DOCSLIB.ORG

Theosophical Garden Cities in England, India and Australia

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Theosophical Garden Cities in England, India and Australia An Enchanted World Order: Theosophical Garden Cities in England, India and Australia The international spread of the Garden City movement has been historicized as a tussle between the ideals of social reform first advocated by Ebenezer Howard and the commercial viability of the many garden suburbs that were built. Garden suburbs are noted for betraying Howard’s vision of class mixing and communal ownership of land. Nonetheless, the developers of garden suburbs shared Howard’s conviction that town planning could remedy overcrowding in cities. This paper uncovers how the Theosophical Society brought global attention to Ebenezer Howard’s Garden City concept even as it raised doubts about the ability of physical planning to remove the public health problems associated with uncontrolled city growth. The Theosophical Society was founded in New York in 1875 with the objective of studying paranormal phenomena, but quickly grew into an international network of professionals searching for spiritual and philosophical alternatives to organized, mainstream religion. Theosophists were amongst the earliest residents of the First Garden City of Letchworth, and by 1920 the Theosophical Society built a boarding school and a Lodge in Letchworth, and had organized several conferences on the progressive planning ideals of the Garden City movement. Between 1924 and 1928 the Theosophical Society built its own Garden City on the outskirts of Bombay, and in 1926 it launched a lecture series, a magazine and a radio station that would popularize the idea of Garden City living in Australia. Using urban design plans, polemical texts and newspaper articles from England, India and Australia, this paper argues that the Theosophical Society appropriated and transformed Ebenezer Howard’s Garden City concept from an ideal of city planning into a means of conflict resolution. Thus, I show that while the Theosophical Society viewed the Garden City as a modern example of communitarian living, it did not associate the Garden City with any particular urban form. On the contrary, the Theosophical Society was remarkably anti-formalist in its study and reproduction of the Garden City. Rather than specify the ideal density, plot layout or open space requirements for its own Garden cities in India and Australia, the Theosophical Society only specified how to resolve disputes between members of a Theosophical Garden City. Instead of seeing the Garden City as an ideal urban form in which different classes lived together in an organic social harmony, the Theosophical Society understood the Garden City as a site for provoking and transcending social antagonisms. By the mid-1920s, the Theosophical Society would even publicly advocate its Garden Cities as means for overcoming the rise of Fascism and Soviet Socialism. This paper revises the history of the Garden City movement by showing how the Theosophical Society appropriated and transformed Ebenezer Howard’s idea of land-based social reform into a program that used experimental pedagogy and public arts performance for conflict resolution. More broadly, this paper also provides insight into how the rhetoric of spirituality challenged the normative public health goals of modern town planning. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Garden Cities Located in What Now Are the Suburbs of Berlin
    focus | 2009 | volume VI 53 GAR D EN CITIES: LESSONS FROM GERMANY Kar L ECKE R T Karl Eckert is a senior at Ebenezer Howard’s lessons and the Garden City movement spread throughout Europe the BCRP program, City between the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th. In this article, Karl Eckert and Regional Planning Department, Cal Poly. discusses the origins of the movement and the translation of the concept to Germany. During a recent trip, he visited and studied tSiemensstadt and Britz, two garden cities located in what now are the suburbs of Berlin. In reading the book Cities of Tomorrow by Sir Peter Hall, one comes to realize the profession of planning is a relatively new field of expertise. Modern day city planning stems from the early 1900’s when the societies of the developing world were dealing with the menace of the urban slum, a new phenomenon spurred by industrial forces and a rise in migratory populations to major city centers for employment. Developing ideas that would counter-attack this dire urban condition would soon define and establish what is known today as city planning. Life in the Slums Peter Hall’s Cities of Tomorrow elaborates on how, during the period of 1880 to 1920, major cities such as London, Berlin, Paris and New York experienced complications with slum populations. These cities exhibited high concentrations of poor residents within areas defined by the lack of physical maintenance, crowded conditions, disregard for sanitation, and general social decline. Andrew Figure 1 Mearns, a pamphlet writer of the time, described the slums of London with clarity: The Siemens factory, which was the main employment outlet “Few who read these pages have any conception of what these pestilential human rookeries for those living in are, where tens of thousands are crowded together amidst horrors which call to mind what we Seimensstadt.
    [Show full text]
  • From the Garden City Movement Onwards
    From the Garden City Movement Onwards Utopianism in British Garden Cities Rick William Moerman Department of Human Geography Examiner: Mads Barbesgaard SGEM08 Supervisor: Anders Lund Hansen Spring 2020 2 Abstract With the publication of Garden Cities of To-Morrow in 1898, Ebenezer Howard gave the go-ahead to the Garden City Movement. Howard’s concept of the garden city arose from his anti-capitalist critiques. Many industrial cities in the United Kingdom were facing urbanization problems, leading to the working class living in terrible circumstances in the suburban areas. This process caused a poor quality of life, housing shortages, polluted air and water and a lack of access to nature. At the same time, the countryside lacked career opportunities and a lack of (cultural) amusement. Howard proposed the garden city as a new alternative to both ways of living. A garden city would have a green character and a blooming cultural life. Surrounding greenbelts and enough job opportunities would make the city self-sustainable. The reactions to Howard’s utopian ideas were mainly positive, leading to the construction of two garden cities in the United Kingdom. Letchworth and Welwyn Garden City were located close to London and offered a way of living as proposed by Howard. These projects were considered successful, leading to the establishment of the related New Town Movement. This movement eventually led to the creation of 28 new and self-sustaining towns all over the United Kingdom. Meanwhile, the two original garden cities had developed into rich commuter towns which had become too expansive for the working class population.
    [Show full text]
  • Deconstructing Howard Through the Lens of Hall: Lessons from the Garden City Reformer
    FOCUS 14 Essays Deconstructing Howard through the Lens of Hall: Lessons from the Garden City Reformer. William Riggs PhD; Assistant Professor, City and Regional Planning Department, Cal Poly.* In this provocative essay, William Riggs discusses the lasting legacy of Ebenezer Howard's and Sir Peter Hall's work and who it challenges us to think our solutions and deal with familiar issues like protecting green belts, equitable jobs and housing. The author notes that the resurgence of a stronger focus on physical design and the sustainability and eco-towns movements will help us move towards a Howard-inspired "Peaceful Path to Real Reform". he work of reformer Ebenezer Howard had a speciÿc and country environment as well as the beneÿts of the town. Tlasting vision on city design, the legacies of which we see This article deconstructs the lessons of Howard through the today. Like many planners today, Howard was deeply con- contextual lens that Hall provides. It focuses on tacit lessons cerned about social issues and problems and saw the design urban planners and policy makers might realize today and in- of a good city as a way to correct this. He outlined a city, and tegrate into their own thinking or practice. The also provides explained how it could expand growing cluster by cluster, reminders of key design lessons and principles that still reso- in little pods connected by the railways, yet maintaining the nate when we look at our most desired spaces and places. same concordance with city/country feel by making sure to These include a focus on design, behavior, social and eco- insert rings of green space within the growing clusters and nomic change—things that planners can consider in projects preserve the countryside.
    [Show full text]
  • OLMSTED TRACT; Torrance, California 2011 – 2013 SURVEY of HISTORIC RESOURCES
    OLMSTED TRACT; Torrance, California 2011 – 2013 SURVEY OF HISTORIC RESOURCES II. HISTORIC CONTEXT STATEMENT A. Torrance and Garden City Movement: The plan for the original City of Torrance, known as the Olmsted Tract, owes its origins to a movement that begin in England in the late 19th Century. Sir Ebenezer Howard published his manifesto “Garden Cities of To-morrow" in 1898 where he describes a utopian city in which man lives harmoniously together with the rest of nature. The London suburbs of Letchworth Garden City and Welwyn Garden City were the first built examples of garden city planning and became a model for urban planners in America. In 1899 Ebenezer founded the Garden City Association to promote his idea for the Garden City ‘in which all the advantages of the most energetic town life would be secured in perfect combination with all the beauty and delight of the country.” His notions about the integration of nature with town planning had profound influence on the design of cities and the modern suburb in the 20th Century. Examples of Garden City Plans in America include: Forest Hills Gardens, New York (by Fredrick Law Olmsted Jr.); Radburn, New Jersey; Shaker Heights, Ohio; Baldwin Hills Village, in Los Angeles, California and Greenbelt, Maryland. Fredrick Law Olmsted is considered to be the father of the landscape architecture profession in America. He had two sons that inherited his legacy and firm. They practiced as the Olmsted Brothers of Brookline Massachusetts. Fredrick Law Olmsted Junior was a founding member of The National Planning Institute of America and was its President from 1910 to 1919.
    [Show full text]
  • Foundations of Modern American City Planning
    FOUNDATIONS OF MODERN AMERICAN CITY PLANNING Most historians agree that modern American city planning began in the late 1800’s. Some affix the date to 1893 and the Columbian Exposition in Chicago, though there is less orthodoxy regarding this moment than 15 years ago. In contrast to the earlier Colonial planning period (Philadelphia, Savannah, Williamsburg, etc.) wherein plans preceded development, planning in the 1800s generally responded to the urbanization stimulated by the industrial revolution in existing and haphazardly developing cities. The American Industrial Revolution occurred in two waves, the first in 1820-1870 and the second in 1870-1920. The U.S. grew from 7% urban in 1820 to 25% urban in 1870 and 50% urban in 1920. Several social movements categorized as precursors to modern American city planning (public health, sanitary reform, settlement house and housing reform, parks planning) responded to the challenges and consequences of chaotic urbanization prior to modern planning’s beginnings. The City Beautiful movement was a fifth response at about the same time that modern planning began. The Garden Cities Movement simultaneously commenced in England and was imported soon after. American planning grew out of and hoped to provide a broader, more comprehensive vision to these movements. Five interrelated and overlapping 1. Sanitary Reform Movement movements of the 19th Century have 2. Parks Planning/Parks Systems Movement profound effect on the first half of 3. Settlement House/Housing Reform Movement the 20th Century 4. Garden City Movement 5. City Beautiful Movement Movement Attributes Sanitary Reform (extensive overlap An outgrowth and response to the accelerating with and sometimes referred to as urbanization of the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Howard Park and Howard Garden, Letchworth Garden City, Herts Archaeological Desk Based Assessment
    Howard Park and Howard Garden, Letchworth Garden City, Herts Archaeological Desk Based Assessment Keith J Fitzpatrick-Matthews North Hertfordshire District Council Museums Service Archaeology Report 35 2008 Howard Park and Howard Garden, Letchworth Garden City, Herts Archaeological Desk Based Assessment Keith J Fitzpatrick-Matthews North Hertfordshire District Council Museums Service Archaeology Report 35 2008 Contents Metadata Title: Howard Park and Howard Garden, Letchworth Garden City, Herts: archaeological desk based assessment Author: Keith J Fitzpatrick-Matthews (Archaeology Officer, North Hertfordshire District Council, [email protected]) Derivation: First revision Origination Date: 11 April 2008 Reviser(s): Keith J Fitzpatrick-Matthews Date of last revision: 8 May 2008 Version: 1.1 Status: Final version Summary of Changes: Illustrations added; corrections to errors in the text; additional text; spelling check Circulation: North Hertfordshire District Council, Hertfordshire County Council Historic Environment Record, Letchworth Library Required Action: Scan for errors File Name/Location: h:\kmatthew\My Documents\Parishes\Letchworth\Howard Park\Desk Based Assessment 2008.doc Approval: Not required Table of Contents Contents.............................................................................................................................................i Metadata.........................................................................................................................................i Table
    [Show full text]
  • Preserving and Maintaining the Concept of Letchworth Garden City
    Preserving and Maintaining the Concept of Letchworth Garden City Edited summary of a paper presented by John Lewis to the Society of American City and Regional Planning History conference, October 2013 Letchworth Garden City is the world’s first Garden City. The Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation (www.letchworth.com) is a self-funding charitable organisation re-investing for the long- term benefit of communities in Letchworth Garden City. The Foundation is the descendant of First Garden City Limited, a private company set up in 1903 to test and prove the validity of Ebenezer Howard’s garden city principles by developing the world’s first garden city. Ebenezer Howard sought to combine the very best of town and country living to create healthy homes for working people. In his book ‘To-Morrow: A Peaceful Path to Real Reform’ Howard described how garden cities would be planned new settlements respectful of the natural environment providing high quality affordable housing and locally accessible jobs. Residents would enjoy a full range of social, educational and leisure facilities as well as jobs, decent homes and an environment which would promote health and wellbeing. The development of garden cities was underpinned by a set of principles which helped to convert Howard’s utopian ideals into real living places. The acquisition of the Letchworth-Willian Estate on 24 June 1903 secured 3818 acres of land as the canvas upon which to paint the ideals of Ebenezer Howard. The First Garden City Ltd, a private company responsible for the development of the estate, agreed to limit the dividends to shareholders to a maximum of 5% with the remaining surpluses to be captured and distributed for the benefit of all local communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal of Interdisciplinary History of Ideas, 16 | 2019 [Online], Online Since 31 December 2019, Connection on 30 July 2020
    Journal of Interdisciplinary History of Ideas 16 | 2019 Varia Electronic version URL: http://journals.openedition.org/jihi/276 ISSN: 2280-8574 Publisher GISI – UniTo Electronic reference Journal of Interdisciplinary History of Ideas, 16 | 2019 [Online], Online since 31 December 2019, connection on 30 July 2020. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/jihi/276 This text was automatically generated on 30 July 2020. Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International Public License 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Éditorial Manuela Albertone and Enrico Pasini Articles Rendering Sociology. On the Utopian Positivism of Harriet Martineau and the ‘Mumbo Jumbo Club’ Matthew Wilson Individualism and Social Change An Unexpected Theoretical Dilemma in Marxian Analysis Vitantonio Gioia Notes Introduction to the Open Peer-Reviewed Section on DR2 Methodology Examples Guido Bonino, Paolo Tripodi and Enrico Pasini Exploring Knowledge Dynamics in the Humanities Two Science Mapping Experiments Eugenio Petrovich and Emiliano Tolusso Reading Wittgenstein Between the Texts Marco Santoro, Massimo Airoldi and Emanuela Riviera Two Quantitative Researches in the History of Philosophy Some Down-to-Earth and Haphazard Methodological Reflections Guido Bonino, Paolo Maffezioli and Paolo Tripodi Book Reviews Becoming a New Self: Practices of Belief in Early Modern Catholicism, Moshe Sluhovsky Lucia Delaini Journal of Interdisciplinary History of Ideas, 16 | 2019 2 Éditorial Manuela Albertone et Enrico Pasini 1 Le numéro qu’on va présenter à nos lecteurs donne deux expressions d’une histoire interdisciplinaire des idées, qui touche d’une façon différente à la dimension sociologique. Une nouvelle attention au jeune Marx est axée sur le rapport entre la formation de l’individualisme et le contexte historique, que l’orthodoxie marxiste a négligé, faute d’une connaissance directe des écrits de la période de la jeunesse du philosophe allemand.
    [Show full text]
  • A Prospectus For
    A prospectus for A research, advocacy and resource centre for global Garden Cities HELLERAU PINELANDS NEW DELHI DON MILLS KAPUSKASING PARIS SAO PAULO SUNNYSIDE BRUSSELS RADBURN DEN-EN-CHOFU CANBERRA COLONEL LIGHT GARDENS GREENBELT HELLERAU DON MILLS SAO PAULO BRUSSELS LETCHWORTH CANBERRA COLONEL LIGHT GARDENS Letchworth Garden City Foreword by Founding President the Marquess of Salisbury The world is urbanising fast and we have a choice. We can either trust to luck and hope those flocking to the cities are not condemned to living with social dystopia in slums, or we can ensure that they will be housed in places where they will be proud and happy to live and work. The case is urgent and governments, international organisations, academics and, above all, the rest of us should get together to make such places and improve existing settlements. The United Kingdom has a proud tradition of building such places. The first garden cities were built in Hertfordshire at Letchworth and Welwyn and, although much of the new urbanisation will not be in the form of Garden Cities, this kind of development will have a part to play. Equally, every nation will want to build in a way that accords with its own culture and traditions. However, there are certain basic principles which seem to underpin most successful communities. The Garden City Institute has been founded to encourage discussion of those principles, to promote their adoption and to exchange views with practitioners and the general public worldwide. With its history of building successful communities, Hertfordshire is an entirely appropriate place to act as the hub of such a network.
    [Show full text]
  • Planning Theory
    Responses to the Industrial City Planning, Social Theory & Policy Industrial City (1870-1920) Population Change: Multiplier Effect Social Change: Immigrants & Class Issues Technological & Environmental Change Restructuring the City Chicago as ‘Shock City’ Multiplier Effect Population Growth: 1840 - 4,470 1870 – 298,977 1900 – 1,698,575 1930 – 3,376,438 Social Change ‘New Immigrants’ (1880 – 1920) – *Eastern European *Southern European Industrial Workers – strikes & violence New Land Use Patterns Central Business District Industrial Districts Residential Districts Commuter Suburbs Industrial Suburbs [Burgess’ Concentric Zone Model] Central Business District Skyscrapers --steel frame --elevator Department Stores Mass Market of Housing Rise of Real Estate Developer Example: S.E. Gross – ‘Friend of the Working Man’ New York’s Zoning “ . Restrictions on land use are constitutional because they enable city government to carry out their duties of protecting the health, safety, morals and general welfare of their citizens.” 1) Separate land uses into appropriate zones; 2) Restrict building heights 3) Limit lot coverage Environmental Controls Emergence of Zoning Laws/Building Codes Parks Movement City Beautiful Movement City Beautiful Movement Goals “beauty, order, system & harmony” Middle & upper-class effort to refashion the city into beautiful, functional entities Focus on civic improvements & parks Ebenezer Howard’s Garden City Howard’s vision Life’s experience: Homesteading, Chicago – before 1871 Town/Country Ebenezer Howard no training in
    [Show full text]
  • 2011 AICP Review Course HISTORY and THEORY
    2011 AICP Review Course HISTORY AND THEORY February 2011 Kelly O’Brien, AICP, PP, LEED AP Professional Development Officer of Exam Prep American Planning Association – New Jersey Chapter MAY 2011 AICP EXAM REVIEW HISTORY AND THEORY History and Theory (and Law) 15% • History of planning • Planning law • Theory of planning • Patterns of human settlement MAY 2011 AICP EXAM REVIEW HISTORY AND THEORY Primary functions of planning • improve efficiency of outcomes • counterbalance market failures - balance public and private interests • widen the range of choice - enhance consciousness of decision making • civic engagement - expand opportunity and understanding in community MAY 2011 AICP EXAM REVIEW HISTORY AND THEORY Professionalization of Planning 1901 NYC: “New Law” regulates tenement housing 1907 Hartford: first official & permanent local planning board 1909 – Washington DC: first planning association – National Conference on City Planning – Wisconsin: first state enabling legislation permitting cities to plan – Chicago Plan: Burnham creates first regional plan – Los Angeles: first land use zoning ordinance – Harvard School of Landscape Architecture: first course in city planning MAY 2011 AICP EXAM REVIEW HISTORY AND THEORY Pre-modern to New Urban Form 1682 Philadelphia plan Grid system & William Penn neighborhood parks Thomas Holme 1695 Annapolis plan Radiocentric Francis Nicholson 1733 Savannah Ward park system Oglethorpe 1790 Washington Grand, whole city plan Pierre L’Enfant 1852-1870 Paris Model for “City Beautiful” Napoleon III; Haussmann 1856 Central Park First major purchase of F L Olmsted Sr parkland 1869 Riverside, IL Model curved street FL Olmsted Sr “suburb” Calvert Vaux 1880 Pullman, IL Model industrial town George Pullman MAY 2011 AICP EXAM REVIEW HISTORY AND THEORY Philosophies and Movements Agrarian Philosophy 1800’S – Belief that a life rooted in agriculture is the most humanly valuable.
    [Show full text]
  • Bodies and Nature in International Garden City Movement Planning, 1898-1937
    ABSTRACT Title of Dissertation: ACTS OF LIVELIHOOD: BODIES AND NATURE IN INTERNATIONAL GARDEN CITY MOVEMENT PLANNING, 1898-1937 Samuel M. Clevenger Doctor of Philosophy, 2018 Dissertation directed by: Professor David L. Andrews Department of Kinesiology Urban planning and reform scholars and policymakers continue to cite the “garden city” community model as a potential blueprint for planning environmentally sustainable, economically equitable, humane built environments. Articulated by the British social reformer Sir Ebenezer Howard and his 1898 book To-Morrow: A Peaceful Path to Real Reform, the model represented a method for uniting the benefits of town and country through a singular, pre-planned, “healthy” community, balancing spaces of “countryside” and “nature” with affordable, well-built housing and plentiful cultural attractions associated with city life. The book catalyzed an early twentieth-century international movement for the promotion and construction of garden cities. Howard’s garden city remains a highly influential context in the history of town planning and urban public health reform, as well as more recent environmentally-friendly urban design movements. To date, while historians have long examined the garden city as an agent of social and spatial reform, little analysis has been devoted to the role of prescribed embodiment and deemed “healthy” physical cultural forms and practices in the promotion and construction of garden cities as planned communities for “healthy living.” Informed by recent scholarship in Physical Cultural Studies (PCS), embodied environmental history, cultural materialism, and theories of modern biopower, this dissertation studies the cultural history of international garden city movement planning in early twentieth century Britain and the United States.
    [Show full text]