equipment 13 1. Weighting systems 13 2. Buoy pocket 14 Pre-dive inspection of the compensator 14 Care, maintenance and storage recommendations 15 Service checks 15 General technical information 15 Operating temperature range 16 Warranty information 16 Manufacturer information 16 Annex 1 - detailed description of the wing label 17 Revised – February 2020 1 CE CERTIFICATION INFORMATION All DTD – DARE TO DIVE buoyancy compensators have been CE certified according to European standards. The CE mark governs the conditions for bringing Personal Protective Equipment to market and the health and safety requirements for this equipment.
    [Show full text]
  • Pressure Vs. Volume and Boyle's
    Pressure vs. Volume and Boyle’s Law SCIENTIFIC Boyle’s Law Introduction In 1642 Evangelista Torricelli, who had worked as an assistant to Galileo, conducted a famous experiment demonstrating that the weight of air would support a column of mercury about 30 inches high in an inverted tube. Torricelli’s experiment provided the first measurement of the invisible pressure of air. Robert Boyle, a “skeptical chemist” working in England, was inspired by Torricelli’s experiment to measure the pressure of air when it was compressed or expanded. The results of Boyle’s experiments were published in 1662 and became essentially the first gas law—a mathematical equation describing the relationship between the volume and pressure of air. What is Boyle’s law and how can it be demonstrated? Concepts • Gas properties • Pressure • Boyle’s law • Kinetic-molecular theory Background Open end Robert Boyle built a simple apparatus to measure the relationship between the pressure and volume of air. The apparatus ∆h ∆h = 29.9 in. Hg consisted of a J-shaped glass tube that was Sealed end 1 sealed at one end and open to the atmosphere V2 = /2V1 Trapped air (V1) at the other end. A sample of air was trapped in the sealed end by pouring mercury into Mercury the tube (see Figure 1). In the beginning of (Hg) the experiment, the height of the mercury Figure 1. Figure 2. column was equal in the two sides of the tube. The pressure of the air trapped in the sealed end was equal to that of the surrounding air and equivalent to 29.9 inches (760 mm) of mercury.
    [Show full text]
  • High Blood Pressure: Weight Control
    Sacramento Heart & Vascular Medical Associates February 18, 2012 500 University Ave. Sacramento, CA 95825 Page 1 916-830-2000 Fax: 916-830-2001 Patient Information For: Only A Test High Blood Pressure: Weight Control What is high blood pressure? Blood pressure is the force of blood against artery walls as the heart pumps blood through the body. High blood pressure (hypertension) is blood pressure that keeps being higher than normal. How is high blood pressure affected by weight? One of the most important causes of high blood pressure is overweight. An unhealthy weight puts stress on the heart and lungs, forcing them to work harder. Losing weight reduces the stress on your heart. It can also lower your blood pressure. What can I do to control my weight? Change your eating habits so that you lose 1 to 2 pounds a week until you reach a healthy weight. Even a modest weight loss of 5 to 10 pounds can help. Your diet needs to be low in fat, cholesterol, and salt. Be careful about serving sizes. Don't drink a lot of juice or soda. Also limit the amount of alcohol you drink. A regular, moderate exercise program can help you lose weight or keep a normal weight because it increases your metabolism and burns up calories. It reduces stress and promotes good health. Exercise also lowers your cholesterol and blood sugar levels. Ask your healthcare provider to recommend a diet and exercise program that is right for you. How long will the effects last? If you are overweight and have high blood pressure, you will need to control your blood pressure all of your life.
    [Show full text]