Of the American Mathematical Society Notices of the American Mathematical Society
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ISSN 0002-9920 201 Charles Street, Providence, RI 02904-2294 USA Notices of the American Mathematical Society Notices of the American Mathematical Society A MERICAN M ATHEMATICAL S OCIETY CURRENT EVENTS BULLETIN Saturday, January 8, 2011, 1:00 PM to 5:00 PM Joint Mathematics Meetings, New Orleans, LA of the American Mathematical Society Organized by David Eisenbud, University of California, Berkeley January 2011 Volume 58, Number 1 1:00 PM Vortices and Statesboro Meeting Luca Trevisan, Khot's unique games con- x1 x3 Two-Dimensional page 102 x1-x3=1 (mod 3) jecture: its consequences and the evidence x1-x2=2 (mod 3) Fluid Motion x2-x3=1 (mod 3) x4-x2=0 (mod 3) for and against page 10 Iowa City Meeting x3-x4=1 (mod 3) A conjecture that makes fundamental new connections page 105 x2 x4 between some classical mathematics and the difficulty From Cartan to Tanaka: of computing Image courtesy of Luca Trevisan. Getting Real in the Complex World 2:00 PM page 20 Thomas Scanlon, Counting special points: logic, Diophantine geometry and transcen- Mathematics Classes dence theory for Future Elementary Another beautiful use of logic to prove a deep theorem Teachers: Data about rational numbers from Mathematics Figure by C. Goodman-Strauss from John H. Conway, Departments Heidi Burgiel, and C. Goodman Strauss. The Symmetries of Things. AK Peters, Ltd., 2008. page 29 3:00 PM Real Face of Ulrike Tillmann, Spaces of graphs János Bolyai and surfaces page 41 Topological tools lead to new ways of distinguishing families of graphs and surfaces Volume 58, Number 1, Pages 1–224, January 2011 Image courtesy of Ulrike Tillmann. 4:00 PM David Nadler, The geometric nature of the fundamental lemma The geometry behind the number theory behind one of this year's Fields Medals. Image courtesy of David Jordan. About the Cover: 2D Vortex Formation (see page 35) current-events-bull-noti-ad.indd 1 11/22/10 3:13 PM Trim: 8.25" x 10.75" 224 pages on 40 lb Velocity • Spine: 1/4" • Print Cover on 9pt Carolina jjan10-cov.inddan10-cov.indd 1 111/23/101/23/10 99:09:09 AAMM Notices of the American Mathematical Society January 2011 Communications 4411 36 WHAT IS... Persistent Homology? Shmuel Weinberger 53 Doceamus: What Do the NAEP Math Tests Really Measure? David Klein 62 Best Current Practices for Journals 56 10 IMU Committee on Electronic Information and Communication Features 66 Palis Awarded Balzan Prize From a mistaken portrait of János Bolyai to complex geometry to vortices and fluid flow to mathematics education, we see this month the panorama of mathematical life. Our lives consist of Commentary research, teaching, service, and a great variety of scholarship. 7 Opinion: Commentary on Learning is what we do, and the Notices supports that effort. Education Legislation: A —Steven G. Krantz Mathematical Perspective Editor Matthew M. Pascal and Mary Gray 10 Vortices and Two-Dimensional Fluid 8 Letters to the Editor Motion 56 Perfect Rigor: A Genius C. Eugene Wayne and the Mathematical Breakthrough of the 20 From Cartan to Tanaka: Getting Real in Century— A Book Review the Complex World Reviewed by Donal O’Shea Vladimir Ezhov, Ben McLaughlin, and Gerd Schmalz 59 Numbers Rule: The Vexing Mathematics of Democracy, 29 Mathematics Classes for Future from Plato to the Present— Elementary Teachers: Data from A Book Review Mathematics Departments Reviewed by Jonathan K. Hodge Raven McCrory and Marisa Cannata 41 Real Face of János Bolyai Tamás Dénes Real Face of János Bolyai Tamás Dénes On the 150th anniversary of the death of János Bolyai1 n Vol. 56, No. 11, of Notices, I saw a fascinat- The article entitled “The real face of János ing article with the title: Changing Faces—The Bolyai” originates from my conversations with Mistaken Portrait of Legendre. The author, Pe- Professor Elemér Kiss. Unfortunately his serious ter Duren, writes with understandable bewil- illness, followed by his death in 2006, thwarted derment: “It seems incredible that such egre- our writing of a shared article. This piece of work Igious error could have gone undetected for so many is intended to fill this gap. years.” This encouraged me to publish, in the same journal, the story—no less fascinating—of the real Only Two Pictures of János Bolyai Ever face of János Bolyai. Existed, Neither of Which Has Survived It should be explained that in the case of János Bolyai (December 15, 1802–January 29, 1860) János Bolyai two different interpretations of the emerges like a comet from the history of Hungarian word “face” are justified: the “face” in terms of mathematics. the portrait (painting, drawing), and the “face” as “He was an illustrious mathematician with a an abstract concept. The first part of the article great mind; the first amongst the first”—read the introduces the surprising story of his only portrait, record of his death in the book of the Reform which, although universally accepted, turns out not Church of Marosvásárhely in Transylvania. On to be of him at all. The second part explores his November 3, 1823, he had sent a letter to his father intellectual or “mind-face” (it is my own word from Temesvar, including the words that would formation) and outlines a new approach to Bolyai’s later become famous: “I created a new, different creative life and work. world out of nothing.” The town of Marosvásárhely—which lies in the What he meant by this “new world” was the heart of the Central European Transylvania—fulfills idea of hyperbolic geometry, which was outlined an important role in the history of the Bolyai fam- in 1832, as an appendix to the book Tentamen ily: János lived most of his life there, and the local by Farkas Bolyai,2 entitled “The absolute true sci- library holds most of his manuscripts. The reader ence of space” (Scientiam Spatii absolute veram might find it strange that while János Bolyai is well exhibens). This, under the name “Appendix”, has known around the world as an eminent Hungar- become his best known piece of writing. ian, Transylvania (and so Marosvásárhely) can be The theory outlined in this work has been found within the borders of Romania. This can be named “Bolyai-Lobachevsky geometry”, following explained by the unsettled history of Transylvania. a decision made in 1894 at the International Bib- If we look back only to the nineteenth century, the liographic Congress of Mathematical Sciences. In part of Transylvania that was populated mainly January 2009 the “Appendix” by János Bolyai was by Hungarians was autonomous at times, whereas added to UNESCO’s Memory of the World Register. at other times it belonged to Hungary. In 1947, János Bolyai was the son of Farkas Bolyai— following World War II, the Treaty of Paris gave himself a defining figure of nineteenth-century this area to Romania, so that is where it is found Hungarian mathematics, who was in regular corre- on today’s maps. spondence with Gauss. As a result, it is perhaps Tamás Dénes is a mathematician and cryptologist from not surprising that Farkas Bolyai and his wife Hungary. His email address is [email protected]. Zsuzsanna Árkosi Benkö were immortalized by 1Dedicated to the memory of Professor Elemér Kiss (1929–2006). 2Father of János Bolyai. January 2011 Notices of the AMS 41 The Portrait of János Bolyai That Isn’t The question is: how has this—supposedly authentic—portrait spread around the world with the name of János Bolyai? Well, exactly fifty years ago, on the centenary of János Bolyai’s death, Hungarian and Romanian stamps were published with Bolyai’s name on them. Since then there has been an increased presence of this portrait everywhere: in books, on postcards, and most recently on the Internet, too. Today we know for certain that this portrait is not that of János Bolyai. Figure 2. The portrait, not of János Bolyai (on Hungarian and Romanian stamps in 1960), that has been circulated around the world. (Source: Hungarian Academy of Sciences Library) The year 2010 is the 150th jubilee of János Figure 1. Title page of the “Appendix” by János Bolyai’s death, so it’s about time that—after a latent Bolyai. period of fifty years—we resolve this scandalous mystery and bring to the public the results of contemporary artists in both drawings and oil the latest Bolyai research. In order to do this, I paintings. It might therefore be assumed that first need to briefly introduce the reader to two their child, who had already become famous in contemporaries of Bolyai: two Hungarian painters his lifetime, would be immortalized in a similar and a painting that plays a key role in the story. manner. Mór Adler (1826–1902) was one of the pioneers But based on contemporary sources, only two of Hungarian painting. He stood out as a student of pictures of János Bolyai ever existed, neither of some merit at the Weisenberger School of Graphic which has survived. One of the “Vienna pictures” Art, from which he went to the Vienna Academy. was mentioned by Farkas Bolyai himself in a letter There he was taught by the then well-known histor- written to his son on September 3, 1821. According ical and religious painters, between 1842 and 1845. to other sources, by 1837 this picture could no He then traveled to Munich in 1845 to study the longer be found. works of Zimneirmann and Schnorr von Carolsfeld The other one was made while he was serving as and for further studies in 1846–1847 in Paris. Next a lieutenant. The destruction of this was accounted he settled in Pest in 1848, where he would become for by János Bolyai himself: “I tore up this picture, a respected figure in the art world by the end of which had been taken in a military parade, for I his career.