Climate Resilience WASH Programming in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh an End-Line Study

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Climate Resilience WASH Programming in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh an End-Line Study Climate Resilience WASH Programming in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh An End-Line Study House 97 B Road 25 Block-A, Banani, Dhaka 1213 www.wateraid.org/bangladesh dm.W atch Disaster Management Watch 856/1 A, Kajipara, Mirpur, Dhaka-1216. Contact No: 01717064843, 01717232615, Email: [email protected] End Line Study of Climate Resilience WASH Programming in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh Contents Summary Table: Comparison between baseline and endline ................................................................... 6 Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................. 9 Section 1: Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 13 Section 2: Background and Context ....................................................................................................... 13 2.1. Project Overview .................................................................................................................... 14 2.2. Rationale of the Study ............................................................................................................ 15 2.3. Main Study Objectives............................................................................................................ 15 2.4. Specific Study Objectives ........................................................................................................ 15 Section 3: Methodology......................................................................................................................... 17 3.1. Study design and approach ......................................................................................................... 17 3.2. Study area................................................................................................................................... 17 3.2.1. Assasuni Upazila: .................................................................................................................. 18 3.2.2. Shyamnagar Upazila ............................................................................................................. 18 3.3. Data collection method ............................................................................................................... 19 3.4. Study population and sampling ................................................................................................... 20 3.5. Sample for Water Quality Test .................................................................................................... 21 3.6. Quality assurance during data collection ..................................................................................... 21 3.7. Data management and analysis................................................................................................... 21 3.8. Limitation ................................................................................................................................... 21 Section 4: Demographic profile of households and respondents ............................................................ 22 4.1. Profile of the Households ............................................................................................................ 22 4.2. Profile of the Respondents .......................................................................................................... 23 Section 5: Access to safe drinking water ................................................................................................ 24 5.1. Sources of drinking water: .......................................................................................................... 24 5.2. Sources of water used for other purposes: .................................................................................. 24 5.3. Availability of water sources in crisis: .......................................................................................... 24 5.4. Ownership of the source of drinking water: ................................................................................ 25 5.5. Maintenance of water sources: ................................................................................................... 26 5.5.1. Pond Sand Filters (PSF): ........................................................................................................ 26 2 5.5.2. Sallow Tube Well (STW): ...................................................................................................... 26 Page End Line Study of Climate Resilience WASH Programming in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh 5.5.3. Rain Water Harvesting: ........................................................................................................ 26 5.6. Distance, transportation and time factors: .................................................................................. 26 5.7. Quality of water pot and storage:................................................................................................ 27 5.8. Water Quality: ............................................................................................................................ 28 5.8.2. Arsenic (Source level): .......................................................................................................... 29 5.8.3. Iron (Source level): ............................................................................................................... 30 5.8.4. Salinity: ................................................................................................................................ 30 5.9. Observation of WSP at household: .............................................................................................. 31 Section 6: Access to improved sanitation ............................................................................................... 32 Section 7: Hygiene ................................................................................................................................. 33 Section 8: Risks and impacts of climate change on water, sanitation and hygiene practice .................... 35 Section 9: Prevalence of water-borne disease ........................................................................................ 38 9.1. Status of water borne disease: .................................................................................................... 38 9.2. Health seeking behavior and consequences of diseases: ............................................................. 39 Section 10: Role of community and local government ........................................................................... 40 10.1. Role of community in operation and maintenance of the water facilities: ................................. 41 10.2. Involvement of the local government (Union Parishad) to meet the WASH needs in the communities:..................................................................................................................................... 41 Section 11: Discussion and Conclusion ................................................................................................... 43 Annex 2: Statistical tables ...................................................................................................................... 49 Annex 3: Household survey questionnaire ............................................................................................. 70 References ............................................................................................................................................ 79 List of Tables: Table1: HH income-expenditure dynamics (taka) Table2: Occupation of Household head Table3: Education level of respondent and household head Table 4: Type of latrine used by HH Table 5: Hand Washing Practice Table 6: Hygiene practices at household levels Table7: How to cope with the risk of climate change Table 8: Type of water-borne diseases that affected HH members? List of Figures: 3 Figure 1: Crisis month of drinking water Page End Line Study of Climate Resilience WASH Programming in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh Figure 2: Water quality test – TTC at source Figure 3: Water quality test – TTC at HH Figure 4: Water quality test result – Arsenic Figure 5: Water quality test result – Iron List of Boxes: Box 1: Physical status of PSF Box 2: Perception of water quality Box 3: How people serve drinking water Box 4: Time line of climate change in southwest of Bangladesh Box 5: Role of WDMC to function PSF mitigate conflict 4 Page End Line Study of Climate Resilience WASH Programming in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh Abbreviation AAS Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer BCCSAP Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan BDS Bangladesh Drinking Standard DoE Department of Environment DTW Deep Tube well COP Convention on Climate Change CBO Community Based Organization CFU Colony Forming Unit DA Daily Allowance DPHE Department of Public Health Engineering FGD Focus Group Discussion GoB Government of Bangladesh IPCC Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change KII Key Informant Interview LGI Local Government Institutes LOQ Level On Quantization MFM Membrane Filtration Method NGO Non Government Organization NAPA National Adaptation Programme of Action PSF Pond-Sand Filter RWH Rain Water Harvesting RO Reverse Osmosis STW Shallow Tube Well TA Travel Allowance TTC Thermo Tolerance Coliform UNFCCC United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change UNICEF United Nations International
Recommended publications
  • Esdo Profile
    ECO-SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATION (ESDO) ESDO PROFILE Head Office Address: Eco-Social Development Organization (ESDO) Collegepara (Gobindanagar), Thakurgaon-5100, Thakurgaon, Bangladesh Phone:+88-0561-52149, +88-0561-61614 Fax: +88-0561-61599 Mobile: +88-01714-063360, +88-01713-149350 E-mail:[email protected], [email protected] Web: www.esdo.net.bd Dhaka Office: ESDO House House # 748, Road No: 08, Baitul Aman Housing Society, Adabar,Dhaka-1207, Bangladesh Phone: +88-02-58154857, Mobile: +88-01713149259, Email: [email protected] Web: www.esdo.net.bd 1 Eco-Social Development Organization (ESDO) 1. Background Eco-Social Development Organization (ESDO) has started its journey in 1988 with a noble vision to stand in solidarity with the poor and marginalized people. Being a peoples' centered organization, we envisioned for a society which will be free from inequality and injustice, a society where no child will cry from hunger and no life will be ruined by poverty. Over the last thirty years of relentless efforts to make this happen, we have embraced new grounds and opened up new horizons to facilitate the disadvantaged and vulnerable people to bring meaningful and lasting changes in their lives. During this long span, we have adapted with the changing situation and provided the most time-bound effective services especially to the poor and disadvantaged people. Taking into account the government development policies, we are currently implementing a considerable number of projects and programs including micro-finance program through a community focused and people centered approach to accomplish government’s development agenda and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) of the UN as a whole.
    [Show full text]
  • Mapping Exercise on Water- Logging in South West of Bangladesh
    MAPPING EXERCISE ON WATER- LOGGING IN SOUTH WEST OF BANGLADESH DRAFT FOR CONSULTATION FOOD AND AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION OF THE UNITED NATIONS March 2015 I Preface This report presents the results of a study conducted in 2014 into the factors leading to water logging in the South West region of Bangladesh. It is intended to assist the relevant institutions of the Government of Bangladesh address the underlying causes of water logging. Ultimately, this will be for the benefit of local communities, and of local institutions, and will improve their resilience to the threat of recurring and/or long-lasting flooding. The study is intended not as an end point, but as a starting point for dialogue between the various stakeholders both within and outside government. Following release of this draft report, a number of consultations will be held organized both in Dhaka and in the South West by the study team, to help establish some form of consensus on possible ways forward, and get agreement on the actions needed, the resources required and who should be involved. The work was carried out by FAO as co-chair of the Bangladesh Food Security Cluster, and is also a contribution towards the Government’s Master Plan for the Agricultural development of the Southern Region of the country. This preliminary work was funded by DfID, in association with activities conducted by World Food Programme following the water logging which took place in Satkhira, Khulna and Jessore during late 2013. Mike Robson FAO Representative in Bangladesh II Mapping Exercise on Water Logging in Southwest Bangladesh Table of Contents Chapter Title Page no.
    [Show full text]
  • Local Government and Rural Development in the Bengal Sundarbans: an Inquiry in Managing Common Property Resources 1
    Agriculture and Human Values 7, 2 (Spring 1990), 40-51. Local Government and Rural Development in the Bengal Sundarbans: An Inquiry in Managing Common Property Resources 1 Harry W. Blair Harry Blair is professor of political science at Bucknell University, and has held appointments at Colgate, Cornell, Columbia and Yale Universities, as well as at the United States Agency for International Development. He has conducted academic research and has served as a consultant in South Asia for more than 20 years, focusing on rural development policy, natural resource management and decentralization. In the subcontinent, his primary geographical concentration has been on Bangladesh and, within India, on Maharashtra and Bihar. ABSTRACT Of the three strategies available for managing common property resources (CPR)--centralized control, privatization and local management-this essay focuses on the last, which has proven quite effective in various settings throughout the Third World, with the key to success being local ability to control access to the resource. The major factors at issue in the Sundarbans situation are: historically external pressure on theforest; currently dense population in adjacent areas; a land distribution even more unequal than the norm in Bangladesh; and a decentralized local government structure initiated in the mid-1980s. The first three factors have encouraged the local population to view this CRP as a frontier to be exploited, rather than as a resource to be preserved for sustained yield. Thus to the extent that the new local government structure proves to be democratic and responsive to popular needs, it would most likely accelerate destruction of the Sundarbans, using the area as a cheap and easy way to provide some livelihood to the rural poor and landless.
    [Show full text]
  • Investigating the Climate-Induced Livelihood Vulnerability Index in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh
    Article Investigating the Climate-Induced Livelihood Vulnerability Index in Coastal Areas of Bangladesh Mehedi Mudasser 1, Md. Zakir Hossain 2 , Khan Rubayet Rahaman 3,* and Nur Mohammad Ha-Mim 2 1 National Resilience Programme (NRP), UNDP Bangladesh, IDB Bhaban, 18th Floor, UN Offices, E/8-A, Begum Rokeya Sarani, Dhaka 1207, Bangladesh; [email protected] 2 Urban and Rural Planning Discipline, Khulna University, Khulna 9208, Bangladesh; [email protected] (M.Z.H.); [email protected] (N.M.H.-M.) 3 Department of Geography and Environmental Studies, St. Mary’s University, 923 Robie Street, Halifax, NS B3H 3C3, Canada * Correspondence: [email protected] Received: 31 July 2020; Accepted: 10 September 2020; Published: 15 September 2020 Abstract: Understanding the complex dynamics of a household’s livelihood and potential vulnerabilities in the face of climate change is challenging. This research paper considers the Shyamnagar sub-district in the southern part of Bangladesh to analyze the complex issues of the vulnerability of livelihoods in the face of climate change. We conducted a questionnaire survey (n = 156) of approximately 15.6% of households in the study area. Consequently, we collected Geographical Information System (GIS) data and satellite imagery to demonstrate the land-use changes concerning vulnerabilities. A total of 54 indicators were selected to assess the livelihood vulnerability index, considering the demographic profiles, livelihood strategies, social networks, food security, water security, income, physical infrastructures, access to health services, and impacts of natural disasters. The results of the study demonstrate that only 21% of the people in the studied regions are less vulnerable to livelihood impacts in the face of climate change, while 23% of the households remain the most vulnerable.
    [Show full text]
  • Bangladesh: Human Rights Report 2015
    BANGLADESH: HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT 2015 Odhikar Report 1 Contents Odhikar Report .................................................................................................................................. 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................... 4 Detailed Report ............................................................................................................................... 12 A. Political Situation ....................................................................................................................... 13 On average, 16 persons were killed in political violence every month .......................................... 13 Examples of political violence ..................................................................................................... 14 B. Elections ..................................................................................................................................... 17 City Corporation Elections 2015 .................................................................................................. 17 By-election in Dohar Upazila ....................................................................................................... 18 Municipality Elections 2015 ........................................................................................................ 18 Pre-election violence ..................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Cyclone AMPHAN Joint Needs Assessment (JNA)
    Cyclone AMPHAN Joint Needs Assessment (JNA) Needs Assessment Working Group (NAWG) Bangladesh Date: 31 May 2020 BANGLADESH Cyclone AMPHAN: Joint Needs Assessment Monsoon Flood | July Coordinated efforts of Needs Assessment Working Group About the Working Group : The Needs Assessment Working Group (NAWG) is the platform for government and non government humanitarian agencies under Humanitarian Coordination Task Team (HCTT). The secretariat of the Working Group is hosted by CARE Bangladesh under the “Supporting Bangladesh Rapid Needs Assessment (SUBARNA) Project.” Implemented By Fund Managed By Funded By Disclaimer: This material has been funded by UK aid from the UK government, however the views expressed do not necessarily reflect the UK government’s official policies. BANGLADESH Cyclone AMPHAN: Joint Needs Assessment Monsoon Flood | July Topic • Executive Summary • Key Findings • Sectoral Key impacts and Recommendations • Geographical Synopsis of Cyclone AMPHAN • Cyclone AMPHAN : GoB Preparedness - Early Warning and Impact • Preparatory response by GoB • Cyclone AMPHAN : Geographical Scope of the Assessment • Cyclone AMPHAN : Overall Impact • Overall impact in the assessment areas : Demographic and geographic • Internal Disablement • Cyclone AMPHAN Impact- : Child Protection • Cyclone AMPHAN Impact: Early Recovery • Cyclone AMPHAN Impact: Education • Cyclone AMPHAN Impact: Food Security • Cyclone AMPHAN Impact: Gender Based Violence (GBV) • Cyclone AMPHAN Impact: Cyclone AMPHAN : Health • Cyclone AMPHAN Impact: Nutrition • Cyclone AMPHAN
    [Show full text]
  • TR 16-B Field Trip Reports from 2014
    Blue Gold Program Technical Report No. 16 - B Field Trip Reports from 2014 Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands Dhaka Bangladesh Bangladesh Water Development Board (BWDB) Department of Agricultural Extension (DAE) May 2015 Technical Report 16 Field Trip Reports from 2014 Date : 05/05/2015 Blue Gold Program address client in style ~DocClientAddress (Arial 8) Mott MacDonald, Amsterdamseweg 15, 6814 CM Arnhem, Postbus 441, 6800 AK, Arnhem, Nederland T +31 (0)26 3577 111 F +31 (0)26 3577 577 W www.mottmac.com Green corner – Save a tree today! Mott MacDonald is committed to integrating sustainability into our operational practices and culture. As a world leading consultancy business we are always seeking to improve our own performance and reduce the environmental impact of our business. Meanwhile, many of our staff are committed to living sustainably in their personal lives – as an employee-owned company Mott MacDonald shares their concerns. We feel an ethical obligation to reduce our emissions and resource use and have committed to reducing our per capita carbon footprint by a minimum of 5% year on year. We print our reports and client submissions using recycled, double-sided paper. Compared to printing single sided on A4 virgin paper, double sided printing on recycled paper saves the equivalent of two trees, over a ton of CO2 and a cubic metre of landfill space for every 100 reams. By choosing the greener path we have been able to achieve efficiencies benefiting both Mott MacDonald and our customers. We would like to share some of the principles of our own ‗Going Green‘ initiative: • When possible we scan rather than print and consider what really needs to be on paper • We use electronic faxing when practicable • We work on e-forms • We use recycled paper when possible and print on both sides • Reducing paper in the office creates a better working environment for our staff and our clients We believe that you, as one of our esteemed clients, will share our concern to conserve precious resources for the benefit of our planet and its inhabitants.
    [Show full text]
  • Funded By: European Commission Shushilan
    Evaluation Report on “Institutionalizing Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) for Enhanced Access to Justice of the Vulnerable Communities” Project Funded by: European Commission Submitted by: Sk. Amirul Islam Development Consultant Submitted to: Shushilan Kaliganj, satkhira January, 2011 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page No. Executive Summary 3 Chapter -1 Introduction and Objectives 4 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Objectives and Scope of the evaluation 1.3 Brief Description of the Project Chapter - 2 Methodology of the Study 2.1 Approach and Methods followed 2.2 Report preparation 2.3 Limitations of the study Chapter -3 Findings of the Evaluation 3.1 Justification of the Project 3.2 Strength and Weakness of the Project 3.3 Capacity Building of people’s organizations 3.4 Social Protection of Beneficiaries 3.5 Comparison between Baseline and Final Evaluation Findings 3.6 Sustainability of the Project Interventions 3.7 Impacts of the Project 3.8 Achievement of target 3.9 Project Achievements 3.10 Cost-benefit Analysis 3.11 Qualitative Findings & Case Studies Chapter -4 Lessons Learned and SWOT Analysis 4.1 Strength 4.2 Weakness 4.3 Opportunity 4.4 Threat 4.5 Lessons learned Chapter - 5 Recommendations References Annexure Annex -1: Terms of Reference Annex -2: List of participants attended the FGD discussion 2 Executive Summary This report covers the findings of the final evaluation of the project “Institutionalizing Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) for Enhanced Access to Justice of the Vulnerable Communities” project funded by European Commission, conducted during December 2010. The 2 years project has been implemented for the period of February 2009 to January 2011, covering 12 unions of Kaliganj & Shyamnagar Upazila under Satkhira District.
    [Show full text]
  • Participatory Action Research on Climate Risk Management, Bangladesh
    Studies & Reviews: 2012-39 Participatory Action Research on Climate Risk Management, Bangladesh Melody Braun, Mustafa Saroar Studies & Reviews: 2012-39 Participatory Action Research on Climate Risk Management, Bangladesh Authors Melody Braun, Mustafa Saroar This publication should be cited as: Braun, M., Saroar, M. (2012). Participatory Action Research on Climate Risk Management, Bangladesh. WorldFish, Penang, Malaysia. Studies & Reviews: 2012-39. Disclaimer © 2012 WorldFish. All rights reserved. This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part and in any form for educational or nonprofit purposes without the permission of the copyright holders provided that due acknowledgement of the source is given. This publication may not be copied or distributed electronically for resale or other commercial purposes without prior permission, in writing, from WorldFish. To obtain permission contact the Communications and Donor Relations Division, [email protected]. 2 Table of Contents List of Tables 4 Executive Summary 5 1. Introduction 6 2. Methodology 7 2.1 Site selection 7 2.2 Participatory research activities 7 2.3 Research techniques 7 2.4 Options raised for discussion 8 2.4.1 Designed diversification 8 2.4.2 Index-based financial risk transfer 8 2.4.3 Adaptive management in response to advance information 8 2.5 Participants, gender and equity 9 3. Vulnerability and Needs Assessment 9 3.1 Jagannathpur village, Suktagarh union, Rajapur upazila, Jhalokati district 9 3.1.1 The study site and livelihood activities 9 3.1.2 Risk assessment
    [Show full text]
  • Climate Resilient Drinking Water Infrastructure Based on a Demand- Supply and Gap Analysis
    Synthesis Report Climate resilient drinking water infrastructure based on a demand- supply and gap analysis For 39 Unions of 5 Upazilas under Khulna and Satkhira District June 22, 2017 Submitted to: UNDP by WaterAid Bangladesh 2 Abbreviation ACS : Appreciative Consulting Services BDT : Bangladeshi Taka BOT : Build – Operate – Transfer BWDB : Bangladesh Water Development Board CBO : Community Based Organisation CCTF : Climate Change Trust Fund DPHE : Department of Public Health Engineering GIS : Geographic Information System GOB : Government of Bangladesh HH : Household ICCAD : International Conference on Computer Aided Design ITN-BUET : International Training Network – Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology JMP : Joint Monitoring Programme KM : Kilometer LGSP : Local Government Support Project LPCD : Liter Per Capita Per Day LPD : Liter Per Day MAR : Managed Aquifer Recharge MIS : Management Information System MoEF : Ministry of Environment and Forest NAPA : National Adaptation Programme of Action O&M : Operation and Maintenance PPP : Public Private Partnership PPT : Parts Per Thousand PRA : Participatory Rural/Rapid Appraisal PSF : Pond Sand Filter PWS : Piped Water System RO : Reverse Osmosis RWH : Rain Water Harvesting RWHS : Rain Water Harvesting System SMC : School Management Committee Sq.km : Square Kilometer UNDP : United Nations Development Programme UNICEF : United Nations Children’s Emergency Fund UP : Union Parishad WAB : WaterAid Bangladesh WSP : Water Safety Plan WSP-WB : Water and Sanitation Program – The World
    [Show full text]
  • Upazila: Shyamnagar, District: Satkhira December 2014
    of Upazila: Shyamnagar, District: Satkhira December 2014 Local Capacity Building and Community Empowerment (LCBCE) Programme. Supported by: UNICEF Table of Content Sl # Content Page # 1. Union Map 03 2. Background, Socio-economic conditions , Disaster Vulnerabilities 04 3. Socio-economic condition 04 4. Geography 04 5. Disaster/ Vulnérabilités 05 6. Hard-to-Reach Areas. 05 7. Population in general 05 8. Child Population 06 9. Snapshot of situation of children and women in the union 06 10. Health and Nutrition 07 11. Situation of Birth Registration, Disability and Child Marriage 08 12. Child Labour 09 13. Education: Pre Primary, Primary and Secondary level 09 14. Water and Sanitation 10 15. Service by NGOs 10 16. Union Parishad Functional Status 11 17. Table 1.1: Ward wise Sex disaggregated population data 13 18. Table 1.2: Age specific child population 14 19. Table 2.1: Ward wise number of Children fully immunized or left out 15 20. Table 2.2: Ward wise number of pregnant women with status of IFA intake 16 21. Table 2.3: Infrastructure and facilities/ Health & FP 17 22. Table 2.4 and 2.5: HR status of Health and FP 17 23. Table 3.1: Situation of birth registration child labour, disability 18 24. Table 4.1: Pre-primary Education coverage 19 25. Table 4.2: Primary Education coverage 20 26. Table 4.3: Secondary education coverage 20 27. Table 4.4: Infrastructure and facilities of Educational institution 21 28. Table 4.5: HR status of Institution 21 29. Table 5.1: Source of safe water and water Coverage 22 30.
    [Show full text]
  • Development of Climate Resilient Slope Protection for Dykes in Saline Zones of Bangladesh
    DEVELOPMENT OF CLIMATE RESILIENT SLOPE PROTECTION FOR DYKES IN SALINE ZONES OF BANGLADESH A Thesis submitted by B. A. M. SHAHRIAR Student No. 1009042222P A Thesis Submitted to the Department of Civil Engineering in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for the Degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE IN CIVIL ENGINEERING BANGLADESH UNIVERSITY OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY JUNE, 2015 DEDICATED TO My Parents And My Respected Supervisor Dr. Mohammad Shariful Islam i ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Firstly I would like to thank Almighty Allah for his bless to give me ability for completing this thesis work successfully. The author wishes to express his deepest gratitude to his supervisor Dr. Mohammad Shariful Islam, Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology for his constant supervision, continuous guidance and valuable suggestions without which this thesis work would not come into reality. He provides knowledge, reference to the author to carry out the work smoothly. His relentless expert guidance, keen interest in this topic, valuable advice, encouragement, interest, contribution to new ideas and supervision were the sources of inspiration to the author. He gave unyielding support to author for completing this thesis. The author is grateful to Dr. A.M.M Taufiqul Anwar, Professor and Head of the Department of Civil Engineering, Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology for his guidance and support from the Department. The author expresses his gratitude to Dr. Mohammed Kabirul Islam, Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology for his valuable information, guidance and suggestions that made this work resourceful. The author is very grateful to Dr.
    [Show full text]