Spaces of Commoning
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Publication Series of the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna VOLUME 18 Spaces of Commoning Artistic Research and the Utopia of the Everyday Anette Baldauf Stefan Gruber Moira Hille Annette Krauss Vladimir Miller Mara Verlič Hong-Kai Wang Julia Wieger (Eds.) Spaces of Commoning Artistic Research and the Utopia of the Everyday Spaces of Commoning Artistic Research and the Utopia of the Everyday Anette Baldauf Stefan Gruber Moira Hille Annette Krauss Vladimir Miller Mara Verlič Hong-Kai Wang Publication Series of the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna Julia Wieger (Eds.) Eva Blimlinger, Andrea B. Braidt, Karin Riegler (Series Eds.) Volume 18 On the Publication Series We are pleased to present this new volume in the publication series of the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna. The series, published in cooperation with our highly committed partner Sternberg Press, is devoted to central themes of con- temporary thought about art practices and art theories. The volumes in the series comprise collected contributions on subjects that form the focus of dis- course in terms of art theory, cultural studies, art history, and research at the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna, and represent the quintessence of international study and discussion taking place in the respective fields. Each volume is pub- lished in the form of an anthology, edited by staff members of the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna. Authors of high international repute are invited to write contri- butions dealing with the respective areas of emphasis. Research activities such as international conferences, lecture series, institute-specific research focuses, or research projects serve as points of departure for the individual volumes. With Spaces of Commoning: Artistic Research and the Utopia of the Everyday, we are launching volume eighteen of the series. The book presents the results of a research project that has been conducted at the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna over the last two years. The project was funded by the WWTF the Vienna Sci- ence and Technology Fund through the funding program “Public Spaces in Transition (2013).” The project, headed by Anette Baldauf, professor at the Insti- tute for Art Theory and Cultural Studies at the Academy, and Stefan Gruber, then professor at the Institute for Art and Architecture at the Academy, brought together an international group of artistic researchers who developed case studies as tools for research into the question of “commoning,” case studies that looked closely at the history of commoning practices in Austria, in Ethio- pia, and in other selected places around the world—for example, on the island of Lesvos, Greece. It is not always the case that recent political developments make research ques- tions and research topics, which are formulated in regard to the state of the art of research, timely in an almost extreme way. In the summer of 2015, when thousands of refugees who had fled from Syria to seek asylum in safe places reached Austria, questions of commoning and of sharing became much more than an academic interest. The research project “Spaces of Commoning” reacted to this development in many ways, and we are happy that this in- depth publication was produced to tackle the many different aspects of the phenomenon in question. We thank the editors of this volume, the Spaces of Commoning research group, for bringing together this wide range of expertise, and for doing this as a group. And we thank, as usual, our partner, Sternberg Press, for publishing our series. The Rectorate of the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna Eva Blimlinger, Andrea B. Braidt, Karin Riegler Contents What Collects in a Collective? Stefano Harney 10 Artistic Practices and Uncommon Knowledge Pelin Tan 14 Editors: Anette Baldauf, Stefan Gruber, Moira Hille, Annette Krauss, Vladimir Introduction: Having to Make It, without Being Able to … Miller, Mara Verlič, Hong -Kai Wang, Julia Wieger Anette Baldauf, Stefan Gruber, Moira Hille, Annette Krauss, Editorial Coordinator: Martina Huber Vladimir Miller, Mara Verlič, Hong-Kai Wang, and Julia Wieger 20 Copyeditor: Helen Chang Proofreader: Niamh Dunphy Design: Victor Kassis, Surface, Frankfurt am Main/Berlin Study as Commoning: No Beginnings Cover image: Anette Baldauf, If we don’t come together, we will all fall apart, 2005. Photograph. Courtesy of the artist. Dear Border, Printing: Holzhausen Druck GmbH, Wolkersdorf Berhanu Ashagrie Deribew and Participants of the Commoning Seminar, Binding: Buchbinderei Papyrus, Vienna European Forum Alpbach 2015 34 This book is a result of a two-year research project “Spaces of Commoning: Artistic Practices, the Making of Urban Commons and Visions of Change” Allmeinde (http://www.spacesofcommoning.net), which was supportedd by the WWTF— Anette Baldauf 36 Vienna Science and Technology Fund. ISBN 978-3-95679-266-3 Crisis and Commoning: Periods of Despair, Periods of Hope Stavros Stavrides in Conversation with Mara Verlič 48 © 2016 Akademie der bildenden Künste Wien, Sternberg Press All rights reserved, including the right of reproduction in whole or in part in any form. Negotiating Addis Ababa’s Spatial Transformations Brook Teklehaimanot in Conversation Sternberg Press with Stefan Gruber and Vladimir Miller 60 Caroline Schneider Karl-Marx-Allee 78 D-10243 Berlin Cruising as www.sternberg-press.com Moira Hille 72 Study as Commoning: Call to Order Study across Borders: Addis Ababa—Vienna Anette Baldauf, Tesfaye Bekele Beri, Stefan Gruber, Designing Commoning Institutions: The Dilemma of the Vienna Mihret Kebede, Moira Hille, Annette Krauss, Settlers, the Commoner, and the Architect Vladimir Miller, Mara Verlič, Hong-Kai Wang, and Julia Wieger 194 Stefan Gruber 86 Merkato and the Mall: A Short History of Modernization Study across Time: Glancing Back at Vienna’s Settlers’ Movement Anette Baldauf and Elizabeth Giorgis 214 Anette Baldauf, Stefan Gruber, Moira Hille, Annette Krauss, Vladimir Miller, Mara Verlič, Hong-Kai Wang, and Julia Wieger 102 Study as Commoning: Bodies and Other Ghosts Housing Commons between Redistribution and Self-Organization Where Do You Come From: A Question of Uncommoning? Vienna’s Settlers’ Movement Then and Now Annette Krauss 230 Mara Verlič 120 The Intimacies of Other Humanities Always Forward: Hermann Neubacher and the Commons Lisa Lowe in Conversation with Hong-Kai Wang 242 Anette Baldauf, Maria Mesner, and Mara Verlič 132 City of Commons Study as Commoning: Wage Labor and Reproductive Labor Stefan Gruber and Vladimir Miller 254 A Great Source of Teaching for All of Us Silvia Federici in Conversation with Aluminé Cabrera 148 Study as Commoning: Commoning as Horizon Kitchen Politics Julia Wieger 154 Appendix Image Credits 266 Site for Unlearning (Art Organization) Team at Casco—Office for Art, Design and Theory and Annette Krauss 168 Biographies 270 Acknowledgments 274 Study as Commoning: Noise as Border How to Hear in Common: The More Impossible, the More Political, No? Ultra-red 186 Stefano Harney 11 What collects in a collective? I believe the Spaces of Commoning collective poses this question in the collection that follows. It is a collection that at first What Collects sight might be misrecognized, so familiar is the form of collected studies. Indeed, rather than approaching what follows as a common collection of studies, one might instead approach these essays as studies that collect the common. One might unlearn some of our assumptions about the autonomy of studies in a collection. One might then begin to hear in common some- in a Collective? thing that collects in these studies. One can begin to cross these studies, to cruise them for what collects. One begins to unsettle oneself as a way to move through this collection, in a movement of what collects. As we do we Stefano Harney start to feel that we are collected by cruising this collection. We are brought together by what follows, by what we let follow us, collect us. We are brought together in study by these studies. And to be brought together in study is to let oneself be collected. It is the act of allowing oneself to be collected. This is the act of study. To be brought together in the Merkato in Addis Ababa or in the archive of Llano del Rio in California, or the settlers’ movement in Vienna is to let go of one’s collected self. It is to be neither calm nor collected. It is to allow oneself to be uncollected, unclaimed by oneself, awaiting collection. To enter into study with Casco in the Netherlands, or Ultra-red in the United Kingdom, to be collected by Queer Base in Austria, or by Ethiopian university colleagues in a meda in the midst of a city is to feel the unsettling movement of coming together in study with others, of allowing oneself to de-collect in this collection. To become the site for collection, to be collected by collection is to cease to be the collector; that is, to cease to be the collector of oneself as the pre- tense for collecting others. It is a pretense because the collection of the self is always the collection of others and therefore never the collected self, never the self-collected authority to collect others. But it is a powerful pretense. It is the kind of pretense that thrives off the idea of a collection of studies. Here the study stands for the self-collected authority of the researcher who is ca- pable of entering into collection with others based on his own calm and col- lected will, a will authorized by his authoritative study. This is at the same time the kind of powerful pretense to the authority of a collector who seeks to bring together studies in such a collection. But there is no such pretense here: one does not find a collection to call one’s own; one does not come to own what one collects, nor does collection become the act of seizure, the right to ownership, or the ownership of such rights.