Frontier Schools: a Reflectiœsi of Toe Turner Hypotoesis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
I Thisdisseitalloiihisbeeo , . odaoiDrawlsxaetlratracslvsd 09-Zl,9/0 ALLISON, Clinton Boyd, 1935- FRONTIER SCHOOLS: A REFLECTIŒSI OF TOE TURNER HYPOTOESIS. TTie University of Oklahoma, PhJD., 1969 • Education, history University Microfilms, Inc., Aim Arbor, Ibfichigan © CLINTON BOYD ALLISON 1970 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED THE UNIVERSITY OP OKLAHOMA GRADUATE COLLEGE FRONTIER SCHOOLS: A REFLECTION OF THE TURNER HYPOTHESIS A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE FACULTY in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY BY CLINTON BOYD ALLISON Norman, Oklahoma 1969 FRONTIER SCHOOLS: A REFLECTION OF THE TURNER HYPOTHESIS DISSERTATION COMMITTEE For Claudia, Janice, Beth Ann, and Kathleen ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I wish to express my gratitude to a number of persons who aided in developing this dissertation. Lloyd P. Williams, David Ross Boyd Professor of History and Philosophy of Educa tion, directed the study and gave encouragement, time, and numerous helpful suggestions. Professor John Pulliam of the College of Education critically read each of the preliminary drafts and suggested a number of improvements. Professor A. M. Gibson of the History Department, in spite of a leave of absence during the time that this study was being completed, gave generously of his time. Appreciation is expressed to Professor Jack Parker of the College of Education for his encouragement and his numerous courtesies. My wife, Claudia, typed each of the chapters several times, read with a critical eye, and maintained unfailingly good spirits. Particular appreciation is expressed to Beryl Hamilton of Wichita, Kansas, who helped to develop my interest in both education and in frontier history. IV PREFACE This work explores the significance of the frontier experience on the development and practices of schools in seven middle western states. To aid the reader, a short synopsis of each chapter follows. "The Frontier Hypothesis and Educational History" contains a statement of the frontier hypothesis and a discus sion of the controversy surrounding it. The impact of the theory on American historiography and on other spheres of American thought is reviewed, and the positions of some of the major critics and defenders are examined. The applica tion of the theory to frontier education, including a short review of the literature, concludes the chapter. "Intellectual and Literary Activity on the Frontier" is concerned with the cultural milieu in which the schools developed. Vaurious stereotypes of the Westerner and the heterogeneous nature of society on the middle western fron tier are explored. Anti-intellectualism, including the role of religious fundamentalism, is examined, and the quantity and quality of literary and intellectual activity is surveyed. "Desire and Disdain for Education" contrasts the criticisms, foreign and domestic, regarding the frontiersman's unconcern with educational opportunities with the enthusiasm and pride that many Westerners exhibited in their schools. The views and efforts of the New Englander, Southerner, and immigrant toward education on the middle western frontier are contrasted. Attention is given to the leadership role of the clergy in education. "The First Schools on the Frontier" is concerned with the forced innovations in schools established by the early settlers. The subscription schools, the makeshift buildings, the limited curriculum, the often ill prepared teachers, and school discipline are described. Educational opportunities at the secondary level on the frontier are discussed. "Tradition and Innovation in Education" explores the conflicts between the advocates of classical and more utili tarian curriculums. The perpetuation of the traditional clas sical curriculum in the middle western academies and early high schools is stressed. Attempts at reconstruction of the courses of study, including manual labor schools and Pesta- lozzian reforms, are investigated. "The Windfall of Public Lands" reviews the land grants from the national domain to education, and consideration is given to the effect of the land grauits on western educational thought. The inconsequential amount of income from and the mismanagement of school lands is discussed. Competition be tween schools and railroads for both land grants and the use of proceeds from the public lands is studied. vi "The Struggle for Tax Supported Schools" contains a review of the legislation leading to free common schools in each of the seven states studied. Impediments to a quick acceptance of free public schools as a result of the physical and economic burdens of the frontier are suggested. The com peting forces in the public school campaign are examined, and the relationship between the movement in the Middle West and the national common school revival is explored. "The Significance of the Frontier on Middle Western Schools" suggests the changes that might be anticipated if education reflected the frontier hypothesis. Attention is given to the affect of the frontier experience on innovation in curriculum and educational organization, and on the democ ratization of the schools. The chapter is concluded with recommendations for further study. Vil TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.................................... iv PREFACE ...................... V Chapter I. THE FRONTIER HYPOTHESIS AND EDUCATIONAL HISTORY .................................... 1 II. INTELLECTUAL AND LITERARY ACTIVITY ON THE FRONTIER........................... 35 III. DESIRE AND DISDAIN FOR EDUCATION ..... 73 IV. THE FIRST SCHOOLS ON THE FRONTIER .... 103 V. TRADITION AND INNOVATION IN EDUCATION . 138 VI. THE WINDFALL OF PUBLIC L A N D S ............. 170 VII. THE STRUGGLE FOR TAX SUPPORTED SCHOOLS . 189 VIII. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE FRONTIER ON MIDDLE WESTERN SCHOOLS ................... 238 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY.............................. 249 viii FRONTIER SCHOOLS: A REFLECTION OF THE TURNER HYPOTHESIS CHAPTER I THE FRONTIER HYPOTHESIS AND EDUCATIONAL HISTORY The most productive, bitter, and sometimes humorous, debates among American historians have been conducted over the controversy surrounding the significance of the frontier experience in American history. American historians are now in the third generation of the controversy. From 1893, when Frederick Jackson Turner read the paper which -was to be of paramount importance for American historiography— "The Sig nificance of the Frontier in American History"— at the meet ing of the American Historical Association in Chicago, until his death in 1932, the frontier thesis was accepted almost without challenge as the answer to the enigma as to the cause of the distinctiveness of the American character. Following Turner's death, and for a generation there after, the denunciations of the thesis were as complete and devastating as had been the acceptance before. In the present decade, according to a warm supporter of the hypoth esis, the "attitude is still one of doubt, but scholars in 2 a variety of fields are increasingly showing a willingness to test aspects of the thesis, rather than accept or condemn it as a whole. The elements of the thesis which were important for the purposes of this study are stated below: The experience of three hundred years of people continually returning to a more primitive environment by moving into a frontier region has been one of the most important factors in producing a distinctive people in the Western World— the American. The modifications required in tools, ideas, and institutions because of the demands of the new environment; and the work and skill required to garner the fruits of the abundance which the frontier possessed, but gave grudgingly, transformed the European in the frontiersman. The characteristics of the frontiersman, not all of them attractive by any means, became the most distinctive of American traits. Among the western characteristics was a vociferous equalitarianism which had the virtues of an insistence on democracy and which allowed rapid upward social mobility, but which also resulted in rudeness, disregard or indifference for the conventions of civilization, and an abhorrence of outside control. In order to conquer the wilderness, the frontiersman was driven to hard work, and because it payed, it became a habit and a virtue, and leisure a vice. The ^Ray Allen Billington, America * s Frontier Heritage (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, l^éé), xii. 3 result was a coarsening of the Westerner; he came to honor materialism, and failed to develop an appreciation of the aesthetic. The riches of the frontier in the form of miner als, timber, furs, or land led to exploitive and wasteful use of the natural resources of the continent. The existence of the wealth and the lack of societal restraints on its appropriation by individuals resulted in a mobile population and a restless energy as men sought to get their share. As the frontiersman faced the challenge of new prob lems on new frontiers, he was forced to experimentation and innovation. The result was an inventive and pragmatic per sonality which habitually accepted the new when it demon- 2 strated practicality, and readily*discarded the old. The Frontier hypothesis has strongly, if not always desirably, influenced thought in America.^ For most twentieth century Americans, or at least for those who considered the sources of their culture at all, it was the explanation of 2 The statement of the hypothesis was developed from a number of sources including: Frederick Jackson Turner, "The Significance of the Frontier