The Interesting Transition of Third-Person Pronouns from the Old English to the Present Forms
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Interesting Transition of Third-Person Pronouns from the Old English to the Present Forms 三人称代名詞の興味深い形態上の変遷 SATO Tetsuzo* 摘 要 古英語期の三人称代名詞の語頭は, 性, 格, 数に関わらず全てh であった. 現代英語のそれと比較すると, 中性単 数のh は消失し, 単数女性主格はsh に代わり, 複数はth に代わったことがわかる. 古英語期に整然と使用されてい たものが, 中英語期, 現代英語期への時代の変遷と共に変化していった過程は興味深いものがある. またその変遷 過程の一時期の古形と新形が混在している状況下で, 絶妙な意味合いの違いをそれぞれの形に付与して, 筋の展 開に奥行きの深さを与えている作品も生まれた. 本論では, 三人称代名詞における語頭の変遷過程を説明し, その 後で, 中英語期の中盤に書かれたHavelok the Dane (デーン人ハヴェロック) に現れる三人称単数女性主格形と三 人称複数主格形をつぶさに観察することで, その妙技の一端を確認したい. Keyword Old English forms, third-person pronouns, Havelok the Dane CONTENTS Introduction Chapter I A General View of the Changing Forms of the Third-Person Pronouns Chapter II Sentences and Phrases Containing “She” and “They” in Havelok the Dane Chapter III Consideration of the Lists Conclusion Notes References Introduction Due to this state of linguistic confusion, in the districts where these dialects were spoken there may have been All the third-person pronouns in Old English (OE) a strong motive for using sh-forms as the singular began with an initial letter h. As a result of the phonetic feminine nominative and th-forms as the plural development of various dialects between late OE and nominative. With regard to the former group, the early Middle English (ME), the third-person pronoun Peterborough Chronicle for the year 1140 provides our nominatives with the initial h, except the singular neuter first evidence of the form with the initial /∫/-sound, scæ, 1) hit (which lost its initial h between the 12th and 15th in ME. In Havelok the Dane, written in the North East centuries in Standard English), became almost or wholly Midland dialect about 150 years later than the Chronicle, identical in form. the more developed forms of scho, * [email protected] -55- sho, sche, and she appeared. Since Havelok was Several previous studies (by Kobayashi, Sato, Higuchi written while these forms were developing into the and Sato, D.Sato) have considered this topic. In the present form she, it is not surprising that all four forms present paper, I seek to elucidate how each form is used should appear in the literary work, and we could regard in Havelok by closely examining all sentences that scho and sho as the older forms and sche and she as the contain each of the sh-forms as singular feminine newer ones. nominatives or each of the th-forms as plural With regard to the th-forms, it was in the Ormulum,2) nominatives. Before doing so, I will present an overview written in the East Midland dialect around the year 1200, of the changing forms of the third-person pronouns. that the th-form þeʒʒ first appeared in ME. In Havelok the Dane, written about 100 years after Ormulum, the various forms he, hi, þei, and þey appeared. Again, since Chapter I A General View of the this romance was written in the transition period from the old forms to the new ones, it is no wonder that all Changing Forms of the Third-Person sh four forms should appear in it; as with the -forms, we Pronouns could regard he and hi as the old forms and þei and þey as the new ones. The author of Havelok, however, may have given a In OE, the base he (third-person pronoun, masculine certain role to each of the sh-forms as singular feminine singular, nominative case) supplied all parts of the nominatives and to the th-forms as plural nominatives third-person pronoun, both singular and plural. It was and may have used each of them properly. inflected as shown in Table1. Table1 The 3rd Person Pronouns in OE Singular Plural Masculine Neuter Feminine Allgenders Nominative he hit heo hi(e) Accusative hine hit hi(e) hi(e) Genitive his his hi(e)re hi(e)ra Dative him him hi(e)re him (Sweet) In all the cognate languages, even in the early period, This pattern also extended to English in the 11th or 12th certain parts of the hi- or i- stem were lost and replaced century. by the corresponding parts of the demonstrative base se. Table2 Demonstratives in OE Singular Plural Masculine Neuter Feminine Allgenders Nominative se þæt seo þa Accusative þone þæt þa þa Genitive þæs þæs þære þara Dative þæm þæm þære þæm Instrumental þy þy,þon (þære) (Wright, EOE) The feminine heo became supplanted by the feminine that. In Northumbrian, around the year 950, the OE þa, demonstrative seo, which appeared as sco, scho = sho in plural of þæt, was often used instead of hi(e), and within Northumbrian, and scæ = shæ in Mercian, and now as the next two centuries the equivalent Old Norse þeir she. In the oblique cases, which are cases other than must have been adopted, as it appears in full use in the nominative and vocative, her remains. The original Ormulum around 1200 as þeʒʒ . From this word arose plural has been supplanted by a plural of the demonstrative the later they, thei, thay, and thai, which gradually -56- spread south, and before 1500 they superseded hi and hy, so that the plural forms are now they, them, and their. first in the nominative and then also in the other cases, Table 3 Demonstratives in Old Norse Singular Plural Mas. Fem. Neu. Mas. Fem. Neu. Nom. sa su þat þeir þær þau Acc. þann þa þat þa þær þau Gen. þess þeir(r)ar þess þeir(r)a þeir(r)a þeir(r)a Dat. þeim þeir(r)i þ(v)f þeim þeim þeim (Gordon) The original accusative forms have been replaced, Swanborow), was deprived of the right to succeed to everywhere except in the neuter gender, by an extended the throne after Birkabeyn’s death by Godard, an evil use of the dative. This process began in the Midland regent. Havelok was then raised by Grim, a Danish dialect before 1000 and was completed in the Southern fisherman, who had a wife named Leve, two daughters dialect by 1350. In the neuter, the accusative hit (Gunnild and Levive), and three sons (Huwe Raven, remained and also displaced the dative him. In all Roberd the Rede, William Wenduth). Later, Havelok constructions, hit lost its initial h between the 12th and became a kitchen boy under Bertram, cook in the 15th centuries in Standard English, and in the 16th and castle of Godrich (who was earl of Cornwall and evil 17th centuries the original neuter genitive his was regent of England after Athelwold’s death), at Lincoln. displaced first by it and then by it’s and its. Goldeborow (or Goldeboru), daughter of Athelwold―who The genitive cases his, hire, hire (their) were treated had been deprived of her own right of succession by after 1100. Like the other possessives, they also Godrich―married Havelok. The couple then regained developed two forms, an adjective and an absolute, the both of their rights by killing Godard and Godrich with latter being hers, theirs (the –s of which was originally the help of Grim’s sons, Ubbe (former seneschal of the possessive‘s). The changes that these words, Denmark), and others. In this way, Havelok became king originally genitives of the personal pronoun, have of Denmark and England. undergone make it more convenient in modern grammar to treat them separately as possessive pronouns.3) . II-3 The characters who appear in Havelok the Dane as speaker (S) or as referent (R) are as follows: Angel; Aþ(= th)elwold (king of England and father of Goldeboru); Chapter II Sentences and Phrases Bernard (headman of the community where Ubbe lives in Denmark); Bertram (cook in Godrich’s castle at Containing “She” and “They” in Lincoln); Birkabeyn(king of Denmark and father of Havelok the Dane4) Havelok); Chester (earl of Chester); Christ; (H)elfled (one of Havelok’s two sisters); Goldeboru (daughter of Aþelwold); Godard (regent of Denmark after Birkabeyn’s II-1 Havelok the Dane is a metrical romance that was death); Godrich (earl of Cornwall and regent of England popular in England between 1200 and 1500. after Aþelwold’s death); Grim (Danish fisherman (who It was written in rhyming couplet in the North saved Havelok’s life and founded Grimsby); Gunnild (one Midland dialect of English around 1285 and reflects of Grim’s two daughters); Havelok (son and heir of strong Norse influence, although the unknown poet’s Birkabeyn); Huwe Raven (one of Grim’s three sons); Leve style and ideas are believed to have been drawn from (Grim’s wife); Levive (one of Grim’s two daughters); French heroic poetry. The only known manuscript of the Roberd þe Rede(Grim’s eldest son); Storyteller; poem is located at the Bodleian Library, Oxford, England. Swanborow (one of Havelok’s two sisters); Ubbe(former seneschal of Denmark, restored by Havelok); William II-2 In the story, Havelok, son and heir of Birkabeyn (king Wenduth (one of Grim’s three sons). of Denmark and also father of two daughters, Elfled and From the above summary, we can roughly surmise the -57- social standing of each character. pronoun “she” (scho, sho, sche, she) that appear in Havelok the Dane.5) II-4 Following is a complete list of the sentences and phrases containing the third-person nominative singular 1. R: Goldeboru; S: Storyteller] (1) (line 112) Ðat was so yung þat sho ne couþe (‘that was so young that she could not’) 2. R: Goldeboru; S: Athelwold] (2) (122) Sho is mikel in mi þouht (‘She is much in my thought’) (3) (125) Sho ne kan speke, ne sho kan go. (‘She cannot speak, nor can she go.’) (4) (126) Yif scho couþe on horse ride, (‘If she could ride on a horse,’) (5) (128) And sho were comen in-til elde, (‘and she were come into eld [‘of age’],’) (6) (129) And Engelond sho couþe welde (‘and she could wield England’) (7) (174) Til þat she wuman [be] of elde (‘till she [be] a woman of eld’) (8) (175) And þat she mowe [hir] yemen and welde? (‘and that [‘till’] she may [‘can’] yeme and wield [her])?’) 3.